library(survey)
## Loading required package: grid
## Loading required package: Matrix
## Loading required package: survival
## 
## Attaching package: 'survey'
## The following object is masked from 'package:graphics':
## 
##     dotchart
source('analysis/chendaniely/model_utils.R')

load('data/model_dataframes.RData')

svy_never_every     <- svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_every[!is.na(never_every$weight), ])
svy_never_some      <- svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_some[!is.na(never_some$weight), ])
svy_never_someevery <- svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_someevery[!is.na(never_someevery$weight), ])
svy_some_every      <- svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), ])

1 Demographic model

Demographics + Q13

1.1 Every vs. never (referent)

ne_demo <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work,
       design = svy_never_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(ne_demo)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work, design = svy_never_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_every[!is.na(never_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                         -1.15875    0.38131  -3.039 0.002410
## ppagecat25-34                       -0.12446    0.25785  -0.483 0.629387
## ppagecat35-44                        0.11411    0.24482   0.466 0.641197
## ppagecat45-54                        0.36594    0.23766   1.540 0.123797
## ppagecat55-64                        0.79890    0.22843   3.497 0.000482
## ppagecat65-74                        1.23304    0.24325   5.069 4.43e-07
## ppagecat75+                          1.78680    0.31427   5.686 1.53e-08
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.12528    0.21964   0.570 0.568488
## PPEDUCATSome college                 0.04576    0.22502   0.203 0.838890
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.56223    0.23241   2.419 0.015662
## income$10k to $25k                  -0.03187    0.32358  -0.098 0.921563
## income$25k to $50k                   0.32064    0.31107   1.031 0.302792
## income$50k to $75k                   0.54019    0.31574   1.711 0.087289
## income$75k to $100k                  0.59079    0.32660   1.809 0.070644
## income$100k to $150k                 0.84520    0.32077   2.635 0.008493
## incomeover $150k                     1.11446    0.36584   3.046 0.002352
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.08301    0.16879   0.492 0.622954
## PPREG4South                          0.07621    0.14528   0.525 0.599952
## PPREG4West                           0.18289    0.17063   1.072 0.283932
## workemployed                        -0.32218    0.13615  -2.366 0.018070
##                                        
## (Intercept)                         ** 
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                          
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher *  
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                  .  
## income$75k to $100k                 .  
## income$100k to $150k                ** 
## incomeover $150k                    ** 
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                        *  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.004179)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term     or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 0.3139  **      1.464  -2.5559
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 0.8830          1.294  -1.6535
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 1.1209          1.277  -1.3828
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 1.4419          1.268  -1.0439
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 2.2231 ***      1.257  -0.2399
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 3.4316 ***      1.275   0.9319
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 5.9703 ***      1.369   3.2866
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 1.1335          1.246  -1.3080
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 1.0468          1.252  -1.4078
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.7546   *      1.262  -0.7182
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 0.9686          1.382  -1.7402
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.3780          1.365  -1.2972
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.7163   .      1.371  -0.9714
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.8054   .      1.386  -0.9116
## 15                income$100k to $150k 2.3284  **      1.378  -0.3728
## 16                    incomeover $150k 3.0479  **      1.442   0.2222
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 1.0865          1.184  -1.2338
## 18                         PPREG4South 1.0792          1.156  -1.1873
## 19                          PPREG4West 1.2007          1.186  -1.1240
## 20                        workemployed 0.7246   *      1.146  -1.5213
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     3.184 -1.15875    0.3813  -3.03891 2.410e-03
## 2     3.419 -0.12446    0.2578  -0.48268 6.294e-01
## 3     3.625  0.11411    0.2448   0.46611 6.412e-01
## 4     3.928  0.36594    0.2377   1.53979 1.238e-01
## 5     4.686  0.79890    0.2284   3.49733 4.820e-04
## 6     5.931  1.23304    0.2433   5.06894 4.435e-07
## 7     8.654  1.78680    0.3143   5.68561 1.530e-08
## 8     3.575  0.12528    0.2196   0.57039 5.685e-01
## 9     3.501  0.04576    0.2250   0.20334 8.389e-01
## 10    4.227  0.56223    0.2324   2.41912 1.566e-02
## 11    3.677 -0.03187    0.3236  -0.09848 9.216e-01
## 12    4.053  0.32064    0.3111   1.03078 3.028e-01
## 13    4.404  0.54019    0.3157   1.71086 8.729e-02
## 14    4.522  0.59079    0.3266   1.80889 7.064e-02
## 15    5.030  0.84520    0.3208   2.63487 8.493e-03
## 16    5.874  1.11446    0.3658   3.04635 2.352e-03
## 17    3.407  0.08301    0.1688   0.49176 6.230e-01
## 18    3.346  0.07621    0.1453   0.52457 6.000e-01
## 19    3.525  0.18289    0.1706   1.07187 2.839e-01
## 20    2.970 -0.32218    0.1361  -2.36646 1.807e-02

1.2 Some vs. never

ns_demo <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work,
       design = svy_never_some,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(ns_demo)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work, design = svy_never_some, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_some[!is.na(never_some$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)  
## (Intercept)                         -0.86890    0.43842  -1.982   0.0477 *
## ppagecat25-34                       -0.16824    0.25760  -0.653   0.5138  
## ppagecat35-44                       -0.33740    0.25325  -1.332   0.1830  
## ppagecat45-54                       -0.23398    0.24717  -0.947   0.3440  
## ppagecat55-64                       -0.62973    0.24657  -2.554   0.0108 *
## ppagecat65-74                       -0.27059    0.28752  -0.941   0.3468  
## ppagecat75+                         -0.87755    0.48353  -1.815   0.0698 .
## PPEDUCATHigh school                 -0.32996    0.27255  -1.211   0.2263  
## PPEDUCATSome college                 0.42652    0.26473   1.611   0.1074  
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.55928    0.26815   2.086   0.0372 *
## income$10k to $25k                  -0.08734    0.39014  -0.224   0.8229  
## income$25k to $50k                   0.29968    0.35424   0.846   0.3977  
## income$50k to $75k                   0.39828    0.36387   1.095   0.2739  
## income$75k to $100k                  0.54574    0.37211   1.467   0.1427  
## income$100k to $150k                 0.59808    0.36959   1.618   0.1059  
## incomeover $150k                     0.53540    0.40798   1.312   0.1897  
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.05572    0.20960  -0.266   0.7904  
## PPREG4South                         -0.22860    0.18411  -1.242   0.2146  
## PPREG4West                           0.43145    0.19312   2.234   0.0257 *
## workemployed                        -0.15314    0.16011  -0.956   0.3390  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9956768)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term     or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 0.4194   *      1.550  -2.6191
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 0.8451          1.294  -1.6907
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 0.7136          1.288  -1.8113
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 0.7914          1.280  -1.7182
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 0.5327   *      1.280  -1.9753
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 0.7629          1.333  -1.8500
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 0.4158   .      1.622  -2.7629
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 0.7190          1.313  -1.8551
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 1.5319          1.303  -1.0221
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.7494   *      1.308  -0.8134
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 0.9164          1.477  -1.9789
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.3494          1.425  -1.4437
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.4893          1.439  -1.3310
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.7259          1.451  -1.1177
## 15                income$100k to $150k 1.8186          1.447  -1.0178
## 16                    incomeover $150k 1.7081          1.504  -1.2393
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 0.9458          1.233  -1.4712
## 18                         PPREG4South 0.7956          1.202  -1.5606
## 19                          PPREG4West 1.5395   *      1.213  -0.8380
## 20                        workemployed 0.8580          1.174  -1.4423
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic p.value
## 1     3.458 -0.86890    0.4384   -1.9819 0.04772
## 2     3.381 -0.16824    0.2576   -0.6531 0.51380
## 3     3.239 -0.33740    0.2533   -1.3322 0.18303
## 4     3.301 -0.23398    0.2472   -0.9467 0.34400
## 5     3.041 -0.62973    0.2466   -2.5540 0.01077
## 6     3.376 -0.27059    0.2875   -0.9411 0.34684
## 7     3.595 -0.87755    0.4835   -1.8149 0.06979
## 8     3.293 -0.32996    0.2726   -1.2106 0.22628
## 9     4.086  0.42652    0.2647    1.6112 0.10740
## 10    4.312  0.55928    0.2681    2.0857 0.03721
## 11    3.812 -0.08734    0.3901   -0.2239 0.82290
## 12    4.143  0.29968    0.3542    0.8460 0.39772
## 13    4.309  0.39828    0.3639    1.0945 0.27393
## 14    4.569  0.54574    0.3721    1.4666 0.14274
## 15    4.655  0.59808    0.3696    1.6182 0.10587
## 16    4.656  0.53540    0.4080    1.3123 0.18965
## 17    3.363 -0.05572    0.2096   -0.2658 0.79043
## 18    3.152 -0.22860    0.1841   -1.2416 0.21461
## 19    3.917  0.43145    0.1931    2.2341 0.02565
## 20    3.158 -0.15314    0.1601   -0.9565 0.33901

1.3 Some+every vs. never

nse_demo <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work,
       design = svy_never_someevery,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(nse_demo)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work, design = svy_never_someevery, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_someevery[!is.na(never_someevery$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                         -0.35017    0.32215  -1.087 0.277165
## ppagecat25-34                       -0.12243    0.21134  -0.579 0.562456
## ppagecat35-44                       -0.10054    0.20422  -0.492 0.622546
## ppagecat45-54                        0.09667    0.19929   0.485 0.627687
## ppagecat55-64                        0.28297    0.19367   1.461 0.144144
## ppagecat65-74                        0.69794    0.21432   3.257 0.001146
## ppagecat75+                          1.12506    0.29206   3.852 0.000121
## PPEDUCATHigh school                 -0.01512    0.19489  -0.078 0.938153
## PPEDUCATSome college                 0.21655    0.19897   1.088 0.276565
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.55083    0.20533   2.683 0.007361
## income$10k to $25k                  -0.01750    0.27925  -0.063 0.950044
## income$25k to $50k                   0.31860    0.26522   1.201 0.229789
## income$50k to $75k                   0.48772    0.26983   1.807 0.070830
## income$75k to $100k                  0.57717    0.27929   2.067 0.038895
## income$100k to $150k                 0.75141    0.27516   2.731 0.006371
## incomeover $150k                     0.93784    0.31411   2.986 0.002861
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.02439    0.15181   0.161 0.872404
## PPREG4South                         -0.03050    0.13238  -0.230 0.817824
## PPREG4West                           0.30264    0.15085   2.006 0.044951
## workemployed                        -0.26498    0.12214  -2.169 0.030159
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                          
## ppagecat55-64                          
## ppagecat65-74                       ** 
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher ** 
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                  .  
## income$75k to $100k                 *  
## income$100k to $150k                ** 
## incomeover $150k                    ** 
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                          *  
## workemployed                        *  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.00668)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term     or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 0.7046          1.380  -2.0004
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 0.8848          1.235  -1.5365
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 0.9044          1.227  -1.4997
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 1.1015          1.221  -1.2908
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 1.3271          1.214  -1.0518
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 2.0096  **      1.239  -0.4189
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 3.0804 ***      1.339   0.4556
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 0.9850          1.215  -1.3968
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 1.2418          1.220  -1.1497
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.7347  **      1.228  -0.6721
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 0.9827          1.322  -1.6087
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.3752          1.304  -1.1801
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.6286   .      1.310  -0.9385
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.7810   *      1.322  -0.8105
## 15                income$100k to $150k 2.1200  **      1.317  -0.4608
## 16                    incomeover $150k 2.5545  **      1.369  -0.1288
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 1.0247          1.164  -1.2566
## 18                         PPREG4South 0.9700          1.142  -1.2675
## 19                          PPREG4West 1.3534   *      1.163  -0.9257
## 20                        workemployed 0.7672   *      1.130  -1.4474
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     3.410 -0.35017    0.3221  -1.08699 0.2771645
## 2     3.306 -0.12243    0.2113  -0.57929 0.5624560
## 3     3.308 -0.10054    0.2042  -0.49232 0.6225456
## 4     3.494  0.09667    0.1993   0.48506 0.6276867
## 5     3.706  0.28297    0.1937   1.46107 0.1441437
## 6     4.438  0.69794    0.2143   3.25650 0.0011456
## 7     5.705  1.12506    0.2921   3.85214 0.0001205
## 8     3.367 -0.01512    0.1949  -0.07760 0.9381533
## 9     3.633  0.21655    0.1990   1.08835 0.2765655
## 10    4.141  0.55083    0.2053   2.68262 0.0073612
## 11    3.574 -0.01750    0.2792  -0.06266 0.9500436
## 12    3.930  0.31860    0.2652   1.20125 0.2297891
## 13    4.196  0.48772    0.2698   1.80747 0.0708304
## 14    4.372  0.57717    0.2793   2.06657 0.0388953
## 15    4.701  0.75141    0.2752   2.73076 0.0063709
## 16    5.238  0.93784    0.3141   2.98576 0.0028610
## 17    3.306  0.02439    0.1518   0.16062 0.8724041
## 18    3.207 -0.03050    0.1324  -0.23037 0.8178240
## 19    3.633  0.30264    0.1508   2.00630 0.0449507
## 20    2.982 -0.26498    0.1221  -2.16945 0.0301590

2 Demographic model + Belief (Q20)

Demographics + Q13 + Q20

2.1 Every vs. never

ne_demo_belief <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20,
       design = svy_never_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(ne_demo_belief)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20, design = svy_never_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_every[!is.na(never_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                      Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          1.111703   0.467912   2.376 0.017618
## ppagecat25-34                        0.257290   0.316924   0.812 0.417000
## ppagecat35-44                        0.286100   0.296855   0.964 0.335298
## ppagecat45-54                        0.652244   0.288885   2.258 0.024085
## ppagecat55-64                        1.071285   0.282470   3.793 0.000154
## ppagecat65-74                        1.718542   0.303408   5.664 1.73e-08
## ppagecat75+                          2.080317   0.389260   5.344 1.03e-07
## PPEDUCATHigh school                 -0.140217   0.262998  -0.533 0.594001
## PPEDUCATSome college                 0.013590   0.268861   0.051 0.959694
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.485933   0.271065   1.793 0.073202
## income$10k to $25k                  -0.285509   0.401252  -0.712 0.476845
## income$25k to $50k                   0.177264   0.384890   0.461 0.645175
## income$50k to $75k                   0.383067   0.387103   0.990 0.322523
## income$75k to $100k                  0.381543   0.394885   0.966 0.334076
## income$100k to $150k                 0.544320   0.392350   1.387 0.165522
## incomeover $150k                     0.760511   0.423591   1.795 0.072769
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.015898   0.199993  -0.079 0.936649
## PPREG4South                         -0.005494   0.171567  -0.032 0.974459
## PPREG4West                           0.093077   0.190572   0.488 0.625322
## workemployed                        -0.249378   0.154690  -1.612 0.107124
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.932446   0.216389  -8.930  < 2e-16
## Q20It varies from season to season  -2.657984   0.236578 -11.235  < 2e-16
## Q20Not effective                    -5.157342   0.525368  -9.817  < 2e-16
## Q20Don_t know                       -4.415717   0.329667 -13.394  < 2e-16
##                                        
## (Intercept)                         *  
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                       *  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher .  
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                    .  
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.012814)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
## 
##                                   term       or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 3.039529   *      1.597 -0.08992
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 1.293420          1.373 -1.39746
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 1.331226          1.346 -1.30619
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 1.919844   *      1.335 -0.69664
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 2.919129 ***      1.326  0.31938
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 5.576390 ***      1.354  2.92163
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 8.007009 ***      1.476  5.11427
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 0.869170          1.301 -1.68044
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 1.013682          1.308 -1.55093
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.625692   .      1.311 -0.94457
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 0.751632          1.494 -2.17601
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.193946          1.469 -1.68618
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.466777          1.473 -1.41973
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.464543          1.484 -1.44452
## 15                income$100k to $150k 1.723436          1.480 -1.17826
## 16                    incomeover $150k 2.139370   .      1.527 -0.85441
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 0.984228          1.221 -1.40970
## 18                         PPREG4South 0.994521          1.187 -1.33232
## 19                          PPREG4West 1.097547          1.210 -1.27394
## 20                        workemployed 0.779286          1.167 -1.50862
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective 0.144794 ***      1.242 -2.28871
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season 0.070089 ***      1.267 -2.41305
## 23                    Q20Not effective 0.005757 ***      1.691 -3.30876
## 24                       Q20Don_t know 0.012086 ***      1.391 -2.71330
##    or_upper  estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     6.169  1.111703    0.4679   2.37588 1.762e-02
## 2     3.984  0.257290    0.3169   0.81183 4.170e-01
## 3     3.969  0.286100    0.2969   0.96377 3.353e-01
## 4     4.536  0.652244    0.2889   2.25779 2.409e-02
## 5     5.519  1.071285    0.2825   3.79257 1.543e-04
## 6     8.231  1.718542    0.3034   5.66412 1.732e-08
## 7    10.900  2.080317    0.3893   5.34429 1.031e-07
## 8     3.419 -0.140217    0.2630  -0.53315 5.940e-01
## 9     3.578  0.013590    0.2689   0.05054 9.597e-01
## 10    4.196  0.485933    0.2711   1.79268 7.320e-02
## 11    3.679 -0.285509    0.4013  -0.71154 4.768e-01
## 12    4.074  0.177264    0.3849   0.46056 6.452e-01
## 13    4.353  0.383067    0.3871   0.98957 3.225e-01
## 14    4.374  0.381543    0.3949   0.96621 3.341e-01
## 15    4.625  0.544320    0.3923   1.38733 1.655e-01
## 16    5.133  0.760511    0.4236   1.79539 7.277e-02
## 17    3.378 -0.015898    0.2000  -0.07949 9.366e-01
## 18    3.321 -0.005494    0.1716  -0.03202 9.745e-01
## 19    3.469  0.093077    0.1906   0.48841 6.253e-01
## 20    3.067 -0.249378    0.1547  -1.61211 1.071e-01
## 21    2.578 -1.932446    0.2164  -8.93043 1.077e-18
## 22    2.553 -2.657984    0.2366 -11.23512 2.657e-28
## 23    3.320 -5.157342    0.5254  -9.81662 3.665e-22
## 24    2.737 -4.415717    0.3297 -13.39448 5.746e-39

2.2 Some vs. never

ns_demo_belief <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20,
       design = svy_never_some,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(ns_demo_belief)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20, design = svy_never_some, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_some[!is.na(never_some$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                      Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.342553   0.472241   0.725   0.4684
## ppagecat25-34                        0.089256   0.277557   0.322   0.7478
## ppagecat35-44                       -0.240676   0.264334  -0.910   0.3627
## ppagecat45-54                       -0.117146   0.250290  -0.468   0.6398
## ppagecat55-64                       -0.485524   0.255052  -1.904   0.0572
## ppagecat65-74                       -0.004515   0.297290  -0.015   0.9879
## ppagecat75+                         -0.601732   0.480598  -1.252   0.2108
## PPEDUCATHigh school                 -0.418800   0.280988  -1.490   0.1364
## PPEDUCATSome college                 0.511144   0.275911   1.853   0.0642
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.425203   0.279053   1.524   0.1278
## income$10k to $25k                  -0.157969   0.416059  -0.380   0.7042
## income$25k to $50k                   0.135212   0.372071   0.363   0.7164
## income$50k to $75k                   0.267820   0.388324   0.690   0.4905
## income$75k to $100k                  0.386658   0.392101   0.986   0.3243
## income$100k to $150k                 0.353797   0.384644   0.920   0.3579
## incomeover $150k                     0.374320   0.417745   0.896   0.3704
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.083956   0.215883  -0.389   0.6974
## PPREG4South                         -0.236242   0.191895  -1.231   0.2185
## PPREG4West                           0.476215   0.202568   2.351   0.0189
## workemployed                        -0.186572   0.169359  -1.102   0.2708
## Q20Somewhat effective               -0.654320   0.272663  -2.400   0.0166
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.365035   0.293946  -4.644 3.79e-06
## Q20Not effective                    -2.260054   0.387190  -5.837 6.81e-09
## Q20Don_t know                       -2.312482   0.329565  -7.017 3.76e-12
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                          
## ppagecat55-64                       .  
## ppagecat65-74                          
## ppagecat75+                            
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                .  
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                          *  
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               *  
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9903779)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 1.40854          1.604  -1.7345
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 1.09336          1.320  -1.4936
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 0.78610          1.303  -1.7669
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 0.88946          1.284  -1.6280
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 0.61537   .      1.291  -1.9141
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 0.99549          1.346  -1.6431
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 0.54786          1.617  -2.6215
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 0.65784          1.324  -1.9381
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 1.66720   .      1.318  -0.9156
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.52990          1.322  -1.0610
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 0.85388          1.516  -2.1174
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.14478          1.451  -1.6987
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.30711          1.475  -1.5829
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.47205          1.480  -1.4289
## 15                income$100k to $150k 1.42447          1.469  -1.4550
## 16                    incomeover $150k 1.45400          1.519  -1.5223
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 0.91947          1.241  -1.5128
## 18                         PPREG4South 0.78959          1.212  -1.5850
## 19                          PPREG4West 1.60997   *      1.225  -0.7901
## 20                        workemployed 0.82980          1.185  -1.4919
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective 0.51980   *      1.313  -2.0546
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season 0.25537 ***      1.342  -2.3744
## 23                    Q20Not effective 0.10434 ***      1.473  -2.7824
## 24                       Q20Don_t know 0.09902 ***      1.390  -2.6261
##    or_upper  estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     4.552  0.342553    0.4722   0.72538 4.684e-01
## 2     3.680  0.089256    0.2776   0.32158 7.478e-01
## 3     3.339 -0.240676    0.2643  -0.91050 3.627e-01
## 4     3.407 -0.117146    0.2503  -0.46804 6.398e-01
## 5     3.145 -0.485524    0.2551  -1.90363 5.719e-02
## 6     3.634 -0.004515    0.2973  -0.01519 9.879e-01
## 7     3.717 -0.601732    0.4806  -1.25205 2.108e-01
## 8     3.254 -0.418800    0.2810  -1.49046 1.364e-01
## 9     4.250  0.511144    0.2759   1.85257 6.419e-02
## 10    4.121  0.425203    0.2791   1.52373 1.278e-01
## 11    3.825 -0.157969    0.4161  -0.37968 7.042e-01
## 12    3.988  0.135212    0.3721   0.36340 7.164e-01
## 13    4.197  0.267820    0.3883   0.68968 4.905e-01
## 14    4.373  0.386658    0.3921   0.98612 3.243e-01
## 15    4.304  0.353797    0.3846   0.91980 3.579e-01
## 16    4.430  0.374320    0.4177   0.89605 3.704e-01
## 17    3.352 -0.083956    0.2159  -0.38890 6.974e-01
## 18    3.164 -0.236242    0.1919  -1.23110 2.185e-01
## 19    4.010  0.476215    0.2026   2.35089 1.889e-02
## 20    3.152 -0.186572    0.1694  -1.10163 2.708e-01
## 21    3.094 -0.654320    0.2727  -2.39974 1.656e-02
## 22    2.885 -1.365035    0.2939  -4.64383 3.792e-06
## 23    2.991 -2.260054    0.3872  -5.83707 6.809e-09
## 24    2.824 -2.312482    0.3296  -7.01677 3.764e-12

2.3 Some+every vs. never

nse_demo_belief <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20,
       design = svy_never_someevery,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(nse_demo_belief)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20, design = svy_never_someevery, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_someevery[!is.na(never_someevery$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                      Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          1.560743   0.387582   4.027 5.85e-05
## ppagecat25-34                        0.215717   0.250575   0.861 0.389396
## ppagecat35-44                        0.001712   0.235219   0.007 0.994193
## ppagecat45-54                        0.203090   0.225265   0.902 0.367392
## ppagecat55-64                        0.354798   0.219980   1.613 0.106923
## ppagecat65-74                        0.915637   0.240970   3.800 0.000149
## ppagecat75+                          1.145851   0.327454   3.499 0.000476
## PPEDUCATHigh school                 -0.144782   0.221305  -0.654 0.513042
## PPEDUCATSome college                 0.348094   0.229158   1.519 0.128908
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.508423   0.231912   2.192 0.028465
## income$10k to $25k                  -0.090667   0.331705  -0.273 0.784620
## income$25k to $50k                   0.226580   0.308746   0.734 0.463108
## income$50k to $75k                   0.389262   0.317248   1.227 0.219960
## income$75k to $100k                  0.429722   0.322469   1.333 0.182808
## income$100k to $150k                 0.487213   0.320240   1.521 0.128308
## incomeover $150k                     0.675470   0.346260   1.951 0.051218
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.018486   0.169996  -0.109 0.913417
## PPREG4South                         -0.073798   0.147349  -0.501 0.616536
## PPREG4West                           0.337980   0.166073   2.035 0.041962
## workemployed                        -0.226606   0.136482  -1.660 0.096995
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.549009   0.212490  -7.290 4.36e-13
## Q20It varies from season to season  -2.268787   0.227127  -9.989  < 2e-16
## Q20Not effective                    -3.758014   0.331932 -11.322  < 2e-16
## Q20Don_t know                       -3.582236   0.264587 -13.539  < 2e-16
##                                        
## (Intercept)                         ***
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                          
## ppagecat55-64                          
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher *  
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                    .  
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                          *  
## workemployed                        .  
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9815631)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err  or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 4.76236 ***      1.473  1.874467
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 1.24075          1.285 -1.277385
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 1.00171          1.265 -1.478050
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 1.22518          1.253 -1.230019
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 1.42589          1.246 -1.016369
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 2.49837 ***      1.272  0.004301
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 3.14512 ***      1.387  0.425754
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 0.86521          1.248 -1.580289
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 1.41637          1.258 -1.048414
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.66267   *      1.261 -0.808909
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 0.91332          1.393 -1.817628
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.25430          1.362 -1.414660
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.47589          1.373 -1.215861
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.53683          1.381 -1.169015
## 15                income$100k to $150k 1.62777          1.377 -1.072044
## 16                    incomeover $150k 1.96496   .      1.414 -0.806034
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 0.98168          1.185 -1.341504
## 18                         PPREG4South 0.92886          1.159 -1.342308
## 19                          PPREG4West 1.40211   *      1.181 -0.911980
## 20                        workemployed 0.79723   .      1.146 -1.449385
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective 0.21246 ***      1.237 -2.211579
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season 0.10344 ***      1.255 -2.356342
## 23                    Q20Not effective 0.02333 ***      1.394 -2.708239
## 24                       Q20Don_t know 0.02781 ***      1.303 -2.525857
##    or_upper  estimate std.error  statistic   p.value
## 1     7.650  1.560743    0.3876   4.026875 5.851e-05
## 2     3.759  0.215717    0.2506   0.860890 3.894e-01
## 3     3.481  0.001712    0.2352   0.007279 9.942e-01
## 4     3.680  0.203090    0.2253   0.901562 3.674e-01
## 5     3.868  0.354798    0.2200   1.612865 1.069e-01
## 6     4.992  0.915637    0.2410   3.799799 1.489e-04
## 7     5.864  1.145851    0.3275   3.499279 4.761e-04
## 8     3.311 -0.144782    0.2213  -0.654219 5.130e-01
## 9     3.881  0.348094    0.2292   1.519013 1.289e-01
## 10    4.134  0.508423    0.2319   2.192314 2.847e-02
## 11    3.644 -0.090667    0.3317  -0.273338 7.846e-01
## 12    3.923  0.226580    0.3087   0.733872 4.631e-01
## 13    4.168  0.389262    0.3172   1.226997 2.200e-01
## 14    4.243  0.429722    0.3225   1.332596 1.828e-01
## 15    4.328  0.487213    0.3202   1.521402 1.283e-01
## 16    4.736  0.675470    0.3463   1.950757 5.122e-02
## 17    3.305 -0.018486    0.1700  -0.108742 9.134e-01
## 18    3.200 -0.073798    0.1473  -0.500840 6.165e-01
## 19    3.716  0.337980    0.1661   2.035126 4.196e-02
## 20    3.044 -0.226606    0.1365  -1.660333 9.700e-02
## 21    2.636 -1.549009    0.2125  -7.289800 4.360e-13
## 22    2.563 -2.268787    0.2271  -9.989061 5.436e-23
## 23    2.755 -3.758014    0.3319 -11.321652 6.800e-29
## 24    2.581 -3.582236    0.2646 -13.538952 4.072e-40

2.3.1 F statistic

anova(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief, test = 'F')
## Working (Rao-Scott+F) LRT for Q20
##  in svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20, design = svy_never_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## Working 2logLR =  424.2936 p= < 2.22e-16 
## (scale factors:  1.2 0.98 0.96 0.89 );  denominator df= 1698
anova(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief, test = 'F')
## Working (Rao-Scott+F) LRT for Q20
##  in svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20, design = svy_never_some, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## Working 2logLR =  105.0894 p= < 2.22e-16 
## (scale factors:  1.1 1 0.96 0.88 );  denominator df= 1215
anova(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief, test = 'F')
## Working (Rao-Scott+F) LRT for Q20
##  in svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20, design = svy_never_someevery, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## Working 2logLR =  360.4446 p= < 2.22e-16 
## (scale factors:  1.2 0.98 0.96 0.86 );  denominator df= 2120

2.3.2 AIC/BIC

AIC(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief)
##         eff.p      AIC deltabar
## [1,] 22.71370 2227.893 1.195458
## [2,] 26.96941 1712.290 1.172583
AIC(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief)
##         eff.p      AIC deltabar
## [1,] 21.81199 1555.697 1.147999
## [2,] 26.21122 1438.047 1.139618
AIC(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief)
##         eff.p      AIC deltabar
## [1,] 22.88354 2793.109 1.204397
## [2,] 27.77803 2336.361 1.207741
BIC(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief, maximal = ne_demo_belief)
##       p      BIC     neff
## [1,] 20 2054.776 1404.979
## [2,] 24 1837.181      NaN
BIC(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief, maximal = ns_demo_belief)
##       p      BIC     neff
## [1,] 20 1620.012 1037.038
## [2,] 24 1556.554      NaN
BIC(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief, maximal = nse_demo_belief)
##       p      BIC     neff
## [1,] 20 2698.113 1673.793
## [2,] 24 2464.895      NaN

Keep the belief variable.

3 Social influence and herd immunity (Q15 + Q16 + Q17)

3.1 Every vs. some

Q15, Q16, Q17

se_demo_belief_social <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q15 + Q16 + Q17,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_social)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q15 + Q16 + Q17, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.88747    0.66112   1.342 0.179710
## ppagecat25-34                        0.08441    0.32935   0.256 0.797759
## ppagecat35-44                        0.44295    0.31211   1.419 0.156087
## ppagecat45-54                        0.53434    0.30118   1.774 0.076273
## ppagecat55-64                        1.26262    0.29120   4.336 1.57e-05
## ppagecat65-74                        1.56814    0.32296   4.855 1.35e-06
## ppagecat75+                          2.38301    0.45055   5.289 1.44e-07
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.38074    0.32299   1.179 0.238695
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.34230    0.31503  -1.087 0.277429
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.07294    0.32405   0.225 0.821945
## income$10k to $25k                   0.26675    0.53090   0.502 0.615434
## income$25k to $50k                   0.40267    0.51396   0.783 0.433501
## income$50k to $75k                   0.58473    0.51412   1.137 0.255604
## income$75k to $100k                  0.38522    0.52220   0.738 0.460837
## income$100k to $150k                 0.53958    0.51625   1.045 0.296136
## incomeover $150k                     0.81674    0.53185   1.536 0.124868
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.05313    0.23188  -0.229 0.818826
## PPREG4South                          0.10034    0.20311   0.494 0.621363
## PPREG4West                          -0.34905    0.21209  -1.646 0.100060
## workemployed                        -0.12694    0.17113  -0.742 0.458346
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.29642    0.20424  -6.348 3.03e-10
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.36430    0.23855  -5.719 1.33e-08
## Q20Not effective                    -1.95679    0.64569  -3.031 0.002490
## Q20Don_t know                       -2.18393    0.39468  -5.533 3.81e-08
## Q15No, no effect                     0.29685    0.20184   1.471 0.141598
## Q15No, less likely                   0.07716    0.36710   0.210 0.833566
## Q16No, no effect                    -0.72761    0.21109  -3.447 0.000585
## Q16No, less likely                  -1.44622    0.32419  -4.461 8.87e-06
## Q17Protect myself and others         0.25287    0.15616   1.619 0.105613
## Q17Protect others                   -0.92209    0.42587  -2.165 0.030557
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                       .  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ** 
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q15No, no effect                       
## Q15No, less likely                     
## Q16No, no effect                    ***
## Q16No, less likely                  ***
## Q17Protect myself and others           
## Q17Protect others                   *  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.007552)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept)  2.4290          1.937  -1.3674
## 2                        ppagecat25-34  1.0881          1.390  -1.6365
## 3                        ppagecat35-44  1.5573          1.366  -1.1207
## 4                        ppagecat45-54  1.7063   .      1.351  -0.9425
## 5                        ppagecat55-64  3.5347 ***      1.338   0.9121
## 6                        ppagecat65-74  4.7977 ***      1.381   2.0905
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 10.8375 ***      1.569   7.7619
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school  1.4634          1.381  -1.2439
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college  0.7101          1.370  -1.9756
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  1.0757          1.383  -1.6345
## 11                  income$10k to $25k  1.3057          1.700  -2.0272
## 12                  income$25k to $50k  1.4958          1.672  -1.7811
## 13                  income$50k to $75k  1.7945          1.672  -1.4829
## 14                 income$75k to $100k  1.4699          1.686  -1.8341
## 15                income$100k to $150k  1.7153          1.676  -1.5692
## 16                    incomeover $150k  2.2631          1.702  -1.0730
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast  0.9483          1.261  -1.5232
## 18                         PPREG4South  1.1056          1.225  -1.2958
## 19                          PPREG4West  0.7054          1.236  -1.7177
## 20                        workemployed  0.8808          1.187  -1.4450
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective  0.2735 ***      1.227  -2.1306
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season  0.2556 ***      1.269  -2.2325
## 23                    Q20Not effective  0.1413  **      1.907  -3.5970
## 24                       Q20Don_t know  0.1126 ***      1.484  -2.7959
## 25                    Q15No, no effect  1.3456          1.224  -1.0527
## 26                  Q15No, less likely  1.0802          1.444  -1.7491
## 27                    Q16No, no effect  0.4831 ***      1.235  -1.9376
## 28                  Q16No, less likely  0.2355 ***      1.383  -2.4750
## 29        Q17Protect myself and others  1.2877          1.169  -1.0035
## 30                   Q17Protect others  0.3977   *      1.531  -2.6029
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     6.225  0.88747    0.6611    1.3424 1.797e-01
## 2     3.813  0.08441    0.3294    0.2563 7.978e-01
## 3     4.235  0.44295    0.3121    1.4192 1.561e-01
## 4     4.355  0.53434    0.3012    1.7742 7.627e-02
## 5     6.157  1.26262    0.2912    4.3359 1.566e-05
## 6     7.505  1.56814    0.3230    4.8555 1.349e-06
## 7    13.913  2.38301    0.4505    5.2891 1.445e-07
## 8     4.171  0.38074    0.3230    1.1788 2.387e-01
## 9     3.396 -0.34230    0.3150   -1.0866 2.774e-01
## 10    3.786  0.07294    0.3240    0.2251 8.219e-01
## 11    4.639  0.26675    0.5309    0.5025 6.154e-01
## 12    4.773  0.40267    0.5140    0.7835 4.335e-01
## 13    5.072  0.58473    0.5141    1.1374 2.556e-01
## 14    4.774  0.38522    0.5222    0.7377 4.608e-01
## 15    5.000  0.53958    0.5163    1.0452 2.961e-01
## 16    5.599  0.81674    0.5318    1.5357 1.249e-01
## 17    3.420 -0.05313    0.2319   -0.2291 8.188e-01
## 18    3.507  0.10034    0.2031    0.4940 6.214e-01
## 19    3.128 -0.34905    0.2121   -1.6458 1.001e-01
## 20    3.207 -0.12694    0.1711   -0.7418 4.583e-01
## 21    2.678 -1.29642    0.2042   -6.3476 3.031e-10
## 22    2.744 -1.36430    0.2385   -5.7192 1.332e-08
## 23    3.880 -1.95679    0.6457   -3.0305 2.490e-03
## 24    3.021 -2.18393    0.3947   -5.5334 3.807e-08
## 25    3.744  0.29685    0.2018    1.4708 1.416e-01
## 26    3.910  0.07716    0.3671    0.2102 8.336e-01
## 27    2.904 -0.72761    0.2111   -3.4470 5.853e-04
## 28    2.946 -1.44622    0.3242   -4.4610 8.875e-06
## 29    3.579  0.25287    0.1562    1.6194 1.056e-01
## 30    3.398 -0.92209    0.4259   -2.1652 3.056e-02

3.1.1 F statistic

#anova(ne_demo_belief_social, ne_demo_belief, test = 'F')
#anova(ns_demo_belief_social, ns_demo_belief, test = 'F')
#anova(nse_demo_belief_social, nse_demo_belief, test = 'F')

3.1.2 AIC/BIC

#AIC(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief, ne_demo_belief_social)
#AIC(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief, ns_demo_belief_social)
AIC(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief, se_demo_belief_social)
##         eff.p      AIC deltabar
## [1,] 22.88354 2793.109 1.204397
## [2,] 27.77803 2336.361 1.207741
## [3,] 35.26805 1436.213 1.216140
#BIC(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief, ne_demo_belief_social, maximal = ne_demo_belief_social)
#BIC(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief, ns_demo_belief_social, maximal = ns_demo_belief_social)
BIC(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief, se_demo_belief_social, maximal = se_demo_belief_social)
##       p      BIC     neff
## [1,] 20 1613.851 1830.200
## [2,] 24 1588.922 1874.308
## [3,] 30 1580.964      NaN

4 Social influence and herd immunity Sub

4.1 Every vs. some

4.1.1 Q16

se_demo_belief_social <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q16,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_social)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q16, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.99152    0.63100   1.571 0.116347
## ppagecat25-34                        0.18988    0.32384   0.586 0.557746
## ppagecat35-44                        0.48789    0.30842   1.582 0.113920
## ppagecat45-54                        0.60007    0.29830   2.012 0.044466
## ppagecat55-64                        1.34996    0.28835   4.682 3.15e-06
## ppagecat65-74                        1.68512    0.31877   5.286 1.46e-07
## ppagecat75+                          2.45314    0.44137   5.558 3.31e-08
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.48986    0.31179   1.571 0.116397
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.24402    0.30389  -0.803 0.422144
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.15242    0.31340   0.486 0.626822
## income$10k to $25k                   0.18880    0.52138   0.362 0.717321
## income$25k to $50k                   0.34426    0.50592   0.680 0.496334
## income$50k to $75k                   0.53035    0.50618   1.048 0.294950
## income$75k to $100k                  0.34297    0.51424   0.667 0.504926
## income$100k to $150k                 0.51806    0.50726   1.021 0.307310
## incomeover $150k                     0.81476    0.52398   1.555 0.120204
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.06739    0.23029  -0.293 0.769853
## PPREG4South                          0.10044    0.20064   0.501 0.616744
## PPREG4West                          -0.32617    0.21164  -1.541 0.123523
## workemployed                        -0.11856    0.16945  -0.700 0.484233
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.25591    0.20173  -6.226 6.47e-10
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.27847    0.23666  -5.402 7.83e-08
## Q20Not effective                    -2.12834    0.63143  -3.371 0.000772
## Q20Don_t know                       -2.09757    0.39361  -5.329 1.16e-07
## Q16No, no effect                    -0.59448    0.18244  -3.259 0.001149
## Q16No, less likely                  -1.59648    0.30999  -5.150 3.01e-07
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                       *  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q16No, no effect                    ** 
## Q16No, less likely                  ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.007445)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept)  2.6953          1.879  -0.9885
## 2                        ppagecat25-34  1.2091          1.382  -1.5005
## 3                        ppagecat35-44  1.6289          1.361  -1.0392
## 4                        ppagecat45-54  1.8222   *      1.348  -0.8190
## 5                        ppagecat55-64  3.8573 ***      1.334   1.2422
## 6                        ppagecat65-74  5.3931 ***      1.375   2.6973
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 11.6248 ***      1.555   8.5773
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school  1.6321          1.366  -1.0450
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college  0.7835          1.355  -1.8726
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  1.1646          1.368  -1.5168
## 11                  income$10k to $25k  1.2078          1.684  -2.0935
## 12                  income$25k to $50k  1.4109          1.659  -1.8397
## 13                  income$50k to $75k  1.6995          1.659  -1.5520
## 14                 income$75k to $100k  1.4091          1.672  -1.8687
## 15                income$100k to $150k  1.6788          1.661  -1.5763
## 16                    incomeover $150k  2.2586          1.689  -1.0513
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast  0.9348          1.259  -1.5327
## 18                         PPREG4South  1.1057          1.222  -1.2898
## 19                          PPREG4West  0.7217          1.236  -1.7003
## 20                        workemployed  0.8882          1.185  -1.4337
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective  0.2848 ***      1.224  -2.1133
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season  0.2785 ***      1.267  -2.2049
## 23                    Q20Not effective  0.1190 ***      1.880  -3.5663
## 24                       Q20Don_t know  0.1228 ***      1.482  -2.7826
## 25                    Q16No, no effect  0.5519  **      1.200  -1.8004
## 26                  Q16No, less likely  0.2026 ***      1.363  -2.4697
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     6.379  0.99152    0.6310    1.5714 1.163e-01
## 2     3.919  0.18988    0.3238    0.5863 5.577e-01
## 3     4.297  0.48789    0.3084    1.5819 1.139e-01
## 4     4.463  0.60007    0.2983    2.0116 4.447e-02
## 5     6.472  1.34996    0.2884    4.6817 3.146e-06
## 6     8.089  1.68512    0.3188    5.2864 1.464e-07
## 7    14.672  2.45314    0.4414    5.5580 3.313e-08
## 8     4.309  0.48986    0.3118    1.5711 1.164e-01
## 9     3.440 -0.24402    0.3039   -0.8030 4.221e-01
## 10    3.846  0.15242    0.3134    0.4863 6.268e-01
## 11    4.509  0.18880    0.5214    0.3621 7.173e-01
## 12    4.662  0.34426    0.5059    0.6805 4.963e-01
## 13    4.951  0.53035    0.5062    1.0477 2.950e-01
## 14    4.687  0.34297    0.5142    0.6669 5.049e-01
## 15    4.934  0.51806    0.5073    1.0213 3.073e-01
## 16    5.569  0.81476    0.5240    1.5549 1.202e-01
## 17    3.402 -0.06739    0.2303   -0.2926 7.699e-01
## 18    3.501  0.10044    0.2006    0.5006 6.167e-01
## 19    3.144 -0.32617    0.2116   -1.5412 1.235e-01
## 20    3.210 -0.11856    0.1694   -0.6997 4.842e-01
## 21    2.683 -1.25591    0.2017   -6.2257 6.473e-10
## 22    2.762 -1.27847    0.2367   -5.4021 7.834e-08
## 23    3.804 -2.12834    0.6314   -3.3707 7.721e-04
## 24    3.028 -2.09757    0.3936   -5.3290 1.165e-07
## 25    2.904 -0.59448    0.1824   -3.2586 1.149e-03
## 26    2.875 -1.59648    0.3100   -5.1500 3.010e-07

4.1.2 Q16 + Q17

se_demo_belief_social <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q16 + Q17,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_social)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q16 + Q17, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.86952    0.66019   1.317  0.18805
## ppagecat25-34                        0.12259    0.32646   0.376  0.70734
## ppagecat35-44                        0.46395    0.30940   1.500  0.13399
## ppagecat45-54                        0.56638    0.29963   1.890  0.05895
## ppagecat55-64                        1.30662    0.28892   4.522 6.68e-06
## ppagecat65-74                        1.60665    0.31986   5.023 5.80e-07
## ppagecat75+                          2.42618    0.44676   5.431 6.71e-08
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.45252    0.31882   1.419  0.15603
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.25973    0.30995  -0.838  0.40220
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.15505    0.31823   0.487  0.62618
## income$10k to $25k                   0.25660    0.53705   0.478  0.63287
## income$25k to $50k                   0.36961    0.52107   0.709  0.47825
## income$50k to $75k                   0.57172    0.52154   1.096  0.27318
## income$75k to $100k                  0.38244    0.52816   0.724  0.46915
## income$100k to $150k                 0.52132    0.52252   0.998  0.31861
## incomeover $150k                     0.80737    0.53868   1.499  0.13417
## PPREG4Northeast                     -0.04754    0.23073  -0.206  0.83678
## PPREG4South                          0.09591    0.20144   0.476  0.63406
## PPREG4West                          -0.33602    0.21123  -1.591  0.11190
## workemployed                        -0.12483    0.17016  -0.734  0.46332
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.26729    0.20375  -6.220 6.72e-10
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.30431    0.23883  -5.461 5.67e-08
## Q20Not effective                    -1.95128    0.64557  -3.023  0.00256
## Q20Don_t know                       -2.12775    0.39589  -5.375 9.11e-08
## Q16No, no effect                    -0.59728    0.18556  -3.219  0.00132
## Q16No, less likely                  -1.50849    0.31463  -4.795 1.82e-06
## Q17Protect myself and others         0.25003    0.15580   1.605  0.10878
## Q17Protect others                   -0.88537    0.42373  -2.089  0.03686
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                       .  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ** 
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q16No, no effect                    ** 
## Q16No, less likely                  ***
## Q17Protect myself and others           
## Q17Protect others                   *  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.010245)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept)  2.3858          1.935  -1.4071
## 2                        ppagecat25-34  1.1304          1.386  -1.5862
## 3                        ppagecat35-44  1.5903          1.363  -1.0804
## 4                        ppagecat45-54  1.7619   .      1.349  -0.8829
## 5                        ppagecat55-64  3.6937 ***      1.335   1.0771
## 6                        ppagecat65-74  4.9861 ***      1.377   2.2873
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 11.3156 ***      1.563   8.2516
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school  1.5723          1.375  -1.1237
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college  0.7713          1.363  -1.9009
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  1.1677          1.375  -1.5267
## 11                  income$10k to $25k  1.2925          1.711  -2.0609
## 12                  income$25k to $50k  1.4472          1.684  -1.8531
## 13                  income$50k to $75k  1.7713          1.685  -1.5305
## 14                 income$75k to $100k  1.4658          1.696  -1.8579
## 15                income$100k to $150k  1.6842          1.686  -1.6208
## 16                    incomeover $150k  2.2420          1.714  -1.1169
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast  0.9536          1.260  -1.5151
## 18                         PPREG4South  1.1007          1.223  -1.2967
## 19                          PPREG4West  0.7146          1.235  -1.7064
## 20                        workemployed  0.8826          1.185  -1.4409
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective  0.2816 ***      1.226  -2.1213
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season  0.2714 ***      1.270  -2.2174
## 23                    Q20Not effective  0.1421  **      1.907  -3.5958
## 24                       Q20Don_t know  0.1191 ***      1.486  -2.7929
## 25                    Q16No, no effect  0.5503  **      1.204  -1.8093
## 26                  Q16No, less likely  0.2212 ***      1.370  -2.4635
## 27        Q17Protect myself and others  1.2841          1.169  -1.0064
## 28                   Q17Protect others  0.4126   *      1.528  -2.5816
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     6.179  0.86952    0.6602    1.3171 1.880e-01
## 2     3.847  0.12259    0.3265    0.3755 7.073e-01
## 3     4.261  0.46395    0.3094    1.4995 1.340e-01
## 4     4.407  0.56638    0.2996    1.8903 5.895e-02
## 5     6.310  1.30662    0.2889    4.5224 6.680e-06
## 6     7.685  1.60665    0.3199    5.0230 5.804e-07
## 7    14.380  2.42618    0.4468    5.4306 6.714e-08
## 8     4.268  0.45252    0.3188    1.4194 1.560e-01
## 9     3.443 -0.25973    0.3100   -0.8380 4.022e-01
## 10    3.862  0.15505    0.3182    0.4872 6.262e-01
## 11    4.646  0.25660    0.5370    0.4778 6.329e-01
## 12    4.747  0.36961    0.5211    0.7093 4.783e-01
## 13    5.073  0.57172    0.5215    1.0962 2.732e-01
## 14    4.790  0.38244    0.5282    0.7241 4.691e-01
## 15    4.989  0.52132    0.5225    0.9977 3.186e-01
## 16    5.601  0.80737    0.5387    1.4988 1.342e-01
## 17    3.422 -0.04754    0.2307   -0.2061 8.368e-01
## 18    3.498  0.09591    0.2014    0.4761 6.341e-01
## 19    3.136 -0.33602    0.2112   -1.5908 1.119e-01
## 20    3.206 -0.12483    0.1702   -0.7336 4.633e-01
## 21    2.685 -1.26729    0.2037   -6.2199 6.720e-10
## 22    2.760 -1.30431    0.2388   -5.4613 5.670e-08
## 23    3.880 -1.95128    0.6456   -3.0226 2.556e-03
## 24    3.031 -2.12775    0.3959   -5.3746 9.112e-08
## 25    2.910 -0.59728    0.1856   -3.2188 1.320e-03
## 26    2.906 -1.50849    0.3146   -4.7945 1.821e-06
## 27    3.575  0.25003    0.1558    1.6048 1.088e-01
## 28    3.407 -0.88537    0.4237   -2.0895 3.686e-02

5 Cost and health insurance (Q14, Q19, Q21)

5.1 Every vs. some

5.1.1 Q14

se_demo_belief_cost <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q14,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_cost)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q14, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.58212    0.59429   0.980  0.32750
## ppagecat25-34                        0.13820    0.31759   0.435  0.66353
## ppagecat35-44                        0.42166    0.30581   1.379  0.16819
## ppagecat45-54                        0.54191    0.29888   1.813  0.07004
## ppagecat55-64                        1.32789    0.28523   4.655 3.56e-06
## ppagecat65-74                        1.56145    0.31986   4.882 1.18e-06
## ppagecat75+                          2.42238    0.44925   5.392 8.27e-08
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.49773    0.33130   1.502  0.13325
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.26234    0.31912  -0.822  0.41118
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.22501    0.33125   0.679  0.49710
## income$10k to $25k                   0.42829    0.49943   0.858  0.39129
## income$25k to $50k                   0.53901    0.48931   1.102  0.27085
## income$50k to $75k                   0.65987    0.48832   1.351  0.17683
## income$75k to $100k                  0.52940    0.49617   1.067  0.28618
## income$100k to $150k                 0.58769    0.49541   1.186  0.23573
## incomeover $150k                     1.09529    0.50959   2.149  0.03179
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.04654    0.22535   0.207  0.83640
## PPREG4South                          0.16207    0.19846   0.817  0.41429
## PPREG4West                          -0.23730    0.20856  -1.138  0.25543
## workemployed                        -0.19839    0.17071  -1.162  0.24541
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.25412    0.20318  -6.173 8.97e-10
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.32438    0.23686  -5.592 2.74e-08
## Q20Not effective                    -2.33497    0.56184  -4.156 3.45e-05
## Q20Don_t know                       -1.89508    0.41441  -4.573 5.27e-06
## Q14Less than $30                    -0.84095    0.18543  -4.535 6.29e-06
## Q14$30 to $60                       -1.06938    0.31752  -3.368  0.00078
## Q14More than $60                    13.57957    0.79642  17.051  < 2e-16
## Q14Don_t know                       -1.40823    0.30752  -4.579 5.11e-06
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                       .  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                    *  
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q14Less than $30                    ***
## Q14$30 to $60                       ***
## Q14More than $60                    ***
## Q14Don_t know                       ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9593007)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 13
## 
##                                   term        or sig or_std_err   or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 1.790e+00          1.812 -1.761e+00
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 1.148e+00          1.374 -1.544e+00
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 1.524e+00          1.358 -1.137e+00
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 1.719e+00   .      1.348 -9.235e-01
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 3.773e+00 ***      1.330  1.166e+00
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 4.766e+00 ***      1.377  2.067e+00
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 1.127e+01 ***      1.567  8.201e+00
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 1.645e+00          1.393 -1.085e+00
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 7.692e-01          1.376 -1.928e+00
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.252e+00          1.393 -1.477e+00
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 1.535e+00          1.648 -1.695e+00
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.714e+00          1.631 -1.483e+00
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.935e+00          1.630 -1.259e+00
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.698e+00          1.642 -1.521e+00
## 15                income$100k to $150k 1.800e+00          1.641 -1.417e+00
## 16                    incomeover $150k 2.990e+00   *      1.665 -2.726e-01
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 1.048e+00          1.253 -1.408e+00
## 18                         PPREG4South 1.176e+00          1.220 -1.214e+00
## 19                          PPREG4West 7.888e-01          1.232 -1.626e+00
## 20                        workemployed 8.201e-01          1.186 -1.505e+00
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective 2.853e-01 ***      1.225 -2.116e+00
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season 2.660e-01 ***      1.267 -2.218e+00
## 23                    Q20Not effective 9.681e-02 ***      1.754 -3.341e+00
## 24                       Q20Don_t know 1.503e-01 ***      1.513 -2.816e+00
## 25                    Q14Less than $30 4.313e-01 ***      1.204 -1.928e+00
## 26                       Q14$30 to $60 3.432e-01 ***      1.374 -2.349e+00
## 27                    Q14More than $60 7.898e+05 ***      2.218  7.898e+05
## 28                       Q14Don_t know 2.446e-01 ***      1.360 -2.421e+00
##     or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1  5.341e+00  0.58212    0.5943    0.9795 3.275e-01
## 2  3.841e+00  0.13820    0.3176    0.4351 6.635e-01
## 3  4.186e+00  0.42166    0.3058    1.3788 1.682e-01
## 4  4.362e+00  0.54191    0.2989    1.8132 7.004e-02
## 5  6.380e+00  1.32789    0.2852    4.6554 3.565e-06
## 6  7.465e+00  1.56145    0.3199    4.8817 1.182e-06
## 7  1.434e+01  2.42238    0.4493    5.3920 8.269e-08
## 8  4.375e+00  0.49773    0.3313    1.5024 1.332e-01
## 9  3.466e+00 -0.26234    0.3191   -0.8221 4.112e-01
## 10 3.982e+00  0.22501    0.3313    0.6793 4.971e-01
## 11 4.764e+00  0.42829    0.4994    0.8576 3.913e-01
## 12 4.911e+00  0.53901    0.4893    1.1016 2.709e-01
## 13 5.129e+00  0.65987    0.4883    1.3513 1.768e-01
## 14 4.917e+00  0.52940    0.4962    1.0670 2.862e-01
## 15 5.017e+00  0.58769    0.4954    1.1863 2.357e-01
## 16 6.253e+00  1.09529    0.5096    2.1494 3.179e-02
## 17 3.503e+00  0.04654    0.2253    0.2065 8.364e-01
## 18 3.566e+00  0.16207    0.1985    0.8166 4.143e-01
## 19 3.203e+00 -0.23730    0.2086   -1.1378 2.554e-01
## 20 3.145e+00 -0.19839    0.1707   -1.1621 2.454e-01
## 21 2.687e+00 -1.25412    0.2032   -6.1725 8.968e-10
## 22 2.750e+00 -1.32438    0.2369   -5.5915 2.741e-08
## 23 3.534e+00 -2.33497    0.5618   -4.1559 3.452e-05
## 24 3.117e+00 -1.89508    0.4144   -4.5729 5.269e-06
## 25 2.791e+00 -0.84095    0.1854   -4.5351 6.289e-06
## 26 3.036e+00 -1.06938    0.3175   -3.3679 7.796e-04
## 27 7.898e+05 13.57957    0.7964   17.0507 5.582e-59
## 28 2.910e+00 -1.40823    0.3075   -4.5793 5.113e-06

5.1.2 Q19

se_demo_belief_cost <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q19,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_cost)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q19, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.60422    0.58587   1.031   0.3026
## ppagecat25-34                        0.24922    0.31179   0.799   0.4243
## ppagecat35-44                        0.51422    0.29416   1.748   0.0807
## ppagecat45-54                        0.68622    0.28714   2.390   0.0170
## ppagecat55-64                        1.43484    0.27332   5.250 1.78e-07
## ppagecat65-74                        1.65941    0.30537   5.434 6.57e-08
## ppagecat75+                          2.55477    0.45293   5.641 2.08e-08
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.27425    0.32610   0.841   0.4005
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.41839    0.31428  -1.331   0.1833
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher -0.03315    0.32542  -0.102   0.9189
## income$10k to $25k                   0.28871    0.50722   0.569   0.5693
## income$25k to $50k                   0.34480    0.49921   0.691   0.4899
## income$50k to $75k                   0.47452    0.49609   0.957   0.3390
## income$75k to $100k                  0.27899    0.50358   0.554   0.5797
## income$100k to $150k                 0.45767    0.50251   0.911   0.3626
## incomeover $150k                     0.78275    0.51349   1.524   0.1277
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.04329    0.22239   0.195   0.8457
## PPREG4South                          0.21409    0.19601   1.092   0.2749
## PPREG4West                          -0.22413    0.20213  -1.109   0.2677
## workemployed                        -0.16151    0.16609  -0.972   0.3310
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.29355    0.20206  -6.402 2.14e-10
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.34003    0.23648  -5.667 1.79e-08
## Q20Not effective                    -2.28828    0.57688  -3.967 7.69e-05
## Q20Don_t know                       -2.18179    0.37790  -5.773 9.71e-09
## Q19No                               -0.92399    0.39634  -2.331   0.0199
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                       .  
## ppagecat45-54                       *  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q19No                               *  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9861006)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept)  1.8298          1.797  -1.6914
## 2                        ppagecat25-34  1.2830          1.366  -1.3941
## 3                        ppagecat35-44  1.6723   .      1.342  -0.9580
## 4                        ppagecat45-54  1.9862   *      1.333  -0.6257
## 5                        ppagecat55-64  4.1990 ***      1.314   1.6229
## 6                        ppagecat65-74  5.2562 ***      1.357   2.5963
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 12.8683 ***      1.573   9.7854
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school  1.3155          1.386  -1.4001
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college  0.6581          1.369  -2.0257
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.9674          1.385  -1.7465
## 11                  income$10k to $25k  1.3347          1.661  -1.9202
## 12                  income$25k to $50k  1.4117          1.647  -1.8172
## 13                  income$50k to $75k  1.6072          1.642  -1.6116
## 14                 income$75k to $100k  1.3218          1.655  -1.9213
## 15                income$100k to $150k  1.5804          1.653  -1.6592
## 16                    incomeover $150k  2.1875          1.671  -1.0879
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast  1.0442          1.249  -1.4039
## 18                         PPREG4South  1.2387          1.217  -1.1457
## 19                          PPREG4West  0.7992          1.224  -1.5998
## 20                        workemployed  0.8509          1.181  -1.4633
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective  0.2743 ***      1.224  -2.1246
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season  0.2618 ***      1.267  -2.2210
## 23                    Q20Not effective  0.1014 ***      1.780  -3.3883
## 24                       Q20Don_t know  0.1128 ***      1.459  -2.7472
## 25                               Q19No  0.3969   *      1.486  -2.5164
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     5.351  0.60422    0.5859    1.0313 3.026e-01
## 2     3.960  0.24922    0.3118    0.7993 4.243e-01
## 3     4.303  0.51422    0.2942    1.7481 8.069e-02
## 4     4.598  0.68622    0.2871    2.3899 1.700e-02
## 5     6.775  1.43484    0.2733    5.2496 1.779e-07
## 6     7.916  1.65941    0.3054    5.4341 6.569e-08
## 7    15.951  2.55477    0.4529    5.6406 2.078e-08
## 8     4.031  0.27425    0.3261    0.8410 4.005e-01
## 9     3.342 -0.41839    0.3143   -1.3313 1.833e-01
## 10    3.681 -0.03315    0.3254   -0.1019 9.189e-01
## 11    4.590  0.28871    0.5072    0.5692 5.693e-01
## 12    4.641  0.34480    0.4992    0.6907 4.899e-01
## 13    4.826  0.47452    0.4961    0.9565 3.390e-01
## 14    4.565  0.27899    0.5036    0.5540 5.797e-01
## 15    4.820  0.45767    0.5025    0.9108 3.626e-01
## 16    5.463  0.78275    0.5135    1.5244 1.277e-01
## 17    3.492  0.04329    0.2224    0.1947 8.457e-01
## 18    3.623  0.21409    0.1960    1.0922 2.749e-01
## 19    3.198 -0.22413    0.2021   -1.1088 2.677e-01
## 20    3.165 -0.16151    0.1661   -0.9724 3.310e-01
## 21    2.673 -1.29355    0.2021   -6.4017 2.142e-10
## 22    2.745 -1.34003    0.2365   -5.6666 1.792e-08
## 23    3.591 -2.28828    0.5769   -3.9666 7.687e-05
## 24    2.973 -2.18179    0.3779   -5.7734 9.707e-09
## 25    3.310 -0.92399    0.3963   -2.3313 1.989e-02

5.1.3 Q21

se_demo_belief_cost <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q21,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_cost)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q21, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                           Estimate Std. Error t value
## (Intercept)                                0.48435    0.59319   0.817
## ppagecat25-34                              0.17537    0.32544   0.539
## ppagecat35-44                              0.39490    0.30561   1.292
## ppagecat45-54                              0.72047    0.30050   2.398
## ppagecat55-64                              1.33482    0.29016   4.600
## ppagecat65-74                              1.52607    0.32190   4.741
## ppagecat75+                                2.23826    0.46012   4.865
## PPEDUCATHigh school                        0.14956    0.35064   0.427
## PPEDUCATSome college                      -0.48562    0.34319  -1.415
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher       -0.05857    0.35303  -0.166
## income$10k to $25k                         0.75933    0.50689   1.498
## income$25k to $50k                         0.87149    0.49126   1.774
## income$50k to $75k                         0.94853    0.49090   1.932
## income$75k to $100k                        0.75445    0.49726   1.517
## income$100k to $150k                       0.89087    0.49667   1.794
## incomeover $150k                           1.28071    0.50836   2.519
## PPREG4Northeast                            0.04272    0.22919   0.186
## PPREG4South                                0.14465    0.20120   0.719
## PPREG4West                                -0.26328    0.20958  -1.256
## workemployed                              -0.19688    0.17172  -1.147
## Q20Somewhat effective                     -1.26417    0.20768  -6.087
## Q20It varies from season to season        -1.35065    0.23889  -5.654
## Q20Not effective                          -2.14665    0.65254  -3.290
## Q20Don_t know                             -1.89025    0.41644  -4.539
## Q21Yes, but only part of the cost is paid -0.75444    0.24429  -3.088
## Q21No                                     -0.25206    0.52935  -0.476
## Q21Don_t know                             -0.59791    0.20952  -2.854
##                                           Pr(>|t|)    
## (Intercept)                                0.41436    
## ppagecat25-34                              0.59007    
## ppagecat35-44                              0.19654    
## ppagecat45-54                              0.01665 *  
## ppagecat55-64                             4.65e-06 ***
## ppagecat65-74                             2.37e-06 ***
## ppagecat75+                               1.29e-06 ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                        0.66979    
## PPEDUCATSome college                       0.15731    
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher        0.86825    
## income$10k to $25k                         0.13438    
## income$25k to $50k                         0.07631 .  
## income$50k to $75k                         0.05356 .  
## income$75k to $100k                        0.12947    
## income$100k to $150k                       0.07310 .  
## incomeover $150k                           0.01188 *  
## PPREG4Northeast                            0.85218    
## PPREG4South                                0.47230    
## PPREG4West                                 0.20928    
## workemployed                               0.25181    
## Q20Somewhat effective                     1.53e-09 ***
## Q20It varies from season to season        1.94e-08 ***
## Q20Not effective                           0.00103 ** 
## Q20Don_t know                             6.19e-06 ***
## Q21Yes, but only part of the cost is paid  0.00206 ** 
## Q21No                                      0.63403    
## Q21Don_t know                              0.00439 ** 
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9785475)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 5
## 
##                                         term     or sig or_std_err
## 1                                (Intercept) 1.6231          1.810
## 2                              ppagecat25-34 1.1917          1.385
## 3                              ppagecat35-44 1.4842          1.357
## 4                              ppagecat45-54 2.0554   *      1.351
## 5                              ppagecat55-64 3.7993 ***      1.337
## 6                              ppagecat65-74 4.6001 ***      1.380
## 7                                ppagecat75+ 9.3770 ***      1.584
## 8                        PPEDUCATHigh school 1.1613          1.420
## 9                       PPEDUCATSome college 0.6153          1.409
## 10       PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 0.9431          1.423
## 11                        income$10k to $25k 2.1368          1.660
## 12                        income$25k to $50k 2.3905   .      1.634
## 13                        income$50k to $75k 2.5819   .      1.634
## 14                       income$75k to $100k 2.1264          1.644
## 15                      income$100k to $150k 2.4373   .      1.643
## 16                          incomeover $150k 3.5992   *      1.663
## 17                           PPREG4Northeast 1.0436          1.258
## 18                               PPREG4South 1.1556          1.223
## 19                                PPREG4West 0.7685          1.233
## 20                              workemployed 0.8213          1.187
## 21                     Q20Somewhat effective 0.2825 ***      1.231
## 22        Q20It varies from season to season 0.2591 ***      1.270
## 23                          Q20Not effective 0.1169  **      1.920
## 24                             Q20Don_t know 0.1510 ***      1.517
## 25 Q21Yes, but only part of the cost is paid 0.4703  **      1.277
## 26                                     Q21No 0.7772          1.698
## 27                             Q21Don_t know 0.5500  **      1.233
##    or_lower or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1   -1.9240    5.170  0.48435    0.5932    0.8165 4.144e-01
## 2   -1.5222    3.906  0.17537    0.3254    0.5389 5.901e-01
## 3   -1.1764    4.145  0.39490    0.3056    1.2922 1.965e-01
## 4   -0.5916    4.702  0.72047    0.3005    2.3976 1.665e-02
## 5    1.1795    6.419  1.33482    0.2902    4.6003 4.646e-06
## 6    1.8958    7.304  1.52607    0.3219    4.7409 2.371e-06
## 7    6.2718   12.482  2.23826    0.4601    4.8645 1.293e-06
## 8   -1.6218    3.944  0.14956    0.3506    0.4265 6.698e-01
## 9   -2.1472    3.378 -0.48562    0.3432   -1.4150 1.573e-01
## 10  -1.8467    3.733 -0.05857    0.3530   -0.1659 8.682e-01
## 11  -1.1170    5.391  0.75933    0.5069    1.4980 1.344e-01
## 12  -0.8129    5.594  0.87149    0.4913    1.7740 7.631e-02
## 13  -0.6203    5.784  0.94853    0.4909    1.9322 5.356e-02
## 14  -1.0962    5.349  0.75445    0.4973    1.5172 1.295e-01
## 15  -0.7835    5.658  0.89087    0.4967    1.7937 7.310e-02
## 16   0.3406    6.858  1.28071    0.5084    2.5193 1.188e-02
## 17  -1.4212    3.509  0.04272    0.2292    0.1864 8.522e-01
## 18  -1.2412    3.552  0.14465    0.2012    0.7190 4.723e-01
## 19  -1.6485    3.186 -0.26328    0.2096   -1.2562 2.093e-01
## 20  -1.5059    3.148 -0.19688    0.1717   -1.1465 2.518e-01
## 21  -2.1299    2.695 -1.26417    0.2077   -6.0870 1.527e-09
## 22  -2.2298    2.748 -1.35065    0.2389   -5.6540 1.940e-08
## 23  -3.6471    3.881 -2.14665    0.6525   -3.2897 1.031e-03
## 24  -2.8214    3.123 -1.89025    0.4164   -4.5391 6.192e-06
## 25  -2.0321    2.973 -0.75444    0.2443   -3.0883 2.057e-03
## 26  -2.5505    4.105 -0.25206    0.5293   -0.4762 6.340e-01
## 27  -1.8669    2.967 -0.59791    0.2095   -2.8538 4.391e-03

5.1.4 Q14 + Q19

se_demo_belief_cost <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q14 + Q19,
       design = svy_some_every,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(se_demo_belief_cost)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q14 + Q19, design = svy_some_every, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = some_every[!is.na(some_every$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                          0.71547    0.63011   1.135 0.256391
## ppagecat25-34                        0.16584    0.32165   0.516 0.606232
## ppagecat35-44                        0.43247    0.30705   1.408 0.159243
## ppagecat45-54                        0.58484    0.29808   1.962 0.049976
## ppagecat55-64                        1.34657    0.28560   4.715 2.68e-06
## ppagecat65-74                        1.55488    0.32090   4.845 1.42e-06
## ppagecat75+                          2.41805    0.45754   5.285 1.47e-07
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.33933    0.34500   0.984 0.325508
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.41604    0.33113  -1.256 0.209192
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.05930    0.34143   0.174 0.862137
## income$10k to $25k                   0.47042    0.51465   0.914 0.360855
## income$25k to $50k                   0.56634    0.50483   1.122 0.262143
## income$50k to $75k                   0.67976    0.50369   1.350 0.177390
## income$75k to $100k                  0.54403    0.51092   1.065 0.287162
## income$100k to $150k                 0.61553    0.51055   1.206 0.228181
## incomeover $150k                     1.09154    0.52466   2.080 0.037679
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.04867    0.22589   0.215 0.829454
## PPREG4South                          0.19088    0.19972   0.956 0.339381
## PPREG4West                          -0.20985    0.20943  -1.002 0.316532
## workemployed                        -0.20609    0.17100  -1.205 0.228354
## Q20Somewhat effective               -1.27513    0.20603  -6.189 8.11e-10
## Q20It varies from season to season  -1.34690    0.23862  -5.645 2.03e-08
## Q20Not effective                    -2.24024    0.57432  -3.901 0.000101
## Q20Don_t know                       -1.94089    0.41874  -4.635 3.93e-06
## Q14Less than $30                    -0.81653    0.18402  -4.437 9.89e-06
## Q14$30 to $60                       -0.98585    0.32493  -3.034 0.002461
## Q14More than $60                    12.95651    0.85760  15.108  < 2e-16
## Q14Don_t know                       -1.38986    0.30885  -4.500 7.40e-06
## Q19No                               -0.60828    0.40283  -1.510 0.131278
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                       *  
## ppagecat55-64                       ***
## ppagecat65-74                       ***
## ppagecat75+                         ***
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                    *  
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                             
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               ***
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q14Less than $30                    ***
## Q14$30 to $60                       ** 
## Q14More than $60                    ***
## Q14Don_t know                       ***
## Q19No                                  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 0.9602307)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 13
## 
##                                   term        or sig or_std_err   or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept) 2.045e+00          1.878 -1.635e+00
## 2                        ppagecat25-34 1.180e+00          1.379 -1.523e+00
## 3                        ppagecat35-44 1.541e+00          1.359 -1.123e+00
## 4                        ppagecat45-54 1.795e+00   *      1.347 -8.460e-01
## 5                        ppagecat55-64 3.844e+00 ***      1.331  1.236e+00
## 6                        ppagecat65-74 4.735e+00 ***      1.378  2.033e+00
## 7                          ppagecat75+ 1.122e+01 ***      1.580  8.127e+00
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school 1.404e+00          1.412 -1.363e+00
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college 6.597e-01          1.393 -2.070e+00
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher 1.061e+00          1.407 -1.697e+00
## 11                  income$10k to $25k 1.601e+00          1.673 -1.679e+00
## 12                  income$25k to $50k 1.762e+00          1.657 -1.485e+00
## 13                  income$50k to $75k 1.973e+00          1.655 -1.270e+00
## 14                 income$75k to $100k 1.723e+00          1.667 -1.544e+00
## 15                income$100k to $150k 1.851e+00          1.666 -1.415e+00
## 16                    incomeover $150k 2.979e+00   *      1.690 -3.333e-01
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast 1.050e+00          1.253 -1.407e+00
## 18                         PPREG4South 1.210e+00          1.221 -1.183e+00
## 19                          PPREG4West 8.107e-01          1.233 -1.606e+00
## 20                        workemployed 8.138e-01          1.186 -1.512e+00
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective 2.794e-01 ***      1.229 -2.129e+00
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season 2.600e-01 ***      1.269 -2.228e+00
## 23                    Q20Not effective 1.064e-01 ***      1.776 -3.374e+00
## 24                       Q20Don_t know 1.436e-01 ***      1.520 -2.836e+00
## 25                    Q14Less than $30 4.420e-01 ***      1.202 -1.914e+00
## 26                       Q14$30 to $60 3.731e-01  **      1.384 -2.339e+00
## 27                    Q14More than $60 4.236e+05 ***      2.358  4.236e+05
## 28                       Q14Don_t know 2.491e-01 ***      1.362 -2.420e+00
## 29                               Q19No 5.443e-01          1.496 -2.388e+00
##     or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1  5.726e+00  0.71547    0.6301    1.1355 2.564e-01
## 2  3.884e+00  0.16584    0.3216    0.5156 6.062e-01
## 3  4.206e+00  0.43247    0.3071    1.4084 1.592e-01
## 4  4.435e+00  0.58484    0.2981    1.9620 4.998e-02
## 5  6.452e+00  1.34657    0.2856    4.7149 2.680e-06
## 6  7.436e+00  1.55488    0.3209    4.8454 1.416e-06
## 7  1.432e+01  2.41805    0.4575    5.2849 1.475e-07
## 8  4.172e+00  0.33933    0.3450    0.9836 3.255e-01
## 9  3.389e+00 -0.41604    0.3311   -1.2564 2.092e-01
## 10 3.819e+00  0.05930    0.3414    0.1737 8.621e-01
## 11 4.880e+00  0.47042    0.5147    0.9141 3.609e-01
## 12 5.009e+00  0.56634    0.5048    1.1218 2.621e-01
## 13 5.217e+00  0.67976    0.5037    1.3496 1.774e-01
## 14 4.990e+00  0.54403    0.5109    1.0648 2.872e-01
## 15 5.116e+00  0.61553    0.5105    1.2056 2.282e-01
## 16 6.291e+00  1.09154    0.5247    2.0805 3.768e-02
## 17 3.507e+00  0.04867    0.2259    0.2154 8.295e-01
## 18 3.604e+00  0.19088    0.1997    0.9557 3.394e-01
## 19 3.227e+00 -0.20985    0.2094   -1.0020 3.165e-01
## 20 3.139e+00 -0.20609    0.1710   -1.2052 2.284e-01
## 21 2.688e+00 -1.27513    0.2060   -6.1890 8.112e-10
## 22 2.748e+00 -1.34690    0.2386   -5.6446 2.032e-08
## 23 3.587e+00 -2.24024    0.5743   -3.9007 1.009e-04
## 24 3.123e+00 -1.94089    0.4187   -4.6351 3.928e-06
## 25 2.798e+00 -0.81653    0.1840   -4.4371 9.892e-06
## 26 3.086e+00 -0.98585    0.3249   -3.0341 2.461e-03
## 27 4.236e+05 12.95651    0.8576   15.1078 1.287e-47
## 28 2.918e+00 -1.38986    0.3088   -4.5001 7.402e-06
## 29 3.477e+00 -0.60828    0.4028   -1.5100 1.313e-01

5.1.5 AIC/BIC

#AIC(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief, ne_demo_belief_social, ne_demo_belief_cost)
#AIC(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief, ns_demo_belief_social, ns_demo_belief_cost)
#AIC(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief, nse_demo_belief_social, nse_demo_belief_cost)
#BIC(ne_demo, ne_demo_belief, ne_demo_belief_cost, maximal = ne_demo_belief_cost)
#BIC(ns_demo, ns_demo_belief, ns_demo_belief_cost, maximal = ns_demo_belief_cost)
#BIC(nse_demo, nse_demo_belief, nse_demo_belief_cost, maximal = nse_demo_belief_cost)

6 Barriers: Reasons to not get a vaccine

library(forcats)
df <- readRDS('./data/subset_recode.RDS')
never_some_flipped <- df[df$Q13 %in% c('Yes, some years', 'No, never'), ]
never_some_flipped$Q13 <- droplevels(never_some$Q13)
never_some_flipped$Q13 <- fct_relevel(never_some$Q13, 'Yes, some years', after = 0L)
table(never_some_flipped$Q13, useNA = 'always')
## 
## Yes, some years       No, never            <NA> 
##             423             819               0
levels(never_some_flipped$Q13)
## [1] "Yes, some years" "No, never"
testthat::expect_equal(levels(never_some_flipped$Q13)[1], "Yes, some years")
table(never_some_flipped$Q13, never_some_flipped$Q18_1, useNA = 'always')
##                  
##                   Yes  No <NA>
##   Yes, some years  61 362    0
##   No, never        49 770    0
##   <NA>              0   0    0
make_no_ref <- function(dat) {
  dat <- fct_relevel(dat, "No", after = 0L)
  testthat::expect_equal(levels(dat)[1], "No")
  return(dat)
}
never_some_flipped$Q18_1 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_1, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_2 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_2, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_3 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_3, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_4 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_4, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_5 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_5, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_6 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_6, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_7 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_7, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_8 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_8, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_9 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_9, make_no_ref)
never_some_flipped$Q18_10 <- sapply(never_some_flipped$Q18_10, make_no_ref)

svy_never_some_flipped <- svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_some_flipped[!is.na(never_some_flipped$weight), ])
lapply(never_some_flipped[, 37:46], table)
## $Q18_1
## 
##   No  Yes 
## 1132  110 
## 
## $Q18_2
## 
##  No Yes 
## 903 339 
## 
## $Q18_3
## 
##  No Yes 
## 964 278 
## 
## $Q18_4
## 
##   No  Yes 
## 1199   43 
## 
## $Q18_5
## 
##  No Yes 
## 958 284 
## 
## $Q18_6
## 
##   No  Yes 
## 1184   58 
## 
## $Q18_7
## 
##  No Yes 
## 976 266 
## 
## $Q18_8
## 
##  No Yes 
## 878 364 
## 
## $Q18_9
## 
##   No  Yes 
## 1216   26 
## 
## $Q18_10
## 
##   No  Yes 
## 1064  178
table(df$Q18_1, df$Q13)
##      
##       Yes, every year Yes, some years No, never
##   Yes               0              61        49
##   No                0             362       770

6.1 Never vs. some

6.1.1 Q18: 1-9

  • p-value < 0.05 for Q18: 1, 2, 3, 5, 8
ns_demo_belief_barriers <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q18_1 + Q18_2 + Q18_3 + Q18_4 + Q18_5 + Q18_6 + Q18_7 + Q18_8 + Q18_9,
       design = svy_never_some_flipped,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(ns_demo_belief_barriers)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q18_1 + Q18_2 + Q18_3 + Q18_4 + Q18_5 + Q18_6 + 
##     Q18_7 + Q18_8 + Q18_9, design = svy_never_some_flipped, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_some_flipped[!is.na(never_some_flipped$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                         -0.11943    0.49337  -0.242 0.808762
## ppagecat25-34                       -0.06752    0.28025  -0.241 0.809648
## ppagecat35-44                        0.19226    0.26866   0.716 0.474357
## ppagecat45-54                        0.11810    0.25388   0.465 0.641882
## ppagecat55-64                        0.38623    0.26548   1.455 0.145981
## ppagecat65-74                       -0.03875    0.31132  -0.124 0.900955
## ppagecat75+                          0.42025    0.50862   0.826 0.408825
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.40185    0.29800   1.349 0.177744
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.61032    0.29650  -2.058 0.039762
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher -0.51711    0.29814  -1.734 0.083092
## income$10k to $25k                   0.19170    0.43985   0.436 0.663048
## income$25k to $50k                  -0.21758    0.38326  -0.568 0.570328
## income$50k to $75k                  -0.20197    0.39379  -0.513 0.608123
## income$75k to $100k                 -0.40893    0.39720  -1.030 0.303442
## income$100k to $150k                -0.40049    0.39353  -1.018 0.309032
## incomeover $150k                    -0.44416    0.42933  -1.035 0.301094
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.07685    0.22517   0.341 0.732954
## PPREG4South                          0.26925    0.20194   1.333 0.182682
## PPREG4West                          -0.48288    0.21626  -2.233 0.025738
## workemployed                         0.26944    0.18246   1.477 0.140007
## Q20Somewhat effective                0.67578    0.28365   2.382 0.017352
## Q20It varies from season to season   1.44612    0.31190   4.636 3.93e-06
## Q20Not effective                     2.35138    0.41027   5.731 1.26e-08
## Q20Don_t know                        2.36151    0.34568   6.832 1.33e-11
## Q18_1Yes                            -0.96454    0.25615  -3.766 0.000174
## Q18_2Yes                            -0.87339    0.17417  -5.015 6.11e-07
## Q18_3Yes                             0.70333    0.18525   3.797 0.000154
## Q18_4Yes                             0.41153    0.50115   0.821 0.411708
## Q18_5Yes                             0.72765    0.19790   3.677 0.000246
## Q18_6Yes                            -0.54682    0.36191  -1.511 0.131073
## Q18_7Yes                             0.34355    0.18823   1.825 0.068231
## Q18_8Yes                            -0.65987    0.15379  -4.291 1.92e-05
## Q18_9Yes                            -0.45983    0.42004  -1.095 0.273854
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                          
## ppagecat55-64                          
## ppagecat65-74                          
## ppagecat75+                            
## PPEDUCATHigh school                    
## PPEDUCATSome college                *  
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher .  
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                          *  
## workemployed                           
## Q20Somewhat effective               *  
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q18_1Yes                            ***
## Q18_2Yes                            ***
## Q18_3Yes                            ***
## Q18_4Yes                               
## Q18_5Yes                            ***
## Q18_6Yes                               
## Q18_7Yes                            .  
## Q18_8Yes                            ***
## Q18_9Yes                               
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.007906)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept)  0.8874          1.638  -2.3227
## 2                        ppagecat25-34  0.9347          1.323  -1.6593
## 3                        ppagecat35-44  1.2120          1.308  -1.3521
## 4                        ppagecat45-54  1.1254          1.289  -1.4011
## 5                        ppagecat55-64  1.4714          1.304  -1.0845
## 6                        ppagecat65-74  0.9620          1.365  -1.7139
## 7                          ppagecat75+  1.5223          1.663  -1.7371
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school  1.4946          1.347  -1.1458
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college  0.5432   *      1.345  -2.0933
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.5962   .      1.347  -2.0446
## 11                  income$10k to $25k  1.2113          1.552  -1.8316
## 12                  income$25k to $50k  0.8045          1.467  -2.0710
## 13                  income$50k to $75k  0.8171          1.483  -2.0887
## 14                 income$75k to $100k  0.6644          1.488  -2.2514
## 15                income$100k to $150k  0.6700          1.482  -2.2351
## 16                    incomeover $150k  0.6414          1.536  -2.3697
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast  1.0799          1.253  -1.3751
## 18                         PPREG4South  1.3090          1.224  -1.0896
## 19                          PPREG4West  0.6170   *      1.241  -1.8162
## 20                        workemployed  1.3092          1.200  -1.0431
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective  1.9656   *      1.328  -0.6372
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season  4.2466 ***      1.366   1.5692
## 23                    Q20Not effective 10.5001 ***      1.507   7.5459
## 24                       Q20Don_t know 10.6070 ***      1.413   7.8376
## 25                            Q18_1Yes  0.3812 ***      1.292  -2.1510
## 26                            Q18_2Yes  0.4175 ***      1.190  -1.9154
## 27                            Q18_3Yes  2.0205 ***      1.204  -0.3384
## 28                            Q18_4Yes  1.5091          1.651  -1.7261
## 29                            Q18_5Yes  2.0702 ***      1.219  -0.3187
## 30                            Q18_6Yes  0.5788          1.436  -2.2359
## 31                            Q18_7Yes  1.4099   .      1.207  -0.9560
## 32                            Q18_8Yes  0.5169 ***      1.166  -1.7689
## 33                            Q18_9Yes  0.6314          1.522  -2.3518
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     4.098 -0.11943    0.4934   -0.2421 8.088e-01
## 2     3.529 -0.06752    0.2803   -0.2409 8.096e-01
## 3     3.776  0.19226    0.2687    0.7156 4.744e-01
## 4     3.652  0.11810    0.2539    0.4652 6.419e-01
## 5     4.027  0.38623    0.2655    1.4548 1.460e-01
## 6     3.638 -0.03875    0.3113   -0.1245 9.010e-01
## 7     4.782  0.42025    0.5086    0.8263 4.088e-01
## 8     4.135  0.40185    0.2980    1.3485 1.777e-01
## 9     3.180 -0.61032    0.2965   -2.0584 3.976e-02
## 10    3.237 -0.51711    0.2981   -1.7345 8.309e-02
## 11    4.254  0.19170    0.4399    0.4358 6.630e-01
## 12    3.680 -0.21758    0.3833   -0.5677 5.703e-01
## 13    3.723 -0.20197    0.3938   -0.5129 6.081e-01
## 14    3.580 -0.40893    0.3972   -1.0295 3.034e-01
## 15    3.575 -0.40049    0.3935   -1.0177 3.090e-01
## 16    3.652 -0.44416    0.4293   -1.0345 3.011e-01
## 17    3.535  0.07685    0.2252    0.3413 7.330e-01
## 18    3.708  0.26925    0.2019    1.3333 1.827e-01
## 19    3.050 -0.48288    0.2163   -2.2329 2.574e-02
## 20    3.662  0.26944    0.1825    1.4767 1.400e-01
## 21    4.568  0.67578    0.2836    2.3825 1.735e-02
## 22    6.924  1.44612    0.3119    4.6364 3.931e-06
## 23   13.454  2.35138    0.4103    5.7313 1.258e-08
## 24   13.376  2.36151    0.3457    6.8316 1.329e-11
## 25    2.913 -0.96454    0.2561   -3.7656 1.742e-04
## 26    2.750 -0.87339    0.1742   -5.0147 6.106e-07
## 27    4.379  0.70333    0.1852    3.7967 1.539e-04
## 28    4.744  0.41153    0.5012    0.8212 4.117e-01
## 29    4.459  0.72765    0.1979    3.6770 2.464e-04
## 30    3.393 -0.54682    0.3619   -1.5109 1.311e-01
## 31    3.776  0.34355    0.1882    1.8251 6.823e-02
## 32    2.803 -0.65987    0.1538   -4.2909 1.922e-05
## 33    3.615 -0.45983    0.4200   -1.0947 2.739e-01
#ns_demo_belief_barriers <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q18_1 + Q18_2 + #Q18_3 + Q18_4 + Q18_5 + Q18_6 + Q18_7 + Q18_8 + Q18_9 + Q18_10 + PPEDUCAT*Q20,
#       design = svy_never_some_flipped,
#       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
#print_svy_mod(ns_demo_belief_barriers)

6.1.2 Q18 + Q19

ns_demo_belief_barriers <- svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + work + Q20 + Q18_1 + Q18_2 + Q18_3 + Q18_5 + Q18_7 + Q18_8 + Q19,
       design = svy_never_some_flipped,
       family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
print_svy_mod(ns_demo_belief_barriers)
## 
## Call:
## svyglm(formula = Q13 ~ ppagecat + PPEDUCAT + income + PPREG4 + 
##     work + Q20 + Q18_1 + Q18_2 + Q18_3 + Q18_5 + Q18_7 + Q18_8 + 
##     Q19, design = svy_never_some_flipped, family = quasibinomial(link = "logit"))
## 
## Survey design:
## svydesign(ids = ~1, weights = ~weight, data = never_some_flipped[!is.na(never_some_flipped$weight), 
##     ])
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                     Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                         -0.35805    0.48747  -0.735 0.462784
## ppagecat25-34                       -0.07992    0.28568  -0.280 0.779709
## ppagecat35-44                        0.18026    0.27106   0.665 0.506158
## ppagecat45-54                        0.08450    0.25410   0.333 0.739532
## ppagecat55-64                        0.33610    0.26344   1.276 0.202263
## ppagecat65-74                        0.03575    0.30929   0.116 0.907993
## ppagecat75+                          0.48101    0.50365   0.955 0.339746
## PPEDUCATHigh school                  0.52222    0.30779   1.697 0.090015
## PPEDUCATSome college                -0.44687    0.30797  -1.451 0.147040
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher -0.36520    0.31164  -1.172 0.241481
## income$10k to $25k                   0.21810    0.43240   0.504 0.614067
## income$25k to $50k                  -0.09471    0.37856  -0.250 0.802489
## income$50k to $75k                  -0.09986    0.39857  -0.251 0.802202
## income$75k to $100k                 -0.28458    0.39937  -0.713 0.476253
## income$100k to $150k                -0.27784    0.39312  -0.707 0.479857
## incomeover $150k                    -0.32393    0.42521  -0.762 0.446324
## PPREG4Northeast                      0.04862    0.22435   0.217 0.828482
## PPREG4South                          0.24102    0.20234   1.191 0.233821
## PPREG4West                          -0.48215    0.21433  -2.250 0.024657
## workemployed                         0.30055    0.18240   1.648 0.099662
## Q20Somewhat effective                0.62174    0.28218   2.203 0.027760
## Q20It varies from season to season   1.39990    0.30952   4.523 6.70e-06
## Q20Not effective                     2.33807    0.41687   5.609 2.53e-08
## Q20Don_t know                        2.19797    0.34005   6.464 1.48e-10
## Q18_1Yes                            -1.06830    0.25226  -4.235 2.46e-05
## Q18_2Yes                            -0.88746    0.17409  -5.098 3.99e-07
## Q18_3Yes                             0.66577    0.18713   3.558 0.000389
## Q18_5Yes                             0.68298    0.20141   3.391 0.000719
## Q18_7Yes                             0.39058    0.19251   2.029 0.042693
## Q18_8Yes                            -0.65330    0.15379  -4.248 2.32e-05
## Q19No                                0.71368    0.32102   2.223 0.026387
##                                        
## (Intercept)                            
## ppagecat25-34                          
## ppagecat35-44                          
## ppagecat45-54                          
## ppagecat55-64                          
## ppagecat65-74                          
## ppagecat75+                            
## PPEDUCATHigh school                 .  
## PPEDUCATSome college                   
## PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher    
## income$10k to $25k                     
## income$25k to $50k                     
## income$50k to $75k                     
## income$75k to $100k                    
## income$100k to $150k                   
## incomeover $150k                       
## PPREG4Northeast                        
## PPREG4South                            
## PPREG4West                          *  
## workemployed                        .  
## Q20Somewhat effective               *  
## Q20It varies from season to season  ***
## Q20Not effective                    ***
## Q20Don_t know                       ***
## Q18_1Yes                            ***
## Q18_2Yes                            ***
## Q18_3Yes                            ***
## Q18_5Yes                            ***
## Q18_7Yes                            *  
## Q18_8Yes                            ***
## Q19No                               *  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for quasibinomial family taken to be 1.015909)
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 4
## 
##                                   term      or sig or_std_err or_lower
## 1                          (Intercept)  0.6990          1.628  -2.4922
## 2                        ppagecat25-34  0.9232          1.331  -1.6849
## 3                        ppagecat35-44  1.1975          1.311  -1.3727
## 4                        ppagecat45-54  1.0882          1.289  -1.4388
## 5                        ppagecat55-64  1.3995          1.301  -1.1513
## 6                        ppagecat65-74  1.0364          1.362  -1.6340
## 7                          ppagecat75+  1.6177          1.655  -1.6256
## 8                  PPEDUCATHigh school  1.6858   .      1.360  -0.9806
## 9                 PPEDUCATSome college  0.6396          1.361  -2.0273
## 10 PPEDUCATBachelor_s degree or higher  0.6941          1.366  -1.9826
## 11                  income$10k to $25k  1.2437          1.541  -1.7765
## 12                  income$25k to $50k  0.9096          1.460  -1.9523
## 13                  income$50k to $75k  0.9050          1.490  -2.0148
## 14                 income$75k to $100k  0.7523          1.491  -2.1698
## 15                income$100k to $150k  0.7574          1.482  -2.1465
## 16                    incomeover $150k  0.7233          1.530  -2.2753
## 17                     PPREG4Northeast  1.0498          1.252  -1.4031
## 18                         PPREG4South  1.2725          1.224  -1.1270
## 19                          PPREG4West  0.6175   *      1.239  -1.8110
## 20                        workemployed  1.3506   .      1.200  -1.0016
## 21               Q20Somewhat effective  1.8622   *      1.326  -0.7368
## 22  Q20It varies from season to season  4.0548 ***      1.363   1.3838
## 23                    Q20Not effective 10.3612 ***      1.517   7.3875
## 24                       Q20Don_t know  9.0067 ***      1.405   6.2528
## 25                            Q18_1Yes  0.3436 ***      1.287  -2.1788
## 26                            Q18_2Yes  0.4117 ***      1.190  -1.9210
## 27                            Q18_3Yes  1.9460 ***      1.206  -0.4174
## 28                            Q18_5Yes  1.9798 ***      1.223  -0.4176
## 29                            Q18_7Yes  1.4778   *      1.212  -0.8983
## 30                            Q18_8Yes  0.5203 ***      1.166  -1.7655
## 31                               Q19No  2.0415   *      1.379  -0.6604
##    or_upper estimate std.error statistic   p.value
## 1     3.890 -0.35805    0.4875   -0.7345 4.628e-01
## 2     3.531 -0.07992    0.2857   -0.2798 7.797e-01
## 3     3.768  0.18026    0.2711    0.6650 5.062e-01
## 4     3.615  0.08450    0.2541    0.3325 7.395e-01
## 5     3.950  0.33610    0.2634    1.2758 2.023e-01
## 6     3.707  0.03575    0.3093    0.1156 9.080e-01
## 7     4.861  0.48101    0.5036    0.9550 3.397e-01
## 8     4.352  0.52222    0.3078    1.6967 9.002e-02
## 9     3.307 -0.44687    0.3080   -1.4510 1.470e-01
## 10    3.371 -0.36520    0.3116   -1.1719 2.415e-01
## 11    4.264  0.21810    0.4324    0.5044 6.141e-01
## 12    3.772 -0.09471    0.3786   -0.2502 8.025e-01
## 13    3.825 -0.09986    0.3986   -0.2506 8.022e-01
## 14    3.674 -0.28458    0.3994   -0.7126 4.763e-01
## 15    3.661 -0.27784    0.3931   -0.7068 4.799e-01
## 16    3.722 -0.32393    0.4252   -0.7618 4.463e-01
## 17    3.503  0.04862    0.2244    0.2167 8.285e-01
## 18    3.672  0.24102    0.2023    1.1912 2.338e-01
## 19    3.046 -0.48215    0.2143   -2.2496 2.466e-02
## 20    3.703  0.30055    0.1824    1.6478 9.966e-02
## 21    4.461  0.62174    0.2822    2.2033 2.776e-02
## 22    6.726  1.39990    0.3095    4.5229 6.703e-06
## 23   13.335  2.33807    0.4169    5.6086 2.528e-08
## 24   11.761  2.19797    0.3401    6.4636 1.481e-10
## 25    2.866 -1.06830    0.2523   -4.2349 2.460e-05
## 26    2.744 -0.88746    0.1741   -5.0977 3.990e-07
## 27    4.309  0.66577    0.1871    3.5577 3.886e-04
## 28    4.377  0.68298    0.2014    3.3910 7.190e-04
## 29    3.854  0.39058    0.1925    2.0288 4.269e-02
## 30    2.806 -0.65330    0.1538   -4.2479 2.324e-05
## 31    4.743  0.71368    0.3210    2.2232 2.639e-02