Tahapan Pengestimasian Direct dan Traditional Indirect Estimation:
library(readxl)
Jatim_logpengeluaran <- read_excel("D:/Kuliah/tkt IV/The Journey Start/SAE/Data SAE/Jatim_logpengeluaran.xlsx",
col_types = c("numeric", "text", "text",
"text", "text", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric"))
Xnew_ya <- read_excel("D:/Kuliah/tkt IV/The Journey Start/SAE/Data SAE/Xnew ya.xlsx",
sheet = "Sheet2", col_types = c("text", "text", "text", "text", "text", "text",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric",
"numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric", "numeric"))
muatan <- read_excel("D:/Kuliah/tkt IV/The Journey Start/SAE/Data SAE/muatan.xlsx",
sheet = "Sheet3", col_types = c("text","text", "numeric"))
#variabel_X_signifikan
x7 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X7, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x13 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X13, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x14 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X14, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x18 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X18, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x19 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X19, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x20 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X20, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x21 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X21, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x24 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X24, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x25 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X25, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
x34 <- aggregate(Xnew_ya$X34, list(Xnew_ya$R102),sum,na.rm=TRUE)
dt1 <- data.frame(cbind("bs_o"=Jatim_logpengeluaran$`No Kode Sampel`,"pop"=Jatim_logpengeluaran$Exp_krb,"kab"=Jatim_logpengeluaran$R102))
mat_x <- matrix(cbind(1,x7$x,x13$x,x14$x,x18$x,x19$x,x20$x,x21$x,x24$x,x25$x,x34$x),ncol = 11)
# Fungsi Menghitung Jumlah desa
jml_desa <- function(data){
r102 = unique(Jatim_logpengeluaran$R102)
de = data.frame(r102)
Peng_jatim <- data.frame(Jatim_logpengeluaran)
ds <- list()
for (i in r102){
ds[[i]] <- subset(Peng_jatim, R102 %in% i)
}
bsz <- list()
for(j in r102){
bsz[[j]] <- unique(ds[[j]]$No.Kode.tiga)
}
Ni <- c()
for(k in r102){
Ni[k] <- length(bsz[[k]])
}
Ni <- Ni[-c(30:70)]
N_desa <- data.frame("desa"=Ni)
return(N_desa)
}
Ni_desa <- jml_desa(Jatim_logpengeluaran)Jumlah desa setiap kabupaten/kota:
Ni_desa## desa
## 1 34
## 2 43
## 3 42
## 4 51
## 5 52
## 6 64
## 7 80
## 8 50
## 9 87
## 10 71
## 11 45
## 12 44
## 13 55
## 14 63
## 15 72
## 16 50
## 17 52
## 18 47
## 19 41
## 20 32
## 21 46
## 22 54
## 23 53
## 24 53
## 25 52
## 26 42
## 27 43
## 28 40
## 29 52
## 30 15
## 31 10
## 32 35
## 33 14
## 34 12
## 35 9
## 36 11
## 37 94
## 38 13Fungsi Estimasi untuk metode SRS
resampling_srs = function(data, dataX, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY = data
prop = proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
srs_sampling <- function(data, prop){
kab_1= data
samp_rt <- sample(1:length(kab_1$pop), size = prop*length(kab_1$pop), replace = FALSE)
hs_samp_srs <- kab_1[samp_rt,]
hs_samp_srs$pop <- as.numeric(paste(hs_samp_srs$pop))
hs_samp_srs <- data.frame(hs_samp_srs)
est_ybar_srs <- function(data,f){
hs_samp_srs <- data
y_tot_samp <- sum(hs_samp_srs$pop)
n <- length(hs_samp_srs$pop)
y_bar <- y_tot_samp/n
Y_cap_est <- n/f*y_bar
s_kw <- sum((hs_samp_srs$pop - (matrix(y_bar,ncol = 1)))^2)/(n-1)
var_y_bar <- (1-f)*s_kw/n
Var_cap_est <- (n/f)^2*var_y_bar
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result = est_ybar_srs(hs_samp_srs, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- srs_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary){
#synthetic function
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
mse_syn <- abs(((Y_syn-y)^2)-vary)
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
return(datafinal)
}b. MEnggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang perbaikanresampling_srs_2 <- function(data, dataX, Ni, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY <- data
prop <- proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
srs_sampling <- function(data, prop){
kab_1= data
samp_rt <- sample(1:length(kab_1$pop), size = prop*length(kab_1$pop), replace = FALSE)
hs_samp_srs <- kab_1[samp_rt,]
hs_samp_srs$pop <- as.numeric(paste(hs_samp_srs$pop))
hs_samp_srs <- data.frame(hs_samp_srs)
est_ybar_srs <- function(data,f){
hs_samp_srs <- data
y_tot_samp <- sum(hs_samp_srs$pop)
n <- length(hs_samp_srs$pop)
y_bar <- y_tot_samp/n
Y_cap_est <- n/f*y_bar
s_kw <- sum((hs_samp_srs$pop - (matrix(y_bar,ncol = 1)))^2)/(n-1)
var_y_bar <- (1-f)*s_kw/n
Var_cap_est <- (n/f)^2*var_y_bar
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result = est_ybar_srs(hs_samp_srs, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- srs_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary,Ni){
#synthetic function
N <- Ni
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
var_y_cap_is <- matrix(var(Y_syn),nrow = nrow(N))
Ni_2 <- N^2/nrow(N) #Ni kuadrat*1/m
var_Ysyn_y <- matrix(var(Y_syn - y),nrow = nrow(N))
ht_2 <- 1/N^2*var_Ysyn_y
y_sel <- data.frame((Y_syn - y)^2)
ba_2 <- (1/N^2)*(y_sel)-ht_2
mse_syn <- var_y_cap_is + (Ni_2*ba_2)
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est,Ni)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
return(datafinal)
}Fungsi Estimasi untuk metode One stage Cluster
#Pakai rumus awal
resampling_1st = function(data, dataX, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY = data
prop = proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
cb_sampling <- function(data, prop){
mydata= data
bs_u <-unique(mydata$bs_o)
bs_u <- data.frame(bs_u)
samp_bs <- sample(1:nrow(bs_u), size = prop*nrow(bs_u), replace = FALSE)
sampi= bs_u[samp_bs,]
sampi2 = as.matrix(sampi)
dat = as.matrix(mydata)
hasil = c()
for(i in 1: length(sampi2)){
hasil = rbind(hasil,dat[dat[,1]==sampi[i],])
}
hasil <- data.frame(hasil)
hasil$pop = as.numeric(paste(hasil$pop))
est_ybar_1cs <- function(data,f){
hs_sam <- data
Mi <- data.frame(table(hs_sam$bs_o))
y_bar_i <- aggregate(hs_sam$pop, by=list(hs_sam$bs_o), FUN=mean)
y_bar_n <- (sum(y_bar_i$x*Mi$Freq))/sum(Mi$Freq)
M_bar <- sum(Mi$Freq)/nrow(Mi)
pnyb <- sum((Mi$Freq^2)*((y_bar_i$x-rep(c(y_bar_n),nrow(Mi)))^2))
pmbg <- nrow(Mi)*(M_bar)^2*(nrow(Mi)-1)
var_y_bar_n <- (1-f)*pnyb/pmbg
Y_cap_est <- (nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar*y_bar_n
Var_cap_est <- ((nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar)^2*var_y_bar_n
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result = est_ybar_1cs(hasil, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- cb_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary){
#synthetic function
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
mse_syn <- abs(((Y_syn-y)^2)-vary)
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
return(datafinal)
}b. MEnggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang perbaikanresampling_1st_2 <- function(data, dataX, Ni, proporsi,iterasi ){
myDataY <- data
prop <- proporsi
propinsi <- function(data, prop){
cb_sampling <- function(data, prop){
mydata<- data
bs_u <-unique(mydata$bs_o)
bs_u <- data.frame(bs_u)
samp_bs <- sample(1:nrow(bs_u), size = prop*nrow(bs_u), replace = FALSE)
sampi=bs_u[samp_bs,]
sampi2 = as.matrix(sampi)
dat <- as.matrix(mydata)
hasil <- c()
for(i in 1: length(sampi2)){
hasil = rbind(hasil,dat[dat[,1]==sampi[i],])
}
hasil <- data.frame(hasil)
hasil$pop <- as.numeric(paste(hasil$pop))
est_ybar_1cs <- function(data,f){
hs_sam <- data
Mi <- data.frame(table(hs_sam$bs_o))
y_bar_i <- aggregate(hs_sam$pop, by=list(hs_sam$bs_o), FUN=mean)
y_bar_n <- (sum(y_bar_i$x*Mi$Freq))/sum(Mi$Freq)
M_bar <- sum(Mi$Freq)/nrow(Mi)
pnyb <- sum((Mi$Freq^2)*((y_bar_i$x-rep(c(y_bar_n),nrow(Mi)))^2))
pmbg <- nrow(Mi)*(M_bar)^2*(nrow(Mi)-1)
var_y_bar_n <- (1-f)*pnyb/pmbg
Y_cap_est <- (nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar*y_bar_n
Var_cap_est <- ((nrow(Mi)/f)*M_bar)^2*var_y_bar_n
rel_var_y <- Var_cap_est/Y_cap_est
hasil <- cbind(Y_cap_est,Var_cap_est,rel_var_y)
return(hasil)
}
result <- est_ybar_1cs(hasil, prop)
}
r102 = unique(dt1$kab)
datakoeh = list()
for(b in r102){
datakoeh[[b]] <- subset(dt1, kab %in% b)
}
try_ye <- list()
for(c in r102){
try_ye[[c]] <- cb_sampling(data = datakoeh[[c]], prop = prop)
}
this_it = data.frame()
for (q in r102) {
this_it <- rbind(this_it, try_ye[[q]])
}
this_it = cbind(r102, this_it)
}
#fungsi estimasi synthetic dan composite
Y_synth_comp <- function(x,y,vary,Ni){
#synthetic function
N <- Ni
xty <- t(x)%*%y
xtx <- t(x)%*%x
bt_xy <- solve(xtx)%*%xty
bt_xy = t(bt_xy)
Y_syn <- c(rep(0,nrow(x)))
for(i in 1: ncol(x)){
Y_syn = Y_syn + x[,i]*bt_xy[,i]
}
Y_syn <- as.data.frame(Y_syn)
var_y_cap_is <- matrix(var(Y_syn),nrow = nrow(N))
Ni_2 <- N^2/nrow(N) #Ni kuadrat*1/m
var_Ysyn_y <- matrix(var(Y_syn - y),nrow = nrow(N))
ht_2 <- 1/N^2*var_Ysyn_y
y_sel <- data.frame((Y_syn - y)^2)
ba_2 <- (1/N^2)*(y_sel)-ht_2
mse_syn <- var_y_cap_is + (Ni_2*ba_2)
rel_mse_syn <- mse_syn/Y_syn
#composite function
tetha_i <- mse_syn/(vary+mse_syn)
tetha_i[tetha_i<0]<-0
tetha_i[tetha_i>1]<-1
Y_comp <- (tetha_i*y) + ((1-tetha_i)*Y_syn)
mse_comp <- (1-tetha_i)*mse_syn
rel_mse_comp <- mse_comp/Y_comp
Syn_Comp <- data.frame(cbind(Y_syn, Y_comp,mse_syn, mse_comp, rel_mse_syn, rel_mse_comp))
colnames(Syn_Comp) = c("Y syn","Y comp", "MSE syn", "MSE comp", "Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE comp")
return(Syn_Comp)
}
dataset = list()
est_dataset = list()
for( j in 1:iterasi){
set.seed(j)
dataset[[j]] = propinsi(myDataY, prop)
est_dataset [[j]] = Y_synth_comp(dataX,dataset[[j]]$Y_cap_est,dataset[[j]]$Var_cap_est,Ni)
}
databind = data.frame()
databind_ind = data.frame()
for (b in 1:iterasi) {
databind = rbind(databind, dataset[[b]])
databind_ind = rbind(databind_ind, est_dataset[[b]])
}
datafinal = aggregate(list(databind$Y_cap_est,databind_ind$`Y syn`,databind_ind$`Y comp`,
databind$Var_cap_est,databind_ind$`MSE syn`,databind_ind$`MSE comp`
,databind$rel_var_y,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE syn`,databind_ind$`Relatif MSE comp`),
by=list(databind$r102),
FUN=mean)
colnames(datafinal) = c("kab", "Y dir", "Y syn","Y com", "MSE dir","MSE syn","MSE com",
"Relatif MSE dir","Relatif MSE syn","Relatif MSE com")
return(datafinal)
}res_srs_1 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_1 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.9 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.9 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.8 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.8 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.7 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.7 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.6 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.6 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.5 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.5 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.4 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.4 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.3 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.3 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.2 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.2 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.1 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.1 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 10)
res_srs_0.05 <- resampling_srs(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 10)
res_srs2_0.05 <- resampling_srs_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 10)res_1sc_1 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_1 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 1, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.9 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.9 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa , proporsi = 0.9, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.8 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.8 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.8, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.7 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.7 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.7, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.6 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.6 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.6, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.5 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.5 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.5, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.4 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.4 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.4, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.3 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.3 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.3, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.2 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.2 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.2, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.1 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.1 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.1, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc_0.05 <- resampling_1st(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 10)
res_1sc2_0.05 <- resampling_1st_2(data = dt1, dataX = mat_x, Ni = Ni_desa, proporsi = 0.05, iterasi = 10)MEnggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang awal
res_srs_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4220.403 4216.292 4220.403 0 1.689987e+01 0
## 2 10 6158.917 6172.297 6158.917 0 1.790177e+02 0
## 3 11 4634.496 4655.050 4634.496 0 4.224791e+02 0
## 4 12 4919.014 4612.412 4919.014 0 9.400516e+04 0
## 5 13 5127.194 5210.191 5127.194 0 6.888535e+03 0
## 6 14 5928.762 5876.421 5928.762 0 2.739513e+03 0
## 7 15 6342.583 6245.147 6342.583 0 9.493707e+03 0
## 8 16 5103.006 4911.246 5103.006 0 3.677202e+04 0
## 9 17 5268.416 5397.589 5268.416 0 1.668564e+04 0
## 10 18 4970.796 5093.818 4970.796 0 1.513452e+04 0
## 11 19 4751.743 4396.560 4751.743 0 1.261550e+05 0
## 12 2 4700.143 4755.819 4700.143 0 3.099840e+03 0
## 13 20 4525.222 4394.751 4525.222 0 1.702264e+04 0
## 14 21 4848.178 4752.708 4848.178 0 9.114580e+03 0
## 15 22 5460.264 5519.749 5460.264 0 3.538503e+03 0
## 16 23 5271.905 5297.644 5271.905 0 6.624653e+02 0
## 17 24 5362.188 5414.360 5362.188 0 2.721931e+03 0
## 18 25 5427.660 5439.128 5427.660 0 1.315308e+02 0
## 19 26 4734.623 4823.859 4734.623 0 7.963093e+03 0
## 20 27 4777.379 4776.869 4777.379 0 2.598680e-01 0
## 21 28 4702.797 4658.169 4702.797 0 1.991721e+03 0
## 22 29 5239.878 5237.877 5239.878 0 4.005938e+00 0
## 23 3 4708.626 4794.793 4708.626 0 7.424634e+03 0
## 24 4 5056.916 5048.966 5056.916 0 6.320760e+01 0
## 25 5 5198.709 5215.515 5198.709 0 2.824529e+02 0
## 26 6 5926.092 5914.324 5926.092 0 1.384940e+02 0
## 27 7 6685.010 6943.755 6685.010 0 6.694903e+04 0
## 28 71 3701.777 3582.993 3701.777 0 1.410965e+04 0
## 29 72 3067.757 3396.768 3067.757 0 1.082479e+05 0
## 30 73 4787.325 4261.271 4787.325 0 2.767331e+05 0
## 31 74 3646.103 3494.168 3646.103 0 2.308415e+04 0
## 32 75 3205.130 3439.743 3205.130 0 5.504338e+04 0
## 33 76 3125.115 3468.370 3125.115 0 1.178234e+05 0
## 34 77 3215.490 3385.882 3215.490 0 2.903334e+04 0
## 35 78 6979.747 7098.937 6979.747 0 1.420619e+04 0
## 36 79 3361.141 3446.142 3361.141 0 7.225189e+03 0
## 37 8 5024.538 4887.130 5024.538 0 1.888111e+04 0
## 38 9 6903.494 6831.826 6903.494 0 5.136210e+03 0
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0 4.008229e-03 0
## 2 0 2.900342e-02 0
## 3 0 9.075716e-02 0
## 4 0 2.038091e+01 0
## 5 0 1.322127e+00 0
## 6 0 4.661874e-01 0
## 7 0 1.520173e+00 0
## 8 0 7.487311e+00 0
## 9 0 3.091314e+00 0
## 10 0 2.971155e+00 0
## 11 0 2.869404e+01 0
## 12 0 6.517993e-01 0
## 13 0 3.873403e+00 0
## 14 0 1.917766e+00 0
## 15 0 6.410622e-01 0
## 16 0 1.250490e-01 0
## 17 0 5.027245e-01 0
## 18 0 2.418233e-02 0
## 19 0 1.650772e+00 0
## 20 0 5.440133e-05 0
## 21 0 4.275759e-01 0
## 22 0 7.648019e-04 0
## 23 0 1.548479e+00 0
## 24 0 1.251892e-02 0
## 25 0 5.415629e-02 0
## 26 0 2.341670e-02 0
## 27 0 9.641617e+00 0
## 28 0 3.937950e+00 0
## 29 0 3.186792e+01 0
## 30 0 6.494146e+01 0
## 31 0 6.606481e+00 0
## 32 0 1.600218e+01 0
## 33 0 3.397084e+01 0
## 34 0 8.574823e+00 0
## 35 0 2.001171e+00 0
## 36 0 2.096602e+00 0
## 37 0 3.863436e+00 0
## 38 0 7.518063e-01 0 b. f = 90%res_srs_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4215.962 4212.608 4214.690 7.218753 1.177478e+01 3.945537
## 2 10 6152.545 6166.747 6153.369 11.351350 1.962883e+02 10.650584
## 3 11 4629.496 4652.793 4629.873 8.642732 5.411404e+02 8.497832
## 4 12 4916.080 4609.792 4916.049 9.324579 9.381298e+04 9.323652
## 5 13 5128.221 5207.313 5128.326 8.314825 6.251510e+03 8.303736
## 6 14 5921.966 5873.988 5921.777 9.043191 2.298988e+03 9.007345
## 7 15 6342.257 6242.549 6342.154 10.236157 9.938938e+03 10.225599
## 8 16 5097.917 4908.800 5097.880 7.045927 3.575999e+04 7.044539
## 9 17 5268.486 5394.187 5268.550 8.116771 1.579897e+04 8.112598
## 10 18 4968.167 5091.340 4968.232 8.032782 1.517114e+04 8.028521
## 11 19 4749.143 4393.794 4749.122 7.427946 1.262680e+05 7.427508
## 12 2 4697.669 4752.874 4697.826 8.636786 3.043338e+03 8.612161
## 13 20 4521.498 4392.227 4521.433 8.357513 1.670678e+04 8.353329
## 14 21 4844.883 4749.877 4844.796 8.212851 9.029006e+03 8.205357
## 15 22 5453.279 5516.833 5453.404 7.960099 4.033243e+03 7.944394
## 16 23 5271.489 5296.101 5271.863 9.047506 6.065401e+02 8.906217
## 17 24 5359.640 5410.648 5359.776 6.930413 2.602029e+03 6.911789
## 18 25 5422.733 5434.850 5423.381 7.631241 1.437419e+02 7.199957
## 19 26 4731.460 4820.784 4731.536 6.781754 7.975038e+03 6.775982
## 20 27 4775.499 4774.368 4774.853 6.007371 7.743902e+00 3.041118
## 21 28 4700.499 4654.043 4700.325 8.093167 2.155455e+03 8.062574
## 22 29 5236.333 5234.386 5234.937 7.334890 3.430726e+00 2.228409
## 23 3 4704.788 4791.804 4704.896 9.421460 7.567690e+03 9.409714
## 24 4 5056.667 5045.802 5055.779 9.299558 1.123485e+02 8.475114
## 25 5 5194.749 5212.619 5195.209 8.054695 3.192716e+02 7.838396
## 26 6 5923.739 5911.818 5922.878 9.564725 1.400720e+02 8.749243
## 27 7 6683.883 6941.009 6683.922 9.901924 6.611161e+04 9.900440
## 28 71 3694.466 3579.976 3694.416 5.776885 1.311038e+04 5.774336
## 29 72 3064.369 3393.742 3064.386 5.733052 1.084836e+05 5.732749
## 30 73 4786.644 4258.562 4786.629 8.043708 2.788690e+05 8.043476
## 31 74 3647.216 3490.978 3647.187 4.534223 2.440770e+04 4.533380
## 32 75 3203.297 3436.680 3203.322 5.752941 5.446750e+04 5.752333
## 33 76 3125.268 3466.671 3125.285 5.594400 1.165522e+05 5.594131
## 34 77 3209.965 3382.349 3210.001 6.096949 2.971333e+04 6.095696
## 35 78 6972.911 7094.107 6973.006 11.552240 1.468132e+04 11.543140
## 36 79 3356.368 3443.072 3356.414 4.023162 7.515989e+03 4.021006
## 37 8 5021.483 4883.018 5021.432 7.045387 1.917008e+04 7.042796
## 38 9 6898.031 6825.951 6897.890 10.156488 5.187129e+03 10.136619
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.001712246 2.795233e-03 0.0009360592
## 2 0.001844990 3.183103e-02 0.0017308796
## 3 0.001866878 1.163046e-01 0.0018354335
## 4 0.001896742 2.035079e+01 0.0018965652
## 5 0.001621388 1.200514e+00 0.0016191924
## 6 0.001527062 3.913848e-01 0.0015210569
## 7 0.001613956 1.592141e+00 0.0016123172
## 8 0.001382117 7.284882e+00 0.0013818547
## 9 0.001540630 2.928889e+00 0.0015398191
## 10 0.001616848 2.979785e+00 0.0016159687
## 11 0.001564058 2.873781e+01 0.0015639732
## 12 0.001838521 6.403143e-01 0.0018332183
## 13 0.001848394 3.803720e+00 0.0018474950
## 14 0.001695151 1.900887e+00 0.0016936340
## 15 0.001459689 7.310779e-01 0.0014567755
## 16 0.001716318 1.145290e-01 0.0016894002
## 17 0.001293077 4.809077e-01 0.0012895697
## 18 0.001407277 2.645030e-02 0.0013276020
## 19 0.001433334 1.654312e+00 0.0014320913
## 20 0.001257958 1.621968e-03 0.0006369002
## 21 0.001721767 4.631388e-01 0.0017153222
## 22 0.001400767 6.554325e-04 0.0004256718
## 23 0.002002537 1.579306e+00 0.0019999945
## 24 0.001839071 2.226553e-02 0.0016762930
## 25 0.001550542 6.124952e-02 0.0015087757
## 26 0.001614645 2.369272e-02 0.0014771356
## 27 0.001481459 9.524775e+00 0.0014812279
## 28 0.001563644 3.662150e+00 0.0015629758
## 29 0.001870879 3.196578e+01 0.0018707695
## 30 0.001680453 6.548434e+01 0.0016804101
## 31 0.001243205 6.991660e+00 0.0012429839
## 32 0.001795940 1.584884e+01 0.0017957366
## 33 0.001790058 3.362075e+01 0.0017899627
## 34 0.001899368 8.784835e+00 0.0018989565
## 35 0.001656729 2.069516e+00 0.0016554013
## 36 0.001198666 2.182934e+00 0.0011980075
## 37 0.001403042 3.925872e+00 0.0014025404
## 38 0.001472372 7.599153e-01 0.0014695214 c. f = 80%res_srs_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4217.431 4212.610 4215.117 16.429791 20.92436 7.208166
## 2 10 6149.110 6165.609 6150.795 25.700485 262.96393 22.561726
## 3 11 4631.796 4652.781 4632.778 19.290717 445.71952 18.248235
## 4 12 4917.832 4609.877 4917.763 21.093985 94827.26490 21.089288
## 5 13 5126.213 5208.748 5126.437 18.474566 6803.67172 18.424313
## 6 14 5921.547 5875.228 5921.112 20.006312 2139.58117 19.816019
## 7 15 6341.686 6243.899 6341.450 23.110139 9550.64376 23.054042
## 8 16 5096.464 4907.863 5096.379 16.124627 35578.19558 16.117297
## 9 17 5266.120 5393.170 5266.265 18.461082 16135.48214 18.439910
## 10 18 4964.552 5089.954 4964.697 18.198892 15714.05353 18.177778
## 11 19 4751.072 4393.919 4751.026 16.577516 127556.72705 16.575360
## 12 2 4694.847 4751.412 4695.195 19.590353 3187.79134 19.469489
## 13 20 4521.961 4391.294 4521.818 18.769622 17074.63737 18.748946
## 14 21 4845.808 4749.073 4845.617 18.437219 9357.22618 18.400721
## 15 22 5453.700 5516.116 5453.988 17.976090 3882.75997 17.892939
## 16 23 5269.107 5295.556 5269.888 20.455437 686.34966 19.837388
## 17 24 5362.303 5412.605 5362.620 15.931154 2519.82102 15.830034
## 18 25 5428.429 5438.028 5430.560 17.144256 88.10064 11.652439
## 19 26 4729.201 4818.961 4729.375 15.621796 8049.21162 15.591359
## 20 27 4774.926 4773.863 4774.511 13.709377 11.91787 5.815897
## 21 28 4699.952 4654.018 4699.551 18.294934 2109.88613 18.132104
## 22 29 5233.391 5231.685 5232.429 16.661340 13.50366 7.424938
## 23 3 4707.667 4793.803 4707.909 20.851500 7405.53406 20.792766
## 24 4 5054.853 5044.872 5052.687 20.922666 97.35601 14.485167
## 25 5 5190.549 5211.537 5191.493 17.935135 452.65471 16.909472
## 26 6 5927.279 5910.329 5925.953 21.940318 272.71079 20.138414
## 27 7 6685.482 6940.638 6685.569 22.209462 65089.81671 22.201882
## 28 71 3694.207 3580.448 3694.092 12.993191 12930.20142 12.980145
## 29 72 3067.188 3394.240 3067.227 12.713463 106953.27614 12.711949
## 30 73 4788.287 4260.501 4788.253 18.240531 278562.30532 18.239335
## 31 74 3646.284 3491.289 3646.218 10.207701 24020.89391 10.203353
## 32 75 3199.628 3437.161 3199.681 12.725169 56415.40489 12.722294
## 33 76 3125.687 3467.417 3125.725 12.779057 116786.39000 12.777657
## 34 77 3210.665 3383.463 3210.746 14.031881 29853.81689 14.025267
## 35 78 6973.917 7095.279 6974.131 25.981123 14707.88164 25.935220
## 36 79 3360.372 3443.423 3360.479 8.943122 6892.90330 8.931484
## 37 8 5020.115 4882.292 5019.998 16.107413 18999.21068 16.093680
## 38 9 6895.224 6821.890 6894.911 22.972291 5361.37569 22.873706
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.003895698 0.004970205 0.001710186
## 2 0.004179535 0.042649378 0.003668369
## 3 0.004164777 0.095801365 0.003939030
## 4 0.004289255 20.570448960 0.004288359
## 5 0.003603995 1.306223785 0.003594035
## 6 0.003378545 0.364174895 0.003346652
## 7 0.003644169 1.529599234 0.003635458
## 8 0.003163890 7.249250302 0.003162505
## 9 0.003505642 2.991838632 0.003501525
## 10 0.003665777 3.087283203 0.003661417
## 11 0.003489197 29.030208203 0.003488777
## 12 0.004172713 0.670929960 0.004146664
## 13 0.004150724 3.888340113 0.004146284
## 14 0.003804756 1.970318054 0.003797373
## 15 0.003296175 0.703893594 0.003280755
## 16 0.003882137 0.129616878 0.003764303
## 17 0.002970947 0.465549169 0.002951915
## 18 0.003158218 0.016201092 0.002146345
## 19 0.003303254 1.670302847 0.003296697
## 20 0.002871122 0.002496533 0.001218042
## 21 0.003892559 0.453359239 0.003858239
## 22 0.003183644 0.002581090 0.001419011
## 23 0.004429282 1.544823028 0.004416579
## 24 0.004139145 0.019298585 0.002866022
## 25 0.003455364 0.086858389 0.003257362
## 26 0.003701569 0.046139345 0.003398271
## 27 0.003322059 9.378076786 0.003320882
## 28 0.003517158 3.611339843 0.003513736
## 29 0.004144987 31.510198754 0.004144441
## 30 0.003809391 65.382573220 0.003809169
## 31 0.002799490 6.880251199 0.002798348
## 32 0.003977063 16.413362151 0.003976098
## 33 0.004088402 33.681001509 0.004087905
## 34 0.004370352 8.823412051 0.004368182
## 35 0.003725454 2.072918589 0.003718758
## 36 0.002661327 2.001752940 0.002657779
## 37 0.003208588 3.891460985 0.003205927
## 38 0.003331626 0.785912693 0.003317480 d. f = 70%res_srs_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4219.698 4211.706 4216.346 28.09899 45.61859 14.42817
## 2 10 6151.935 6164.659 6155.185 44.58035 151.99058 30.25233
## 3 11 4627.168 4650.208 4628.702 33.14687 528.89861 30.62659
## 4 12 4914.377 4607.017 4914.260 35.87448 94467.93452 35.86085
## 5 13 5122.290 5203.854 5122.688 32.40632 6623.75084 32.24766
## 6 14 5924.794 5872.609 5924.115 35.21539 2704.59666 34.74991
## 7 15 6344.236 6244.010 6343.839 39.69274 10025.71360 39.53464
## 8 16 5100.425 4908.610 5100.282 27.48591 36785.91129 27.46534
## 9 17 5260.843 5394.211 5261.082 31.80306 17776.09861 31.74590
## 10 18 4967.121 5089.401 4967.375 30.90939 14947.94576 30.84483
## 11 19 4749.972 4393.679 4749.893 27.92906 126971.47759 27.92289
## 12 2 4691.972 4752.132 4692.534 33.58696 3602.61754 33.26924
## 13 20 4519.798 4391.351 4519.545 32.40900 16494.28205 32.34506
## 14 21 4845.157 4749.029 4844.822 32.07887 9248.94980 31.96604
## 15 22 5456.696 5512.780 5457.254 31.17113 3127.54305 30.85894
## 16 23 5260.142 5292.329 5261.272 35.64928 1020.38989 34.34488
## 17 24 5359.138 5410.148 5359.659 26.50567 2583.79654 26.23217
## 18 25 5423.218 5436.158 5425.581 29.59922 143.52379 23.83181
## 19 26 4733.720 4819.322 4734.028 26.36264 7304.49432 26.26757
## 20 27 4770.548 4771.145 4771.013 23.60433 19.17873 10.42633
## 21 28 4692.275 4652.053 4691.494 30.59288 1631.88794 29.96751
## 22 29 5237.149 5235.606 5236.332 28.43423 25.81638 13.51845
## 23 3 4704.991 4789.050 4705.425 36.36256 7052.72058 36.17407
## 24 4 5054.134 5046.054 5051.146 35.57637 82.00485 17.37794
## 25 5 5199.635 5211.960 5202.540 30.59954 149.37998 20.97532
## 26 6 5922.291 5910.042 5919.066 37.51323 138.66575 24.84128
## 27 7 6684.395 6940.754 6684.543 37.74656 65732.44396 37.72479
## 28 71 3696.797 3579.143 3696.606 22.42612 13846.91720 22.38947
## 29 72 3063.130 3392.336 3063.197 21.90992 108375.54538 21.90549
## 30 73 4775.893 4254.991 4775.834 30.56947 271329.69922 30.56603
## 31 74 3648.536 3489.856 3648.424 17.77796 25170.48463 17.76535
## 32 75 3196.990 3435.767 3197.082 22.10092 57015.39609 22.09234
## 33 76 3123.700 3462.682 3123.764 21.84998 114902.91761 21.84582
## 34 77 3213.909 3381.066 3214.051 23.71641 27936.59868 23.69618
## 35 78 6974.604 7095.435 6974.970 44.20477 14577.72967 44.07030
## 36 79 3355.093 3441.694 3355.274 15.68248 7492.81797 15.64955
## 37 8 5015.512 4882.239 5015.310 26.87231 17750.64736 26.83154
## 38 9 6895.350 6822.549 6894.802 39.78139 5281.80973 39.47853
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.006658986 0.01083417 0.003421378
## 2 0.007246514 0.02465439 0.004916067
## 3 0.007163539 0.11370230 0.006616785
## 4 0.007299770 20.50485446 0.007297169
## 5 0.006326535 1.27287886 0.006295072
## 6 0.005943754 0.46053465 0.005865851
## 7 0.006256516 1.60565440 0.006231984
## 8 0.005388923 7.49427046 0.005385040
## 9 0.006045201 3.29544593 0.006034062
## 10 0.006222607 2.93708334 0.006209294
## 11 0.005879912 28.89854547 0.005878710
## 12 0.007158358 0.75811683 0.007089801
## 13 0.007170335 3.75609836 0.007156587
## 14 0.006620775 1.94758599 0.006597941
## 15 0.005712530 0.56734637 0.005654745
## 16 0.006777332 0.19280880 0.006528019
## 17 0.004945825 0.47759191 0.004894318
## 18 0.005457897 0.02640216 0.004392738
## 19 0.005569108 1.51567621 0.005548662
## 20 0.004947942 0.00401989 0.002185362
## 21 0.006519636 0.35080160 0.006387367
## 22 0.005429359 0.00493091 0.002581669
## 23 0.007728687 1.47269320 0.007687921
## 24 0.007039207 0.01625222 0.003438745
## 25 0.005885010 0.02865944 0.004033007
## 26 0.006334221 0.02346118 0.004195623
## 27 0.005646885 9.47069065 0.005643505
## 28 0.006066365 3.86884229 0.006056764
## 29 0.007152722 31.94722678 0.007151118
## 30 0.006400665 63.76756041 0.006400022
## 31 0.004872764 7.21244381 0.004869458
## 32 0.006913135 16.59464086 0.006910252
## 33 0.006995070 33.18289847 0.006993593
## 34 0.007379143 8.26256587 0.007372522
## 35 0.006337956 2.05451268 0.006318345
## 36 0.004674277 2.17706929 0.004664211
## 37 0.005357808 3.63573007 0.005349894
## 38 0.005769292 0.77420005 0.005725823 e. f = 60%res_srs_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4213.974 4212.417 4212.897 44.24996 31.91289 17.99922
## 2 10 6154.844 6170.773 6159.504 67.42212 212.10820 43.74137
## 3 11 4629.434 4649.265 4632.388 53.46707 376.51556 43.82853
## 4 12 4923.218 4610.679 4923.043 54.72523 97671.44235 54.69450
## 5 13 5118.337 5204.040 5118.911 49.06925 7310.32522 48.73918
## 6 14 5922.846 5874.196 5921.709 54.51281 2347.61112 53.20446
## 7 15 6344.108 6243.856 6343.504 60.44211 10010.89856 60.07618
## 8 16 5100.443 4905.285 5100.220 43.49377 38068.35256 43.44369
## 9 17 5256.155 5392.855 5256.510 48.55063 18648.07265 48.42420
## 10 18 4962.479 5090.129 4962.862 48.91774 16265.22305 48.77060
## 11 19 4750.182 4390.820 4750.058 44.80221 129120.91938 44.78660
## 12 2 4695.005 4748.234 4695.994 52.26742 2796.64897 51.28025
## 13 20 4520.326 4390.700 4519.940 50.05314 16782.24343 49.90355
## 14 21 4847.352 4746.901 4846.858 49.54321 10071.04176 49.29931
## 15 22 5455.916 5516.064 5456.732 48.66356 3599.53532 47.98919
## 16 23 5265.118 5296.362 5266.910 55.22939 935.45029 51.97213
## 17 24 5361.744 5411.816 5362.593 42.19402 2482.48034 41.46617
## 18 25 5429.700 5440.203 5434.179 46.82496 81.09380 22.78921
## 19 26 4727.379 4816.417 4727.840 40.91920 7921.94760 40.70536
## 20 27 4770.669 4773.891 4771.815 35.74541 33.93921 14.23888
## 21 28 4702.049 4654.276 4700.994 49.54117 2276.08067 48.40670
## 22 29 5231.137 5229.723 5230.403 43.52108 41.14183 21.13933
## 23 3 4711.631 4793.966 4712.333 57.51066 6755.12333 57.01434
## 24 4 5052.969 5043.466 5048.849 54.80653 86.44958 26.33579
## 25 5 5187.733 5209.540 5189.999 46.78138 461.68638 41.39846
## 26 6 5928.586 5910.097 5925.427 57.66084 287.82526 47.52321
## 27 7 6675.911 6935.658 6676.138 59.00133 67461.83796 58.94967
## 28 71 3696.708 3579.575 3696.412 34.64635 13712.38895 34.55824
## 29 72 3064.719 3393.754 3064.825 34.64517 108271.63987 34.63397
## 30 73 4785.639 4256.383 4785.545 49.61174 280077.37583 49.60295
## 31 74 3643.737 3491.287 3643.560 26.94697 23227.29903 26.91556
## 32 75 3204.527 3436.690 3204.678 34.94407 53879.79066 34.92130
## 33 76 3124.642 3466.828 3124.739 32.95081 117077.16143 32.94150
## 34 77 3203.172 3381.166 3203.375 36.10406 31662.06984 36.06270
## 35 78 6966.547 7088.201 6967.111 68.59045 14752.72432 68.27137
## 36 79 3356.194 3443.268 3356.469 23.89921 7563.72483 23.82355
## 37 8 5021.797 4883.167 5021.486 43.17498 19185.98298 43.07771
## 38 9 6896.975 6821.956 6896.150 61.69054 5592.17272 61.00785
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.010500701 0.007575150 0.004272088
## 2 0.010954443 0.034375860 0.007103553
## 3 0.011548811 0.081002943 0.009462374
## 4 0.011115781 21.184222288 0.011109934
## 5 0.009587040 1.404765578 0.009521487
## 6 0.009203860 0.399648165 0.008984637
## 7 0.009527090 1.603274488 0.009470310
## 8 0.008527790 7.760732050 0.008518345
## 9 0.009236969 3.457923583 0.009212292
## 10 0.009857631 3.195393638 0.009827220
## 11 0.009431782 29.407069958 0.009428744
## 12 0.011132304 0.589005518 0.010919782
## 13 0.011072549 3.822232055 0.011040401
## 14 0.010220220 2.121613830 0.010170938
## 15 0.008919379 0.652497609 0.008794471
## 16 0.010489800 0.176621896 0.009867892
## 17 0.007869510 0.458720008 0.007732552
## 18 0.008623942 0.014901464 0.004194867
## 19 0.008655874 1.644738806 0.008609804
## 20 0.007492770 0.007109560 0.002984995
## 21 0.010535931 0.489004203 0.010296878
## 22 0.008319457 0.007866824 0.004041564
## 23 0.012206399 1.409092457 0.012099267
## 24 0.010846187 0.017138939 0.005213312
## 25 0.009017789 0.088617620 0.007977161
## 26 0.009726014 0.048696183 0.008020047
## 27 0.008838129 9.726945187 0.008830090
## 28 0.009372056 3.830628955 0.009348967
## 29 0.011303069 31.903191447 0.011299024
## 30 0.010366635 65.802010460 0.010365002
## 31 0.007395461 6.652867377 0.007387198
## 32 0.010904113 15.677749740 0.010896497
## 33 0.010545507 33.770736776 0.010542204
## 34 0.011271331 9.364457171 0.011257703
## 35 0.009845814 2.081324923 0.009799221
## 36 0.007120901 2.196642003 0.007097776
## 37 0.008597456 3.929003457 0.008578618
## 38 0.008944302 0.819729015 0.008846372 f. f = 50%res_srs_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4214.448 4211.044 4212.347 66.35061 51.13736 28.13164
## 2 10 6159.496 6168.204 6164.405 101.81959 89.84588 40.27386
## 3 11 4634.265 4654.179 4638.667 78.77688 351.94984 56.80584
## 4 12 4917.423 4612.444 4917.143 85.44515 92982.10418 85.36617
## 5 13 5128.539 5206.336 5129.512 74.90919 6051.20225 73.94899
## 6 14 5924.606 5874.696 5922.912 82.36325 2460.23138 79.39378
## 7 15 6348.898 6242.940 6348.060 88.65982 11156.86869 87.95420
## 8 16 5101.969 4906.338 5101.640 64.25956 38243.22893 64.15039
## 9 17 5265.611 5391.802 5266.178 71.31062 15898.26210 70.98634
## 10 18 4968.291 5089.657 4968.875 70.61161 14693.43936 70.26986
## 11 19 4745.550 4391.901 4745.362 66.30473 125044.11457 66.26943
## 12 2 4695.584 4748.581 4697.100 79.19550 2772.25160 76.86098
## 13 20 4516.057 4390.891 4515.458 74.77800 15631.15800 74.41711
## 14 21 4841.291 4748.203 4840.484 75.00189 8621.02643 74.34850
## 15 22 5450.553 5512.052 5451.751 72.80047 3753.52548 71.34146
## 16 23 5264.860 5295.410 5267.831 81.20087 918.10037 70.72996
## 17 24 5353.769 5406.618 5354.982 63.19273 2784.37435 61.69729
## 18 25 5420.506 5434.263 5425.552 68.46675 140.75820 39.30223
## 19 26 4735.971 4817.446 4736.716 60.42113 6604.22325 59.86057
## 20 27 4776.481 4774.956 4776.677 54.46272 75.02093 25.82877
## 21 28 4694.608 4652.944 4692.852 71.69840 1698.20235 68.53762
## 22 29 5239.093 5237.424 5238.234 67.31701 64.18798 32.84963
## 23 3 4707.496 4792.876 4708.497 84.40755 7273.41161 83.38296
## 24 4 5047.093 5043.632 5044.245 87.38736 69.63329 35.59995
## 25 5 5199.503 5211.530 5203.217 72.03817 189.00650 40.36661
## 26 6 5918.632 5910.576 5913.888 84.45984 66.31634 32.34362
## 27 7 6676.367 6940.825 6676.698 87.35732 69908.44994 87.24776
## 28 71 3697.497 3580.262 3697.053 52.00041 13723.09648 51.80268
## 29 72 3063.531 3394.305 3063.690 52.59824 109398.91599 52.57265
## 30 73 4786.032 4258.159 4785.897 71.36402 278636.19305 71.34572
## 31 74 3645.385 3491.639 3645.126 39.78351 23617.66068 39.71596
## 32 75 3200.151 3437.208 3200.366 50.96519 56159.79646 50.91890
## 33 76 3127.892 3468.230 3128.040 50.42364 115810.63952 50.40158
## 34 77 3208.099 3381.442 3208.417 55.02813 30017.22217 54.92692
## 35 78 6972.413 7092.872 6973.298 106.49046 14417.89059 105.70553
## 36 79 3360.199 3443.716 3360.619 34.85567 6979.76002 34.67626
## 37 8 5019.816 4882.456 5019.362 62.27636 18828.31591 62.06908
## 38 9 6893.878 6823.795 6892.537 93.55164 4834.97596 91.73954
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.01574314 0.01214400 0.006678457
## 2 0.01653090 0.01457222 0.006535945
## 3 0.01699862 0.07561786 0.012251314
## 4 0.01737644 20.15871681 0.017361369
## 5 0.01460640 1.16216483 0.014416485
## 6 0.01390248 0.41875200 0.013404806
## 7 0.01396445 1.78708687 0.013855140
## 8 0.01259569 7.79471957 0.012575103
## 9 0.01354228 2.94859848 0.013479244
## 10 0.01421233 2.88693865 0.014141890
## 11 0.01397212 28.47175352 0.013965234
## 12 0.01686559 0.58377363 0.016363256
## 13 0.01655859 3.55981751 0.016480851
## 14 0.01549166 1.81566779 0.015359257
## 15 0.01335651 0.68095873 0.013086029
## 16 0.01542400 0.17340544 0.013431702
## 17 0.01180418 0.51499356 0.011522309
## 18 0.01263136 0.02589548 0.007245431
## 19 0.01275788 1.37086651 0.012637535
## 20 0.01140265 0.01572004 0.005406056
## 21 0.01527291 0.36491665 0.014604750
## 22 0.01284905 0.01225559 0.006271136
## 23 0.01792872 1.51772322 0.017707441
## 24 0.01731364 0.01380528 0.007058588
## 25 0.01385503 0.03626008 0.007762204
## 26 0.01426937 0.01122058 0.005468241
## 27 0.01308438 10.07201193 0.013067325
## 28 0.01406314 3.83304943 0.014011349
## 29 0.01716829 32.23004748 0.017159041
## 30 0.01491046 65.43567312 0.014907056
## 31 0.01091390 6.76398723 0.010896145
## 32 0.01592656 16.33900221 0.015911028
## 33 0.01612045 33.39118937 0.016112630
## 34 0.01715254 8.87709934 0.017119298
## 35 0.01527343 2.03272268 0.015158924
## 36 0.01037257 2.02673349 0.010317899
## 37 0.01240611 3.85634551 0.012365938
## 38 0.01357004 0.70862469 0.013309795 g. f = 40%res_srs_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4217.722 4212.808 4213.670 97.15800 47.28189 28.35899
## 2 10 6149.432 6163.649 6156.612 151.09438 178.65744 60.35097
## 3 11 4623.487 4644.355 4628.980 117.23091 363.48244 81.03491
## 4 12 4923.551 4605.688 4923.152 126.59003 100999.32106 126.43004
## 5 13 5123.034 5201.563 5124.463 111.59348 6087.29427 109.53597
## 6 14 5912.444 5870.456 5909.356 118.51208 1771.91933 107.86547
## 7 15 6346.865 6244.675 6345.509 137.21422 10404.85503 135.35365
## 8 16 5091.681 4904.310 5091.174 94.80966 35038.67202 94.55164
## 9 17 5271.057 5391.724 5271.971 109.77948 14490.68559 108.93345
## 10 18 4964.713 5087.758 4965.592 107.48485 15164.76114 106.70692
## 11 19 4754.653 4392.059 4754.379 99.36445 131450.96141 99.28852
## 12 2 4685.354 4749.036 4687.209 115.79991 4041.36512 112.28483
## 13 20 4521.222 4388.345 4520.361 114.05401 17665.66169 113.30876
## 14 21 4851.312 4747.062 4850.240 110.60909 10848.10360 109.43637
## 15 22 5453.974 5514.286 5455.846 111.96047 3551.26393 108.41887
## 16 23 5263.930 5292.808 5268.551 121.61684 777.71822 97.83365
## 17 24 5362.102 5409.786 5364.067 93.09244 2198.95237 89.19470
## 18 25 5426.445 5439.466 5432.153 104.00921 155.12754 49.14337
## 19 26 4728.487 4815.465 4729.541 90.40908 7555.89878 89.27141
## 20 27 4776.085 4770.904 4773.855 79.91975 79.33191 32.71505
## 21 28 4693.680 4652.189 4690.907 113.14291 1648.84775 105.34962
## 22 29 5234.344 5232.633 5233.463 98.68426 94.75568 48.32715
## 23 3 4709.701 4795.475 4711.184 126.50636 7281.06889 124.29157
## 24 4 5052.032 5043.409 5048.637 125.71062 150.57890 62.94441
## 25 5 5192.213 5208.599 5197.039 109.22081 376.01643 60.26656
## 26 6 5913.859 5907.325 5909.679 129.77877 140.21613 56.03206
## 27 7 6671.620 6934.617 6672.126 132.88601 69139.20849 132.62751
## 28 71 3694.088 3579.737 3693.401 78.31397 13071.11328 77.83732
## 29 72 3067.047 3393.504 3067.282 76.58288 106537.37063 76.52733
## 30 73 4784.524 4261.120 4784.312 110.90737 273975.17671 110.86231
## 31 74 3647.602 3490.465 3647.219 60.09812 24668.10400 59.95051
## 32 75 3195.329 3436.257 3195.647 76.51865 58033.65737 76.41727
## 33 76 3124.458 3466.437 3124.672 72.94416 116942.78878 72.89779
## 34 77 3212.809 3383.504 3213.304 84.09095 29132.82328 83.84413
## 35 78 6979.600 7098.279 6980.905 154.10398 13997.24794 152.38530
## 36 79 3347.877 3442.652 3348.474 56.32135 8965.99753 55.96048
## 37 8 5011.025 4879.938 5010.288 95.94273 17212.53773 95.39550
## 38 9 6891.394 6818.410 6889.502 137.43339 5216.17137 133.82142
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.02303321 0.01122472 0.006730674
## 2 0.02457013 0.02900709 0.009810073
## 3 0.02535513 0.07828032 0.017511670
## 4 0.02571160 21.92932431 0.025681190
## 5 0.02178188 1.17029059 0.021374375
## 6 0.02004520 0.30187933 0.018251749
## 7 0.02161916 1.66622100 0.021330501
## 8 0.01862076 7.14454504 0.018571942
## 9 0.02082632 2.68749748 0.020662232
## 10 0.02165053 2.98039608 0.021490068
## 11 0.02090050 29.92907759 0.020885745
## 12 0.02471713 0.85104624 0.023957789
## 13 0.02522516 4.02607537 0.025065075
## 14 0.02280057 2.28509606 0.022563710
## 15 0.02052792 0.64397610 0.019871782
## 16 0.02310460 0.14688554 0.018573144
## 17 0.01736190 0.40654026 0.016629020
## 18 0.01916723 0.02852782 0.009052308
## 19 0.01911967 1.56909618 0.018874944
## 20 0.01673276 0.01663296 0.006850474
## 21 0.02410462 0.35440839 0.022456870
## 22 0.01885378 0.01810946 0.009234628
## 23 0.02686210 1.51820260 0.026383558
## 24 0.02488251 0.02985135 0.012462506
## 25 0.02103551 0.07213580 0.011607288
## 26 0.02194452 0.02373360 0.009480686
## 27 0.01991673 9.97031797 0.019876480
## 28 0.02119954 3.65163393 0.021074422
## 29 0.02496991 31.39537748 0.024949869
## 30 0.02318115 64.29614901 0.023172763
## 31 0.01647576 7.06736581 0.016437021
## 32 0.02394727 16.88882868 0.023913168
## 33 0.02334363 33.73539133 0.023327175
## 34 0.02617223 8.61029393 0.026091408
## 35 0.02207890 1.97205280 0.021828616
## 36 0.01682181 2.60436284 0.016711065
## 37 0.01914588 3.52747430 0.019039448
## 38 0.01994161 0.76499780 0.019422835 h. f = 30%res_srs_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4203.826 4204.234 4204.304 150.87883 192.77236 79.21268
## 2 10 6153.172 6169.597 6163.530 237.63102 185.99683 74.66368
## 3 11 4632.452 4649.911 4637.196 190.70404 450.62926 114.58828
## 4 12 4905.947 4607.954 4905.275 199.55198 88792.66756 199.09905
## 5 13 5117.686 5202.400 5119.637 164.04045 7077.43193 160.19171
## 6 14 5924.406 5867.716 5920.907 191.54046 3124.62769 178.70062
## 7 15 6334.748 6234.340 6332.491 223.60915 10008.52460 218.44175
## 8 16 5093.865 4903.272 5093.074 150.45052 36255.11569 149.81964
## 9 17 5255.278 5387.423 5256.617 175.00165 17418.71545 173.16506
## 10 18 4956.805 5086.385 4958.138 170.13837 16808.12872 168.28378
## 11 19 4734.287 4385.685 4733.843 154.82742 121601.98844 154.62868
## 12 2 4693.833 4741.605 4697.973 175.26224 2279.86505 154.52480
## 13 20 4512.533 4384.337 4511.116 180.29634 16442.77954 178.26866
## 14 21 4838.562 4741.313 4836.791 170.96019 9351.65650 167.78605
## 15 22 5456.861 5515.740 5459.643 161.10370 3364.85354 153.15845
## 16 23 5269.949 5295.138 5277.130 180.50669 597.54703 116.19092
## 17 24 5354.584 5408.255 5357.172 136.28143 2807.67760 129.41162
## 18 25 5418.941 5428.759 5423.546 159.81990 166.35606 71.95043
## 19 26 4718.764 4813.266 4720.281 142.47527 8854.95677 140.14953
## 20 27 4770.270 4769.608 4771.241 128.12351 95.29685 43.87948
## 21 28 4707.160 4649.466 4704.060 165.99056 3390.40861 155.49570
## 22 29 5221.257 5218.396 5219.767 160.08055 150.45862 77.52043
## 23 3 4688.131 4784.550 4690.056 183.99662 9193.46099 180.21759
## 24 4 5043.866 5036.635 5040.403 205.05460 236.78704 84.99345
## 25 5 5185.563 5202.905 5194.702 167.44196 163.72886 71.50402
## 26 6 5920.128 5903.859 5912.525 213.23559 268.95344 83.48557
## 27 7 6670.314 6933.531 6671.114 209.55162 69299.41561 208.90643
## 28 71 3699.627 3576.316 3698.586 127.45487 15168.56001 126.35454
## 29 72 3057.736 3391.006 3058.095 119.62393 111012.68126 119.49301
## 30 73 4790.044 4257.451 4789.711 177.29145 283667.44917 177.17989
## 31 74 3642.107 3487.994 3641.463 98.74523 23721.00034 98.32649
## 32 75 3205.916 3433.315 3206.443 119.15079 51713.94727 118.87011
## 33 76 3130.757 3467.344 3131.105 116.93922 113261.02010 116.81717
## 34 77 3196.048 3378.952 3196.757 129.32384 33417.11055 128.81598
## 35 78 6965.500 7083.305 6967.648 251.15116 13728.56327 246.48230
## 36 79 3353.321 3440.437 3354.235 78.53672 7606.57940 77.68073
## 37 8 5025.033 4877.791 5024.044 145.45373 21582.59155 144.46574
## 38 9 6901.638 6830.724 6898.565 215.52354 4864.25701 205.87172
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.03588796 0.04587571 0.018840449
## 2 0.03861866 0.03017551 0.012131221
## 3 0.04117567 0.09693233 0.024735319
## 4 0.04067594 19.26869624 0.040589160
## 5 0.03205670 1.36074740 0.031292991
## 6 0.03233215 0.53244890 0.030180355
## 7 0.03529904 1.60537178 0.034495256
## 8 0.02953611 7.39435499 0.029416834
## 9 0.03329716 3.23331935 0.032939388
## 10 0.03432025 3.30483250 0.033937163
## 11 0.03269868 27.72666945 0.032659785
## 12 0.03734120 0.48072928 0.032909664
## 13 0.03995183 3.75058965 0.039514736
## 14 0.03533254 1.97242484 0.034689177
## 15 0.02952287 0.61004221 0.028052941
## 16 0.03425305 0.11288611 0.022033351
## 17 0.02545130 0.51905644 0.024156956
## 18 0.02949623 0.03061958 0.013267316
## 19 0.03019452 1.83960428 0.029692144
## 20 0.02685917 0.01998727 0.009194826
## 21 0.03526530 0.72928692 0.033053911
## 22 0.03066031 0.02883306 0.014851757
## 23 0.03924935 1.92132381 0.038427468
## 24 0.04065774 0.04699108 0.016851825
## 25 0.03228988 0.03146300 0.013768660
## 26 0.03601128 0.04551764 0.014098048
## 27 0.03141640 9.99462052 0.031315918
## 28 0.03444991 4.24165513 0.034162085
## 29 0.03911787 32.73700425 0.039070419
## 30 0.03701654 66.62637786 0.036995825
## 31 0.02711330 6.80085831 0.027003094
## 32 0.03716135 15.06235279 0.037067713
## 33 0.03735099 32.66478154 0.037307841
## 34 0.04046317 9.88940292 0.040295310
## 35 0.03605559 1.93820927 0.035374592
## 36 0.02341856 2.21071467 0.023157123
## 37 0.02894352 4.42446930 0.028752614
## 38 0.03122738 0.71221462 0.029842226 i. f = 20%res_srs_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4204.162 4210.294 4206.991 264.7276 265.8931 122.69486
## 2 10 6147.940 6159.913 6157.178 404.6032 212.1424 126.06292
## 3 11 4612.688 4629.535 4619.512 328.1080 466.0039 169.85916
## 4 12 4915.424 4595.841 4914.361 338.8068 101937.3394 337.66348
## 5 13 5101.556 5187.655 5105.072 292.3870 7329.5960 279.40766
## 6 14 5913.640 5857.924 5907.101 319.7343 3079.2130 269.56514
## 7 15 6340.554 6237.566 6337.127 347.3467 10363.7348 335.25688
## 8 16 5085.924 4897.633 5084.584 251.1691 35342.6094 249.33301
## 9 17 5262.204 5387.232 5264.680 301.9594 15671.8398 295.60139
## 10 18 4953.493 5083.452 4955.704 286.1963 16739.9706 281.26692
## 11 19 4750.013 4385.406 4749.283 266.0667 132862.7243 265.53126
## 12 2 4692.003 4744.754 4698.901 328.8003 2678.3097 274.17256
## 13 20 4504.606 4381.799 4502.201 290.5994 15016.6461 284.63398
## 14 21 4858.171 4740.880 4855.686 286.9483 13701.5345 280.63562
## 15 22 5463.474 5514.610 5469.752 300.2650 2467.2549 256.89618
## 16 23 5253.115 5288.827 5261.054 324.9591 1440.3225 213.63146
## 17 24 5354.246 5405.438 5359.346 246.0789 2468.5156 216.86635
## 18 25 5423.800 5435.157 5432.024 295.6562 130.8044 78.20997
## 19 26 4723.122 4810.305 4726.100 249.8267 7654.3796 240.51887
## 20 27 4748.947 4763.767 4754.921 231.1155 317.4277 115.74873
## 21 28 4690.309 4647.097 4682.550 298.3559 1793.4235 231.43827
## 22 29 5228.525 5225.957 5227.217 257.1503 249.7505 126.68458
## 23 3 4702.371 4790.299 4706.125 325.0010 7566.0905 310.48068
## 24 4 5033.156 5037.993 5033.826 346.7185 291.4409 139.97429
## 25 5 5201.039 5200.146 5201.315 295.9193 232.1516 117.57545
## 26 6 5906.785 5899.576 5901.319 365.0429 216.0046 127.41566
## 27 7 6646.355 6919.961 6647.602 340.7466 74808.4787 339.18493
## 28 71 3697.976 3574.672 3696.395 194.6339 15187.0069 192.11858
## 29 72 3067.919 3388.743 3068.525 193.5978 102858.1331 193.22227
## 30 73 4790.454 4256.350 4789.918 286.6791 285299.9740 286.38861
## 31 74 3650.884 3485.651 3649.924 158.2176 27265.7714 157.27141
## 32 75 3186.051 3431.098 3186.852 194.5098 60130.6313 193.85135
## 33 76 3123.786 3461.809 3124.344 188.2765 114196.8162 187.96082
## 34 77 3191.754 3379.503 3192.923 217.9817 35224.7626 216.57660
## 35 78 6969.305 7089.690 6972.871 425.1564 14243.3198 412.26514
## 36 79 3334.491 3438.002 3335.861 141.4231 10617.7300 139.52516
## 37 8 5016.740 4874.540 5015.108 230.0399 20173.3828 227.33103
## 38 9 6889.166 6817.078 6884.227 352.7890 4891.8425 328.01089
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.06295782 0.06315915 0.02917091
## 2 0.06580664 0.03440865 0.02046006
## 3 0.07113048 0.10059154 0.03677754
## 4 0.06893115 22.18082557 0.06871347
## 5 0.05730966 1.41271280 0.05472962
## 6 0.05407469 0.52570932 0.04562200
## 7 0.05479022 1.66141338 0.05291107
## 8 0.04939058 7.21656228 0.04904256
## 9 0.05738090 2.90898550 0.05614744
## 10 0.05778065 3.29311786 0.05676036
## 11 0.05601250 30.29733112 0.05590839
## 12 0.07007264 0.56472980 0.05837860
## 13 0.06451469 3.42727854 0.06322349
## 14 0.05906311 2.88982711 0.05779229
## 15 0.05495725 0.44743276 0.04697512
## 16 0.06186973 0.27227318 0.04066929
## 17 0.04595242 0.45671497 0.04046466
## 18 0.05451550 0.02408232 0.01440913
## 19 0.05289656 1.59112235 0.05089547
## 20 0.04866434 0.06663941 0.02436107
## 21 0.06362239 0.38615623 0.04941661
## 22 0.04917827 0.04778537 0.02423335
## 23 0.06910703 1.57991336 0.06596957
## 24 0.06888098 0.05783387 0.02781643
## 25 0.05689669 0.04464717 0.02259580
## 26 0.06180930 0.03660670 0.02158858
## 27 0.05127749 10.81229453 0.05103294
## 28 0.05261980 4.24865817 0.05196179
## 29 0.06308990 30.35161057 0.06295489
## 30 0.05982836 67.03013118 0.05977449
## 31 0.04333704 7.82156409 0.04308934
## 32 0.06103219 17.52697621 0.06081036
## 33 0.06027680 32.98565069 0.06016484
## 34 0.06829693 10.42297140 0.06783162
## 35 0.06100287 2.00882889 0.05912335
## 36 0.04241473 3.08816468 0.04182823
## 37 0.04585183 4.13883621 0.04532654
## 38 0.05121342 0.71760982 0.04764982 j. f = 10%res_srs_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4209.943 4193.254 4205.296 556.4114 875.1348 265.4614
## 2 10 6155.572 6155.327 6152.202 896.4634 804.5177 354.7597
## 3 11 4624.276 4627.728 4626.216 669.5460 596.2088 313.7463
## 4 12 4892.276 4589.405 4889.694 782.4219 91325.0145 775.6705
## 5 13 5080.150 5169.033 5087.983 658.1169 7521.8929 590.4557
## 6 14 5925.501 5842.667 5915.851 708.3874 6576.9471 592.8226
## 7 15 6356.499 6233.626 6349.578 826.9329 14774.1189 776.9850
## 8 16 5087.130 4882.298 5084.482 538.7387 41652.1357 531.5054
## 9 17 5217.435 5361.306 5221.942 642.0345 20326.6100 621.1719
## 10 18 4937.302 5059.895 4942.555 614.8969 14910.7334 584.7483
## 11 19 4737.975 4368.170 4736.453 563.4928 136374.1786 561.0995
## 12 2 4674.615 4715.227 4689.640 683.3317 1235.6339 390.9257
## 13 20 4485.106 4350.994 4480.277 644.9829 17788.1878 621.3940
## 14 21 4817.880 4719.267 4810.942 617.5336 9914.2435 561.1753
## 15 22 5461.196 5500.258 5473.921 660.9145 1516.4648 378.9299
## 16 23 5237.866 5290.888 5251.733 688.7692 2718.3474 447.6488
## 17 24 5335.698 5400.191 5344.612 544.0631 3889.1308 458.9764
## 18 25 5401.212 5425.109 5414.531 603.1098 528.3019 236.3804
## 19 26 4691.270 4783.745 4697.459 566.2592 8142.9955 527.3985
## 20 27 4731.734 4747.979 4738.050 481.7789 581.6739 230.0867
## 21 28 4664.213 4620.181 4652.964 671.0080 2237.0278 427.4292
## 22 29 5195.664 5193.702 5194.662 535.5033 527.1814 265.6067
## 23 3 4681.088 4772.939 4689.677 709.3697 8413.4461 621.7767
## 24 4 4991.940 5011.390 4999.497 778.0726 1058.9344 348.3422
## 25 5 5154.083 5170.770 5165.126 651.3947 433.7761 236.9889
## 26 6 5869.321 5859.759 5863.521 823.2036 560.1752 313.6196
## 27 7 6632.109 6918.413 6634.653 726.4400 81468.5311 719.8786
## 28 71 3696.259 3567.614 3692.808 434.9357 16342.2127 422.2651
## 29 72 3040.139 3381.482 3041.652 514.6835 116512.4142 512.3017
## 30 73 4794.335 4263.662 4793.025 692.9874 281636.2905 691.2434
## 31 74 3648.743 3476.654 3646.598 367.3513 29371.1235 362.6979
## 32 75 3164.920 3422.914 3166.764 468.2575 66801.2489 464.7135
## 33 76 3128.930 3468.615 3130.221 437.0300 115145.8838 435.2927
## 34 77 3191.379 3370.659 3194.308 514.6782 32231.0050 505.5561
## 35 78 6965.904 7083.352 6973.368 877.0423 12987.5831 820.6983
## 36 79 3346.126 3430.263 3350.345 323.1922 7159.3747 302.5444
## 37 8 4987.870 4857.891 4983.423 573.3928 16737.6015 552.5247
## 38 9 6898.318 6825.354 6886.883 765.1744 5037.4973 618.9620
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.13210472 0.20909444 0.06304498
## 2 0.14560955 0.13060626 0.05764429
## 3 0.14475597 0.12883388 0.06781145
## 4 0.15987851 19.89932537 0.15858346
## 5 0.12952361 1.45488978 0.11604307
## 6 0.11959332 1.12563623 0.10018812
## 7 0.13007570 2.36861245 0.12234031
## 8 0.10591242 8.53150939 0.10454542
## 9 0.12306698 3.79168276 0.11896680
## 10 0.12453769 2.94573111 0.11831048
## 11 0.11889670 31.21917355 0.11843113
## 12 0.14620167 0.26202860 0.08342395
## 13 0.14370241 4.08685849 0.13859080
## 14 0.12817582 2.10037373 0.11659724
## 15 0.12101152 0.27577258 0.06932636
## 16 0.13152895 0.51358395 0.08540739
## 17 0.10198450 0.72098871 0.08592632
## 18 0.11165053 0.09729989 0.04366901
## 19 0.12071185 1.70225875 0.11228407
## 20 0.10184554 0.12253275 0.04861144
## 21 0.14387587 0.48452510 0.09175676
## 22 0.10305902 0.10149574 0.05112669
## 23 0.15153196 1.76306438 0.13265223
## 24 0.15583520 0.21130211 0.06975456
## 25 0.12639005 0.08386056 0.04587013
## 26 0.14021277 0.09554802 0.05345584
## 27 0.10951442 11.77490356 0.10848347
## 28 0.11767371 4.58065863 0.11435100
## 29 0.16935087 34.45742635 0.16848097
## 30 0.14456297 66.05653825 0.14423891
## 31 0.10066767 8.44872913 0.09945097
## 32 0.14792597 19.51865721 0.14672247
## 33 0.13963909 33.19487040 0.13902506
## 34 0.16123508 9.55971542 0.15823209
## 35 0.12589482 1.83303751 0.11767923
## 36 0.09658353 2.08612984 0.09032546
## 37 0.11493306 3.44640194 0.11085071
## 38 0.11094120 0.73786432 0.08985787 k. f = 5%res_srs_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4155.505 4149.867 4151.453 1224.2922 835.6602 472.0179
## 2 10 6128.526 6099.136 6115.754 1815.7103 2113.7322 798.0999
## 3 11 4548.667 4567.106 4560.165 1600.0986 1230.6085 666.3080
## 4 12 4804.449 4528.476 4798.926 1487.4124 76073.2836 1453.9863
## 5 13 5086.741 5117.792 5110.948 1524.6507 657.1449 422.6026
## 6 14 5836.227 5788.927 5822.313 1458.1814 3529.5042 785.9429
## 7 15 6342.391 6191.773 6330.429 1721.8853 21728.7832 1565.0796
## 8 16 5019.580 4819.252 5013.888 1127.1902 39244.2461 1092.3414
## 9 17 5152.149 5304.149 5161.736 1379.3323 22992.7857 1279.0820
## 10 18 4845.710 4993.376 4857.514 1353.3733 22873.5262 1121.3213
## 11 19 4663.310 4318.571 4659.804 1208.6168 118165.2040 1195.6923
## 12 2 4601.551 4664.110 4623.590 1431.0036 3323.2302 808.4163
## 13 20 4411.531 4287.592 4397.897 1629.4724 14171.6240 1429.3799
## 14 21 4818.920 4668.053 4809.728 1234.3109 23549.9259 1133.3876
## 15 22 5388.275 5433.268 5408.073 1448.1358 2375.9946 669.8866
## 16 23 5172.611 5221.569 5195.150 1568.0728 2359.9613 700.5354
## 17 24 5263.964 5345.167 5279.449 1156.7279 5949.1605 886.1431
## 18 25 5388.272 5386.220 5388.076 1009.2022 716.6024 399.6005
## 19 26 4692.828 4725.119 4710.856 1242.3198 1018.7422 531.0453
## 20 27 4660.157 4689.846 4678.561 917.9270 666.5009 325.2399
## 21 28 4589.071 4567.463 4579.452 1266.3162 1158.8754 527.5803
## 22 29 5157.659 5157.301 5157.473 1338.7125 1324.5072 665.7498
## 23 3 4617.211 4735.018 4631.672 1535.8079 13470.8537 1285.2734
## 24 4 4944.305 4959.104 4949.761 1409.4637 1678.7124 665.3388
## 25 5 5144.463 5118.929 5129.907 1211.5903 1045.7011 492.9592
## 26 6 5793.746 5795.721 5796.094 1860.4970 1267.3872 714.8146
## 27 7 6569.000 6876.031 6574.664 1690.6968 94170.2080 1656.3291
## 28 71 3621.683 3514.743 3612.322 914.1700 11285.5789 811.7153
## 29 72 2969.911 3326.818 2972.689 981.7518 127077.9022 973.4966
## 30 73 4735.638 4224.001 4732.722 1496.7220 261139.3902 1487.3361
## 31 74 3648.815 3421.562 3645.382 775.1938 51270.2461 762.3925
## 32 75 3099.349 3368.468 3103.147 992.2085 72040.0661 975.3912
## 33 76 3133.663 3407.373 3137.323 1000.1136 74753.4964 985.1049
## 34 77 3135.661 3324.361 3141.509 1055.0625 35897.2183 1017.2568
## 35 78 6965.959 7081.106 6982.103 1809.0323 11722.9081 1529.7720
## 36 79 3259.172 3374.699 3265.644 686.6908 13115.0657 632.7419
## 37 8 4929.870 4805.909 4919.695 1206.8658 14743.2677 1084.1120
## 38 9 6833.142 6771.707 6812.661 1716.6608 3829.2090 1013.2374
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.2946233 0.2015979 0.11381441
## 2 0.2960457 0.3459075 0.13013985
## 3 0.3516507 0.2694318 0.14609185
## 4 0.3097309 16.7955842 0.30311589
## 5 0.2996153 0.1281972 0.08259014
## 6 0.2499426 0.6097089 0.13468235
## 7 0.2716198 3.5075890 0.24729652
## 8 0.2244987 8.1459766 0.21781971
## 9 0.2677334 4.3349413 0.24787196
## 10 0.2791884 4.5889096 0.23172012
## 11 0.2591180 27.3633714 0.25654836
## 12 0.3111494 0.7122028 0.17534938
## 13 0.3694217 3.3067311 0.32501984
## 14 0.2559644 5.0427381 0.23527234
## 15 0.2691426 0.4367913 0.12415827
## 16 0.3031136 0.4525162 0.13526424
## 17 0.2199298 1.1128006 0.16812709
## 18 0.1871943 0.1329551 0.07408891
## 19 0.2647769 0.2154917 0.11272620
## 20 0.1971103 0.1421846 0.06967453
## 21 0.2759466 0.2535321 0.11504408
## 22 0.2596708 0.2569213 0.12913760
## 23 0.3325828 2.8478635 0.27786888
## 24 0.2852224 0.3387199 0.13465085
## 25 0.2354014 0.2042616 0.09603471
## 26 0.3209717 0.2187095 0.12331043
## 27 0.2573290 13.6862810 0.25188113
## 28 0.2524433 3.2094364 0.22455883
## 29 0.3305272 38.1949119 0.32742799
## 30 0.3158134 61.8286472 0.31404782
## 31 0.2124970 14.9841095 0.20919802
## 32 0.3198415 21.3801638 0.31400314
## 33 0.3192322 21.9351201 0.31404135
## 34 0.3360517 10.7958737 0.32341931
## 35 0.2595924 1.6545934 0.21901473
## 36 0.2102477 3.8879872 0.19337234
## 37 0.2449271 3.0704249 0.22045941
## 38 0.2512323 0.5653479 0.14844371 2. Metode One stage cluster
a. f = 100%res_1sc_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4220.403 4216.292 4220.403 0 1.689987e+01 0
## 2 10 6158.917 6172.297 6158.917 0 1.790177e+02 0
## 3 11 4634.496 4655.050 4634.496 0 4.224791e+02 0
## 4 12 4919.014 4612.412 4919.014 0 9.400516e+04 0
## 5 13 5127.194 5210.191 5127.194 0 6.888535e+03 0
## 6 14 5928.762 5876.421 5928.762 0 2.739513e+03 0
## 7 15 6342.583 6245.147 6342.583 0 9.493707e+03 0
## 8 16 5103.006 4911.246 5103.006 0 3.677202e+04 0
## 9 17 5268.416 5397.589 5268.416 0 1.668564e+04 0
## 10 18 4970.796 5093.818 4970.796 0 1.513452e+04 0
## 11 19 4751.743 4396.560 4751.743 0 1.261550e+05 0
## 12 2 4700.143 4755.819 4700.143 0 3.099840e+03 0
## 13 20 4525.222 4394.751 4525.222 0 1.702264e+04 0
## 14 21 4848.178 4752.708 4848.178 0 9.114580e+03 0
## 15 22 5460.264 5519.749 5460.264 0 3.538503e+03 0
## 16 23 5271.905 5297.644 5271.905 0 6.624653e+02 0
## 17 24 5362.188 5414.360 5362.188 0 2.721931e+03 0
## 18 25 5427.660 5439.128 5427.660 0 1.315308e+02 0
## 19 26 4734.623 4823.859 4734.623 0 7.963093e+03 0
## 20 27 4777.379 4776.869 4777.379 0 2.598680e-01 0
## 21 28 4702.797 4658.169 4702.797 0 1.991721e+03 0
## 22 29 5239.878 5237.877 5239.878 0 4.005938e+00 0
## 23 3 4708.626 4794.793 4708.626 0 7.424634e+03 0
## 24 4 5056.916 5048.966 5056.916 0 6.320760e+01 0
## 25 5 5198.709 5215.515 5198.709 0 2.824529e+02 0
## 26 6 5926.092 5914.324 5926.092 0 1.384940e+02 0
## 27 7 6685.010 6943.755 6685.010 0 6.694903e+04 0
## 28 71 3701.777 3582.993 3701.777 0 1.410965e+04 0
## 29 72 3067.757 3396.768 3067.757 0 1.082479e+05 0
## 30 73 4787.325 4261.271 4787.325 0 2.767331e+05 0
## 31 74 3646.103 3494.168 3646.103 0 2.308415e+04 0
## 32 75 3205.130 3439.743 3205.130 0 5.504338e+04 0
## 33 76 3125.115 3468.370 3125.115 0 1.178234e+05 0
## 34 77 3215.490 3385.882 3215.490 0 2.903334e+04 0
## 35 78 6979.747 7098.937 6979.747 0 1.420619e+04 0
## 36 79 3361.141 3446.142 3361.141 0 7.225189e+03 0
## 37 8 5024.538 4887.130 5024.538 0 1.888111e+04 0
## 38 9 6903.494 6831.826 6903.494 0 5.136210e+03 0
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0 4.008229e-03 0
## 2 0 2.900342e-02 0
## 3 0 9.075716e-02 0
## 4 0 2.038091e+01 0
## 5 0 1.322127e+00 0
## 6 0 4.661874e-01 0
## 7 0 1.520173e+00 0
## 8 0 7.487311e+00 0
## 9 0 3.091314e+00 0
## 10 0 2.971155e+00 0
## 11 0 2.869404e+01 0
## 12 0 6.517993e-01 0
## 13 0 3.873403e+00 0
## 14 0 1.917766e+00 0
## 15 0 6.410622e-01 0
## 16 0 1.250490e-01 0
## 17 0 5.027245e-01 0
## 18 0 2.418233e-02 0
## 19 0 1.650772e+00 0
## 20 0 5.440133e-05 0
## 21 0 4.275759e-01 0
## 22 0 7.648019e-04 0
## 23 0 1.548479e+00 0
## 24 0 1.251892e-02 0
## 25 0 5.415629e-02 0
## 26 0 2.341670e-02 0
## 27 0 9.641617e+00 0
## 28 0 3.937950e+00 0
## 29 0 3.186792e+01 0
## 30 0 6.494146e+01 0
## 31 0 6.606481e+00 0
## 32 0 1.600218e+01 0
## 33 0 3.397084e+01 0
## 34 0 8.574823e+00 0
## 35 0 2.001171e+00 0
## 36 0 2.096602e+00 0
## 37 0 3.863436e+00 0
## 38 0 7.518063e-01 0 b. f = 90%res_1sc_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4206.525 4194.166 4204.677 21.726908 138.66001 18.132402
## 2 10 6159.870 6151.517 6158.891 24.175115 119.34648 17.057514
## 3 11 4608.688 4631.976 4609.880 23.879443 594.00645 22.218317
## 4 12 4921.846 4597.506 4921.744 33.202694 105227.66832 33.192179
## 5 13 5086.344 5168.464 5086.550 16.828938 6757.18649 16.785789
## 6 14 5900.372 5855.750 5899.659 30.099863 2072.63161 29.562252
## 7 15 6335.437 6230.148 6335.111 33.888654 11192.55261 33.781282
## 8 16 5106.666 4884.256 5106.604 13.805887 49499.71087 13.802010
## 9 17 5223.341 5370.754 5223.474 19.633399 21723.83513 19.615537
## 10 18 4968.848 5073.381 4969.010 16.867199 10942.39639 16.840801
## 11 19 4723.400 4367.521 4723.357 15.265387 126646.85269 15.263541
## 12 2 4673.405 4729.769 4673.886 27.020005 3165.68553 26.787961
## 13 20 4469.247 4373.273 4469.069 17.070454 9244.14615 17.038185
## 14 21 4845.055 4728.768 4844.841 24.771012 13531.00523 24.725273
## 15 22 5446.567 5489.662 5447.060 20.840315 1871.96579 20.593056
## 16 23 5229.354 5289.504 5229.823 27.719486 3644.89469 27.495392
## 17 24 5318.788 5378.887 5319.044 15.250383 3620.20947 15.184606
## 18 25 5386.545 5411.089 5388.183 35.719830 756.95755 30.915061
## 19 26 4699.423 4794.968 4699.729 28.857094 9198.98306 28.761109
## 20 27 4750.690 4760.447 4752.140 18.632334 107.56854 14.386020
## 21 28 4671.369 4624.372 4670.696 31.168528 2203.66079 30.708035
## 22 29 5198.262 5196.627 5197.368 30.467751 27.02246 14.272985
## 23 3 4683.496 4768.562 4683.826 27.917177 7239.19411 27.807918
## 24 4 5054.219 5023.387 5053.539 20.524476 950.54978 20.054205
## 25 5 5159.540 5191.793 5160.243 20.446740 1109.28805 19.895202
## 26 6 5900.510 5890.562 5899.081 22.094160 181.77496 13.864643
## 27 7 6667.071 6919.537 6667.176 26.491119 63824.80872 26.480073
## 28 71 3709.489 3557.167 3709.403 13.026759 23409.25274 13.019194
## 29 72 3051.863 3370.607 3051.903 12.679725 101617.00487 12.678120
## 30 73 4766.149 4221.039 4766.099 27.317589 297191.47330 27.315062
## 31 74 3615.472 3469.336 3615.407 9.365371 21368.64989 9.361236
## 32 75 3148.793 3414.405 3148.843 13.352270 70654.80520 13.349688
## 33 76 3109.599 3449.210 3109.628 10.123176 115366.57568 10.122278
## 34 77 3167.663 3347.225 3167.764 17.906456 32477.16306 17.896221
## 35 78 6917.386 7047.857 6917.753 47.678149 17083.27563 47.542942
## 36 79 3303.465 3421.078 3303.528 7.354578 13854.39273 7.350621
## 37 8 5023.669 4865.701 5023.575 14.931933 24964.17358 14.922951
## 38 9 6849.588 6797.748 6848.964 32.157643 2668.99181 31.764567
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.005165230 0.033061448 0.004312269
## 2 0.003924552 0.019397582 0.002768436
## 3 0.005181284 0.128140694 0.004819745
## 4 0.006745856 22.888999186 0.006743860
## 5 0.003308449 1.307360431 0.003299833
## 6 0.005101325 0.353888144 0.005010730
## 7 0.005348858 1.796286703 0.005332178
## 8 0.002703542 10.134346006 0.002702816
## 9 0.003758753 4.044746064 0.003755237
## 10 0.003394538 2.156722555 0.003389116
## 11 0.003231866 28.997547690 0.003231505
## 12 0.005781789 0.669296225 0.005731549
## 13 0.003819513 2.113930892 0.003812445
## 14 0.005112471 2.861473222 0.005103256
## 15 0.003826278 0.340985397 0.003780553
## 16 0.005300652 0.688936081 0.005257336
## 17 0.002867195 0.672968286 0.002854691
## 18 0.006631555 0.139821661 0.005739772
## 19 0.006140330 1.918336896 0.006119512
## 20 0.003921950 0.022595954 0.003027690
## 21 0.006672210 0.476604680 0.006574575
## 22 0.005861125 0.005199791 0.002746139
## 23 0.005960684 1.517967477 0.005936939
## 24 0.004060828 0.189237831 0.003968297
## 25 0.003962855 0.213678618 0.003855572
## 26 0.003744109 0.030819328 0.002348158
## 27 0.003973594 9.223658389 0.003971875
## 28 0.003511996 6.580370580 0.003510037
## 29 0.004154259 30.147638822 0.004153678
## 30 0.005732113 70.408697313 0.005731643
## 31 0.002590359 6.159747233 0.002589261
## 32 0.004239577 20.694164132 0.004238689
## 33 0.003255310 33.445613473 0.003254990
## 34 0.005652776 9.702391565 0.005649368
## 35 0.006893939 2.425033626 0.006874035
## 36 0.002226377 4.049477884 0.002225136
## 37 0.002972285 5.130682522 0.002970553
## 38 0.004694883 0.392634235 0.004637916 c. f = 80%res_1sc_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4194.636 4180.339 4191.773 49.63114 293.08333 29.72563
## 2 10 6149.933 6154.870 6152.709 56.13016 54.49741 24.29194
## 3 11 4575.031 4618.736 4576.371 54.62070 1985.90013 52.69919
## 4 12 4914.377 4580.243 4914.151 75.56193 111689.03804 75.51071
## 5 13 5116.838 5154.308 5118.074 41.50545 1467.95047 39.72280
## 6 14 5876.094 5852.982 5872.932 66.02491 613.12475 50.85609
## 7 15 6342.387 6247.629 6341.476 79.04659 9701.86864 78.14395
## 8 16 5105.644 4892.760 5105.496 31.59750 45434.91631 31.57515
## 9 17 5254.754 5377.021 5255.123 45.09899 14922.68142 44.96260
## 10 18 4968.525 5065.349 4968.925 38.27026 9431.18141 38.10844
## 11 19 4691.175 4365.042 4691.075 32.83595 106409.02521 32.82576
## 12 2 4641.211 4715.707 4642.017 59.29027 5573.32539 58.63229
## 13 20 4484.435 4364.469 4484.099 40.16645 14380.24654 40.05285
## 14 21 4842.141 4716.462 4841.695 55.99219 15825.20932 55.79180
## 15 22 5426.804 5484.453 5427.640 46.37649 3382.14962 45.64061
## 16 23 5256.515 5275.766 5259.950 63.73274 424.62027 45.44044
## 17 24 5347.768 5405.769 5348.385 34.84417 3417.38275 34.45147
## 18 25 5425.100 5438.822 5427.400 82.62482 480.21571 49.68214
## 19 26 4668.030 4784.106 4668.588 63.62529 13632.96517 63.30686
## 20 27 4718.577 4734.241 4721.858 41.96979 274.45767 27.79547
## 21 28 4639.078 4614.374 4636.598 69.82558 700.81094 58.54877
## 22 29 5223.098 5220.724 5221.800 66.74588 59.34976 31.31363
## 23 3 4647.812 4745.960 4648.447 62.19397 9610.91303 61.78476
## 24 4 5060.643 5023.362 5059.343 45.64021 1415.05922 43.83276
## 25 5 5189.021 5178.897 5186.462 43.56853 164.05410 24.16274
## 26 6 5861.979 5879.278 5865.013 47.22443 316.38019 33.45773
## 27 7 6651.803 6921.068 6652.024 59.45068 72643.63396 59.40132
## 28 71 3693.608 3551.951 3693.410 27.81769 20250.23367 27.77780
## 29 72 3035.554 3361.888 3035.645 29.84058 106583.32058 29.83200
## 30 73 4725.591 4203.799 4725.479 58.07473 272280.82798 58.06226
## 31 74 3580.915 3462.112 3580.731 21.78109 14110.59967 21.74691
## 32 75 3164.801 3408.628 3164.928 30.95625 59487.37856 30.93975
## 33 76 3094.480 3426.426 3094.548 22.67897 110192.73812 22.67428
## 34 77 3173.744 3341.575 3173.965 36.66224 28301.90392 36.61155
## 35 78 6935.530 7049.166 6936.464 105.82245 12877.14541 104.93641
## 36 79 3312.538 3412.574 3312.704 16.54551 10037.53893 16.51760
## 37 8 5021.820 4860.176 5021.614 33.27823 26156.17802 33.23571
## 38 9 6854.508 6795.465 6853.377 66.64495 3450.88577 65.35457
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.011832751 0.070106905 0.007084314
## 2 0.009127339 0.008855441 0.003948847
## 3 0.011938219 0.429858731 0.011515244
## 4 0.015374182 24.384493607 0.015364468
## 5 0.008111821 0.284690805 0.007762073
## 6 0.011235556 0.104742590 0.008654009
## 7 0.012463992 1.552262818 0.012323074
## 8 0.006188823 9.286393690 0.006184626
## 9 0.008582721 2.775297648 0.008556164
## 10 0.007702673 1.861755264 0.007669496
## 11 0.006999013 24.377321321 0.006996991
## 12 0.012775471 1.181714119 0.012631545
## 13 0.008957115 3.294886059 0.008932452
## 14 0.011562548 3.355216634 0.011522224
## 15 0.008545237 0.616722999 0.008408442
## 16 0.012124684 0.080483907 0.008645354
## 17 0.006515516 0.631859991 0.006441339
## 18 0.015225509 0.088396125 0.009161710
## 19 0.013629523 2.849844541 0.013559742
## 20 0.008895068 0.057935234 0.005890147
## 21 0.015051539 0.151984417 0.012624311
## 22 0.012778421 0.011366745 0.005996220
## 23 0.013381355 2.024910383 0.013291486
## 24 0.009018155 0.281718210 0.008662918
## 25 0.008396312 0.031677122 0.004655471
## 26 0.008054653 0.053822283 0.005707185
## 27 0.008938107 10.495431306 0.008930388
## 28 0.007530317 5.700152026 0.007519917
## 29 0.009828665 31.702504925 0.009825538
## 30 0.012289404 64.770870646 0.012287056
## 31 0.006082490 4.075951007 0.006073260
## 32 0.009779773 17.451932216 0.009774162
## 33 0.007329009 32.158161976 0.007327330
## 34 0.011547650 8.470618406 0.011530879
## 35 0.015260727 1.826982050 0.015130901
## 36 0.004994989 2.941274993 0.004986312
## 37 0.006626175 5.381863630 0.006617981
## 38 0.009723073 0.507929685 0.009536400 d. f = 70%res_1sc_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4171.158 4184.927 4175.783 83.92571 304.51799 39.82013
## 2 10 6153.657 6154.541 6152.454 89.97023 94.76801 32.25617
## 3 11 4622.687 4625.612 4623.451 89.61128 103.15378 38.12976
## 4 12 4923.968 4596.174 4923.563 132.62876 107475.60311 132.46357
## 5 13 5059.535 5167.644 5060.159 66.68653 11694.06347 66.28271
## 6 14 5912.818 5843.053 5911.182 107.21383 5066.91908 104.34448
## 7 15 6315.920 6203.155 6314.733 129.95917 12968.86350 128.48921
## 8 16 5109.328 4879.994 5109.093 53.66014 52657.83274 53.60462
## 9 17 5197.378 5373.495 5197.800 73.54824 31082.93055 73.36303
## 10 18 4972.027 5071.626 4972.718 68.13531 9990.65206 67.64922
## 11 19 4732.685 4366.943 4732.526 58.09497 133762.11252 58.06931
## 12 2 4675.264 4723.726 4677.368 99.97510 2298.89206 95.46317
## 13 20 4489.132 4379.031 4488.534 65.71128 12102.22426 65.34755
## 14 21 4850.547 4728.584 4849.750 95.98041 14919.04893 95.32703
## 15 22 5417.888 5468.030 5419.641 79.19746 2711.50178 75.82050
## 16 23 5201.468 5257.078 5203.461 107.04312 3114.07172 102.91800
## 17 24 5289.860 5351.957 5290.820 57.11437 3953.11171 56.14696
## 18 25 5365.506 5388.166 5368.933 141.36506 773.93995 96.26366
## 19 26 4723.790 4796.801 4725.805 115.64053 6213.59190 110.13943
## 20 27 4761.543 4756.328 4759.426 73.02089 83.88574 35.72520
## 21 28 4689.616 4637.407 4687.152 121.10383 2746.34731 114.59838
## 22 29 5164.710 5163.874 5164.287 113.15671 111.65847 56.19942
## 23 3 4688.906 4759.999 4690.557 114.67834 5039.73359 111.84759
## 24 4 5054.329 5024.346 5051.340 75.21577 972.16368 64.46310
## 25 5 5124.761 5197.939 5125.836 76.65806 5415.02659 75.46798
## 26 6 5910.544 5900.196 5907.165 87.13649 174.84764 54.65484
## 27 7 6624.815 6902.656 6625.192 104.20311 77518.92222 104.05897
## 28 71 3705.130 3562.778 3704.712 54.77175 21933.27818 54.58214
## 29 72 3016.701 3378.300 3016.846 52.18896 130777.37955 52.16740
## 30 73 4773.954 4217.236 4773.769 102.76134 310139.77076 102.72667
## 31 74 3626.109 3478.065 3625.870 35.12378 22020.90192 35.06499
## 32 75 3178.901 3421.827 3179.119 51.87096 59754.68367 51.82104
## 33 76 3066.435 3441.741 3066.535 37.46303 140899.39307 37.45268
## 34 77 3188.346 3358.601 3188.781 71.98049 29875.61705 71.78377
## 35 78 6934.254 7059.304 6935.766 188.19092 15503.84640 185.86554
## 36 79 3332.325 3428.969 3332.632 29.52628 9422.30906 29.42982
## 37 8 5027.378 4866.263 5027.024 56.97162 25980.42267 56.84542
## 38 9 6861.064 6798.070 6859.028 124.50165 3947.15471 120.12271
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.020120954 0.07270241 0.009545414
## 2 0.014621604 0.01540408 0.005246470
## 3 0.019385770 0.02229417 0.008250682
## 4 0.026935039 23.38533986 0.026903715
## 5 0.013179159 2.26291466 0.013097728
## 6 0.018135239 0.86687896 0.017654385
## 7 0.020573904 2.09092641 0.020344843
## 8 0.010503023 10.79104524 0.010492641
## 9 0.014146890 5.78450009 0.014110103
## 10 0.013704339 1.96986530 0.013604706
## 11 0.012273504 30.63203072 0.012268503
## 12 0.021383969 0.48666315 0.020410045
## 13 0.014637142 2.76407318 0.014558087
## 14 0.019787749 3.15518520 0.019656278
## 15 0.014617285 0.49528222 0.013989996
## 16 0.020580693 0.59229038 0.019780407
## 17 0.010796457 0.73819109 0.010611729
## 18 0.026353003 0.14391093 0.017958460
## 19 0.024486466 1.29575224 0.023319623
## 20 0.015334775 0.01762907 0.007503191
## 21 0.025823435 0.59241890 0.024447752
## 22 0.021903671 0.02161722 0.010879397
## 23 0.024458143 1.05869210 0.023846229
## 24 0.014880280 0.19357977 0.012756497
## 25 0.014959237 1.04178957 0.014724132
## 26 0.014743699 0.02964120 0.009253289
## 27 0.015729775 11.23116281 0.015707128
## 28 0.014781119 6.14948903 0.014731286
## 29 0.017294370 38.71166331 0.017286377
## 30 0.021530814 73.53397769 0.021524392
## 31 0.009686355 6.33394997 0.009670788
## 32 0.016308938 17.46234869 0.016292120
## 33 0.012215425 40.93559641 0.012211638
## 34 0.022586337 8.89379585 0.022521649
## 35 0.027133777 2.19636979 0.026792776
## 36 0.008864732 2.74770362 0.008834949
## 37 0.011331300 5.33866135 0.011306995
## 38 0.018146296 0.58076210 0.017513126 e. f = 60%res_1sc_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4141.323 4163.805 4146.092 126.03144 569.0364 84.85604
## 2 10 6149.981 6167.306 6152.970 142.45707 551.1770 87.78490
## 3 11 4563.809 4599.089 4567.065 136.97078 1321.1066 117.35079
## 4 12 4921.563 4572.501 4920.996 198.27996 121813.0345 197.95351
## 5 13 5093.768 5132.977 5097.335 95.75046 1798.7863 74.72055
## 6 14 5859.539 5830.142 5855.842 175.25657 1402.8814 134.81707
## 7 15 6335.901 6220.979 6333.979 206.62920 13815.3051 202.58892
## 8 16 5091.358 4883.021 5090.935 87.63365 43491.6695 87.45073
## 9 17 5232.782 5378.894 5233.530 107.70013 21393.8746 107.10190
## 10 18 4972.163 5060.475 4973.342 101.99184 7858.2636 100.55738
## 11 19 4683.502 4355.196 4683.206 96.96537 107891.0013 96.87615
## 12 2 4645.305 4700.955 4648.567 151.97358 3349.4615 138.88450
## 13 20 4498.010 4362.936 4497.259 101.28861 18203.7062 100.71712
## 14 21 4847.808 4710.083 4846.645 154.40500 19304.7163 152.97286
## 15 22 5376.161 5454.501 5377.823 126.31678 6204.8158 123.44543
## 16 23 5235.177 5237.525 5236.121 177.51629 141.6468 69.76477
## 17 24 5325.071 5365.992 5327.396 88.32995 1687.2300 82.33332
## 18 25 5380.280 5408.946 5385.559 209.81082 1245.5780 141.25544
## 19 26 4670.990 4779.455 4672.852 180.62584 12698.2775 176.50413
## 20 27 4713.447 4722.815 4716.310 108.46754 336.7188 61.81434
## 21 28 4644.562 4620.219 4639.402 187.16963 737.1424 116.42746
## 22 29 5196.448 5194.382 5195.398 183.54296 178.9112 90.59316
## 23 3 4650.311 4726.637 4652.594 170.90661 5743.7893 165.41178
## 24 4 5056.530 5021.078 5052.857 117.87933 1272.4368 102.76852
## 25 5 5158.446 5180.415 5161.204 116.93826 842.1926 78.01093
## 26 6 5867.783 5886.546 5871.928 117.04872 462.2936 75.55292
## 27 7 6596.535 6901.370 6597.069 163.00382 93846.8751 162.71524
## 28 71 3708.578 3550.233 3708.033 82.71713 26298.1273 82.40381
## 29 72 2985.240 3361.512 2985.454 79.77457 141973.4575 79.72585
## 30 73 4707.242 4186.849 4706.893 180.63798 271231.4143 180.51370
## 31 74 3582.792 3464.173 3582.305 57.51530 14198.2482 57.27050
## 32 75 3188.474 3408.399 3188.863 84.88185 48477.6274 84.72436
## 33 76 3039.401 3408.242 3039.547 53.49101 136084.2922 53.46970
## 34 77 3180.155 3341.755 3180.841 104.26661 26972.6891 103.73406
## 35 78 6958.070 7063.654 6960.904 295.01548 11045.9412 286.73853
## 36 79 3334.960 3413.267 3335.502 41.26992 6217.3848 40.96025
## 37 8 5025.481 4858.534 5024.939 89.53498 28009.6341 89.23315
## 38 9 6885.973 6810.059 6883.387 190.87129 5789.7467 183.96531
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.03043640 0.13662510 0.02048143
## 2 0.02315974 0.08946274 0.01428399
## 3 0.03000676 0.28720895 0.02569781
## 4 0.04028491 26.64185139 0.04022329
## 5 0.01879602 0.34982796 0.01466922
## 6 0.02990726 0.24052980 0.02300703
## 7 0.03260835 2.21909744 0.03197884
## 8 0.01721222 8.90734325 0.01717773
## 9 0.02057888 3.97739574 0.02046155
## 10 0.02051235 1.55252761 0.02021921
## 11 0.02070037 24.77317066 0.02068265
## 12 0.03271188 0.71178145 0.02988033
## 13 0.02251756 4.17267182 0.02239428
## 14 0.03186558 4.09869279 0.03157751
## 15 0.02349743 1.13725132 0.02295648
## 16 0.03390681 0.02703516 0.01332585
## 17 0.01658409 0.31439987 0.01545258
## 18 0.03899369 0.22996091 0.02625222
## 19 0.03867255 2.65785559 0.03778009
## 20 0.02300588 0.07121895 0.01310555
## 21 0.04029694 0.15949991 0.02506546
## 22 0.03530511 0.03442718 0.01742925
## 23 0.03675064 1.21526287 0.03555169
## 24 0.02331333 0.25355031 0.02033639
## 25 0.02266379 0.16256110 0.01513032
## 26 0.01994995 0.07860082 0.01287983
## 27 0.02472968 13.59994474 0.02468389
## 28 0.02229965 7.40188166 0.02221815
## 29 0.02670769 42.22925741 0.02668937
## 30 0.03839309 64.78895040 0.03836955
## 31 0.01605015 4.10056898 0.01598406
## 32 0.02661106 14.22207449 0.02655841
## 33 0.01759710 39.92298184 0.01758925
## 34 0.03276969 8.07643438 0.03259630
## 35 0.04238980 1.56507136 0.04118517
## 36 0.01237540 1.82087940 0.01228051
## 37 0.01781795 5.76662172 0.01775981
## 38 0.02771564 0.85045549 0.02672232 f. f = 50%res_1sc_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4227.266 4216.647 4221.387 199.75663 152.4836 79.92537
## 2 10 6169.227 6181.228 6172.673 209.06967 560.5219 89.59813
## 3 11 4635.449 4655.926 4638.562 212.24300 970.1129 127.09650
## 4 12 4919.087 4613.427 4918.051 317.20012 93268.8952 316.10509
## 5 13 5137.188 5214.829 5139.403 159.14268 6189.6293 153.61792
## 6 14 5922.870 5883.538 5920.669 260.78747 2583.4636 217.14945
## 7 15 6349.936 6260.931 6346.495 317.95083 9650.3005 285.89733
## 8 16 5096.876 4910.203 5096.207 121.11095 35367.4155 120.63406
## 9 17 5273.778 5400.312 5275.319 187.99449 16511.2756 185.50889
## 10 18 4971.586 5089.641 4972.774 136.37116 14267.3113 134.89149
## 11 19 4742.009 4400.329 4741.603 138.60002 116823.0559 138.43146
## 12 2 4701.557 4753.622 4706.899 236.34493 2810.4987 200.71783
## 13 20 4524.956 4388.843 4523.774 159.39206 18804.0282 157.96042
## 14 21 4861.110 4755.768 4858.569 246.58254 11474.6965 239.24233
## 15 22 5455.121 5511.465 5459.023 198.61519 3193.3644 181.10640
## 16 23 5273.302 5291.638 5273.891 245.86132 912.6146 145.32992
## 17 24 5365.766 5413.565 5369.258 145.29387 2466.7710 130.93912
## 18 25 5433.488 5447.447 5433.827 332.61561 1507.7242 202.19767
## 19 26 4701.490 4820.833 4704.655 300.63463 15954.3359 286.75467
## 20 27 4771.273 4776.393 4772.063 153.08833 199.8502 70.42270
## 21 28 4705.205 4659.644 4698.365 271.24707 2074.2225 216.38411
## 22 29 5229.199 5226.325 5227.682 255.63943 241.4266 124.04845
## 23 3 4712.801 4803.109 4715.861 271.25478 8054.6244 261.49371
## 24 4 5062.732 5051.751 5061.414 179.40125 530.7174 95.92490
## 25 5 5205.443 5220.697 5208.048 188.76163 782.2066 114.67569
## 26 6 5932.585 5915.458 5929.206 195.87625 1031.2647 130.78505
## 27 7 6716.995 6965.288 6718.018 252.12207 62081.0358 251.04275
## 28 71 3716.546 3584.967 3715.469 116.98177 18822.5300 115.31527
## 29 72 3056.568 3397.008 3056.861 99.67946 116248.7221 99.59023
## 30 73 4796.122 4275.443 4795.689 225.05070 271899.1735 224.86096
## 31 74 3646.460 3494.331 3645.881 87.75771 23112.0072 87.40902
## 32 75 3216.676 3440.125 3217.231 119.37214 51338.5190 119.04143
## 33 76 3124.436 3466.261 3124.700 90.38339 116989.1851 90.31224
## 34 77 3226.424 3390.424 3227.482 169.58486 27446.5238 168.41951
## 35 78 7033.381 7149.900 7037.469 445.04356 13904.4824 426.53566
## 36 79 3353.922 3446.002 3354.730 71.89829 8647.9645 71.19739
## 37 8 5026.561 4889.587 5025.520 140.95967 19015.7508 139.86379
## 38 9 6913.530 6846.019 6908.865 315.19081 4290.9988 292.93958
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.04727772 0.03612504 0.01891785
## 2 0.03388629 0.09079902 0.01454195
## 3 0.04578198 0.20793978 0.02743297
## 4 0.06446537 20.21663232 0.06425664
## 5 0.03097161 1.18648626 0.02988497
## 6 0.04402155 0.43910566 0.03664395
## 7 0.05007169 1.53983186 0.04498844
## 8 0.02377208 7.20338297 0.02368151
## 9 0.03564600 3.05494907 0.03516477
## 10 0.02743350 2.80113922 0.02712952
## 11 0.02922443 26.54957783 0.02919144
## 12 0.05027504 0.59097679 0.04267420
## 13 0.03522175 4.28819079 0.03491447
## 14 0.05073205 2.41334497 0.04924275
## 15 0.03640784 0.57913083 0.03317918
## 16 0.04662754 0.17201721 0.02758069
## 17 0.02707612 0.45477880 0.02438778
## 18 0.06116059 0.27740455 0.03724625
## 19 0.06389376 3.31196195 0.06093079
## 20 0.03208108 0.04180313 0.01475993
## 21 0.05763417 0.44517665 0.04599957
## 22 0.04887472 0.04617852 0.02372210
## 23 0.05754657 1.67551137 0.05543907
## 24 0.03543478 0.10513611 0.01892989
## 25 0.03627280 0.15006792 0.02206237
## 26 0.03303362 0.17449716 0.02204689
## 27 0.03753945 8.91041957 0.03737299
## 28 0.03151552 5.25162206 0.03107059
## 29 0.03262380 34.21658753 0.03259137
## 30 0.04690581 63.59361754 0.04687052
## 31 0.02406541 6.61461901 0.02397373
## 32 0.03709437 14.92554515 0.03698540
## 33 0.02892682 33.74174893 0.02890156
## 34 0.05259625 8.09447174 0.05221841
## 35 0.06324681 1.94838326 0.06059347
## 36 0.02143794 2.50953970 0.02122393
## 37 0.02803631 3.88943271 0.02782394
## 38 0.04557789 0.62675625 0.04238941 g. f = 40%res_1sc_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4198.123 4168.369 4191.084 287.7380 1195.6307 173.2689
## 2 10 6164.900 6126.829 6160.258 332.7553 2187.8096 217.1313
## 3 11 4575.449 4605.118 4581.604 319.7883 1139.9319 219.2247
## 4 12 4922.341 4580.109 4921.058 439.0035 116911.7136 437.3244
## 5 13 5045.413 5109.373 5049.563 211.4620 4522.2126 187.6490
## 6 14 5869.276 5841.594 5865.939 412.3636 4840.6763 301.7492
## 7 15 6379.258 6232.992 6375.803 459.0769 22980.6454 445.1120
## 8 16 5111.942 4857.543 5111.204 188.4588 64802.6471 187.8885
## 9 17 5178.431 5344.071 5179.990 250.8477 27674.9955 248.2256
## 10 18 4967.828 5052.798 4970.311 202.9273 7319.6656 196.3647
## 11 19 4680.222 4333.577 4679.694 182.1809 120643.9843 181.8957
## 12 2 4642.580 4703.675 4649.723 379.8491 3801.2152 320.5307
## 13 20 4403.046 4350.794 4397.460 268.6676 2696.9013 234.4382
## 14 21 4849.759 4702.992 4847.210 350.9126 22617.2678 343.8290
## 15 22 5432.050 5451.988 5436.063 280.5407 1001.4038 127.9566
## 16 23 5175.760 5290.426 5178.839 331.5826 13499.7398 321.0679
## 17 24 5276.971 5341.637 5280.629 214.1468 4293.9148 198.7346
## 18 25 5327.866 5386.396 5336.422 516.1736 3994.7741 378.5268
## 19 26 4673.778 4760.482 4674.299 348.5720 12521.0546 290.4611
## 20 27 4720.161 4741.341 4725.361 227.8930 635.7260 136.6974
## 21 28 4631.218 4574.499 4621.264 417.2689 3637.2376 281.2657
## 22 29 5146.168 5144.304 5145.137 414.6836 392.7274 201.4117
## 23 3 4632.709 4731.163 4636.925 402.4670 9551.2928 383.5371
## 24 4 5051.785 4998.596 5046.135 276.8586 2756.4810 241.1809
## 25 5 5108.892 5168.300 5114.910 279.8889 4034.7765 233.7917
## 26 6 5871.409 5867.217 5870.812 288.9299 254.1834 113.6017
## 27 7 6651.476 6906.344 6652.841 344.3958 65527.9670 342.4633
## 28 71 3683.259 3519.800 3682.014 183.2884 28775.9324 181.4795
## 29 72 3046.242 3329.880 3046.940 195.3801 80659.0016 194.8562
## 30 73 4731.690 4154.125 4731.145 319.5824 334599.1189 319.2455
## 31 74 3581.769 3431.844 3580.930 124.6799 22564.3320 123.9485
## 32 75 3083.905 3376.854 3084.560 190.2817 85934.9507 189.8055
## 33 76 3086.779 3416.343 3087.137 117.9646 108703.5703 117.8262
## 34 77 3064.375 3284.387 3065.404 213.4081 49571.3940 212.1842
## 35 78 6839.429 6981.226 6843.830 604.2259 20382.7494 583.8099
## 36 79 3228.551 3382.435 3229.251 104.9658 23911.6210 104.4348
## 37 8 5037.296 4842.906 5036.236 206.1569 38195.5157 205.0093
## 38 9 6769.970 6749.752 6762.837 389.4251 693.6717 201.5793
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.06858545 0.28646624 0.04128184
## 2 0.05402522 0.35588107 0.03515627
## 3 0.06990954 0.24704795 0.04788416
## 4 0.08918283 25.53162723 0.08886533
## 5 0.04188887 0.88371104 0.03715040
## 6 0.07020605 0.83022939 0.05138385
## 7 0.07199033 3.68544523 0.06982806
## 8 0.03686775 13.34113604 0.03676171
## 9 0.04842983 5.17634043 0.04790882
## 10 0.04085543 1.44812910 0.03951524
## 11 0.03892860 27.84398225 0.03887208
## 12 0.08181880 0.80629653 0.06894511
## 13 0.06100025 0.62010432 0.05328729
## 14 0.07235505 4.81167945 0.07092796
## 15 0.05161107 0.18365746 0.02357553
## 16 0.06408025 2.55118635 0.06201422
## 17 0.04057604 0.80275689 0.03763099
## 18 0.09683206 0.74477643 0.07107288
## 19 0.07472522 2.62983055 0.06249294
## 20 0.04826913 0.13402438 0.02894424
## 21 0.09012122 0.79643865 0.06073040
## 22 0.08060138 0.07637003 0.03915882
## 23 0.08688251 2.01899335 0.08272258
## 24 0.05480689 0.55190894 0.04779407
## 25 0.05477902 0.78112036 0.04575660
## 26 0.04921804 0.04339037 0.01935842
## 27 0.05176930 9.48904415 0.05146830
## 28 0.04976345 8.16898975 0.04928527
## 29 0.06413315 24.22171972 0.06394577
## 30 0.06745224 80.58836039 0.06739008
## 31 0.03480247 6.57750667 0.03460660
## 32 0.06163749 25.44845496 0.06146919
## 33 0.03820637 31.81557147 0.03815678
## 34 0.06952905 15.10676840 0.06910951
## 35 0.08839803 2.92547323 0.08536479
## 36 0.03249853 7.06421690 0.03232696
## 37 0.04090897 7.88984756 0.04068987
## 38 0.05749275 0.10280906 0.02977196 h. f = 30%res_1sc_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4136.414 4106.935 4127.748 437.3430 1349.9235 231.0975
## 2 10 6187.042 6159.751 6178.134 539.0915 1459.9698 305.6426
## 3 11 4480.443 4573.521 4486.401 525.3830 8520.1787 486.5769
## 4 12 4926.953 4545.458 4925.038 723.8743 146004.2103 720.0218
## 5 13 5093.677 5057.932 5088.410 309.9493 2062.8004 216.8916
## 6 14 5809.397 5827.003 5811.389 591.8908 2329.1968 418.0097
## 7 15 6348.017 6260.703 6341.625 663.4003 10815.9014 538.6740
## 8 16 5098.266 4857.217 5096.909 321.1533 58958.3379 319.2355
## 9 17 5221.489 5338.922 5225.138 415.4835 14094.2995 400.5615
## 10 18 4967.216 5016.340 4976.515 358.3671 2673.3706 236.3040
## 11 19 4584.810 4298.116 4583.786 295.8967 83092.6201 294.7687
## 12 2 4529.589 4625.573 4535.722 562.5151 8991.6246 519.2422
## 13 20 4386.985 4308.292 4382.453 325.9701 6345.1722 302.1919
## 14 21 4823.697 4645.480 4820.416 545.5654 32909.0454 533.4908
## 15 22 5370.808 5413.599 5378.704 442.6293 2223.5629 306.7954
## 16 23 5221.288 5247.717 5223.776 560.5080 2433.0396 345.4807
## 17 24 5313.050 5386.744 5317.470 296.0293 5578.7472 272.1199
## 18 25 5417.580 5441.869 5428.521 663.5997 1425.2742 260.1176
## 19 26 4555.923 4704.669 4560.333 571.6390 23280.6178 546.4601
## 20 27 4609.619 4667.038 4614.806 329.8761 3648.7244 281.1896
## 21 28 4512.766 4536.583 4527.387 677.7051 711.5306 211.8724
## 22 29 5207.138 5203.652 5205.244 529.9483 494.2122 255.2598
## 23 3 4540.777 4656.003 4545.854 497.3120 13906.3405 463.3412
## 24 4 5066.098 4971.899 5061.566 407.0594 8714.8618 384.0424
## 25 5 5153.684 5113.197 5149.843 392.4885 3782.4569 281.4543
## 26 6 5767.671 5822.024 5771.779 471.0117 5010.7004 317.0560
## 27 7 6631.513 6897.268 6633.849 607.8239 70863.3660 601.8982
## 28 71 3682.586 3494.364 3680.986 241.1880 40225.8817 237.4804
## 29 72 2979.718 3298.343 2980.497 239.2289 102161.9905 238.4745
## 30 73 4620.666 4089.037 4619.521 607.0259 282666.3162 605.6722
## 31 74 3478.694 3405.840 3476.138 176.6460 5425.7276 169.0780
## 32 75 3092.657 3352.339 3093.873 301.5280 69152.5128 299.7149
## 33 76 3036.622 3354.755 3037.312 218.7544 101569.7006 218.2544
## 34 77 3079.897 3249.519 3081.791 306.7425 29834.7197 302.4721
## 35 78 6828.841 6946.949 6838.647 1064.6151 14373.4254 958.6986
## 36 79 3230.311 3352.869 3231.437 130.3703 15393.6887 128.8664
## 37 8 5031.141 4820.608 5029.620 323.2368 45048.6035 320.8402
## 38 9 6779.809 6754.727 6766.023 778.7160 662.9353 263.0558
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.10583595 0.32910540 0.05595970
## 2 0.08711612 0.23681761 0.04937485
## 3 0.11717363 1.86102934 0.10838014
## 4 0.14691628 32.12488147 0.14619286
## 5 0.06083567 0.40956448 0.04259370
## 6 0.10180342 0.39966489 0.07192897
## 7 0.10433803 1.72440319 0.08447308
## 8 0.06300536 12.14082106 0.06264560
## 9 0.07956960 2.63754896 0.07666074
## 10 0.07213222 0.53230477 0.04753401
## 11 0.06444518 19.34441055 0.06421501
## 12 0.12416047 1.94388626 0.11445867
## 13 0.07427616 1.47429013 0.06890864
## 14 0.11316175 7.08819031 0.11072935
## 15 0.08236122 0.41066465 0.05708999
## 16 0.10736315 0.46219401 0.06624179
## 17 0.05567862 1.03440455 0.05114186
## 18 0.12235841 0.26188545 0.04787630
## 19 0.12538125 4.94793167 0.11977567
## 20 0.07156916 0.78146593 0.06095961
## 21 0.14998877 0.15675984 0.04679299
## 22 0.10176269 0.09496267 0.04903398
## 23 0.10943550 2.98576374 0.10190297
## 24 0.08035362 1.75294630 0.07588005
## 25 0.07611685 0.73830288 0.05451285
## 26 0.08146805 0.86141516 0.05497665
## 27 0.09161555 10.27417682 0.09068921
## 28 0.06539200 11.50017963 0.06438753
## 29 0.08006834 30.97228770 0.07979267
## 30 0.13143180 69.13989923 0.13117199
## 31 0.05079379 1.59574818 0.04865525
## 32 0.09722385 20.63137618 0.09659747
## 33 0.07198687 30.25685698 0.07180551
## 34 0.09967812 9.19124063 0.09822208
## 35 0.15591021 2.07934546 0.14029646
## 36 0.04037006 4.58787500 0.03988984
## 37 0.06417244 9.34630869 0.06371644
## 38 0.11469639 0.09826212 0.03884053 i. f = 20%res_1sc_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4029.165 4103.533 4036.603 678.3063 7149.6846 564.3854
## 2 10 6146.630 6105.264 6134.123 796.5270 2034.9275 455.5622
## 3 11 4581.064 4546.391 4569.880 775.9969 1983.4110 369.5878
## 4 12 4926.605 4548.218 4923.544 1153.6403 143291.2809 1143.7612
## 5 13 4882.154 5035.538 4886.996 692.9383 24042.9003 664.1299
## 6 14 5834.753 5755.881 5824.055 1093.3263 10372.6764 818.6329
## 7 15 6322.308 6124.856 6315.366 1173.7348 42573.5878 1112.6096
## 8 16 5110.866 4797.544 5109.355 455.2503 100151.3375 452.7620
## 9 17 5012.800 5310.219 5015.027 651.5559 88909.9891 646.1113
## 10 18 4942.796 5003.625 4947.502 568.4461 5832.0928 415.9965
## 11 19 4691.506 4293.419 4690.199 519.8747 159008.5071 518.0233
## 12 2 4629.523 4641.721 4636.110 964.9470 914.9040 401.8450
## 13 20 4413.027 4326.345 4405.075 617.2260 7278.4630 529.2649
## 14 21 4886.826 4672.045 4881.481 1091.8449 46334.9071 1059.2948
## 15 22 5248.543 5301.658 5255.733 595.6822 4812.8915 398.3466
## 16 23 4990.389 5143.333 4996.986 851.6133 25421.0702 792.5544
## 17 24 5116.168 5164.524 5124.639 566.5820 3207.0424 381.7205
## 18 25 5156.954 5249.536 5169.486 1399.4100 13325.7373 980.8766
## 19 26 4667.878 4720.582 4671.411 1156.6744 9240.1146 696.7583
## 20 27 4706.372 4697.090 4703.564 649.9278 845.8887 332.0857
## 21 28 4636.209 4563.689 4623.179 1162.9898 6231.8589 763.9193
## 22 29 4991.913 4995.646 4993.888 1024.4967 983.8660 501.5395
## 23 3 4660.347 4665.494 4656.348 1038.0951 1316.2142 347.6948
## 24 4 5066.367 4966.006 5057.775 769.0843 9856.6909 673.9018
## 25 5 4924.669 5160.947 4927.889 745.4742 57641.4603 734.8174
## 26 6 5875.210 5856.681 5870.878 664.5896 1288.8191 360.2794
## 27 7 6509.883 6836.468 6512.920 930.6504 111492.7060 919.9979
## 28 71 3678.933 3506.628 3677.145 411.0062 35964.9604 388.5914
## 29 72 2889.678 3321.009 2890.351 290.1600 186093.0311 289.6926
## 30 73 4741.128 4102.661 4739.711 895.9452 407890.4917 893.6945
## 31 74 3586.635 3427.922 3584.583 327.4388 25229.9641 323.0033
## 32 75 3092.037 3368.024 3093.720 416.8449 81025.3493 413.0646
## 33 76 2924.134 3360.176 2924.887 328.9865 190392.3519 328.3763
## 34 77 3099.398 3276.465 3104.588 524.7781 36493.3131 441.6512
## 35 78 6867.691 7026.390 6879.820 1909.9021 24757.8403 1746.9565
## 36 79 3234.267 3375.146 3236.233 251.0223 20492.0441 245.6585
## 37 8 5034.327 4811.507 5031.705 576.3769 50303.6204 568.7483
## 38 9 6780.472 6727.444 6766.110 807.5713 2587.8884 510.2353
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.16842604 1.7324218 0.14000751
## 2 0.12973336 0.3328596 0.07417536
## 3 0.16934200 0.4375404 0.08058147
## 4 0.23418497 31.4987013 0.23232847
## 5 0.14193201 4.7655475 0.13589699
## 6 0.18731513 1.7952941 0.14005048
## 7 0.18569784 6.9458881 0.17615961
## 8 0.08922622 20.8719093 0.08876491
## 9 0.12996368 16.7313853 0.12881669
## 10 0.11515387 1.1603741 0.08430856
## 11 0.11078708 37.0548599 0.11042567
## 12 0.20858828 0.1968009 0.08668790
## 13 0.13978135 1.6848311 0.12010035
## 14 0.22363641 9.9137594 0.21720962
## 15 0.11354260 0.9050900 0.07594429
## 16 0.17077864 4.9409770 0.15885188
## 17 0.11057378 0.6216462 0.07445844
## 18 0.27069405 2.5554816 0.18998523
## 19 0.24745647 1.9675598 0.14984491
## 20 0.13805926 0.1800708 0.07054187
## 21 0.25094073 1.3688434 0.16485418
## 22 0.20489588 0.1966119 0.10026247
## 23 0.22288202 0.2793363 0.07460395
## 24 0.15181697 1.9856436 0.13319550
## 25 0.15165060 11.1817556 0.14939289
## 26 0.11325474 0.2194864 0.06134100
## 27 0.14276244 16.3136509 0.14106715
## 28 0.11146763 10.2532711 0.10517303
## 29 0.10045822 56.0266813 0.10027233
## 30 0.18891934 99.4437384 0.18850739
## 31 0.09126189 7.3658681 0.09008010
## 32 0.13433498 24.0425457 0.13303522
## 33 0.11251571 56.6194595 0.11227578
## 34 0.16888567 11.1622219 0.14342237
## 35 0.27882444 3.5330157 0.25461411
## 36 0.07738338 6.0737166 0.07567858
## 37 0.11449635 10.4656238 0.11304438
## 38 0.11897120 0.3864984 0.07538027 j. f = 10%res_1sc_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 3711.736 3857.826 3724.276 1754.4522 20974.126 1541.1903
## 2 10 6102.929 6125.044 6106.426 1763.9485 6867.081 906.5536
## 3 11 4318.126 4376.797 4331.711 2167.2675 5981.500 1203.6919
## 4 12 4899.411 4397.216 4893.443 2864.7804 255979.761 2821.1682
## 5 13 4910.571 4781.575 4897.076 1578.5142 16415.281 1350.9233
## 6 14 5562.869 5636.066 5585.981 2592.8763 6609.049 1471.3800
## 7 15 6422.295 6134.634 6413.246 2521.8136 87121.106 2433.7442
## 8 16 5135.359 4792.639 5132.009 1102.6865 121365.477 1089.9542
## 9 17 5034.994 5295.929 5040.190 1312.7050 69342.464 1283.8928
## 10 18 4983.325 4905.099 4971.482 1284.5519 8640.378 880.0637
## 11 19 4369.919 4167.298 4363.987 1009.7047 44617.125 955.5383
## 12 2 4320.900 4396.995 4337.515 2250.8216 8724.430 1197.6278
## 13 20 4406.972 4214.915 4401.434 1025.3390 36582.871 984.2503
## 14 21 4826.594 4491.236 4820.294 2099.7334 116536.333 2050.9239
## 15 22 4975.251 5126.268 4988.684 1643.1456 24228.373 1392.3953
## 16 23 4988.915 4958.596 4971.771 2357.8353 1960.247 996.5140
## 17 24 5088.833 5167.987 5096.697 1144.7879 9863.628 807.0113
## 18 25 5192.878 5273.267 5212.022 2698.3677 9879.067 1229.0451
## 19 26 4368.095 4551.295 4383.097 2050.3554 49241.404 1678.6448
## 20 27 4406.580 4442.983 4416.647 1183.7103 2409.467 615.7403
## 21 28 4335.090 4415.035 4358.092 2356.8322 6818.424 1386.4976
## 22 29 4989.179 4998.751 4994.139 2609.6084 2500.942 1276.4449
## 23 3 4349.652 4355.754 4351.690 1817.2991 1216.954 620.2833
## 24 4 5050.426 4882.833 5040.650 1416.8842 29108.628 1278.7508
## 25 5 4958.906 5000.230 4966.317 2314.0050 7560.997 1377.6267
## 26 6 5589.856 5754.855 5609.664 2252.9635 30183.427 1425.5195
## 27 7 6231.907 6732.513 6236.461 2101.3772 256201.960 2072.2123
## 28 71 3678.482 3409.761 3676.035 664.4859 75258.518 654.5138
## 29 72 2563.412 3206.119 2564.656 783.2893 413828.375 780.1609
## 30 73 4426.949 3835.964 4422.448 2429.3560 356431.255 2397.4547
## 31 74 3248.388 3332.170 3258.852 969.4255 7275.873 781.9898
## 32 75 3071.293 3274.972 3076.332 730.5538 45677.725 673.0858
## 33 76 2605.360 3140.912 2606.573 654.0909 288787.951 652.0253
## 34 77 3158.922 3136.955 3157.310 1536.3410 8232.048 745.6097
## 35 78 6733.923 6869.734 6747.726 2671.5679 23058.808 2105.3568
## 36 79 3232.974 3268.423 3231.359 586.4658 5636.246 359.0477
## 37 8 5037.215 4697.938 5032.981 1473.7821 115279.397 1453.2092
## 38 9 6794.008 6675.914 6774.043 1865.7427 13807.366 1317.0234
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.4723685 5.4352612 0.4133442
## 2 0.2908907 1.1396616 0.1509424
## 3 0.5012962 1.3596606 0.2784292
## 4 0.5856919 58.3320325 0.5775705
## 5 0.3218174 3.4428112 0.2763220
## 6 0.4659342 1.1726856 0.2641937
## 7 0.3918585 14.2095284 0.3786639
## 8 0.2147727 25.3323568 0.2124358
## 9 0.2606316 13.0716814 0.2546491
## 10 0.2579541 1.7724655 0.1766294
## 11 0.2311055 10.7456020 0.2189121
## 12 0.5207001 1.9765345 0.2767909
## 13 0.2325556 8.6895734 0.2235953
## 14 0.4332813 25.9387110 0.4238382
## 15 0.3306078 4.7130108 0.2794614
## 16 0.4721997 0.3947534 0.2002144
## 17 0.2249005 1.9028857 0.1586124
## 18 0.5195551 1.8975217 0.2376393
## 19 0.4699366 10.8687271 0.3847276
## 20 0.2686388 0.5422595 0.1397640
## 21 0.5433724 1.5391130 0.3183855
## 22 0.5234952 0.5007895 0.2558182
## 23 0.4170758 0.2792032 0.1425168
## 24 0.2805512 5.9689427 0.2536895
## 25 0.4666069 1.5116120 0.2782369
## 26 0.4010358 5.2882203 0.2534076
## 27 0.3358445 38.0481594 0.3309019
## 28 0.1799864 22.0231952 0.1774934
## 29 0.3056182 129.0264615 0.3040977
## 30 0.5528750 92.9775605 0.5462798
## 31 0.2989854 2.1758933 0.2403972
## 32 0.2342222 13.9852968 0.2153537
## 33 0.2515189 91.7785799 0.2505580
## 34 0.4847578 2.6336224 0.2339756
## 35 0.3993720 3.3887342 0.3153083
## 36 0.1803996 1.7155713 0.1109040
## 37 0.2921449 24.5551722 0.2883523
## 38 0.2744741 2.0757276 0.1940634 k. f = 5%res_1sc_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 3708.075 3592.546 3671.085 4688.6714 10712.754 2653.8648
## 2 10 6217.901 6007.666 6186.939 5717.3552 47403.499 4116.5751
## 3 11 3644.828 4096.541 3652.589 3565.2088 203605.441 3482.5053
## 4 12 4970.499 4148.380 4963.341 6131.4334 676964.645 6052.8434
## 5 13 4925.917 4230.966 4922.167 2548.7495 486322.296 2528.6245
## 6 14 4936.231 5476.891 4946.377 5080.7982 298679.851 4906.0692
## 7 15 6354.069 6253.315 6322.179 7162.8027 22517.936 3292.2160
## 8 16 5125.253 4607.604 5120.672 2359.4696 269334.836 2331.4846
## 9 17 5019.665 5066.738 5039.331 4851.3202 9142.664 2151.2243
## 10 18 5008.964 4664.361 5003.538 1643.3964 120959.525 1581.6258
## 11 19 3749.149 3834.852 3747.271 1972.4433 19498.762 1163.7044
## 12 2 3735.642 4067.267 3746.863 3367.7135 112264.448 3173.4135
## 13 20 3773.197 3908.090 3790.809 2741.7041 20682.564 1758.7353
## 14 21 4873.396 4155.384 4866.914 4259.7391 526086.102 4200.6620
## 15 22 4913.784 4919.082 4901.045 4227.3408 10414.349 1851.9905
## 16 23 5053.319 4983.813 5037.909 5754.2174 17123.259 3031.7429
## 17 24 5107.367 5161.351 5115.307 2859.1920 20147.285 1907.5318
## 18 25 5127.989 5318.378 5149.148 5543.5701 54296.884 4141.3823
## 19 26 3673.477 4181.730 3680.863 3253.6874 287271.749 3150.5909
## 20 27 3774.534 4119.528 3780.583 2088.3981 123253.513 2023.4298
## 21 28 3720.246 3930.444 3736.746 2951.7179 48996.314 2358.5661
## 22 29 5008.927 4992.595 4997.805 1648.0955 1165.210 633.8147
## 23 3 3719.601 3932.625 3740.341 3178.0541 49373.967 2348.1469
## 24 4 5032.763 4622.017 5027.430 2193.0471 172808.379 2153.9765
## 25 5 4985.836 4632.382 4970.580 4754.8265 129753.433 4389.7222
## 26 6 4918.054 5383.459 4925.137 2942.1260 218727.236 2809.0940
## 27 7 6238.950 6598.083 6251.189 3899.2426 133344.419 3606.8599
## 28 71 3749.669 3061.628 3744.919 1691.7801 503213.331 1565.6585
## 29 72 2570.412 2817.652 2573.780 895.2579 62605.234 873.8647
## 30 73 3651.812 3245.710 3644.096 2834.8445 178732.922 2687.7813
## 31 74 2611.873 2971.053 2615.393 1262.6679 128484.632 1237.1866
## 32 75 2457.513 2921.313 2460.598 1186.4266 223302.190 1148.6903
## 33 76 2605.754 2794.466 2610.931 908.0377 37169.261 837.6791
## 34 77 2381.076 2596.606 2399.879 4331.1467 65699.194 1867.3101
## 35 78 6181.766 6206.827 6196.139 11846.2895 9830.992 4306.1075
## 36 79 2550.780 2896.834 2552.273 479.2383 126013.230 473.6175
## 37 8 5020.613 4475.650 5017.080 2019.6634 301348.951 2001.3996
## 38 9 6177.889 6402.963 6201.434 5030.8533 60396.829 3881.3593
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 1.2517201 3.0082662 0.7217310
## 2 0.9234702 7.8844618 0.6643267
## 3 0.9833975 49.6768518 0.9576543
## 4 1.2246618 163.4073603 1.2118077
## 5 0.5172979 115.1423423 0.5137552
## 6 1.0285725 54.6409274 0.9895487
## 7 1.1234650 3.6398692 0.5243879
## 8 0.4600002 58.5076349 0.4550805
## 9 0.9572698 1.8004536 0.4240232
## 10 0.3293185 26.0231312 0.3175408
## 11 0.5245091 5.0290402 0.3111626
## 12 0.8946343 27.4827625 0.8394457
## 13 0.7269478 5.2626960 0.4625954
## 14 0.8792602 126.6946487 0.8683075
## 15 0.8582648 2.1355605 0.3808862
## 16 1.1381461 3.4826635 0.6034871
## 17 0.5570672 3.9307037 0.3714072
## 18 1.1168052 10.7393021 0.8450997
## 19 0.8793117 69.1172021 0.8492852
## 20 0.5543969 29.8215878 0.5356911
## 21 0.7915231 12.4727384 0.6300854
## 22 0.3301579 0.2342547 0.1272852
## 23 0.8527554 12.4686828 0.6259144
## 24 0.4352439 37.4765535 0.4280987
## 25 0.9557488 28.0284067 0.8847297
## 26 0.5890819 40.8069199 0.5611054
## 27 0.6225915 20.1644326 0.5746297
## 28 0.4805983 164.3478521 0.4447405
## 29 0.3510473 22.1866778 0.3417409
## 30 0.7807913 55.4164939 0.7439422
## 31 0.4828043 43.2119340 0.4717320
## 32 0.4692780 76.4003488 0.4525587
## 33 0.3476060 13.2335843 0.3195076
## 34 1.7358355 25.4154540 0.7543901
## 35 1.9314480 1.6128355 0.7020001
## 36 0.1873756 43.4939041 0.1849499
## 37 0.3991913 67.3759636 0.3960267
## 38 0.8200468 9.2903772 0.6290050MEnggunakan rumus MSE synthetic yang perbaikan
res_srs2_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com Relatif MSE dir
## 1 1 4220.403 4216.292 4220.403 0 974040.1 0 0
## 2 10 6158.917 6172.297 6158.917 0 974044.3 0 0
## 3 11 4634.496 4655.050 4634.496 0 974050.7 0 0
## 4 12 4919.014 4612.412 4919.014 0 976513.4 0 0
## 5 13 5127.194 5210.191 5127.194 0 974220.9 0 0
## 6 14 5928.762 5876.421 5928.762 0 974111.7 0 0
## 7 15 6342.583 6245.147 6342.583 0 974289.4 0 0
## 8 16 5103.006 4911.246 5103.006 0 975007.3 0 0
## 9 17 5268.416 5397.589 5268.416 0 974478.7 0 0
## 10 18 4970.796 5093.818 4970.796 0 974437.9 0 0
## 11 19 4751.743 4396.560 4751.743 0 977359.5 0 0
## 12 2 4700.143 4755.819 4700.143 0 974121.2 0 0
## 13 20 4525.222 4394.751 4525.222 0 974487.6 0 0
## 14 21 4848.178 4752.708 4848.178 0 974279.5 0 0
## 15 22 5460.264 5519.749 5460.264 0 974132.7 0 0
## 16 23 5271.905 5297.644 5271.905 0 974057.0 0 0
## 17 24 5362.188 5414.360 5362.188 0 974111.2 0 0
## 18 25 5427.660 5439.128 5427.660 0 974043.1 0 0
## 19 26 4734.623 4823.859 4734.623 0 974249.2 0 0
## 20 27 4777.379 4776.869 4777.379 0 974039.6 0 0
## 21 28 4702.797 4658.169 4702.797 0 974092.0 0 0
## 22 29 5239.878 5237.877 5239.878 0 974039.7 0 0
## 23 3 4708.626 4794.793 4708.626 0 974235.0 0 0
## 24 4 5056.916 5048.966 5056.916 0 974041.3 0 0
## 25 5 5198.709 5215.515 5198.709 0 974047.0 0 0
## 26 6 5926.092 5914.324 5926.092 0 974043.3 0 0
## 27 7 6685.010 6943.755 6685.010 0 975801.4 0 0
## 28 71 3701.777 3582.993 3701.777 0 974410.9 0 0
## 29 72 3067.757 3396.768 3067.757 0 976888.2 0 0
## 30 73 4787.325 4261.271 4787.325 0 981322.1 0 0
## 31 74 3646.103 3494.168 3646.103 0 974647.1 0 0
## 32 75 3205.130 3439.743 3205.130 0 975488.1 0 0
## 33 76 3125.115 3468.370 3125.115 0 977140.2 0 0
## 34 77 3215.490 3385.882 3215.490 0 974803.6 0 0
## 35 78 6979.747 7098.937 6979.747 0 974413.5 0 0
## 36 79 3361.141 3446.142 3361.141 0 974229.7 0 0
## 37 8 5024.538 4887.130 5024.538 0 974536.5 0 0
## 38 9 6903.494 6831.826 6903.494 0 974174.8 0 0
## Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 231.0182 0
## 2 157.8090 0
## 3 209.2460 0
## 4 211.7143 0
## 5 186.9837 0
## 6 165.7661 0
## 7 156.0074 0
## 8 198.5255 0
## 9 180.5396 0
## 10 191.2981 0
## 11 222.3010 0
## 12 204.8272 0
## 13 221.7390 0
## 14 204.9946 0
## 15 176.4813 0
## 16 183.8661 0
## 17 179.9125 0
## 18 179.0807 0
## 19 201.9647 0
## 20 203.9075 0
## 21 209.1148 0
## 22 185.9608 0
## 23 203.1860 0
## 24 192.9190 0
## 25 186.7595 0
## 26 164.6922 0
## 27 140.5294 0
## 28 271.9545 0
## 29 287.5935 0
## 30 230.2886 0
## 31 278.9354 0
## 32 283.5933 0
## 33 281.7290 0
## 34 287.9024 0
## 35 137.2619 0
## 36 282.7016 0
## 37 199.4088 0
## 38 142.5936 0 b. f = 90%res_srs2_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4215.962 4212.608 4215.962 7.218753 973397.9 7.218699
## 2 10 6152.545 6166.747 6152.545 11.351350 973403.0 11.351218
## 3 11 4629.496 4652.793 4629.496 8.642732 973412.0 8.642655
## 4 12 4916.080 4609.792 4916.077 9.324579 975866.5 9.324490
## 5 13 5128.221 5207.313 5128.222 8.314825 973562.2 8.314754
## 6 14 5921.966 5873.988 5921.966 9.043191 973458.2 9.043107
## 7 15 6342.257 6242.549 6342.256 10.236157 973659.3 10.236049
## 8 16 5097.917 4908.800 5097.916 7.045927 974338.7 7.045876
## 9 17 5268.486 5394.187 5268.487 8.116771 973813.5 8.116704
## 10 18 4968.167 5091.340 4968.168 8.032782 973797.0 8.032715
## 11 19 4749.143 4393.794 4749.140 7.427946 976720.5 7.427889
## 12 2 4697.669 4752.874 4697.669 8.636786 973477.8 8.636709
## 13 20 4521.498 4392.227 4521.496 8.357513 973837.4 8.357441
## 14 21 4844.883 4749.877 4844.882 8.212851 973635.3 8.212782
## 15 22 5453.279 5516.833 5453.279 7.960099 973503.8 7.960034
## 16 23 5271.489 5296.101 5271.490 9.047506 973413.7 9.047422
## 17 24 5359.640 5410.648 5359.640 6.930413 973466.2 6.930364
## 18 25 5422.733 5434.850 5422.733 7.631241 973401.5 7.631181
## 19 26 4731.460 4820.784 4731.460 6.781754 973607.5 6.781707
## 20 27 4775.499 4774.368 4775.499 6.007371 973397.7 6.007334
## 21 28 4700.499 4654.043 4700.499 8.093167 973454.4 8.093100
## 22 29 5236.333 5234.386 5236.333 7.334890 973397.6 7.334835
## 23 3 4704.788 4791.804 4704.789 9.421460 973596.9 9.421369
## 24 4 5056.667 5045.802 5056.667 9.299558 973400.7 9.299469
## 25 5 5194.749 5212.619 5194.749 8.054695 973406.1 8.054628
## 26 6 5923.739 5911.818 5923.738 9.564725 973401.4 9.564631
## 27 7 6683.883 6941.009 6683.886 9.901924 975137.5 9.901823
## 28 71 3694.466 3579.976 3694.466 5.776885 973742.7 5.776851
## 29 72 3064.369 3393.742 3064.371 5.733052 976252.5 5.733018
## 30 73 4786.644 4258.562 4786.640 8.043708 980736.4 8.043642
## 31 74 3647.216 3490.978 3647.216 4.534223 974039.9 4.534202
## 32 75 3203.297 3436.680 3203.299 5.752941 974831.0 5.752907
## 33 76 3125.268 3466.671 3125.270 5.594400 976464.8 5.594368
## 34 77 3209.965 3382.349 3209.966 6.096949 974179.6 6.096911
## 35 78 6972.911 7094.107 6972.912 11.552240 973784.2 11.552103
## 36 79 3356.368 3443.072 3356.368 4.023162 973595.4 4.023146
## 37 8 5021.483 4883.018 5021.482 7.045387 973902.2 7.045336
## 38 9 6898.031 6825.951 6898.030 10.156488 973534.3 10.156382
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.001712246 231.0678 0.001712233
## 2 0.001844990 157.8471 0.001844968
## 3 0.001866878 209.2103 0.001866861
## 4 0.001896742 211.6943 0.001896725
## 5 0.001621388 186.9606 0.001621374
## 6 0.001527062 165.7236 0.001527047
## 7 0.001613956 155.9714 0.001613939
## 8 0.001382117 198.4882 0.001382107
## 9 0.001540630 180.5302 0.001540617
## 10 0.001616848 191.2653 0.001616834
## 11 0.001564058 222.2955 0.001564047
## 12 0.001838521 204.8188 0.001838505
## 13 0.001848394 221.7184 0.001848379
## 14 0.001695151 204.9812 0.001695137
## 15 0.001459689 176.4606 0.001459677
## 16 0.001716318 183.7982 0.001716302
## 17 0.001293077 179.9168 0.001293068
## 18 0.001407277 179.1037 0.001407266
## 19 0.001433334 201.9604 0.001433324
## 20 0.001257958 203.8799 0.001257950
## 21 0.001721767 209.1632 0.001721753
## 22 0.001400767 185.9622 0.001400756
## 23 0.002002537 203.1796 0.002002517
## 24 0.001839071 192.9130 0.001839054
## 25 0.001550542 186.7403 0.001550529
## 26 0.001614645 164.6535 0.001614629
## 27 0.001481459 140.4893 0.001481443
## 28 0.001563644 271.9970 0.001563635
## 29 0.001870879 287.6626 0.001870867
## 30 0.001680453 230.2976 0.001680441
## 31 0.001243205 279.0164 0.001243200
## 32 0.001795940 283.6549 0.001795929
## 33 0.001790058 281.6723 0.001790047
## 34 0.001899368 288.0187 0.001899355
## 35 0.001656729 137.2666 0.001656709
## 36 0.001198666 282.7694 0.001198661
## 37 0.001403042 199.4468 0.001403032
## 38 0.001472372 142.6225 0.001472357 c. f = 80%res_srs2_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4217.431 4212.610 4217.431 16.429791 972761.8 16.429514
## 2 10 6149.110 6165.609 6149.110 25.700485 972768.7 25.699806
## 3 11 4631.796 4652.781 4631.796 19.290717 972773.3 19.290335
## 4 12 4917.832 4609.877 4917.825 21.093985 975257.1 21.093529
## 5 13 5126.213 5208.748 5126.215 18.474566 972940.6 18.474215
## 6 14 5921.547 5875.228 5921.546 20.006312 972817.9 20.005901
## 7 15 6341.686 6243.899 6341.684 23.110139 973013.0 23.109590
## 8 16 5096.464 4907.863 5096.461 16.124627 973697.8 16.124359
## 9 17 5266.120 5393.170 5266.122 18.461082 973186.2 18.460731
## 10 18 4964.552 5089.954 4964.554 18.198892 973175.1 18.198551
## 11 19 4751.072 4393.919 4751.066 16.577516 976118.3 16.577234
## 12 2 4694.847 4751.412 4694.849 19.590353 972845.5 19.589958
## 13 20 4521.961 4391.294 4521.959 18.769622 973210.9 18.769260
## 14 21 4845.808 4749.073 4845.806 18.437219 973007.8 18.436869
## 15 22 5453.700 5516.116 5453.701 17.976090 972863.7 17.975757
## 16 23 5269.107 5295.556 5269.107 20.455437 972779.7 20.455006
## 17 24 5362.303 5412.605 5362.303 15.931154 972827.8 15.930893
## 18 25 5428.429 5438.028 5428.429 17.144256 972763.8 17.143954
## 19 26 4729.201 4818.961 4729.202 15.621796 972973.3 15.621545
## 20 27 4774.926 4773.863 4774.926 13.709377 972761.4 13.709183
## 21 28 4699.952 4654.018 4699.951 18.294934 972817.1 18.294589
## 22 29 5233.391 5231.685 5233.391 16.661340 972761.1 16.661054
## 23 3 4707.667 4793.803 4707.668 20.851500 972956.5 20.851053
## 24 4 5054.853 5044.872 5054.853 20.922666 972764.1 20.922216
## 25 5 5190.549 5211.537 5190.549 17.935135 972773.4 17.934805
## 26 6 5927.279 5910.329 5927.279 21.940318 972768.8 21.939823
## 27 7 6685.482 6940.638 6685.488 22.209462 974474.5 22.208956
## 28 71 3694.207 3580.448 3694.205 12.993191 973101.7 12.993017
## 29 72 3067.188 3394.240 3067.192 12.713463 975576.0 12.713297
## 30 73 4788.287 4260.501 4788.278 18.240531 980092.1 18.240191
## 31 74 3646.284 3491.289 3646.282 10.207701 973393.5 10.207594
## 32 75 3199.628 3437.161 3199.631 12.725169 974246.0 12.725003
## 33 76 3125.687 3467.417 3125.692 12.779057 975834.7 12.778890
## 34 77 3210.665 3383.463 3210.667 14.031881 973547.1 14.031678
## 35 78 6973.917 7095.279 6973.920 25.981123 973148.8 25.980429
## 36 79 3360.372 3443.423 3360.372 8.943122 972942.7 8.943039
## 37 8 5020.115 4882.292 5020.113 16.107413 973261.5 16.107146
## 38 9 6895.224 6821.890 6895.222 22.972291 972902.8 22.971748
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.003895698 230.9169 0.003895633
## 2 0.004179535 157.7733 0.004179425
## 3 0.004164777 209.0736 0.004164694
## 4 0.004289255 211.5582 0.004289168
## 5 0.003603995 186.7897 0.003603926
## 6 0.003378545 165.5796 0.003378477
## 7 0.003644169 155.8342 0.003644084
## 8 0.003163890 198.3955 0.003163840
## 9 0.003505642 180.4479 0.003505574
## 10 0.003665777 191.1953 0.003665706
## 11 0.003489197 222.1521 0.003489142
## 12 0.004172713 204.7488 0.004172627
## 13 0.004150724 221.6228 0.004150647
## 14 0.003804756 204.8838 0.003804685
## 15 0.003296175 176.3676 0.003296113
## 16 0.003882137 183.6974 0.003882055
## 17 0.002970947 179.7337 0.002970898
## 18 0.003158218 178.8818 0.003158162
## 19 0.003303254 201.9052 0.003303200
## 20 0.002871122 203.7682 0.002871082
## 21 0.003892559 209.0273 0.003892487
## 22 0.003183644 185.9365 0.003183589
## 23 0.004429282 202.9614 0.004429185
## 24 0.004139145 192.8224 0.004139056
## 25 0.003455364 186.6577 0.003455300
## 26 0.003701569 164.5879 0.003701486
## 27 0.003322059 140.4013 0.003321980
## 28 0.003517158 271.7822 0.003517113
## 29 0.004144987 287.4211 0.004144927
## 30 0.003809391 230.0416 0.003809328
## 31 0.002799490 278.8064 0.002799462
## 32 0.003977063 283.4451 0.003977007
## 33 0.004088402 281.4301 0.004088342
## 34 0.004370352 287.7369 0.004370286
## 35 0.003725454 137.1544 0.003725353
## 36 0.002661327 282.5512 0.002661302
## 37 0.003208588 199.3452 0.003208536
## 38 0.003331626 142.6148 0.003331549 d. f = 70%res_srs2_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4219.698 4211.706 4219.697 28.09899 973980.1 28.09818
## 2 10 6151.935 6164.659 6151.936 44.58035 973983.2 44.57831
## 3 11 4627.168 4650.208 4627.169 33.14687 973993.1 33.14574
## 4 12 4914.377 4607.017 4914.366 35.87448 976465.2 35.87316
## 5 13 5122.290 5203.854 5122.293 32.40632 974153.4 32.40524
## 6 14 5924.794 5872.609 5924.793 35.21539 974050.4 35.21412
## 7 15 6344.236 6244.010 6344.232 39.69274 974243.2 39.69112
## 8 16 5100.425 4908.610 5100.420 27.48591 974947.1 27.48514
## 9 17 5260.843 5394.211 5260.847 31.80306 974446.9 31.80202
## 10 18 4967.121 5089.401 4967.125 30.90939 974372.5 30.90841
## 11 19 4749.972 4393.679 4749.962 27.92906 977320.4 27.92826
## 12 2 4691.972 4752.132 4691.974 33.58696 974074.0 33.58580
## 13 20 4519.798 4391.351 4519.793 32.40900 974413.2 32.40792
## 14 21 4845.157 4749.029 4845.154 32.07887 974222.5 32.07781
## 15 22 5456.696 5512.780 5456.698 31.17113 974061.4 31.17013
## 16 23 5260.142 5292.329 5260.143 35.64928 974006.1 35.64798
## 17 24 5359.138 5410.148 5359.139 26.50567 974047.0 26.50495
## 18 25 5423.218 5436.158 5423.219 29.59922 973982.8 29.59831
## 19 26 4733.720 4819.322 4733.722 26.36264 974171.2 26.36193
## 20 27 4770.548 4771.145 4770.548 23.60433 973978.4 23.60376
## 21 28 4692.275 4652.053 4692.274 30.59288 974022.0 30.59192
## 22 29 5237.149 5235.606 5237.149 28.43423 973978.3 28.43340
## 23 3 4704.991 4789.050 4704.994 36.36256 974164.8 36.36120
## 24 4 5054.134 5046.054 5054.133 35.57637 973980.9 35.57506
## 25 5 5199.635 5211.960 5199.635 30.59954 973983.0 30.59858
## 26 6 5922.291 5910.042 5922.290 37.51323 973982.8 37.51178
## 27 7 6684.395 6940.754 6684.405 37.74656 975709.1 37.74510
## 28 71 3696.797 3579.143 3696.795 22.42612 974343.3 22.42560
## 29 72 3063.130 3392.336 3063.138 21.90992 976830.8 21.90943
## 30 73 4775.893 4254.991 4775.876 30.56947 981119.3 30.56852
## 31 74 3648.536 3489.856 3648.533 17.77796 974641.1 17.77764
## 32 75 3196.990 3435.767 3196.995 22.10092 975479.3 22.10042
## 33 76 3123.700 3462.682 3123.707 21.84998 977002.6 21.84949
## 34 77 3213.909 3381.066 3213.913 23.71641 974714.1 23.71583
## 35 78 6974.604 7095.435 6974.609 44.20477 974363.1 44.20276
## 36 79 3355.093 3441.694 3355.094 15.68248 974175.9 15.68223
## 37 8 5015.512 4882.239 5015.508 26.87231 974446.1 26.87157
## 38 9 6895.350 6822.549 6895.347 39.78139 974118.3 39.77977
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.006658986 231.2557 0.006658794
## 2 0.007246514 157.9947 0.007246181
## 3 0.007163539 209.4516 0.007163294
## 4 0.007299770 211.9518 0.007299518
## 5 0.006326535 187.1985 0.006326321
## 6 0.005943754 165.8633 0.005943541
## 7 0.006256516 156.0284 0.006256265
## 8 0.005388923 198.6197 0.005388776
## 9 0.006045201 180.6467 0.006044998
## 10 0.006222607 191.4513 0.006222404
## 11 0.005879912 222.4378 0.005879756
## 12 0.007158358 204.9762 0.007158107
## 13 0.007170335 221.8937 0.007170103
## 14 0.006620775 205.1414 0.006620561
## 15 0.005712530 176.6916 0.005712345
## 16 0.006777332 184.0412 0.006777082
## 17 0.004945825 180.0407 0.004945689
## 18 0.005457897 179.1676 0.005457730
## 19 0.005569108 202.1386 0.005568954
## 20 0.004947942 204.1394 0.004947822
## 21 0.006519636 209.3748 0.006519433
## 22 0.005429359 186.0300 0.005429200
## 23 0.007728687 203.4153 0.007728393
## 24 0.007039207 193.0183 0.007038949
## 25 0.005885010 186.8746 0.005884824
## 26 0.006334221 164.8013 0.006333977
## 27 0.005646885 140.5768 0.005646658
## 28 0.006066365 272.2282 0.006066229
## 29 0.007152722 287.9524 0.007152544
## 30 0.006400665 230.5810 0.006400487
## 31 0.004872764 279.2784 0.004872679
## 32 0.006913135 283.9190 0.006912967
## 33 0.006995070 282.1523 0.006994897
## 34 0.007379143 288.2862 0.007378953
## 35 0.006337956 137.3226 0.006337664
## 36 0.004674277 283.0514 0.004674200
## 37 0.005357808 199.5900 0.005357664
## 38 0.005769292 142.7793 0.005769059 e. f = 60%res_srs2_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4213.974 4212.417 4213.973 44.24996 972317.5 44.24794
## 2 10 6154.844 6170.773 6154.846 67.42212 972324.4 67.41744
## 3 11 4629.434 4649.265 4629.435 53.46707 972328.3 53.46412
## 4 12 4923.218 4610.679 4923.200 54.72523 974888.8 54.72215
## 5 13 5118.337 5204.040 5118.342 49.06925 972510.7 49.06677
## 6 14 5922.846 5874.196 5922.843 54.51281 972380.2 54.50975
## 7 15 6344.108 6243.856 6344.102 60.44211 972582.1 60.43835
## 8 16 5100.443 4905.285 5100.435 43.49377 973320.0 43.49182
## 9 17 5256.155 5392.855 5256.162 48.55063 972809.1 48.54820
## 10 18 4962.479 5090.129 4962.485 48.91774 972746.4 48.91528
## 11 19 4750.182 4390.820 4750.166 44.80221 975716.1 44.80015
## 12 2 4695.005 4748.234 4695.008 52.26742 972392.0 52.26460
## 13 20 4520.326 4390.700 4520.319 50.05314 972760.0 50.05056
## 14 21 4847.352 4746.901 4847.347 49.54321 972583.4 49.54069
## 15 22 5455.916 5516.064 5455.919 48.66356 972413.0 48.66112
## 16 23 5265.118 5296.362 5265.119 55.22939 972343.1 55.22625
## 17 24 5361.744 5411.816 5361.746 42.19402 972383.5 42.19219
## 18 25 5429.700 5440.203 5429.701 46.82496 972320.3 46.82270
## 19 26 4727.379 4816.417 4727.383 40.91920 972526.6 40.91748
## 20 27 4770.669 4773.891 4770.669 35.74541 972318.3 35.74410
## 21 28 4702.049 4654.276 4702.047 49.54117 972378.2 49.53864
## 22 29 5231.137 5229.723 5231.137 43.52108 972317.1 43.51913
## 23 3 4711.631 4793.966 4711.636 57.51066 972496.3 57.50725
## 24 4 5052.969 5043.466 5052.969 54.80653 972320.2 54.80344
## 25 5 5187.733 5209.540 5187.734 46.78138 972330.4 46.77913
## 26 6 5928.586 5910.097 5928.585 57.66084 972326.1 57.65741
## 27 7 6675.911 6935.658 6675.926 59.00133 974093.9 58.99776
## 28 71 3696.708 3579.575 3696.704 34.64635 972678.8 34.64512
## 29 72 3064.719 3393.754 3064.731 34.64517 975167.2 34.64393
## 30 73 4785.639 4256.383 4785.612 49.61174 979688.8 49.60922
## 31 74 3643.737 3491.287 3643.733 26.94697 972929.0 26.94623
## 32 75 3204.527 3436.690 3204.535 34.94407 973735.8 34.94281
## 33 76 3124.642 3466.828 3124.654 32.95081 975398.9 32.94969
## 34 77 3203.172 3381.166 3203.178 36.10406 973151.2 36.10272
## 35 78 6966.547 7088.201 6966.555 68.59045 972707.1 68.58561
## 36 79 3356.194 3443.268 3356.196 23.89921 972516.7 23.89862
## 37 8 5021.797 4883.167 5021.791 43.17498 972823.1 43.17307
## 38 9 6896.975 6821.956 6896.970 61.69054 972465.8 61.68662
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.010500701 230.8221 0.010500222
## 2 0.010954443 157.5693 0.010953681
## 3 0.011548811 209.1360 0.011548172
## 4 0.011115781 211.4416 0.011115196
## 5 0.009587040 186.8763 0.009586546
## 6 0.009203860 165.5342 0.009203348
## 7 0.009527090 155.7662 0.009526506
## 8 0.008527790 198.4227 0.008527422
## 9 0.009236969 180.3885 0.009236496
## 10 0.009857631 191.1045 0.009857122
## 11 0.009431782 222.2174 0.009431381
## 12 0.011132304 204.7904 0.011131698
## 13 0.011072549 221.5502 0.011071995
## 14 0.010220220 204.8881 0.010219710
## 15 0.008919379 176.2877 0.008918928
## 16 0.010489800 183.5870 0.010489200
## 17 0.007869510 179.6780 0.007869164
## 18 0.008623942 178.7288 0.008623525
## 19 0.008655874 201.9192 0.008655503
## 20 0.007492770 203.6743 0.007492494
## 21 0.010535931 208.9217 0.010535399
## 22 0.008319457 185.9217 0.008319084
## 23 0.012206399 202.8588 0.012205663
## 24 0.010846187 192.7881 0.010845576
## 25 0.009017789 186.6442 0.009017353
## 26 0.009726014 164.5196 0.009725438
## 27 0.008838129 140.4472 0.008837572
## 28 0.009372056 271.7306 0.009371732
## 29 0.011303069 287.3422 0.011302622
## 30 0.010366635 230.1699 0.010366168
## 31 0.007395461 278.6739 0.007395264
## 32 0.010904113 283.3358 0.010903692
## 33 0.010545507 281.3525 0.010545111
## 34 0.011271331 287.8161 0.011270889
## 35 0.009845814 137.2291 0.009845108
## 36 0.007120901 282.4405 0.007120721
## 37 0.008597456 199.2198 0.008597084
## 38 0.008944302 142.5494 0.008943739 f. f = 50%res_srs2_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4214.448 4211.044 4214.447 66.35061 972683.8 66.34606
## 2 10 6159.496 6168.204 6159.497 101.81959 972685.4 101.80892
## 3 11 4634.265 4654.179 4634.266 78.77688 972694.0 78.77048
## 4 12 4917.423 4612.444 4917.397 85.44515 975131.8 85.43764
## 5 13 5128.539 5206.336 5128.545 74.90919 972843.9 74.90339
## 6 14 5924.606 5874.696 5924.602 82.36325 972749.6 82.35627
## 7 15 6348.898 6242.940 6348.888 88.65982 972978.6 88.65172
## 8 16 5101.969 4906.338 5101.956 64.25956 973690.7 64.25529
## 9 17 5265.611 5391.802 5265.620 71.31062 973102.9 71.30538
## 10 18 4968.291 5089.657 4968.300 70.61161 973071.2 70.60647
## 11 19 4745.550 4391.901 4745.526 66.30473 975975.0 66.30022
## 12 2 4695.584 4748.581 4695.588 79.19550 972757.7 79.18903
## 13 20 4516.057 4390.891 4516.048 74.77800 973096.0 74.77224
## 14 21 4841.291 4748.203 4841.284 75.00189 972911.5 74.99609
## 15 22 5450.553 5512.052 5450.557 72.80047 972783.3 72.79501
## 16 23 5264.860 5295.410 5264.863 81.20087 972708.9 81.19407
## 17 24 5353.769 5406.618 5353.772 63.19273 972757.6 63.18860
## 18 25 5420.506 5434.263 5420.507 68.46675 972688.1 68.46191
## 19 26 4735.971 4817.446 4735.976 60.42113 972858.0 60.41737
## 20 27 4776.481 4774.956 4776.481 54.46272 972684.3 54.45966
## 21 28 4694.608 4652.944 4694.605 71.69840 972729.2 71.69309
## 22 29 5239.093 5237.424 5239.093 67.31701 972682.7 67.31233
## 23 3 4707.496 4792.876 4707.503 84.40755 972876.3 84.40019
## 24 4 5047.093 5043.632 5047.093 87.38736 972684.5 87.37948
## 25 5 5199.503 5211.530 5199.504 72.03817 972688.8 72.03282
## 26 6 5918.632 5910.576 5918.631 84.45984 972685.2 84.45248
## 27 7 6676.367 6940.825 6676.391 87.35732 974524.6 87.34948
## 28 71 3697.497 3580.262 3697.491 52.00041 973045.2 51.99762
## 29 72 3063.531 3394.305 3063.549 52.59824 975563.0 52.59538
## 30 73 4786.032 4258.159 4785.993 71.36402 980017.1 71.35882
## 31 74 3645.385 3491.639 3645.379 39.78351 973305.2 39.78188
## 32 75 3200.151 3437.208 3200.163 50.96519 974161.9 50.96251
## 33 76 3127.892 3468.230 3127.909 50.42364 975731.6 50.42103
## 34 77 3208.099 3381.442 3208.109 55.02813 973474.0 55.02502
## 35 78 6972.413 7092.872 6972.426 106.49046 973064.9 106.47879
## 36 79 3360.199 3443.716 3360.202 34.85567 972867.2 34.85442
## 37 8 5019.816 4882.456 5019.807 62.27636 973179.8 62.27237
## 38 9 6893.878 6823.795 6893.871 93.55164 972812.4 93.54262
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.01574314 230.9839 0.01574206
## 2 0.01653090 157.6933 0.01652917
## 3 0.01699862 208.9940 0.01699723
## 4 0.01737644 211.4135 0.01737501
## 5 0.01460640 186.8580 0.01460525
## 6 0.01390248 165.5831 0.01390131
## 7 0.01396445 155.8528 0.01396320
## 8 0.01259569 198.4560 0.01259488
## 9 0.01354228 180.4783 0.01354126
## 10 0.01421233 191.1862 0.01421127
## 11 0.01397212 222.2219 0.01397124
## 12 0.01686559 204.8523 0.01686420
## 13 0.01655859 221.6174 0.01655735
## 14 0.01549166 204.9011 0.01549049
## 15 0.01335651 176.4828 0.01335550
## 16 0.01542400 183.6891 0.01542270
## 17 0.01180418 179.9197 0.01180340
## 18 0.01263136 178.9918 0.01263046
## 19 0.01275788 201.9448 0.01275707
## 20 0.01140265 203.7055 0.01140201
## 21 0.01527291 209.0568 0.01527179
## 22 0.01284905 185.7183 0.01284816
## 23 0.01792872 202.9841 0.01792713
## 24 0.01731364 192.8541 0.01731208
## 25 0.01385503 186.6418 0.01385400
## 26 0.01426937 164.5671 0.01426813
## 27 0.01308438 140.4047 0.01308316
## 28 0.01406314 271.7810 0.01406241
## 29 0.01716829 287.4124 0.01716726
## 30 0.01491046 230.1507 0.01490949
## 31 0.01091390 278.7537 0.01091347
## 32 0.01592656 283.4173 0.01592567
## 33 0.01612045 281.3349 0.01611952
## 34 0.01715254 287.8879 0.01715152
## 35 0.01527343 137.1891 0.01527173
## 36 0.01037257 282.5057 0.01037219
## 37 0.01240611 199.3217 0.01240534
## 38 0.01357004 142.5618 0.01356874 g. f = 40%res_srs2_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4217.722 4212.808 4217.722 97.15800 972067.6 97.14822
## 2 10 6149.432 6163.649 6149.434 151.09438 972072.5 151.07085
## 3 11 4623.487 4644.355 4623.489 117.23091 972078.2 117.21666
## 4 12 4923.551 4605.688 4923.510 126.59003 974727.0 126.57350
## 5 13 5123.034 5201.563 5123.043 111.59348 972228.9 111.58062
## 6 14 5912.444 5870.456 5912.439 118.51208 972115.6 118.49759
## 7 15 6346.865 6244.675 6346.851 137.21422 972343.2 137.19483
## 8 16 5091.681 4904.310 5091.662 94.80966 972990.4 94.80038
## 9 17 5271.057 5391.724 5271.071 109.77948 972450.0 109.76704
## 10 18 4964.713 5087.758 4964.727 107.48485 972467.7 107.47293
## 11 19 4754.653 4392.059 4754.616 99.36445 975527.7 99.35427
## 12 2 4685.354 4749.036 4685.362 115.79991 972175.2 115.78604
## 13 20 4521.222 4388.345 4521.207 114.05401 972533.7 114.04059
## 14 21 4851.312 4747.062 4851.300 110.60909 972354.2 110.59645
## 15 22 5453.974 5514.286 5453.981 111.96047 972162.2 111.94755
## 16 23 5263.930 5292.808 5263.934 121.61684 972089.5 121.60156
## 17 24 5362.102 5409.786 5362.106 93.09244 972126.1 93.08349
## 18 25 5426.445 5439.466 5426.447 104.00921 972071.4 103.99806
## 19 26 4728.487 4815.465 4728.495 90.40908 972267.0 90.40063
## 20 27 4776.085 4770.904 4776.085 79.91975 972068.3 79.91316
## 21 28 4693.680 4652.189 4693.675 113.14291 972112.2 113.12968
## 22 29 5234.344 5232.633 5234.344 98.68426 972065.9 98.67421
## 23 3 4709.701 4795.475 4709.712 126.50636 972260.8 126.48985
## 24 4 5052.032 5043.409 5052.031 125.71062 972070.4 125.69430
## 25 5 5192.213 5208.599 5192.214 109.22081 972077.1 109.20850
## 26 6 5913.859 5907.325 5913.858 129.77877 972070.8 129.76141
## 27 7 6671.620 6934.617 6671.655 132.88601 973888.8 132.86779
## 28 71 3694.088 3579.737 3694.079 78.31397 972411.9 78.30763
## 29 72 3067.047 3393.504 3067.073 76.58288 974871.4 76.57682
## 30 73 4784.524 4261.120 4784.465 110.90737 979278.6 110.89479
## 31 74 3647.602 3490.465 3647.592 60.09812 972716.6 60.09439
## 32 75 3195.329 3436.257 3195.348 76.51865 973595.0 76.51262
## 33 76 3124.458 3466.437 3124.484 72.94416 975145.2 72.93863
## 34 77 3212.809 3383.504 3212.824 84.09095 972834.7 84.08365
## 35 78 6979.600 7098.279 6979.619 154.10398 972438.2 154.07946
## 36 79 3347.877 3442.652 3347.882 56.32135 972303.2 56.31807
## 37 8 5011.025 4879.938 5011.012 95.94273 972521.3 95.93324
## 38 9 6891.394 6818.410 6891.384 137.43339 972206.7 137.41389
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.02303321 230.7415 0.02303089
## 2 0.02457013 157.7104 0.02456630
## 3 0.02535513 209.3042 0.02535203
## 4 0.02571160 211.6360 0.02570846
## 5 0.02178188 186.9120 0.02177933
## 6 0.02004520 165.5949 0.02004277
## 7 0.02161916 155.7074 0.02161616
## 8 0.01862076 198.3950 0.01861901
## 9 0.02082632 180.3597 0.02082390
## 10 0.02165053 191.1390 0.02164807
## 11 0.02090050 222.1122 0.02089853
## 12 0.02471713 204.7104 0.02471413
## 13 0.02522516 221.6182 0.02522228
## 14 0.02280057 204.8331 0.02279802
## 15 0.02052792 176.2992 0.02052552
## 16 0.02310460 183.6628 0.02310168
## 17 0.01736190 179.6981 0.01736022
## 18 0.01916723 178.7074 0.01916517
## 19 0.01911967 201.9053 0.01911785
## 20 0.01673276 203.7498 0.01673138
## 21 0.02410462 208.9585 0.02410182
## 22 0.01885378 185.7696 0.01885186
## 23 0.02686210 202.7464 0.02685853
## 24 0.02488251 192.7408 0.02487928
## 25 0.02103551 186.6294 0.02103313
## 26 0.02194452 164.5539 0.02194159
## 27 0.01991673 140.4386 0.01991390
## 28 0.02119954 271.6443 0.02119788
## 29 0.02496991 287.2770 0.02496772
## 30 0.02318115 229.8180 0.02317881
## 31 0.01647576 278.6792 0.01647478
## 32 0.02394727 283.3313 0.02394525
## 33 0.02334363 281.3125 0.02334167
## 34 0.02617223 287.5243 0.02616984
## 35 0.02207890 136.9960 0.02207532
## 36 0.01682181 282.4297 0.01682080
## 37 0.01914588 199.2898 0.01914403
## 38 0.01994161 142.5854 0.01993881 h. f = 30%res_srs2_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4203.826 4204.234 4203.826 150.87883 972340.9 150.85513
## 2 10 6153.172 6169.597 6153.176 237.63102 972346.6 237.57244
## 3 11 4632.452 4649.911 4632.456 190.70404 972351.1 190.66645
## 4 12 4905.947 4607.954 4905.886 199.55198 974679.6 199.51098
## 5 13 5117.686 5202.400 5117.700 164.04045 972528.3 164.01264
## 6 14 5924.406 5867.716 5924.395 191.54046 972425.0 191.50253
## 7 15 6334.748 6234.340 6334.724 223.60915 972607.0 223.55759
## 8 16 5093.865 4903.272 5093.836 150.45052 973295.8 150.42717
## 9 17 5255.278 5387.423 5255.301 175.00165 972800.7 174.96994
## 10 18 4956.805 5086.385 4956.827 170.13837 972784.5 170.10804
## 11 19 4734.287 4385.685 4734.231 154.82742 975541.9 154.80262
## 12 2 4693.833 4741.605 4693.842 175.26224 972402.3 175.23054
## 13 20 4512.533 4384.337 4512.509 180.29634 972775.2 180.26270
## 14 21 4838.562 4741.313 4838.545 170.96019 972588.3 170.92999
## 15 22 5456.861 5515.740 5456.871 161.10370 972430.5 161.07674
## 16 23 5269.949 5295.138 5269.954 180.50669 972357.6 180.47303
## 17 24 5354.584 5408.255 5354.591 136.28143 972415.2 136.26217
## 18 25 5418.941 5428.759 5418.942 159.81990 972343.2 159.79348
## 19 26 4718.764 4813.266 4718.778 142.47527 972574.5 142.45427
## 20 27 4770.270 4769.608 4770.270 128.12351 972341.1 128.10651
## 21 28 4707.160 4649.466 4707.151 165.99056 972431.3 165.96202
## 22 29 5221.257 5218.396 5221.256 160.08055 972338.0 160.05410
## 23 3 4688.131 4784.550 4688.149 183.99662 972584.5 183.96141
## 24 4 5043.866 5036.635 5043.864 205.05460 972344.0 205.01120
## 25 5 5185.563 5202.905 5185.566 167.44196 972346.0 167.41296
## 26 6 5920.128 5903.859 5920.125 213.23559 972349.2 213.18814
## 27 7 6670.314 6933.531 6670.371 209.55162 974166.9 209.50633
## 28 71 3699.627 3576.316 3699.611 127.45487 972740.3 127.43805
## 29 72 3057.736 3391.006 3057.777 119.62393 975262.3 119.60909
## 30 73 4790.044 4257.451 4789.948 177.29145 979807.3 177.25928
## 31 74 3642.107 3487.994 3642.091 98.74523 972964.6 98.73516
## 32 75 3205.916 3433.315 3205.944 119.15079 973701.8 119.13612
## 33 76 3130.757 3467.344 3130.798 116.93922 975321.4 116.92508
## 34 77 3196.048 3378.952 3196.073 129.32384 973220.5 129.30653
## 35 78 6965.500 7083.305 6965.530 251.15116 972705.6 251.08610
## 36 79 3353.321 3440.437 3353.328 78.53672 972540.0 78.53033
## 37 8 5025.033 4877.791 5025.011 145.45373 972909.5 145.43173
## 38 9 6901.638 6830.724 6901.622 215.52354 972471.4 215.47535
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.03588796 231.2780 0.03588232
## 2 0.03861866 157.6027 0.03860911
## 3 0.04117567 209.1123 0.04116752
## 4 0.04067594 211.5212 0.04066809
## 5 0.03205670 186.9384 0.03205118
## 6 0.03233215 165.7243 0.03232580
## 7 0.03529904 156.0079 0.03529103
## 8 0.02953611 198.4994 0.02953170
## 9 0.03329716 180.5688 0.03329097
## 10 0.03432025 191.2530 0.03431397
## 11 0.03269868 222.4382 0.03269383
## 12 0.03734120 205.0801 0.03733437
## 13 0.03995183 221.8757 0.03994459
## 14 0.03533254 205.1312 0.03532643
## 15 0.02952287 176.3012 0.02951788
## 16 0.03425305 183.6325 0.03424663
## 17 0.02545130 179.8018 0.02544767
## 18 0.02949623 179.1094 0.02949135
## 19 0.03019452 202.0620 0.03018998
## 20 0.02685917 203.8622 0.02685560
## 21 0.03526530 209.1491 0.03525931
## 22 0.03066031 186.3297 0.03065525
## 23 0.03924935 203.2762 0.03924169
## 24 0.04065774 193.0545 0.04064914
## 25 0.03228988 186.8855 0.03228426
## 26 0.03601128 164.6975 0.03600330
## 27 0.03141640 140.5006 0.03140934
## 28 0.03444991 271.9962 0.03444552
## 29 0.03911787 287.6040 0.03911249
## 30 0.03701654 230.1402 0.03701057
## 31 0.02711330 278.9479 0.02711065
## 32 0.03716135 283.6052 0.03715645
## 33 0.03735099 281.2897 0.03734600
## 34 0.04046317 288.0257 0.04045745
## 35 0.03605559 137.3236 0.03604609
## 36 0.02341856 282.6805 0.02341660
## 37 0.02894352 199.4571 0.02893927
## 38 0.03122738 142.3676 0.03122047 i. f = 20%res_srs2_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4204.162 4210.294 4204.163 264.7276 970499.6 264.6544
## 2 10 6147.940 6159.913 6147.945 404.6032 970501.4 404.4322
## 3 11 4612.688 4629.535 4612.693 328.1080 970507.6 327.9947
## 4 12 4915.424 4595.841 4915.313 338.8068 973185.2 338.6880
## 5 13 5101.556 5187.655 5101.582 292.3870 970694.4 292.2981
## 6 14 5913.640 5857.924 5913.622 319.7343 970583.2 319.6281
## 7 15 6340.554 6237.566 6340.518 347.3467 970775.6 347.2216
## 8 16 5085.924 4897.633 5085.875 251.1691 971430.5 251.1030
## 9 17 5262.204 5387.232 5262.243 301.9594 970914.1 301.8647
## 10 18 4953.493 5083.452 4953.532 286.1963 970941.8 286.1111
## 11 19 4750.013 4385.406 4749.913 266.0667 973997.2 265.9937
## 12 2 4692.003 4744.754 4692.021 328.8003 970572.9 328.6876
## 13 20 4504.606 4381.799 4504.569 290.5994 970896.6 290.5114
## 14 21 4858.171 4740.880 4858.136 286.9483 970861.9 286.8627
## 15 22 5463.474 5514.610 5463.490 300.2650 970566.6 300.1705
## 16 23 5253.115 5288.827 5253.127 324.9591 970537.7 324.8498
## 17 24 5354.246 5405.438 5354.259 246.0789 970565.2 246.0149
## 18 25 5423.800 5435.157 5423.804 295.6562 970501.4 295.5640
## 19 26 4723.122 4810.305 4723.145 249.8267 970701.8 249.7611
## 20 27 4748.947 4763.767 4748.951 231.1155 970504.8 231.0598
## 21 28 4690.309 4647.097 4690.296 298.3559 970548.8 298.2636
## 22 29 5228.525 5225.957 5228.524 257.1503 970494.0 257.0804
## 23 3 4702.371 4790.299 4702.400 325.0010 970701.4 324.8901
## 24 4 5033.156 5037.993 5033.158 346.7185 970502.2 346.5926
## 25 5 5201.039 5200.146 5201.039 295.9193 970500.2 295.8286
## 26 6 5906.785 5899.576 5906.783 365.0429 970497.7 364.9017
## 27 7 6646.355 6919.961 6646.452 340.7466 972471.4 340.6264
## 28 71 3697.976 3574.672 3697.951 194.6339 970898.6 194.5943
## 29 72 3067.919 3388.743 3067.983 193.5978 973205.7 193.5585
## 30 73 4790.454 4256.350 4790.298 286.6791 978009.2 286.5942
## 31 74 3650.884 3485.651 3650.857 158.2176 971215.5 158.1912
## 32 75 3186.051 3431.098 3186.100 194.5098 972081.3 194.4704
## 33 76 3123.786 3461.809 3123.852 188.2765 973503.9 188.2396
## 34 77 3191.754 3379.503 3191.796 217.9817 971426.5 217.9318
## 35 78 6969.305 7089.690 6969.358 425.1564 970879.8 424.9692
## 36 79 3334.491 3438.002 3334.506 141.4231 970776.9 141.4023
## 37 8 5016.740 4874.540 5016.707 230.0399 971030.7 229.9850
## 38 9 6889.166 6817.078 6889.140 352.7890 970631.8 352.6598
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.06295782 230.5090 0.06294038
## 2 0.06580664 157.5504 0.06577876
## 3 0.07113048 209.6347 0.07110583
## 4 0.06893115 211.7530 0.06890854
## 5 0.05730966 187.1167 0.05729195
## 6 0.05407469 165.6869 0.05405689
## 7 0.05479022 155.6334 0.05477081
## 8 0.04939058 198.3477 0.04937806
## 9 0.05738090 180.2249 0.05736247
## 10 0.05778065 191.0003 0.05776300
## 11 0.05601250 222.1006 0.05599832
## 12 0.07007264 204.5587 0.07004835
## 13 0.06451469 221.5754 0.06449569
## 14 0.05906311 204.7854 0.05904593
## 15 0.05495725 175.9994 0.05493980
## 16 0.06186973 183.5070 0.06184877
## 17 0.04595242 179.5543 0.04594036
## 18 0.05451550 178.5603 0.05449848
## 19 0.05289656 201.7967 0.05288241
## 20 0.04866434 203.7260 0.04865257
## 21 0.06362239 208.8506 0.06360288
## 22 0.04917827 185.7067 0.04916492
## 23 0.06910703 202.6394 0.06908302
## 24 0.06888098 192.6367 0.06885595
## 25 0.05689669 186.6292 0.05687925
## 26 0.06180930 164.5028 0.06178541
## 27 0.05127749 140.5311 0.05125864
## 28 0.05261980 271.6059 0.05260946
## 29 0.06308990 287.1885 0.06307578
## 30 0.05982836 229.7763 0.05981262
## 31 0.04333704 278.6331 0.04333012
## 32 0.06103219 283.3161 0.06101890
## 33 0.06027680 281.2123 0.06026370
## 34 0.06829693 287.4481 0.06828039
## 35 0.06100287 136.9419 0.06097554
## 36 0.04241473 282.3673 0.04240829
## 37 0.04585183 199.2049 0.04584119
## 38 0.05121342 142.3817 0.05119487 j. f = 10%res_srs2_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4209.943 4193.254 4209.932 556.4114 970404.6 556.0901
## 2 10 6155.572 6155.327 6155.571 896.4634 970398.2 895.6128
## 3 11 4624.276 4627.728 4624.278 669.5460 970379.7 669.0767
## 4 12 4892.276 4589.405 4892.031 782.4219 972799.5 781.7811
## 5 13 5080.150 5169.033 5080.209 658.1169 970590.9 657.6606
## 6 14 5925.501 5842.667 5925.442 708.3874 970567.3 707.8588
## 7 15 6356.499 6233.626 6356.394 826.9329 970786.1 826.2189
## 8 16 5087.130 4882.298 5087.017 538.7387 971485.9 538.4330
## 9 17 5217.435 5361.306 5217.530 642.0345 970927.4 641.6007
## 10 18 4937.302 5059.895 4937.379 614.8969 970784.2 614.4990
## 11 19 4737.975 4368.170 4737.760 563.4928 973979.2 563.1543
## 12 2 4674.615 4715.227 4674.644 683.3317 970423.2 682.8317
## 13 20 4485.106 4350.994 4485.015 644.9829 970860.7 644.5425
## 14 21 4817.880 4719.267 4817.818 617.5336 970652.7 617.1265
## 15 22 5461.196 5500.258 5461.223 660.9145 970426.1 660.4579
## 16 23 5237.866 5290.888 5237.905 688.7692 970463.8 688.2728
## 17 24 5335.698 5400.191 5335.734 544.0631 970492.3 543.7515
## 18 25 5401.212 5425.109 5401.226 603.1098 970399.4 602.7214
## 19 26 4691.270 4783.745 4691.325 566.2592 970604.8 565.9243
## 20 27 4731.734 4747.979 4731.743 481.7789 970392.7 481.5337
## 21 28 4664.213 4620.181 4664.183 671.0080 970446.5 670.5386
## 22 29 5195.664 5193.702 5195.663 535.5033 970375.8 535.2027
## 23 3 4681.088 4772.939 4681.155 709.3697 970615.7 708.8427
## 24 4 4991.940 5011.390 4991.954 778.0726 970404.5 777.4314
## 25 5 5154.083 5170.770 5154.094 651.3947 970387.4 650.9509
## 26 6 5869.321 5859.759 5869.311 823.2036 970386.5 822.4902
## 27 7 6632.109 6918.413 6632.323 726.4400 972538.6 725.8911
## 28 71 3696.259 3567.614 3696.202 434.9357 970817.1 434.7353
## 29 72 3040.139 3381.482 3040.320 514.6835 973455.3 514.4010
## 30 73 4794.335 4263.662 4793.960 692.9874 977805.3 692.4902
## 31 74 3648.743 3476.654 3648.678 367.3513 971158.2 367.2114
## 32 75 3164.920 3422.914 3165.044 468.2575 972145.8 468.0282
## 33 76 3128.930 3468.615 3129.083 437.0300 973417.2 436.8271
## 34 77 3191.379 3370.659 3191.474 514.6782 971237.3 514.3950
## 35 78 6965.904 7083.352 6966.010 877.0423 970740.4 876.2385
## 36 79 3346.126 3430.263 3346.154 323.1922 970572.5 323.0830
## 37 8 4987.870 4857.891 4987.792 573.3928 970831.1 573.0302
## 38 9 6898.318 6825.354 6898.260 765.1744 970528.3 764.5608
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.13210472 231.4278 0.13202882
## 2 0.14560955 157.6520 0.14547144
## 3 0.14475597 209.6887 0.14465449
## 4 0.15987851 211.9661 0.15975581
## 5 0.12952361 187.7712 0.12943230
## 6 0.11959332 166.1159 0.11950521
## 7 0.13007570 155.7327 0.12996558
## 8 0.10591242 198.9814 0.10585473
## 9 0.12306698 181.0988 0.12298150
## 10 0.12453769 191.8582 0.12445514
## 11 0.11889670 222.9732 0.11883090
## 12 0.14620167 205.8105 0.14609372
## 13 0.14370241 223.1371 0.14360742
## 14 0.12817582 205.6794 0.12809305
## 15 0.12101152 176.4349 0.12092734
## 16 0.13152895 183.4217 0.13143311
## 17 0.10198450 179.7180 0.10192535
## 18 0.11165053 178.8739 0.11157831
## 19 0.12071185 202.8982 0.12063904
## 20 0.10184554 204.3797 0.10179350
## 21 0.14387587 210.0458 0.14377614
## 22 0.10305902 186.8355 0.10300120
## 23 0.15153196 203.3579 0.15141726
## 24 0.15583520 193.6403 0.15570641
## 25 0.12639005 187.6672 0.12630364
## 26 0.14021277 165.6005 0.14009155
## 27 0.10951442 140.5706 0.10942811
## 28 0.11767371 272.1239 0.11762137
## 29 0.16935087 287.8836 0.16924743
## 30 0.14456297 229.3347 0.14447070
## 31 0.10066767 279.3426 0.10063113
## 32 0.14792597 284.0171 0.14784765
## 33 0.13963909 280.6378 0.13956727
## 34 0.16123508 288.1498 0.16114147
## 35 0.12589482 137.0429 0.12577747
## 36 0.09658353 282.9493 0.09655011
## 37 0.11493306 199.8487 0.11486235
## 38 0.11094120 142.1950 0.11085315 k. f = 5%res_srs2_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4155.505 4149.867 4155.494 1224.2922 977708.9 1222.6341
## 2 10 6128.526 6099.136 6128.461 1815.7103 977761.4 1812.0982
## 3 11 4548.667 4567.106 4548.695 1600.0986 977717.3 1597.3538
## 4 12 4804.449 4528.476 4804.031 1487.4124 979733.1 1485.0135
## 5 13 5086.741 5117.792 5086.790 1524.6507 977723.1 1522.0392
## 6 14 5836.227 5788.927 5836.160 1458.1814 977791.7 1455.9695
## 7 15 6342.391 6191.773 6342.127 1721.8853 978309.1 1718.7038
## 8 16 5019.580 4819.252 5019.351 1127.1902 978754.4 1125.8196
## 9 17 5152.149 5304.149 5152.364 1379.3323 978333.4 1377.3241
## 10 18 4845.710 4993.376 4845.910 1353.3733 978329.3 1351.4340
## 11 19 4663.310 4318.571 4662.884 1208.6168 980833.4 1207.0524
## 12 2 4601.551 4664.110 4601.647 1431.0036 977812.9 1428.8039
## 13 20 4411.531 4287.592 4411.326 1629.4724 978107.8 1626.6750
## 14 21 4818.920 4668.053 4818.727 1234.3109 978344.2 1232.7032
## 15 22 5388.275 5433.268 5388.349 1448.1358 977775.5 1445.8820
## 16 23 5172.611 5221.569 5172.689 1568.0728 977776.1 1565.4980
## 17 24 5263.964 5345.167 5264.061 1156.7279 977879.0 1155.2783
## 18 25 5388.272 5386.220 5388.266 1009.2022 977709.5 1008.1136
## 19 26 4692.828 4725.119 4692.871 1242.3198 977732.0 1240.6036
## 20 27 4660.157 4689.846 4660.188 917.9270 977721.1 917.0066
## 21 28 4589.071 4567.463 4589.043 1266.3162 977727.6 1264.6017
## 22 29 5157.659 5157.301 5157.660 1338.7125 977692.4 1336.8104
## 23 3 4617.211 4735.018 4617.397 1535.8079 978086.9 1533.3052
## 24 4 4944.305 4959.104 4944.332 1409.4637 977734.3 1407.3439
## 25 5 5144.463 5118.929 5144.431 1211.5903 977726.2 1210.0047
## 26 6 5793.746 5795.721 5793.744 1860.4970 977711.7 1856.7568
## 27 7 6569.000 6876.031 6569.523 1690.6968 980214.7 1687.7157
## 28 71 3621.683 3514.743 3621.583 914.1700 978013.1 913.2752
## 29 72 2969.911 3326.818 2970.265 981.7518 981062.0 980.7177
## 30 73 4735.638 4224.001 4734.857 1496.7220 984603.5 1494.1776
## 31 74 3648.815 3421.562 3648.635 775.1938 979061.6 774.5256
## 32 75 3099.349 3368.468 3099.615 992.2085 979613.9 991.1047
## 33 76 3133.663 3407.373 3133.944 1000.1136 979685.5 998.9736
## 34 77 3135.661 3324.361 3135.862 1055.0625 978664.4 1053.8599
## 35 78 6965.959 7081.106 6966.171 1809.0323 978048.1 1805.5808
## 36 79 3259.172 3374.699 3259.250 686.6908 978055.2 686.1406
## 37 8 4929.870 4805.909 4929.717 1206.8658 978111.7 1205.2101
## 38 9 6833.142 6771.707 6833.033 1716.6608 977820.6 1713.6298
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.2946233 235.6049 0.2942253
## 2 0.2960457 160.3131 0.2954610
## 3 0.3516507 214.0817 0.3510457
## 4 0.3097309 216.3517 0.3092598
## 5 0.2996153 191.0458 0.2990992
## 6 0.2499426 168.9068 0.2495661
## 7 0.2716198 158.0006 0.2711296
## 8 0.2244987 203.0995 0.2242365
## 9 0.2677334 184.4486 0.2673321
## 10 0.2791884 195.9306 0.2787769
## 11 0.2591180 227.1227 0.2588076
## 12 0.3111494 209.6510 0.3106636
## 13 0.3694217 228.1304 0.3688049
## 14 0.2559644 209.5844 0.2556420
## 15 0.2691426 179.9687 0.2687192
## 16 0.3031136 187.2641 0.3026114
## 17 0.2199298 182.9484 0.2196496
## 18 0.1871943 181.5198 0.1869928
## 19 0.2647769 206.9255 0.2644082
## 20 0.1971103 208.4788 0.1969111
## 21 0.2759466 214.0678 0.2755750
## 22 0.2596708 189.5772 0.2593017
## 23 0.3325828 206.5682 0.3320270
## 24 0.2852224 197.1605 0.2847915
## 25 0.2354014 191.0022 0.2350951
## 26 0.3209717 168.6983 0.3203273
## 27 0.2573290 142.5533 0.2568547
## 28 0.2524433 278.2660 0.2522035
## 29 0.3305272 294.9039 0.3301377
## 30 0.3158134 233.1078 0.3153359
## 31 0.2124970 286.1518 0.2123253
## 32 0.3198415 290.8258 0.3194565
## 33 0.3192322 287.5390 0.3188364
## 34 0.3360517 294.4059 0.3356469
## 35 0.2595924 138.1188 0.2590892
## 36 0.2102477 289.8284 0.2100742
## 37 0.2449271 203.5232 0.2445994
## 38 0.2512323 144.3981 0.2507928 2. Metode One stage cluster
a. f = 100%res_1sc2_1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com Relatif MSE dir
## 1 1 4220.403 4216.292 4220.403 0 974040.1 0 0
## 2 10 6158.917 6172.297 6158.917 0 974044.3 0 0
## 3 11 4634.496 4655.050 4634.496 0 974050.7 0 0
## 4 12 4919.014 4612.412 4919.014 0 976513.4 0 0
## 5 13 5127.194 5210.191 5127.194 0 974220.9 0 0
## 6 14 5928.762 5876.421 5928.762 0 974111.7 0 0
## 7 15 6342.583 6245.147 6342.583 0 974289.4 0 0
## 8 16 5103.006 4911.246 5103.006 0 975007.3 0 0
## 9 17 5268.416 5397.589 5268.416 0 974478.7 0 0
## 10 18 4970.796 5093.818 4970.796 0 974437.9 0 0
## 11 19 4751.743 4396.560 4751.743 0 977359.5 0 0
## 12 2 4700.143 4755.819 4700.143 0 974121.2 0 0
## 13 20 4525.222 4394.751 4525.222 0 974487.6 0 0
## 14 21 4848.178 4752.708 4848.178 0 974279.5 0 0
## 15 22 5460.264 5519.749 5460.264 0 974132.7 0 0
## 16 23 5271.905 5297.644 5271.905 0 974057.0 0 0
## 17 24 5362.188 5414.360 5362.188 0 974111.2 0 0
## 18 25 5427.660 5439.128 5427.660 0 974043.1 0 0
## 19 26 4734.623 4823.859 4734.623 0 974249.2 0 0
## 20 27 4777.379 4776.869 4777.379 0 974039.6 0 0
## 21 28 4702.797 4658.169 4702.797 0 974092.0 0 0
## 22 29 5239.878 5237.877 5239.878 0 974039.7 0 0
## 23 3 4708.626 4794.793 4708.626 0 974235.0 0 0
## 24 4 5056.916 5048.966 5056.916 0 974041.3 0 0
## 25 5 5198.709 5215.515 5198.709 0 974047.0 0 0
## 26 6 5926.092 5914.324 5926.092 0 974043.3 0 0
## 27 7 6685.010 6943.755 6685.010 0 975801.4 0 0
## 28 71 3701.777 3582.993 3701.777 0 974410.9 0 0
## 29 72 3067.757 3396.768 3067.757 0 976888.2 0 0
## 30 73 4787.325 4261.271 4787.325 0 981322.1 0 0
## 31 74 3646.103 3494.168 3646.103 0 974647.1 0 0
## 32 75 3205.130 3439.743 3205.130 0 975488.1 0 0
## 33 76 3125.115 3468.370 3125.115 0 977140.2 0 0
## 34 77 3215.490 3385.882 3215.490 0 974803.6 0 0
## 35 78 6979.747 7098.937 6979.747 0 974413.5 0 0
## 36 79 3361.141 3446.142 3361.141 0 974229.7 0 0
## 37 8 5024.538 4887.130 5024.538 0 974536.5 0 0
## 38 9 6903.494 6831.826 6903.494 0 974174.8 0 0
## Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 231.0182 0
## 2 157.8090 0
## 3 209.2460 0
## 4 211.7143 0
## 5 186.9837 0
## 6 165.7661 0
## 7 156.0074 0
## 8 198.5255 0
## 9 180.5396 0
## 10 191.2981 0
## 11 222.3010 0
## 12 204.8272 0
## 13 221.7390 0
## 14 204.9946 0
## 15 176.4813 0
## 16 183.8661 0
## 17 179.9125 0
## 18 179.0807 0
## 19 201.9647 0
## 20 203.9075 0
## 21 209.1148 0
## 22 185.9608 0
## 23 203.1860 0
## 24 192.9190 0
## 25 186.7595 0
## 26 164.6922 0
## 27 140.5294 0
## 28 271.9545 0
## 29 287.5935 0
## 30 230.2886 0
## 31 278.9354 0
## 32 283.5933 0
## 33 281.7290 0
## 34 287.9024 0
## 35 137.2619 0
## 36 282.7016 0
## 37 199.4088 0
## 38 142.5936 0 b. f = 90%res_1sc2_0.9## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4206.525 4194.166 4206.525 21.726908 971939.6 21.726421
## 2 10 6159.870 6151.517 6159.870 24.175115 971938.7 24.174512
## 3 11 4608.688 4631.976 4608.688 23.879443 971951.6 23.878855
## 4 12 4921.846 4597.506 4921.835 33.202694 974705.4 33.201560
## 5 13 5086.344 5168.464 5086.345 16.828938 972113.6 16.828645
## 6 14 5900.372 5855.750 5900.371 30.099863 971990.7 30.098929
## 7 15 6335.437 6230.148 6335.433 33.888654 972230.8 33.887465
## 8 16 5106.666 4884.256 5106.663 13.805887 973238.3 13.805691
## 9 17 5223.341 5370.754 5223.344 19.633399 972507.6 19.633002
## 10 18 4968.848 5073.381 4968.850 16.867199 972223.8 16.866906
## 11 19 4723.400 4367.521 4723.394 15.265387 975268.6 15.265147
## 12 2 4673.405 4729.769 4673.407 27.020005 972019.4 27.019252
## 13 20 4469.247 4373.273 4469.246 17.070454 972179.1 17.070153
## 14 21 4845.055 4728.768 4845.052 24.771012 972292.1 24.770378
## 15 22 5446.567 5489.662 5446.568 20.840315 971985.2 20.839867
## 16 23 5229.354 5289.504 5229.356 27.719486 972032.0 27.718693
## 17 24 5318.788 5378.887 5318.789 15.250383 972031.0 15.250143
## 18 25 5386.545 5411.089 5386.546 35.719830 971956.1 35.718515
## 19 26 4699.423 4794.968 4699.426 28.857094 972178.2 28.856232
## 20 27 4750.690 4760.447 4750.691 18.632334 971938.5 18.631975
## 21 28 4671.369 4624.372 4671.367 31.168528 971994.2 31.167528
## 22 29 5198.262 5196.627 5198.262 30.467751 971935.5 30.466794
## 23 3 4683.496 4768.562 4683.499 27.917177 972126.6 27.916375
## 24 4 5054.219 5023.387 5054.218 20.524476 971960.9 20.524042
## 25 5 5159.540 5191.793 5159.541 20.446740 971965.1 20.446309
## 26 6 5900.510 5890.562 5900.510 22.094160 971940.5 22.093656
## 27 7 6667.071 6919.537 6667.078 26.491119 973615.7 26.490397
## 28 71 3709.489 3557.167 3709.487 13.026759 972551.7 13.026584
## 29 72 3051.863 3370.607 3051.867 12.679725 974609.8 12.679558
## 30 73 4766.149 4221.039 4766.134 27.317589 979756.9 27.316825
## 31 74 3615.472 3469.336 3615.470 9.365371 972497.9 9.365281
## 32 75 3148.793 3414.405 3148.796 13.352270 973795.0 13.352085
## 33 76 3109.599 3449.210 3109.602 10.123176 974971.6 10.123070
## 34 77 3167.663 3347.225 3167.667 17.906456 972790.5 17.906125
## 35 78 6917.386 7047.857 6917.393 47.678149 972386.2 47.675799
## 36 79 3303.465 3421.078 3303.466 7.354578 972300.1 7.354522
## 37 8 5023.669 4865.701 5023.667 14.931933 972592.7 14.931703
## 38 9 6849.588 6797.748 6849.586 32.157643 972006.4 32.156578
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.005165230 231.7367 0.005165114
## 2 0.003924552 157.9998 0.003924454
## 3 0.005181284 209.8370 0.005181156
## 4 0.006745856 212.0086 0.006745641
## 5 0.003308449 188.0859 0.003308391
## 6 0.005101325 165.9893 0.005101168
## 7 0.005348858 156.0528 0.005348674
## 8 0.002703542 199.2609 0.002703505
## 9 0.003758753 181.0745 0.003758675
## 10 0.003394538 191.6324 0.003394478
## 11 0.003231866 223.3006 0.003231819
## 12 0.005781789 205.5111 0.005781626
## 13 0.003819513 222.3008 0.003819447
## 14 0.005112471 205.6122 0.005112343
## 15 0.003826278 177.0574 0.003826195
## 16 0.005300652 183.7675 0.005300499
## 17 0.002867195 180.7132 0.002867149
## 18 0.006631555 179.6236 0.006631310
## 19 0.006140330 202.7497 0.006140143
## 20 0.003921950 204.1699 0.003921875
## 21 0.006672210 210.1894 0.006671998
## 22 0.005861125 187.0321 0.005860941
## 23 0.005960684 203.8612 0.005960510
## 24 0.004060828 193.4871 0.004060743
## 25 0.003962855 187.2116 0.003962771
## 26 0.003744109 164.9993 0.003744023
## 27 0.003973594 140.7051 0.003973482
## 28 0.003511996 273.4079 0.003511950
## 29 0.004154259 289.1516 0.004154199
## 30 0.005732113 232.1129 0.005731971
## 31 0.002590359 280.3142 0.002590335
## 32 0.004239577 285.2041 0.004239514
## 33 0.003255310 282.6677 0.003255272
## 34 0.005652776 290.6270 0.005652666
## 35 0.006893939 137.9688 0.006893592
## 36 0.002226377 284.2106 0.002226359
## 37 0.002972285 199.8878 0.002972241
## 38 0.004694883 142.9890 0.004694729 c. f = 80%res_1sc2_0.8## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4194.636 4180.339 4194.635 49.63114 981847.6 49.62862
## 2 10 6149.933 6154.870 6149.934 56.13016 981840.7 56.12694
## 3 11 4575.031 4618.736 4575.033 54.62070 981892.8 54.61765
## 4 12 4914.377 4580.243 4914.351 75.56193 984780.3 75.55611
## 5 13 5116.838 5154.308 5116.840 41.50545 981878.9 41.50370
## 6 14 5876.094 5852.982 5876.093 66.02491 981856.8 66.02045
## 7 15 6342.387 6247.629 6342.380 79.04659 982096.5 79.04018
## 8 16 5105.644 4892.760 5105.638 31.59750 983035.6 31.59648
## 9 17 5254.754 5377.021 5254.759 45.09899 982233.0 45.09692
## 10 18 4968.525 5065.349 4968.529 38.27026 982088.3 38.26876
## 11 19 4691.175 4365.042 4691.165 32.83595 984640.2 32.83485
## 12 2 4641.211 4715.707 4641.216 59.29027 981987.4 59.28667
## 13 20 4484.435 4364.469 4484.430 40.16645 982218.6 40.16480
## 14 21 4842.141 4716.462 4842.134 55.99219 982257.1 55.98898
## 15 22 5426.804 5484.453 5426.807 46.37649 981929.4 46.37429
## 16 23 5256.515 5275.766 5256.516 63.73274 981851.7 63.72859
## 17 24 5347.768 5405.769 5347.770 34.84417 981930.0 34.84293
## 18 25 5425.100 5438.822 5425.101 82.62482 981852.9 82.61778
## 19 26 4668.030 4784.106 4668.038 63.62529 982199.6 63.62115
## 20 27 4718.577 4734.241 4718.577 41.96979 981847.4 41.96798
## 21 28 4639.078 4614.374 4639.076 69.82558 981859.1 69.82060
## 22 29 5223.098 5220.724 5223.097 66.74588 981839.3 66.74128
## 23 3 4647.812 4745.960 4647.818 62.19397 982093.7 62.18999
## 24 4 5060.643 5023.362 5060.641 45.64021 981877.6 45.63808
## 25 5 5189.021 5178.897 5189.020 43.56853 981844.2 43.56659
## 26 6 5861.979 5879.278 5861.980 47.22443 981848.6 47.22211
## 27 7 6651.803 6921.068 6651.819 59.45068 983752.4 59.44705
## 28 71 3693.608 3551.951 3693.604 27.81769 982372.8 27.81689
## 29 72 3035.554 3361.888 3035.564 29.84058 984644.7 29.83966
## 30 73 4725.591 4203.799 4725.560 58.07473 989006.0 58.07130
## 31 74 3580.915 3462.112 3580.912 21.78109 982211.0 21.78061
## 32 75 3164.801 3408.628 3164.809 30.95625 983405.4 30.95526
## 33 76 3094.480 3426.426 3094.487 22.67897 984739.5 22.67844
## 34 77 3173.744 3341.575 3173.750 36.66224 982584.9 36.66084
## 35 78 6935.530 7049.166 6935.542 105.82245 982180.8 105.81087
## 36 79 3312.538 3412.574 3312.540 16.54551 982103.7 16.54523
## 37 8 5021.820 4860.176 5021.815 33.27823 982528.3 33.27710
## 38 9 6854.508 6795.465 6854.504 66.64495 981931.7 66.64036
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.011832751 234.8764 0.011832152
## 2 0.009127339 159.5219 0.009126815
## 3 0.011938219 212.5905 0.011937547
## 4 0.015374182 215.0064 0.015373078
## 5 0.008111821 190.4960 0.008111475
## 6 0.011235556 167.7524 0.011234801
## 7 0.012463992 157.1945 0.012462997
## 8 0.006188823 200.9166 0.006188632
## 9 0.008582721 182.6715 0.008582316
## 10 0.007702673 193.8832 0.007702365
## 11 0.006999013 225.5749 0.006998794
## 12 0.012775471 208.2394 0.012774683
## 13 0.008957115 225.0491 0.008956758
## 14 0.011562548 208.2619 0.011561902
## 15 0.008545237 179.0386 0.008544827
## 16 0.012124684 186.1071 0.012123891
## 17 0.006515516 181.6454 0.006515281
## 18 0.015225509 180.5269 0.015224210
## 19 0.013629523 205.3054 0.013628614
## 20 0.008895068 207.3932 0.008894684
## 21 0.015051539 212.7821 0.015050470
## 22 0.012778421 188.0661 0.012777541
## 23 0.013381355 206.9321 0.013380482
## 24 0.009018155 195.4620 0.009017738
## 25 0.008396312 189.5851 0.008395939
## 26 0.008054653 167.0002 0.008054257
## 27 0.008938107 142.1382 0.008937539
## 28 0.007530317 276.5752 0.007530109
## 29 0.009828665 292.8874 0.009828329
## 30 0.012289404 235.2652 0.012288759
## 31 0.006082490 283.7054 0.006082358
## 32 0.009779773 288.5077 0.009779437
## 33 0.007329009 287.3994 0.007328822
## 34 0.011547650 294.0509 0.011547188
## 35 0.015260727 139.3317 0.015259029
## 36 0.004994989 287.7924 0.004994901
## 37 0.006626175 202.1598 0.006625956
## 38 0.009723073 144.4978 0.009722409 d. f = 70%res_1sc2_0.7## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4171.158 4184.927 4171.159 83.92571 963719.8 83.91836
## 2 10 6153.657 6154.541 6153.657 89.97023 963714.0 89.96180
## 3 11 4622.687 4625.612 4622.687 89.61128 963713.9 89.60289
## 4 12 4923.968 4596.174 4923.923 132.62876 966542.5 132.61043
## 5 13 5059.535 5167.644 5059.542 66.68653 964020.2 66.68182
## 6 14 5912.818 5843.053 5912.810 107.21383 963846.9 107.20177
## 7 15 6315.920 6203.155 6315.905 129.95917 964055.4 129.94140
## 8 16 5109.328 4879.994 5109.315 53.66014 965097.9 53.65712
## 9 17 5197.378 5373.495 5197.392 73.54824 964530.6 73.54248
## 10 18 4972.027 5071.626 4972.034 68.13531 963975.4 68.13045
## 11 19 4732.685 4366.943 4732.663 58.09497 967232.3 58.09140
## 12 2 4675.264 4723.726 4675.269 99.97510 963773.9 99.96470
## 13 20 4489.132 4379.031 4489.124 65.71128 964030.9 65.70674
## 14 21 4850.547 4728.584 4850.534 95.98041 964105.9 95.97070
## 15 22 5417.888 5468.030 5417.892 79.19746 963784.2 79.19091
## 16 23 5201.468 5257.078 5201.474 107.04312 963795.5 107.03112
## 17 24 5289.860 5351.957 5289.864 57.11437 963816.3 57.11098
## 18 25 5365.506 5388.166 5365.510 141.36506 963733.9 141.34416
## 19 26 4723.790 4796.801 4723.799 115.64053 963877.3 115.62653
## 20 27 4761.543 4756.328 4761.543 73.02089 963713.1 73.01531
## 21 28 4689.616 4637.407 4689.609 121.10383 963786.2 121.08853
## 22 29 5164.710 5163.874 5164.710 113.15671 963710.8 113.14317
## 23 3 4688.906 4759.999 4688.914 114.67834 963846.4 114.66455
## 24 4 5054.329 5024.346 5054.327 75.21577 963738.3 75.20985
## 25 5 5124.761 5197.939 5124.767 76.65806 963855.3 76.65194
## 26 6 5910.544 5900.196 5910.543 87.13649 963716.9 87.12849
## 27 7 6624.815 6902.656 6624.845 104.20311 965753.4 104.19176
## 28 71 3705.130 3562.778 3705.122 54.77175 964289.4 54.76860
## 29 72 3016.701 3378.300 3016.721 52.18896 967153.6 52.18607
## 30 73 4773.954 4217.236 4773.895 102.76134 971875.0 102.75034
## 31 74 3626.109 3478.065 3626.104 35.12378 964291.2 35.12248
## 32 75 3178.901 3421.827 3178.914 51.87096 965284.6 51.86807
## 33 76 3066.435 3441.741 3066.449 37.46303 967419.6 37.46155
## 34 77 3188.346 3358.601 3188.359 71.98049 964498.8 71.97501
## 35 78 6934.254 7059.304 6934.279 188.19092 964123.7 188.15380
## 36 79 3332.325 3428.969 3332.328 29.52628 963959.5 29.52536
## 37 8 5027.378 4866.263 5027.368 56.97162 964395.9 56.96824
## 38 9 6861.064 6798.070 6861.056 124.50165 963817.9 124.48531
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.020120954 230.2849 0.020119185
## 2 0.014621604 156.5858 0.014620235
## 3 0.019385770 208.3450 0.019383955
## 4 0.026935039 210.2934 0.026931564
## 5 0.013179159 186.5500 0.013178210
## 6 0.018135239 164.9562 0.018133222
## 7 0.020573904 155.4148 0.020571142
## 8 0.010503023 197.7684 0.010502459
## 9 0.014146890 179.4986 0.014145744
## 10 0.013704339 190.0723 0.013703342
## 11 0.012273504 221.4923 0.012272809
## 12 0.021383969 204.0295 0.021381723
## 13 0.014637142 220.1479 0.014636154
## 14 0.019787749 203.8898 0.019785796
## 15 0.014617285 176.2581 0.014616066
## 16 0.020580693 183.3328 0.020578359
## 17 0.010796457 180.0878 0.010795808
## 18 0.026353003 178.8625 0.026349091
## 19 0.024486466 200.9423 0.024483454
## 20 0.015334775 202.6168 0.015333604
## 21 0.025823435 207.8289 0.025820207
## 22 0.021903671 186.6267 0.021901050
## 23 0.024458143 202.4892 0.024455157
## 24 0.014880280 191.8146 0.014879116
## 25 0.014959237 185.4307 0.014958027
## 26 0.014743699 163.3363 0.014742349
## 27 0.015729775 139.9111 0.015727990
## 28 0.014781119 270.6624 0.014780302
## 29 0.017294370 286.2900 0.017293300
## 30 0.021530814 230.4585 0.021528777
## 31 0.009686355 277.2547 0.009686012
## 32 0.016308938 282.1026 0.016307961
## 33 0.012215425 281.0869 0.012214881
## 34 0.022586337 287.1829 0.022584525
## 35 0.027133777 136.5775 0.027128330
## 36 0.008864732 281.1276 0.008864446
## 37 0.011331300 198.1804 0.011330648
## 38 0.018146296 141.7793 0.018143937 e. f = 60%res_1sc2_0.6## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4141.323 4163.805 4141.326 126.03144 980481.4 126.01477
## 2 10 6149.981 6167.306 6149.983 142.45707 980479.7 142.43617
## 3 11 4563.809 4599.089 4563.814 136.97078 980501.8 136.95136
## 4 12 4921.563 4572.501 4921.493 198.27996 983675.0 198.23935
## 5 13 5093.768 5132.977 5093.772 95.75046 980514.0 95.74104
## 6 14 5859.539 5830.142 5859.533 175.25657 980504.8 175.22483
## 7 15 6335.901 6220.979 6335.876 206.62920 980833.1 206.58491
## 8 16 5091.358 4883.021 5091.340 87.63365 981611.0 87.62574
## 9 17 5232.782 5378.894 5232.798 107.70013 981030.0 107.68776
## 10 18 4972.163 5060.475 4972.172 101.99184 980673.6 101.98112
## 11 19 4683.502 4355.196 4683.470 96.96537 983305.9 96.95563
## 12 2 4645.305 4700.955 4645.313 151.97358 980556.3 151.94984
## 13 20 4498.010 4362.936 4497.996 101.28861 980945.9 101.27804
## 14 21 4847.808 4710.083 4847.786 154.40500 980976.2 154.38021
## 15 22 5376.161 5454.501 5376.171 126.31678 980630.8 126.30022
## 16 23 5235.177 5237.525 5235.178 177.51629 980468.7 177.48384
## 17 24 5325.071 5365.992 5325.075 88.32995 980510.9 88.32189
## 18 25 5380.280 5408.946 5380.286 209.81082 980499.7 209.76439
## 19 26 4670.990 4779.455 4671.010 180.62584 980803.1 180.59172
## 20 27 4713.447 4722.815 4713.448 108.46754 980473.7 108.45525
## 21 28 4644.562 4620.219 4644.557 187.16963 980487.2 187.13350
## 22 29 5196.448 5194.382 5196.448 183.54296 980464.3 183.50713
## 23 3 4650.311 4726.637 4650.325 170.90661 980619.8 170.87586
## 24 4 5056.530 5021.078 5056.526 117.87933 980500.7 117.86494
## 25 5 5158.446 5180.415 5158.448 116.93826 980487.3 116.92421
## 26 6 5867.783 5886.546 5867.786 117.04872 980479.0 117.03436
## 27 7 6596.535 6901.370 6596.586 163.00382 982938.1 162.97610
## 28 71 3708.578 3550.233 3708.565 82.71713 981158.4 82.71001
## 29 72 2985.240 3361.512 2985.271 79.77457 984202.4 79.76769
## 30 73 4707.242 4186.849 4707.147 180.63798 987606.6 180.60450
## 31 74 3582.792 3464.173 3582.785 57.51530 980839.3 57.51182
## 32 75 3188.474 3408.399 3188.492 84.88185 981742.1 84.87437
## 33 76 3039.401 3408.242 3039.421 53.49101 984046.7 53.48806
## 34 77 3180.155 3341.755 3180.172 104.26661 981176.7 104.25516
## 35 78 6958.070 7063.654 6958.102 295.01548 980762.6 294.92507
## 36 79 3334.960 3413.267 3334.963 41.26992 980628.9 41.26813
## 37 8 5025.481 4858.534 5025.466 89.53498 981203.6 89.52674
## 38 9 6885.973 6810.059 6885.958 190.87129 980621.5 190.83350
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.03043640 235.4811 0.03043235
## 2 0.02315974 158.9832 0.02315633
## 3 0.03000676 213.1959 0.03000247
## 4 0.04028491 215.1325 0.04027725
## 5 0.01879602 191.0235 0.01879415
## 6 0.02990726 168.1783 0.02990187
## 7 0.03260835 157.6642 0.03260149
## 8 0.01721222 201.0251 0.01721073
## 9 0.02057888 182.3856 0.02057645
## 10 0.02051235 193.7930 0.02051015
## 11 0.02070037 225.7775 0.02069844
## 12 0.03271188 208.5873 0.03270672
## 13 0.02251756 224.8406 0.02251528
## 14 0.03186558 208.2720 0.03186060
## 15 0.02349743 179.7846 0.02349431
## 16 0.03390681 187.2020 0.03390061
## 17 0.01658409 182.7264 0.01658256
## 18 0.03899369 181.2758 0.03898501
## 19 0.03867255 205.2138 0.03866507
## 20 0.02300588 207.6067 0.02300327
## 21 0.04029694 212.2214 0.04028920
## 22 0.03530511 188.7577 0.03529823
## 23 0.03675064 207.4689 0.03674392
## 24 0.02331333 195.2773 0.02331050
## 25 0.02266379 189.2688 0.02266106
## 26 0.01994995 166.5644 0.01994750
## 27 0.02472968 142.4246 0.02472527
## 28 0.02229965 276.3687 0.02229781
## 29 0.02670769 292.7928 0.02670510
## 30 0.03839309 235.8835 0.03838675
## 31 0.01605015 283.1458 0.01604921
## 32 0.02661106 288.0428 0.02660856
## 33 0.01759710 288.7330 0.01759602
## 34 0.03276969 293.6166 0.03276591
## 35 0.04238980 138.8450 0.04237662
## 36 0.01237540 287.3069 0.01237485
## 37 0.01781795 201.9576 0.01781636
## 38 0.02771564 143.9969 0.02771022 f. f = 50%res_1sc2_0.5## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4227.266 4216.647 4227.264 199.75663 985258.5 199.71482
## 2 10 6169.227 6181.228 6169.229 209.06967 985268.5 209.02432
## 3 11 4635.449 4655.926 4635.453 212.24300 985280.2 212.19681
## 4 12 4919.087 4613.427 4918.989 317.20012 987715.2 317.09617
## 5 13 5137.188 5214.829 5137.200 159.14268 985419.5 159.11639
## 6 14 5922.870 5883.538 5922.860 260.78747 985326.7 260.71747
## 7 15 6349.936 6260.931 6349.907 317.95083 985513.2 317.84569
## 8 16 5096.876 4910.203 5096.853 121.11095 986186.3 121.09573
## 9 17 5273.778 5400.312 5273.803 187.99449 985691.9 187.95786
## 10 18 4971.586 5089.641 4971.602 136.37116 985631.4 136.35181
## 11 19 4742.009 4400.329 4741.961 138.60002 988330.3 138.58005
## 12 2 4701.557 4753.622 4701.569 236.34493 985332.6 236.28688
## 13 20 4524.956 4388.843 4524.934 159.39206 985751.4 159.36547
## 14 21 4861.110 4755.768 4861.084 246.58254 985560.9 246.52026
## 15 22 5455.121 5511.465 5455.132 198.61519 985341.7 198.57477
## 16 23 5273.302 5291.638 5273.307 245.86132 985281.2 245.79940
## 17 24 5365.766 5413.565 5365.773 145.29387 985321.1 145.27202
## 18 25 5433.488 5447.447 5433.492 332.61561 985300.6 332.50023
## 19 26 4701.490 4820.833 4701.525 300.63463 985680.2 300.53978
## 20 27 4771.273 4776.393 4771.274 153.08833 985258.5 153.06405
## 21 28 4705.205 4659.644 4705.193 271.24707 985314.1 271.17165
## 22 29 5229.199 5226.325 5229.198 255.63943 985252.8 255.57038
## 23 3 4712.801 4803.109 4712.826 271.25478 985471.5 271.17790
## 24 4 5062.732 5051.751 5062.730 179.40125 985268.3 179.36778
## 25 5 5205.443 5220.697 5205.446 188.76163 985275.8 188.72488
## 26 6 5932.585 5915.458 5932.582 195.87625 985282.7 195.83616
## 27 7 6716.995 6965.288 6717.058 252.12207 986892.8 252.05615
## 28 71 3716.546 3584.967 3716.531 116.98177 985750.8 116.96757
## 29 72 3056.568 3397.008 3056.602 99.67946 988314.2 99.66904
## 30 73 4796.122 4275.443 4796.004 225.05070 992413.6 224.99892
## 31 74 3646.460 3494.331 3646.447 87.75771 985862.9 87.74964
## 32 75 3216.676 3440.125 3216.702 119.37214 986606.6 119.35723
## 33 76 3124.436 3466.261 3124.467 90.38339 988333.4 90.37493
## 34 77 3226.424 3390.424 3226.452 169.58486 985979.1 169.55490
## 35 78 7033.381 7149.900 7033.433 445.04356 985630.0 444.83786
## 36 79 3353.922 3446.002 3353.929 71.89829 985481.9 71.89286
## 37 8 5026.561 4889.587 5026.541 140.95967 985756.5 140.93933
## 38 9 6913.530 6846.019 6913.508 315.19081 985373.6 315.08735
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.04727772 233.6652 0.04726784
## 2 0.03388629 159.3964 0.03387892
## 3 0.04578198 211.6205 0.04577197
## 4 0.06446537 214.0974 0.06444557
## 5 0.03097161 188.9616 0.03096641
## 6 0.04402155 167.4684 0.04400982
## 7 0.05007169 157.4034 0.05005536
## 8 0.02377208 200.8460 0.02376920
## 9 0.03564600 182.5246 0.03563889
## 10 0.02743350 193.6575 0.02742951
## 11 0.02922443 224.6029 0.02922052
## 12 0.05027504 207.2828 0.05026255
## 13 0.03522175 224.6098 0.03521605
## 14 0.05073205 207.2342 0.05071950
## 15 0.03640784 178.7833 0.03640035
## 16 0.04662754 186.2000 0.04661575
## 17 0.02707612 182.0098 0.02707201
## 18 0.06116059 180.8728 0.06113936
## 19 0.06389376 204.4655 0.06387314
## 20 0.03208108 206.2773 0.03207599
## 21 0.05763417 211.4576 0.05761831
## 22 0.04887472 188.5186 0.04886153
## 23 0.05754657 205.1699 0.05752995
## 24 0.03543478 195.0344 0.03542818
## 25 0.03627280 188.7230 0.03626570
## 26 0.03303362 166.5612 0.03302687
## 27 0.03753945 141.6830 0.03752927
## 28 0.03151552 274.9731 0.03151181
## 29 0.03262380 290.9445 0.03262001
## 30 0.04690581 232.1175 0.04689620
## 31 0.02406541 282.1399 0.02406329
## 32 0.03709437 286.8015 0.03708942
## 33 0.02892682 285.1399 0.02892382
## 34 0.05259625 290.8181 0.05258647
## 35 0.06324681 137.8481 0.06321710
## 36 0.02143794 285.9866 0.02143628
## 37 0.02803631 201.6045 0.02803238
## 38 0.04557789 143.9340 0.04556308 g. f = 40%res_1sc2_0.4## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4198.123 4168.369 4198.115 287.7380 979204.7 287.6493
## 2 10 6164.900 6126.829 6164.888 332.7553 979233.2 332.6382
## 3 11 4575.449 4605.118 4575.459 319.7883 979203.1 319.6794
## 4 12 4922.341 4580.109 4922.188 439.0035 982257.5 438.8033
## 5 13 5045.413 5109.373 5045.426 211.4620 979293.9 211.4130
## 6 14 5869.276 5841.594 5869.263 412.3636 979307.5 412.1872
## 7 15 6379.258 6232.992 6379.189 459.0769 979786.2 458.8506
## 8 16 5111.942 4857.543 5111.893 188.4588 980879.7 188.4206
## 9 17 5178.431 5344.071 5178.473 250.8477 979904.3 250.7808
## 10 18 4967.828 5052.798 4967.846 202.9273 979367.3 202.8841
## 11 19 4680.222 4333.577 4680.157 182.1809 982349.0 182.1464
## 12 2 4642.580 4703.675 4642.603 379.8491 979279.4 379.7003
## 13 20 4403.046 4350.794 4403.032 268.6676 979247.4 268.5923
## 14 21 4849.759 4702.992 4849.706 350.9126 979773.8 350.7820
## 15 22 5432.050 5451.988 5432.055 280.5407 979200.0 280.4568
## 16 23 5175.760 5290.426 5175.798 331.5826 979533.3 331.4650
## 17 24 5276.971 5341.637 5276.985 214.1468 979288.0 214.0990
## 18 25 5327.866 5386.396 5327.896 516.1736 979284.6 515.8877
## 19 26 4673.778 4760.482 4673.812 348.5720 979507.1 348.4341
## 20 27 4720.161 4741.341 4720.166 227.8930 979187.9 227.8358
## 21 28 4631.218 4574.499 4631.194 417.2689 979276.1 417.0875
## 22 29 5146.168 5144.304 5146.168 414.6836 979169.9 414.5007
## 23 3 4632.709 4731.163 4632.749 402.4670 979431.3 402.2970
## 24 4 5051.785 4998.596 5051.770 276.8586 979249.2 276.7780
## 25 5 5108.892 5168.300 5108.909 279.8889 979282.9 279.8074
## 26 6 5871.409 5867.217 5871.409 288.9299 979179.6 288.8410
## 27 7 6651.476 6906.344 6651.565 344.3958 980902.8 344.2714
## 28 71 3683.259 3519.800 3683.228 183.2884 979931.5 183.2515
## 29 72 3046.242 3329.880 3046.298 195.3801 981297.1 195.3390
## 30 73 4731.690 4154.125 4731.500 319.5824 987983.0 319.4613
## 31 74 3581.769 3431.844 3581.750 124.6799 979766.4 124.6635
## 32 75 3083.905 3376.854 3083.961 190.2817 981435.8 190.2414
## 33 76 3086.779 3416.343 3086.818 117.9646 982033.1 117.9492
## 34 77 3064.375 3284.387 3064.422 213.4081 980479.5 213.3595
## 35 78 6839.429 6981.226 6839.517 604.2259 979721.7 603.8439
## 36 79 3228.551 3382.435 3228.567 104.9658 979801.4 104.9541
## 37 8 5037.296 4842.906 5037.254 206.1569 980179.9 206.1116
## 38 9 6769.970 6749.752 6769.962 389.4251 979189.2 389.2600
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.06858545 234.9153 0.06856442
## 2 0.05402522 159.8273 0.05400629
## 3 0.06990954 212.6361 0.06988556
## 4 0.08918283 214.4622 0.08914500
## 5 0.04188887 191.6673 0.04187907
## 6 0.07020605 167.6425 0.07017622
## 7 0.07199033 157.1920 0.07195566
## 8 0.03686775 201.9312 0.03686065
## 9 0.04842983 183.3629 0.04841652
## 10 0.04085543 193.8272 0.04084657
## 11 0.03892860 226.6850 0.03892177
## 12 0.08181880 208.1970 0.08178632
## 13 0.06100025 225.0758 0.06098335
## 14 0.07235505 208.3298 0.07232896
## 15 0.05161107 179.6049 0.05159560
## 16 0.06408025 185.1516 0.06405702
## 17 0.04057604 183.3321 0.04056687
## 18 0.09683206 181.8079 0.09677790
## 19 0.07472522 205.7591 0.07469494
## 20 0.04826913 206.5198 0.04825696
## 21 0.09012122 214.0765 0.09008248
## 22 0.08060138 190.3411 0.08056583
## 23 0.08688251 207.0170 0.08684501
## 24 0.05480689 195.9046 0.05479110
## 25 0.05477902 189.4775 0.05476289
## 26 0.04921804 166.8902 0.04920290
## 27 0.05176930 142.0269 0.05174989
## 28 0.04976345 278.4142 0.04975387
## 29 0.06413315 294.7064 0.06411844
## 30 0.06745224 237.8433 0.06742996
## 31 0.03480247 285.5034 0.03479807
## 32 0.06163749 290.6474 0.06162323
## 33 0.03820637 287.4595 0.03820085
## 34 0.06952905 298.5478 0.06951215
## 35 0.08839803 140.3390 0.08834093
## 36 0.03249853 289.6844 0.03249477
## 37 0.04090897 202.3943 0.04090035
## 38 0.05749275 145.0703 0.05746846 h. f = 30%res_1sc2_0.3## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4136.414 4106.935 4136.403 437.3430 1006336 437.1362
## 2 10 6187.042 6159.751 6187.027 539.0915 1006342 538.7957
## 3 11 4480.443 4573.521 4480.491 525.3830 1006534 525.0939
## 4 12 4926.953 4545.458 4926.680 723.8743 1010157 723.3340
## 5 13 5093.677 5057.932 5093.665 309.9493 1006356 309.8494
## 6 14 5809.397 5827.003 5809.404 591.8908 1006363 591.5303
## 7 15 6348.017 6260.703 6347.955 663.4003 1006594 662.9224
## 8 16 5098.266 4857.217 5098.190 321.1533 1007856 321.0482
## 9 17 5221.489 5338.922 5221.539 415.4835 1006678 415.2980
## 10 18 4967.216 5016.340 4967.233 358.3671 1006375 358.2321
## 11 19 4584.810 4298.116 4584.724 295.8967 1008490 295.8009
## 12 2 4529.589 4625.573 4529.642 562.5151 1006547 562.1797
## 13 20 4386.985 4308.292 4386.958 325.9701 1006471 325.8614
## 14 21 4823.697 4645.480 4823.602 545.5654 1007176 545.2514
## 15 22 5370.808 5413.599 5370.826 442.6293 1006361 442.4177
## 16 23 5221.288 5247.717 5221.303 560.5080 1006364 560.1896
## 17 24 5313.050 5386.744 5313.071 296.0293 1006450 295.9343
## 18 25 5417.580 5441.869 5417.595 663.5997 1006346 663.1262
## 19 26 4555.923 4704.669 4556.004 571.6390 1006923 571.2952
## 20 27 4609.619 4667.038 4609.638 329.8761 1006399 329.7551
## 21 28 4512.766 4536.583 4512.780 677.7051 1006318 677.2216
## 22 29 5207.138 5203.652 5207.137 529.9483 1006297 529.6404
## 23 3 4540.777 4656.003 4540.834 497.3120 1006675 497.0436
## 24 4 5066.098 4971.899 5066.061 407.0594 1006536 406.8847
## 25 5 5153.684 5113.197 5153.667 392.4885 1006400 392.3315
## 26 6 5767.671 5822.024 5767.693 471.0117 1006430 470.7653
## 27 7 6631.513 6897.268 6631.672 607.8239 1008177 607.4350
## 28 71 3682.586 3494.364 3682.540 241.1880 1007361 241.1239
## 29 72 2979.718 3298.343 2979.792 239.2289 1008990 239.1631
## 30 73 4620.666 4089.037 4620.348 607.0259 1013750 606.6505
## 31 74 3478.694 3405.840 3478.681 176.6460 1006443 176.6118
## 32 75 3092.657 3352.339 3092.733 301.5280 1008123 301.4218
## 33 76 3036.622 3354.755 3036.691 218.7544 1008974 218.7045
## 34 77 3079.897 3249.519 3079.949 306.7425 1007089 306.6285
## 35 78 6828.841 6946.949 6828.967 1064.6151 1006702 1063.4456
## 36 79 3230.311 3352.869 3230.327 130.3703 1006704 130.3520
## 37 8 5031.141 4820.608 5031.072 323.2368 1007490 323.1252
## 38 9 6779.809 6754.727 6779.788 778.7160 1006325 778.0333
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.10583595 245.0384 0.10578610
## 2 0.08711612 163.3736 0.08706856
## 3 0.11717363 220.1036 0.11710791
## 4 0.14691628 222.2432 0.14681505
## 5 0.06083567 198.9783 0.06081622
## 6 0.10180342 172.7014 0.10174139
## 7 0.10433803 160.7722 0.10426411
## 8 0.06300536 207.5017 0.06298570
## 9 0.07956960 188.5501 0.07953324
## 10 0.07213222 200.6208 0.07210481
## 11 0.06444518 234.6396 0.06442568
## 12 0.12416047 217.6070 0.12408492
## 13 0.07427616 233.6203 0.07425186
## 14 0.11316175 216.8063 0.11309898
## 15 0.08236122 185.9041 0.08232158
## 16 0.10736315 191.7764 0.10730184
## 17 0.05567862 186.8454 0.05566052
## 18 0.12235841 184.9216 0.12227082
## 19 0.12538125 214.0318 0.12530361
## 20 0.07156916 215.6417 0.07154255
## 21 0.14998877 221.8296 0.14988140
## 22 0.10176269 193.3908 0.10170361
## 23 0.10943550 216.2017 0.10937497
## 24 0.08035362 202.4410 0.08031975
## 25 0.07611685 196.8184 0.07608669
## 26 0.08146805 172.8612 0.08142526
## 27 0.09161555 146.1645 0.09155464
## 28 0.06539200 288.3043 0.06537557
## 29 0.08006834 305.9420 0.08004415
## 30 0.13143180 247.9327 0.13135982
## 31 0.05079379 295.5336 0.05078414
## 32 0.09722385 300.7532 0.09718699
## 33 0.07198687 300.8017 0.07196872
## 34 0.09967812 309.9572 0.09963885
## 35 0.15591021 144.9055 0.15573588
## 36 0.04037006 300.2829 0.04036422
## 37 0.06417244 208.9974 0.06415128
## 38 0.11469639 148.9838 0.11459638 i. f = 20%res_1sc2_0.2## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 4029.165 4103.533 4029.226 678.3063 958873.8 677.7664
## 2 10 6146.630 6105.264 6146.598 796.5270 958735.4 795.7981
## 3 11 4581.064 4546.391 4581.034 775.9969 958737.1 775.3010
## 4 12 4926.605 4548.218 4926.149 1153.6403 962473.6 1152.1769
## 5 13 4882.154 5035.538 4882.264 692.9383 959323.4 692.3801
## 6 14 5834.753 5755.881 5834.659 1093.3263 958971.6 1092.0539
## 7 15 6322.308 6124.856 6322.067 1173.7348 959823.7 1172.1964
## 8 16 5110.866 4797.544 5110.721 455.2503 961320.0 455.0229
## 9 17 5012.800 5310.219 5013.001 651.5559 961029.3 651.0779
## 10 18 4942.796 5003.625 4942.837 568.4461 958838.0 568.0758
## 11 19 4691.506 4293.419 4691.291 519.8747 962870.6 519.5707
## 12 2 4629.523 4641.721 4629.536 964.9470 958692.8 963.9337
## 13 20 4413.027 4326.345 4412.974 617.2260 958880.2 616.7556
## 14 21 4886.826 4672.045 4886.588 1091.8449 959920.5 1090.5245
## 15 22 5248.543 5301.658 5248.575 595.6822 958809.7 595.2946
## 16 23 4990.389 5143.333 4990.525 851.6133 959363.8 850.8227
## 17 24 5116.168 5164.524 5116.193 566.5820 958764.6 566.2044
## 18 25 5156.954 5249.536 5157.078 1399.4100 959044.5 1397.0813
## 19 26 4667.878 4720.582 4667.935 1156.6744 958914.3 1155.1293
## 20 27 4706.372 4697.090 4706.365 649.9278 958695.3 649.4574
## 21 28 4636.209 4563.689 4636.126 1162.9898 958854.7 1161.5280
## 22 29 4991.913 4995.646 4991.917 1024.4967 958673.5 1023.1582
## 23 3 4660.347 4665.494 4660.342 1038.0951 958714.8 1036.7605
## 24 4 5066.367 4966.006 5066.289 769.0843 958952.1 768.4188
## 25 5 4924.669 5160.947 4924.857 745.4742 960208.9 744.8741
## 26 6 5875.210 5856.681 5875.198 664.5896 958714.1 664.1029
## 27 7 6509.883 6836.468 6510.193 930.6504 961631.0 929.6914
## 28 71 3678.933 3506.628 3678.856 411.0062 959628.2 410.8060
## 29 72 2889.678 3321.009 2889.808 290.1600 963577.3 290.0702
## 30 73 4741.128 4102.661 4740.541 895.9452 969430.0 895.0237
## 31 74 3586.635 3427.922 3586.580 327.4388 959345.0 327.3194
## 32 75 3092.037 3368.024 3092.149 416.8449 960815.7 416.6170
## 33 76 2924.134 3360.176 2924.284 328.9865 963691.4 328.8646
## 34 77 3099.398 3276.465 3099.493 524.7781 959646.5 524.4514
## 35 78 6867.691 7026.390 6868.023 1909.9021 959374.2 1905.4625
## 36 79 3234.267 3375.146 3234.302 251.0223 959218.3 250.9396
## 37 8 5034.327 4811.507 5034.193 576.3769 960011.4 575.9952
## 38 9 6780.472 6727.444 6780.427 807.5713 958758.6 806.8321
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.16842604 233.6823 0.16828865
## 2 0.12973336 157.0241 0.12961514
## 3 0.16934200 210.8808 0.16919147
## 4 0.23418497 211.6134 0.23391079
## 5 0.14193201 190.5274 0.14181410
## 6 0.18731513 166.6033 0.18710037
## 7 0.18569784 156.7019 0.18546189
## 8 0.08922622 200.3775 0.08918423
## 9 0.12996368 180.9712 0.12986267
## 10 0.11515387 191.6232 0.11507762
## 11 0.11078708 224.2734 0.11072784
## 12 0.20858828 206.5402 0.20836844
## 13 0.13978135 221.6408 0.13967677
## 14 0.22363641 205.4575 0.22337702
## 15 0.11354260 180.8437 0.11346796
## 16 0.17077864 186.5173 0.17061516
## 17 0.11057378 185.6387 0.11049962
## 18 0.27069405 182.6974 0.27023677
## 19 0.24745647 203.1311 0.24712278
## 20 0.13805926 204.0986 0.13795960
## 21 0.25094073 210.1167 0.25062961
## 22 0.20489588 191.9384 0.20462826
## 23 0.22288202 205.5152 0.22259609
## 24 0.15181697 193.0991 0.15168802
## 25 0.15165060 186.0495 0.15152204
## 26 0.11325474 163.6963 0.11317194
## 27 0.14276244 140.6531 0.14260843
## 28 0.11146763 273.6863 0.11141617
## 29 0.10045822 290.1812 0.10042247
## 30 0.18891934 236.3348 0.18875099
## 31 0.09126189 279.8887 0.09123014
## 32 0.13433498 285.3063 0.13425561
## 33 0.11251571 286.8388 0.11246773
## 34 0.16888567 292.9564 0.16877503
## 35 0.27882444 136.5430 0.27815836
## 36 0.07738338 284.2305 0.07735698
## 37 0.11449635 199.5164 0.11442390
## 38 0.11897120 142.5068 0.11886324 j. f = 10%res_1sc2_0.1## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 3711.736 3857.826 3711.991 1754.4522 1015598 1750.3209
## 2 10 6102.929 6125.044 6103.007 1763.9485 1015197 1760.3360
## 3 11 4318.126 4376.797 4318.238 2167.2675 1015174 2162.1029
## 4 12 4899.411 4397.216 4898.026 2864.7804 1021812 2855.3923
## 5 13 4910.571 4781.575 4910.378 1578.5142 1015473 1575.6454
## 6 14 5562.869 5636.066 5563.059 2592.8763 1015214 2585.8091
## 7 15 6422.295 6134.634 6421.545 2521.8136 1017359 2514.9411
## 8 16 5135.359 4792.639 5134.991 1102.6865 1018223 1101.3769
## 9 17 5034.994 5295.929 5035.331 1312.7050 1016859 1310.9253
## 10 18 4983.325 4905.099 4983.231 1284.5519 1015249 1282.5845
## 11 19 4369.919 4167.298 4369.715 1009.7047 1016201 1008.5120
## 12 2 4320.900 4396.995 4321.055 2250.8216 1015269 2244.7217
## 13 20 4406.972 4214.915 4406.783 1025.3390 1015990 1024.0230
## 14 21 4826.594 4491.236 4825.866 2099.7334 1018122 2094.1731
## 15 22 4975.251 5126.268 4975.488 1643.1456 1015681 1640.1306
## 16 23 4988.915 4958.596 4988.828 2357.8353 1015062 2351.1385
## 17 24 5088.833 5167.987 5088.925 1144.7879 1015285 1143.3384
## 18 25 5192.878 5273.267 5193.119 2698.3677 1015325 2687.9859
## 19 26 4368.095 4551.295 4368.486 2050.3554 1016350 2043.3998
## 20 27 4406.580 4442.983 4406.623 1183.7103 1015069 1182.0485
## 21 28 4335.090 4415.035 4335.270 2356.8322 1015220 2350.7030
## 22 29 4989.179 4998.751 4989.203 2609.6084 1015003 2601.5334
## 23 3 4349.652 4355.754 4349.653 1817.2991 1015045 1813.3419
## 24 4 5050.426 4882.833 5050.200 1416.8842 1015803 1414.2322
## 25 5 4958.906 5000.230 4958.997 2314.0050 1015230 2308.6114
## 26 6 5589.856 5754.855 5590.152 2252.9635 1015852 2245.6909
## 27 7 6231.907 6732.513 6232.881 2101.3772 1021797 2095.9639
## 28 71 3678.482 3409.761 3678.299 664.4859 1016998 663.6783
## 29 72 2563.412 3206.119 2563.889 783.2893 1025911 782.1018
## 30 73 4426.949 3835.964 4425.611 2429.3560 1024444 2421.5372
## 31 74 3248.388 3332.170 3248.472 969.4255 1015212 968.2310
## 32 75 3071.293 3274.972 3071.412 730.5538 1016221 729.5147
## 33 76 2605.360 3140.912 2605.707 654.0909 1022617 653.4960
## 34 77 3158.922 3136.955 3158.887 1536.3410 1015232 1533.1030
## 35 78 6733.923 6869.734 6734.311 2671.5679 1015677 2663.3661
## 36 79 3232.974 3268.423 3232.980 586.4658 1015150 585.9514
## 37 8 5037.215 4697.938 5036.705 1473.7821 1018072 1471.1886
## 38 9 6794.008 6675.914 6793.812 1865.7427 1015412 1861.9380
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 0.4723685 263.3194 0.4712138
## 2 0.2908907 165.7317 0.2902849
## 3 0.5012962 232.0059 0.5000920
## 4 0.5856919 232.3762 0.5839651
## 5 0.3218174 212.4069 0.3212473
## 6 0.4659342 180.1159 0.4646469
## 7 0.3918585 165.8179 0.3908434
## 8 0.2147727 212.4654 0.2145340
## 9 0.2606316 191.9853 0.2602599
## 10 0.2579541 206.9569 0.2575649
## 11 0.2311055 243.8824 0.2308453
## 12 0.5207001 230.9399 0.5192657
## 13 0.2325556 241.0400 0.2322700
## 14 0.4332813 226.6876 0.4322235
## 15 0.3306078 198.1673 0.3299833
## 16 0.4721997 204.7433 0.4708700
## 17 0.2249005 196.5433 0.2246108
## 18 0.5195551 192.5803 0.5175163
## 19 0.4699366 223.3226 0.4682416
## 20 0.2686388 228.4561 0.2682583
## 21 0.5433724 229.9383 0.5419352
## 22 0.5234952 203.1018 0.5218723
## 23 0.4170758 233.0178 0.4161696
## 24 0.2805512 208.0244 0.2800428
## 25 0.4666069 203.0142 0.4655101
## 26 0.4010358 176.4853 0.3997196
## 27 0.3358445 151.7588 0.3349202
## 28 0.1799864 298.3063 0.1797862
## 29 0.3056182 320.0359 0.3050403
## 30 0.5528750 267.1226 0.5513081
## 31 0.2989854 304.7077 0.2986050
## 32 0.2342222 310.3571 0.2338729
## 33 0.2515189 325.6424 0.2512414
## 34 0.4847578 323.7695 0.4837458
## 35 0.3993720 147.8538 0.3981096
## 36 0.1803996 310.6337 0.1802420
## 37 0.2921449 216.7119 0.2916682
## 38 0.2744741 152.0881 0.2739228 k. f = 5%res_1sc2_0.05## kab Y dir Y syn Y com MSE dir MSE syn MSE com
## 1 1 3708.075 3592.546 3707.513 4688.6714 1175546 4651.1739
## 2 10 6217.901 6007.666 6216.946 5717.3552 1176523 5683.3906
## 3 11 3644.828 4096.541 3646.228 3565.2088 1180592 3549.9785
## 4 12 4970.499 4148.380 4966.115 6131.4334 1193117 6078.4907
## 5 13 4925.917 4230.966 4924.455 2548.7495 1188006 2541.1332
## 6 14 4936.231 5476.891 4938.433 5080.7982 1183134 5043.2165
## 7 15 6354.069 6253.315 6353.487 7162.8027 1175867 7102.7482
## 8 16 5125.253 4607.604 5124.203 2359.4696 1182290 2352.9260
## 9 17 5019.665 5066.738 5019.725 4851.3202 1175391 4811.8883
## 10 18 5008.964 4664.361 5008.539 1643.3964 1178367 1639.5068
## 11 19 3749.149 3834.852 3749.265 1972.4433 1175674 1963.6723
## 12 2 3735.642 4067.267 3736.532 3367.7135 1178183 3353.5470
## 13 20 3773.197 3908.090 3773.466 2741.7041 1175730 2727.9896
## 14 21 4873.396 4155.384 4870.928 4259.7391 1189097 4241.5952
## 15 22 4913.784 4919.082 4913.772 4227.3408 1175414 4206.7140
## 16 23 5053.319 4983.813 5052.895 5754.2174 1175651 5712.9008
## 17 24 5107.367 5161.351 5107.497 2859.1920 1175702 2846.9404
## 18 25 5127.989 5318.378 5129.044 5543.5701 1176636 5497.1637
## 19 26 3673.477 4181.730 3674.798 3253.6874 1182786 3239.0995
## 20 27 3774.534 4119.528 3775.176 2088.3981 1178439 2081.3594
## 21 28 3720.246 3930.444 3720.773 2951.7179 1176508 2937.5761
## 22 29 5008.927 4992.595 5008.901 1648.0955 1175157 1644.5819
## 23 3 3719.601 3932.625 3720.101 3178.0541 1176523 3166.7315
## 24 4 5032.763 4622.017 5031.972 2193.0471 1179746 2187.3348
## 25 5 4985.836 4632.382 4984.432 4754.8265 1178680 4728.5274
## 26 6 4918.054 5383.459 4919.108 2942.1260 1180974 2925.8367
## 27 7 6238.950 6598.083 6240.072 3899.2426 1178752 3877.1397
## 28 71 3749.669 3061.628 3748.967 1691.7801 1188427 1684.6283
## 29 72 2570.412 2817.652 2570.627 895.2579 1176812 893.7137
## 30 73 3651.812 3245.710 3650.851 2834.8445 1179919 2816.2175
## 31 74 2611.873 2971.053 2612.268 1262.6679 1178555 1259.6983
## 32 75 2457.513 2921.313 2457.901 1186.4266 1181048 1182.3912
## 33 76 2605.754 2794.466 2605.899 908.0377 1176143 906.5047
## 34 77 2381.076 2596.606 2381.484 4331.1467 1176880 4290.4086
## 35 78 6181.766 6206.827 6182.448 11846.2895 1175534 11683.4665
## 36 79 2550.780 2896.834 2550.915 479.2383 1178469 478.7837
## 37 8 5020.613 4475.650 5019.602 2019.6634 1183124 2013.5283
## 38 9 6177.889 6402.963 6178.828 5030.8533 1176839 5003.5144
## Relatif MSE dir Relatif MSE syn Relatif MSE com
## 1 1.2517201 327.3328 1.2422313
## 2 0.9234702 195.8085 0.9181446
## 3 0.9833975 288.3649 0.9785913
## 4 1.2246618 287.6409 1.2160580
## 5 0.5172979 280.9574 0.5159624
## 6 1.0285725 215.9899 1.0201172
## 7 1.1234650 188.0101 1.1142444
## 8 0.4600002 256.5682 0.4588587
## 9 0.9572698 231.9387 0.9495642
## 10 0.3293185 252.6230 0.3285812
## 11 0.5245091 306.6015 0.5221172
## 12 0.8946343 289.8072 0.8905802
## 13 0.7269478 300.8850 0.7231875
## 14 0.8792602 286.1872 0.8760008
## 15 0.8582648 238.9423 0.8541069
## 16 1.1381461 235.9210 1.1301388
## 17 0.5570672 227.8167 0.5546633
## 18 1.1168052 221.4097 1.1067428
## 19 0.8793117 282.9886 0.8749299
## 20 0.5543969 286.1183 0.5523423
## 21 0.7915231 299.3876 0.7875389
## 22 0.3301579 235.3928 0.3294530
## 23 0.8527554 299.1710 0.8495805
## 24 0.4352439 255.2221 0.4342057
## 25 0.9557488 254.4676 0.9508251
## 26 0.5890819 219.3769 0.5856168
## 27 0.6225915 178.6341 0.6189202
## 28 0.4805983 388.1595 0.4786641
## 29 0.3510473 417.6807 0.3503602
## 30 0.7807913 363.8225 0.7762245
## 31 0.4828043 396.6846 0.4815066
## 32 0.4692780 404.2917 0.4674724
## 33 0.3476060 420.8997 0.3469806
## 34 1.7358355 453.6405 1.7194875
## 35 1.9314480 189.6320 1.9042086
## 36 0.1873756 406.8228 0.1871774
## 37 0.3991913 264.3597 0.3981472
## 38 0.8200468 183.8735 0.8154157