Intercomparison of TSI aerosol monitors

Danchovski V., Ivanov D., Hlebarov I.

Aims and objectives

A short-term inter-comparison of TSI aerosol monitors was carried out in order to evaluate instruments comparability for future field experiments.

Apparatuses

All monitors use same type of photometer to measure PM mass concentration.

Instruments setup and analysis period

  • experiment duration - 2 days;
  • logging interval - 5 minutes;
  • pause between logging points - 5 minutes;
  • two tests - indoor and outdoor;
  • 8533’s outdoor tests are accomplished with different sampling - direct and indirect (PTFE tube is used)
  • 8543 is auto zeroed every hour, 8533 are zeroed by hand at the beginning of each test (indoor and outdoor)

Results

Time series

  • all instruments measure PM concentration with similar temporal patterns but magnitudes are different;
  • MCERTS always reports lower values;
  • quite low intra-channel variance for 8533’s (especially 8533_402);
  • during indoor test night-time concentration is nearly constant but different according to each instrument (role of auto-zeroing in MCERTS and accumulated contamination of 8533’s photometer optics and temperature dependency);
  • indoor PM concentration can serve as a proxy of when I am at work 😊

Exposition effects on the comparability of the instruments readings

  • better comparability during outdoor test (it is likely result of higher mixing rate);
  • desktop monitors report about twice concentration of MCERTS

Samplings inflow path role on the comparability of the instruments readings

  • air sampling through 2.5m PTFE tube reduces PM concentration by ~80-90%;
  • the coarse fractions experience higher reduction.

Conclusions

  • 8533’s need to be manually zeroed regularly
  • conductive tube must be used for air sampling
  • 8543 use MCERTS calibration but 8533’s are set to factory calibration
  • lack of intra-channel variance in 8533’s needs to be addressed

Acknowledgements

  • National Science Fund - aerosol monitor 8543-MCERTS is acquired under contract KP-06-COST/7 - 19.08.2021;
  • Non-governmental organization “For the Earth” - provided desktop aerosol monitors;
  • National Science Program “Environmental Protection and Reduction of Risks of Adverse Events and Natural Disasters” - conference participation funding

\[\mathcal{Thank~you!}\]