CEP 923 Final Project: Approaches to Dealing with Speededness

Alex Lishinski
4/25/16

Introduction

Presentation Overview:

  • Speeded test basics and issues
  • Approaches to speeded tests
  • PISA Problem Solving Data Analysis

Speeded Test Basics (Lu and Sireci 2007)

Whenever tests involve a time limit, the rate at which students work will affect their performance, and this can undermine the validity of the test for measuring the construct of interest.

  • Speed vs Power Tests
  • Score Approach vs Fairness Approach
  • Error Score Partitioning
    • Omitted items
    • Items not reached
  • Impact on Validity and Reliability

Speeded Test Issues

  • Parameter Estimate Bias
  • Effect on Factor Structure
  • Differential Item Functioning
  • Content Validity
  • Issues with IRT assumptions
  • Approaches to Identifying Speededness
    • Multiple Administration
    • Single Administration

IRT Approaches to Speeded Tests

Detecting vs Removing Effects of Speededness

  • Incorrect vs Missing

Detecting Speededness effects

  • 2 class mixture Rasch Model (Bolt et al 2002)
  • Mixture Rasch (Wollack 2003)
  • Goegebeur et al. (2008)

Improved Model Estimation

  • Maximum Marginal Likelihood Estimation (Glas and Pimentel 2008)
  • Performance Decrement Parameters (Jin and Want 2014)
  • Bayesian MCMC estimation 2PL model (Chang et al. 2014)

PISA Problem Solving Data Analysis Plan

2003 PISA Problems Solving Items: 4 Items 10 quesitons

  • Examination of different approaches
  • Simulation Study
  • Application of Models to PISA Data
    • Speededness Effects
    • Testlet Effects