## Loading 'metafor' package (version 1.9-9). For an overview 
## and introduction to the package please type: help(metafor).
## Loading 'meta' package (version 4.6-0).
## Type 'help("meta-package")' for a brief overview.
Treatment Efficacy for benchmarks (ITT)
Measure K d se lci Q Qp tau2 I2 H2
HRSD 8 2.434 0.094 2.249 23.254 0.002 0 69.897 3.322
BDI 11 1.706 0.056 1.815 120.556 0.000 0 91.705 12.056
Treatment Efficacy for benchmarks (Completers)
Measure K d se lci Q Qp tau2 I2 H2
HRSD 24 2.249 0.058 2.134 135.649 0 0 83.044 5.898
BDI 29 1.859 0.046 1.950 228.231 0 0 87.732 8.151
Natural History for benchmarks
Measure K d se lci Q Qp tau2 I2 H2
HRSD 9 0.401 0.099 0.207 23.477 0.003 0 65.924 2.935
BDI 11 0.371 0.089 0.546 12.976 0.225 0 22.936 1.298


HRSD ITT Effects (k=8)
Study ID 1st Auth Year n M-Pre SD-Pre M-Post SD-Post g d var.d Calculated-d Calculated-var.d
86 Elkin, I. 1989 120 19.600 4.270 10.242 7.900 2.191 2.177 0.028 2.177 0.028
150 Hollon, S. 1992 57 24.100 4.300 13.300 10.000 2.512 2.478 0.071 2.478 0.071
154 Jacobson, N. S. 1996 141 18.461 4.077 6.814 5.724 2.857 2.841 0.036 2.841 0.036
159 Jarrett, R. B. 1999 36 21.110 4.500 10.250 8.100 2.413 2.361 0.105 2.361 0.105
218 Murphy, G. E. 1984 24 18.830 3.000 7.750 6.500 3.693 3.572 0.307 3.571 0.307
268 Rush, A. J. 1977 16 20.940 3.400 6.250 3.980 4.321 4.101 0.588 4.100 0.588
311 Steuer, J. L. 1984 33 19.604 3.416 10.697 5.577 2.607 2.546 0.128 2.546 0.128
340 Thompson, L. W. 2001 31 18.900 3.700 12.500 7.000 1.730 1.686 0.078 1.686 0.078
BDI ITT Effects (k=11)
Study ID 1st Auth Year n M-Pre SD-Pre M-Post SD-Post g d var.d Calculated-d Calculated-var.d
86 Elkin, I. 1989 120 26.492 7.849 12.688 10.600 1.759 1.747 0.021 1.747 0.021
150 Hollon, S. 1992 57 30.100 5.700 13.300 12.000 2.947 2.908 0.092 2.908 0.092
154 Jacobson, N. S. 1996 149 29.410 6.501 9.868 8.906 3.006 2.991 0.037 2.991 0.037
159 Jarrett, R. B. 1999 36 27.580 7.320 11.720 9.720 2.167 2.120 0.090 2.120 0.090
163 Johnson, W. B. 1994 32 21.905 6.518 8.000 5.246 2.133 2.081 0.099 2.081 0.099
172 King, M. 2000 260 27.600 8.451 14.458 11.009 1.555 1.551 0.008 1.551 0.008
218 Murphy, G. E. 1984 24 28.920 4.720 10.880 8.930 3.822 3.696 0.326 3.696 0.326
268 Rush, A. J. 1977 19 30.210 6.640 7.260 7.740 3.456 3.310 0.341 3.310 0.341
311 Steuer, J. L. 1984 33 15.880 6.399 10.485 5.179 0.843 0.823 0.041 0.823 0.041
340 Thompson, L. W. 2001 31 24.300 7.500 16.400 9.700 1.053 1.027 0.049 1.027 0.049
357 Watson, J. C. 2003 85 24.812 8.774 12.791 11.285 1.370 1.358 0.023 1.358 0.023
HRSD Completers Effects (k=24)
Study ID 1st Auth Year n M-Pre SD-Pre M-Post SD-Post g d var.d Calculated-d Calculated-var.d
8 Arean, P. A. 1993 47 25.260 5.943 14.043 8.642 1.887 1.856 0.058 1.856 0.058
24 Beck, A. T. 1985 12 21.670 3.370 6.000 4.860 4.650 4.325 0.863 4.324 0.862
30 Beutler, L. E. 1991 43 19.748 4.266 10.641 7.057 2.135 2.097 0.074 2.097 0.074
34 Blackburn, I. M. 1997 23 19.200 3.600 10.100 7.100 2.528 2.441 0.173 2.440 0.173
86 Elkin, I. 1989 84 19.032 3.771 7.208 5.800 3.135 3.107 0.069 3.107 0.069
150 Hollon, S. 1992 31 24.800 3.900 8.800 7.800 4.103 3.999 0.290 3.999 0.290
153 Jacobson, N. S. 1991 60 20.320 5.453 6.282 6.510 2.575 2.542 0.071 2.542 0.071
154 Jacobson, N. S. 1996 134 18.408 3.966 6.542 5.296 2.992 2.975 0.040 2.975 0.040
169 Keller, M. B. 2000 156 26.400 4.122 15.100 8.618 2.742 2.728 0.030 2.728 0.030
178 Kohlenberg, R. J. 2002 38 14.761 3.874 6.736 5.684 2.072 2.029 0.081 2.029 0.081
180 Kornblith, S. J. 1983 39 16.367 5.106 5.885 6.190 2.053 2.012 0.078 2.012 0.078
218 Murphy, G. E. 1984 19 18.470 2.840 6.420 6.160 4.243 4.064 0.487 4.063 0.487
219 Neimeyer, R. A. 1990 60 17.285 5.819 9.515 6.107 1.335 1.318 0.031 1.318 0.031
222 Nezu, A. M. 1989 14 24.070 2.970 7.710 4.460 5.508 5.184 1.031 5.183 1.031
237 Pecheur, D. R. 1984 27 34.550 7.301 18.300 8.162 2.226 2.161 0.124 2.161 0.124
248 Propst, L. R. 1992 38 16.591 4.772 9.325 5.090 1.523 1.492 0.056 1.492 0.056
255 Rehm, L. P. 1987 104 18.287 4.987 6.867 5.023 2.290 2.273 0.034 2.273 0.034
256 Rehm, L. P. 1981 41 16.736 4.869 9.829 6.992 1.419 1.392 0.048 1.392 0.048
268 Rush, A. J. 1977 15 21.200 3.340 5.800 3.670 4.611 4.359 0.700 4.359 0.700
280 Scott, A. I. F. 1992 29 18.300 5.400 6.700 6.100 2.148 2.090 0.110 2.090 0.110
311 Steuer, J. L. 1984 20 18.650 2.323 8.900 4.739 4.197 4.029 0.456 4.029 0.456
314 Stravynski, A. 1994 9 20.800 3.800 10.200 5.300 2.789 2.520 0.464 2.518 0.463
341 Thompson, L. W. 1984 33 19.095 3.779 9.244 6.297 2.607 2.545 0.128 2.545 0.128
376 Zettle, R. D. 1989 31 21.517 4.622 10.192 7.385 2.450 2.388 0.124 2.388 0.124
BDI Completers Effects (k=29)
Study ID 1st Auth Year n M-Pre SD-Pre M-Post SD-Post g d var.d Calculated-d Calculated-var.d
8 Arean, P. A. 1993 47 23.640 6.014 16.415 8.555 1.201 1.182 0.036 1.182 0.036
24 Beck, A. T. 1985 14 31.000 7.630 8.640 8.450 2.931 2.758 0.343 2.758 0.343
30 Beutler, L. E. 1991 43 26.127 8.990 15.068 10.208 1.230 1.208 0.040 1.208 0.040
34 Blackburn, I. M. 1997 22 27.300 8.700 18.200 12.200 1.046 1.008 0.069 1.008 0.069
86 Elkin, I. 1989 84 26.073 8.015 8.801 8.644 2.155 2.135 0.039 2.135 0.039
126 Greenberg, L. S. 1998 68 24.035 6.013 8.755 5.537 2.541 2.512 0.061 2.512 0.061
150 Hollon, S. 1992 32 30.400 6.500 7.900 9.500 3.462 3.377 0.209 3.377 0.209
153 Jacobson, N. S. 1991 60 26.510 4.833 8.830 7.926 3.658 3.611 0.125 3.611 0.125
154 Jacobson, N. S. 1996 137 29.248 6.739 8.972 8.464 3.009 2.992 0.040 2.992 0.040
172 King, M. 2000 229 27.600 8.456 12.402 9.297 1.797 1.791 0.011 1.791 0.011
178 Kohlenberg, R. J. 2002 38 21.658 6.558 9.423 7.568 1.866 1.828 0.070 1.827 0.070
180 Kornblith, S. J. 1983 39 28.044 10.760 13.269 11.571 1.373 1.346 0.049 1.346 0.049
204 McKnight, D. L. 1992 22 32.809 5.080 14.855 8.658 3.535 3.407 0.309 3.407 0.309
208 McNamara, K. 1986 30 24.270 4.569 5.600 3.771 4.086 3.980 0.297 3.980 0.297
218 Murphy, G. E. 1984 19 28.680 4.780 9.530 8.210 4.006 3.837 0.440 3.837 0.440
219 Neimeyer, R. A. 1990 60 24.045 7.374 15.625 9.592 1.142 1.127 0.027 1.127 0.027
221 Nezu, A. M. 1986 11 23.910 7.090 9.820 4.710 1.987 1.834 0.244 1.834 0.244
222 Nezu, A. M. 1989 14 26.000 2.960 6.570 3.290 6.564 6.178 1.435 6.177 1.434
237 Pecheur, D. R. 1984 27 23.000 5.156 7.100 3.523 3.084 2.994 0.203 2.994 0.203
248 Propst, L. R. 1992 38 17.313 8.014 6.394 5.372 1.362 1.335 0.050 1.335 0.050
255 Rehm, L. P. 1987 104 29.338 7.519 10.970 7.668 2.443 2.425 0.038 2.425 0.038
256 Rehm, L. P. 1981 41 28.646 7.140 17.661 10.864 1.539 1.510 0.052 1.510 0.052
268 Rush, A. J. 1977 18 30.280 6.820 5.940 5.330 3.569 3.409 0.378 3.409 0.378
270 Rush, A. J. 1981 31 29.277 6.622 14.239 11.624 2.271 2.214 0.111 2.214 0.111
311 Steuer, J. L. 1984 20 15.300 5.038 10.150 4.922 1.022 0.981 0.074 0.981 0.074
314 Stravynski, A. 1994 9 23.500 6.100 8.800 5.100 2.410 2.177 0.374 2.175 0.374
341 Thompson, L. W. 1984 33 25.003 6.744 12.484 7.297 1.857 1.813 0.080 1.813 0.080
357 Watson, J. C. 2003 66 24.620 8.442 9.650 9.138 1.773 1.753 0.038 1.753 0.038
376 Zettle, R. D. 1989 31 27.515 5.287 13.225 8.705 2.703 2.635 0.144 2.635 0.144
HRSD WLC Effects (k=9)
Study ID 1st Auth Year n M-Pre SD-Pre M-Post SD-Post g d var.d Calculated-d Calculated-var.d
8 Arean, P. A. 1993 20 22.40 5.50 22.00 4.50 0.073 0.070 0.050 0.070 0.050
222 Nezu, A. M. 1989 13 25.91 4.09 21.00 5.46 1.200 1.124 0.126 1.124 0.125
237 Pecheur, D. R. 1984 7 35.40 9.80 36.30 8.40 -0.092 -0.080 0.143 -0.080 0.143
248 Propst, L. R. 1992 11 17.18 2.48 13.72 6.08 1.395 1.288 0.166 1.287 0.166
256 Rehm, L. P. 1981 15 18.94 5.34 14.80 7.49 0.775 0.733 0.085 0.733 0.085
263 Rokke, P. D. 2000 16 14.69 4.42 10.69 5.21 0.905 0.859 0.086 0.859 0.086
342 Thompson, L. W. 1987 19 18.26 3.65 17.95 4.29 0.085 0.081 0.053 0.081 0.053
347 Verduyn, C. 2003 12 14.00 4.40 11.20 6.80 0.636 0.592 0.098 0.592 0.098
372 Wilson, P. H. 1983 9 13.22 4.08 14.78 5.96 -0.382 -0.345 0.118 -0.345 0.118
BDI WLC Effects (k=11)
Study ID 1st Auth Year n M-Pre SD-Pre M-Post SD-Post g d var.d Calculated-d Calculated-var.d
8 Arean, P. A. 1993 20 23.00 4.30 21.20 6.00 0.419 0.402 0.054 0.402 0.054
47 Brown, R. A. 1984 11 31.09 9.74 18.18 11.29 1.325 1.224 0.159 1.223 0.159
221 Nezu, A. M. 1986 6 20.67 5.39 21.00 6.27 -0.061 -0.052 0.167 -0.051 0.167
222 Nezu, A. M. 1989 13 27.27 4.29 24.73 7.76 0.592 0.554 0.089 0.554 0.089
237 Pecheur, D. R. 1984 7 22.10 5.70 19.60 8.40 0.439 0.381 0.153 0.381 0.153
248 Propst, L. R. 1992 11 17.27 7.10 13.54 8.03 0.525 0.485 0.102 0.485 0.102
256 Rehm, L. P. 1981 15 26.00 7.72 21.87 8.20 0.535 0.506 0.075 0.506 0.075
263 Rokke, P. D. 2000 16 18.06 7.75 15.06 8.31 0.387 0.367 0.067 0.367 0.067
342 Thompson, L. W. 1987 19 21.21 6.66 22.48 7.82 -0.191 -0.183 0.054 -0.183 0.054
347 Verduyn, C. 2003 13 24.60 8.40 18.90 10.20 0.679 0.635 0.092 0.635 0.092
372 Wilson, P. H. 1983 9 23.66 7.45 21.44 5.52 0.298 0.269 0.115 0.269 0.115