Group Project Instruction

Econ 57a, Environmental Economics, Fall 2019

Overview

We live in a world full of environmental and resource problems: climate changing, water polluted, species extinct, aquifer overexploited, etc. And this is the chance for you to sit down and take a serious stab of your most interested problem.

Think of your paper as an attempt to address an environmental or natural resource issue as an economist: describe the issue; analyze the issue using an analytical or quantitative framework; and offer your conclusion or suggestion. It is not expected that your paper be the last word on the topic or be entirely comprehensive. The point of the paper is for you to learn in greater detail about a particular topic and relate that to what has been learned throughout the course.

You are expected to work on the group project in a group of 3-4 students. You can choose your topic at your discretion, as long as it is related to an environmental or natural resource problem. The paper is expected to be academic, i.e. not a collection of opinions from blogs and websites. You are expected to use data and information from credible sources, for example refereed journal articles, research reports, and governmental agencies such as the EPA, DOE, and CBO, etc. Make sure you include those references at the end of your paper. Plagiarism will not be tolerated.

Paper Structure

It is recommend that the paper be structured into the following sections, although your creativity is very much encouraged:

  1. Introduction: Please include the following subsections: (1) What is the issue (define the problem), and (2) why is this issue important?
  2. Economic Framework: What are the trade-offs involved in your issue? How do you propose to evaluate these trade-offs? Relate to models and concepts we have talked about in class if possible. (If you are writing an empirical paper, point to the relevant economic models/concepts of which your study contributes to.)
  3. Analysis: Use data and information to back-up the analytical framework you’ve proposed.
  4. Conclusion and Recommendation: What is your recommendation on the issue, or what can we learn from your study?
  5. Reference: List all references used in the paper.

Your paper must include at least one table and one graph/model. For the graph/model you need to apply one of the models discussed in class to your specific issue. You need to describe in detail how the model works in the context of your chosen topic, not generically. The graph/model and table must be well-labeled and accessible to the reader-do not merely print out Excel output with cryptic variable names.

Grading

The project accounts for 20% of your final grade. The grade for this project will be based on a total of 150 points. Your grades will be determined by three aspects: a proposal, the written paper, and the oral presentation. Detailed rubric is as follows:

1. Project Proposal: 10 points

To help you keep on track, please submit a half-page to one-page project proposal by 11/1 so that I can give you feedbacks to move forward. Briefly describe your research question, proposed analytical framework, and potential sources of data/information in your proposal. The proposal will be graded on a good-faith basis: you will get full points as long as you have shown efforts.

2. Written Paper: 80 points

Each team will submit a written paper of around 8 pages, not including references but everything else. The written paper will be graded based on the following criteria:

  • Clear problem definition and motivation (15 pts)
  • Appropriate application of economic model/concept (20 pts)
  • Logically coherent chain of reasoning (15 pts)
  • Reasonable conclusion and recommendation (15 pts)
  • Clear and concise writing (15 pts)

3. Present your story: 60 points

Each team will have about 10 minutes to present their policy analysis project in a format of their choice. No specific form of presentation is required. Your group may present your spoken material with the help of PowerPoint slides, a staged debate, a group discussion, a play, etc. Creative presentation formats are encouraged. Each group must allow 2 minutes for questions from the instructor and the audience.

The grading for the presentation will be based on the following:

  • Clear problem definition and motivation (10 pts)
  • Appropriate application of economic model/concept (15 pts)
  • Logically coherent chain of reasoning (10 pts)
  • Reasonable conclusion and recommendation (10 pts)
  • Presentation skills (15 pts)

Logistics

Group signup sheets will be available on 9/17. Please sign up for groups based on your intellectual interests. Groups will be finalized on 9/24. Use the following link to sign up:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zdtVK9KjciG8HsFy58WCeqJQM8OcdBrzDO7IbBQi0CU/edit?usp=sharing

We will have one to two group project mini-workshops in class.

The proposal is due on 11/1. The group presentations will be held on the last several classes of the semester. The final paper is due electronically on 12/10.