Valuation Report Components

Vanderbilt Health Valuation Lab

September 2, 2022

Components of an Evaluation Report

  1. Executive Summary
  2. Company Overview
  3. Service/Product/Innovation Evaluation
  4. Intellectual Property and Regulatory Pathway
  5. Reimbursement/Revenue Pathway
  6. Impact and Evaluation
  7. Financial Analysis
  8. Summary Analysis: Strengths, Weaknesses, Threats and Opportunity (SWOT)
  9. Recommendation.

Executive Summary

Executive Summary

  • Brief overview of product/service.
  • Identify market gaps.
  • How does this company address them?
    • What is the size of the addressable market?
    • What is the competitive landscape like?

Provide your recommendation.

Executive Summary

Company Overview

Company Introduction

  • Provide details on founding, ownership and organization.
  • Where is the company now?
    • Existing investors?

Service/Product/Innovation Evaluation

Service/Technology/Innovation Overview

  • What are the key services offered?
  • How do these services work?
  • Who is the end user?
  • Who hosts/sponsors the service/technology?
  • Does the service / technology require integration with other technology (e.g., EHR)?

Value Summary

  • What does this company uniquely bring to the market?

    • What is the status quo and what defined gap/insufficiency is the service/technology/innovation filling?

    • What are the advantages and disadvantages of consumers/stakeholders using this service/technology over the status quo and over any relevant competitors.

Voice of Stakeholders, Consumers/Users and Sponsors/Hosts

  • Describe the relevant stakeholders, users, and sponsors/hosts.
  • Who is the end user and how will they experience the technology/service?
  • How would each value and use the technology/service?

Voice of Stakeholders, Consumers/Users and Sponsors/Hosts

Voice of Stakeholders, Consumers/Users and Sponsors/Hosts

  • What are current customers/users are saying about the product?

Voice of Stakeholders, Consumers/Users and Sponsors/Hosts

Market Analysis and Strategic Positioning

  • What is the size and scope of the US market for the technology/service/innovation?
  • Potential for global markets?

Market Analysis and Strategic Positioning

Market Analysis and Strategic Positioning

Strategy Timeline

  • You should get this from the companies themselves.
    • What milestones have they already hit?

    • Where do they expect to be in 1 year, 5 years, 10 years, etc.?

Strategy Timeline

Competitor Analysis

  • Who else is working in or near this space?
  • Provide details on founding, ownership and organization.

Competitor Analysis

  • How are competitors positioning themselves (similarly or differently than assigned company)?
  • What is the competitor’s Value Proposition (if you can gather it from web searches)?
  • What types of clients are competitors targeting?

Competitor Analysis

Intellectual Property and Regulatory Pathway

Intellectual Property

  • What are the key IP components?
  • Patents? If so, obtain information on application details, duration, scope, etc.
  • Does service/technology require partnership with other firms or services? If so, how is IP protected?
  • If service/technology requires integration (e.g., with EHR), how is the company working to ensure seamless integration (and easy plug-ins)?

Regulatory and Policy Landscape

  • Who/what are the regulatory & policy stakeholders?
    • CMS/HHS?
    • FDA?
    • State Medicaid agency?
    • Other state/federal agencies?
  • Are there relevant payment/regulatory changes proposed or under consideration?

Reimbursement/Revenue Pathway

Reimbursement/Revenue Pathway

  • What is the current revenue/reimbursement plan?
  • How is pricing determined today?
  • What is the revenue growth plan?
  • Are there are alternative/unexplored revenue/reimbursement strategies?

Impact and Evaluation

Impact and Evaluation

  • How does the company measure impact?
  • To what extent are evaluation and assessments part of the business strategy and operations?

Financial Analysis

Financial Analysis

  • Under current revenue model.

  • Under alternative payment/revenue models?

Financial Analysis

Value Summary: SWOT

SWOT

Strengths Weaknesses
Opportunities Threats

SWOT

Recommendations

Market and Timeline Adjustments

Appendix and Works Cited