Introduction

Political finance at its fundamental level is equally pertinent to the functioning of a sound democracy as for the presence of political parties and elections. The way political finance, in a democracy, is carried out is shaped by the nature of politics and economy in that democracy or their evolution over time. Political finance in India is not unaffected by the twists and turns of the country’s political and economic trajectory. To understand the current state of political finance and the practices and regulations associated with it, it is imperative to briefly recall the evolution of both political systems and economic paradigms in India.

Brief Recollection

Single-party political system with Congress party as the hegemon dominated the initial decades of independent India at a time when general elections were conducted simultaneously with assembly elections. This came to an end with the party losing half of the assembly elections ushering in the next stage of political system – Duvergarian political system. The weakening of Congress party continued as regional parties proliferated and its political rival – Jana Sangh, the predecessor of BJP – strengthened themselves paving path to coalition party system where no single party attained majority at the lower house to form a government themselves. It could argued that with the consecutive victories of BJP in both 2014 and 2019 general elections, we are back at the single-party political system with BJP as the hegemon.

In the front of economy, India began its journey anchoring its development in import substitution industrialisation with strong emphasis on the role of state; heavily regulating private players. At the backdrop of severe economic crises, Indira Gandhi nationalised major sectors of the economy and furthered the regulations on private actors. The state of economic affairs took a different turn in the 1980s with ruling party opting for a pro-business attitude toning down existent regulations before giving in to pro-market structural adjustments in the 1990s.

Political finance as an aspect of democracy evolved in the intersection of these political and economic developments. It is a no secret that in a democracy like India it is unconducive for any party to contest elections and carry out basic affairs or let alone survive merely on membership fee and paltry donations. It is necessary for them to take donations from private players and big business houses. The ties between parties and business houses precede independence.

Congress party that was in power during the first two party systems benefitted the most when it came to donations from private players and big business houses. Acts and regulations of then were framed in such a manner that it never hindered the dominance of the ruling Congress party. There was no cap on the amount of money a party could spend or could receive. Furthermore, the state of reporting and disclosure were inexistent. Moreover, at a time when state controlled or regulated most aspects of the economy; the private actors were more inclined to donate money to the ruling party; which again benefitted the Congress party. It was only in 1969, the Indira Gandhi-led government banned corporate political donations in attempt to thwart the corporate political donations that were made to Swatantra Party and Jana Sangh. Despite banning such donations, Congress continued to receive such donations from corporate houses in many forms. In the absence of any alternate steps to procure political donations; the step reinforced the deep nexus between corruption and politics in India. Even though Rajiv Gandhi, in 1975, re-legalised corporate donations, it did not translate into freeing politics from the clutches of corruption and black money.

Post-1990s, with the efforts of civil society actors; judicial interventions and legislations, witnessed certain semblance of transparency and accountability added to political finance. But it did not result in any structural change to the way political finance was carried out as donations made below ₹20,000 were not under the purview of accountability. With the introduction of 2017 Finance Bill, the current BJP regime ushered in a new phase of political finance, lowering cash donations to ₹2,000; requiring any donations above the threshold to be made via digital payments and tying the threshold to individual or entity donor rather than donations. The bill further removed the cap on corporate donations and eliminated the requirement of declaration of corporate donations made to parties in their audit report. The bill also introduced the controversial scheme of Electoral Bonds that provided anonymity to corporate donations.

Political Finance

What is evident from these developments is that parties in power have no incentive to bring transparency and accountability to political finance; rather would make use of every instrument at their disposal to benefit the most. Publicly available data also corroborates these arguments. It is to be kept in mind that parties receive money through different channels and the actual amount is far greater than the reported amounts. It is applicable to both political donations as well as the income and expenditure. Another important thing to be kept in mind is that parties were not mandated to report the political donations received by them before 2003 (Election and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act) as well as report their audit reports before 2008 (CIC ruled in favour of ADR mandating parties to make their audit reports public going back to 2004-05).

Political Donations and Donors

From the publicly available data, what can be seen is that in the initial years of the millennium Congress Party and its principal political rival BJP received comparatively similar amounts of money through the channel of political donations with BJP receiving slightly higher amounts. To reiterate again, the actual amounts received by the parties are higher than the reported amounts and the data reported only has amounts donated through formal banking systems and excludes the direct cash donations.

It can be observed that there is a discernible increase in the number of donors and the amount of donations received by the parties at the time of general elections. Congress party received more political donation during UPA-I regime than BJP but interestingly at the time of 2009 general elections BJP received more amounts in donations. Since 2010-11, BJP has received far greater amounts in political donations than the ruling party possibly owing to the poor public perception from corruption allegations that tormented the UPA-II regime.

Political donations received by BJP between the financial years 2013-15 were 3 times more than that received by the Congress party that was facing strong anti-incumbency. Ever since BJP has come to power, the political donations received by the ruling party has been astronomically higher than the crisis-ridden Congress to a point BJP received almost 7 times higher donations 2019-20 when the 17th general elections took place bringing back BJP to the helm of power. The huge amount of political donations received by BJP also coincide with the 2017 Finance Bill and the introduction of Electoral Bonds; with no cap on corporate donations and complete anonymity associated with the nature of these donations, the ruling party with high proclivity for pro-business measures benefitted the most.

Political Donations
UPA

NDA

Political Donors
UPA

NDA

INC Donation as percentage of BJP Donation
UPA

NDA

Political Donations and Donors - Detailed Analysis

It is imperative to breakdown the data and look at the specifics vis-a-vis the count and sum of donations made by different donor groups. For this we have broken-down the data on the basis of single-time donation amounts and categorised them after clubbing them into 4 categories. The categories based on amount of donations are of the following - Up to 50 Thousand (donation bracket-1); Between 50 Thousand and 1 Lakh (donation bracket -2); Between 1 Lakh and 5 Lakhs (donation bracket -3); and Above 5 Lakhs (donation bracket-4). The amounts are in Lakhs to capture all the small donations that were made.

Political Donations

Looking at the median number of donors show us extent of dominance BJP has over INC.The median amount donated to BJP is 2.6 times greater than that donated to INC. The donation received by BJP from the donation bracket of amounts above 5 Lakhs is 2.7 times greater than INC. BJP received 2, 1.6, and 4.7 times more than INC in the donation brackets of 1, 2, and 3 respectively.

INC

BJP

Political Donors

Similarly, the median number of donors donating amounts more than 5 Lakhs to BJP is 2.7 times more than that to INC; that for donors donating amounts between 5 Lakhs and 1 Lakh to BJP is 3.2 times than INC; and similarly for donors donating amounts less than 50 Thousands to BJP is 2 times than that to INC. Said otherwise, BJP has a clear dominance over INC in terms of the number of donations they receive from all donation brackets.

INC

BJP

Donor status

Looking at the data(2013-19) on the status of donors based on the PAN card information submitted by the parties, we can get a picture of the status of donors vis-a-vis the number of companies, firms, and trusts that donate to political parties. In the light of these information, we can see the extent of disproportionate numbers of donors BJP attracts in comparison to INC. It has to be noted this does not show us the ground reality of donations as it is the only disclosed donations that is captured by this data and the actual amount of donation and donors are far greater than what the data tells us. Another matter to be kept in mind is that with the introduction of electoral bonds, political finance has gotten even obscure to monitor, in the sense that there is no way to discern who has donated to party and how much through the channel of electoral bonds. The information pertaining to donations made through electoral bonds are confined to the donors and parties. Even the banks that are entrusted to facilitate the sale of electoral bonds only have knowledge of who buy these bonds and not who they donate to.

Regardless, with the available data what we can observe is the greater number of donations going to BJP in comparison to INC from all discernible categories based on the PAN status. BJP has received 7 times greater number donation from companies than INC between 2013-19. And when it comes to donations from electoral trusts, the number of donations received by BJP is 4.6 times greater than INC in the same time period. BJP received almost 14 times higher number of donation from Firms than INC again in the same time period. The number of individual donors that donated to BJP in the same period was 3 times greater than those donated to INC. What this again reiterates is the incapacity of INC to bring in donations as major national party.

Type of Donor BJP INC
Person 5845 1951
Company/Firm 2490 289
Trust/Association 137 31
Others 60 26

Even though the mean number of individual donors that donated to BJP was 2.5 times greater than those donated to INC. A similar trend can be observed vis-a-vis firm, trusts and companies. Companies were 2.5 times more likely to donate to BJP than INC; firms were 12 times and trusts were 3 times more likely to donate to BJP. What this could indicate is a strong partisanship in political donation with BJP receiving a disproportionate number of donations as they have emerged as the dominant political entity in the new party system. One interesting facet of politics that can be interpreted from this data is the proclivity HUFs have for BJP and it is reflected in the number of donations made to them.

Party Status 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
BJP Person 324 67 238 214 1331 1697 1974
BJP Company/Firm 192 116 136 126 585 574 761
BJP Trust/Association 5 1 13 11 41 33 33
BJP Others 4 0 3 7 14 11 21
INC Person 0 22 489 363 559 353 165
INC Company/Firm 0 40 30 57 25 66 71
INC Trust/Association 0 0 4 10 5 7 5
INC Others 0 0 8 7 4 4 3

Candidate level Assets

Elected representative and political candidates who contest in elections getting rich by every election cycle or to put it another way it is the rich that are given tickets by parties. Data pertaining to assets of candidates display a sharp contrast between assets of candidates and the mass they represent as elected officials.According to the latest World Inequality Report the bottom 50% of the Indian population hold only 5.9% of the total wealth in the country. The average wealth held by this section is less than 3.5 Lakhs and the average assets held by candidates who contested on both INC and BJP tickets is around 16 Crores.

For a party like INC who claims to be the representatives of the poor and champions of socialism, the average assets were 19 Crore for the general elections in 2019. The numbers show something contrary to what the party claim. Congress candidates are far wealthier than their BJP counterparts and the sections of the population they want to represent.

The median asset for candidates contested on INC ticket in 2014 general election was 362.1 Lakhs and that BJP was 239.6 Lakhs. Coming to the general election in 2019, the median asset for candidates for both parties increase. For candidates who contested on INC ticket, the median asset was 489 Lakhs and that for BJP candidates the median was 402 Lakhs. The percentage change in median assets is 35% for INC and 68% for BJP. INC candidates are far richer than their BJP counterparts.

Taking a closer at the data, we can see an overwhelming number of candidates with assets of value above 1 Crore for both parties. Number of such candidates in the 2014 general election for BJP and INC were 305 and 355 respectively with median assets worth of 3 Crore and 5 Crore for BJP and INC respectively. Coming to the general election in 2019, the number of candidates with assets worth more than a crore for BJP and INC were 360 and 346 respectively. Though the median number of candidates with assets worth more than 1 Crore has gone down for INC, the median assets is still larger than that of BJP roughly 1.3 times greater than the latter.

Boxplots of Candidate Assets
INC

BJP

Number of Candidates
BJP
Candidates 2014 2019
Assets above 1 Crore 305 360
Assets between 50 Lakh and 1 Crore 53 27
Assets between 10 Lakh and 50 Lakh 45 37
Assets between 1 Lakh and 10 Lakh 15 7
Assets below 1 Lakh 1 1
INC
Candidates 2014 2019
Assets above 1 Crore 355 346
Assets between 50 Lakh and 1 Crore 46 38
Assets between 10 Lakh and 50 Lakh 39 28
Assets between 1 Lakh and 10 Lakh 6 6
Assets below 1 Lakh 1 0
Median Assets of Candidates
BJP
Candidates 2014 2019
Assets above 1 Crore 38602862 54324745
Assets between 50 Lakh and 1 Crore 6366653 6843278
Assets between 10 Lakh and 50 Lakh 2702481 2827638
Assets between 1 Lakh and 10 Lakh 315000 563879
Assets below 1 Lakh 34311 6200
INC
Candidates 2014 2019
Assets above 1 Crore 52207873.0 74340417.5
Assets between 50 Lakh and 1 Crore 7116242.5 7331508.0
Assets between 10 Lakh and 50 Lakh 3764729.0 3114812.5
Assets between 1 Lakh and 10 Lakh 483079.5 654711.5
Assets below 1 Lakh 31567.0 0.0

Income and Expenditure Analysis

It is no surprise to find that Congress party, having been in power for a long time, had greater income and assets than its rival BJP. From the data that is available, it can be seen that the Congress party on average had 2 times more the income than BJP till 2007-08. Since 2010-11, BJP has received more income than the Congress party. Similar to political donations the gap between BJP and Congress has widened over time and reached a point where BJP had 5 times the income that of the Congress party in 2019-20.

Similar trajectory can be observed in the front of reported expenditure too with Congress spending more than BJP during the period of UPA regime. The positions reverse with the fall of Congress-led UPA regime. It is interesting to note that BJP have had a greater positive net income than Congress and the latter more often running in deficit greater times than the former.

Similar story follow the front of assets and liabilities, with Congress having greater assets and lesser liabilities in the initial years. There has been a steady increase in assets for both parties in the first decade of the century but ever since the Modi-led BJP government came to power in 2014 the assets of BJP has grown rapidly surpassing that of Congress to an point it would be a herculean task for the latter to catch up. At the heights of 2019 general elections BJP held on to 8 times more the assets than that of Congress.

The liabilities of the Congress has been skyrocketing since 2012-13, effectively diminishing the net assets the party hold on to. The difference between the both parties have come to a point where as of 2020-21, BJP hold around 9 times more the assets than the Congress. The crisis-ridden Congress party is becoming poor according to the reported data. To reiterate again, the reported data is far lesser than the actual amounts these parties receive and spend.

Income

Expenditure

Assets

Liabilities

Net Assets

Income-Expenditure Analysis in Detail

Political parties, as we understand, receive income throught various channels and these channels need not be the same for each party. For instance, INC receive a sizeable amount of income through sale of coupons whereas BJP receive income through Aajiwan Sahayog Nidhi. There appears no way to corroborate the the actual amount of money received is through these channels as they are self-reported amounts.

INC receive income mainly through Fee & Subscription,Sale of Coupons, and Voluntary Contributions - Individual donors, Company donation, Electoral trust and foundations, and Electoral Bonds. Whereas BJP receive income mainly through Fee & Subscription, Interest from Banks, and Voluntary Donations - Aajiwan Sahayog Nidhi, Donations from Morchas, Donations from Meetings, and Electoral Bonds.

Parties primarily spend money for administrative expenses, employee expenses, finace expenses, and election expenditure. It is only recently we have publicly available broken-down data on where the money comes from and where they are spent. Prior to 2015-16 financial year, parties submitted the overall aggregate income and expenditure. The earlier data is not reliable to monitor the the sub-channels of income and expenditure to lack to clarity and discrepancies. For instance BJP in their earlier self-reported files have a expenditure titled Hire charges which in their later self-reported files appear twice - under administrative expenses and election expenditure - thus making it hard for social science researchers or anyone interested in political finance to discern the nature of Hire Charges in their earlier files.

Regardless, with the available data from 2015-16, we can understand from where the parties the parties receive income and and how they spend it.

The table below shows the proportion of income INC has received from 2015-16 to present.Sale of coupons contribute a greater share to income - around 50% in the first three years. After the introduction of electoral bonds they take a dip. When the income received from electoral bonds got drastically reduced in 2020-21, we can see a resurgence in the income received from the sale of coupons. Before the introduction of electoral bonds the party at most received only 22% of income from voluntary contributions. Sale of coupons at best is a proxy for the donations they receive that they don not wish to disclose with the ECI.

Income_main Income_particular 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Fee & Subscription Fee & Subscription 3.98 5.96 12.74 3.00 0.78 7.26
Other Income Other Income 17.57 20.26 15.54 1.78 2.21 4.44
Sale of Coupons Sale of Coupons 64.21 51.32 55.42 35.14 28.21 54.91
Voluntary Contributions Individual Donation 10.98 7.61 10.62 5.52 4.92 17.21
Voluntary Contributions Company Donation 1.71 7.28 0.50 2.25 13.78 8.56
Voluntary Contributions Electoral Trust & Foundation 1.53 7.20 2.01 10.30 0.15 2.58
Voluntary Contributions Electoral Bonds NA NA 2.51 41.75 46.59 3.53
Voluntary Contributions Other Donation 0.00 0.37 0.66 0.26 3.36 1.52

When it comes to BJP, the opacity with respect to where political parties receive money continues. The source of main income for BJP is through Voluntary Donations and the within Voluntary Donation the main source is named as “Other Donation” that does not come under Aajiwan Sahayog Nidhi or Donations from Morchas and Meetings.

Income_main Income_particular 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Fee & Subscription Fee & Subscription 1.81 0.41 0.54 0.08 0.60 0.67
Interest from Banks Interest from Banks 3.44 3.02 3.04 2.24 4.77 22.43
Other Income Other Income 0.79 0.16 0.08 0.01 0.03 0.08
Voluntary Contributions Aajiwan Sahayog Nidhi 6.13 4.28 6.25 1.02 0.64 2.70
Voluntary Contributions Morchas Donations 0.31 2.48 0.09 0.03 0.14 0.00
Voluntary Contributions Meetings Donations 0.01 0.42 0.02 0.04 0.01 0.02
Voluntary Contributions Electoral Bonds NA NA 20.44 60.20 70.52 2.98
Voluntary Contributions Other Donations 87.52 89.22 69.55 36.38 23.30 71.14

Election expenditure for BJP is far greater than that of INC. There is a multi-fold increase in the amount churned out by BJP to contest elections ever since they have come to power. In the general election of 2019 BJP spent 1352.9 Crore on elections whereas INC managed to spent only 864.0 Crores. If we take a look at the BJP’s election expenditure as a percentage of INC’s election expenditure, we could see the dominance BJP has in receiving political finance and their disposal. It also tells us how obstinate the party has become to win elections at any cost.

The below is the table for the proportion of money BJP spent on elections. What is noticeable is the presence of Financial assistance the party provides for their candidates which can be seen to increase at crucial election cycles.BJP,as obvious, spends a huge amount of money on election publicity and advertisements. The huge surge in Publicity Expenses in 2017-18 coincide with the state level election especially that in the state of Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat.

Expenditure_main Expenditure_particular 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Election Expenditure Financial Assistance to Candidates 16.52 12.21 6.09 7.62 14.66 18.69
Election Expenditure Meetings Expenditure 2.65 8.51 5.75 8.46 3.76 2.56
Election Expenditure Morcha/Rally/Andolan Expenditure 8.66 13.01 6.23 8.77 4.18 24.73
Election Expenditure Other Election Expenditure 6.41 1.99 8.42 12.15 1.67 3.71
Election Expenditure Press Conference Expenditure 0.18 0.15 0.13 0.10 1.09 0.12
Election Expenditure Publicity Expenditure 61.76 43.55 71.23 54.95 54.43 41.04
Election Expenditure Travel Expenditure 3.81 20.59 2.14 7.94 20.22 9.14

When it comes to the election expenditure of INC, the party does not, at least based on the available data, provide financial support to their candidates. The sub-category, “Other Election Expenditure” for the party is where one could speculate the party include such financial assistance, which on record includes Boarding & Lodging expenses, Public Meetings, and “Others”.

Expenditure_main Expenditure_particular 2015-16 2016-17 2017-18 2018-19 2019-20 2020-21
Election Expenditure Publicity Expenditure 15.61 41.93 28.79 25.23 46.96 33.21
Election Expenditure Travel Expenditure 17.89 18.03 33.56 23.42 14.67 29.89
Election Expenditure Survey Expenditure 2.52 0.02 0.00 0.19 0.66 0.61
Election Expenditure Other Election Expenditure 63.98 40.01 37.65 51.17 37.71 36.28

Tables

Donations and Donors

INC
Financial Year Total Donation (Rs. Crore) Total Donors
2003-04 2.8 141
2004-05 32.1 163
2005-06 5.9 350
2006-07 12.1 103
2007-08 7.9 127
2008-09 27.9 145
2009-10 84.1 248
2010-11 8.0 421
2011-12 9.6 361
2012-13 11.7 703
2013-14 59.6 743
2014-15 141.5 280
2015-16 20.4 918
2016-17 41.9 599
2017-18 26.7 777
2018-19 148.6 605
2019-20 139.0 350
2020-21 74.5 1077
BJP
Financial Year Total Donation (Rs. Crore) Total Donors
2003-04 11.7 318
2004-05 34.0 306
2005-06 3.6 127
2006-07 3.0 109
2007-08 25.0 197
2008-09 30.6 174
2009-10 88.0 280
2010-11 14.6 514
2011-12 33.4 1104
2012-13 83.2 2940
2013-14 170.9 1480
2014-15 437.4 1234
2015-16 76.8 613
2016-17 532.3 1194
2017-18 437.0 2977
2018-19 742.2 4483
2019-20 785.8 5575
2020-21 477.5 2206

Balance Sheet

INC
Financial Year Assets Liability Net Assets Income Expenditure Net Income
2001-02 53.3 9.0 44.3 69.6 75.0 -5.4
2002-03 65.4 11.0 54.4 61.5 51.4 10.1
2003-04 135.8 7.2 128.6 152.9 79.1 73.8
2004-05 167.4 8.0 159.4 220.7 191.4 29.3
2005-06 228.5 13.6 214.9 124.9 69.5 55.4
2006-07 285.3 14.1 271.2 169.4 113.0 56.4
2007-08 340.3 13.4 326.9 220.8 165.3 55.5
2008-09 611.8 62.8 549.0 496.9 274.7 222.2
2009-10 507.7 17.2 490.5 467.6 526.0 -58.4
2010-11 497.8 20.0 477.8 307.1 319.8 -12.7
2011-12 513.0 59.5 453.5 356.3 380.6 -24.3
2012-13 585.7 22.4 563.3 425.7 314.2 111.5
2013-14 767.2 248.2 519.0 598.1 644.3 -46.2
2014-15 702.3 355.0 347.3 593.3 765.0 -171.7
2015-16 758.8 343.1 415.7 261.6 193.3 68.3
2016-17 854.8 535.4 319.4 225.4 321.7 -96.3
2017-18 724.4 402.7 321.7 199.2 197.4 1.8
2018-19 928.8 159.2 769.6 918.0 469.9 448.1
2019-20 588.2 133.8 454.4 682.2 998.2 -316.0
2020-21 691.1 159.9 531.2 285.8 209.0 76.8
BJP
Financial Year Assets Liability Net Assets Income Expenditure Net Income
2001-02 81.4 4.3 77.1 44.2 36.8 7.4
2002-03 90.5 17.3 73.2 49.5 44.5 5.0
2003-04 155.4 33.0 122.4 91.5 49.4 42.1
2004-05 122.9 14.3 108.6 104.1 114.6 -10.5
2005-06 111.8 9.1 102.7 38.3 38.3 0.0
2006-07 137.2 9.5 127.7 82.5 55.3 27.2
2007-08 177.4 9.2 168.2 123.8 81.7 42.1
2008-09 260.7 14.8 245.9 220.0 137.1 82.9
2009-10 239.6 10.2 229.4 258.0 261.7 -3.7
2010-11 294.8 19.6 275.2 168.0 121.4 46.6
2011-12 414.3 33.9 380.4 309.5 196.9 112.6
2012-13 463.6 26.3 437.3 324.2 223.4 100.8
2013-14 780.7 8.8 771.9 673.8 328.6 345.2
2014-15 760.0 23.1 736.9 970.4 913.0 57.4
2015-16 893.9 25.0 868.9 570.9 438.8 132.1
2016-17 1213.1 20.0 1193.1 1034.3 710.1 324.2
2017-18 1483.4 21.4 1462.0 1027.3 758.5 268.8
2018-19 2904.2 37.5 2866.7 2410.1 1005.3 1404.8
2019-20 4847.8 8.8 4839.0 3623.3 1651.0 1972.3
2020-21 4990.2 11.2 4979.0 752.3 620.4 131.9