9/11/2017

Course Syllabus (will discuss later)

What is Economic Geography?

  • ‘By "economic geography" I mean the "the location of production in space"; that is, that branch of economics that worries about where things happen in relation to one another.’

    • Krugman, P. 1992. Geography and Trade. MIT Press. pp 1.
  • Also known as (AKA)
    • Geographical Economics
    • Regional Science
    • Urban Economics

The issue: The spatial location

  • In classical economics the place of economic activity is quite irrelevant

  • The price of capital is also determined by supply and demand: the scarcer it is, the higher is the price

  • In developing countries there is less capital and more labor

    – thus the value of the capital is high . . .

    – if capital can flow freely it goes to developing countries . . .

    – as a result the country develops.

  • The growing supply of capital drives the prices down and when the country becomes developed the prices equalize . . .

  • In reality this is not the case…

    • Robert Lucas: Why doesn’t capital flow to Africa? AER.

We live in a Spiky World

Economic Geography (cont.)

  • Why economic activity does not diffuse across space still an important question…
  • Clear juxtapositions exist
    • Cross-Countries
    • Regions (North-South and East-West divides)
    • Urban vs. rural
    • Clusters

Objectives of this course

  1. Understand the importance of location/space/geography in explaining economic, social and political phenemona
  2. Understand the role, different types, and implications of place-based policies that attemp to improve welfare

An empirical Example: Applying EG Lens to Real Events

Question

  1. How important do you think economic geography is for explaining Trump’s victory in the US 2016 Presidential Election?

Predicted Voter Turnout

Actual Voter Turnout

Compare to 2012

Democrats concentrated in Coasts…

Democrats concentrated in Cities…

Welcome to the 'Great Divergence'

  • Economists define the Great Divergence as the growing divide between…

    1. the higher-skilled, higher-income, more educated workers of Blue America

    2. the lower-skilled, lower-income, less educated workers of Red America.

  • The election of Donald Trump exposed the polarization of America by class and geography.
    • Knowledge workers and manufacturing workers occupy different classes, AND different spaces and worlds.

  • Prior to 1980s
    • incomes of workers actually converged, both across skill groups and across regions of the country.
    • e.g. a rising-tide-lifts-all-boats kind of economy.
  • Since 1980s
    • loss of high-paying blue-collar jobs led to bifurcation of market into high-paid knowledge workers and low-paid service workers.
  • Geographic clustering amplified market segmentation
    • knowledge workers clustered into a select group of large cities and tech hubs.

End Outcome: America, and Americans, have split apart by class and geography.

Stude 1: Ganong and Shoag

Note: x-axes: the initial income per capita in a state. y-axes: annual income growth rate, or how much wages increased over time.

  • 1940-1960: steep line indicates convergence: The less a state earned initially, the faster it would grow.
  • 1990-2010: flat line shows income convergence broke down after 1990.

Study 2: Giannone

  • 1940-1980: steep line indicates wage convergence
  • 1980-2010: flat line highlights the more recent divergence of wages
  • Note the positioning of Boston, San Francisco, and New York

Summary of the 2 studies

  • Ganong and Shoag Study shows:
    • From 1880 to 1980, incomes across states converged at a rate of 1.8 percent per year.
    • From 1990 to 2010, convergence slowed to less than half that
  • Giannone study looks at wages
    • Wage convergence prior to 1980,
    • but divergence afterwards.
  • Both studies show how states have drifted apart in recent decades

Implications for US 2016 presidential outcome?

  • America’s division into blue and red states and cities is not just a result of political preferences and ideology, but of the sorting of its people into distinct separate classes and locations.

  • While Clinton won the popular vote (large populations in few clustered cities), but lost the electoral college.

  • Trump Won electoral college because majority of higher-skilled workers clustered in too few coastal cities/states, while too many disaffected working-class workers dispersed throughout the country.

No-College Whites fled to the GOP

No-College Whites fled to the GOP

Course Overview

How this class will work

  • There are no prerequesites for this class

  • Some basic economic knowledge is presumed, but will be reviewed
    • e.g. increasing returns to scale
  • Class attendance is expected

Course Structure

  • Two 50 minute lectures a week:

    • First 50 minutes: concepts, methods, examples
    • Last 50 minutes: Experiments, student presentations, quizzes
  • Experiments:
    • Students will participate in small in-class experiments to gain a deeper intuition and better connect abstract class concepts to real life.

Required Readings

  • No required textbook, but several are highly recommended:

    • The Web book of Regional Science Regional Research Institute. West Virginia University.
    • Brueckner, Lectures on Urban Economics
    • O ’Sullivan, A. Urban Economics
    • Barnes et al. (2012), Companion to Economic Geography
    • Baldwin, R. et al. (2007), Economic Geography and Public Policy (Advanced)

Policies

  • Excessive tardiness or absences will negatively affect your final grade.

  • Plagiarism is not allowed in any form.

  • Please do not use your cell phones or surf the web during class
    • During student presentations, all computers and cell phones should be turned off

Course Outline

  • The course is broken down into several parts:
    1. Introduction to Economic Geography and Urbanization (Weeks 1-4)
      • Why cities exist, what is pros/cons of urbanization
    2. Regional Inequality and Public Policy (Weeks 5-7)
      • Uneven development, geographical immobility, indirect place-based policies
    3. Clustering and Public Policies (Weeks 8-10)
      • Anatomy of a cluster, cluster mechanisms, and direct place-based policies
    4. Core Urban Laws and Theory (Weeks 11-15)
      • Laws of cities, spatial equilibriurm
    5. Student Presentations (Weeks 15-16)

Grading

Class participation (10%)

  • Participation grade is based on in-class attendance and participation in experiments

  • There will be approximately 4 experiments during the semester

Participation points are calculated as follows:

# of Experiments Participate 0 1 2 3 4
Points 0 1 4 7 10

Quizzes (10%)

  • 2 quizzes in the second half of term.
  • Will be based on class labs.
  • Dates and times will be announced in advance.
  • Purpose is to assess your understanding of various concepts that are central to the class.

Urban Snapshots Mini-Project (30%)

  • This mini-project requires students to explore Beijing
  • Create urban scenes by taking pictures of particular features of the city and juxtapose constrasting themes
  • e.g. visualize the good and bad of urbanization, e.g. luxury cars/hotels, tall skylines contrasted by congestion, polution, inequality, etc,
  • Reflect on your experience and give a short presentation to the class.

Final Cluster Map project (50%)

  • Write a fieldwork-led report that examines the anatomy of a local Beijing-based cluster.
  • Complete research experience; Students will be expected to:
    1. select a Beijing cluster and find out who the main actors are and how they interact with each other;
    2. interview a main actor in the cluster to help guide policy;
    3. provide a policy recommendation on how to better support your local cluster;
    4. write a report describing the anatomy of the cluster, your fieldwork experience, and any findings
  • Work in small groups to decide what cluster you want to focus on and to carry out fieldwork
  • BUT each student will be required to produce and submit their own final report.

Grading Distribution

Activity Grade Contribution
Participation 10%
Quizzes 10%
Mini-Project 30%
Cluster Map Project 50%

Time Committment (32hrs Total)

  • Quizzes: 4 hours
    • 2hrs: preparation/study for each quiz (x2)
  • Mini-Project: 10 hours
    • 5hrs: take pic of Beijiing
    • 5hrs: annotate pics, write short reflection, 1-2 .ppt slides
  • Cluster Map Project: 18 hours
    • 3hrs: study cluster literature (e.g. google); summarize
    • 3hrs: study chosen cluster (e.g. news articles); summarize
    • 4hrs: fieldwork (e.g. pics of main actors, 1 interview)
    • 5hrs: write-up fieldwork results, use pictures to dicuss main actors, create cluster map
    • 3hrs: create and prepare for final presentation

Course resources

  • Office hours by appointment

  • Syllabus, class notes, and grading policies posted on class email.

  • Use course email for gradebook and for turning in assignments

  • Wechat for class forum
    • Please post class related question on Wechat instead of emailing the teaching staff

Feedback

  • I value students' opinions regarding my teaching effectiveness
  • I will take student feedback in consideration to make this course as exciting and engaging as possible.
  • You are encouraged to leave (anonymous) feedback in the form of a note in my departmental mail box.

Any Questions?