Tahapan Pengestimasian Direct dan Traditional Indirect Estimation:
library(readxl)
Jatim_pengeluaran <- read_excel("D:/Kuliah/tkt IV/The Journey Start/SAE/Data SAE/Jatim_pengeluaran.xlsx",
col_types = c("text", "text", "numeric",
"text", "text", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric"))
Xnew_ya <- read_excel("D:/Kuliah/tkt IV/The Journey Start/SAE/Data SAE/Xnew ya.xlsx",
sheet = "Sheet2", col_types = c("text", "text", "text", "text", "text", "text",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric"))
muatan <- read_excel("D:/Kuliah/tkt IV/The Journey Start/SAE/Data SAE/muatan.xlsx",
sheet = "Sheet3", col_types = c("text","text", "numeric"))
#variabel_X_signifikan
x1 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X1, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x12 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X12, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x13 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X13, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x20 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X20, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x27 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X27, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x31 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X31, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
dt1 <- data.frame(cbind("bs_o"=Jatim_pengeluaran$`No Kode Sampel`,"pop"=Jatim_pengeluaran$Exp_krb,"kab"=Jatim_pengeluaran$R102))
mat_x <- matrix(cbind(1,x1$x,x12$x,x13$x,x20$x,x27$x,x31$x),ncol=7)
#Jumlah ruta tiap kab (Ni)
ht_rt <- function(dt1){
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
de = data.frame(r102)
Peng_jatim <- data.frame(dt1)
ds <- list()
for (i in r102){
ds[[i]] <- subset(Peng_jatim, kab %in% i)
}
Ni <- c()
for(k in r102){
Ni[k] <- length(ds[[k]]$kab)
}
N_desa <- data.frame("desa"=Ni)
return(N_desa)
}
Ni_ruta <- ht_rt(dt1)Fungsi Estimasi untuk metode SRS
resampling_srs = function(data, dataX, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY = data
prop = proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
srs_sampling <- function(data, prop){
kab_1= data
samp_rt <- sample(1:length(kab_1$pop), size = prop*length(kab_1$pop), replace = FALSE)
hs_samp_srs <- kab_1[samp_rt,]
hs_samp_srs$pop <- as.numeric(paste(hs_samp_srs$pop))
hs_samp_srs <- data.frame(hs_samp_srs)
est_ybar_srs <- function(data,f){
hs_samp_srs <- data
y_tot_samp <- sum(hs_samp_srs$pop)
n <- length(hs_samp_srs$pop)
y_bar <- y_tot_samp/n
Y_cap_est <- n/f*y_bar
s_kw <- sum((hs_samp_srs$pop - (matrix(y_bar,ncol = 1)))^2)/(n-1)
var_y_bar <- (1-f)*s_kw/n
Var_cap_est <- (n/f)^2*var_y_bar
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result = est_ybar_srs(hs_samp_srs, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- srs_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary){
#synthetic function
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
mse_syn <- ((Y_syn-y)^2)-vary
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
datafinal$Efisiensi_syn <- datafinal$`MSE syn`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
datafinal$Efisiensi_com <- datafinal$`MSE com`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
return(datafinal)
}b. Menggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang perbaikanresampling_srs_2 <- function(data, dataX, Ni, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY <- data
prop <- proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
srs_sampling <- function(data, prop){
kab_1= data
samp_rt <- sample(1:length(kab_1$pop), size = prop*length(kab_1$pop), replace = FALSE)
hs_samp_srs <- kab_1[samp_rt,]
hs_samp_srs$pop <- as.numeric(paste(hs_samp_srs$pop))
hs_samp_srs <- data.frame(hs_samp_srs)
est_ybar_srs <- function(data,f){
hs_samp_srs <- data
y_tot_samp <- sum(hs_samp_srs$pop)
n <- length(hs_samp_srs$pop)
y_bar <- y_tot_samp/n
Y_cap_est <- n/f*y_bar
s_kw <- sum((hs_samp_srs$pop - (matrix(y_bar,ncol = 1)))^2)/(n-1)
var_y_bar <- (1-f)*s_kw/n
Var_cap_est <- (n/f)^2*var_y_bar
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result = est_ybar_srs(hs_samp_srs, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- srs_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary,Ni){
#synthetic function
N <- Ni
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
m <- length(Y_syn)
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
mse <- sum((y - Y_syn)^2)/m-2
var_y_cap_is <- c(rep(mse,m))
Ni_2 <- N^2
ba.1 <- (sum((Y_syn-y)^2/Ni_2))/m
ba.2 <- (sum(rep(var(Y_syn-y),m)/Ni_2))/m
ba_a <- ba.1 - ba.2
mse_syn <- var_y_cap_is + (Ni_2*ba_a)
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est,Ni)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
datafinal$Efisiensi_syn <- datafinal$`MSE syn`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
datafinal$Efisiensi_com <- datafinal$`MSE com`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
return(datafinal)
}Fungsi Estimasi untuk metode One stage Cluster
#Pakai rumus awal
resampling_1st = function(data, dataX, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY = data
prop = proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
cb_sampling <- function(data, prop){
mydata= data
bs_u <-unique(mydata$bs_o)
bs_u <- data.frame(bs_u)
samp_bs <- sample(1:nrow(bs_u), size = prop*nrow(bs_u), replace = FALSE)
sampi= bs_u[samp_bs,]
sampi2 = as.matrix(sampi)
dat = as.matrix(mydata)
hasil = c()
for(i in 1: length(sampi2)){
hasil = rbind(hasil,dat[dat[,1]==sampi[i],])
}
hasil <- data.frame(hasil)
hasil$pop = as.numeric(paste(hasil$pop))
est_ybar_1cs <- function(data,f){
hs_sam <- data
Mi <- data.frame(table(hs_sam$bs_o))
y_bar_i <- aggregate(hs_sam$pop, by=list(hs_sam$bs_o), FUN=mean)
y_bar_n <- (sum(y_bar_i$x*Mi$Freq))/sum(Mi$Freq)
M_bar <- sum(Mi$Freq)/nrow(Mi)
pnyb <- sum((Mi$Freq^2)*((y_bar_i$x-rep(c(y_bar_n),nrow(Mi)))^2))
pmbg <- nrow(Mi)*(M_bar)^2*(nrow(Mi)-1)
var_y_bar_n <- (1-f)*pnyb/pmbg
Y_cap_est <- (nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar*y_bar_n
Var_cap_est <- ((nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar)^2*var_y_bar_n
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result = est_ybar_1cs(hasil, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- cb_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary){
#synthetic function
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
mse_syn <- ((Y_syn-y)^2)-vary
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
datafinal$Efisiensi_syn <- datafinal$`MSE syn`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
datafinal$Efisiensi_com <- datafinal$`MSE com`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
return(datafinal)
}b. Menggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang perbaikanresampling_1st_2 <- function(data, dataX, Ni, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY <- data
prop <- proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
cb_sampling <- function(data, prop){
mydata<- data
bs_u <-unique(mydata$bs_o)
bs_u <- data.frame(bs_u)
samp_bs <- sample(1:nrow(bs_u), size = prop*nrow(bs_u), replace = FALSE)
sampi=bs_u[samp_bs,]
sampi2 = as.matrix(sampi)
dat <- as.matrix(mydata)
hasil <- c()
for(i in 1: length(sampi2)){
hasil = rbind(hasil,dat[dat[,1]==sampi[i],])
}
hasil <- data.frame(hasil)
hasil$pop <- as.numeric(paste(hasil$pop))
est_ybar_1cs <- function(data,f){
hs_sam <- data
Mi <- data.frame(table(hs_sam$bs_o))
y_bar_i <- aggregate(hs_sam$pop, by=list(hs_sam$bs_o), FUN=mean)
y_bar_n <- (sum(y_bar_i$x*Mi$Freq))/sum(Mi$Freq)
M_bar <- sum(Mi$Freq)/nrow(Mi)
pnyb <- sum((Mi$Freq^2)*((y_bar_i$x-rep(c(y_bar_n),nrow(Mi)))^2))
pmbg <- nrow(Mi)*(M_bar)^2*(nrow(Mi)-1)
var_y_bar_n <- (1-f)*pnyb/pmbg
Y_cap_est <- (nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar*y_bar_n
Var_cap_est <- ((nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar)^2*var_y_bar_n
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result <- est_ybar_1cs(hasil, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- cb_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary,Ni){
#synthetic function
N <- Ni
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
m <- length(Y_syn)
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
mse <- sum((y - Y_syn)^2)/m-2
var_y_cap_is <- c(rep(mse,m))
Ni_2 <- N^2
ba.1 <- (sum((Y_syn-y)^2/Ni_2))/m
ba.2 <- (sum(rep(var(Y_syn-y),m)/Ni_2))/m
ba_a <- ba.1 - ba.2
mse_syn <- var_y_cap_is + (Ni_2*ba_a)
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est,Ni)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
datafinal$Efisiensi_syn <- datafinal$`MSE syn`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
datafinal$Efisiensi_com <- datafinal$`MSE com`/datafinal$`MSE dir`
return(datafinal)
}res_srs_1 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_1 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.9 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.9 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.8 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.8 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.7 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.7 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.6 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.6 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.5 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.5 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.4 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.4 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.3 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.3 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.2 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.2 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.1 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.1 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 100)
res_srs_0.05 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 100)
res_srs2_0.05 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 100)res_1sc_1 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_1 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.9 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.9 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta , proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.8 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.8 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.7 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.7 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.6 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.6 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.5 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.5 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.4 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.4 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.3 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.3 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.2 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.2 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.1 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.1 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc_0.05 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 100)
res_1sc2_0.05 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_ruta, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 100)MEnggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang awal
res_srs_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1637409 1484546 1637409 0 23367160158 0
## 2 10 2452226 2656398 2452226 0 41686037135 0
## 3 11 1432925 1736676 1432925 0 92264682627 0
## 4 12 1628141 2070386 1628141 0 195581155363 0
## 5 13 1660654 1452773 1660654 0 43214520571 0
## 6 14 2677707 2617885 2677707 0 3578628369 0
## 7 15 5059790 4863519 5059790 0 38522139703 0
## 8 16 2702258 2596479 2702258 0 11189241307 0
## 9 17 2063216 2280593 2063216 0 47252536988 0
## 10 18 1802921 1720645 1802921 0 6769362207 0
## 11 19 1893080 2266122 1893080 0 139160429063 0
## 12 2 1631372 1473225 1631372 0 25010528782 0
## 13 20 1933963 1539654 1933963 0 155479806202 0
## 14 21 1543883 1871616 1543883 0 107408906085 0
## 15 22 2024290 1859814 2024290 0 27052299781 0
## 16 23 2145480 2562473 2145480 0 173883605020 0
## 17 24 2721467 2698896 2721467 0 509476091 0
## 18 25 3923463 3722909 3923463 0 40222101589 0
## 19 26 2049321 2256961 2049321 0 43114400382 0
## 20 27 1850200 1379119 1850200 0 221917551646 0
## 21 28 1632444 1899669 1632444 0 71409379673 0
## 22 29 1945828 2049705 1945828 0 10790438814 0
## 23 3 1794553 1899490 1794553 0 11011912392 0
## 24 4 2297582 2449242 2297582 0 23000653140 0
## 25 5 2083579 1902456 2083579 0 32805645589 0
## 26 6 2526531 2124414 2526531 0 161698161955 0
## 27 7 2716794 3050885 2716794 0 111616270475 0
## 28 71 2297609 2314435 2297609 0 283139160 0
## 29 72 1872873 2081921 1872873 0 43701295609 0
## 30 73 3484448 3097221 3484448 0 149945060415 0
## 31 74 2197198 2088987 2197198 0 11709568505 0
## 32 75 1867766 2160606 1867766 0 85755048745 0
## 33 76 2088732 1998934 2088732 0 8063635637 0
## 34 77 2275392 2228054 2275392 0 2240872147 0
## 35 78 7020112 6960868 7020112 0 3509873670 0
## 36 79 2178314 2012520 2178314 0 27487633079 0
## 37 8 2025630 1758243 2025630 0 71496025026 0
## 38 9 2279804 2230617 2279804 0 2419373518 0
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 0 15740.2769 0 Inf
## 2 0 15692.6939 0 Inf
## 3 0 53127.1634 0 Inf
## 4 0 94466.0213 0 Inf
## 5 0 29746.2278 0 Inf
## 6 0 1366.9922 0 Inf
## 7 0 7920.6305 0 Inf
## 8 0 4309.3906 0 Inf
## 9 0 20719.4082 0 Inf
## 10 0 3934.2014 0 Inf
## 11 0 61409.0701 0 Inf
## 12 0 16976.7190 0 Inf
## 13 0 100983.6028 0 Inf
## 14 0 57388.3367 0 Inf
## 15 0 14545.7042 0 Inf
## 16 0 67857.7295 0 Inf
## 17 0 188.7721 0 Inf
## 18 0 10803.9457 0 Inf
## 19 0 19102.8585 0 Inf
## 20 0 160912.5386 0 Inf
## 21 0 37590.4229 0 Inf
## 22 0 5264.3865 0 Inf
## 23 0 5797.2981 0 Inf
## 24 0 9390.9274 0 Inf
## 25 0 17243.8418 0 Inf
## 26 0 76114.2496 0 Inf
## 27 0 36584.8880 0 Inf
## 28 0 122.3362 0 Inf
## 29 0 20990.8477 0 Inf
## 30 0 48412.7746 0 Inf
## 31 0 5605.3812 0 Inf
## 32 0 39690.2743 0 Inf
## 33 0 4033.9683 0 Inf
## 34 0 1005.7531 0 Inf
## 35 0 504.2293 0 Inf
## 36 0 13658.3135 0 Inf
## 37 0 40663.3405 0 Inf
## 38 0 1084.6208 0 Inf
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 NaN
## 2 NaN
## 3 NaN
## 4 NaN
## 5 NaN
## 6 NaN
## 7 NaN
## 8 NaN
## 9 NaN
## 10 NaN
## 11 NaN
## 12 NaN
## 13 NaN
## 14 NaN
## 15 NaN
## 16 NaN
## 17 NaN
## 18 NaN
## 19 NaN
## 20 NaN
## 21 NaN
## 22 NaN
## 23 NaN
## 24 NaN
## 25 NaN
## 26 NaN
## 27 NaN
## 28 NaN
## 29 NaN
## 30 NaN
## 31 NaN
## 32 NaN
## 33 NaN
## 34 NaN
## 35 NaN
## 36 NaN
## 37 NaN
## 38 NaNRata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_1 <- mean(res_srs_1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_1 <- mean(res_srs_1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_1## [1] Infrt_com_1_1## [1] NaN b. f = 90%res_srs_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1637950 1483833 1635318 402455800 23816617552 395454784
## 2 10 2450030 2654313 2452799 557099538 41672541869 549271772
## 3 11 1427539 1735603 1428722 361164162 94918548665 359732480
## 4 12 1627050 2068453 1627769 316631546 194826494509 316108756
## 5 13 1659070 1452264 1657314 361885648 42791087893 358786582
## 6 14 2676482 2616771 2667092 512694594 3436062901 397892551
## 7 15 5063089 4862328 5050373 2477638157 39127830965 2311198536
## 8 16 2700715 2595871 2695284 547294945 10863919169 516347658
## 9 17 2063877 2279751 2065844 418649197 46636587984 414691320
## 10 18 1800682 1719622 1795991 359734753 6559949418 336148735
## 11 19 1892716 2264843 1893876 429732922 138379683280 428373245
## 12 2 1629238 1472153 1626906 362173025 24714672063 356674664
## 13 20 1934881 1538533 1932922 776053326 156904429035 772206886
## 14 21 1542883 1869929 1543882 324828697 106964200145 323821505
## 15 22 2023100 1859744 2021069 329032516 26640172535 324870471
## 16 23 2144757 2561868 2145760 416394000 174008120443 415379465
## 17 24 2723196 2701128 2710669 764955135 237886050 -115206081
## 18 25 3921741 3723463 3915053 1301678096 38799028941 1256047126
## 19 26 2050800 2255073 2052385 321073774 41686910382 318531582
## 20 27 1847144 1378056 1846459 321479344 219882264572 321007818
## 21 28 1632488 1897329 1633882 366948432 70019637502 364985631
## 22 29 1942709 2045140 1947135 447958062 10168664141 427942856
## 23 3 1790989 1897676 1797214 613085059 11402418965 569505301
## 24 4 2299061 2447583 2305145 869928097 21818074695 831023606
## 25 5 2079982 1900623 2077241 488262198 32107105454 480695905
## 26 6 2527640 2121998 2525785 751388354 164456207950 747942173
## 27 7 2717801 3050413 2719118 436441679 110496240564 434694938
## 28 71 2288263 2312975 2299949 1142795661 486458993 -379600925
## 29 72 1871201 2080292 1876597 1096658962 43473481291 1066238243
## 30 73 3481539 3093549 3477625 1513355241 149955157512 1497985039
## 31 74 2199782 2087311 2195556 458395346 12686842659 439898870
## 32 75 1867030 2159140 1869416 688724057 85287578415 682926163
## 33 76 2094468 1997346 2082901 1060924348 8927199264 917643563
## 34 77 2270178 2226235 2249376 1384027135 1548340918 209219150
## 35 78 7007674 6951401 6957005 4233355393 -780172025 -955540884
## 36 79 2174836 2010955 2170755 659235024 26759211207 642362101
## 37 8 2018998 1757221 2017238 459833109 68491188764 456727691
## 38 9 2277752 2228548 2269465 384197825 2295222115 291683878
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 245.4791 16062.37120 241.58913 59.1782192
## 2 227.3021 15700.56892 223.86057 74.8026860
## 3 252.7535 54691.29337 251.54347 262.8127556
## 4 194.5243 94186.33774 194.11724 615.3098047
## 5 217.9639 29471.70347 216.32436 118.2447775
## 6 191.5193 1312.99506 148.82681 6.7019683
## 7 489.2314 8045.13219 457.40553 15.7923912
## 8 202.6038 4185.27097 191.48675 19.8502092
## 9 202.7657 20455.75215 200.66111 111.3977723
## 10 199.7027 3817.33684 187.00937 18.2355176
## 11 226.9594 61096.70281 226.10301 322.0132232
## 12 222.1836 16796.11069 219.11503 68.2399580
## 13 400.8621 101985.45450 399.27846 202.1825355
## 14 210.4538 57197.05324 209.66628 329.2941822
## 15 162.6065 14329.86506 160.70847 80.9651667
## 16 194.0863 67920.37204 193.52331 417.8929577
## 17 280.7516 89.08811 -42.95664 0.3109804
## 18 331.8386 10419.76946 320.72377 29.8069308
## 19 156.5364 18481.28224 155.17836 129.8359248
## 20 173.9699 159579.93037 173.77948 683.9701172
## 21 224.6989 36904.08121 223.30766 190.8160152
## 22 230.4013 4968.36107 219.61443 22.7000360
## 23 341.9425 6007.93898 316.72240 18.5984290
## 24 378.1349 8915.01278 360.32773 25.0803196
## 25 234.6102 16893.33397 231.27339 65.7579177
## 26 297.1401 77500.19672 295.99353 218.8697856
## 27 160.5609 36220.23290 159.84113 253.1752713
## 28 498.9161 211.06566 -162.03186 0.4256745
## 29 585.4541 20898.58357 567.62946 39.6417508
## 30 434.5681 48471.24681 430.63398 99.0878767
## 31 208.3221 6080.51036 200.26713 27.6766393
## 32 368.7004 39497.56805 365.13654 123.8341793
## 33 506.2638 4470.12322 439.80688 8.4145484
## 34 609.2050 695.09635 89.12672 1.1187215
## 35 604.0266 -113.13515 -138.42232 -0.1842916
## 36 302.9376 13305.50187 295.71700 40.5913069
## 37 227.6472 38982.05220 226.30571 148.9479278
## 38 168.6239 1030.73095 128.16990 5.9740633
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9826043
## 2 0.9859491
## 3 0.9960359
## 4 0.9983489
## 5 0.9914363
## 6 0.7760810
## 7 0.9328233
## 8 0.9434541
## 9 0.9905461
## 10 0.9344350
## 11 0.9968360
## 12 0.9848184
## 13 0.9950436
## 14 0.9968993
## 15 0.9873507
## 16 0.9975635
## 17 -0.1506050
## 18 0.9649445
## 19 0.9920822
## 20 0.9985333
## 21 0.9946510
## 22 0.9553190
## 23 0.9289173
## 24 0.9552785
## 25 0.9845036
## 26 0.9954136
## 27 0.9959978
## 28 -0.3321687
## 29 0.9722605
## 30 0.9898436
## 31 0.9596495
## 32 0.9915817
## 33 0.8649472
## 34 0.1511669
## 35 -0.2257171
## 36 0.9744053
## 37 0.9932466
## 38 0.7592023Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.9 <- mean(res_srs_0.9$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.9 <- mean(res_srs_0.9$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.9## [1] 127.8254rt_com_1_0.9## [1] 0.8474652 c. f = 80%res_srs_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1639780 1483803 1633750 919625802 24428167183 881935144
## 2 10 2447781 2654147 2454016 1243869640 42300253598 1202864203
## 3 11 1433045 1734770 1435824 824183467 90939100800 816112347
## 4 12 1630086 2069539 1631715 708581283 193287884149 705849015
## 5 13 1661093 1452800 1657129 820771653 43391023569 804884717
## 6 14 2674741 2616757 2658170 1122671712 3212520588 470608989
## 7 15 5060801 4864062 5030832 5545086783 35478864345 4579003289
## 8 16 2689936 2594761 2675972 1198420257 9084522220 915739953
## 9 17 2064539 2277695 2069119 946993461 45394395437 924989691
## 10 18 1797108 1717211 1786180 797287196 6438946653 636284335
## 11 19 1887099 2263562 1889625 939015769 141731209521 932432608
## 12 2 1624684 1469152 1619324 815433485 24159569233 786117678
## 13 20 1923422 1537323 1919041 1691978325 149327912088 1672651309
## 14 21 1541665 1867975 1543883 715239562 106397142007 710170011
## 15 22 2017671 1855103 2013081 735005217 26218629689 713589068
## 16 23 2155830 2560944 2158193 948375390 164029400790 942683346
## 17 24 2724848 2699051 2706902 1760386684 -103946614 -502522597
## 18 25 3922965 3724353 3907760 2920020355 38047897697 2680899694
## 19 26 2048536 2255033 2052104 719886064 42623955243 706715532
## 20 27 1847701 1379940 1846183 711359832 218619310334 709022941
## 21 28 1634144 1899721 1637304 828221618 70307984292 817991877
## 22 29 1945016 2050055 1955169 1023140588 10331700396 912265985
## 23 3 1793947 1897861 1809383 1395390064 10552106803 1098013618
## 24 4 2295009 2446453 2309550 1916328728 22926397769 1653895797
## 25 5 2081892 1900055 2075611 1122636524 32823515137 1082575172
## 26 6 2528004 2119956 2523792 1713315458 166345109617 1695469881
## 27 7 2716072 3051718 2719000 977407849 112128470268 968744524
## 28 71 2295165 2315165 2300375 2615668686 35809366 -1276306306
## 29 72 1869626 2082161 1881746 2414130748 44531511625 2249624749
## 30 73 3490320 3096499 3481405 3471167619 154190531338 3390767631
## 31 74 2197964 2089424 2187664 1035289894 11578111628 901463904
## 32 75 1869696 2161092 1875219 1572726951 84662565789 1541092205
## 33 76 2090132 1999232 2065954 2378655121 7967791506 1262202603
## 34 77 2275681 2228257 2252415 3091588288 2471166124 130386212
## 35 78 7013607 6956193 6956927 9577135301 -5663983043 -5676998388
## 36 79 2177799 2012784 2168452 1484193904 26874642372 1392344841
## 37 8 2025710 1757294 2021740 1059226537 71958396569 1043362806
## 38 9 2275558 2226769 2259132 851434210 2139834400 340987881
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 559.8589 16493.27509 538.79376 26.56315984
## 2 507.8006 15939.09556 489.88201 34.00698291
## 3 574.1203 52421.74500 567.40494 110.33841910
## 4 434.0884 93386.55913 431.98258 272.78152670
## 5 493.3348 29888.76029 484.92378 52.86613327
## 6 419.4313 1226.90301 174.24237 2.86149598
## 7 1095.2072 7290.52968 908.40353 6.39825231
## 8 445.2618 3503.41692 340.38017 7.58041444
## 9 458.2678 19931.48752 446.67364 47.93527867
## 10 443.2183 3755.15003 354.43151 8.07606930
## 11 497.1211 62611.72755 492.98102 150.93592065
## 12 501.3925 16459.21095 484.87901 29.62788463
## 13 877.6568 97153.06276 869.59702 88.25639776
## 14 463.3682 56960.47534 459.42824 148.75735024
## 15 364.0767 14144.08018 354.25108 35.67135182
## 16 439.6350 64048.19065 436.52164 172.95830583
## 17 645.3347 -37.56296 -186.72876 -0.05904760
## 18 743.9634 10210.62137 685.42817 13.03001112
## 19 351.2494 18889.82939 344.24171 59.20930740
## 20 384.4822 158484.73652 383.53883 307.32591390
## 21 506.4785 37008.70801 499.27549 84.89030324
## 22 525.1596 5035.40414 466.01138 10.09802614
## 23 776.5188 5558.97929 608.23821 7.56211978
## 24 833.4142 9370.31297 716.55576 11.96370823
## 25 538.7771 17270.82790 521.03770 29.23788281
## 26 677.1027 78475.91000 671.15825 97.08959834
## 27 359.7469 36737.52723 356.17644 114.72024744
## 28 1137.2634 15.89265 -546.84286 0.01369033
## 29 1287.2248 21389.12495 1192.37774 18.44618883
## 30 993.9386 49802.21674 973.32864 44.42036463
## 31 470.8496 5542.34230 410.98986 11.18344890
## 32 840.4495 39166.85945 821.19940 53.83170025
## 33 1135.8768 3982.76908 598.73278 3.34970439
## 34 1354.8918 1107.00256 46.20204 0.79931928
## 35 1364.9743 -816.67598 -818.54784 -0.59140681
## 36 680.9547 13358.88756 641.24875 18.10723134
## 37 522.4494 40969.74307 515.61896 67.93485061
## 38 373.9557 962.95214 149.15377 2.51321168
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.95901522
## 2 0.96703398
## 3 0.99020713
## 4 0.99614403
## 5 0.98064390
## 6 0.41918665
## 7 0.82577667
## 8 0.76412256
## 9 0.97676460
## 10 0.79806165
## 11 0.99298930
## 12 0.96404881
## 13 0.98857727
## 14 0.99291209
## 15 0.97086259
## 16 0.99399811
## 17 -0.28546149
## 18 0.91810993
## 19 0.98170470
## 20 0.99671490
## 21 0.98764855
## 22 0.89163307
## 23 0.78688651
## 24 0.86305433
## 25 0.96431494
## 26 0.98958419
## 27 0.99113643
## 28 -0.48794647
## 29 0.93185705
## 30 0.97683777
## 31 0.87073573
## 32 0.97988542
## 33 0.53063708
## 34 0.04217451
## 35 -0.59276581
## 36 0.93811519
## 37 0.98502329
## 38 0.40048647Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.8 <- mean(res_srs_0.8$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.8 <- mean(res_srs_0.8$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.8## [1] 56.59714rt_com_1_0.8## [1] 0.7694924 d. f = 70%res_srs_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1639426 1483879 1629072 1559774074 24194955966 1446249480
## 2 10 2447562 2654970 2458457 2121674978 42604561180 1990029498
## 3 11 1431042 1735672 1435827 1425652326 92357592653 1401484227
## 4 12 1625684 2067821 1628457 1206640896 195560112541 1198577986
## 5 13 1662990 1453841 1655991 1448664815 43613225850 1398666193
## 6 14 2680686 2617089 2656516 1970642517 3509376640 544946562
## 7 15 5061846 4859941 5012209 9555627259 36310041800 6218202036
## 8 16 2698522 2595133 2677116 2096850852 10652771092 1424008986
## 9 17 2056607 2279864 2064235 1605599869 50078339920 1541614945
## 10 18 1802901 1719927 1786089 1403292030 6774101826 948948672
## 11 19 1894920 2263677 1899575 1673794401 136065945840 1650853144
## 12 2 1629906 1472490 1620610 1409967899 24741743425 1320536004
## 13 20 1929668 1538315 1922081 2967285094 152827622871 2909113742
## 14 21 1543480 1869632 1547395 1246082453 106512856093 1229937820
## 15 22 2028002 1860017 2020088 1292146659 28064368752 1227935011
## 16 23 2141020 2561266 2144928 1617215647 176603864288 1601443228
## 17 24 2724640 2700996 2709459 3037863835 -508488408 -1132637439
## 18 25 3916633 3721676 3889281 4967565878 35960095447 4165470789
## 19 26 2048962 2254388 2055224 1242697963 42071781550 1201578257
## 20 27 1846824 1379007 1844245 1210827542 218493303794 1204027518
## 21 28 1631258 1897240 1636731 1418416779 70431536217 1386951465
## 22 29 1941901 2045450 1960012 1710370698 9795916414 1320149949
## 23 3 1792194 1897280 1818820 2372906958 10603496554 1318611434
## 24 4 2293040 2446923 2317371 3280618704 23451281083 2339871618
## 25 5 2083704 1901181 2073108 1866861662 32858246203 1749556489
## 26 6 2528186 2122537 2520887 2940510400 164204697816 2886792872
## 27 7 2720633 3052788 2725773 1682525230 109847609016 1655438310
## 28 71 2300438 2311118 2302366 4472031300 -717862548 -1798284186
## 29 72 1871024 2078374 1895332 4247972892 43065541527 3482716253
## 30 73 3480240 3091258 3464690 5919522541 150300975094 5672963018
## 31 74 2203982 2085563 2188332 1746819520 13690389486 1443387290
## 32 75 1857672 2157231 1866855 2637899531 89243759401 2546617514
## 33 76 2092686 1995526 2059632 4137882775 9076211552 1471883102
## 34 77 2257345 2224207 2232561 5168087718 738456231 -1163296245
## 35 78 7004214 6946581 6946780 16260783068 -11586652723 -11590619526
## 36 79 2171649 2009237 2154978 2514593575 26288645726 2195600537
## 37 8 2020381 1757836 2013534 1778010383 69065575884 1730519542
## 38 9 2279357 2231296 2258124 1487553668 1977511353 144692288
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 948.4946 16339.1786 884.57759 15.5118336
## 2 865.8880 16044.6202 809.04050 20.0806257
## 3 994.2230 53216.3634 974.15890 64.7826900
## 4 740.5269 94564.0340 734.32431 162.0698529
## 5 868.8646 30022.4644 842.32915 30.1058087
## 6 734.5414 1341.4026 199.96908 1.7808286
## 7 1885.9028 7466.2539 1229.30978 3.7998596
## 8 775.9973 4106.0740 527.31598 5.0803666
## 9 779.3149 21965.1616 745.74529 31.1898007
## 10 776.9804 3938.3311 525.22723 4.8272930
## 11 881.4544 60106.6305 867.28155 81.2919112
## 12 863.4789 16818.6755 812.83197 17.5477353
## 13 1533.3437 99380.0378 1509.16208 51.5041926
## 14 805.5762 56962.8080 793.16978 85.4781767
## 15 636.5243 15105.4821 607.10281 21.7191822
## 16 754.6409 68935.6028 745.94238 109.2024212
## 17 1112.4244 -184.5675 -419.17611 -0.1673835
## 18 1267.3165 9666.2370 1068.31022 7.2389771
## 19 606.0815 18639.3373 584.32552 33.8551947
## 20 654.2852 158602.0595 651.54177 180.4495655
## 21 868.1137 37121.0945 846.11973 49.6550360
## 22 878.1553 4777.7336 672.91953 5.7273645
## 23 1319.4173 5592.9849 735.02297 4.4685682
## 24 1425.5540 9584.6672 1015.46102 7.1484324
## 25 894.7508 17291.6059 842.29909 17.6007933
## 26 1161.4828 77389.6494 1143.50022 55.8422435
## 27 618.0858 35973.5130 607.01185 65.2873473
## 28 1936.2534 -307.1674 -773.31974 -0.1605227
## 29 2257.3263 20728.3217 1837.01903 10.1379040
## 30 1698.8270 48596.3486 1634.87576 25.3907260
## 31 791.8716 6575.8918 657.16295 7.8373234
## 32 1417.7577 41355.4697 1362.46472 33.8313716
## 33 1969.5744 4546.5912 683.11398 2.1934434
## 34 2278.4535 333.1656 -529.68889 0.1428877
## 35 2319.8812 -1671.2478 -1671.83042 -0.7125520
## 36 1155.6296 13099.4937 1013.89170 10.4544313
## 37 878.4006 39306.4726 857.74204 38.8443040
## 38 651.8946 893.9073 60.23191 1.3293714
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.92721728
## 2 0.93795210
## 3 0.98304769
## 4 0.99331789
## 5 0.96548641
## 6 0.27653243
## 7 0.65073719
## 8 0.67911792
## 9 0.96014890
## 10 0.67623036
## 11 0.98629386
## 12 0.93657168
## 13 0.98039577
## 14 0.98704369
## 15 0.95030622
## 16 0.99024718
## 17 -0.37284009
## 18 0.83853358
## 19 0.96691094
## 20 0.99438399
## 21 0.97781659
## 22 0.77185019
## 23 0.55569454
## 24 0.71324096
## 25 0.93716451
## 26 0.98173190
## 27 0.98390103
## 28 -0.40211798
## 29 0.81985369
## 30 0.95834807
## 31 0.82629446
## 32 0.96539595
## 33 0.35570923
## 34 -0.22509220
## 35 -0.71279590
## 36 0.87314330
## 37 0.97328990
## 38 0.09726862Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.7 <- mean(res_srs_0.7$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.7 <- mean(res_srs_0.7$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.7## [1] 33.22019rt_com_1_0.7## [1] 0.7041666 e. f = 60%res_srs_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1637125 1481263 1620449 2432317862 24823241703 2110396056
## 2 10 2442475 2650665 2460420 3326979523 43356938031 2941986935
## 3 11 1435409 1733680 1443369 2238408231 89136811362 2165955785
## 4 12 1629303 2068771 1633724 1898138253 193242205756 1877257140
## 5 13 1658375 1449978 1647737 2164763509 43632894914 2046042854
## 6 14 2671724 2614621 2643835 2986526338 2865505704 14078246
## 7 15 5042676 4861605 4974228 14460204278 27690050496 5142708456
## 8 16 2701020 2592868 2671324 3360105578 11160512718 1800807111
## 9 17 2055988 2275982 2067698 2439361931 47689521281 2289143328
## 10 18 1792728 1715722 1768295 2131641831 5594527157 923236896
## 11 19 1891422 2263225 1898574 2548754453 138477021536 2492414192
## 12 2 1628454 1468033 1613928 2188186217 25541136774 1961489859
## 13 20 1923350 1536237 1911854 4454728760 148996527139 4320152412
## 14 21 1543163 1867603 1549292 1924402860 105129970876 1884108233
## 15 22 2019101 1854907 2006610 1951645087 26467680644 1786126623
## 16 23 2142448 2559339 2148594 2494643483 173932494332 2454774664
## 17 24 2729487 2697062 2709619 4723588130 -580304732 -1744427126
## 18 25 3922827 3722517 3881462 7802823189 36837161342 5617790603
## 19 26 2043439 2256585 2052755 1902244029 45083881557 1809903560
## 20 27 1852547 1379604 1848331 1995383757 222876130164 1977071374
## 21 28 1634403 1900488 1643064 2226091068 70203684178 2146443663
## 22 29 1942268 2051001 1968720 2718368705 10113648756 1801291599
## 23 3 1791882 1896537 1819892 3628497038 11649499920 631200426
## 24 4 2290768 2445637 2322191 5064236234 24472123175 2163032423
## 25 5 2078041 1897898 2060997 2924851972 31738247205 2617652143
## 26 6 2527656 2118070 2516676 4466962920 167084398570 4345002680
## 27 7 2717802 3043751 2726239 2648784844 106301253765 2573179017
## 28 71 2306319 2314112 2300646 7082780833 -825545827 -2943565504
## 29 72 1872780 2081697 1909890 6671417653 41977863816 4409446795
## 30 73 3492940 3096595 3468860 9212498797 155422688800 8610162314
## 31 74 2195801 2088779 2171066 2736142398 11622021150 1569820057
## 32 75 1881399 2160321 1897926 4305908258 76749666624 3999824906
## 33 76 2084319 1998623 2044908 6376210063 6208046272 607156270
## 34 77 2265535 2227815 2236074 8047452479 604917702 -1551506284
## 35 78 7024052 6960825 6961944 25461538178 -19387760702 -19432753040
## 36 79 2172091 2011942 2145930 3968819025 25409775314 3087255120
## 37 8 2009752 1754196 1999106 2691152157 64955612602 2576159694
## 38 9 2269548 2221866 2247976 2242812812 2229901590 205207528
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 1476.6873 16814.4082 1290.100509 10.20559117
## 2 1359.8559 16343.7972 1196.343428 13.03192212
## 3 1550.1921 51425.2525 1492.119274 39.82151698
## 4 1161.9542 93368.9742 1146.079817 101.80618058
## 5 1299.4069 30157.2317 1235.567758 20.15596380
## 6 1115.9124 1100.8285 -3.230547 0.95947779
## 7 2860.4724 5673.0508 998.881254 1.91491420
## 8 1242.2405 4312.1885 663.730306 3.32147680
## 9 1184.5723 20955.7100 1105.944443 19.54999817
## 10 1187.1683 3265.6250 509.281165 2.62451556
## 11 1342.2806 61181.2408 1307.790040 54.33125242
## 12 1340.1701 17416.6002 1209.796486 11.67228665
## 13 2306.3062 97040.1371 2249.967275 33.44682363
## 14 1244.1908 56269.5716 1213.473070 54.62991822
## 15 965.4745 14293.3664 888.452191 13.56172842
## 16 1162.3309 67940.2113 1140.576215 69.72238538
## 17 1724.9387 -206.1463 -647.761752 -0.12285253
## 18 1986.6629 9903.0267 1436.353166 4.72100424
## 19 930.1787 19946.4146 881.322380 23.70036697
## 20 1074.4625 161736.1131 1067.095450 111.69587274
## 21 1359.5719 36912.1294 1304.329746 31.53675300
## 22 1394.3780 4903.3543 916.287563 3.72048455
## 23 2011.2003 6143.6282 385.874490 3.21055792
## 24 2197.0543 10015.7573 965.025730 4.83234234
## 25 1404.2353 16727.6274 1265.174296 10.85123196
## 26 1763.0884 78915.2219 1722.249640 37.40447404
## 27 973.4781 34880.7071 942.898094 40.13208322
## 28 3054.4522 -350.2455 -1262.269037 -0.11655674
## 29 3531.9218 20201.6248 2331.407229 6.29219545
## 30 2633.4185 50212.9111 2476.393701 16.87085038
## 31 1244.2972 5573.9098 709.969696 4.24759368
## 32 2280.7934 35550.9346 2102.523899 17.82426889
## 33 3043.9774 3104.4483 246.154589 0.97362637
## 34 3534.3066 274.5239 -705.488238 0.07516884
## 35 3621.7353 -2792.8575 -2799.209083 -0.76145285
## 36 1820.2661 12651.3902 1423.313004 6.40235172
## 37 1335.1232 37047.1207 1284.574167 24.13672986
## 38 985.8628 1006.9710 84.777745 0.99424329
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.86764813
## 2 0.88428165
## 3 0.96763216
## 4 0.98899916
## 5 0.94515768
## 6 0.00471392
## 7 0.35564563
## 8 0.53593766
## 9 0.93841889
## 10 0.43311070
## 11 0.97789498
## 12 0.89639988
## 13 0.96979023
## 14 0.97906123
## 15 0.91519028
## 16 0.98401823
## 17 -0.36930128
## 18 0.71996897
## 19 0.95145709
## 20 0.99082263
## 21 0.96422096
## 22 0.66263697
## 23 0.17395644
## 24 0.42711918
## 25 0.89496910
## 26 0.97269728
## 27 0.97145641
## 28 -0.41559461
## 29 0.66094600
## 30 0.93461747
## 31 0.57373478
## 32 0.92891550
## 33 0.09522212
## 34 -0.19279471
## 35 -0.76321992
## 36 0.77787752
## 37 0.95727017
## 38 0.09149561Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.6 <- mean(res_srs_0.6$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.6 <- mean(res_srs_0.6$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.6## [1] 21.03624rt_com_1_0.6## [1] 0.6224309 f. f = 50%res_srs_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1634292 1483976 1608995 3647159434 23542265786 2781871922
## 2 10 2454318 2651805 2482654 5077949491 39295119624 3781158377
## 3 11 1424265 1734276 1435260 3183109192 95707245822 3038565102
## 4 12 1631493 2069023 1638133 2821429692 191220618329 2773299459
## 5 13 1658537 1448071 1643065 3182679716 44420336366 2930100434
## 6 14 2679847 2614598 2645899 4626282269 3011593059 45827558
## 7 15 5061372 4865367 4971280 22191612229 27710961375 5359120479
## 8 16 2703903 2596243 2665283 4967391133 10585497731 1743065369
## 9 17 2055037 2277704 2074116 3729544690 49675185162 3275371230
## 10 18 1797858 1717613 1766479 3233577355 6070406892 902092498
## 11 19 1890713 2266030 1901688 3903725208 140218011940 3766299521
## 12 2 1634902 1470070 1613245 3385973696 26070361260 2876400684
## 13 20 1937447 1538309 1919451 7139104612 157984048139 6806678127
## 14 21 1536018 1868973 1545099 2881449270 110624110550 2789230550
## 15 22 2027255 1856353 2008383 2975122800 28739065293 2584604549
## 16 23 2144106 2561757 2153545 3776700052 174692655458 3679721847
## 17 24 2722045 2699128 2702962 6674639299 -353076540 -2213386664
## 18 25 3923728 3725649 3865835 11662098725 34322467038 6562469069
## 19 26 2041433 2253770 2056265 2820994939 45270837191 2551024995
## 20 27 1845328 1374467 1839391 2808069690 220961143178 2770845680
## 21 28 1627384 1896094 1640702 3306080090 71911901461 3099670308
## 22 29 1940171 2044393 1976206 3982806073 9015899076 1418260780
## 23 3 1794141 1897924 1827189 5591362677 10567864302 380383455
## 24 4 2296178 2447393 2343961 7927137605 21338170992 1996346959
## 25 5 2085535 1898391 2060236 4427734487 34533780985 3659930016
## 26 6 2506643 2119212 2489406 6576632460 149273133227 6272386151
## 27 7 2709186 3044986 2721199 3911427478 111212631578 3758061347
## 28 71 2294160 2317185 2302582 10321504318 -1408771162 -4108240156
## 29 72 1892722 2084599 1945927 10233846727 35963565539 2649979469
## 30 73 3480838 3098179 3441396 13925812961 147083854805 12187211339
## 31 74 2193458 2091308 2159669 4087433877 9868737197 1564754952
## 32 75 1875600 2163501 1900970 6354774308 83000825104 5496569997
## 33 76 2101706 2001566 2048938 9631534275 8080344270 512537267
## 34 77 2259258 2230756 2233184 12064502278 1050955753 -3286915987
## 35 78 7018980 6956897 6956897 37973125753 -31598669335 -31598669335
## 36 79 2187444 2014991 2151928 5997515917 28822650678 4118086156
## 37 8 2016385 1755735 2000055 4096364878 68024257502 3817748815
## 38 9 2273403 2220801 2246455 3377397073 2101087159 -53677007
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 2210.450 15990.0206 1699.135556 6.45495932
## 2 2063.313 14821.2868 1533.161089 7.73838332
## 3 2218.759 55169.1146 2102.224010 30.06722046
## 4 1723.415 92392.4291 1687.199491 67.77436945
## 5 1904.951 30733.9662 1768.465744 13.95689806
## 6 1721.771 1155.3728 3.077696 0.65097477
## 7 4371.784 5660.6475 1018.025150 1.24871330
## 8 1832.545 4078.2306 632.033322 2.13099743
## 9 1808.152 21794.7075 1577.932157 13.31936987
## 10 1791.634 3541.2318 481.873235 1.87730375
## 11 2055.742 61868.8703 1972.547725 35.91902721
## 12 2063.664 17775.0548 1771.077162 7.69951677
## 13 3665.901 102715.3967 3526.990963 22.12939251
## 14 1868.389 59145.2978 1798.576004 38.39183001
## 15 1465.242 15550.1303 1282.342050 9.65979128
## 16 1756.705 68186.4596 1704.503124 46.25536925
## 17 2435.458 -116.9512 -813.838764 -0.05289822
## 18 2966.801 9211.4053 1669.503340 2.94307807
## 19 1378.556 20077.3350 1240.573922 16.04782645
## 20 1514.199 161024.7805 1499.207047 78.68791291
## 21 2022.699 37913.7034 1883.279566 21.75140938
## 22 2040.656 4350.7483 727.262220 2.26370526
## 23 3093.870 5561.4167 270.481332 1.89003377
## 24 3430.672 8719.4670 910.377444 2.69178764
## 25 2115.321 18196.7176 1759.378984 7.79942453
## 26 2614.002 70411.0598 2509.318776 22.69750273
## 27 1441.660 36477.0255 1379.269428 28.43274794
## 28 4463.613 -605.0480 -1760.598185 -0.13648894
## 29 5330.888 17280.7370 1486.415428 3.51417864
## 30 3987.549 47433.6439 3515.079351 10.56195823
## 31 1860.595 4741.0760 702.181062 2.41440901
## 32 3371.640 38357.6160 2896.460599 13.06117591
## 33 4546.251 4046.5786 167.152820 0.83894674
## 34 5273.950 459.3222 -1496.325795 0.08711141
## 35 5404.877 -4545.1635 -4545.163515 -0.83213243
## 36 2729.357 14322.9887 1878.865662 4.80576477
## 37 2024.138 38803.8424 1899.921314 16.60600545
## 38 1481.813 963.8640 -31.222339 0.62210250
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.762750292
## 2 0.744623077
## 3 0.954590282
## 4 0.982941190
## 5 0.920639428
## 6 0.009905915
## 7 0.241493066
## 8 0.350901574
## 9 0.878222813
## 10 0.278976625
## 11 0.964796270
## 12 0.849504734
## 13 0.953435829
## 14 0.967995716
## 15 0.868738779
## 16 0.974321973
## 17 -0.331611427
## 18 0.562717674
## 19 0.904299742
## 20 0.986743915
## 21 0.937566612
## 22 0.356095867
## 23 0.068030546
## 24 0.251837051
## 25 0.826592025
## 26 0.953738283
## 27 0.960790240
## 28 -0.398027267
## 29 0.258942658
## 30 0.875152594
## 31 0.382820860
## 32 0.864951253
## 33 0.053214499
## 34 -0.272445221
## 35 -0.832132428
## 36 0.686631968
## 37 0.931984559
## 38 -0.015893010Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.5 <- mean(res_srs_0.5$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.5 <- mean(res_srs_0.5$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.5## [1] 14.26236rt_com_1_0.5## [1] 0.5451536 g. f = 40%res_srs_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1635985 1484912 1598999 5615293161 23191090392 3523443968
## 2 10 2443283 2653746 2482580 7489420770 44821685289 4391006401
## 3 11 1424325 1736256 1442828 5002347393 97688003270 4518797856
## 4 12 1629233 2070789 1638904 4069231756 194677019031 3960228885
## 5 13 1652100 1449692 1627359 4858024477 41530178319 4125325786
## 6 14 2672777 2615155 2639165 7063352890 2612795240 -764091736
## 7 15 5064000 4865144 4952697 32992121833 24225479716 3174879268
## 8 16 2710265 2597037 2666598 7523780042 12519382838 1945903993
## 9 17 2064182 2279647 2095544 5878240231 45183356366 4336507519
## 10 18 1810041 1719849 1774736 5031762593 7991533848 1072852949
## 11 19 1890016 2267496 1906702 5792774117 141922285369 5451706460
## 12 2 1637618 1472542 1604904 5109517373 25706057432 3736591612
## 13 20 1924560 1540109 1898327 10046872548 148457859048 9334043545
## 14 21 1551494 1871542 1566707 4466287293 102288424708 4188357417
## 15 22 2014916 1858605 1987088 4350353069 24238721890 3019100527
## 16 23 2145654 2562562 2160058 5678373744 173479470950 5444297267
## 17 24 2715231 2698208 2697165 10711202017 -4066562324 -5012675254
## 18 25 3932662 3724328 3856600 17678329380 36587297223 7203651499
## 19 26 2050440 2256767 2074087 4285804397 42734226031 3497706219
## 20 27 1853886 1376861 1844811 4353562993 225619301468 4265105778
## 21 28 1633092 1897509 1654036 4971697907 69241906907 4439234024
## 22 29 1938458 2042313 1988000 5998671534 6683130691 1004453019
## 23 3 1808919 1899916 1847592 9117821237 6169256557 -2080183201
## 24 4 2301896 2449221 2347337 12111593301 21341598789 -1111591011
## 25 5 2074651 1900966 2035292 6457701926 29959913477 4287681966
## 26 6 2527342 2122462 2501495 10277315076 162961585304 9588339672
## 27 7 2713645 3045620 2732341 5866126178 108171892600 5475316189
## 28 71 2293523 2317577 2299948 15211860569 -3977898032 -7794478406
## 29 72 1892051 2085300 1956781 15708995387 33186012071 708852419
## 30 73 3500227 3098180 3443950 20803931498 160008031374 17006271315
## 31 74 2194578 2091857 2154285 6045416467 10813643678 1003393453
## 32 75 1850161 2163983 1884594 9215147864 97494549241 7418378100
## 33 76 2093224 2002245 2040611 14126099819 8040048388 -925359551
## 34 77 2296378 2231321 2250052 19572434907 954221480 -5029392717
## 35 78 7010811 6958992 6958992 56491753131 -49844257661 -49844257661
## 36 79 2159707 2015634 2109111 8550169849 19422026453 3442322503
## 37 8 2020015 1756908 1995357 6274025719 68573685244 5630605299
## 38 9 2274504 2224602 2246865 5138366174 1681005945 -1198579672
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 3388.179 15746.5017 2139.2903 4.12998747
## 2 3046.889 16899.3651 1801.7722 5.98466646
## 3 3469.176 56243.7369 3104.5649 19.52843247
## 4 2481.516 94001.9339 2400.8940 47.84122180
## 5 2907.209 28737.4137 2496.3789 8.54877914
## 6 2628.751 1007.1639 -308.0007 0.36990864
## 7 6485.244 4945.1986 560.7344 0.73428074
## 8 2762.021 4811.9851 685.2367 1.66397513
## 9 2835.042 19812.0376 2087.0988 7.68654471
## 10 2766.997 4659.6258 552.2176 1.58821759
## 11 3043.259 62561.5015 2841.4959 24.49988253
## 12 3105.263 17490.5509 2290.0306 5.03101478
## 13 5161.945 96574.0623 4857.3268 14.77652457
## 14 2860.277 54639.0864 2659.6058 22.90233879
## 15 2153.226 13133.1855 1499.1740 5.57166775
## 16 2638.041 67693.9886 2513.9670 30.55090749
## 17 3911.075 -1487.4763 -1841.1620 -0.37965509
## 18 4481.190 9821.9561 1805.5103 2.06961283
## 19 2085.420 18865.0490 1694.3264 9.97110976
## 20 2334.165 164232.5060 2298.8039 51.82405810
## 21 3029.558 36459.4953 2679.8412 13.92721525
## 22 3067.985 3222.0929 524.7754 1.11410179
## 23 4987.266 3246.2848 -1022.1076 0.67661521
## 24 5198.560 8706.4960 -327.9137 1.76208020
## 25 3092.532 15776.4985 2053.8499 4.63940792
## 26 4041.432 76691.2518 3805.9588 15.85643566
## 27 2156.048 35456.7740 1999.7553 18.44008965
## 28 6560.160 -1692.6901 -3330.1994 -0.26149977
## 29 8187.052 15868.8207 626.7019 2.11254834
## 30 5914.302 51692.2163 4871.9204 7.69124006
## 31 2744.574 5212.0867 420.0386 1.78873428
## 32 4945.213 45076.7560 3962.9264 10.57981388
## 33 6650.109 3998.2237 -587.1099 0.56916265
## 34 8429.885 428.5878 -2321.1152 0.04875334
## 35 8041.461 -7156.2829 -7156.2829 -0.88232804
## 36 3935.168 9660.6391 1561.1383 2.27153692
## 37 3085.786 39148.0343 2799.1077 10.92977433
## 38 2247.644 778.0656 -551.1119 0.32714795
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.62747284
## 2 0.58629453
## 3 0.90333547
## 4 0.97321291
## 5 0.84917765
## 6 -0.10817692
## 7 0.09623144
## 8 0.25863382
## 9 0.73772206
## 10 0.21321613
## 11 0.94112188
## 12 0.73130030
## 13 0.92904966
## 14 0.93777161
## 15 0.69398977
## 16 0.95877755
## 17 -0.46798438
## 18 0.40748486
## 19 0.81611429
## 20 0.97968165
## 21 0.89290100
## 22 0.16744591
## 23 -0.22814477
## 24 -0.09177909
## 25 0.66396406
## 26 0.93296154
## 27 0.93337852
## 28 -0.51239481
## 29 0.04512398
## 30 0.81745469
## 31 0.16597590
## 32 0.80501997
## 33 -0.06550708
## 34 -0.25696306
## 35 -0.88232804
## 36 0.40260282
## 37 0.89744696
## 38 -0.23326085Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.4 <- mean(res_srs_0.4$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.4 <- mean(res_srs_0.4$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.4## [1] 9.381166rt_com_1_0.4## [1] 0.4346928 h. f = 30%res_srs_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1628704 1480832 1583080 8398705154 23363985185 3936495787
## 2 10 2447272 2653771 2501385 11898135371 40946651425 4259443011
## 3 11 1454864 1733497 1492293 8766590353 77227999502 6058939443
## 4 12 1610511 2066415 1625575 6380264226 207437211253 6091328951
## 5 13 1677556 1452199 1639576 8463151804 52254724857 6499476677
## 6 14 2675051 2612459 2646166 10661839563 4020811294 -1566944835
## 7 15 5025055 4847789 4922914 50021689503 15540601912 -7759801492
## 8 16 2707267 2588445 2651713 11824966680 12195104451 835591075
## 9 17 2055552 2275814 2099965 8768602052 49497901719 4053082455
## 10 18 1807191 1717882 1763790 7632632319 6568065643 340157461
## 11 19 1875708 2259356 1900670 8542732824 147977533025 7305309181
## 12 2 1616163 1471233 1569184 7347192758 20146336217 3454142587
## 13 20 1939387 1536300 1897193 16970122572 159631587925 15092022839
## 14 21 1524842 1868563 1545711 6265088987 118367769430 5661302001
## 15 22 2025354 1855099 1983748 7098752350 26865976390 4375650473
## 16 23 2137048 2554785 2159743 8607852055 174155528253 7975423198
## 17 24 2705014 2686575 2683550 14384172251 -3854887807 -6075549386
## 18 25 3916253 3707607 3820868 27320658717 32515197077 5625125042
## 19 26 2038781 2253027 2072714 6801606592 45645765308 4771440021
## 20 27 1852340 1378899 1837245 7238479013 222416315291 6982867612
## 21 28 1622965 1897561 1654284 7544241092 73987484248 6131199558
## 22 29 1938588 2049217 1994395 9751086600 6951051587 -316647031
## 23 3 1780209 1896239 1816737 11810941037 12705726293 -2312223131
## 24 4 2297735 2443800 2357458 17988199005 17460719151 -2937571684
## 25 5 2077302 1901315 2024670 10083301538 31486735280 5330846164
## 26 6 2536384 2123836 2494966 16577925967 169369349866 14778675785
## 27 7 2715204 3047707 2745605 9297420178 107670084293 8218830092
## 28 71 2298738 2306208 2292298 25188971593 -5799966983 -11196057732
## 29 72 1855747 2074494 1907670 22244149141 47749585226 -2709555480
## 30 73 3481010 3089367 3392807 31796826493 149084786452 22539932173
## 31 74 2205340 2081860 2153763 9766068708 14468000069 1586470971
## 32 75 1863324 2152664 1917845 14037600435 82987084674 7694398934
## 33 76 2094169 1991805 2030468 22069169268 9813482478 -1974539650
## 34 77 2246969 2220291 2220281 28816551894 -973369783 -9214219261
## 35 78 7017355 6949227 6949227 87430705924 -75946938489 -75946938489
## 36 79 2172494 2005499 2109906 13674581772 25910380136 4467562995
## 37 8 2020552 1755585 1980542 9980441811 69472496352 8264653618
## 38 9 2277091 2233868 2254849 8028505580 2107739918 -1403313198
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 5054.848 15992.6173 2341.6515 2.78185563
## 2 4826.351 15448.5322 1795.5363 3.44143432
## 3 5918.330 44511.4105 4093.7872 8.80935420
## 4 3923.647 100395.9020 3713.6313 32.51232298
## 5 4958.947 36239.9434 3847.4419 6.17438114
## 6 3959.895 1541.1623 -639.5605 0.37712172
## 7 9877.880 3132.0685 -1755.4006 0.31067727
## 8 4343.312 4703.8226 236.4445 1.03130138
## 9 4224.204 21729.7939 2010.4514 5.64490228
## 10 4193.002 3850.1387 112.4217 0.86052431
## 11 4501.430 65472.3666 3842.0644 17.32203688
## 12 4514.789 13875.9141 2105.1474 2.74204542
## 13 8607.677 103944.8633 7807.9709 9.40662551
## 14 4053.073 63304.3449 3623.5975 18.89323036
## 15 3488.526 14524.8162 2160.2744 3.78460539
## 16 4002.034 68068.1873 3674.6801 20.23217025
## 17 5246.842 -1408.1622 -2232.4875 -0.26799511
## 18 6949.845 8784.8561 1364.0212 1.19013225
## 19 3323.340 20161.9898 2328.3377 6.71102697
## 20 3852.309 161628.7602 3749.9937 30.72694069
## 21 4613.722 38928.6126 3715.6690 9.80714738
## 22 4946.724 3353.8346 -106.1655 0.71284892
## 23 6531.527 6675.9638 -1091.0725 1.07575901
## 24 7729.826 7156.4856 -1060.5089 0.97067634
## 25 4805.869 16644.2923 2519.5409 3.12266128
## 26 6469.819 79679.1352 5847.9150 10.21655846
## 27 3411.106 35187.1346 2987.5168 11.58064089
## 28 10749.895 -2501.0049 -4829.3559 -0.23025819
## 29 11576.491 23036.0819 -848.1507 2.14661325
## 30 9072.067 48176.3951 6481.8160 4.68866874
## 31 4403.924 6997.5668 644.7300 1.48145590
## 32 7446.232 38443.3669 4176.5459 5.91177139
## 33 10329.443 4915.4679 -1191.4035 0.44466932
## 34 12538.078 -428.7044 -4194.4590 -0.03377815
## 35 12419.512 -10923.6149 -10923.6149 -0.86865293
## 36 6233.696 13032.2592 1973.2283 1.89478410
## 37 4898.261 39780.1565 4115.9114 6.96086382
## 38 3506.259 977.8681 -647.3112 0.26253204
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.46870270
## 2 0.35799248
## 3 0.69113979
## 4 0.95471421
## 5 0.76797354
## 6 -0.14696759
## 7 -0.15512874
## 8 0.07066329
## 9 0.46222675
## 10 0.04456621
## 11 0.85514897
## 12 0.47013093
## 13 0.88932904
## 14 0.90362675
## 15 0.61639712
## 16 0.92652884
## 17 -0.42237741
## 18 0.20589273
## 19 0.70151661
## 20 0.96468714
## 21 0.81269931
## 22 -0.03247300
## 23 -0.19576959
## 24 -0.16330549
## 25 0.52868063
## 26 0.89146711
## 27 0.88399039
## 28 -0.44448253
## 29 -0.12180981
## 30 0.70887364
## 31 0.16244725
## 32 0.54812779
## 33 -0.08947050
## 34 -0.31975440
## 35 -0.86865293
## 36 0.32670564
## 37 0.82808495
## 38 -0.17479133Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.3 <- mean(res_srs_0.3$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.3 <- mean(res_srs_0.3$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.3## [1] 6.127096rt_com_1_0.3## [1] 0.3396666 i. f = 20%res_srs_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1636202 1481666 1574166 14572545244 23375797723 4510695163
## 2 10 2446665 2652868 2510919 20001752276 39537388743 1453890787
## 3 11 1417673 1729914 1464111 12816346281 97321023636 7310525358
## 4 12 1616938 2061117 1644337 10762754056 197623934948 9695545677
## 5 13 1635462 1438544 1579923 12733635533 39445221817 7198910503
## 6 14 2673866 2610873 2632046 16602009048 5554512554 -1595558742
## 7 15 5085111 4863610 4930522 88623745643 -277664980 -21287175995
## 8 16 2703177 2597244 2646103 19636376252 13280476485 191061757
## 9 17 2084702 2278620 2138334 15320312578 36930800196 1636683593
## 10 18 1788705 1719188 1755279 12943817775 5903202221 -2871618240
## 11 19 1890455 2265483 1937840 15222832622 138858072176 10957859005
## 12 2 1636162 1472639 1579239 12755913040 29443828181 4300926069
## 13 20 1904382 1536712 1833476 26216597936 133900472516 20643295867
## 14 21 1549447 1868566 1588839 11537995417 101595669380 7922607721
## 15 22 2027927 1859389 1968143 12275742962 25612929788 4378745585
## 16 23 2139092 2560774 2178862 14975880969 176142401483 12549829518
## 17 24 2684891 2696039 2674266 27119655841 -8105361463 -13451983753
## 18 25 3941422 3720543 3807658 47438228161 23203015866 1624625337
## 19 26 2031133 2241181 2077945 11132858176 44784375206 4137525345
## 20 27 1840008 1354789 1816731 11418601491 231713897129 10769257838
## 21 28 1610492 1878695 1660674 12396717677 68666160643 7265618045
## 22 29 1931315 2026521 1994606 16174169563 -2741587051 -6731449670
## 23 3 1784157 1893897 1817651 21400938990 8253873734 -8497938778
## 24 4 2319251 2446761 2348296 35058309618 14070016899 -15758814917
## 25 5 2090102 1896221 2012878 18116413384 34535696139 6776819947
## 26 6 2524980 2122393 2456265 27558232708 156766471309 21506968557
## 27 7 2693459 3046031 2741129 15456068590 120151376283 11698421032
## 28 71 2296368 2309874 2294108 40205739987 -9535895606 -17340577086
## 29 72 1874180 2077123 1915615 42091333916 41750474571 -16566158651
## 30 73 3500473 3092016 3381825 54628848415 160917314383 29019793679
## 31 74 2205154 2083299 2150929 15583358454 16708291356 932927208
## 32 75 1861248 2156380 1936815 24740361743 84292512765 5800524176
## 33 76 2089428 1994162 2021695 37673504866 -1601863836 -11202807862
## 34 77 2233458 2223572 2209788 44814192212 -3379055899 -17195119769
## 35 78 6985679 6948383 6948383 152322296477 -141277641818 -141277641818
## 36 79 2160215 2008181 2086963 24287997701 21382356313 1554191917
## 37 8 2014679 1753451 1950259 16906371134 65813537237 11197728992
## 38 9 2282664 2224002 2239099 14175749991 -2519404557 -4854764312
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 8652.927 15992.2491 2568.58762 1.604098483
## 2 8054.468 14973.4429 831.78315 1.976696251
## 3 8810.268 56169.4110 5129.45363 7.593507658
## 4 6589.613 95622.1674 5861.28432 18.361836934
## 5 7603.301 27944.0685 4333.42150 3.097718771
## 6 6150.133 2153.5329 -640.33769 0.334568698
## 7 17293.798 -179.4467 -4600.59522 -0.003133077
## 8 7174.811 5111.4389 -48.90101 0.676320127
## 9 7261.415 16185.3248 991.87113 2.410577461
## 10 7151.400 3553.8524 -1770.53071 0.456063452
## 11 7908.498 61249.3685 5663.86836 9.121697363
## 12 7664.719 20164.2657 2438.27701 2.308249366
## 13 13365.170 87371.7538 10816.74580 5.107469430
## 14 7305.425 54378.4744 5061.74562 8.805313723
## 15 6002.197 13974.4705 2110.59962 2.086466772
## 16 6942.762 68682.4296 5765.29618 11.761738882
## 17 9757.869 -2966.8259 -4883.17453 -0.298874053
## 18 11957.781 6207.6881 225.05724 0.489120626
## 19 5445.168 19912.4387 2134.44121 4.022720356
## 20 6094.335 171668.3411 5833.50698 20.292668705
## 21 7611.914 36418.1351 4501.27263 5.539059809
## 22 8155.034 -1285.4367 -3215.94479 -0.169504038
## 23 11661.067 4443.8376 -4238.70682 0.385678111
## 24 14651.390 5818.2094 -6186.75875 0.401331868
## 25 8537.517 18344.7033 3122.42317 1.906320827
## 26 10753.874 74008.8764 8521.68342 5.688553144
## 27 5705.146 39116.4959 4296.35845 7.773734671
## 28 16992.632 -4082.0864 -7474.89505 -0.237177468
## 29 20951.851 20508.9916 -7179.62727 0.991901912
## 30 15415.309 51806.5876 8084.18280 2.945647200
## 31 7001.616 8143.8169 273.94128 1.072188091
## 32 13003.567 39077.0338 3565.98738 3.407084894
## 33 17539.763 -757.9501 -5822.07316 -0.042519639
## 34 19440.603 -1434.5497 -7724.08631 -0.075401468
## 35 21697.415 -20248.4403 -20248.44029 -0.927491543
## 36 11043.118 10861.2275 433.82597 0.880367191
## 37 8259.027 37701.8872 5538.10359 3.892824588
## 38 6139.166 -1092.3194 -2174.99516 -0.177726368
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.309533790
## 2 0.072688171
## 3 0.570406354
## 4 0.900842445
## 5 0.565346046
## 6 -0.096106365
## 7 -0.240197205
## 8 0.009729991
## 9 0.106830953
## 10 -0.221852493
## 11 0.719830486
## 12 0.337171166
## 13 0.787413223
## 14 0.686653741
## 15 0.356699028
## 16 0.838002755
## 17 -0.496023395
## 18 0.034247176
## 19 0.371649875
## 20 0.943132821
## 21 0.586092080
## 22 -0.416185180
## 23 -0.397082520
## 24 -0.449502988
## 25 0.374070728
## 26 0.780419005
## 27 0.756882060
## 28 -0.431296056
## 29 -0.393576471
## 30 0.531217379
## 31 0.059866890
## 32 0.234455916
## 33 -0.297365692
## 34 -0.383698086
## 35 -0.927491543
## 36 0.063990121
## 37 0.662337819
## 38 -0.342469662Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.2 <- mean(res_srs_0.2$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.2 <- mean(res_srs_0.2$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.2## [1] 3.512097rt_com_1_0.2## [1] 0.1728069 j. f = 10%res_srs_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1651737 1475670 1570203 34192283666 29226622341 777346398
## 2 10 2456110 2642080 2520886 46315363403 29632293197 -10363913639
## 3 11 1442237 1723227 1504226 33338750410 74057646378 -6531658292
## 4 12 1596365 2049804 1654510 23562803397 203210736995 15511830205
## 5 13 1663225 1444868 1564719 31735802158 43705859338 8519796158
## 6 14 2653677 2607601 2618875 38276980280 4947428856 -8778691672
## 7 15 5109561 4841286 4918300 200453584817 -24785224131 -57703165129
## 8 16 2692387 2585466 2623827 44356568288 3857899326 -11454409999
## 9 17 2037823 2269626 2119896 33210569697 51587613986 -2445295107
## 10 18 1779507 1710482 1727518 27499744705 875914364 -6325947774
## 11 19 1888606 2250105 1958467 34509820648 136030059713 2106387007
## 12 2 1613718 1463547 1539025 27968584075 20967428996 1297443724
## 13 20 1920884 1527194 1779249 64932688501 146955685741 33209767049
## 14 21 1512527 1855415 1574961 23920546731 120015174097 8020644839
## 15 22 2016962 1853833 1936349 27108579913 22175758238 2451149647
## 16 23 2145624 2551191 2232492 32304043717 161828962012 16879323798
## 17 24 2711322 2701713 2681857 60865777169 -10199617776 -25184913836
## 18 25 3896691 3712241 3769877 103774964093 2141792796 -27353531696
## 19 26 2027224 2231518 2108429 25115934530 37337374387 319018396
## 20 27 1835198 1361115 1784323 24855907783 221225927943 21328589358
## 21 28 1615265 1877334 1690189 27762762152 65093761913 1114974784
## 22 29 1936066 2031757 1998327 36508903327 -15369169758 -20753670621
## 23 3 1814353 1881559 1798453 56046873210 5897620170 -21112110543
## 24 4 2277054 2432404 2311629 74688513919 11624314881 -35143769112
## 25 5 2085644 1887112 1977886 44018781586 28354723727 3089822212
## 26 6 2515348 2107882 2382738 63894087092 156037248043 35880704003
## 27 7 2675396 3048719 2768301 32707486138 123796580890 17880168207
## 28 71 2250029 2293986 2242431 81834232211 -16014638276 -33518784607
## 29 72 1841602 2060501 1876987 97052474214 27155255746 -48653077137
## 30 73 3516720 3069322 3324150 125593321784 197204731926 31398788954
## 31 74 2193817 2068142 2115344 36769038865 6905234530 -8472232472
## 32 75 1828400 2140212 1907222 55353149538 95357118833 -874367249
## 33 76 2105634 1978184 2004142 87618226192 3339220594 -20717886993
## 34 77 2162940 2205912 2156337 90931091100 2368483178 -27772610145
## 35 78 6920687 6893963 6893963 329813291988 -309486530047 -309486530047
## 36 79 2149536 1992501 2053998 45019414856 14695621735 -9067781290
## 37 8 1979416 1749237 1885808 34394179861 52535675767 10427803335
## 38 9 2277855 2220438 2241660 29463295232 -1290796653 -9830978126
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 19739.10 20662.3796 -376.1528 0.85477246
## 2 18413.74 11136.8196 -3458.1664 0.63979403
## 3 21703.46 42972.7715 -2583.9068 2.22136839
## 4 14405.41 98761.7387 9529.9891 8.62421731
## 5 18215.42 31439.0993 4651.1567 1.37717834
## 6 13989.84 2017.4371 -3478.6762 0.12925337
## 7 38239.17 -5407.9434 -12463.2333 -0.12364570
## 8 16169.79 1506.7468 -4642.9242 0.08697470
## 9 15881.77 22843.0619 -528.8738 1.55334926
## 10 15128.73 509.5338 -3850.9173 0.03185173
## 11 17424.57 60537.9830 2105.8022 3.94177823
## 12 16900.52 14862.8669 317.3446 0.74967789
## 13 31914.12 95929.9972 16359.4015 2.26320039
## 14 15235.99 64134.2898 5653.0059 5.01724210
## 15 13213.55 12177.1580 932.0253 0.81803467
## 16 14905.10 63066.1951 7969.4885 5.00955742
## 17 21353.73 -3525.1016 -9120.5824 -0.16757558
## 18 26151.28 855.1480 -7554.5087 0.02063882
## 19 12284.16 16043.6599 500.3411 1.48660104
## 20 12948.84 163937.0178 11483.7636 8.90033588
## 21 16705.29 34580.7754 1517.3724 2.34464285
## 22 17774.68 -6781.8557 -9309.0462 -0.42097046
## 23 28723.93 3055.8275 -10795.4545 0.10522657
## 24 30772.67 4915.1246 -13847.5418 0.15563725
## 25 20477.66 15114.8814 823.4373 0.64415058
## 26 24444.36 74094.4216 13902.3817 2.44212344
## 27 12078.70 40414.0959 6654.4898 3.78496166
## 28 34038.20 -6925.1883 -14384.1450 -0.19569608
## 29 47181.80 13857.9191 -21798.0032 0.27979973
## 30 34831.90 63337.9128 7550.8140 1.57018486
## 31 16512.41 3635.8604 -4276.7929 0.18780025
## 32 28937.74 44231.9922 1296.8889 1.72270448
## 33 39122.34 1844.4373 -11160.5048 0.03811103
## 34 38893.95 1303.3289 -12522.1218 0.02604701
## 35 47141.29 -44496.7245 -44496.7245 -0.93836888
## 36 20367.69 7567.8190 -5026.7690 0.32642854
## 37 16669.84 30422.4343 4798.5076 1.52745831
## 38 12619.41 -390.4486 -4432.5922 -0.04381033
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.02273456
## 2 -0.22376838
## 3 -0.19591791
## 4 0.65831853
## 5 0.26846009
## 6 -0.22934651
## 7 -0.28786297
## 8 -0.25823481
## 9 -0.07363003
## 10 -0.23003660
## 11 0.06103732
## 12 0.04638932
## 13 0.51144913
## 14 0.33530358
## 15 0.09041970
## 16 0.52251427
## 17 -0.41377791
## 18 -0.26358508
## 19 0.01270183
## 20 0.85808933
## 21 0.04016080
## 22 -0.56845505
## 23 -0.37668668
## 24 -0.47053780
## 25 0.07019327
## 26 0.56156533
## 27 0.54666898
## 28 -0.40959368
## 29 -0.50130692
## 30 0.25000365
## 31 -0.23041757
## 32 -0.01579616
## 33 -0.23645636
## 34 -0.30542480
## 35 -0.93836888
## 36 -0.20141935
## 37 0.30318511
## 38 -0.33366866Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.1 <- mean(res_srs_0.1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.1 <- mean(res_srs_0.1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.1## [1] 1.499764rt_com_1_0.1## [1] -0.0422394 k. f = 5%res_srs_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1605266 1444798 1519734 58544128587 24483004818 -9143978370
## 2 10 2462822 2632037 2504598 94631985375 11224815540 -44245567336
## 3 11 1424771 1701439 1466087 67132805488 84446965486 -19432824785
## 4 12 1613137 2033371 1708690 52966402143 172559686576 -729282937
## 5 13 1672546 1428623 1542466 73328298941 48330252720 5276930961
## 6 14 2612636 2595422 2587155 82475762200 -8179109573 -32193055568
## 7 15 5084982 4827410 4865063 426028285126 -94322081214 -157041663721
## 8 16 2631731 2558517 2575973 80173336652 -1674125976 -22630861992
## 9 17 1970492 2248021 2044542 62040838795 75508884776 -12430911908
## 10 18 1741692 1685909 1680696 61122287360 914024999 -16592785919
## 11 19 1823223 2224414 1920313 56995747177 152532009473 -1216407695
## 12 2 1592739 1437274 1490567 62124812253 9266140806 -12035724250
## 13 20 1895380 1499794 1713055 127264054064 150620242650 43931761962
## 14 21 1575244 1834821 1641349 62539789837 62521945852 -20015900535
## 15 22 2007998 1827237 1905150 56645253446 30390993570 -815528941
## 16 23 2091849 2526882 2208117 64875716342 187159769968 3721250199
## 17 24 2739948 2667196 2664805 156446147603 -39555990805 -63129077356
## 18 25 3832270 3685580 3725212 204316258330 -20183432612 -68038404648
## 19 26 2014974 2223904 2092473 51282434558 36005645273 -12967648560
## 20 27 1800823 1353262 1687427 54829146153 177109492390 32250623387
## 21 28 1578328 1875851 1675180 60763680394 79088290607 -13514469347
## 22 29 1970406 2052446 2013068 89633369826 -52940777379 -66650943258
## 23 3 1739149 1861027 1730720 103966156668 19456254744 -35664258514
## 24 4 2276095 2413918 2294283 150987701858 36442318888 -45274744050
## 25 5 2058514 1871575 1932698 83874427015 29361561471 -3070414305
## 26 6 2492470 2095351 2294305 131097356477 138651722005 28904171394
## 27 7 2693570 3037439 2824569 76188196052 93327856843 -8402100392
## 28 71 2239970 2266304 2187826 188289808885 -47237510147 -92755978577
## 29 72 1850260 2032304 1855062 207324621400 -18569425390 -109557395746
## 30 73 3437453 3062068 3213476 261062860658 108872563472 -27958522779
## 31 74 2225857 2041748 2105819 82092286992 18165477392 -9462783957
## 32 75 1787210 2111090 1859828 111059477662 116975858156 -28055197176
## 33 76 2104429 1949337 1971412 182747167146 8829393007 -31597377767
## 34 77 2184151 2179412 2107761 219245561388 3791637613 -57363044820
## 35 78 7003672 6950964 6950964 713049902144 -671669893959 -671669893959
## 36 79 2079220 1963674 1980476 99833494950 -253249742 -25896974670
## 37 8 1954082 1726467 1823088 77807965279 47682759321 5811861106
## 38 9 2275690 2218162 2225243 64497901700 -9413374303 -22603379369
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 34127.81 18676.3383 -7126.376 0.418197442
## 2 36404.00 4642.7316 -16012.052 0.118615450
## 3 40505.52 48752.2415 -9387.064 1.257909078
## 4 30681.84 85368.7364 2628.077 3.257908402
## 5 39345.16 35752.5430 1422.714 0.659094148
## 6 30486.48 -3175.0914 -12413.589 -0.099169857
## 7 79033.91 -20799.0088 -33690.544 -0.221398636
## 8 29341.92 -797.6624 -9185.976 -0.020881331
## 9 29786.90 33144.7965 -4187.285 1.217083557
## 10 32618.79 666.3206 -9913.230 0.014954038
## 11 29430.29 68486.5105 1565.684 2.676199840
## 12 36957.39 7559.8574 -9094.253 0.149153623
## 13 58813.39 101790.4327 20639.912 1.183525417
## 14 36289.49 34075.3533 -9313.874 0.999714678
## 15 27114.35 17379.4008 -1108.211 0.536514389
## 16 29957.10 73458.5021 3501.117 2.884897162
## 17 50393.47 -12922.3841 -22074.439 -0.252840939
## 18 51357.26 -5843.6689 -18984.606 -0.098785250
## 19 24781.73 15207.5560 -5268.220 0.702104835
## 20 28133.52 137630.5449 18140.247 3.230207012
## 21 35790.52 41928.1531 -5412.477 1.301571763
## 22 41056.78 -23004.2364 -29158.332 -0.590636919
## 23 51480.52 10335.4057 -18074.963 0.187140271
## 24 57062.46 14811.4715 -18425.125 0.241359518
## 25 37690.59 15730.3055 -3060.940 0.350065717
## 26 49739.73 66713.5508 9288.565 1.057624087
## 27 27509.22 30307.6553 -1668.890 1.224964780
## 28 75482.23 -20033.9600 -39642.451 -0.250876616
## 29 91661.67 -8128.8064 -50428.249 -0.089566908
## 30 71546.48 34599.7162 -12850.129 0.417035817
## 31 35700.41 9792.8954 -5303.750 0.221281171
## 32 56392.73 54222.3707 -10628.731 1.053272180
## 33 75696.99 5051.4700 -17727.823 0.048314801
## 34 84396.32 2637.8285 -25097.417 0.017294022
## 35 99523.17 -94660.8232 -94660.823 -0.941967585
## 36 44541.03 287.0298 -13482.018 -0.002536721
## 37 36969.47 28736.3044 1904.149 0.612826195
## 38 27382.84 -4281.1095 -10133.881 -0.145948536
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 -0.15618950
## 2 -0.46755404
## 3 -0.28946838
## 4 -0.01376878
## 5 0.07196309
## 6 -0.39033353
## 7 -0.36861793
## 8 -0.28227417
## 9 -0.20036660
## 10 -0.27146867
## 11 -0.02134208
## 12 -0.19373458
## 13 0.34520165
## 14 -0.32005065
## 15 -0.01439713
## 16 0.05735968
## 17 -0.40351954
## 18 -0.33300534
## 19 -0.25286726
## 20 0.58820218
## 21 -0.22241032
## 22 -0.74359520
## 23 -0.34303719
## 24 -0.29985716
## 25 -0.03660728
## 26 0.22047867
## 27 -0.11028087
## 28 -0.49262347
## 29 -0.52843408
## 30 -0.10709498
## 31 -0.11527007
## 32 -0.25261416
## 33 -0.17290215
## 34 -0.26163834
## 35 -0.94196758
## 36 -0.25940166
## 37 0.07469494
## 38 -0.35045139Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_1_0.05 <- mean(res_srs_0.05$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_1_0.05 <- mean(res_srs_0.05$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_1_0.05## [1] 0.6137953rt_com_1_0.05## [1] -0.2068222 2. Metode One stage cluster
a. f = 100%res_1sc_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1637409 1484546 1637409 0 23367160158 0
## 2 10 2452226 2656398 2452226 0 41686037135 0
## 3 11 1432925 1736676 1432925 0 92264682627 0
## 4 12 1628141 2070386 1628141 0 195581155363 0
## 5 13 1660654 1452773 1660654 0 43214520571 0
## 6 14 2677707 2617885 2677707 0 3578628369 0
## 7 15 5059790 4863519 5059790 0 38522139703 0
## 8 16 2702258 2596479 2702258 0 11189241307 0
## 9 17 2063216 2280593 2063216 0 47252536988 0
## 10 18 1802921 1720645 1802921 0 6769362207 0
## 11 19 1893080 2266122 1893080 0 139160429063 0
## 12 2 1631372 1473225 1631372 0 25010528782 0
## 13 20 1933963 1539654 1933963 0 155479806202 0
## 14 21 1543883 1871616 1543883 0 107408906085 0
## 15 22 2024290 1859814 2024290 0 27052299781 0
## 16 23 2145480 2562473 2145480 0 173883605020 0
## 17 24 2721467 2698896 2721467 0 509476091 0
## 18 25 3923463 3722909 3923463 0 40222101589 0
## 19 26 2049321 2256961 2049321 0 43114400382 0
## 20 27 1850200 1379119 1850200 0 221917551646 0
## 21 28 1632444 1899669 1632444 0 71409379673 0
## 22 29 1945828 2049705 1945828 0 10790438814 0
## 23 3 1794553 1899490 1794553 0 11011912392 0
## 24 4 2297582 2449242 2297582 0 23000653140 0
## 25 5 2083579 1902456 2083579 0 32805645589 0
## 26 6 2526531 2124414 2526531 0 161698161955 0
## 27 7 2716794 3050885 2716794 0 111616270475 0
## 28 71 2297609 2314435 2297609 0 283139160 0
## 29 72 1872873 2081921 1872873 0 43701295609 0
## 30 73 3484448 3097221 3484448 0 149945060415 0
## 31 74 2197198 2088987 2197198 0 11709568505 0
## 32 75 1867766 2160606 1867766 0 85755048745 0
## 33 76 2088732 1998934 2088732 0 8063635637 0
## 34 77 2275392 2228054 2275392 0 2240872147 0
## 35 78 7020112 6960868 7020112 0 3509873670 0
## 36 79 2178314 2012520 2178314 0 27487633079 0
## 37 8 2025630 1758243 2025630 0 71496025026 0
## 38 9 2279804 2230617 2279804 0 2419373518 0
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 0 15740.2769 0 Inf
## 2 0 15692.6939 0 Inf
## 3 0 53127.1634 0 Inf
## 4 0 94466.0213 0 Inf
## 5 0 29746.2278 0 Inf
## 6 0 1366.9922 0 Inf
## 7 0 7920.6305 0 Inf
## 8 0 4309.3906 0 Inf
## 9 0 20719.4082 0 Inf
## 10 0 3934.2014 0 Inf
## 11 0 61409.0701 0 Inf
## 12 0 16976.7190 0 Inf
## 13 0 100983.6028 0 Inf
## 14 0 57388.3367 0 Inf
## 15 0 14545.7042 0 Inf
## 16 0 67857.7295 0 Inf
## 17 0 188.7721 0 Inf
## 18 0 10803.9457 0 Inf
## 19 0 19102.8585 0 Inf
## 20 0 160912.5386 0 Inf
## 21 0 37590.4229 0 Inf
## 22 0 5264.3865 0 Inf
## 23 0 5797.2981 0 Inf
## 24 0 9390.9274 0 Inf
## 25 0 17243.8418 0 Inf
## 26 0 76114.2496 0 Inf
## 27 0 36584.8880 0 Inf
## 28 0 122.3362 0 Inf
## 29 0 20990.8477 0 Inf
## 30 0 48412.7746 0 Inf
## 31 0 5605.3812 0 Inf
## 32 0 39690.2743 0 Inf
## 33 0 4033.9683 0 Inf
## 34 0 1005.7531 0 Inf
## 35 0 504.2293 0 Inf
## 36 0 13658.3135 0 Inf
## 37 0 40663.3405 0 Inf
## 38 0 1084.6208 0 Inf
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 NaN
## 2 NaN
## 3 NaN
## 4 NaN
## 5 NaN
## 6 NaN
## 7 NaN
## 8 NaN
## 9 NaN
## 10 NaN
## 11 NaN
## 12 NaN
## 13 NaN
## 14 NaN
## 15 NaN
## 16 NaN
## 17 NaN
## 18 NaN
## 19 NaN
## 20 NaN
## 21 NaN
## 22 NaN
## 23 NaN
## 24 NaN
## 25 NaN
## 26 NaN
## 27 NaN
## 28 NaN
## 29 NaN
## 30 NaN
## 31 NaN
## 32 NaN
## 33 NaN
## 34 NaN
## 35 NaN
## 36 NaN
## 37 NaN
## 38 NaNRata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_1 <- mean(res_1sc_1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_1 <- mean(res_1sc_1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_1## [1] Infrt_com_2_1## [1] NaN b. f = 90%res_1sc_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1630245 1476800 1623657 967558390 23800101347 922251410
## 2 10 2451728 2645514 2456531 905334100 37494462357 881443930
## 3 11 1427724 1726411 1430535 828155147 89114768750 820052937
## 4 12 1633745 2055681 1636022 953912648 177820190655 948654874
## 5 13 1647670 1445834 1644659 602279355 40761648804 593064991
## 6 14 2672073 2605765 2654481 1310790998 4460561496 609477469
## 7 15 5047244 4837242 5004614 8365042828 41513711427 5971354774
## 8 16 2698089 2583709 2689898 853738513 13206230119 777730735
## 9 17 2046559 2270266 2050630 886135802 50123910124 868890880
## 10 18 1804629 1712994 1797522 601033201 8393939597 545177608
## 11 19 1880520 2252404 1882586 761998543 138230529416 757669715
## 12 2 1625254 1466822 1619523 882128747 25011861595 848269125
## 13 20 1907960 1530587 1904889 1155305219 142209884174 1145831291
## 14 21 1545187 1860751 1547639 763535367 99703682390 757379158
## 15 22 2021562 1852325 2016278 874676752 28490579723 846114494
## 16 23 2128727 2549428 2131471 1145093996 176916384461 1137464721
## 17 24 2693096 2687735 2692348 1144501812 275973343 -286035995
## 18 25 3899411 3702676 3866815 6399992446 36927908650 4767617463
## 19 26 2035556 2238883 2042296 1327597596 41073930449 1280221884
## 20 27 1837456 1366614 1835677 837325480 221457194365 834147584
## 21 28 1620293 1883507 1624971 1207763233 69029771724 1185262288
## 22 29 1932028 2034917 1948843 1585722629 9703679099 1263150785
## 23 3 1780090 1887342 1796349 1487842337 11621494006 1146112364
## 24 4 2293830 2435606 2304743 1434998078 19832640776 1304004175
## 25 5 2066918 1892869 2060856 1032472440 30187357473 994933188
## 26 6 2506349 2115166 2502045 1680635216 153382072269 1661910102
## 27 7 2710464 3044015 2713750 1085552196 111068051881 1074579767
## 28 71 2297885 2297114 2293999 2149882186 -211288804 -763774542
## 29 72 1860215 2065059 1871013 2046520226 42313775986 1917886707
## 30 73 3471490 3075500 3460531 4263288906 156096563754 4141144495
## 31 74 2179834 2072384 2172026 775303856 11682366668 699884503
## 32 75 1837016 2143781 1843194 1840192276 94056278315 1800087070
## 33 76 2077261 1982692 2061319 1377032941 8814697398 1010642016
## 34 77 2239860 2210460 2224032 2964797107 1029114995 -358253781
## 35 78 6962747 6913278 6913278 18591946422 -14867037006 -14867037006
## 36 79 2136666 1996717 2129598 938536049 19745138970 885703536
## 37 8 2025481 1750504 2022368 848303426 75887819138 838517320
## 38 9 2262540 2226052 2242999 1412869912 1138650262 149598722
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 592.8180 16168.2711 567.14661 24.59810342
## 2 369.1794 14164.9850 358.76257 41.41505588
## 3 579.5465 51613.0677 572.76334 107.60636954
## 4 583.5449 86496.3583 579.52624 186.41139843
## 5 365.3001 28241.6821 360.36591 67.67897404
## 6 490.4941 1713.3639 226.62458 3.40295402
## 7 1654.8052 8578.5583 1183.16465 4.96276137
## 8 316.3809 5114.4352 288.84598 15.46870608
## 9 432.6223 22073.4192 423.38799 56.56459202
## 10 332.9503 4902.4143 302.88536 13.96585010
## 11 405.0057 61365.0553 402.26675 181.40524102
## 12 542.5369 17059.8441 523.42868 28.35398084
## 13 605.2005 92930.3026 601.19866 123.09291244
## 14 493.7047 53576.2733 488.95796 130.58161639
## 15 432.5348 15398.9067 419.45986 32.57269574
## 16 537.7700 69387.0995 533.50709 154.49944294
## 17 424.8307 106.2330 -105.74611 0.24112967
## 18 1638.8293 9960.6069 1221.57125 5.76999254
## 19 651.8279 18330.7154 626.57786 30.93853934
## 20 455.4352 162110.7776 454.14679 264.48161382
## 21 744.9316 36645.9920 729.01044 57.15505311
## 22 818.8873 4759.5616 648.01151 6.11940507
## 23 834.7718 6151.1305 640.62082 7.81097145
## 24 624.9891 8142.3618 565.65115 13.82067410
## 25 499.1212 15948.4085 482.30139 29.23793052
## 26 669.4820 72544.0349 663.15402 91.26434507
## 27 400.4071 36464.4672 395.88388 102.31479640
## 28 934.4853 -91.4158 -331.66877 -0.09827925
## 29 1097.6514 20495.3019 1023.47829 20.67596276
## 30 1227.5031 50763.5472 1195.95056 36.61411816
## 31 355.6530 5641.8615 321.75563 15.06811371
## 32 999.7080 43867.7808 974.69052 51.11220145
## 33 662.5509 4448.8461 486.61500 6.40122479
## 34 1321.5299 465.5580 -167.90534 0.34711144
## 35 2665.6955 -2151.2603 -2151.26027 -0.79964930
## 36 438.9071 9895.2108 415.37854 21.03823181
## 37 418.5637 43377.2827 414.35956 89.45834333
## 38 623.3980 515.3087 65.31223 0.80591302
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9531739
## 2 0.9736118
## 3 0.9902166
## 4 0.9944882
## 5 0.9847008
## 6 0.4649692
## 7 0.7138463
## 8 0.9109707
## 9 0.9805392
## 10 0.9070674
## 11 0.9943191
## 12 0.9616160
## 13 0.9917996
## 14 0.9919372
## 15 0.9673454
## 16 0.9933374
## 17 -0.2499218
## 18 0.7449411
## 19 0.9643147
## 20 0.9962047
## 21 0.9813697
## 22 0.7965774
## 23 0.7703184
## 24 0.9087149
## 25 0.9636414
## 26 0.9888583
## 27 0.9898923
## 28 -0.3552634
## 29 0.9371452
## 30 0.9713497
## 31 0.9027228
## 32 0.9782060
## 33 0.7339273
## 34 -0.1208359
## 35 -0.7996493
## 36 0.9437075
## 37 0.9884639
## 38 0.1058829Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.9 <- mean(res_1sc_0.9$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.9 <- mean(res_1sc_0.9$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.9## [1] 53.21996rt_com_2_0.9## [1] 0.7609081 c. f = 80%res_1sc_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1624312 1471983 1608363 2199618313 23537009539 1911452018
## 2 10 2457058 2647065 2468639 2028526604 36354323302 1879340257
## 3 11 1405915 1722378 1411837 1809129511 100133304429 1771334398
## 4 12 1625649 2048575 1630828 2148033993 178725320771 2120202948
## 5 13 1663682 1446157 1657090 1402146507 47423954044 1357231628
## 6 14 2648726 2610265 2630779 2875560607 1819360486 -241987719
## 7 15 5067949 4846004 4992756 19337153056 44057393488 8324107404
## 8 16 2695027 2584974 2676068 1925149448 12371352754 1308087147
## 9 17 2053979 2271344 2063547 1948816235 47289945613 1847430864
## 10 18 1805098 1710402 1789204 1363874990 8811574268 1028603666
## 11 19 1870100 2247957 1874717 1709564199 142803013723 1687435493
## 12 2 1614713 1462698 1600717 1989578074 22616175172 1777437883
## 13 20 1920657 1524355 1914069 2592773911 157073752032 2548994681
## 14 21 1542085 1855075 1547663 1702658832 97773494533 1670127491
## 15 22 2023139 1854560 2011093 1937416554 28148315324 1785535454
## 16 23 2135366 2551040 2141712 2579077629 172942888870 2537303747
## 17 24 2714173 2701232 2709344 2616127325 1410777708 -462958776
## 18 25 3901898 3711873 3835716 14077719994 31719463430 5995116672
## 19 26 2024313 2232910 2039958 2983561101 43069927853 2703447336
## 20 27 1827896 1361733 1823820 1897236946 216660743875 1880462381
## 21 28 1603463 1877174 1613620 2651155935 74698259687 2540024643
## 22 29 1944249 2031043 1982763 3625216768 5322644115 937990755
## 23 3 1769095 1880219 1798978 3365118156 11571425850 1542143252
## 24 4 2298987 2432988 2326257 3240001926 19176878869 1868610815
## 25 5 2075718 1888985 2062542 2332452614 34916741135 2149158673
## 26 6 2495695 2111690 2485685 3836790637 147057898259 3735075624
## 27 7 2716348 3057822 2723686 2461214769 115831231250 2405525410
## 28 71 2299056 2288740 2290120 4888146413 -1687627878 -2519911099
## 29 72 1847757 2054437 1872982 4622309488 41306988691 3858776128
## 30 73 3420435 3067250 3392695 9351140694 122526985950 8545417865
## 31 74 2159206 2062445 2139582 1743723932 9451195384 1158194438
## 32 75 1842447 2134223 1857798 4021511489 86251771500 3740657604
## 33 76 2064658 1971926 2037581 3051573568 8539569218 1242070041
## 34 77 2226812 2200171 2205220 6503347937 1803957492 -1258848895
## 35 78 6965679 6908238 6908238 41447865320 -35318782504 -35318782504
## 36 79 2153013 1986514 2138777 2164382683 28058828790 1939823088
## 37 8 2018219 1748766 2011117 1879192901 73100944228 1827868176
## 38 9 2273591 2230957 2248651 3250183872 809169364 -460457592
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 1350.9484 16090.1427 1181.97682 10.7004972
## 2 825.0495 13723.2988 761.44607 17.9215413
## 3 1282.5568 58145.9469 1250.62975 55.3488868
## 4 1319.1956 87227.3433 1298.05389 83.2041399
## 5 841.7022 32924.4532 817.90171 33.8223957
## 6 1085.1662 698.7292 -97.88319 0.6326977
## 7 3804.0089 9086.4602 1619.41508 2.2783806
## 8 714.1624 4791.5790 484.13210 6.4261779
## 9 946.9244 20818.7844 893.93666 24.2659850
## 10 755.0746 5158.0088 570.99809 6.4606906
## 11 913.0406 63527.4802 899.05620 83.5318228
## 12 1231.2052 15489.6152 1107.76706 11.3673223
## 13 1348.2365 103119.2664 1329.94310 60.5813532
## 14 1102.6825 52690.7634 1077.84047 57.4240081
## 15 956.3148 15202.4730 885.97596 14.5287885
## 16 1206.9191 67762.4060 1183.96126 67.0561006
## 17 963.0585 532.4699 -169.90657 0.5392619
## 18 3594.5893 8516.5346 1506.03106 2.2531677
## 19 1472.0844 19259.5003 1325.57289 14.4357452
## 20 1036.5991 159270.3945 1029.73723 114.1980417
## 21 1650.8250 39793.3742 1572.56683 28.1757322
## 22 1855.5713 2601.6811 482.08243 1.4682278
## 23 1898.8699 6155.4182 881.83983 3.4386388
## 24 1405.8835 7867.0947 815.40783 5.9187863
## 25 1121.4501 18489.2432 1038.72536 14.9699681
## 26 1532.7818 69631.3537 1498.07213 38.3283614
## 27 905.5324 37828.8914 882.67695 47.0626264
## 28 2121.3980 -734.6031 -1100.75138 -0.3452490
## 29 2492.0100 20106.0393 2060.26281 8.9364394
## 30 2730.5765 39977.8772 2513.04586 13.1028919
## 31 807.4201 4600.8014 536.89133 5.4201214
## 32 2165.1767 40434.6577 1998.97471 21.4476004
## 33 1476.4304 4340.3717 591.51811 2.7984150
## 34 2905.6577 822.6824 -579.76596 0.2773890
## 35 5929.7051 -5101.9597 -5101.95972 -0.8521255
## 36 1003.9985 14159.9282 904.14135 12.9638945
## 37 929.6190 41865.3612 907.27607 38.9001811
## 38 1425.1661 374.4022 -208.54310 0.2489611
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.86899259
## 2 0.92645581
## 3 0.97910867
## 4 0.98704348
## 5 0.96796706
## 6 -0.08415323
## 7 0.43047223
## 8 0.67947304
## 9 0.94797592
## 10 0.75417738
## 11 0.98705594
## 12 0.89337428
## 13 0.98311491
## 14 0.98089380
## 15 0.92160638
## 16 0.98380278
## 17 -0.17696340
## 18 0.42585850
## 19 0.90611429
## 20 0.99115842
## 21 0.95808195
## 22 0.25874060
## 23 0.45827314
## 24 0.57673139
## 25 0.92141579
## 26 0.97348956
## 27 0.97737322
## 28 -0.51551465
## 29 0.83481561
## 30 0.91383695
## 31 0.66420746
## 32 0.93016211
## 33 0.40702608
## 34 -0.19356936
## 35 -0.85212549
## 36 0.89624774
## 37 0.97268789
## 38 -0.14167124Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.8 <- mean(res_1sc_0.8$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.8 <- mean(res_1sc_0.8$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.8## [1] 23.92731rt_com_2_0.8## [1] 0.6419405 d. f = 70%res_1sc_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1608711 1463532 1582774 3690096960 21480182564 2515742775
## 2 10 2450337 2649899 2470022 3477714264 39908535220 3021621231
## 3 11 1432558 1721980 1444308 3209780927 83403425628 3056587939
## 4 12 1626934 2055869 1635853 3727702471 183330759124 3644313220
## 5 13 1640088 1432961 1629004 2210318047 43715951134 2077921088
## 6 14 2668889 2600771 2635790 4945616664 3997881782 -141360276
## 7 15 5064430 4849225 4959395 32496861579 32085421143 6416301959
## 8 16 2700804 2579763 2674183 3353980651 15070631563 1805771743
## 9 17 2032761 2269457 2048544 3363538079 56472783975 3070833752
## 10 18 1806416 1709638 1782310 2332476531 9410844627 1310085084
## 11 19 1878253 2252140 1886263 2896188724 139752852921 2828121933
## 12 2 1621438 1463028 1598060 3383067725 25367002511 2657333388
## 13 20 1913479 1524305 1901983 4407461349 151591972726 4272479779
## 14 21 1543510 1863154 1553101 2937664918 102072464110 2838501938
## 15 22 2013851 1848265 1991948 3310458572 27126256205 2755404022
## 16 23 2114018 2545112 2124402 4354152893 184884733940 4240850035
## 17 24 2692934 2666956 2678250 4493523535 1696687423 -792167767
## 18 25 3865489 3694441 3769826 24652924062 16189896437 2875260168
## 19 26 2032692 2247432 2060323 5064943072 46213722682 4037733290
## 20 27 1831015 1359598 1824290 3170759496 221590912705 3124744088
## 21 28 1625079 1881247 1644909 4722316526 64210547645 4282761684
## 22 29 1914496 2022606 1962755 6025391854 7841493403 1146265595
## 23 3 1791077 1886750 1829715 5809511623 8507956964 -170752836
## 24 4 2302177 2438997 2338644 5512128452 20133155404 1672711542
## 25 5 2049643 1894098 2021864 3874343926 23545133562 3002973960
## 26 6 2516436 2123840 2499504 6593250830 153798835146 6299167039
## 27 7 2701237 3036508 2714020 4111938267 111896902252 3934651482
## 28 71 2306484 2292105 2288082 8316009013 -293559142 -2722390289
## 29 72 1828805 2060546 1867427 7800816132 50912282690 5791184415
## 30 73 3472311 3082352 3426012 16681083601 148637148361 14352916318
## 31 74 2184094 2067007 2159192 2965890717 13754978569 1742420226
## 32 75 1843636 2138204 1870603 6851820027 86358027753 5912093628
## 33 76 2043596 1977117 2013467 5179311732 3882146227 -194784520
## 34 77 2237998 2207137 2208692 11524465598 -156493778 -3669026614
## 35 78 7040191 6982970 6982970 74252788939 -66680215706 -66680215706
## 36 79 2158084 1990844 2134846 3662156088 28769895220 2885273281
## 37 8 2029845 1740709 2018049 3297366826 83983782461 3152547556
## 38 9 2270484 2233717 2245099 5337589633 -321225929 -1506870509
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 2284.238 14845.87391 1560.28454 5.82103473
## 2 1417.578 15053.68127 1225.02487 11.47550724
## 3 2230.659 48415.00045 2107.69044 25.98414893
## 4 2287.621 89116.04283 2224.61519 49.18063085
## 5 1341.941 30723.04059 1269.66428 19.77812704
## 6 1851.456 1533.09736 -73.81089 0.80836871
## 7 6386.966 6598.76298 1213.34737 0.98733907
## 8 1241.111 5865.93472 663.66616 4.49335674
## 9 1648.393 24868.19803 1495.30653 16.78969664
## 10 1289.988 5514.92273 720.74997 4.03470067
## 11 1538.911 62035.04451 1496.62696 48.25405601
## 12 2082.668 17397.95504 1644.82150 7.49822486
## 13 2298.028 99671.11413 2240.67032 34.39439639
## 14 1898.866 54728.06659 1824.05793 34.74612216
## 15 1640.110 14699.80171 1374.30073 8.19410834
## 16 2057.658 72629.63940 1994.73508 42.46170001
## 17 1666.419 652.79301 -298.17412 0.37758508
## 18 6344.631 4369.53361 681.21912 0.65671303
## 19 2486.535 20516.30512 1971.09124 9.12423339
## 20 1725.993 163232.80020 1707.26010 69.88575228
## 21 2900.042 34092.85341 2603.11193 13.59725620
## 22 3120.506 3853.19006 605.68400 1.30140804
## 23 3226.425 4527.61644 -26.29439 1.46448747
## 24 2384.431 8247.22567 754.07981 3.65251927
## 25 1884.441 12439.19614 1470.41582 6.07719243
## 26 2607.751 72576.03996 2507.77915 23.32670774
## 27 1519.287 36775.74815 1447.25537 27.21269022
## 28 3582.714 -112.79792 -1183.68442 -0.03530048
## 29 4232.508 24761.89284 3107.94009 6.52653284
## 30 4797.415 48270.11125 4168.65766 8.91052116
## 31 1357.166 6674.65755 793.04780 4.63772266
## 32 3672.000 40424.62429 3131.35325 12.60366259
## 33 2529.480 1975.96118 -128.18988 0.74954867
## 34 5114.732 -65.34375 -1669.91942 -0.01357927
## 35 10501.046 -9527.62739 -9527.62739 -0.89801631
## 36 1692.799 14499.72739 1337.82619 7.85599918
## 37 1621.720 48337.68872 1558.81113 25.46995433
## 38 2335.087 -131.26220 -674.02144 -0.06018183
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.68175520
## 2 0.86885264
## 3 0.95227307
## 4 0.97762985
## 5 0.94010049
## 6 -0.02858294
## 7 0.19744374
## 8 0.53839659
## 9 0.91297725
## 10 0.56167128
## 11 0.97649781
## 12 0.78548040
## 13 0.96937430
## 14 0.96624428
## 15 0.83233303
## 16 0.97397821
## 17 -0.17629100
## 18 0.11662958
## 19 0.79719224
## 20 0.98548758
## 21 0.90691966
## 22 0.19023918
## 23 -0.02939194
## 24 0.30346019
## 25 0.77509225
## 26 0.95539624
## 27 0.95688486
## 28 -0.32736740
## 29 0.74238186
## 30 0.86043069
## 31 0.58748632
## 32 0.86285010
## 33 -0.03760819
## 34 -0.31836848
## 35 -0.89801631
## 36 0.78786191
## 37 0.95608033
## 38 -0.28231292Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.7 <- mean(res_1sc_0.7$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.7 <- mean(res_1sc_0.7$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.7## [1] 14.14013rt_com_2_0.7## [1] 0.5479332 e. f = 60%res_1sc_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1596830 1462873 1561907 5748600406 19006226065 2919855837
## 2 10 2453780 2640554 2486867 5451677413 33844140666 3758440991
## 3 11 1408747 1717212 1426080 4832188810 95426726123 4467501820
## 4 12 1633631 2045035 1648654 5840302635 168664419810 5588610407
## 5 13 1649960 1435372 1632468 3578287628 46034601083 3241102962
## 6 14 2656859 2600141 2624817 7662383884 3243117519 -798437910
## 7 15 5035380 4836678 4908692 49293215685 14931390953 -3716002002
## 8 16 2697008 2576717 2661591 5097493129 14549027193 2151423955
## 9 17 2042885 2265307 2069621 5199922738 49014067156 4052644106
## 10 18 1801417 1705616 1771144 3596638272 9208897080 1363632548
## 11 19 1872032 2244309 1885315 4652618008 138856938373 4456439130
## 12 2 1616706 1459029 1580807 5200698779 24813764114 3272451762
## 13 20 1932066 1519577 1914796 7026459885 169114264781 6722793977
## 14 21 1542516 1853667 1558454 4573931601 97040568708 4279901897
## 15 22 1991569 1849494 1954505 5159586400 19330697709 3045345572
## 16 23 2126017 2542705 2143480 6884341903 173088285940 6548767480
## 17 24 2704546 2683070 2690811 6710087537 932671015 -1978941277
## 18 25 3901931 3697155 3799556 37678785198 30353576484 4772351025
## 19 26 2013663 2233760 2053188 7708170832 47773557209 4898320453
## 20 27 1820780 1355804 1810193 4909417839 214591585365 4793719141
## 21 28 1610098 1873247 1641369 7174828041 68003713405 5954320663
## 22 29 1921270 2021782 1982728 9056570963 3545007702 -674398632
## 23 3 1760780 1876649 1795435 8522545943 14847840370 -331968157
## 24 4 2287032 2429590 2332465 8623147940 19795703011 1754090919
## 25 5 2067625 1884952 2031700 6203672308 32918736586 4525305922
## 26 6 2492687 2110785 2465906 10050757640 142927877754 9283842465
## 27 7 2688002 3039258 2707207 6378923803 121692891886 5965778436
## 28 71 2295948 2282580 2278161 13421204601 -4095633572 -6280962017
## 29 72 1816565 2049967 1871792 12030466272 55387479068 4459074886
## 30 73 3425704 3064926 3354273 24670414636 125617055656 18048085606
## 31 74 2165353 2057246 2134259 4590980123 13852208063 1419702565
## 32 75 1831418 2128692 1874249 10585275364 85730737276 7958196844
## 33 76 2033239 1967128 2007166 7990667945 6944344344 104979789
## 34 77 2239629 2195800 2206846 17124777211 2127723788 -5375405939
## 35 78 6986886 6925236 6925236 112772563787 -104734805844 -104734805844
## 36 79 2161281 1981300 2128301 5593024783 33208223930 4046793873
## 37 8 2020501 1739305 2001450 5092042994 78744098456 4703216553
## 38 9 2275306 2225128 2237579 8541603621 -371900960 -2510458109
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 3572.626 13196.6921 1.803738e+03 3.30623538
## 2 2218.569 12787.8502 1.526518e+03 6.20802335
## 3 3399.819 55559.0294 3.109586e+03 19.74813690
## 4 3560.198 82419.5603 3.378172e+03 28.87939724
## 5 2160.248 32391.9385 1.976445e+03 12.86498065
## 6 2878.932 1248.7087 -3.260526e+02 0.42325177
## 7 9726.245 3090.7602 -8.781761e+02 0.30290965
## 8 1887.869 5662.7939 7.869431e+02 2.85415337
## 9 2536.785 21608.5077 1.972511e+03 9.42592220
## 10 1992.722 5403.5241 7.378748e+02 2.56041792
## 11 2477.203 61874.2725 2.357718e+03 29.84490413
## 12 3203.939 17072.5024 2.012618e+03 4.77123655
## 13 3626.535 111465.1962 3.499741e+03 24.06820327
## 14 2952.045 52314.7947 2.737727e+03 21.21600784
## 15 2582.231 10504.3543 1.528765e+03 3.74655955
## 16 3232.288 68020.9022 3.052373e+03 25.14231402
## 17 2474.707 373.2870 -7.324836e+02 0.13899536
## 18 9569.181 8139.3233 1.052647e+03 0.80558798
## 19 3812.626 21298.6495 2.426602e+03 6.19778132
## 20 2684.807 158744.3154 2.637113e+03 43.71018976
## 21 4435.408 36358.0257 3.643123e+03 9.47809662
## 22 4651.222 1746.9569 -2.913822e+02 0.39142935
## 23 4793.695 7912.2879 -4.349178e+01 1.74218367
## 24 3750.675 8139.6210 8.159000e+02 2.29564692
## 25 2987.343 17503.7543 2.194423e+03 5.30633066
## 26 4013.255 67801.1303 3.745965e+03 14.22060733
## 27 2367.361 39967.1902 2.199212e+03 19.07733901
## 28 5799.432 -1785.7317 -2.747331e+03 -0.30516140
## 29 6535.175 27108.8065 2.576113e+03 4.60393453
## 30 7174.905 40989.0927 5.287331e+03 5.09180966
## 31 2117.809 6773.1987 6.296349e+02 3.01726596
## 32 5701.549 40316.9601 4.230360e+03 8.09905594
## 33 3911.193 3568.2430 -8.194221e-01 0.86905680
## 34 7560.930 960.6493 -2.502356e+03 0.12424826
## 35 16028.639 -15038.6446 -1.503864e+04 -0.92872594
## 36 2576.112 16826.1184 1.870914e+03 5.93743551
## 37 2515.062 45406.2150 2.341838e+03 15.46414642
## 38 3718.149 -145.8777 -1.128835e+03 -0.04353995
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.50792465
## 2 0.68941001
## 3 0.92452965
## 4 0.95690425
## 5 0.90576927
## 6 -0.10420229
## 7 -0.07538567
## 8 0.42205529
## 9 0.77936622
## 10 0.37914087
## 11 0.95783473
## 12 0.62923309
## 13 0.95678252
## 14 0.93571620
## 15 0.59023056
## 16 0.95125541
## 17 -0.29492034
## 18 0.12665883
## 19 0.63547118
## 20 0.97643332
## 21 0.82989037
## 22 -0.07446512
## 23 -0.03895176
## 24 0.20341654
## 25 0.72945599
## 26 0.92369578
## 27 0.93523275
## 28 -0.46798795
## 29 0.37064855
## 30 0.73156799
## 31 0.30923736
## 32 0.75181765
## 33 0.01313780
## 34 -0.31389640
## 35 -0.92872594
## 36 0.72354299
## 37 0.92364039
## 38 -0.29390946Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.6 <- mean(res_1sc_0.6$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.6 <- mean(res_1sc_0.6$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.6## [1] 8.964641rt_com_2_0.6## [1] 0.4520409 f. f = 50%res_1sc_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1632835 1484396 1587700 9149275272 24710825324 3600460559
## 2 10 2442102 2658680 2484736 7982011652 47442665743 4807211628
## 3 11 1436098 1734481 1465764 7720659809 88823987812 6384506992
## 4 12 1622028 2069503 1642273 8223150817 201419986695 7720955720
## 5 13 1658700 1455429 1632825 5267253894 44493306809 4168586106
## 6 14 2680381 2616552 2654106 11553496906 4394988910 -1907469406
## 7 15 5049364 4865599 4922524 75538502109 211702643 -18050628493
## 8 16 2704944 2594129 2663401 7696106400 12618541482 1450062426
## 9 17 2051418 2278097 2087937 7775100723 52034466309 4643942407
## 10 18 1789562 1717167 1760212 5336973548 5245592723 -104476699
## 11 19 1885847 2261112 1905849 6893154128 140627612789 6421194833
## 12 2 1630842 1468403 1583462 7834424327 24991897061 3923690202
## 13 20 1929203 1536348 1901610 10634835530 151350964943 9844575843
## 14 21 1541598 1866919 1566020 6992767358 106014126401 6233046544
## 15 22 2006537 1851819 1960359 7553923526 23249265268 3707170325
## 16 23 2139990 2559908 2167293 10297389336 176566341195 9380422906
## 17 24 2730352 2695276 2705003 10411215457 2770248296 -2571872059
## 18 25 3931271 3721743 3810568 56823637116 25854402629 -2115114619
## 19 26 2040098 2252817 2097818 12181761255 44783115954 4966525375
## 20 27 1851796 1380423 1836040 7406626495 219999093114 7146902363
## 21 28 1635279 1896860 1683694 11001886098 66936460635 6958205278
## 22 29 1930172 2041215 1994725 13383817835 3472679605 -2724557737
## 23 3 1785951 1898597 1827580 13275318879 12511112390 -1790863735
## 24 4 2289779 2445629 2336206 12587035083 27758580633 380193800
## 25 5 2087316 1902848 2034377 9800476889 32528185002 5535274249
## 26 6 2531720 2122752 2490956 16310014002 161528922618 14520781286
## 27 7 2719634 3062810 2750592 9586691380 116071926073 8428355652
## 28 71 2304420 2313967 2289799 19363750966 -1804806154 -8321759197
## 29 72 1868184 2080171 1931877 18943411549 45095800285 -66996860
## 30 73 3496997 3093098 3397968 38993407097 151112504160 25079083681
## 31 74 2193982 2087575 2155270 7046233853 11323391968 1306409428
## 32 75 1857099 2159343 1922719 17023642203 90505691992 7987323741
## 33 76 2072897 1997407 2032107 11976143554 4774368130 -1801279242
## 34 77 2302002 2226120 2244680 29039513066 -785965586 -7629609260
## 35 78 7010166 6951603 6951603 171393204556 -159075991797 -159075991797
## 36 79 2176669 2011265 2127547 8745647098 29256785951 3872442105
## 37 8 2029909 1759446 1998376 7845808231 72865230246 6669952232
## 38 9 2308347 2235983 2251192 14377199825 182871752 -2930864696
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 5545.196 17091.06986 2140.9449 2.700850569
## 2 3255.867 17809.03687 1972.8303 5.943697881
## 3 5335.778 51137.97638 4376.5082 11.504714624
## 4 5023.250 97324.24144 4667.3643 24.494259097
## 5 3141.983 31164.97839 2508.7194 8.447154382
## 6 4302.623 1702.16457 -767.5090 0.380403349
## 7 14824.919 62.37873 -3825.3771 0.002802579
## 8 2843.400 4879.87548 503.1396 1.639600705
## 9 3760.162 22834.80897 2274.7885 6.692449161
## 10 2975.198 3083.23538 -111.6313 0.982877782
## 11 3637.933 62164.24181 3358.3704 20.401054463
## 12 4784.870 17205.18210 2375.7519 3.190010653
## 13 5482.503 98614.37933 5143.5490 14.231622531
## 14 4499.833 56684.22632 3965.0380 15.160539593
## 15 3739.404 12628.41104 1811.8127 3.077773449
## 16 4793.961 68940.12143 4326.5928 17.146709271
## 17 3800.182 1114.70451 -935.2181 0.266083082
## 18 14282.295 6786.81744 -915.3874 0.454993801
## 19 5932.033 19793.64797 2476.8782 3.676243116
## 20 3972.433 159687.60473 3866.5057 29.703008956
## 21 6681.356 35201.15002 4243.4087 6.084089586
## 22 6812.275 1706.32108 -1264.5876 0.259468535
## 23 7362.256 6560.78390 -794.0801 0.942434039
## 24 5447.706 11314.55422 302.4660 2.205331156
## 25 4662.435 17131.01112 2627.0299 3.319041040
## 26 6403.429 76328.63477 5788.1197 9.903665478
## 27 3509.611 37786.85818 3057.9329 12.107610590
## 28 8273.735 -731.34530 -3567.8244 -0.093205400
## 29 9916.151 21873.69275 372.9404 2.380553269
## 30 11101.486 48799.60290 7172.5296 3.875334715
## 31 3203.388 5444.26846 549.0460 1.607013364
## 32 8981.224 41835.61786 4289.6770 5.316470524
## 33 5747.393 2389.87161 -965.9305 0.398656555
## 34 12485.621 -368.93950 -3506.1763 -0.027065384
## 35 24160.139 -22678.83241 -22678.8324 -0.928134766
## 36 3995.768 14692.34711 1731.9743 3.345296880
## 37 3847.904 41712.67680 3305.7774 9.287154121
## 38 6135.435 141.00458 -1295.4563 0.012719567
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.393524126
## 2 0.602255652
## 3 0.826938001
## 4 0.938929115
## 5 0.791415449
## 6 -0.165098881
## 7 -0.238959312
## 8 0.188415070
## 9 0.597283890
## 10 -0.019576020
## 11 0.931532172
## 12 0.500826869
## 13 0.925691405
## 14 0.891356201
## 15 0.490760902
## 16 0.910951563
## 17 -0.247028992
## 18 -0.037222443
## 19 0.407701749
## 20 0.964933545
## 21 0.632455673
## 22 -0.203571042
## 23 -0.134901749
## 24 0.030205191
## 25 0.564796419
## 26 0.890298517
## 27 0.879172523
## 28 -0.429759669
## 29 -0.003536684
## 30 0.643162154
## 31 0.185405346
## 32 0.469190062
## 33 -0.150405615
## 34 -0.262731997
## 35 -0.928134766
## 36 0.442785086
## 37 0.850129398
## 38 -0.203855044Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.5 <- mean(res_1sc_0.5$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.5 <- mean(res_1sc_0.5$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.5## [1] 6.055086rt_com_2_0.5## [1] 0.3401404 g. f = 40%res_1sc_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1627819 1457220 1574173 13661967555 34882256945 4565449154
## 2 10 2461838 2629777 2519165 12296877279 26860859463 2945015874
## 3 11 1419674 1713898 1466165 11237745018 86036882125 7457872190
## 4 12 1606572 2040026 1638915 12232130719 187245047149 10845897032
## 5 13 1635850 1435009 1595833 7918258386 41924425739 5290756048
## 6 14 2644197 2591303 2617990 16963951147 1300268288 -5385808398
## 7 15 5017904 4816432 4869264 107175050073 16581986340 -18473742859
## 8 16 2705339 2566454 2653327 11771003943 19036493298 2179905111
## 9 17 2013291 2258388 2062783 11715566013 59827946419 6125157821
## 10 18 1793140 1700617 1751254 8046523741 8024159721 711866027
## 11 19 1878358 2236471 1910453 10141971305 127604602508 8868593518
## 12 2 1616477 1455015 1559542 11868938909 25783526211 4084146614
## 13 20 1878523 1515214 1833778 15499838106 131052954627 13307922054
## 14 21 1522444 1848831 1557161 9781414904 106513443687 7935940591
## 15 22 2025466 1846072 1968459 11763347876 31816808551 5048262837
## 16 23 2108607 2533650 2148864 15308600581 179741088359 13400299177
## 17 24 2678137 2676007 2676546 15937303428 857236141 -5996293932
## 18 25 3878452 3683325 3738921 89500331110 321220633 -19305932562
## 19 26 2018850 2233731 2092171 17549488451 41199986615 5096093717
## 20 27 1834772 1361079 1810870 11319350788 219731381881 10704810116
## 21 28 1629138 1872864 1695471 17008645370 57030586125 6486797547
## 22 29 1909741 2013384 1967831 20497924779 -2301559877 -9845662952
## 23 3 1750773 1871027 1795164 19758797405 13986317988 -4617222058
## 24 4 2284572 2421378 2334747 19116386793 18070809933 -3442929190
## 25 5 2049203 1879784 1985531 13857019176 26051595510 4760125030
## 26 6 2503678 2103505 2443507 23564940218 157918808743 19500301823
## 27 7 2698824 3025619 2749747 14763088671 101987505245 11240768977
## 28 71 2293864 2273770 2260326 30341244726 -1887782472 -11091284651
## 29 72 1857247 2042539 1921478 28982832643 32512280889 -3567242128
## 30 73 3410397 3050337 3282343 55793685578 121509303146 21544294127
## 31 74 2157622 2049713 2119084 10300082065 11960958342 108731677
## 32 75 1791985 2120565 1870785 24442831808 100304302157 7868750583
## 33 76 2079564 1959910 2011079 18525023450 9375901021 -1141168013
## 34 77 2210053 2187290 2184401 38559658656 -1336895871 -13580952802
## 35 78 6957154 6896767 6896767 262564863669 -241802782761 -241802782761
## 36 79 2092725 1973719 2038840 12766347717 13953040495 1424347098
## 37 8 2014224 1732895 1971823 11603367125 80493096212 9282824304
## 38 9 2235646 2218540 2214374 18173537620 -6124860175 -8610151417
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 8244.350 25011.03701 2650.32552 2.553238163
## 2 4975.901 10179.28770 1260.06606 2.184364278
## 3 7799.467 50106.92345 5180.70604 7.656062848
## 4 7525.748 91662.74361 6577.08199 15.307639483
## 5 4777.923 29865.75613 3220.74454 5.294652396
## 6 6403.725 530.45127 -2118.47362 0.076648905
## 7 20994.948 3465.31155 -3997.33885 0.154718718
## 8 4351.147 7435.98425 745.96827 1.617236167
## 9 5763.758 26507.17006 3083.16200 5.106705588
## 10 4467.386 4775.58798 333.90653 0.997220661
## 11 5368.412 56975.61997 4637.16631 12.581834307
## 12 7281.371 17874.10037 2408.47425 2.172353098
## 13 8171.598 86724.77969 7145.19034 8.455117642
## 14 6354.523 57403.77199 5103.91157 10.889369763
## 15 5761.753 17466.13067 2435.79040 2.704740936
## 16 7226.562 70873.65966 6234.38119 11.741183487
## 17 5921.521 478.33610 -2216.11100 0.053788029
## 18 22696.452 33.65131 -5533.97534 0.003589044
## 19 8619.476 18087.22241 2589.42499 2.347646014
## 20 6098.801 161763.28509 5846.82735 19.412012755
## 21 10357.749 30306.85466 4149.54014 3.353035170
## 22 10449.586 -1088.77596 -4721.02273 -0.112282580
## 23 11115.809 7467.48932 -2241.20059 0.707852695
## 24 8281.224 7435.33156 -1256.14976 0.945304682
## 25 6710.745 13956.21303 2228.07764 1.880028827
## 26 9261.660 75385.39612 7823.61299 6.701430484
## 27 5447.057 33305.27778 4091.43645 6.908276955
## 28 12947.966 -824.03589 -4872.89044 -0.062218360
## 29 15277.657 16088.65881 -1236.66768 1.121777201
## 30 16208.066 40028.36063 6025.14290 2.177832525
## 31 4768.287 5921.67564 -49.23173 1.161248839
## 32 13285.103 47328.66911 4546.30623 4.103628538
## 33 8867.682 4828.92677 -733.13944 0.506120872
## 34 17193.080 -659.34166 -6255.08683 -0.034670843
## 35 37085.496 -34601.54196 -34601.54196 -0.920925898
## 36 6041.083 7157.60606 587.71592 1.092954759
## 37 5695.723 46803.20305 4609.12934 6.937046406
## 38 7921.615 -2658.37272 -3800.43214 -0.337020799
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.33417216
## 2 0.23949299
## 3 0.66364490
## 4 0.88667275
## 5 0.66817169
## 6 -0.31748549
## 7 -0.17236981
## 8 0.18519279
## 9 0.52282218
## 10 0.08846877
## 11 0.87444475
## 12 0.34410377
## 13 0.85858458
## 14 0.81132849
## 15 0.42915188
## 16 0.87534449
## 17 -0.37624269
## 18 -0.21570795
## 19 0.29038417
## 20 0.94570884
## 21 0.38138237
## 22 -0.48032486
## 23 -0.23367931
## 24 -0.18010355
## 25 0.34351724
## 26 0.82751332
## 27 0.76141038
## 28 -0.36555141
## 29 -0.12308121
## 30 0.38614216
## 31 0.01055639
## 32 0.32192467
## 33 -0.06160143
## 34 -0.35220625
## 35 -0.92092590
## 36 0.11157045
## 37 0.80001126
## 38 -0.47377410Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.4 <- mean(res_1sc_0.4$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.4 <- mean(res_1sc_0.4$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.4## [1] 3.879988rt_com_2_0.4## [1] 0.228649 h. f = 30%res_1sc_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1607855 1458025 1539376 21047867931 25973345675 2188654678
## 2 10 2477012 2635120 2538655 19649179977 26366319829 -1538526868
## 3 11 1369103 1702713 1424619 16347459322 110933085708 9935408001
## 4 12 1635767 2024828 1694094 19996988398 151260917065 12877853439
## 5 13 1642527 1425976 1588579 13430816149 50050160312 7913526173
## 6 14 2623778 2596654 2599650 26346672526 -574289345 -8437920371
## 7 15 5098079 4844026 4880009 186569027264 -20596803312 -48804349033
## 8 16 2725487 2576611 2662480 18081815026 22996337056 321293354
## 9 17 2030838 2259080 2087056 18325335545 53438474147 3192752873
## 10 18 1825502 1695525 1769160 13116683423 16559069192 2043712748
## 11 19 1819960 2232123 1866023 15377931362 172944922400 11999967010
## 12 2 1590499 1446695 1523021 18439144198 20126158879 2556919872
## 13 20 1893050 1506406 1827205 24442030583 148030772219 18961866284
## 14 21 1533499 1835180 1594194 15976789445 92093181287 9191409725
## 15 22 2017257 1841597 1945767 19613808658 27784505826 4862206136
## 16 23 2108991 2540435 2174742 24218577372 191119976989 16016010624
## 17 24 2676310 2700212 2683874 23421977845 11584679498 -4955902420
## 18 25 3916200 3708754 3774878 137058968422 17710412060 -24397473366
## 19 26 1987171 2200790 2061561 26939252828 42339730257 2374973701
## 20 27 1783670 1327166 1742773 18137083065 204013824526 16232942681
## 21 28 1592698 1841508 1675165 25350413476 57735318081 4915001006
## 22 29 1912693 1991006 1955150 31825897313 -13135577273 -19411606997
## 23 3 1739438 1859849 1767378 30599903497 15055071228 -10239258759
## 24 4 2307529 2416594 2345498 30584240182 14379795214 -7184567629
## 25 5 2060692 1870152 1986451 21059443056 39022227213 6695020446
## 26 6 2456396 2094479 2364569 35988855623 130508710007 21333271938
## 27 7 2689763 3060472 2763150 23314744912 131796860398 14589666580
## 28 71 2306957 2270559 2270171 45369508545 -9791083869 -18682321538
## 29 72 1865543 2033541 1915527 47274809907 25134386783 -15277522247
## 30 73 3373017 3043822 3218444 89248650788 95514420483 11777006058
## 31 74 2105539 2041372 2079400 15586025434 7600874114 -2219827312
## 32 75 1780481 2115122 1829249 33369440130 127560764191 -2976050534
## 33 76 2031371 1951186 1979572 28844716989 6402514698 -5811653289
## 34 77 2195552 2179510 2175145 62616938813 -12048721068 -25949328039
## 35 78 6913568 6867905 6867905 388979749951 -368325184185 -368325184185
## 36 79 2125819 1966713 2058819 19296351628 26337558305 3081195959
## 37 8 2046008 1735026 1981884 19253686511 96226594011 13882838674
## 38 9 2249658 2218546 2215371 29539666318 -4916729694 -10206875403
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 12748.928 19200.6655 1113.58865 1.23401314
## 2 7878.478 9948.6763 -413.13075 1.34185344
## 3 11652.186 65112.3886 7123.54239 6.78595270
## 4 12075.937 74419.9513 7873.95031 7.56418487
## 5 7975.010 36242.6358 4781.46043 3.72651667
## 6 9991.638 -256.1911 -3281.67607 -0.02179741
## 7 35591.156 -4047.0458 -10103.22443 -0.11039776
## 8 6629.496 8969.4465 -35.62104 1.27179362
## 9 8882.412 23607.8394 1833.77725 2.91609799
## 10 7135.297 9852.0985 976.16486 1.26244331
## 11 8329.698 77322.2482 6464.43770 11.24630604
## 12 11389.531 13918.3561 1289.71265 1.09149094
## 13 12765.569 98972.8088 10085.24152 6.05640238
## 14 10303.924 49844.9320 5984.30777 5.76418570
## 15 9560.089 15206.5414 2212.27758 1.41657881
## 16 11391.903 74999.3914 7596.80010 7.89146175
## 17 8688.028 4037.0240 -1867.04925 0.49460723
## 18 33825.105 4690.9490 -7156.65058 0.12921746
## 19 13429.810 18740.4994 1438.17142 1.57167426
## 20 10035.750 156321.9819 9187.26211 11.24843636
## 21 15704.314 31357.3494 3534.32256 2.27749019
## 22 15892.121 -6334.1987 -9281.10119 -0.41273235
## 23 17011.765 8153.5197 -5114.81032 0.49199734
## 24 13069.262 5826.8869 -2838.85134 0.47017010
## 25 10035.487 20955.8968 3011.12684 1.85295628
## 26 14331.858 63093.3588 8537.29858 3.62636454
## 27 8605.292 42639.7428 5346.18341 5.65294027
## 28 19061.871 -4250.7579 -8255.79736 -0.21580758
## 29 24474.331 12303.0031 -7023.92479 0.53166553
## 30 26149.935 31796.9571 2698.69515 1.07020576
## 31 7359.949 3768.6368 -1177.83190 0.48767238
## 32 17592.210 60265.9439 -100.36615 3.82268218
## 33 13999.710 3316.0933 -3138.39655 0.22196490
## 34 27757.137 -5538.6085 -12023.14644 -0.19241952
## 35 54384.901 -52018.3599 -52018.35991 -0.94690067
## 36 8943.225 13678.2748 1251.72741 1.36489834
## 37 9289.657 56162.8948 6799.57389 4.99782699
## 38 12600.152 -2130.3269 -4549.37525 -0.16644500
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.10398463
## 2 -0.07829980
## 3 0.60776466
## 4 0.64398964
## 5 0.58920665
## 6 -0.32026513
## 7 -0.26158870
## 8 0.01776887
## 9 0.17422616
## 10 0.15581018
## 11 0.78033688
## 12 0.13866803
## 13 0.77578932
## 14 0.57529767
## 15 0.24789709
## 16 0.66131096
## 17 -0.21159197
## 18 -0.17800713
## 19 0.08816034
## 20 0.89501397
## 21 0.19388248
## 22 -0.60993118
## 23 -0.33461735
## 24 -0.23491078
## 25 0.31791061
## 26 0.59277439
## 27 0.62576994
## 28 -0.41178144
## 29 -0.32316412
## 30 0.13195724
## 31 -0.14242421
## 32 -0.08918491
## 33 -0.20148068
## 34 -0.41441387
## 35 -0.94690067
## 36 0.15967764
## 37 0.72104834
## 38 -0.34553117Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.3 <- mean(res_1sc_0.3$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.3 <- mean(res_1sc_0.3$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.3## [1] 2.574093rt_com_2_0.3## [1] 0.1077409 i. f = 20%res_1sc_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1565874 1429587 1497696 34942720405 28223500994 -326202804
## 2 10 2439231 2629295 2491992 31280515784 42659833896 -3099692305
## 3 11 1431553 1696380 1503065 31997654158 68288902543 -1685893090
## 4 12 1639969 2024446 1723023 33406100117 149935161157 11412381680
## 5 13 1566874 1397051 1501298 19378905470 31700846505 5055961530
## 6 14 2649779 2550409 2592252 44606400762 7546909639 -9505757612
## 7 15 5049695 4756906 4823993 303974422936 -23740048821 -75999400065
## 8 16 2692722 2531982 2630111 31162768133 31090916146 -2939991483
## 9 17 1976454 2241914 2057330 32442570119 67250303618 -907220444
## 10 18 1809757 1695991 1753076 21536088203 13323630931 -1414673300
## 11 19 1843529 2219376 1915702 26136324172 144042388219 12202736413
## 12 2 1619071 1457465 1530261 32770568474 17554497106 -1725057448
## 13 20 1878370 1503566 1775025 43155234850 139386782607 23589651178
## 14 21 1547200 1853100 1626731 29339817179 94537884266 6875664659
## 15 22 1982165 1827205 1910060 30981843185 26168496707 2591284253
## 16 23 2046435 2495356 2130948 39060304456 208902032904 17570340304
## 17 24 2598284 2569299 2577614 37798320676 17732306821 -4700964106
## 18 25 3667898 3587087 3558572 220334116336 -57892444147 -86141255051
## 19 26 2025389 2219617 2101317 48960322037 25036123861 -13443859879
## 20 27 1804441 1321820 1743413 28362536498 228427754083 23711457768
## 21 28 1584560 1840268 1675220 41144566165 56316869146 -3467960409
## 22 29 1867452 1966266 1928930 58464192785 -31123887080 -41097412521
## 23 3 1793928 1865073 1806235 57952172782 -3687153335 -25373483809
## 24 4 2310403 2411836 2345888 53429744704 1721210661 -22890232019
## 25 5 1993151 1883273 1911861 37046441334 11107083224 -6192671460
## 26 6 2510580 2130768 2383723 60400515984 145941236666 29375673264
## 27 7 2647037 2983702 2735354 36451353014 109155662534 9563279120
## 28 71 2292464 2236598 2231043 73017566239 -12411756024 -33131788509
## 29 72 1765647 2012866 1825386 72081341140 64543591160 -25660266927
## 30 73 3455003 3034669 3235743 162421731143 162376208009 22040929052
## 31 74 2154906 2017647 2101349 27989660933 29042779887 -793485783
## 32 75 1783231 2086096 1847761 59290208293 95854809024 -20965847301
## 33 76 1956851 1930207 1938058 46991219199 -7967482422 -21667707596
## 34 77 2128534 2158084 2109221 91024870062 1557861299 -33487239094
## 35 78 6976462 6951251 6951251 773025841305 -733983861286 -733983861286
## 36 79 2095567 1944226 2015935 33770266000 14742754038 -4223082409
## 37 8 2006574 1709529 1918487 29728581101 100720175269 14535562786
## 38 9 2258432 2245263 2221725 52934909164 -14124253403 -23666301836
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 21171.41 21204.1922 -956.1336 0.80770760
## 2 12663.61 15941.7393 -849.1298 1.36378294
## 3 21523.36 39929.0040 166.6209 2.13418466
## 4 19858.07 73665.6914 7523.6936 4.48825695
## 5 11917.46 24072.7962 3021.1006 1.63584298
## 6 16724.43 2956.0306 -3920.2732 0.16918894
## 7 57624.76 -5432.8275 -16754.4596 -0.07809884
## 8 11567.65 12403.3981 -1460.1000 0.99769430
## 9 15938.50 29991.5298 235.0442 2.07290308
## 10 11819.04 7999.8530 -1119.4907 0.61866532
## 11 13934.35 64871.1525 6810.6335 5.51119535
## 12 19805.90 12837.3053 -1638.3620 0.53567875
## 13 22512.88 93608.9556 12187.2477 3.22989281
## 14 18534.27 50457.1817 4990.8741 3.22217019
## 15 15249.25 14749.0940 935.3273 0.84463976
## 16 18854.97 83447.0307 9051.9313 5.34819264
## 17 14333.81 7326.6153 -1779.0608 0.46912949
## 18 57199.67 -15562.6678 -23638.8208 -0.26274843
## 19 23487.32 11354.5875 -5459.0926 0.51135538
## 20 15294.66 177317.1391 13238.2824 8.05385492
## 21 25296.68 30608.7471 -532.6829 1.36875594
## 22 29088.54 -14037.1706 -19205.0486 -0.53235811
## 23 31118.87 -2029.4059 -13323.2167 -0.06362407
## 24 22504.13 778.6575 -9259.8011 0.03221447
## 25 18091.91 5958.6704 -3598.7524 0.29981512
## 26 22940.14 68843.5487 11165.6115 2.41622500
## 27 13520.02 35913.2637 3851.0862 2.99455723
## 28 30560.55 -5551.1852 -14939.5117 -0.16998315
## 29 38089.73 32530.2210 -11306.4500 0.89542717
## 30 45962.79 52157.1687 4319.5653 0.99971972
## 31 12916.75 14858.0884 -669.4142 1.03762528
## 32 30520.56 45579.7876 -8532.9819 1.61670555
## 33 23802.69 -4222.1175 -11384.7178 -0.16955258
## 34 40542.41 702.1174 -15278.8857 0.01711468
## 35 105975.37 -101639.8617 -101639.8617 -0.94949460
## 36 15824.89 7775.7518 -2547.4317 0.43656020
## 37 14464.52 60383.9746 6920.4259 3.38799134
## 38 22021.77 -5870.3865 -10143.2506 -0.26682304
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 -0.009335358
## 2 -0.099093389
## 3 -0.052688021
## 4 0.341625680
## 5 0.260900263
## 6 -0.213102995
## 7 -0.250019062
## 8 -0.094343079
## 9 -0.027963889
## 10 -0.065688499
## 11 0.466888011
## 12 -0.052640449
## 13 0.546623168
## 14 0.234345859
## 15 0.083638802
## 16 0.449825995
## 17 -0.124369655
## 18 -0.390957408
## 19 -0.274586835
## 20 0.836013301
## 21 -0.084287203
## 22 -0.702950140
## 23 -0.437834901
## 24 -0.428417395
## 25 -0.167159685
## 26 0.486348052
## 27 0.262357315
## 28 -0.453750929
## 29 -0.355990420
## 30 0.135701848
## 31 -0.028349246
## 32 -0.353613993
## 33 -0.461101201
## 34 -0.367891095
## 35 -0.949494599
## 36 -0.125053276
## 37 0.488942366
## 38 -0.447083073Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.2 <- mean(res_1sc_0.2$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.2 <- mean(res_1sc_0.2$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.2## [1] 1.44801rt_com_2_0.2## [1] -0.06380408 j. f = 10%res_1sc_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1474412 1370798 1398517 8.362945e+10 1.573635e+10 -1.670109e+10
## 2 10 2466415 2566205 2500242 7.489146e+10 -6.572291e+09 -3.495379e+10
## 3 11 1350222 1629922 1435806 6.121087e+10 6.877142e+10 -1.050072e+10
## 4 12 1616836 1943930 1706649 7.068443e+10 1.071151e+11 -1.078058e+10
## 5 13 1600199 1341919 1509242 4.784029e+10 9.105960e+10 1.361434e+10
## 6 14 2508111 2504699 2483883 9.621367e+10 -9.409786e+09 -4.225002e+10
## 7 15 5044368 4718471 4758172 7.622693e+11 -3.390843e+11 -3.987273e+11
## 8 16 2715099 2485802 2627401 6.977470e+10 8.029343e+10 -1.035831e+09
## 9 17 1988602 2188734 2031881 6.920891e+10 3.070073e+10 -3.414677e+10
## 10 18 1803904 1634797 1712497 5.054491e+10 3.479456e+10 -3.312870e+09
## 11 19 1740350 2154349 1846664 5.875218e+10 1.689359e+11 1.929112e+09
## 12 2 1492548 1393112 1426764 6.460725e+10 2.143270e+10 -1.201293e+10
## 13 20 1864903 1435537 1695902 9.058667e+10 1.619649e+11 3.750861e+10
## 14 21 1547052 1778241 1611858 6.331594e+10 6.232095e+10 -1.199937e+10
## 15 22 1822352 1783252 1782687 5.326715e+10 9.026443e+09 -1.426812e+10
## 16 23 2016878 2448800 2150192 8.742033e+10 1.781930e+11 -2.131493e+09
## 17 24 2550396 2573544 2528963 8.595585e+10 1.967676e+10 -2.791247e+10
## 18 25 3732677 3568919 3550710 5.009683e+11 -1.554958e+11 -1.973917e+11
## 19 26 1864495 2133159 1953908 9.994400e+10 6.701125e+10 -2.558275e+10
## 20 27 1736203 1243860 1611531 6.296103e+10 2.189475e+11 3.706146e+10
## 21 28 1476617 1755054 1568783 8.930235e+10 6.578631e+10 -2.727854e+10
## 22 29 1838937 1885023 1854455 1.155261e+11 -7.180313e+10 -8.368762e+10
## 23 3 1649226 1786829 1667953 1.085560e+11 1.576314e+10 -4.615581e+10
## 24 4 2320461 2344984 2281191 1.255233e+11 -1.670971e+10 -6.169769e+10
## 25 5 2029842 1808988 1898281 9.071582e+10 5.944582e+10 -2.938630e+09
## 26 6 2418303 2052249 2245938 1.281240e+11 1.171156e+11 2.123465e+10
## 27 7 2502185 2960117 2640620 8.123614e+10 1.779783e+11 9.990031e+09
## 28 71 2276058 2163693 2156850 1.734592e+11 -7.722426e+07 -3.978049e+10
## 29 72 1486706 1933537 1557768 1.121681e+11 1.863377e+11 -4.768131e+10
## 30 73 3195014 2946242 2993060 3.336357e+11 -1.625237e+10 -9.364797e+10
## 31 74 1947222 1939601 1932614 5.348505e+10 -3.245597e+09 -1.974512e+10
## 32 75 1875994 2011022 1895078 1.473517e+11 -7.144589e+09 -6.662035e+10
## 33 76 1734900 1851219 1756841 8.519009e+10 1.972878e+10 -2.871763e+10
## 34 77 2152122 2078441 2041696 2.169290e+11 -2.112450e+10 -8.203359e+10
## 35 78 6842669 6805761 6805761 1.330918e+12 -1.270101e+12 -1.270101e+12
## 36 79 2085723 1866890 1974060 7.450703e+10 4.683627e+10 4.928884e+08
## 37 8 2011617 1652253 1877265 7.095530e+10 1.229781e+11 2.160185e+10
## 38 9 2141691 2181358 2139348 7.494735e+10 -2.127108e+10 -3.908086e+10
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 50980.13 14444.4356 -13349.266 0.1881675414
## 2 29624.74 -2650.9840 -13268.662 -0.0877575472
## 3 41908.25 42802.7475 -4366.685 1.1235165461
## 4 41642.07 54878.1718 -3085.366 1.5153986490
## 5 27568.79 79109.1215 7844.478 1.9034081785
## 6 37971.81 -3919.5442 -16848.349 -0.0978009263
## 7 139614.90 -67949.8391 -81630.821 -0.4448352786
## 8 25436.31 33383.1187 -1225.023 1.1507528561
## 9 32648.67 14097.6657 -14721.622 0.4435950955
## 10 27379.45 22072.2789 -2959.455 0.6883889898
## 11 32290.85 78134.1663 3026.836 2.8753988207
## 12 40601.79 17080.1740 -9277.878 0.3317383359
## 13 46449.76 114025.0407 19166.700 1.7879552257
## 14 38806.74 34449.6552 -5714.945 0.9842853590
## 15 27683.59 5983.7334 -8057.208 0.1694560959
## 16 42051.08 72202.9804 1769.543 2.0383473191
## 17 32734.03 6176.2834 -10700.351 0.2289171060
## 18 118624.64 -42810.6357 -55090.485 -0.3103905004
## 19 50825.85 30880.1290 -10508.954 0.6704879345
## 20 34407.02 185021.0635 21321.830 3.4775082546
## 21 57622.06 36053.3752 -13490.154 0.7366694650
## 22 54986.88 -32383.5116 -38227.351 -0.6215317789
## 23 59094.43 8835.0312 -24931.162 0.1452074456
## 24 51033.57 -7056.2532 -25758.368 -0.1331204057
## 25 42089.79 33329.2957 -3975.455 0.6552971572
## 26 48838.71 58388.7041 7122.037 0.9140797627
## 27 31376.48 59737.0135 5424.670 2.1908764235
## 28 67088.48 623.1566 -18861.813 -0.0004452013
## 29 63413.38 96729.9460 -19313.799 1.6612361571
## 30 99634.47 -4679.0499 -32733.441 -0.0487129070
## 31 27437.06 -1628.7773 -10079.387 -0.0606823184
## 32 67648.57 -3353.4921 -31926.068 -0.0484866418
## 33 46036.31 10402.5675 -14834.230 0.2315854431
## 34 89857.63 -8677.8664 -39163.772 -0.0973797759
## 35 181235.66 -175015.7063 -175015.706 -0.9543044564
## 36 33692.69 25260.0453 -1316.589 0.6286155483
## 37 33578.41 77122.8655 9651.747 1.7331766214
## 38 31802.75 -8939.5920 -16618.371 -0.2838136786
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 -0.199703474
## 2 -0.466725975
## 3 -0.171549930
## 4 -0.152517063
## 5 0.284578885
## 6 -0.439127042
## 7 -0.523079341
## 8 -0.014845364
## 9 -0.493386949
## 10 -0.065543102
## 11 0.032834726
## 12 -0.185937785
## 13 0.414063248
## 14 -0.189515777
## 15 -0.267859672
## 16 -0.024382123
## 17 -0.324730305
## 18 -0.394020289
## 19 -0.255970878
## 20 0.588641268
## 21 -0.305462695
## 22 -0.724404555
## 23 -0.425179694
## 24 -0.491523961
## 25 -0.032393797
## 26 0.165735075
## 27 0.122975210
## 28 -0.229336335
## 29 -0.425087829
## 30 -0.280689293
## 31 -0.369170729
## 32 -0.452117986
## 33 -0.337100586
## 34 -0.378158735
## 35 -0.954304456
## 36 0.006615328
## 37 0.304443013
## 38 -0.521444219Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.1 <- mean(res_1sc_0.1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.1 <- mean(res_1sc_0.1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.1## [1] 0.6653896rt_com_2_0.1## [1] -0.2151417 k. f = 5%res_1sc_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1485403 1304574 1349337 1.811192e+11 4.524334e+10 -4.023127e+10
## 2 10 2442296 2481150 2438467 1.515579e+11 3.705079e+10 -5.225508e+10
## 3 11 1208853 1502209 1243986 1.221906e+11 1.089398e+11 -4.299427e+10
## 4 12 1680146 1740627 1630024 1.729213e+11 1.657019e+10 -8.926775e+10
## 5 13 1533738 1279680 1423013 7.573877e+10 1.116688e+11 1.378217e+08
## 6 14 2284936 2476581 2324186 1.847637e+11 5.063780e+10 -7.255880e+10
## 7 15 5178744 4622091 4677051 1.498139e+12 -4.671302e+11 -6.470369e+11
## 8 16 2696329 2436228 2557769 1.570469e+11 3.267256e+10 -4.108699e+10
## 9 17 1978475 2118127 1962101 1.508735e+11 2.085489e+10 -6.414150e+10
## 10 18 1868387 1551065 1729205 1.172519e+11 9.873737e+10 8.988747e+09
## 11 19 1469693 2019440 1571355 1.045470e+11 2.961264e+11 -3.156222e+10
## 12 2 1302446 1303857 1274648 1.119387e+11 3.792408e+09 -4.504372e+10
## 13 20 1601115 1315922 1415459 1.640984e+11 9.752889e+10 -2.023166e+10
## 14 21 1490601 1618456 1480213 1.199529e+11 3.852777e+10 -3.558387e+10
## 15 22 1819501 1752638 1746740 1.162658e+11 -1.630609e+10 -4.345809e+10
## 16 23 2066684 2393656 2146122 1.686773e+11 1.000401e+11 -7.340958e+10
## 17 24 2649619 2708026 2624915 2.278901e+11 -3.135256e+10 -1.223350e+11
## 18 25 3613853 3578190 3511134 7.438193e+11 -2.637757e+11 -4.057324e+11
## 19 26 1558812 1853655 1608182 1.781009e+11 6.179141e+10 -1.055248e+11
## 20 27 1428695 1030543 1281622 8.997022e+10 1.203525e+11 6.591272e+09
## 21 28 1259832 1527781 1326691 1.375232e+11 6.570052e+10 -7.073626e+10
## 22 29 1876570 1793521 1802071 2.011090e+11 -1.273304e+11 -1.443929e+11
## 23 3 1454547 1610971 1446624 2.355839e+11 -1.798605e+10 -1.170369e+11
## 24 4 2259415 2208072 2180339 2.332514e+11 -3.243069e+09 -7.395320e+10
## 25 5 1982878 1665994 1788116 1.822995e+11 3.722882e+10 -2.771770e+10
## 26 6 2099242 1902682 1947315 2.466143e+11 1.259596e+09 -5.335730e+10
## 27 7 2492877 3062151 2640420 1.729104e+11 2.831316e+11 -2.897613e+10
## 28 71 2394477 1979750 2122094 4.318978e+11 -3.876749e+10 -1.313264e+11
## 29 72 1575159 1724349 1506340 3.302861e+11 -3.311593e+09 -1.677982e+11
## 30 73 2767888 2721627 2616219 6.188210e+11 -1.514434e+11 -3.187193e+11
## 31 74 1530206 1741402 1578449 8.983359e+10 4.013511e+10 -5.078979e+10
## 32 75 1476924 1820247 1525358 1.478340e+11 1.360839e+11 -7.837404e+10
## 33 76 1679902 1647915 1609684 1.493627e+11 1.334886e+10 -6.349604e+10
## 34 77 1794893 1869024 1757003 3.493149e+11 6.954866e+10 -1.713653e+11
## 35 78 6238848 6238045 6228667 2.833200e+12 -2.704769e+12 -2.708750e+12
## 36 79 1648235 1674959 1615465 1.182821e+11 -8.263356e+09 -6.806841e+10
## 37 8 2016827 1598346 1817114 1.533652e+11 1.524074e+11 1.762551e+10
## 38 9 2087040 2120534 2026980 2.532612e+11 -5.863253e+10 -1.247400e+11
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 95063.73 96463.174 -31348.0789 0.249798633
## 2 58396.50 14491.563 -21450.9798 0.244466200
## 3 80873.08 73066.002 -24563.9772 0.891556265
## 4 92853.66 8096.865 -51609.5395 0.095825051
## 5 44626.29 108680.335 -207.2849 1.474393649
## 6 77644.69 19924.446 -28559.7661 0.274067954
## 7 245667.61 -91999.772 -131393.4276 -0.311807081
## 8 57181.21 13892.216 -18197.8174 0.208043302
## 9 66206.35 9868.017 -28893.5710 0.138227660
## 10 59148.03 66791.762 1020.5561 0.842095907
## 11 63588.99 144049.946 -11283.0937 2.832472426
## 12 76877.36 4781.900 -33533.8528 0.033879331
## 13 88368.32 73114.947 -19777.4644 0.594331760
## 14 70806.04 22282.518 -20748.9865 0.321190793
## 15 56908.38 -8580.767 -23777.5055 -0.140248432
## 16 76308.53 41193.751 -27745.1095 0.593085708
## 17 80051.34 -10529.192 -43458.2748 -0.137577530
## 18 178002.47 -77334.295 -113362.3186 -0.354623374
## 19 98611.26 27062.039 -53108.2728 0.346946103
## 20 55742.33 146969.766 2885.3596 1.337693111
## 21 96247.41 38588.002 -45010.3330 0.477741399
## 22 86549.76 -51336.933 -63213.8135 -0.633141266
## 23 127609.90 -10061.516 -69904.6794 -0.076346707
## 24 91881.27 -1926.121 -34909.7449 -0.013903746
## 25 82899.26 24939.698 -19486.9529 0.204217841
## 26 97468.79 3344.768 -28202.5576 0.005107554
## 27 63206.31 91365.106 -3705.6176 1.637446831
## 28 157588.40 -15339.369 -69473.6085 -0.089760814
## 29 149935.84 3366.168 -88631.2826 -0.010026438
## 30 198554.92 -53301.572 -113455.6289 -0.244728863
## 31 57115.04 20897.013 -28650.9450 0.446771793
## 32 83958.77 73970.776 -40056.0092 0.920518474
## 33 77947.82 7922.049 -38144.1216 0.089372097
## 34 156870.54 35650.235 -89615.9439 0.199100204
## 35 376731.62 -364139.542 -365008.2404 -0.954669143
## 36 60558.81 -4266.518 -38829.9504 -0.069861397
## 37 70489.54 105898.878 5392.8459 0.993754665
## 38 97029.52 -26582.184 -54852.1020 -0.231510142
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 -0.222125869
## 2 -0.344786234
## 3 -0.351862291
## 4 -0.516233519
## 5 0.001819698
## 6 -0.392711397
## 7 -0.431893899
## 8 -0.261622363
## 9 -0.425134398
## 10 0.076661825
## 11 -0.301895126
## 12 -0.402396359
## 13 -0.123289793
## 14 -0.296648673
## 15 -0.373782269
## 16 -0.435207091
## 17 -0.536815591
## 18 -0.545471695
## 19 -0.592500331
## 20 0.073260592
## 21 -0.514358772
## 22 -0.717983189
## 23 -0.496795087
## 24 -0.317053537
## 25 -0.152044840
## 26 -0.216359362
## 27 -0.167578891
## 28 -0.304068298
## 29 -0.508038849
## 30 -0.515042700
## 31 -0.565376367
## 32 -0.530148888
## 33 -0.425113039
## 34 -0.490575409
## 35 -0.956074343
## 36 -0.575474946
## 37 0.114925089
## 38 -0.492535195Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_2_0.05 <- mean(res_1sc_0.05$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_2_0.05 <- mean(res_1sc_0.05$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_2_0.05## [1] 0.3206289rt_com_2_0.05## [1] -0.374535MEnggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang perbaikan
res_srs2_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com Relatif MSE dir
## 1 1 1637409 1484546 1637409 0 53757885490 0 0
## 2 10 2452226 2656398 2452226 0 47147642278 0 0
## 3 11 1432925 1736676 1432925 0 52258061800 0 0
## 4 12 1628141 2070386 1628141 0 51433987269 0 0
## 5 13 1660654 1452773 1660654 0 50739021079 0 0
## 6 14 2677707 2617885 2677707 0 48363946648 0 0
## 7 15 5059790 4863519 5059790 0 47676545298 0 0
## 8 16 2702258 2596479 2702258 0 51495764637 0 0
## 9 17 2063216 2280593 2063216 0 50522845707 0 0
## 10 18 1802921 1720645 1802921 0 51413342911 0 0
## 11 19 1893080 2266122 1893080 0 52238481449 0 0
## 12 2 1631372 1473225 1631372 0 52199242895 0 0
## 13 20 1933963 1539654 1933963 0 52927024662 0 0
## 14 21 1543883 1871616 1543883 0 51639003528 0 0
## 15 22 2024290 1859814 2024290 0 49791054445 0 0
## 16 23 2145480 2562473 2145480 0 50544580026 0 0
## 17 24 2721467 2698896 2721467 0 50587970809 0 0
## 18 25 3923463 3722909 3923463 0 50803367638 0 0
## 19 26 2049321 2256961 2049321 0 52413770351 0 0
## 20 27 1850200 1379119 1850200 0 52179584690 0 0
## 21 28 1632444 1899669 1632444 0 52199242895 0 0
## 22 29 1945828 2049705 1945828 0 50566288393 0 0
## 23 3 1794553 1899490 1794553 0 52238481449 0 0
## 24 4 2297582 2449242 2297582 0 51351254126 0 0
## 25 5 2083579 1902456 2083579 0 50781944736 0 0
## 26 6 2526531 2124414 2526531 0 48194003740 0 0
## 27 7 2716794 3050885 2716794 0 45082946891 0 0
## 28 71 2297609 2314435 2297609 0 55404347708 0 0
## 29 72 1872873 2081921 1872873 0 56707316863 0 0
## 30 73 3484448 3097221 3484448 0 52720204779 0 0
## 31 74 2197198 2088987 2197198 0 55565778548 0 0
## 32 75 1867766 2160606 1867766 0 56429844225 0 0
## 33 76 2088732 1998934 2088732 0 56645357835 0 0
## 34 77 2275392 2228054 2275392 0 56481228047 0 0
## 35 78 7020112 6960868 7020112 0 45573428827 0 0
## 36 79 2178314 2012520 2178314 0 56206830653 0 0
## 37 8 2025630 1758243 2025630 0 51392672600 0 0
## 38 9 2279804 2230617 2279804 0 43618767484 0 0
## Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn Efisiensi_com
## 1 36211.67 0 Inf NaN
## 2 17748.71 0 Inf NaN
## 3 30090.85 0 Inf NaN
## 4 24842.70 0 Inf NaN
## 5 34925.63 0 Inf NaN
## 6 18474.43 0 Inf NaN
## 7 9802.89 0 Inf NaN
## 8 19832.92 0 Inf NaN
## 9 22153.38 0 Inf NaN
## 10 29880.28 0 Inf NaN
## 11 23051.93 0 Inf NaN
## 12 35431.95 0 Inf NaN
## 13 34375.92 0 Inf NaN
## 14 27590.60 0 Inf NaN
## 15 26772.07 0 Inf NaN
## 16 19724.92 0 Inf NaN
## 17 18743.95 0 Inf NaN
## 18 13646.15 0 Inf NaN
## 19 23223.17 0 Inf NaN
## 20 37835.45 0 Inf NaN
## 21 27478.07 0 Inf NaN
## 22 24670.03 0 Inf NaN
## 23 27501.31 0 Inf NaN
## 24 20966.18 0 Inf NaN
## 25 26692.84 0 Inf NaN
## 26 22685.79 0 Inf NaN
## 27 14777.01 0 Inf NaN
## 28 23938.60 0 Inf NaN
## 29 27237.97 0 Inf NaN
## 30 17021.78 0 Inf NaN
## 31 26599.39 0 Inf NaN
## 32 26117.60 0 Inf NaN
## 33 28337.79 0 Inf NaN
## 34 25350.03 0 Inf NaN
## 35 6547.09 0 Inf NaN
## 36 27928.58 0 Inf NaN
## 37 29229.57 0 Inf NaN
## 38 19554.58 0 Inf NaNRata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_1 <- mean(res_srs2_1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_1 <- mean(res_srs2_1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_1## [1] Infrt_com_3_1## [1] NaN b. f = 90%res_srs2_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1637950 1483833 1636801 402455800 54234143537 399449714
## 2 10 2450030 2654313 2452382 557099538 47713949382 550629148
## 3 11 1427539 1735603 1429626 361164162 52754751426 358678661
## 4 12 1627050 2068453 1629723 316631546 51941902978 314701658
## 5 13 1659070 1452264 1657611 361885648 51256404072 359324918
## 6 14 2676482 2616771 2675856 512694594 48913684458 507351618
## 7 15 5063089 4862328 5053225 2477638157 48235647339 2356239605
## 8 16 2700715 2595871 2699614 547294945 52002838774 541567725
## 9 17 2063877 2279751 2065627 418649197 51043173582 415216796
## 10 18 1800682 1719622 1800119 359734753 51921539850 357246890
## 11 19 1892716 2264843 1895721 429732922 52735437812 426238262
## 12 2 1629238 1472153 1628158 362173025 52696733790 359684513
## 13 20 1934881 1538533 1929191 776053326 53414601238 764893618
## 14 21 1542883 1869929 1544907 324828697 52144126371 322808186
## 15 22 2023100 1859744 2022036 329032516 50321351259 326886794
## 16 23 2144757 2561868 2148130 416394000 51064611822 413005856
## 17 24 2723196 2701128 2722851 764955135 51107411507 753531409
## 18 25 3921741 3723463 3916814 1301678096 51319874060 1269390486
## 19 26 2050800 2255073 2052031 321073774 52908338813 319130286
## 20 27 1847144 1378056 1844295 321479344 52677343383 319518253
## 21 28 1632488 1897329 1634319 366948432 52696733790 364398361
## 22 29 1942709 2045140 1943601 447958062 51086024463 444018469
## 23 3 1790989 1897676 1792192 613085059 52735437812 605943778
## 24 4 2299061 2447583 2301485 869928097 51860296879 855448952
## 25 5 2079982 1900623 2078278 488262198 51298742995 483620923
## 26 6 2527640 2121998 2521453 751388354 48746056624 739919313
## 27 7 2717801 3050413 2720953 436441679 45677380627 432291108
## 28 71 2288263 2312975 2288711 1142795661 55858176569 1119613027
## 29 72 1871201 2080292 1875094 1096658962 57143395826 1075706105
## 30 73 3481539 3093549 3470778 1513355241 53210598791 1471369701
## 31 74 2199782 2087311 2198862 458395346 56017408293 454660924
## 32 75 1867030 2159140 1870514 688724057 56869703102 680429045
## 33 76 2094468 1997346 2092675 1060924348 57082280845 1041433314
## 34 77 2270178 2226235 2269092 1384027135 56920386940 1350904141
## 35 78 7007674 6951401 7002910 4233355393 46161180897 3876715250
## 36 79 2174836 2010955 2172935 659235024 56649727567 651597946
## 37 8 2018998 1757221 2016686 459833109 51901151124 455769348
## 38 9 2277752 2228548 2277322 384197825 44233147229 380868822
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 245.4791 36551.604 243.8207 134.75801
## 2 227.3021 17975.517 224.4476 85.64708
## 3 252.7535 30396.247 250.6478 146.06862
## 4 194.5243 25111.222 193.0213 164.04526
## 5 217.9639 35295.360 216.6150 141.63702
## 6 191.5193 18692.149 189.5684 95.40511
## 7 489.2314 9919.849 466.1762 19.46840
## 8 202.6038 20032.701 200.5665 95.01794
## 9 202.7657 22389.960 200.9337 121.92350
## 10 199.7027 30194.925 198.3847 144.33284
## 11 226.9594 23284.525 224.7572 122.71677
## 12 222.1836 35798.946 220.8052 145.50154
## 13 400.8621 34719.435 396.2700 68.82852
## 14 210.4538 27886.658 208.8713 160.52808
## 15 162.6065 27060.894 161.6316 152.93732
## 16 194.0863 19932.400 192.2052 122.63532
## 17 280.7516 18921.627 276.5973 66.81099
## 18 331.8386 13782.568 324.0175 39.42593
## 19 156.5364 23462.766 155.4958 164.78561
## 20 173.9699 38229.326 173.1773 163.85919
## 21 224.6989 27774.902 222.8880 143.60801
## 22 230.4013 24982.850 228.2712 114.04198
## 23 341.9425 27789.463 337.7373 86.01651
## 24 378.1349 21188.354 371.4544 59.61446
## 25 234.6102 26990.616 232.5736 105.06393
## 26 297.1401 22972.429 293.3272 64.87465
## 27 160.5609 14973.243 158.8497 104.65861
## 28 498.9161 24149.381 488.7137 48.87853
## 29 585.4541 27468.617 573.0830 52.10681
## 30 434.5681 17200.166 423.8280 35.16068
## 31 208.3221 26836.765 206.7124 122.20327
## 32 368.7004 26338.653 363.5842 82.57255
## 33 506.2638 28578.829 497.3979 53.80429
## 34 609.2050 25567.574 594.9278 41.12664
## 35 604.0266 6640.613 553.5244 10.90416
## 36 302.9376 28170.283 299.6943 85.93252
## 37 227.6472 29536.079 225.8966 112.86954
## 38 168.6239 19848.477 167.1951 115.13118
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9925306
## 2 0.9883856
## 3 0.9931181
## 4 0.9939049
## 5 0.9929239
## 6 0.9895786
## 7 0.9510023
## 8 0.9895354
## 9 0.9918012
## 10 0.9930842
## 11 0.9918678
## 12 0.9931289
## 13 0.9856199
## 14 0.9937798
## 15 0.9934787
## 16 0.9918631
## 17 0.9850661
## 18 0.9751954
## 19 0.9939469
## 20 0.9938998
## 21 0.9930506
## 22 0.9912054
## 23 0.9883519
## 24 0.9833559
## 25 0.9904943
## 26 0.9847362
## 27 0.9904900
## 28 0.9797141
## 29 0.9808939
## 30 0.9722567
## 31 0.9918533
## 32 0.9879560
## 33 0.9816283
## 34 0.9760677
## 35 0.9157547
## 36 0.9884152
## 37 0.9911625
## 38 0.9913352Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.9 <- mean(res_srs2_0.9$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.9 <- mean(res_srs2_0.9$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.9## [1] 99.86583rt_com_3_0.9## [1] 0.9855904 c. f = 80%res_srs2_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1639780 1483803 1637150 919625802 54730698482 904030309
## 2 10 2447781 2654147 2452924 1243869640 48336975012 1212224058
## 3 11 1433045 1734770 1437612 824183467 53280001795 811344345
## 4 12 1630086 2069539 1635924 708581283 52482919978 698955532
## 5 13 1661093 1452800 1657792 820771653 51810717535 807691097
## 6 14 2674741 2616757 2673397 1122671712 49513439107 1097316928
## 7 15 5060801 4864062 5040501 5545086783 48848553716 4975831995
## 8 16 2689936 2594761 2687762 1198420257 52542673817 1171331300
## 9 17 2064539 2277695 2068352 946993461 51601623027 929726820
## 10 18 1797108 1717211 1795877 797287196 52462951830 785215189
## 11 19 1887099 2263562 1893598 939015769 53261062802 922487338
## 12 2 1624684 1469152 1622308 815433485 53223109514 802987571
## 13 20 1923422 1537323 1911560 1691978325 53927052654 1639697812
## 14 21 1541665 1867975 1546025 715239562 52681220892 705493873
## 15 22 2017671 1855103 2015335 735005217 50893801724 724447395
## 16 23 2155830 2560944 2163128 948375390 51622645434 931091455
## 17 24 2724848 2699051 2723931 1760386684 51664614944 1701367906
## 18 25 3922965 3724353 3912300 2920020355 51872956410 2763532291
## 19 26 2048536 2255033 2051276 719886064 53430610083 710244904
## 20 27 1847701 1379940 1841499 711359832 53204095217 701781462
## 21 28 1634144 1899721 1638207 828221618 53223109514 815395899
## 22 29 1945016 2050055 1947048 1023140588 51643642740 1002812305
## 23 3 1793947 1897861 1796516 1395390064 53261062802 1358843217
## 24 4 2295009 2446453 2300178 1916328728 52402896774 1846770386
## 25 5 2081892 1900055 2077984 1122636524 51852235220 1098578301
## 26 6 2528004 2119956 2514165 1713315458 49349062711 1655038009
## 27 7 2716072 3051718 2723028 977407849 46339909106 957058965
## 28 71 2295165 2315165 2295807 2615668686 56323230525 2496901977
## 29 72 1869626 2082161 1877957 2414130748 57583520683 2312792840
## 30 73 3490320 3096499 3466279 3471167619 53727007195 3259330280
## 31 74 2197964 2089424 2195985 1035289894 56479373668 1016524850
## 32 75 1869696 2161092 1877430 1572726951 57315136713 1530301522
## 33 76 2090132 1999232 2086347 2378655121 57523591135 2282357437
## 34 77 2275681 2228257 2272931 3091588288 57364837448 2930016337
## 35 78 7013607 6956193 7003756 9577135301 46814325215 7943236739
## 36 79 2177799 2012784 2173569 1484193904 57099427992 1446235069
## 37 8 2025710 1757294 2020356 1059226537 52442958579 1038058946
## 38 9 2275558 2226769 2274627 851434210 44923689166 835375354
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 559.8589 36892.594 551.2873 59.514096
## 2 507.8006 18211.976 493.8550 38.860161
## 3 574.1203 30715.036 563.3818 64.645803
## 4 434.0884 25359.755 426.6611 74.067607
## 5 493.3348 35668.686 486.4728 63.124399
## 6 419.4313 18921.566 410.1793 44.103221
## 7 1095.2072 10041.938 986.8075 8.809340
## 8 445.2618 20249.381 435.5623 43.843279
## 9 458.2678 22655.851 449.0922 54.489947
## 10 443.2183 30555.084 436.8209 65.801824
## 11 497.1211 23529.927 486.6948 56.720094
## 12 501.3925 36235.097 494.4799 65.269713
## 13 877.6568 35083.286 855.9633 31.872189
## 14 463.3682 28204.519 455.7685 73.655351
## 15 364.0767 27439.350 359.2697 69.242776
## 16 439.6350 20157.499 430.1706 54.432713
## 17 645.3347 19143.713 623.9415 29.348447
## 18 743.9634 13927.341 706.0397 17.764587
## 19 351.2494 23694.182 346.0848 74.220926
## 20 384.4822 38561.767 380.6117 74.792099
## 21 506.4785 28016.977 497.4039 64.261918
## 22 525.1596 25197.916 514.2006 50.475608
## 23 776.5188 28064.902 755.1387 38.169301
## 24 833.4142 21419.884 801.4253 27.345463
## 25 538.7771 27291.655 528.2453 46.187910
## 26 677.1027 23280.777 657.7299 28.803255
## 27 359.7469 15184.937 351.3585 47.411026
## 28 1137.2634 24327.769 1085.4851 21.533014
## 29 1287.2248 27656.088 1227.7710 23.852693
## 30 993.9386 17350.151 939.8148 15.478079
## 31 470.8496 27031.415 462.7385 54.554163
## 32 840.4495 26521.629 814.4360 36.443158
## 33 1135.8768 28773.709 1092.0267 24.183241
## 34 1354.8918 25744.241 1285.9395 18.555135
## 35 1364.9743 6729.804 1133.7783 4.888134
## 36 680.9547 28369.234 664.8610 38.471677
## 37 522.4494 29845.973 513.3857 49.510616
## 38 373.9557 20177.150 367.0601 52.762373
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9830415
## 2 0.9745588
## 3 0.9844220
## 4 0.9864155
## 5 0.9840631
## 6 0.9774157
## 7 0.8973407
## 8 0.9773961
## 9 0.9817669
## 10 0.9848586
## 11 0.9823981
## 12 0.9847371
## 13 0.9691010
## 14 0.9863742
## 15 0.9856357
## 16 0.9817752
## 17 0.9664740
## 18 0.9464086
## 19 0.9866074
## 20 0.9865351
## 21 0.9845141
## 22 0.9801315
## 23 0.9738089
## 24 0.9637023
## 25 0.9785699
## 26 0.9659856
## 27 0.9791808
## 28 0.9545941
## 29 0.9580230
## 30 0.9389723
## 31 0.9818746
## 32 0.9730243
## 33 0.9595159
## 34 0.9477382
## 35 0.8293959
## 36 0.9744246
## 37 0.9800160
## 38 0.9811391Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.8 <- mean(res_srs2_0.8$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.8 <- mean(res_srs2_0.8$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.8## [1] 44.9333rt_com_3_0.8## [1] 0.9687352 d. f = 70%res_srs2_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1639426 1483879 1635086 1559774074 56196607806 1515532270
## 2 10 2447562 2654970 2455963 2121674978 49860841030 2032977372
## 3 11 1431042 1735672 1438724 1425652326 54759061138 1388353298
## 4 12 1625684 2067821 1635308 1206640896 53969204568 1179449573
## 5 13 1662990 1453841 1657326 1448664815 53303095386 1409054181
## 6 14 2680686 2617089 2678224 1970642517 51026640922 1895488970
## 7 15 5061846 4859941 5028879 9555627259 50367782466 8008043626
## 8 16 2698522 2595133 2694495 2096850852 54028416760 2016798171
## 9 17 2056607 2279864 2063061 1605599869 53095896242 1557333689
## 10 18 1802901 1719927 1800711 1403292030 53949417423 1367038245
## 11 19 1894920 2263677 1905788 1673794401 54740293821 1622598989
## 12 2 1629906 1472490 1625854 1409967899 54702684564 1373794237
## 13 20 1929668 1538315 1909502 2967285094 55400246725 2813141743
## 14 21 1543480 1869632 1550776 1246082453 54165707958 1217362205
## 15 22 2028002 1860017 2023891 1292146659 52394491071 1260593393
## 16 23 2141020 2561266 2153451 1617215647 53116728089 1568504586
## 17 24 2724640 2700996 2723135 3037863835 53158317160 2866770897
## 18 25 3916633 3721676 3899747 4967565878 53364770089 4539912820
## 19 26 2048962 2254388 2053495 1242697963 54908304219 1214833884
## 20 27 1846824 1379007 1836614 1210827542 54683842625 1183785637
## 21 28 1631258 1897240 1637960 1418416779 54702684564 1381858740
## 22 29 1941901 2045450 1945084 1710370698 53137535061 1655023706
## 23 3 1792194 1897280 1796316 2372906958 54740293821 2270210841
## 24 4 2293040 2446923 2301423 3280618704 53889906744 3083731482
## 25 5 2083704 1901181 2077371 1866861662 53344236729 1802067360
## 26 6 2528186 2122537 2505649 2940510400 50863754536 2776869731
## 27 7 2720633 3052788 2732007 1682525230 47881877774 1624453952
## 28 71 2300438 2311118 2300558 4472031300 57774704146 4138986004
## 29 72 1871024 2078374 1884148 4247972892 59023570249 3944188570
## 30 73 3480240 3091258 3442228 5919522541 55202014603 5341347529
## 31 74 2203982 2085563 2200431 1746819520 57929431911 1695002157
## 32 75 1857672 2157231 1870401 2637899531 58757619079 2522134832
## 33 76 2092686 1995526 2085821 4137882775 58964183940 3858995480
## 34 77 2257345 2224207 2253802 5168087718 58806869296 4733452398
## 35 78 7004214 6946581 6989361 16260783068 48351993480 12135487476
## 36 79 2171649 2009237 2164751 2514593575 58543865676 2408990385
## 37 8 2020381 1757836 2011818 1778010383 53929605404 1719896646
## 38 9 2279357 2231296 2277764 1487553668 46478495335 1440026753
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 948.4946 37875.115 924.2400 36.028684
## 2 865.8880 18779.852 826.9034 23.500697
## 3 994.2230 31550.601 963.0596 38.409828
## 4 740.5269 26099.945 719.5779 44.726815
## 5 868.8646 36675.935 848.1433 36.794637
## 6 734.5414 19497.066 707.2213 25.893403
## 7 1885.9028 10364.638 1591.2436 5.271007
## 8 775.9973 20818.600 747.5643 25.766457
## 9 779.3149 23289.384 753.5709 33.069196
## 10 776.9804 31367.441 757.8889 38.444897
## 11 881.4544 24180.966 849.6448 32.704312
## 12 863.4789 37151.495 843.5099 38.797113
## 13 1533.3437 36013.937 1469.5730 18.670348
## 14 805.5762 28971.421 783.3309 43.468799
## 15 636.5243 28173.540 622.2721 40.548409
## 16 754.6409 20738.307 727.6988 32.844555
## 17 1112.4244 19686.982 1050.5560 17.498585
## 18 1267.3165 14340.119 1163.3727 10.742640
## 19 606.0815 24362.259 591.1981 44.184754
## 20 654.2852 39682.512 643.3536 45.162371
## 21 868.1137 28836.543 842.3096 38.566016
## 22 878.1553 25979.214 848.4122 31.067847
## 23 1319.4173 28851.846 1259.6298 23.068875
## 24 1425.5540 22022.754 1335.4046 16.426751
## 25 894.7508 28059.227 866.4363 28.574285
## 26 1161.4828 23963.823 1106.9121 17.297594
## 27 618.0858 15687.806 594.2792 28.458342
## 28 1936.2534 24998.413 1792.7483 12.919119
## 29 2257.3263 28398.816 2081.8578 13.894526
## 30 1698.8270 17855.661 1550.0963 9.325417
## 31 791.8716 27776.124 769.6655 33.162803
## 32 1417.7577 27237.340 1346.4507 22.274396
## 33 1969.5744 29548.351 1843.6675 14.249844
## 34 2278.4535 26438.764 2091.4543 11.378845
## 35 2319.8812 6961.079 1735.4050 2.973534
## 36 1155.6296 29137.311 1110.8280 23.281641
## 37 878.4006 30680.211 853.4403 30.331434
## 38 651.8946 20834.018 631.5534 31.244920
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9716358
## 2 0.9581945
## 3 0.9738372
## 4 0.9774653
## 5 0.9726571
## 6 0.9618634
## 7 0.8380448
## 8 0.9618224
## 9 0.9699388
## 10 0.9741652
## 11 0.9694136
## 12 0.9743443
## 13 0.9480524
## 14 0.9769516
## 15 0.9755807
## 16 0.9698797
## 17 0.9436799
## 18 0.9139109
## 19 0.9775778
## 20 0.9776666
## 21 0.9742262
## 22 0.9676404
## 23 0.9567214
## 24 0.9399847
## 25 0.9652924
## 26 0.9443496
## 27 0.9654856
## 28 0.9255271
## 29 0.9284872
## 30 0.9023274
## 31 0.9703362
## 32 0.9561148
## 33 0.9326015
## 34 0.9159002
## 35 0.7463040
## 36 0.9580039
## 37 0.9673153
## 38 0.9680503Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.7 <- mean(res_srs2_0.7$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.7 <- mean(res_srs2_0.7$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.7## [1] 26.86904rt_com_3_0.7## [1] 0.9492461 e. f = 60%res_srs2_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1637125 1481263 1630286 2432317862 56517675569 2323865057
## 2 10 2442475 2650665 2455253 3326979523 49925702303 3112879623
## 3 11 1435409 1733680 1446777 2238408231 55021997217 2145379709
## 4 12 1629303 2068771 1644109 1898138253 54200200334 1831411203
## 5 13 1658375 1449978 1649989 2164763509 53507154949 2076050669
## 6 14 2671724 2614621 2668259 2986526338 51138644949 2816220246
## 7 15 5042676 4861605 5000073 14460204278 50453143497 11173356912
## 8 16 2701020 2592868 2694443 3360105578 54261806956 3159185673
## 9 17 2055988 2275982 2065515 2439361931 53291577061 2329660938
## 10 18 1792728 1715722 1789662 2131641831 54179613033 2048911138
## 11 19 1891422 2263225 1907596 2548754453 55002470985 2430616081
## 12 2 1628454 1468033 1622117 2188186217 54963340881 2102115559
## 13 20 1923350 1536237 1894004 4454728760 55689111144 4111385163
## 14 21 1543163 1867603 1554181 1924402860 54404649951 1856628523
## 15 22 2019101 1854907 2013080 1951645087 52561808385 1880456010
## 16 23 2142448 2559339 2160977 2494643483 53313251309 2380536300
## 17 24 2729487 2697062 2726387 4723588130 53356522165 4317401376
## 18 25 3922827 3722517 3896910 7802823189 53571323662 6799494465
## 19 26 2043439 2256585 2050535 1902244029 55177275408 1837759684
## 20 27 1852547 1379604 1835850 1995383757 54943737009 1922923954
## 21 28 1634403 1900488 1644707 2226091068 54963340881 2137083607
## 22 29 1942268 2051001 1947513 2718368705 53334899677 2579585076
## 23 3 1791882 1896537 1797557 3628497038 55002470985 3389055374
## 24 4 2290768 2445637 2302778 5064236234 54117695855 4598311475
## 25 5 2078041 1897898 2068438 2924851972 53549959971 2769263386
## 26 6 2527656 2118070 2493926 4466962920 50969171744 4097514120
## 27 7 2717802 3043751 2734931 2648784844 47866713495 2506412808
## 28 71 2306319 2314112 2305808 7082780833 58159587156 6274309373
## 29 72 1872780 2081697 1892277 6671417653 59458955055 5935945393
## 30 73 3492940 3096595 3435741 9212498797 55482862887 7885046584
## 31 74 2195801 2088779 2190778 2736142398 58320571820 2610920541
## 32 75 1881399 2160321 1899898 4305908258 59182249320 4004542558
## 33 76 2084319 1998623 2075178 6376210063 59397167275 5734591506
## 34 77 2265535 2227815 2259610 8047452479 59233491122 7038007918
## 35 78 7024052 6960825 7001825 25461538178 48355839796 16617052404
## 36 79 2172091 2011942 2161470 3968819025 58959852131 3709060557
## 37 8 2009752 1754196 1997289 2691152157 54158999854 2559268318
## 38 9 2269548 2221866 2267145 2242812812 46406580910 2136262624
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 1476.6873 38176.365 1417.6537 23.236139
## 2 1359.8559 18834.519 1265.8878 15.006315
## 3 1550.1921 31742.327 1474.2693 24.580859
## 4 1161.9542 26203.381 1110.9754 28.554401
## 5 1299.4069 36924.495 1253.0612 24.717321
## 6 1115.9124 19556.272 1053.8561 17.123119
## 7 2860.4724 10376.717 2231.1222 3.489103
## 8 1242.2405 20926.149 1171.0147 16.148840
## 9 1184.5723 23413.656 1126.1543 21.846523
## 10 1187.1683 31582.541 1143.2014 25.416846
## 11 1342.2806 24302.303 1269.3317 21.580137
## 12 1340.1701 37451.281 1292.7812 25.118219
## 13 2306.3062 36261.106 2163.4461 12.501123
## 14 1244.1908 29132.968 1191.9042 28.270926
## 15 965.4745 28338.285 933.1292 26.932053
## 16 1162.3309 20829.436 1099.7462 21.371090
## 17 1724.9387 19785.100 1579.0208 11.295761
## 18 1986.6629 14389.895 1743.1204 6.865633
## 19 930.1787 24455.559 895.5628 29.006413
## 20 1074.4625 39862.907 1045.2153 27.535424
## 21 1359.5719 28926.830 1297.1172 24.690518
## 22 1394.3780 26013.177 1319.7688 19.620186
## 23 2011.2003 29007.218 1873.6603 15.158472
## 24 2197.0543 22126.920 1985.8257 10.686250
## 25 1404.2353 28220.131 1336.0667 18.308605
## 26 1763.0884 24065.112 1639.9031 11.410252
## 27 973.4781 15728.554 915.4542 18.071197
## 28 3054.4522 25137.293 2708.9048 8.211406
## 29 3531.9218 28569.473 3112.4187 8.912492
## 30 2633.4185 17917.358 2292.4277 6.022564
## 31 1244.2972 27927.524 1190.2497 21.314889
## 32 2280.7934 27401.126 2101.1199 13.744429
## 33 3043.9774 29727.326 2751.9958 9.315435
## 34 3534.3066 26593.116 3102.0416 7.360527
## 35 3621.7353 6946.143 2371.8589 1.899172
## 36 1820.2661 29312.999 1710.3398 14.855767
## 37 1335.1232 30882.841 1278.1098 20.124838
## 38 985.8628 20889.040 940.1938 20.691241
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9554117
## 2 0.9356474
## 3 0.9584399
## 4 0.9648461
## 5 0.9590196
## 6 0.9429752
## 7 0.7726970
## 8 0.9402043
## 9 0.9550288
## 10 0.9611892
## 11 0.9536486
## 12 0.9606658
## 13 0.9229260
## 14 0.9647816
## 15 0.9635236
## 16 0.9542591
## 17 0.9140089
## 18 0.8714147
## 19 0.9661009
## 20 0.9636863
## 21 0.9600163
## 22 0.9489460
## 23 0.9340108
## 24 0.9079970
## 25 0.9468046
## 26 0.9172931
## 27 0.9462501
## 28 0.8858539
## 29 0.8897577
## 30 0.8559075
## 31 0.9542342
## 32 0.9300111
## 33 0.8993731
## 34 0.8745635
## 35 0.6526335
## 36 0.9345502
## 37 0.9509935
## 38 0.9524926Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.6 <- mean(res_srs2_0.6$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.6 <- mean(res_srs2_0.6$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.6## [1] 17.39459rt_com_3_0.6## [1] 0.9242675 f. f = 50%res_srs2_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1634292 1483976 1624700 3647159434 58836870350 3408243472
## 2 10 2454318 2651805 2471167 5077949491 52583093099 4609683673
## 3 11 1424265 1734276 1440096 3183109192 57417926603 2999312158
## 4 12 1631493 2069023 1652269 2821429692 56638291363 2678953935
## 5 13 1658537 1448071 1646590 3182679716 55980802128 2998575443
## 6 14 2679847 2614598 2674106 4626282269 53733806675 4241722082
## 7 15 5061372 4865367 5000640 22191612229 53083474337 15504297975
## 8 16 2703903 2596243 2694650 4967391133 56696737306 4550954334
## 9 17 2055037 2277704 2068559 3729544690 55776284295 3483983773
## 10 18 1797858 1717613 1793061 3233577355 56618760278 3050250917
## 11 19 1890713 2266030 1914176 3903725208 57399402148 3641090763
## 12 2 1634902 1470070 1625299 3385973696 57362279583 3189165397
## 13 20 1937447 1538309 1892800 7139104612 58050814773 6328891270
## 14 21 1536018 1868973 1551944 2881449270 56832251853 2736921589
## 15 22 2027255 1856353 2018220 2975122800 55083955828 2818330775
## 16 23 2144106 2561757 2170459 3776700052 55796846562 3528862976
## 17 24 2722045 2699128 2718315 6674639299 55837897440 5885256113
## 18 25 3923728 3725649 3888715 11662098725 56041678715 9613575544
## 19 26 2041433 2253770 2051182 2820994939 57565238368 2685071169
## 20 27 1845328 1374467 1823066 2808069690 57343681473 2668076745
## 21 28 1627384 1896094 1641782 3306080090 57362279583 3118851200
## 22 29 1940171 2044393 1946811 3982806073 55817384277 3694080845
## 23 3 1794141 1897924 1802065 5591362677 57399402148 5048918382
## 24 4 2296178 2447393 2313059 7927137605 56560019712 6880452897
## 25 5 2085535 1898391 2071137 4427734487 56021411072 4089004529
## 26 6 2506643 2119212 2462851 6576632460 53573028159 5828353120
## 27 7 2709186 3044986 2733673 3911427478 50629739097 3617750264
## 28 71 2294160 2317185 2294788 10321504318 60394544952 8703897305
## 29 72 1892722 2084599 1916068 10233846727 61627249800 8600197866
## 30 73 3480838 3098179 3405577 13925812961 57855147921 11184353528
## 31 74 2193458 2091308 2186689 4087433877 60547270424 3822462023
## 32 75 1875600 2163501 1901665 6354774308 61364740235 5726425190
## 33 76 2101706 2001566 2086348 9631534275 61568631994 8258817163
## 34 77 2259258 2230756 2250225 12064502278 61413353118 9910844319
## 35 78 7018980 6956897 6991815 37973125753 51093771156 21612799577
## 36 79 2187444 2014991 2171100 5997515917 61153752960 5434777161
## 37 8 2016385 1755735 1998163 4096364878 56599204641 3809574271
## 38 9 2273403 2220801 2269683 3377397073 49244517468 3147663265
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 2210.450 39675.972 2080.711 16.132245
## 2 2063.313 19833.283 1861.059 10.355182
## 3 2218.759 33111.832 2067.788 18.038315
## 4 1723.415 27379.821 1615.660 20.074323
## 5 1904.951 38681.517 1809.586 17.589204
## 6 1721.771 20546.586 1582.642 11.614900
## 7 4371.784 10910.157 3095.508 2.392051
## 8 1832.545 21835.650 1685.359 11.413786
## 9 1808.152 24486.672 1678.577 14.955253
## 10 1791.634 32969.043 1695.322 17.509635
## 11 2055.742 25328.202 1894.381 14.703751
## 12 2063.664 39035.120 1956.061 16.941147
## 13 3665.901 37748.500 3330.962 8.131386
## 14 1868.389 30411.965 1756.657 19.723496
## 15 1465.242 29671.282 1394.450 18.514851
## 16 1756.705 21777.388 1621.809 14.773968
## 17 2435.458 20683.552 2152.572 8.365680
## 18 2966.801 15039.440 2468.706 4.805454
## 19 1378.556 25546.482 1306.132 20.406006
## 20 1514.199 41763.149 1457.599 20.421032
## 21 2022.699 30255.120 1891.869 17.350541
## 22 2040.656 27308.416 1887.060 14.014588
## 23 3093.870 30252.016 2784.204 10.265727
## 24 3430.672 23108.647 2958.610 7.134986
## 25 2115.321 29520.402 1968.247 12.652387
## 26 2614.002 25290.115 2359.834 8.145967
## 27 1441.660 16636.527 1321.610 12.944057
## 28 4463.613 26070.448 3770.731 5.851332
## 29 5330.888 29572.289 4434.693 6.021905
## 30 3987.549 18672.852 3276.176 4.154526
## 31 1860.595 28960.320 1745.747 14.813028
## 32 3371.640 28371.970 2998.699 9.656478
## 33 4546.251 30771.690 3934.097 6.392401
## 34 5273.950 27536.586 4364.423 5.090417
## 35 5404.877 7345.409 3089.768 1.345525
## 36 2729.357 30360.467 2494.003 10.196514
## 37 2024.138 32248.610 1900.637 13.816934
## 38 1481.813 22195.247 1383.738 14.580612
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9344926
## 2 0.9077845
## 3 0.9422586
## 4 0.9495023
## 5 0.9421543
## 6 0.9168749
## 7 0.6986558
## 8 0.9161659
## 9 0.9341579
## 10 0.9433054
## 11 0.9327221
## 12 0.9418754
## 13 0.8865105
## 14 0.9498420
## 15 0.9472990
## 16 0.9343773
## 17 0.8817340
## 18 0.8243435
## 19 0.9518171
## 20 0.9501462
## 21 0.9433683
## 22 0.9275071
## 23 0.9029853
## 24 0.8679618
## 25 0.9234981
## 26 0.8862215
## 27 0.9249181
## 28 0.8432780
## 29 0.8403681
## 30 0.8031383
## 31 0.9351740
## 32 0.9011217
## 33 0.8574768
## 34 0.8214880
## 35 0.5691604
## 36 0.9061714
## 37 0.9299890
## 38 0.9319790Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.5 <- mean(res_srs2_0.5$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.5 <- mean(res_srs2_0.5$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.5## [1] 12.1392rt_com_3_0.5## [1] 0.8947849 g. f = 40%res_srs2_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1635985 1484912 1621941 5615293161 61870209985 5068604686
## 2 10 2443283 2653746 2466562 7489420770 55916262923 6545186097
## 3 11 1424325 1736256 1446874 5002347393 60519295871 4568442002
## 4 12 1629233 2070789 1657009 4069231756 59777039350 3786226470
## 5 13 1652100 1449692 1635219 4858024477 59151072684 4437277280
## 6 14 2672777 2615155 2664833 7063352890 57011806854 6224194524
## 7 15 5064000 4865144 4987217 32992121833 56392653955 20526526636
## 8 16 2710265 2597037 2695994 7523780042 59832683169 6631782953
## 9 17 2064182 2279647 2082984 5878240231 58956360224 5317332143
## 10 18 1810041 1719849 1802338 5031762593 59758444661 4622238874
## 11 19 1890016 2267496 1922036 5792774117 60501659550 5244361374
## 12 2 1637618 1472542 1624155 5109517373 60466316785 4692097040
## 13 20 1924560 1540109 1867380 10046872548 61121840942 8515784620
## 14 21 1551494 1871542 1573125 4466287293 59961700627 4136178215
## 15 22 2014916 1858605 2003553 4350353069 58297224652 4037416080
## 16 23 2145654 2562562 2181964 5678373744 58975936656 5156825025
## 17 24 2715231 2698208 2710348 10711202017 59015019398 8857162970
## 18 25 3932662 3724328 3882487 17678329380 59209030613 13501128311
## 19 26 2050440 2256767 2063961 4285804397 60659544942 3993000992
## 20 27 1853886 1376861 1821468 4353562993 60448610339 4036867668
## 21 28 1633092 1897509 1652775 4971697907 60466316785 4575421177
## 22 29 1938458 2042313 1947919 5998671534 58995489714 5374646775
## 23 3 1808919 1899916 1818306 9117821237 60501659550 7815810656
## 24 4 2301896 2449221 2321830 12111593301 59702520344 9845241015
## 25 5 2074651 1900966 2056139 6457701926 59189734678 5776148810
## 26 6 2527342 2122462 2462720 10277315076 56858736680 8623410787
## 27 7 2713645 3045620 2746444 5866126178 54056560241 5262636117
## 28 71 2293523 2317577 2294217 15211860569 63353203662 12000334193
## 29 72 1892051 2085300 1924079 15708995387 64526807889 12252177811
## 30 73 3500227 3098180 3395677 20803931498 60935555114 15390325736
## 31 74 2194578 2091857 2184760 6045416467 63498606887 5496943917
## 32 75 1850161 2163983 1887639 9215147864 64276884044 7986493711
## 33 76 2093224 2002245 2072575 14126099819 64471000446 11385765688
## 34 77 2296378 2231321 2275921 19572434907 64323166237 14661557155
## 35 78 7010811 6958992 6982847 56491753131 54498344815 27414919492
## 36 79 2159707 2015634 2141184 8550169849 64076012312 7480758353
## 37 8 2020015 1756908 1993644 6274025719 59739826597 5637579187
## 38 9 2274504 2224602 2269295 5138366174 52737751477 4648027611
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 3388.179 41698.98 3093.291 11.0181620
## 2 3046.889 21073.05 2640.533 7.4660330
## 3 3469.176 34863.88 3120.037 12.0981793
## 4 2481.516 28870.03 2269.916 14.6900061
## 5 2907.209 40843.36 2689.216 12.1759520
## 6 2628.751 21806.13 2325.953 8.0714935
## 7 6485.244 11593.70 4105.890 1.7092764
## 8 2762.021 23040.50 2450.517 7.9524764
## 9 2835.042 25865.54 2542.658 10.0295935
## 10 2766.997 34756.58 2554.445 11.8762449
## 11 3043.259 26682.94 2710.431 10.4443326
## 12 3105.263 41087.17 2877.429 11.8340564
## 13 5161.945 39700.39 4527.240 6.0836684
## 14 2860.277 32044.03 2613.560 13.4254016
## 15 2153.226 31392.90 2010.436 13.4005732
## 16 2638.041 23017.08 2356.587 10.3860611
## 17 3911.075 21892.72 3247.307 5.5096542
## 18 4481.190 15903.09 3470.637 3.3492435
## 19 2085.420 26892.11 1930.621 14.1535962
## 20 2334.165 43972.54 2206.544 13.8848595
## 21 3029.558 31883.18 2756.326 12.1621060
## 22 3067.985 28943.25 2737.541 9.8347591
## 23 4987.266 31848.25 4261.087 6.6355391
## 24 5198.560 24377.15 4201.678 4.9293696
## 25 3092.532 31142.81 2795.411 9.1657582
## 26 4041.432 26795.47 3486.885 5.5324505
## 27 2156.048 17756.09 1911.713 9.2150354
## 28 6560.160 27340.69 5189.365 4.1647242
## 29 8187.052 30949.85 6297.393 4.1076343
## 30 5914.302 19669.74 4518.943 2.9290404
## 31 2744.574 30361.20 2508.536 10.5035951
## 32 4945.213 29709.05 4207.270 6.9751332
## 33 6650.109 32207.65 5437.684 4.5639633
## 34 8429.885 28831.13 6397.936 3.2864162
## 35 8041.461 7838.33 3924.482 0.9647133
## 36 3935.168 31797.45 3477.957 7.4941216
## 37 3085.786 34016.40 2813.812 9.5217695
## 38 2247.644 23718.44 2039.443 10.2635253
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9026429
## 2 0.8739242
## 3 0.9132596
## 4 0.9304524
## 5 0.9133913
## 6 0.8811955
## 7 0.6221645
## 8 0.8814430
## 9 0.9045789
## 10 0.9186123
## 11 0.9053281
## 12 0.9183053
## 13 0.8476055
## 14 0.9260887
## 15 0.9280663
## 16 0.9081517
## 17 0.8269065
## 18 0.7637106
## 19 0.9316806
## 20 0.9272561
## 21 0.9202935
## 22 0.8959728
## 23 0.8572016
## 24 0.8128774
## 25 0.8944589
## 26 0.8390723
## 27 0.8971229
## 28 0.7888801
## 29 0.7799466
## 30 0.7397797
## 31 0.9092746
## 32 0.8666702
## 33 0.8060091
## 34 0.7490921
## 35 0.4852906
## 36 0.8749251
## 37 0.8985585
## 38 0.9045731Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.4 <- mean(res_srs2_0.4$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.4 <- mean(res_srs2_0.4$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.4## [1] 8.468645rt_com_3_0.4## [1] 0.8564411 h. f = 30%res_srs2_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1628704 1480832 1608853 8398705154 67953404352 7222706064
## 2 10 2447272 2653771 2478311 11898135371 62368866494 9809316804
## 3 11 1454864 1733497 1484160 8766590353 66686306923 7553407622
## 4 12 1610511 2066415 1650059 6380264226 65990103279 5739910763
## 5 13 1677556 1452199 1648578 8463151804 65402974353 7335547857
## 6 14 2675051 2612459 2663798 10661839563 63396438035 8945165351
## 7 15 5025055 4847789 4937668 50021689503 62815700120 27076444419
## 8 16 2707267 2588445 2686806 11824966680 66042294709 9884309949
## 9 17 2055552 2275814 2079239 8768602052 65220342714 7608834177
## 10 18 1807191 1717882 1796282 7632632319 65972662286 6760117472
## 11 19 1875708 2259356 1917365 8542732824 66669764838 7443537504
## 12 2 1616163 1471233 1600282 7347192758 66636614893 6551107612
## 13 20 1939387 1536300 1854220 16970122572 67251467434 13271908893
## 14 21 1524842 1868563 1553366 6265088987 66163307353 5642898758
## 15 22 2025354 1855099 2007237 7098752350 64602102828 6342893779
## 16 23 2137048 2554785 2184908 8607852055 65238704539 7510888331
## 17 24 2705014 2686575 2697827 14384172251 65275362414 11285989746
## 18 25 3916253 3707607 3852330 27320658717 65457336315 19032056968
## 19 26 2038781 2253027 2058349 6801606592 66817854321 6132965972
## 20 27 1852340 1378899 1804630 7238479013 66620007034 6434031067
## 21 28 1622965 1897561 1650156 7544241092 66636614893 6717204920
## 22 29 1938588 2049217 1952077 9751086600 65257044439 8193819176
## 23 3 1780209 1896239 1793061 11810941037 66669764838 9729645052
## 24 4 2297735 2443800 2322596 17988199005 65920207761 13541890644
## 25 5 2077302 1901315 2050969 10083301538 65439237585 8626929775
## 26 6 2536384 2123836 2446563 16577925967 63252865012 12932119310
## 27 7 2715204 3047707 2760289 9297420178 60624547990 7956182482
## 28 71 2298738 2306208 2292509 25188971593 69344386543 17741233692
## 29 72 1855747 2074494 1891938 22244149141 70445175173 15616486108
## 30 73 3481010 3089367 3350382 31796826493 67076739601 21267638470
## 31 74 2205340 2081860 2188724 9766068708 69480768308 8487918436
## 32 75 1863324 2152664 1907429 14037600435 70210757709 11441000176
## 33 76 2094169 1991805 2062383 22069169268 70392830271 16181578014
## 34 77 2246969 2220291 2228833 28816551894 70254168351 19519386537
## 35 78 7017355 6949227 6975326 87430705924 61038922295 35336715945
## 36 79 2172494 2005499 2142176 13674581772 70022348948 11242593976
## 37 8 2020552 1755585 1983182 9980441811 65955199369 8566422381
## 38 9 2277091 2233868 2269812 8028505580 59387563953 6951142178
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 5054.848 45943.437 4429.042 8.0909382
## 2 4826.351 23502.792 3935.636 5.2419026
## 3 5918.330 38478.080 5008.656 7.6068693
## 4 3923.647 31935.794 3445.502 10.3428480
## 5 4958.947 45108.161 4394.860 7.7279689
## 6 3959.895 24269.798 3342.833 5.9461069
## 7 9877.880 12957.371 5468.120 1.2557693
## 8 4343.312 25509.176 3664.633 5.5849878
## 9 4224.204 28655.222 3630.517 7.4379408
## 10 4193.002 38420.149 3742.442 8.6435006
## 11 4501.430 29505.630 3841.022 7.8042666
## 12 4514.789 45348.188 4071.653 9.0696702
## 13 8607.677 43803.636 7085.870 3.9629335
## 14 4053.073 35419.239 3586.880 10.5606333
## 15 3488.526 34856.447 3148.361 9.1004869
## 16 4002.034 25531.874 3418.951 7.5789760
## 17 5246.842 24317.391 4146.761 4.5379992
## 18 6949.845 17655.585 4928.445 2.3958916
## 19 3323.340 29671.293 2969.574 9.8238340
## 20 3852.309 48449.922 3528.924 9.2035919
## 21 4613.722 35149.729 4044.944 8.8327791
## 22 4946.724 31964.528 4137.765 6.6922844
## 23 6531.527 35162.511 5361.398 5.6447462
## 24 7729.826 26970.596 5775.429 3.6646363
## 25 4805.869 34423.810 4176.490 6.4898622
## 26 6469.819 29792.627 5253.710 3.8154872
## 27 3411.106 19906.652 2873.384 6.5205774
## 28 10749.895 30071.532 7648.947 2.7529662
## 29 11576.491 33967.383 8065.734 3.1669081
## 30 9072.067 21714.396 6325.812 2.1095420
## 31 4403.924 33383.707 3861.334 7.1145074
## 32 7446.232 32623.072 5946.309 5.0016210
## 33 10329.443 35354.991 7749.940 3.1896457
## 34 12538.078 31647.410 8649.864 2.4379797
## 35 12419.512 8792.211 5062.441 0.6981406
## 36 6233.696 34927.596 5214.578 5.1206209
## 37 4898.261 37589.431 4293.366 6.6084449
## 38 3506.259 26607.404 3050.191 7.3970882
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.8599785
## 2 0.8244415
## 3 0.8616129
## 4 0.8996353
## 5 0.8667631
## 6 0.8389889
## 7 0.5412941
## 8 0.8358848
## 9 0.8677363
## 10 0.8856862
## 11 0.8713298
## 12 0.8916477
## 13 0.7820750
## 14 0.9006893
## 15 0.8935223
## 16 0.8725624
## 17 0.7846117
## 18 0.6966178
## 19 0.9016937
## 20 0.8888651
## 21 0.8903752
## 22 0.8402981
## 23 0.8237824
## 24 0.7528208
## 25 0.8555660
## 26 0.7800807
## 27 0.8557409
## 28 0.7043254
## 29 0.7020492
## 30 0.6688604
## 31 0.8691234
## 32 0.8150253
## 33 0.7332210
## 34 0.6773672
## 35 0.4041683
## 36 0.8221527
## 37 0.8583210
## 38 0.8658077Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.3 <- mean(res_srs2_0.3$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.3 <- mean(res_srs2_0.3$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.3## [1] 6.03092rt_com_3_0.3## [1] 0.8074927 i. f = 20%res_srs2_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1636202 1481666 1605574 14572545244 74915609232 11441008138
## 2 10 2446665 2652868 2485212 20001752276 69913380752 14939850454
## 3 11 1417673 1729914 1458160 12816346281 73780634234 10472118713
## 4 12 1616938 2061117 1671958 10762754056 73157024942 9147267382
## 5 13 1635462 1438544 1601672 12733635533 72631116960 10444473677
## 6 14 2673866 2610873 2657216 16602009048 70833805639 13051914020
## 7 15 5085111 4863610 4957197 88623745643 70313622267 38106590172
## 8 16 2703177 2597244 2674543 19636376252 73203774282 15077104497
## 9 17 2084702 2278620 2113976 15320312578 72467528637 12344680282
## 10 18 1788705 1719188 1775035 12943817775 73141402552 10773919079
## 11 19 1890455 2265483 1948783 15222832622 73765817020 12197687065
## 12 2 1636162 1472639 1608059 12755913040 73736123677 10642245530
## 13 20 1904382 1536712 1800731 26216597936 74286864485 18503788547
## 14 21 1549447 1868566 1588901 11537995417 73312168730 9673383459
## 15 22 2027927 1859389 2001198 12275742962 71913753689 10342937723
## 16 23 2139092 2560774 2208317 14975880969 72483975843 12202923049
## 17 24 2684891 2696039 2676653 27119655841 72516811338 17880876024
## 18 25 3941422 3720543 3848166 47438228161 72679810507 27909632172
## 19 26 2031133 2241181 2057625 11132858176 73898464958 9569602236
## 20 27 1840008 1354789 1773759 11418601491 73721247548 9612582887
## 21 28 1610492 1878695 1647136 12396717677 73736123677 10424587345
## 22 29 1931315 2026521 1947552 16174169563 72500403410 12523555766
## 23 3 1784157 1893897 1798372 21400938990 73765817020 15583555793
## 24 4 2319251 2446761 2339475 35058309618 73094417550 21487212822
## 25 5 2090102 1896221 2045930 18116413384 72663598963 14044745458
## 26 6 2524980 2122393 2405993 27558232708 70705203222 19153323943
## 27 7 2693459 3046031 2758388 15456068590 68350945343 12377629430
## 28 71 2296368 2309874 2286259 40205739987 76161551315 24671438197
## 29 72 1874180 2077123 1907861 42091333916 77147558819 23197150126
## 30 73 3500473 3092016 3321623 54628848415 74130355824 30641574068
## 31 74 2205154 2083299 2181125 15583358454 76283712319 12749540468
## 32 75 1861248 2156380 1922419 24740361743 76937584468 17921842617
## 33 76 2089428 1994162 2047771 37673504866 77100672010 23783462301
## 34 77 2233458 2223572 2211861 44814192212 76976468607 26454688933
## 35 78 6985679 6948383 6957376 152322296477 68722112126 46520312731
## 36 79 2160215 2008181 2116222 24287997701 76768821412 17775519066
## 37 8 2014679 1753451 1960706 16906371134 73125760523 13333928425
## 38 9 2282664 2224002 2270106 14175749991 67242943761 11428317875
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 8652.927 50640.952 7020.680 5.1408733
## 2 8054.468 26353.187 5954.723 3.4953628
## 3 8810.268 42666.264 7017.788 5.7567604
## 4 6589.613 35505.836 5420.307 6.7972402
## 5 7603.301 50557.439 6420.790 5.7038791
## 6 6150.133 27113.957 4884.546 4.2665804
## 7 17293.798 14449.403 7662.614 0.7933948
## 8 7174.811 28170.370 5597.264 3.7279676
## 9 7261.415 31796.926 5788.860 4.7301599
## 10 7151.400 42580.639 6018.718 5.6506823
## 11 7908.498 32562.707 6163.273 4.8457353
## 12 7664.719 50177.835 6540.493 5.7805446
## 13 13365.170 48402.699 10140.657 2.8335814
## 14 7305.425 39273.874 5994.835 6.3539780
## 15 6002.197 38729.394 5135.192 5.8581997
## 16 6942.762 28289.716 5487.522 4.8400475
## 17 9757.869 26903.222 6547.304 2.6739577
## 18 11957.781 19518.341 7234.987 1.5320937
## 19 5445.168 33001.317 4625.347 6.6378700
## 20 6094.335 54567.661 5365.362 6.4562414
## 21 7611.914 39274.354 6268.769 5.9480361
## 22 8155.034 35937.199 6287.033 4.4824807
## 23 11661.067 38976.688 8502.025 3.4468496
## 24 14651.390 29872.432 9019.046 2.0849384
## 25 8537.517 38348.144 6809.153 4.0109263
## 26 10753.874 33351.030 7908.280 2.5656654
## 27 5705.146 22446.474 4467.680 4.4222724
## 28 16992.632 32974.344 10645.929 1.8942955
## 29 20951.851 37159.894 11737.233 1.8328609
## 30 15415.309 23990.092 9177.059 1.3569819
## 31 7001.616 36633.143 5808.390 4.8952036
## 32 13003.567 35688.872 9194.998 3.1098003
## 33 17539.763 38688.178 11456.511 2.0465490
## 34 19440.603 34631.704 11803.220 1.7176806
## 35 21697.415 9904.614 6683.741 0.4511625
## 36 11043.118 38251.344 8323.151 3.1607719
## 37 8259.027 41726.906 6735.620 4.3253375
## 38 6139.166 30266.930 4992.772 4.7435193
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.7851071
## 2 0.7469271
## 3 0.8170908
## 4 0.8499003
## 5 0.8202272
## 6 0.7861647
## 7 0.4299817
## 8 0.7678150
## 9 0.8057721
## 10 0.8323602
## 11 0.8012758
## 12 0.8342990
## 13 0.7058043
## 14 0.8383938
## 15 0.8425509
## 16 0.8148384
## 17 0.6593327
## 18 0.5883363
## 19 0.8595818
## 20 0.8418354
## 21 0.8409151
## 22 0.7742936
## 23 0.7281716
## 24 0.6128993
## 25 0.7752498
## 26 0.6950128
## 27 0.8008265
## 28 0.6136298
## 29 0.5511146
## 30 0.5609046
## 31 0.8181510
## 32 0.7243970
## 33 0.6313047
## 34 0.5903194
## 35 0.3054071
## 36 0.7318643
## 37 0.7886925
## 38 0.8061879Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.2 <- mean(res_srs2_0.2$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.2 <- mean(res_srs2_0.2$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.2## [1] 3.957118rt_com_3_0.2## [1] 0.730972 j. f = 10%res_srs2_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1651737 1475670 1600879 34192283666 102897607107 22473908721
## 2 10 2456110 2642080 2500658 46315363403 99918228231 29430969047
## 3 11 1442237 1723227 1487522 33338750410 102221604292 21984425106
## 4 12 1596365 2049804 1673534 23562803397 101850176166 18016040229
## 5 13 1663225 1444868 1600412 31735802158 101536939948 21693719808
## 6 14 2653677 2607601 2624305 38276980280 100466442787 25469555855
## 7 15 5109561 4841286 4914023 200453584817 100156616205 61789577717
## 8 16 2692387 2585466 2649165 44356568288 101878020555 29020971154
## 9 17 2037823 2269626 2082362 33210569697 101439505055 23424621845
## 10 18 1779507 1710482 1756712 27499744705 101840871309 20494831969
## 11 19 1888606 2250105 1955779 34509820648 102212779007 23541225980
## 12 2 1613718 1463547 1573831 27968584075 102195093346 20707599870
## 13 20 1920884 1527194 1756094 64932688501 102523120251 35313326067
## 14 21 1512527 1855415 1566121 23920546731 101942581406 18112234885
## 15 22 2016962 1853833 1976407 27108579913 101109670984 20605743639
## 16 23 2145624 2551191 2238261 32304043717 101449301180 23663252352
## 17 24 2711322 2701713 2691772 60865777169 101468858340 32147593686
## 18 25 3896691 3712241 3788719 103774964093 101565942326 48593425033
## 19 26 2027224 2231518 2065228 25115934530 102291785487 19705582531
## 20 27 1835198 1361115 1739086 24855907783 102186232970 18300252355
## 21 28 1615265 1877334 1662400 27762762152 102195093346 20533979159
## 22 29 1936066 2031757 1956062 36508903327 101459085609 23498804695
## 23 3 1814353 1881559 1801231 56046873210 102212779007 30797688872
## 24 4 2277054 2432404 2300229 74688513919 101812886558 35848674425
## 25 5 2085644 1887112 2013695 44018781586 101556286564 28459974301
## 26 6 2515348 2107882 2338474 63894087092 100389845861 35885894623
## 27 7 2675396 3048719 2770183 32707486138 98987625586 23786889594
## 28 71 2250029 2293986 2234517 81834232211 103639703063 39762884474
## 29 72 1841602 2060501 1877222 97052474214 104226979302 38228988745
## 30 73 3516720 3069322 3258383 125593321784 102429902079 53643547194
## 31 74 2193817 2068142 2154281 36769038865 103712463416 26160874352
## 32 75 1828400 2140212 1905764 55353149538 104101916413 32979964233
## 33 76 2105634 1978184 2019841 87618226192 104199053035 41851242782
## 34 77 2162940 2205912 2140735 90931091100 104125076207 41658912259
## 35 78 6920687 6893963 6897162 329813291988 99208696350 74057442910
## 36 79 2149536 1992501 2092019 45019414856 104001399396 29083759676
## 37 8 1979416 1749237 1907295 34394179861 101831554756 23220373858
## 38 9 2277855 2220438 2256552 29463295232 98327688416 21043904905
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 19739.10 69910.20 13812.822 3.0093810
## 2 18413.74 37769.63 11627.420 2.1573452
## 3 21703.46 59338.84 14151.695 3.0661498
## 4 14405.41 49664.52 10540.101 4.3224982
## 5 18215.42 70621.02 13279.104 3.1994446
## 6 13989.84 38539.47 9602.475 2.6247223
## 7 38239.17 20689.70 12518.267 0.4996499
## 8 16169.79 39376.17 10872.205 2.2967967
## 9 15881.77 44684.82 11068.571 3.0544344
## 10 15128.73 59549.95 11531.425 3.7033388
## 11 17424.57 45399.44 11655.295 2.9618461
## 12 16900.52 69936.55 12995.556 3.6539245
## 13 31914.12 67167.57 19778.705 1.5789138
## 14 15235.99 54954.37 11260.253 4.2617162
## 15 13213.55 54776.69 10311.104 3.7298033
## 16 14905.10 39754.05 10497.167 3.1404521
## 17 21353.73 37767.69 11745.797 1.6670921
## 18 26151.28 27388.76 12757.993 0.9787133
## 19 12284.16 46006.08 9487.506 4.0727844
## 20 12948.84 75752.38 10354.672 4.1111447
## 21 16705.29 54605.80 12102.369 3.6810132
## 22 17774.68 50538.25 11555.432 2.7790231
## 23 28723.93 54276.86 16508.503 1.8237017
## 24 30772.67 41826.38 15187.158 1.3631666
## 25 20477.66 53777.02 13938.325 2.3071126
## 26 24444.36 47605.31 15109.019 1.5711915
## 27 12078.70 32515.38 8513.878 3.0264517
## 28 34038.20 45160.13 17460.120 1.2664590
## 29 47181.80 50581.81 19630.383 1.0739240
## 30 34831.90 33342.60 16309.533 0.8155681
## 31 16512.41 50143.11 12042.396 2.8206466
## 32 28937.74 48634.47 16995.899 1.8806864
## 33 39122.34 52684.32 20274.893 1.1892395
## 34 38893.95 47184.43 19110.939 1.1450987
## 35 47141.29 14440.81 10732.461 0.3008026
## 36 20367.69 52198.61 13715.333 2.3101455
## 37 16669.84 58239.17 11981.986 2.9607205
## 38 12619.41 44334.33 9173.024 3.3372943
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.6572801
## 2 0.6354472
## 3 0.6594256
## 4 0.7645966
## 5 0.6835724
## 6 0.6654014
## 7 0.3082488
## 8 0.6542655
## 9 0.7053363
## 10 0.7452735
## 11 0.6821602
## 12 0.7403879
## 13 0.5438451
## 14 0.7571831
## 15 0.7601189
## 16 0.7325167
## 17 0.5281719
## 18 0.4682577
## 19 0.7845849
## 20 0.7362536
## 21 0.7396231
## 22 0.6436459
## 23 0.5494988
## 24 0.4799757
## 25 0.6465416
## 26 0.5616466
## 27 0.7272613
## 28 0.4858955
## 29 0.3939002
## 30 0.4271210
## 31 0.7114919
## 32 0.5958101
## 33 0.4776545
## 34 0.4581372
## 35 0.2245435
## 36 0.6460270
## 37 0.6751251
## 38 0.7142414Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.1 <- mean(res_srs2_0.1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.1 <- mean(res_srs2_0.1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.1## [1] 2.466905rt_com_3_0.1## [1] 0.6150123 k. f = 5%res_srs2_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1605266 1444798 1546212 58544128587 155320152067 35187242148
## 2 10 2462822 2632037 2490834 94631985375 157781571895 51632927128
## 3 11 1424771 1701439 1450852 67132805488 155878633148 35464531051
## 4 12 1613137 2033371 1691499 52966402143 156185489238 34943472061
## 5 13 1672546 1428623 1577170 73328298941 156444269967 39431921763
## 6 14 2612636 2595422 2591623 82475762200 157328663341 48288950902
## 7 15 5084982 4827410 4860831 426028285126 157584627193 102718684974
## 8 16 2631731 2558517 2587759 80173336652 156162485540 47573845325
## 9 17 1970492 2248021 2020876 62040838795 156524765999 39609271040
## 10 18 1741692 1685909 1703904 61122287360 156193176464 38987972014
## 11 19 1823223 2224414 1902686 56995747177 155885924175 37039367985
## 12 2 1592739 1437274 1532901 62124812253 155900535219 38921461770
## 13 20 1895380 1499794 1694789 127264054064 155629535134 56966473376
## 14 21 1575244 1834821 1613251 62539789837 156109148464 37338614399
## 15 22 2007998 1827237 1946563 56645253446 156797259077 38461795618
## 16 23 2091849 2526882 2195769 64875716342 156516672910 41400518153
## 17 24 2739948 2667196 2671586 156446147603 156500515724 59256726336
## 18 25 3832270 3685580 3720011 204316258330 156420309594 80496818586
## 19 26 2014974 2223904 2057434 51282434558 155820652813 36249890380
## 20 27 1800823 1353262 1686141 54829146153 155907855236 34116181544
## 21 28 1578328 1875851 1634885 60763680394 155900535219 38239810799
## 22 29 1970406 2052446 1984768 89633369826 156508589485 45640396891
## 23 3 1739149 1861027 1721756 103966156668 155885924175 47568345125
## 24 4 2276095 2413918 2265814 150987701858 156216296123 57267475237
## 25 5 2058514 1871575 1961324 83874427015 156428286722 45892587062
## 26 6 2492470 2095351 2287724 131097356477 157391944045 62399150041
## 27 7 2693570 3037439 2795978 76188196052 158550391135 47288817153
## 28 71 2239970 2266304 2193469 188289808885 154707068007 68200034071
## 29 72 1850260 2032304 1853674 207324621400 154221888565 62880217295
## 30 73 3437453 3062068 3175279 261062860658 155706547514 89154744177
## 31 74 2225857 2041748 2141631 82092286992 154646956895 49273764136
## 32 75 1787210 2111090 1854849 111059477662 154325209522 54030232559
## 33 76 2104429 1949337 1971738 182747167146 154244959907 66706871558
## 34 77 2184151 2179412 2105502 219245561388 154306076011 72006025769
## 35 78 7003672 6950964 6955837 713049902144 158367753080 124405649465
## 36 79 2079220 1963674 2002274 99833494950 154408251856 50850449784
## 37 8 1954082 1726467 1854891 77807965279 156200873353 44737624228
## 38 9 2275690 2218162 2241990 64497901700 159095599550 40094034411
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 34127.81 108157.47 22442.99 2.6530441
## 2 36404.00 59900.78 20224.12 1.6673176
## 3 40505.52 91576.98 22974.37 2.3219443
## 4 30681.84 76537.20 19913.03 2.9487653
## 5 39345.16 110726.08 23988.35 2.1334774
## 6 30486.48 60584.27 18410.32 1.9075745
## 7 79033.91 32625.55 20894.70 0.3698924
## 8 29341.92 60898.49 18212.80 1.9478107
## 9 29786.90 69589.69 19105.59 2.5229312
## 10 32618.79 92788.93 22036.53 2.5554210
## 11 29430.29 69827.39 18809.07 2.7350448
## 12 36957.39 109091.31 24829.93 2.5094729
## 13 58813.39 103910.88 32366.28 1.2228868
## 14 36289.49 84984.91 22031.76 2.4961572
## 15 27114.35 86441.45 19344.57 2.7680564
## 16 29957.10 61814.22 18430.17 2.4125618
## 17 50393.47 59243.27 21556.49 1.0003475
## 18 51357.26 42452.04 21435.75 0.7655794
## 19 24781.73 70214.37 17348.15 3.0384800
## 20 28133.52 117369.09 19734.85 2.8435215
## 21 35790.52 83097.09 22349.45 2.5656862
## 22 41056.78 77029.99 21681.34 1.7460973
## 23 51480.52 83571.75 26244.14 1.4993910
## 24 57062.46 64509.74 24380.89 1.0346293
## 25 37690.59 83559.18 22841.79 1.8650296
## 26 49739.73 75154.48 26769.92 1.2005730
## 27 27509.22 52612.76 16728.23 2.0810362
## 28 75482.23 68046.80 30147.96 0.8216433
## 29 91661.67 75729.86 32387.83 0.7438667
## 30 71546.48 50595.02 27602.37 0.5964332
## 31 35700.41 75536.43 22735.17 1.8838184
## 32 56392.73 72923.67 28034.47 1.3895726
## 33 75696.99 79011.95 32835.90 0.8440348
## 34 84396.32 70589.72 32832.12 0.7038048
## 35 99523.17 22795.71 17823.60 0.2220991
## 36 44541.03 78495.37 24760.40 1.5466578
## 37 36969.47 90641.02 23366.26 2.0075178
## 38 27382.84 72405.19 17582.53 2.4666787
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.6010379
## 2 0.5456181
## 3 0.5282742
## 4 0.6597290
## 5 0.5377449
## 6 0.5854926
## 7 0.2411077
## 8 0.5933874
## 9 0.6384387
## 10 0.6378683
## 11 0.6498620
## 12 0.6265043
## 13 0.4476242
## 14 0.5970377
## 15 0.6789941
## 16 0.6381512
## 17 0.3787676
## 18 0.3939815
## 19 0.7068676
## 20 0.6222271
## 21 0.6293202
## 22 0.5091898
## 23 0.4575368
## 24 0.3792857
## 25 0.5471583
## 26 0.4759757
## 27 0.6206843
## 28 0.3622078
## 29 0.3032935
## 30 0.3415068
## 31 0.6002240
## 32 0.4864982
## 33 0.3650227
## 34 0.3284264
## 35 0.1744698
## 36 0.5093526
## 37 0.5749749
## 38 0.6216332Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_3_0.05 <- mean(res_srs2_0.05$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_3_0.05 <- mean(res_srs2_0.05$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_3_0.05## [1] 1.790496rt_com_3_0.05## [1] 0.5156704 2. Metode One stage cluster
a. f = 100%res_1sc2_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com Relatif MSE dir
## 1 1 1637409 1484546 1637409 0 53757885490 0 0
## 2 10 2452226 2656398 2452226 0 47147642278 0 0
## 3 11 1432925 1736676 1432925 0 52258061800 0 0
## 4 12 1628141 2070386 1628141 0 51433987269 0 0
## 5 13 1660654 1452773 1660654 0 50739021079 0 0
## 6 14 2677707 2617885 2677707 0 48363946648 0 0
## 7 15 5059790 4863519 5059790 0 47676545298 0 0
## 8 16 2702258 2596479 2702258 0 51495764637 0 0
## 9 17 2063216 2280593 2063216 0 50522845707 0 0
## 10 18 1802921 1720645 1802921 0 51413342911 0 0
## 11 19 1893080 2266122 1893080 0 52238481449 0 0
## 12 2 1631372 1473225 1631372 0 52199242895 0 0
## 13 20 1933963 1539654 1933963 0 52927024662 0 0
## 14 21 1543883 1871616 1543883 0 51639003528 0 0
## 15 22 2024290 1859814 2024290 0 49791054445 0 0
## 16 23 2145480 2562473 2145480 0 50544580026 0 0
## 17 24 2721467 2698896 2721467 0 50587970809 0 0
## 18 25 3923463 3722909 3923463 0 50803367638 0 0
## 19 26 2049321 2256961 2049321 0 52413770351 0 0
## 20 27 1850200 1379119 1850200 0 52179584690 0 0
## 21 28 1632444 1899669 1632444 0 52199242895 0 0
## 22 29 1945828 2049705 1945828 0 50566288393 0 0
## 23 3 1794553 1899490 1794553 0 52238481449 0 0
## 24 4 2297582 2449242 2297582 0 51351254126 0 0
## 25 5 2083579 1902456 2083579 0 50781944736 0 0
## 26 6 2526531 2124414 2526531 0 48194003740 0 0
## 27 7 2716794 3050885 2716794 0 45082946891 0 0
## 28 71 2297609 2314435 2297609 0 55404347708 0 0
## 29 72 1872873 2081921 1872873 0 56707316863 0 0
## 30 73 3484448 3097221 3484448 0 52720204779 0 0
## 31 74 2197198 2088987 2197198 0 55565778548 0 0
## 32 75 1867766 2160606 1867766 0 56429844225 0 0
## 33 76 2088732 1998934 2088732 0 56645357835 0 0
## 34 77 2275392 2228054 2275392 0 56481228047 0 0
## 35 78 7020112 6960868 7020112 0 45573428827 0 0
## 36 79 2178314 2012520 2178314 0 56206830653 0 0
## 37 8 2025630 1758243 2025630 0 51392672600 0 0
## 38 9 2279804 2230617 2279804 0 43618767484 0 0
## Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn Efisiensi_com
## 1 36211.67 0 Inf NaN
## 2 17748.71 0 Inf NaN
## 3 30090.85 0 Inf NaN
## 4 24842.70 0 Inf NaN
## 5 34925.63 0 Inf NaN
## 6 18474.43 0 Inf NaN
## 7 9802.89 0 Inf NaN
## 8 19832.92 0 Inf NaN
## 9 22153.38 0 Inf NaN
## 10 29880.28 0 Inf NaN
## 11 23051.93 0 Inf NaN
## 12 35431.95 0 Inf NaN
## 13 34375.92 0 Inf NaN
## 14 27590.60 0 Inf NaN
## 15 26772.07 0 Inf NaN
## 16 19724.92 0 Inf NaN
## 17 18743.95 0 Inf NaN
## 18 13646.15 0 Inf NaN
## 19 23223.17 0 Inf NaN
## 20 37835.45 0 Inf NaN
## 21 27478.07 0 Inf NaN
## 22 24670.03 0 Inf NaN
## 23 27501.31 0 Inf NaN
## 24 20966.18 0 Inf NaN
## 25 26692.84 0 Inf NaN
## 26 22685.79 0 Inf NaN
## 27 14777.01 0 Inf NaN
## 28 23938.60 0 Inf NaN
## 29 27237.97 0 Inf NaN
## 30 17021.78 0 Inf NaN
## 31 26599.39 0 Inf NaN
## 32 26117.60 0 Inf NaN
## 33 28337.79 0 Inf NaN
## 34 25350.03 0 Inf NaN
## 35 6547.09 0 Inf NaN
## 36 27928.58 0 Inf NaN
## 37 29229.57 0 Inf NaN
## 38 19554.58 0 Inf NaNRata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_1 <- mean(res_1sc2_1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_1 <- mean(res_1sc2_1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_1## [1] Infrt_com_4_1## [1] NaN b. f = 90%res_1sc2_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1630245 1476800 1627500 967558390 54211890757 950311909
## 2 10 2451728 2645514 2455333 905334100 47826371464 888315670
## 3 11 1427724 1726411 1432333 828155147 52763055547 815182973
## 4 12 1633745 2055681 1641365 953912648 51966996515 936519444
## 5 13 1647670 1445834 1645306 602279355 51295656616 595176950
## 6 14 2672073 2605765 2670306 1310790998 49001325967 1276341177
## 7 15 5047244 4837242 5015413 8365042828 48337293731 7114493447
## 8 16 2698089 2583709 2696219 853738513 52026673680 839839741
## 9 17 2046559 2270266 2050351 886135802 51086830410 870820621
## 10 18 1804629 1712994 1803569 601033201 51947053989 594101858
## 11 19 1880520 2252404 1885823 761998543 52744140857 751040990
## 12 2 1625254 1466822 1622626 882128747 52706236268 867489192
## 13 20 1907960 1530587 1899927 1155305219 53409276136 1130644426
## 14 21 1545187 1860751 1549733 763535367 52165042977 752383239
## 15 22 2021562 1852325 2018643 874676752 50379917355 859606636
## 16 23 2128727 2549428 2137959 1145093996 51107825842 1119773486
## 17 24 2693096 2687735 2692948 1144501812 51149741498 1119196151
## 18 25 3899411 3702676 3877112 6399992446 51357815628 5681484342
## 19 26 2035556 2238883 2040521 1327597596 52913470581 1294786128
## 20 27 1837456 1366614 1830061 837325480 52687246370 824132135
## 21 28 1620293 1883507 1626177 1207763233 52706236268 1180411864
## 22 29 1932028 2034917 1935103 1585722629 51128796205 1536575140
## 23 3 1780090 1887342 1782957 1487842337 52744140857 1446428484
## 24 4 2293830 2435606 2297596 1434998078 51887075994 1395868027
## 25 5 2066918 1892869 2063449 1032472440 51337121027 1011893489
## 26 6 2506349 2115166 2493136 1680635216 48837160492 1623505355
## 27 7 2710464 3044015 2718221 1085552196 45831868116 1060132686
## 28 71 2297885 2297114 2297741 2149882186 55802379324 2069068798
## 29 72 1860215 2065059 1867136 2046520226 57061052327 1973977262
## 30 73 3471490 3075500 3441968 4263288906 53209487368 3945086316
## 31 74 2179834 2072384 2178355 775303856 55958322111 764616093
## 32 75 1837016 2143781 1846526 1840192276 56793012737 1780636351
## 33 76 2077261 1982692 2074985 1377032941 57001199678 1344254907
## 34 77 2239860 2210460 2238191 2964797107 56842649698 2815757233
## 35 78 6962747 6913278 6947911 18591946422 46305675473 13202833835
## 36 79 2136666 1996717 2134359 938536049 56577580805 923077647
## 37 8 2025481 1750504 2021024 848303426 51927086393 834545440
## 38 9 2262540 2226052 2261280 1412869912 44417465415 1368008788
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 592.8180 36716.495 583.2604 56.029581
## 2 369.1794 18076.821 361.7093 52.827317
## 3 579.5465 30563.817 568.6381 63.711559
## 4 583.5449 25280.007 570.2493 54.477731
## 5 365.3001 35487.023 361.5194 85.169210
## 6 490.4941 18804.414 477.9233 37.383020
## 7 1654.8052 9991.448 1416.8101 5.778487
## 8 316.3809 20134.961 311.4479 60.939823
## 9 432.6223 22501.718 424.3643 57.651243
## 10 332.9503 30327.003 329.3066 86.429591
## 11 405.0057 23416.295 398.0608 69.218165
## 12 542.5369 35937.955 534.4044 59.748916
## 13 605.2005 34898.491 594.8010 46.229581
## 14 493.7047 28036.266 485.0714 68.320402
## 15 432.5348 27201.468 425.7036 57.598327
## 16 537.7700 20045.603 523.6121 44.631992
## 17 424.8307 19032.357 415.4666 44.691709
## 18 1638.8293 13869.346 1463.5612 8.024668
## 19 651.8279 23636.820 634.1806 39.856558
## 20 455.4352 38567.438 450.0800 62.923257
## 21 744.9316 27987.896 725.4468 43.639544
## 22 818.8873 25141.340 792.2850 32.243215
## 23 834.7718 27946.791 810.2713 35.450087
## 24 624.9891 21302.921 606.9688 36.158290
## 25 499.1212 27121.860 490.0103 49.722510
## 26 669.4820 23089.843 650.2465 29.058751
## 27 400.4071 15054.982 389.9132 42.219866
## 28 934.4853 24291.609 899.4761 25.956017
## 29 1097.6514 27631.744 1054.9240 27.881988
## 30 1227.5031 17301.108 1145.6856 12.480854
## 31 355.6530 27002.126 350.9894 72.175988
## 32 999.7080 26491.687 962.3536 30.862543
## 33 662.5509 28749.926 647.5061 41.394216
## 34 1321.5299 25714.955 1256.1884 19.172526
## 35 2665.6955 6698.905 1898.0318 2.490631
## 36 438.9071 28335.742 432.1540 60.282800
## 37 418.5637 29666.115 412.6924 61.212869
## 38 623.3980 19952.737 603.9832 31.437760
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9821753
## 2 0.9812020
## 3 0.9843361
## 4 0.9817665
## 5 0.9882075
## 6 0.9737183
## 7 0.8505029
## 8 0.9837201
## 9 0.9827169
## 10 0.9884676
## 11 0.9856200
## 12 0.9834043
## 13 0.9786543
## 14 0.9853941
## 15 0.9827706
## 16 0.9778878
## 17 0.9778894
## 18 0.8877330
## 19 0.9752851
## 20 0.9842435
## 21 0.9773537
## 22 0.9690063
## 23 0.9721652
## 24 0.9727316
## 25 0.9800683
## 26 0.9660070
## 27 0.9765838
## 28 0.9624103
## 29 0.9645530
## 30 0.9253622
## 31 0.9862147
## 32 0.9676360
## 33 0.9761966
## 34 0.9497302
## 35 0.7101373
## 36 0.9835292
## 37 0.9837818
## 38 0.9682482Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.9 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.9$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.9 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.9$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.9## [1] 45.14425rt_com_4_0.9## [1] 0.9633529 c. f = 80%res_1sc2_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1624312 1471983 1618351 2199618313 55650683914 2113303149
## 2 10 2457058 2647065 2464544 2028526604 49168770950 1946533492
## 3 11 1405915 1722378 1416021 1809129511 54179977571 1748837690
## 4 12 1625649 2048575 1641989 2148033993 53371901497 2063209326
## 5 13 1663682 1446157 1657925 1402146507 52690427274 1364616952
## 6 14 2648726 2610265 2646503 2875560607 50361462174 2718254695
## 7 15 5067949 4846004 5002602 19337153056 49687405929 13806015389
## 8 16 2695027 2584974 2691153 1925149448 53432479529 1857507074
## 9 17 2053979 2271344 2061648 1948816235 52478448698 1876999193
## 10 18 1805098 1710402 1802679 1363874990 53351657925 1329298653
## 11 19 1870100 2247957 1881650 1709564199 54160777351 1656113883
## 12 2 1614713 1462698 1609203 1989578074 54122300567 1917783334
## 13 20 1920657 1524355 1902604 2592773911 54835953291 2474229051
## 14 21 1542085 1855075 1551712 1702658832 53572937602 1649143209
## 15 22 2023139 1854560 2016886 1937416554 51760864319 1865840051
## 16 23 2135366 2551040 2154822 2579077629 52499761070 2456056909
## 17 24 2714173 2701232 2713422 2616127325 52542309471 2490194910
## 18 25 3901898 3711873 3860037 14077719994 52753524619 11047195878
## 19 26 2024313 2232910 2035041 2983561101 54332663220 2824867177
## 20 27 1827896 1361733 1812019 1897236946 54103024004 1832132279
## 21 28 1603463 1877174 1616149 2651155935 54122300567 2524883280
## 22 29 1944249 2031043 1949710 3625216768 52521047994 3379233146
## 23 3 1769095 1880219 1775420 3365118156 54160777351 3164344833
## 24 4 2298987 2432988 2306337 3240001926 53290774522 3049625716
## 25 5 2075718 1888985 2067615 2332452614 52732517618 2231641041
## 26 6 2495695 2111690 2467755 3836790637 50194818512 3554934331
## 27 7 2716348 3057822 2733469 2461214769 47144159244 2335680595
## 28 71 2299056 2288740 2297863 4888146413 57265181967 4493728493
## 29 72 1847757 2054437 1862373 4622309488 58542855478 4271617350
## 30 73 3420435 3067250 3368154 9351140694 54633148577 7966530622
## 31 74 2159206 2062445 2156318 1743723932 57423478814 1691658081
## 32 75 1842447 2134223 1860327 4021511489 58270769652 3740309248
## 33 76 2064658 1971926 2059870 3051573568 58482099314 2897338516
## 34 77 2226812 2200171 2222894 6503347937 58321155916 5826602409
## 35 78 6965679 6908238 6937840 41447865320 47625119039 21929620245
## 36 79 2153013 1986514 2146885 2164382683 58052085631 2085047753
## 37 8 2018219 1748766 2008890 1879192901 53331388905 1814089716
## 38 9 2273591 2230957 2270277 3250183872 45708405191 3021044307
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 1350.9484 37828.684 1302.9709 25.300155
## 2 825.0495 18574.568 789.3271 24.238662
## 3 1282.5568 31458.493 1230.9911 29.948092
## 4 1319.1956 26054.684 1254.5624 24.846861
## 5 841.7022 36452.968 822.1070 37.578404
## 6 1085.1662 19292.427 1026.7119 17.513615
## 7 3804.0089 10254.023 2754.6067 2.569531
## 8 714.1624 20669.361 690.0681 27.754977
## 9 946.9244 23102.700 908.6839 26.928372
## 10 755.0746 31194.266 736.9481 39.117704
## 11 913.0406 24091.962 879.0863 31.681043
## 12 1231.2052 37010.100 1190.9322 27.202904
## 13 1348.2365 35981.352 1298.9667 21.149531
## 14 1102.6825 28878.892 1061.4164 31.464282
## 15 956.3148 27910.513 923.9451 26.716435
## 16 1206.9191 20578.649 1139.0105 20.356022
## 17 963.0585 19455.653 917.0207 20.084003
## 18 3594.5893 14212.659 2854.7055 3.747306
## 19 1472.0844 24335.317 1386.5363 18.210676
## 20 1036.5991 39758.066 1009.8957 28.516746
## 21 1650.8250 28836.289 1559.9864 20.414605
## 22 1855.5713 25877.762 1725.1700 14.487699
## 23 1898.8699 28808.304 1779.4485 16.094762
## 24 1405.8835 21901.520 1319.3104 16.447760
## 25 1121.4501 27917.581 1077.3639 22.608184
## 26 1532.7818 23769.312 1436.9777 13.082501
## 27 905.5324 15422.921 853.9369 19.154834
## 28 2121.3980 25023.073 1951.7355 11.715112
## 29 2492.0100 28499.860 2285.5850 12.665283
## 30 2730.5765 17812.249 2363.1475 5.842405
## 31 807.4201 27846.539 784.3723 32.931520
## 32 2165.1767 27306.581 1994.6446 14.489768
## 33 1476.4304 29662.789 1405.2250 19.164571
## 34 2905.6577 26510.195 2609.8305 8.967866
## 35 5929.7051 6895.327 3155.0645 1.149037
## 36 1003.9985 29228.435 970.0582 26.821544
## 37 929.6190 30504.766 901.6964 28.379944
## 38 1425.1661 20489.412 1326.9973 14.063329
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9607590
## 2 0.9595800
## 3 0.9666736
## 4 0.9605106
## 5 0.9732342
## 6 0.9452956
## 7 0.7139632
## 8 0.9648638
## 9 0.9631484
## 10 0.9746485
## 11 0.9687345
## 12 0.9639146
## 13 0.9542788
## 14 0.9685694
## 15 0.9630557
## 16 0.9523005
## 17 0.9518630
## 18 0.7847291
## 19 0.9468106
## 20 0.9656845
## 21 0.9523707
## 22 0.9321465
## 23 0.9403369
## 24 0.9412419
## 25 0.9567787
## 26 0.9265385
## 27 0.9489950
## 28 0.9193114
## 29 0.9241305
## 30 0.8519314
## 31 0.9701410
## 32 0.9300755
## 33 0.9494572
## 34 0.8959389
## 35 0.5290893
## 36 0.9633452
## 37 0.9653558
## 38 0.9294995Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.8 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.8$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.8 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.8$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.8## [1] 20.61595rt_com_4_0.8## [1] 0.9270869 d. f = 70%res_1sc2_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1608711 1463532 1599641 3690096960 58828513336 3460547034
## 2 10 2450337 2649899 2462722 3477714264 52534126479 3256862653
## 3 11 1432558 1721980 1447580 3209780927 57400355517 3031318040
## 4 12 1626934 2055869 1653455 3727702471 56615657629 3491220038
## 5 13 1640088 1432961 1631859 2210318047 55953898914 2119883473
## 6 14 2668889 2600771 2662811 4945616664 53692312342 4517778088
## 7 15 5064430 4849225 4978375 32496861579 53037756998 19826118977
## 8 16 2700804 2579763 2693771 3353980651 56674483097 3162349986
## 9 17 2032761 2269457 2045861 3363538079 55748053020 3162297334
## 10 18 1806416 1709638 1802458 2332476531 56595999716 2238113824
## 11 19 1878253 2252140 1896134 2896188724 57381710772 2753071763
## 12 2 1621438 1463028 1612313 3383067725 57344347148 3189970389
## 13 20 1913479 1524305 1885607 4407461349 58037353418 4089648368
## 14 21 1543510 1863154 1559182 2937664918 56810877623 2788427483
## 15 22 2013851 1848265 2004094 3310458572 55051228841 3116560002
## 16 23 2114018 2545112 2145241 4354152893 55768748811 4031204994
## 17 24 2692934 2666956 2690783 4493523535 55810066258 4151768613
## 18 25 3865489 3694441 3809684 24652924062 56015170809 16894421111
## 19 26 2032692 2247432 2049676 5064943072 57548623868 4642168374
## 20 27 1831015 1359598 1806028 3170759496 57325628269 2999913491
## 21 28 1625079 1881247 1644330 4722316526 57344347148 4351731272
## 22 29 1914496 2022606 1924595 6025391854 55789419890 5392197227
## 23 3 1791077 1886750 1798990 5809511623 57381710772 5251911040
## 24 4 2302177 2438997 2313382 5512128452 56536877712 4998685067
## 25 5 2049643 1894098 2039039 3874343926 55994771556 3612861108
## 26 6 2516436 2123840 2471525 6593250830 53530489793 5829689987
## 27 7 2701237 3036508 2726723 4111938267 50568088152 3786937807
## 28 71 2306484 2292105 2302924 8316009013 60396302873 7256621067
## 29 72 1828805 2060546 1853398 7800816132 61637012429 6858789482
## 30 73 3472311 3082352 3384103 16681083601 57840415981 12898925837
## 31 74 2184094 2067007 2178535 2965890717 60550020085 2824984876
## 32 75 1843636 2138204 1871111 6851820027 61372798229 6079987782
## 33 76 2043596 1977117 2037996 5179311732 61578013981 4766985430
## 34 77 2237998 2207137 2230662 11524465598 61421726784 9625041426
## 35 78 7040191 6982970 7004335 74252788939 51035133456 29757318646
## 36 79 2158084 1990844 2148335 3662156088 61160440884 3449863369
## 37 8 2029845 1740709 2013613 3297366826 56576317093 3111739180
## 38 9 2270484 2233717 2265676 5337589633 49173871430 4752599980
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 2284.238 40225.251 2155.541 15.942268
## 2 1417.578 19824.823 1320.982 15.105935
## 3 2230.659 33337.137 2085.021 17.882951
## 4 2287.621 27544.533 2108.280 15.187816
## 5 1341.941 39072.102 1294.163 25.314863
## 6 1851.456 20641.144 1695.347 10.856546
## 7 6386.966 10940.365 3973.707 1.632089
## 8 1241.111 21967.409 1173.351 16.897677
## 9 1648.393 24561.368 1540.110 16.574230
## 10 1289.988 33103.430 1240.607 24.264338
## 11 1538.911 25478.242 1449.252 19.812835
## 12 2082.668 39202.637 1975.309 16.950399
## 13 2298.028 38084.848 2164.629 13.167978
## 14 1898.866 30493.431 1784.379 19.338788
## 15 1640.110 29781.859 1551.949 16.629487
## 16 2057.658 21910.521 1877.460 12.808174
## 17 1666.419 20933.995 1541.130 12.420112
## 18 6344.631 15164.158 4420.795 2.272151
## 19 2486.535 25617.142 2260.564 11.362146
## 20 1725.993 42216.209 1656.275 18.079463
## 21 2900.042 30491.339 2641.903 12.143266
## 22 3120.506 27611.865 2779.794 9.259053
## 23 3226.425 30418.893 2905.797 9.877200
## 24 2384.431 23179.142 2152.835 10.256814
## 25 1884.441 29565.566 1767.163 14.452711
## 26 2607.751 25206.711 2350.783 8.118983
## 27 1519.287 16658.126 1386.079 12.297871
## 28 3582.714 26356.734 3134.806 7.262655
## 29 4232.508 29922.072 3674.268 7.901354
## 30 4797.415 18767.596 3807.923 3.467426
## 31 1357.166 29302.625 1296.067 20.415459
## 32 3672.000 28711.227 3211.836 8.957153
## 33 2529.480 31156.537 2335.200 11.889227
## 34 5114.732 27834.993 4292.748 5.329681
## 35 10501.046 7315.234 4242.619 0.687316
## 36 1692.799 30731.453 1602.339 16.700665
## 37 1621.720 32508.564 1543.097 17.158029
## 38 2335.087 22014.790 2085.348 9.212749
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9377930
## 2 0.9364952
## 3 0.9444003
## 4 0.9365608
## 5 0.9590853
## 6 0.9134914
## 7 0.6100933
## 8 0.9428647
## 9 0.9401699
## 10 0.9595440
## 11 0.9505844
## 12 0.9429224
## 13 0.9278921
## 14 0.9491986
## 15 0.9414285
## 16 0.9258299
## 17 0.9239450
## 18 0.6852908
## 19 0.9165292
## 20 0.9461183
## 21 0.9215247
## 22 0.8949123
## 23 0.9040194
## 24 0.9068521
## 25 0.9325091
## 26 0.8841905
## 27 0.9209617
## 28 0.8726086
## 29 0.8792400
## 30 0.7732667
## 31 0.9524912
## 32 0.8873537
## 33 0.9203897
## 34 0.8351833
## 35 0.4007569
## 36 0.9420307
## 37 0.9437043
## 38 0.8904019Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.7 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.7$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.7 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.7$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.7## [1] 12.83915rt_com_4_0.7## [1] 0.8908588 e. f = 60%res_1sc2_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1596830 1462873 1584290 5748600406 61666744264 5216080710
## 2 10 2453780 2640554 2470352 5451677413 56106576433 4950684590
## 3 11 1408747 1717212 1430836 4832188810 60405176245 4440182765
## 4 12 1633631 2045035 1670090 5840302635 59712010722 5296039460
## 5 13 1649960 1435372 1637231 3578287628 59127443932 3355862022
## 6 14 2656859 2600141 2649132 7662383884 57129663816 6718094778
## 7 15 5035380 4836678 4936716 49293215685 56551460148 25760155054
## 8 16 2697008 2576717 2687004 5097493129 59763974397 4684159976
## 9 17 2042885 2265307 2060432 5199922738 58945609269 4756409407
## 10 18 1801417 1705616 1795562 3596638272 59694645839 3383022110
## 11 19 1872032 2244309 1898408 4652618008 60388706347 4307491697
## 12 2 1616706 1459029 1603453 5200698779 60355701063 4768989257
## 13 20 1932066 1519577 1888647 7026459885 60967870486 6280703175
## 14 21 1542516 1853667 1564305 4573931601 59884458962 4232154820
## 15 22 1991569 1849494 1979535 5159586400 58330067283 4723308691
## 16 23 2126017 2542705 2169568 6884341903 58963890965 6140185930
## 17 24 2704546 2683070 2701957 6710087537 59000388871 6000501281
## 18 25 3901931 3697155 3815856 37678785198 59181568668 22484488578
## 19 26 2013663 2233760 2037622 7708170832 60536149592 6787676169
## 20 27 1820780 1355804 1785159 4909417839 60339165678 4522126278
## 21 28 1610098 1873247 1637216 7174828041 60355701063 6375652485
## 22 29 1921270 2021782 1934294 9056570963 58982150833 7695123372
## 23 3 1760780 1876649 1772767 8522545943 60388706347 7390806439
## 24 4 2287032 2429590 2303361 8623147940 59642420217 7479711676
## 25 5 2067625 1884952 2049021 6203672308 59163548918 5578057596
## 26 6 2492687 2110785 2433320 10050757640 56986717323 8434365828
## 27 7 2688002 3039258 2725210 6378923803 54369869855 5660859886
## 28 71 2295948 2282580 2290669 13421204601 63051656432 10913253693
## 29 72 1816565 2049967 1848952 12030466272 64147641398 9935213596
## 30 73 3425704 3064926 3318496 24670414636 60793905138 17406090188
## 31 74 2165353 2057246 2157626 4590980123 63187443050 4267865276
## 32 75 1831418 2128692 1869881 10585275364 63914246894 8859975752
## 33 76 2033239 1967128 2024703 7990667945 64095524920 7065085385
## 34 77 2239629 2195800 2225169 17124777211 63957468098 13275130390
## 35 78 6986886 6925236 6943981 112772563787 54782435897 36136727411
## 36 79 2161281 1981300 2146007 5593024783 63726660318 5117087293
## 37 8 2020501 1739305 1997688 5092042994 59677259127 4674941316
## 38 9 2275306 2225128 2265934 8541603621 53138283818 7191877425
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 3572.626 42234.882 3271.856 10.727262
## 2 2218.569 21249.541 2001.420 10.291617
## 3 3399.819 35194.076 3076.988 12.500583
## 4 3560.198 29212.666 3159.147 10.224130
## 5 2160.248 41282.325 2043.404 16.523949
## 6 2878.932 21969.836 2532.486 7.455860
## 7 9726.245 11690.716 5204.017 1.147246
## 8 1887.869 23191.960 1741.630 11.724189
## 9 2536.785 26017.436 2301.334 11.335863
## 10 1992.722 35009.467 1880.993 16.597345
## 11 2477.203 26903.952 2262.308 12.979511
## 12 3203.939 41394.508 2964.243 11.605306
## 13 3626.535 40156.073 3318.304 8.676897
## 14 2952.045 32308.760 2693.902 13.092557
## 15 2582.231 31536.061 2379.304 11.305183
## 16 3232.288 23187.502 2825.758 8.564928
## 17 2474.707 22007.190 2215.992 8.792790
## 18 9569.181 16008.440 5866.991 1.570687
## 19 3812.626 27111.711 3319.847 7.853504
## 20 2684.807 44643.022 2524.528 12.290493
## 21 4435.408 32247.771 3879.561 8.412146
## 22 4651.222 29252.614 3931.154 6.512636
## 23 4793.695 32197.958 4136.648 7.085759
## 24 3750.675 24543.170 3233.167 6.916548
## 25 2987.343 31403.558 2713.115 9.536859
## 26 4013.255 27000.997 3457.482 5.669893
## 27 2367.361 17906.505 2072.429 8.523361
## 28 5799.432 27638.678 4736.194 4.697913
## 29 6535.175 31312.697 5314.273 5.332099
## 30 7174.905 19835.424 5234.576 2.464243
## 31 2117.809 30736.148 1976.254 13.763389
## 32 5701.549 30044.044 4677.419 6.038033
## 33 3911.193 32609.233 3475.602 8.021298
## 34 7560.930 29141.792 5920.035 3.734791
## 35 16028.639 7907.884 5189.636 0.485778
## 36 2576.112 32189.520 2375.540 11.393953
## 37 2515.062 34349.197 2336.594 11.719708
## 38 3718.149 23891.740 3149.963 6.221113
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.9073653
## 2 0.9081030
## 3 0.9188761
## 4 0.9068091
## 5 0.9378402
## 6 0.8767630
## 7 0.5225903
## 8 0.9189144
## 9 0.9147077
## 10 0.9406067
## 11 0.9258211
## 12 0.9169901
## 13 0.8938645
## 14 0.9252772
## 15 0.9154433
## 16 0.8919060
## 17 0.8942508
## 18 0.5967413
## 19 0.8805820
## 20 0.9211125
## 21 0.8886140
## 22 0.8496730
## 23 0.8672064
## 24 0.8673992
## 25 0.8991541
## 26 0.8391771
## 27 0.8874318
## 28 0.8131352
## 29 0.8258378
## 30 0.7055451
## 31 0.9296196
## 32 0.8370095
## 33 0.8841671
## 34 0.7752002
## 35 0.3204390
## 36 0.9149052
## 37 0.9180876
## 38 0.8419821Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.6 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.6$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.6 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.6$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.6## [1] 8.731301rt_com_4_0.6## [1] 0.8520829 f. f = 50%res_1sc2_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1632835 1484396 1613201 9149275272 67311267052 7948070392
## 2 10 2442102 2658680 2466708 7982011652 60858805820 6992421633
## 3 11 1436098 1734481 1466663 7720659809 65847243127 6846585626
## 4 12 1622028 2069503 1671054 8223150817 65042838691 7221189479
## 5 13 1658700 1455429 1641716 5267253894 64364460868 4807581210
## 6 14 2680381 2616552 2668716 11553496906 62046077838 9662938225
## 7 15 5049364 4865599 4938295 75538502109 61375084288 32841791663
## 8 16 2704944 2594129 2692447 7696106400 65103141475 6847774518
## 9 17 2051418 2278097 2074119 7775100723 64153445455 6856226160
## 10 18 1789562 1717167 1783542 5336973548 65022687099 4910048163
## 11 19 1885847 2261112 1921024 6893154128 65828130146 6193962187
## 12 2 1630842 1468403 1612471 7834424327 65789828189 6949914399
## 13 20 1929203 1536348 1872919 10634835530 66500238303 9088597489
## 14 21 1541598 1866919 1572280 6992767358 65242961352 6258300391
## 15 22 2006537 1851819 1988688 7553923526 63439121549 6696909296
## 16 23 2139990 2559908 2197780 10297389336 64174660990 8783194497
## 17 24 2730352 2695276 2724411 10411215457 64217016065 8893352334
## 18 25 3931271 3721743 3824907 56823637116 64427271519 29219017843
## 19 26 2040098 2252817 2071120 12181761255 65999235021 10154976073
## 20 27 1851796 1380423 1803166 7406626495 65770639212 6613740995
## 21 28 1635279 1896860 1671101 11001886098 65789828189 9322529043
## 22 29 1930172 2041215 1947762 13383817835 64195851193 10696817390
## 23 3 1785951 1898597 1801648 13275318879 65828130146 10889033626
## 24 4 2289779 2445629 2311009 12587035083 64962080331 10381621248
## 25 5 2087316 1902848 2060778 9800476889 64406359967 8407974252
## 26 6 2531720 2122752 2442357 16310014002 61880191351 12614490978
## 27 7 2719634 3062810 2767909 9586691380 58843393300 8103835657
## 28 71 2304420 2313967 2299269 19363750966 68918429344 14690811281
## 29 72 1868184 2080171 1903761 18943411549 70190297517 14289160232
## 30 73 3496997 3093098 3345317 38993407097 66298355069 24224278103
## 31 74 2193982 2087575 2183312 7046233853 69076006941 6357070891
## 32 75 1857099 2159343 1907501 17023642203 69919447961 13052391409
## 33 76 2072897 1997407 2060241 11976143554 70129817409 10126699458
## 34 77 2302002 2226120 2273553 29039513066 69969605286 20063945356
## 35 78 7010166 6951603 6963500 171393204556 59322167767 42828876146
## 36 79 2176669 2011265 2156973 8745647098 69701757570 7716448412
## 37 8 2029909 1759446 1999560 7845808231 65002510175 6949846857
## 38 9 2308347 2235983 2289253 14377199825 57414162852 11045050025
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 5545.196 45496.965 4887.056 7.3570053
## 2 3255.867 22890.558 2825.438 7.6244947
## 3 5335.778 37982.787 4635.937 8.5287067
## 4 5023.250 31433.200 4286.790 7.9097222
## 5 3141.983 44366.504 2904.133 12.2197377
## 6 4302.623 23697.262 3615.997 5.3703289
## 7 14824.919 12594.038 6626.661 0.8125007
## 8 2843.400 25079.906 2542.015 8.4592310
## 9 3760.162 28146.311 3282.850 8.2511401
## 10 2975.198 37894.851 2747.360 12.1834381
## 11 3637.933 29095.275 3209.919 9.5497836
## 12 4784.870 44880.111 4297.130 8.3975319
## 13 5482.503 43349.612 4834.136 6.2530575
## 14 4499.833 34950.837 3951.487 9.3300632
## 15 3739.404 34241.313 3349.138 8.3981684
## 16 4793.961 25050.016 3983.178 6.2321292
## 17 3800.182 23822.199 3255.099 6.1680614
## 18 14282.295 17290.164 7597.206 1.1338111
## 19 5932.033 29278.721 4876.796 5.4178730
## 20 3972.433 47774.209 3648.475 8.8799724
## 21 6681.356 34690.752 5547.726 5.9798681
## 22 6812.275 31551.892 5410.770 4.7965276
## 23 7362.256 34695.560 6001.455 4.9586854
## 24 5447.706 26543.630 4462.155 5.1610312
## 25 4662.435 33877.596 4059.482 6.5717578
## 26 6403.429 29166.932 5150.599 3.7939999
## 27 3509.611 19236.888 2917.409 6.1380294
## 28 8273.735 29788.095 6321.426 3.5591466
## 29 9916.151 33755.064 7373.495 3.7052617
## 30 11101.486 21424.221 7220.627 1.7002452
## 31 3203.388 33103.491 2905.836 9.8032521
## 32 8981.224 32390.182 6720.418 4.1071968
## 33 5747.393 35132.152 4895.933 5.8557930
## 34 12485.621 31435.562 8769.958 2.4094621
## 35 24160.139 8521.921 6123.326 0.3461174
## 36 3995.768 34678.523 3561.714 7.9698800
## 37 3847.904 37018.154 3464.184 8.2849986
## 38 6135.435 25714.851 4771.373 3.9934176
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.8687104
## 2 0.8760225
## 3 0.8867876
## 4 0.8781536
## 5 0.9127301
## 6 0.8363648
## 7 0.4347689
## 8 0.8897713
## 9 0.8818183
## 10 0.9200061
## 11 0.8985672
## 12 0.8870996
## 13 0.8546063
## 14 0.8949676
## 15 0.8865471
## 16 0.8529535
## 17 0.8542088
## 18 0.5142053
## 19 0.8336213
## 20 0.8929492
## 21 0.8473573
## 22 0.7992351
## 23 0.8202465
## 24 0.8247869
## 25 0.8579148
## 26 0.7734200
## 27 0.8453214
## 28 0.7586759
## 29 0.7543076
## 30 0.6212404
## 31 0.9021941
## 32 0.7667214
## 33 0.8455727
## 34 0.6909188
## 35 0.2498867
## 36 0.8823187
## 37 0.8858038
## 38 0.7682337Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.5 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.5$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.5 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.5$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.5## [1] 6.252932rt_com_4_0.5## [1] 0.806553 g. f = 40%res_1sc2_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1627819 1457220 1595372 13661967555 70765623874 11117887018
## 2 10 2461838 2629777 2487128 12296877279 64512621437 10185643686
## 3 11 1419674 1713898 1457486 11237745018 69346855927 9425277573
## 4 12 1606572 2040026 1669603 12232130719 68567317281 10201551303
## 5 13 1635850 1435009 1613030 7918258386 67909909506 6925736274
## 6 14 2644197 2591303 2631741 16963951147 65663192444 13335316127
## 7 15 5017904 4816432 4872943 107175050073 65012940679 38503781830
## 8 16 2705339 2566454 2684114 11771003943 68625755982 9965988628
## 9 17 2013291 2258388 2046783 11715566013 67705417011 9805512618
## 10 18 1793140 1700617 1782413 8046523741 68547788616 7143816850
## 11 19 1878358 2236471 1922730 10141971305 69328333768 8740602541
## 12 2 1616477 1455015 1590893 11868938909 69291215802 10011041560
## 13 20 1878523 1515214 1809093 15499838106 69979665685 12504501268
## 14 21 1522444 1848831 1561500 9781414904 68761253740 8434200468
## 15 22 2025466 1846072 1996066 11763347876 67013174320 9838010065
## 16 23 2108607 2533650 2185096 15308600581 67725976731 12308867731
## 17 24 2678137 2676007 2676215 15937303428 67767022523 12718257240
## 18 25 3878452 3683325 3755690 89500331110 67970778550 36887225092
## 19 26 2018850 2233731 2059747 17549488451 69494149441 13710314556
## 20 27 1834772 1361079 1766629 11319350788 69272619996 9583159051
## 21 28 1629138 1872864 1674254 17008645370 69291215802 13458645651
## 22 29 1909741 2013384 1928671 20497924779 67746511901 14788519754
## 23 3 1750773 1871027 1770978 19758797405 69328333768 14952931346
## 24 4 2284572 2421378 2308705 19116386793 68489055327 14500748156
## 25 5 2049203 1879784 2018195 13857019176 67950513418 11336134757
## 26 6 2503678 2103505 2391830 23564940218 65502433848 16580546020
## 27 7 2698824 3025619 2761642 14763088671 62559509446 11666244193
## 28 71 2293864 2273770 2276290 30341244726 72323105488 20391414459
## 29 72 1857247 2042539 1897491 28982832643 73555657610 19840266123
## 30 73 3410397 3050337 3245486 55793685578 69784023076 30365181127
## 31 74 2157622 2049713 2143899 10300082065 72475812038 8940132690
## 32 75 1791985 2120565 1859499 24442831808 73293180569 16893434076
## 33 76 2079564 1959910 2052958 18525023450 73497047066 14581245162
## 34 77 2210053 2187290 2191285 38559658656 73341787428 24389850504
## 35 78 6957154 6896767 6903936 262564863669 63023484014 49296479869
## 36 79 2092725 1973719 2071743 12766347717 73082219434 10681813373
## 37 8 2014224 1732895 1970115 11603367125 68528235402 9770460516
## 38 9 2235646 2218540 2223813 18173537620 61174459439 12938736907
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 8244.350 48752.658 6887.680 5.1797535
## 2 4975.901 24525.706 4083.798 5.2462605
## 3 7799.467 40490.499 6383.751 6.1708871
## 4 7525.748 33606.447 6050.885 5.6055089
## 5 4777.923 47477.546 4254.573 8.5763695
## 6 6403.725 25337.171 5060.605 3.8707487
## 7 20994.948 13488.050 7856.030 0.6066052
## 8 4351.147 26741.105 3713.435 5.8300682
## 9 5763.758 29982.695 4752.461 5.7790991
## 10 4467.386 40368.547 3993.918 8.5189320
## 11 5368.412 30999.789 4524.129 6.8357848
## 12 7281.371 47768.059 6255.435 5.8380295
## 13 8171.598 46272.772 6869.662 4.5148643
## 14 6354.523 37221.047 5348.138 7.0297860
## 15 5761.753 36378.684 4901.405 5.6967774
## 16 7226.562 26730.122 5614.130 4.4240475
## 17 5921.521 25396.337 4736.365 4.2521009
## 18 22696.452 18455.667 9776.481 0.7594472
## 19 8619.476 31131.746 6611.549 3.9598960
## 20 6098.801 51055.021 5382.556 6.1198404
## 21 10357.749 37011.073 7994.478 4.0738821
## 22 10449.586 33758.764 7511.908 3.3050425
## 23 11115.809 37066.795 8352.518 3.5087325
## 24 8281.224 28277.294 6234.722 3.5827406
## 25 6710.745 36167.548 5587.467 4.9036891
## 26 9261.660 31162.320 6886.000 2.7796563
## 27 5447.057 20706.506 4208.397 4.2375624
## 28 12947.966 31811.898 8847.943 2.3836565
## 29 15277.657 36022.442 10307.443 2.5379044
## 30 16208.066 22869.364 9313.463 1.2507513
## 31 4768.287 35369.860 4165.929 7.0364305
## 32 13285.103 34573.570 8885.216 2.9985552
## 33 8867.682 37519.264 7083.138 3.9674469
## 34 17193.080 33533.974 11034.569 1.9020341
## 35 37085.496 9139.148 7116.678 0.2400302
## 36 6041.083 37047.991 5121.515 5.7245988
## 37 5695.723 39622.634 4920.575 5.9058922
## 38 7921.615 27598.978 5722.606 3.3661283
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.8137837
## 2 0.8283114
## 3 0.8387161
## 4 0.8339963
## 5 0.8746540
## 6 0.7860973
## 7 0.3592607
## 8 0.8466558
## 9 0.8369645
## 10 0.8878141
## 11 0.8618248
## 12 0.8434656
## 13 0.8067504
## 14 0.8622679
## 15 0.8363274
## 16 0.8040492
## 17 0.7980181
## 18 0.4121462
## 19 0.7812373
## 20 0.8466174
## 21 0.7912826
## 22 0.7214642
## 23 0.7567734
## 24 0.7585507
## 25 0.8180789
## 26 0.7036108
## 27 0.7902306
## 28 0.6720691
## 29 0.6845523
## 30 0.5442405
## 31 0.8679671
## 32 0.6911406
## 33 0.7871108
## 34 0.6325225
## 35 0.1877497
## 36 0.8367165
## 37 0.8420367
## 38 0.7119548Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.4 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.4$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.4 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.4$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.4## [1] 4.434725rt_com_4_0.4## [1] 0.7515003 h. f = 30%res_1sc2_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1607855 1458025 1572202 21047867931 83349892103 16047936047
## 2 10 2477012 2635120 2505397 19649179977 76940084609 15308838075
## 3 11 1369103 1702713 1418334 16347459322 81895546049 13110184079
## 4 12 1635767 2024828 1707654 19996988398 81096459097 15642809530
## 5 13 1642527 1425976 1607657 13430816149 80422565664 11054134955
## 6 14 2623778 2596654 2612086 26346672526 78119508212 19167808365
## 7 15 5098079 4844026 4896091 186569027264 77452950238 50950275200
## 8 16 2725487 2576611 2696411 18081815026 81156363252 14526421405
## 9 17 2030838 2259080 2067230 18325335545 80212945159 14434027882
## 10 18 1825502 1695525 1805304 13116683423 81076440716 11125375674
## 11 19 1819960 2232123 1881298 15377931362 81876559414 12671523976
## 12 2 1590499 1446695 1558473 18439144198 81838510650 14604538633
## 13 20 1893050 1506406 1798887 24442030583 82544224627 18380525625
## 14 21 1533499 1835180 1579967 15976789445 81295258855 13053356125
## 15 22 2017257 1841597 1978086 19613808658 79503343263 15316520399
## 16 23 2108991 2540435 2202432 24218577372 80234020450 18159427740
## 17 24 2676310 2700212 2677759 23421977845 80276095538 17732412106
## 18 25 3916200 3708754 3758937 137058968422 80484961107 46841246390
## 19 26 1987171 2200790 2035451 26939252828 82046533207 19669303250
## 20 27 1783670 1327166 1698444 18137083065 81819448521 14462699001
## 21 28 1592698 1841508 1646840 25350413476 81838510650 18803627531
## 22 29 1912693 1991006 1929018 31825897313 80255070576 20455273934
## 23 3 1739438 1859849 1757957 30599903497 81876559414 21191220421
## 24 4 2307529 2416594 2326992 30584240182 81016234587 21391383616
## 25 5 2060692 1870152 2013971 21059443056 80464187790 16159755311
## 26 6 2456396 2094479 2334201 35988855623 77954718311 23113489617
## 27 7 2689763 3060472 2775840 23314744912 74937994893 16959106809
## 28 71 2306957 2270559 2277795 45369508545 84946430312 27725785153
## 29 72 1865543 2033541 1900125 47274809907 86209890851 27857082539
## 30 73 3373017 3043822 3193203 89248650788 82343675934 41642552813
## 31 74 2105539 2041372 2093857 15586025434 85102966248 12907674112
## 32 75 1780481 2115122 1840506 33369440130 85940831735 20996777751
## 33 76 2031371 1951186 2003387 28844716989 86149810545 20854211884
## 34 77 2195552 2179510 2170999 62616938813 85990657498 33851081900
## 35 78 6913568 6867905 6869661 388979749951 75413604441 60151171561
## 36 79 2125819 1966713 2091987 19296351628 85724580378 15317730336
## 37 8 2046008 1735026 1981967 19253686511 81056397171 15175165145
## 38 9 2249658 2218546 2223479 29539666318 73518212316 18218771067
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 12748.928 57599.74 10041.515 3.9600159
## 2 7878.478 29206.32 6081.498 3.9156893
## 3 11652.186 48146.73 9054.746 5.0096804
## 4 12075.937 40044.43 9080.071 4.0554336
## 5 7975.010 56812.04 6766.839 5.9879135
## 6 9991.638 30100.96 7317.392 2.9650616
## 7 35591.156 15993.84 10342.099 0.4151437
## 8 6629.496 31484.24 5385.229 4.4882863
## 9 8882.412 35501.16 6893.146 4.3771611
## 10 7135.297 47886.06 6132.789 6.1811693
## 11 8329.698 36651.10 6653.452 5.3242896
## 12 11389.531 56769.39 9264.974 4.4383031
## 13 12765.569 54951.06 10160.271 3.3771427
## 14 10303.924 44305.72 8187.920 5.0883351
## 15 9560.089 43246.95 7653.687 4.0534373
## 16 11391.903 31572.97 8206.510 3.3129122
## 17 8688.028 29843.14 6590.038 3.4273833
## 18 33825.105 21708.95 12343.654 0.5872287
## 19 13429.810 37306.93 9592.566 3.0456128
## 20 10035.750 62144.40 8457.531 4.5111691
## 21 15704.314 44505.54 11306.562 3.2282910
## 22 15892.121 40757.78 10279.432 2.5216907
## 23 17011.765 44041.52 11793.593 2.6757130
## 24 13069.262 33497.68 9111.690 2.6489536
## 25 10035.487 43059.73 7939.448 3.8208127
## 26 14331.858 37243.09 9815.426 2.1660794
## 27 8605.292 24568.86 6079.743 3.2141889
## 28 19061.871 37417.92 11979.547 1.8723242
## 29 24474.331 42417.33 14346.352 1.8235904
## 30 26149.935 27035.50 12972.497 0.9226322
## 31 7359.949 41714.09 6136.598 5.4602096
## 32 17592.210 40654.24 10997.740 2.5754352
## 33 13999.710 44201.88 10321.858 2.9866755
## 34 27757.137 39453.78 15405.933 1.3732811
## 35 54384.901 11029.97 8725.925 0.1938754
## 36 8943.225 43638.72 7249.798 4.4425279
## 37 9289.657 46878.96 7601.617 4.2099157
## 38 12600.152 33232.14 8042.380 2.4887963
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.7624495
## 2 0.7791082
## 3 0.8019707
## 4 0.7822583
## 5 0.8230427
## 6 0.7275229
## 7 0.2730907
## 8 0.8033719
## 9 0.7876542
## 10 0.8481851
## 11 0.8240071
## 12 0.7920399
## 13 0.7520049
## 14 0.8170200
## 15 0.7809050
## 16 0.7498140
## 17 0.7570843
## 18 0.3417598
## 19 0.7301354
## 20 0.7974104
## 21 0.7417484
## 22 0.6427242
## 23 0.6925257
## 24 0.6994250
## 25 0.7673401
## 26 0.6422402
## 27 0.7273983
## 28 0.6111105
## 29 0.5892585
## 30 0.4665903
## 31 0.8281569
## 32 0.6292218
## 33 0.7229820
## 34 0.5406058
## 35 0.1546383
## 36 0.7938148
## 37 0.7881693
## 38 0.6167562Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.3 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.3$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.3 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.3$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.3## [1] 3.345957rt_com_4_0.3## [1] 0.6943564 i. f = 20%res_1sc2_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1565874 1429587 1516741 34942720405 103342851663 23291144489
## 2 10 2439231 2629295 2477782 31280515784 97076158363 22702654365
## 3 11 1431553 1696380 1480315 31997654158 101920977343 22846389678
## 4 12 1639969 2024446 1723267 33406100117 101139731907 23822666408
## 5 13 1566874 1397051 1533658 19378905470 100480884747 14966912694
## 6 14 2649779 2550409 2611401 44606400762 98229248530 29660671568
## 7 15 5049695 4756906 4800989 303974422936 97577573048 66918248638
## 8 16 2692722 2531982 2650446 31162768133 101198298560 23106238534
## 9 17 1976454 2241914 2026686 32442570119 100275944519 22941305955
## 10 18 1809757 1695991 1785502 21536088203 101120160485 17232573292
## 11 19 1843529 2219376 1912538 26136324172 101902414630 19974495620
## 12 2 1619071 1457465 1573261 32770568474 101865215395 23557165304
## 13 20 1878370 1503566 1760073 43155234850 102555172629 28981205175
## 14 21 1547200 1853100 1606483 29339817179 101334092988 21726724218
## 15 22 1982165 1827205 1934959 30981843185 99582186173 22240631349
## 16 23 2046435 2495356 2161769 39060304456 100296549254 26999645287
## 17 24 2598284 2569299 2583506 37798320676 100337684916 26462477873
## 18 25 3667898 3587087 3571080 220334116336 100541887064 61261414222
## 19 26 2025389 2219617 2073681 48960322037 102068593354 31238242084
## 20 27 1804441 1321820 1696861 28362536498 101846578874 21106020658
## 21 28 1584560 1840268 1647116 41144566165 101865215395 27718206007
## 22 29 1867452 1966266 1896373 58464192785 100317129386 30206949701
## 23 3 1793928 1865073 1798043 57952172782 101902414630 33856745921
## 24 4 2310403 2411836 2328511 53429744704 101061298600 32835969973
## 25 5 1993151 1883273 1953057 37046441334 100521577561 25614324457
## 26 6 2510580 2130768 2349560 60400515984 98068137955 33181207466
## 27 7 2647037 2983702 2732304 36451353014 95118770060 24819660839
## 28 71 2292464 2236598 2244425 73017566239 104903743361 37941560746
## 29 72 1765647 2012866 1816736 72081341140 106138994139 36854771505
## 30 73 3455003 3034669 3184020 162421731143 102359101663 60032573121
## 31 74 2154906 2017647 2121144 27989660933 105056784260 21290713254
## 32 75 1783231 2086096 1840429 59290208293 105875942407 31296353096
## 33 76 1956851 1930207 1940669 46991219199 106080255268 30952082405
## 34 77 2128534 2158084 2104191 91024870062 105924655691 43470685225
## 35 78 6976462 6951251 6946537 773025841305 95583760494 80652414075
## 36 79 2095567 1944226 2052614 33770266000 105664519376 24062798334
## 37 8 2006574 1709529 1930901 29728581101 101100564459 22005633193
## 38 9 2258432 2245263 2229525 52934909164 93730687506 27517427334
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 21171.41 72669.70 15000.866 2.9574930
## 2 12663.61 36842.44 9083.475 3.1034066
## 3 21523.36 60120.03 14993.710 3.1852640
## 4 19858.07 49887.63 13566.397 3.0275827
## 5 11917.46 72507.98 9573.369 5.1850650
## 6 16724.43 38479.06 11315.846 2.2021335
## 7 57624.76 20469.94 13816.819 0.3210059
## 8 11567.65 39898.96 8720.677 3.2474104
## 9 15938.50 44691.94 11061.647 3.0908755
## 10 11819.04 59714.28 9616.804 4.6953820
## 11 13934.35 45849.66 10291.897 3.8988809
## 12 19805.90 70232.60 14783.111 3.1084360
## 13 22512.88 68351.47 16289.794 2.3764249
## 14 18534.27 54712.88 13287.290 3.4538079
## 15 15249.25 54750.67 11338.953 3.2142112
## 16 18854.97 40137.45 12389.445 2.5677360
## 17 14333.81 39296.84 10168.413 2.6545540
## 18 57199.67 28016.27 16980.439 0.4563156
## 19 23487.32 46107.41 14813.873 2.0847206
## 20 15294.66 78019.31 12274.663 3.5908840
## 21 25296.68 55535.52 16565.248 2.4757878
## 22 29088.54 51940.69 15202.004 1.7158730
## 23 31118.87 54568.76 18423.106 1.7583882
## 24 22504.13 41830.22 13870.414 1.8914801
## 25 18091.91 53346.01 12922.137 2.7133936
## 26 22940.14 46031.76 13910.134 1.6236308
## 27 13520.02 31923.00 8974.150 2.6094716
## 28 30560.55 46805.64 16587.960 1.4366919
## 29 38089.73 52648.39 19468.570 1.4724892
## 30 45962.79 33655.88 18677.524 0.6302057
## 31 12916.75 51990.32 9997.575 3.7534140
## 32 30520.56 50667.37 16290.204 1.7857239
## 33 23802.69 54891.31 15855.558 2.2574485
## 34 40542.41 48981.99 20220.476 1.1636892
## 35 105975.37 13777.74 11569.771 0.1236489
## 36 15824.89 54276.16 11603.082 3.1289217
## 37 14464.52 59226.76 11246.740 3.4007867
## 38 22021.77 41822.39 11989.925 1.7706782
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.6665521
## 2 0.7257762
## 3 0.7140020
## 4 0.7131232
## 5 0.7723301
## 6 0.6649421
## 7 0.2201443
## 8 0.7414694
## 9 0.7071359
## 10 0.8001719
## 11 0.7642427
## 12 0.7188513
## 13 0.6715571
## 14 0.7405201
## 15 0.7178602
## 16 0.6912298
## 17 0.7000967
## 18 0.2780387
## 19 0.6380318
## 20 0.7441514
## 21 0.6736784
## 22 0.5166744
## 23 0.5842187
## 24 0.6145635
## 25 0.6914112
## 26 0.5493530
## 27 0.6808982
## 28 0.5196224
## 29 0.5112942
## 30 0.3696092
## 31 0.7606635
## 32 0.5278503
## 33 0.6586780
## 34 0.4775693
## 35 0.1043334
## 36 0.7125439
## 37 0.7402181
## 38 0.5198352Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.2 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.2$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.2 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.2$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.2## [1] 2.477192rt_com_4_0.2## [1] 0.6211379 j. f = 10%res_1sc2_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1474412 1370798 1408539 8.362945e+10 159612586183 43752503692
## 2 10 2466415 2566205 2480810 7.489146e+10 156328374943 45417954302
## 3 11 1350222 1629922 1397207 6.121087e+10 158867418772 38308228331
## 4 12 1616836 1943930 1687074 7.068443e+10 158457988325 43661237002
## 5 13 1600199 1341919 1527684 4.784029e+10 158112703635 31131279140
## 6 14 2508111 2504699 2493060 9.621367e+10 156932679558 54892374717
## 7 15 5044368 4718471 4742577 7.622693e+11 156591153359 111301711694
## 8 16 2715099 2485802 2631875 6.977470e+10 158488681586 44297194777
## 9 17 1988602 2188734 2013662 6.920891e+10 158005299783 39914912483
## 10 18 1803904 1634797 1751655 5.054491e+10 158447731450 36092032976
## 11 19 1740350 2154349 1825054 5.875218e+10 158857690536 38225133646
## 12 2 1492548 1393112 1443008 6.460725e+10 158838195383 40465978469
## 13 20 1864903 1435537 1696934 9.058667e+10 159199784054 51721261613
## 14 21 1547052 1778241 1586802 6.331594e+10 158559847920 39960794315
## 15 22 1822352 1783252 1795658 5.326715e+10 157641719047 35852020502
## 16 23 2016878 2448800 2143203 8.742033e+10 158016098190 51175956338
## 17 24 2550396 2573544 2543403 8.595585e+10 158037656322 49683594031
## 18 25 3732677 3568919 3546583 5.009683e+11 158144673365 94158927465
## 19 26 1864495 2133159 1927061 9.994400e+10 158944780490 52580791555
## 20 27 1736203 1243860 1594039 6.296103e+10 158828428466 40215621869
## 21 28 1476617 1755054 1547730 8.930235e+10 158838195383 51255606492
## 22 29 1838937 1885023 1846663 1.155261e+11 158026883702 48946534379
## 23 3 1649226 1786829 1647038 1.085560e+11 158857690536 51962825174
## 24 4 2320461 2344984 2287871 1.255233e+11 158416883465 59139949475
## 25 5 2029842 1808988 1919844 9.071582e+10 158134029682 50104913859
## 26 6 2418303 2052249 2235449 1.281240e+11 156848245690 56192595328
## 27 7 2502185 2960117 2640099 8.123614e+10 155302558558 45595053195
## 28 71 2276058 2163693 2160286 1.734592e+11 160430608993 64087066256
## 29 72 1486706 1933537 1566103 1.121681e+11 161077971852 45558891776
## 30 73 3195014 2946242 2983750 3.336357e+11 159097028352 94845968261
## 31 74 1947222 1939601 1939653 5.348505e+10 160510813754 36934879769
## 32 75 1875994 2011022 1871665 1.473517e+11 160940113270 57964574521
## 33 76 1734900 1851219 1742521 8.519009e+10 161047188335 47667639874
## 34 77 2152122 2078441 2046394 2.169290e+11 160965642637 72715137506
## 35 78 6842669 6805761 6800201 1.330918e+12 155546247970 129761399654
## 36 79 2085723 1866890 1999909 7.450703e+10 160829311949 43693765520
## 37 8 2011617 1652253 1889569 7.095530e+10 158437461682 43554545110
## 38 9 2141691 2181358 2132120 7.494735e+10 154575100533 39477923540
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 50980.13 118192.35 30064.24 1.9085691
## 2 29624.74 61171.65 18079.33 2.0873992
## 3 41908.25 97565.63 26050.86 2.5954120
## 4 41642.07 81394.83 25049.28 2.2417665
## 5 27568.79 120198.69 19875.01 3.3050115
## 6 37971.81 62723.53 21915.60 1.6310851
## 7 139614.90 33168.12 23141.23 0.2054276
## 8 25436.31 63669.14 16762.74 2.2714349
## 9 32648.67 72178.65 19029.73 2.2830196
## 10 27379.45 97518.54 20334.40 3.1347908
## 11 32290.85 73612.61 20150.73 2.7038604
## 12 40601.79 115683.38 27157.00 2.4585197
## 13 46449.76 111618.60 30002.86 1.7574305
## 14 38806.74 89456.14 24228.81 2.5042643
## 15 27683.59 89039.74 19377.62 2.9594549
## 16 42051.08 64419.29 23390.68 1.8075442
## 17 32734.03 62063.07 19172.48 1.8385910
## 18 118624.64 44280.98 25922.40 0.3156780
## 19 50825.85 74562.67 26438.66 1.5903384
## 20 34407.02 130579.15 24704.95 2.5226465
## 21 57622.06 90761.05 32140.27 1.7786564
## 22 54986.88 87112.39 25079.95 1.3678892
## 23 59094.43 89006.66 30052.67 1.4633709
## 24 51033.57 67500.94 25250.72 1.2620521
## 25 42089.79 87792.12 25545.87 1.7431802
## 26 48838.71 77156.76 24704.44 1.2241907
## 27 31376.48 53058.82 17123.90 1.9117423
## 28 67088.48 73988.44 28516.84 0.9248897
## 29 63413.38 83175.80 26996.81 1.4360405
## 30 99634.47 54166.79 31399.70 0.4768585
## 31 27437.06 82632.19 18997.32 3.0010405
## 32 67648.57 79885.31 29604.40 1.0922176
## 33 46036.31 86910.09 26330.35 1.8904452
## 34 89857.63 77316.54 34296.14 0.7420200
## 35 181235.66 23157.42 19128.68 0.1168714
## 36 33692.69 86079.89 21312.76 2.1585792
## 37 33578.41 96678.95 22587.86 2.2329193
## 38 31802.75 71893.55 18004.97 2.0624492
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.5231710
## 2 0.6064504
## 3 0.6258403
## 4 0.6176924
## 5 0.6507335
## 6 0.5705257
## 7 0.1460136
## 8 0.6348604
## 9 0.5767308
## 10 0.7140587
## 11 0.6506164
## 12 0.6263381
## 13 0.5709588
## 14 0.6311332
## 15 0.6730606
## 16 0.5854011
## 17 0.5780129
## 18 0.1879539
## 19 0.5261025
## 20 0.6387383
## 21 0.5739558
## 22 0.4236838
## 23 0.4786730
## 24 0.4711474
## 25 0.5523283
## 26 0.4385797
## 27 0.5612657
## 28 0.3694648
## 29 0.4061661
## 30 0.2842800
## 31 0.6905645
## 32 0.3933757
## 33 0.5595444
## 34 0.3352025
## 35 0.0974977
## 36 0.5864382
## 37 0.6138307
## 38 0.5267421Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.1 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.1$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.1 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.1$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.1## [1] 1.815991rt_com_4_0.1## [1] 0.5183456 k. f = 5%res_1sc2_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 1485403 1304574 1364953 1.811192e+11 251230651475 68547113291
## 2 10 2442296 2481150 2406162 1.515579e+11 241702326871 74379537028
## 3 11 1208853 1502209 1219021 1.221906e+11 249068732993 57242281287
## 4 12 1680146 1740627 1631528 1.729213e+11 247880872067 77529072823
## 5 13 1533738 1279680 1459492 7.573877e+10 246879114153 45530693243
## 6 14 2284936 2476581 2316674 1.847637e+11 243455566878 86213301074
## 7 15 5178744 4622091 4651671 1.498139e+12 242464713292 162971191276
## 8 16 2696329 2436228 2582384 1.570469e+11 247969920955 80954863442
## 9 17 1978475 2118127 1959442 1.508735e+11 246567508506 67132370943
## 10 18 1868387 1551065 1744843 1.172519e+11 247851114289 67009635228
## 11 19 1469693 2019440 1562325 1.045470e+11 249040508928 55659934395
## 12 2 1302446 1303857 1269988 1.119387e+11 248983948575 60666515786
## 13 20 1601115 1315922 1455872 1.640984e+11 250033008450 72587782844
## 14 21 1490601 1618456 1481196 1.199529e+11 248176392428 64255635547
## 15 22 1819501 1752638 1767090 1.162658e+11 245512669151 59798927872
## 16 23 2066684 2393656 2135937 1.686773e+11 246598837405 80299343947
## 17 24 2649619 2708026 2629414 2.278901e+11 246661382981 93778060593
## 18 25 3613853 3578190 3497698 7.438193e+11 246971866398 133084531538
## 19 26 1558812 1853655 1599005 1.781009e+11 249293178837 72070568211
## 20 27 1428695 1030543 1330370 8.997022e+10 248955612287 50518667556
## 21 28 1259832 1527781 1296738 1.375232e+11 248983948575 68484352245
## 22 29 1876570 1793521 1833274 2.011090e+11 246630128897 72403913328
## 23 3 1454547 1610971 1422261 2.355839e+11 249040508928 79574964482
## 24 4 2259415 2208072 2171153 2.332514e+11 247761616508 92479021234
## 25 5 1982878 1665994 1825378 1.822995e+11 246940986391 76335594867
## 26 6 2099242 1902682 1953710 2.466143e+11 243210602943 87833968045
## 27 7 2492877 3062151 2676435 1.729104e+11 238726174978 80509570570
## 28 71 2394477 1979750 2141934 4.318978e+11 253603941830 113497682319
## 29 72 1575159 1724349 1507646 3.302861e+11 255482104653 80305727987
## 30 73 2767888 2721627 2630555 6.188210e+11 249734888258 132075660385
## 31 74 1530206 1741402 1557813 8.983359e+10 253836636059 48821580303
## 32 75 1476924 1820247 1506972 1.478340e+11 255082142159 57589660700
## 33 76 1679902 1647915 1622698 1.493627e+11 255392793911 61591664309
## 34 77 1794893 1869024 1746474 3.493149e+11 255156209288 86090631451
## 35 78 6238848 6238045 6214107 2.833200e+12 239433179387 190917651071
## 36 79 1648235 1674959 1611362 1.182821e+11 254760679599 49578885735
## 37 8 2016827 1598346 1837371 1.533652e+11 247821319103 77002313177
## 38 9 2087040 2120534 2031603 2.532612e+11 236615635891 76957599030
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com Efisiensi_syn
## 1 95063.73 205152.04 47025.33 1.3871008
## 2 58396.50 97202.19 30090.21 1.5947853
## 3 80873.08 166412.64 42137.16 2.0383620
## 4 92853.66 141625.04 45016.53 1.4334898
## 5 44626.29 201738.02 30533.13 3.2596135
## 6 77644.69 98526.51 36069.82 1.3176594
## 7 245667.61 52646.31 34424.89 0.1618440
## 8 57181.21 101439.44 31092.33 1.5789541
## 9 66206.35 116396.88 32213.50 1.6342669
## 10 59148.03 161075.89 37669.20 2.1138339
## 11 63588.99 122845.35 32573.09 2.3820919
## 12 76877.36 195465.13 45396.58 2.2242886
## 13 88368.32 193145.52 46977.97 1.5236774
## 14 70806.04 153705.44 40388.53 2.0689484
## 15 56908.38 143080.34 32401.41 2.1116502
## 16 76308.53 102818.12 36263.43 1.4619559
## 17 80051.34 93514.28 34389.63 1.0823697
## 18 178002.47 69212.86 37342.93 0.3320321
## 19 98611.26 137230.00 42129.74 1.3997302
## 20 55742.33 260120.48 36246.94 2.7670890
## 21 96247.41 164797.09 48778.88 1.8104871
## 22 86549.76 144996.53 36977.00 1.2263507
## 23 127609.90 154209.70 51317.79 1.0571203
## 24 91881.27 111814.51 41092.86 1.0622083
## 25 82899.26 148322.01 41190.55 1.3545893
## 26 97468.79 128387.87 42916.21 0.9861985
## 27 63206.31 78603.86 29059.69 1.3806352
## 28 157588.40 127330.71 51831.98 0.5871851
## 29 149935.84 147825.46 47446.24 0.7735176
## 30 198554.92 91360.46 48364.53 0.4035656
## 31 57115.04 145303.19 30142.11 2.8256317
## 32 83958.77 139714.77 34407.30 1.7254631
## 33 77947.82 155167.01 35788.36 1.7098831
## 34 156870.54 135753.20 47348.72 0.7304476
## 35 376731.62 40163.29 30740.14 0.0845098
## 36 60558.81 152271.43 28538.07 2.1538388
## 37 70489.54 157199.41 41299.80 1.6158904
## 38 97029.52 113013.19 36505.30 0.9342752
## Efisiensi_com
## 1 0.37846400
## 2 0.49076644
## 3 0.46846704
## 4 0.44834897
## 5 0.60115438
## 6 0.46661395
## 7 0.10878245
## 8 0.51548194
## 9 0.44495812
## 10 0.57150132
## 11 0.53239162
## 12 0.54196200
## 13 0.44234304
## 14 0.53567382
## 15 0.51432954
## 16 0.47605292
## 17 0.41150557
## 18 0.17892050
## 19 0.40466148
## 20 0.56150430
## 21 0.49798406
## 22 0.36002328
## 23 0.33777761
## 24 0.39647781
## 25 0.41873720
## 26 0.35615933
## 27 0.46561441
## 28 0.26278831
## 29 0.24313990
## 30 0.21343111
## 31 0.54346688
## 32 0.38955623
## 33 0.41236302
## 34 0.24645567
## 35 0.06738586
## 36 0.41915781
## 37 0.50208472
## 38 0.30386654Rata-rata efisiensi:
rt_syn_4_0.05 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.05$Efisiensi_syn)
rt_com_4_0.05 <- mean(res_1sc2_0.05$Efisiensi_com)
rt_syn_4_0.05## [1] 1.481462rt_com_4_0.05## [1] 0.4086935