Economic Hardship Across U.S. Counties
Economic Hardship (EH) Rankings — Arizona Counties
All Arizona Counties vs. U.S. Extremes
Economic Hardship Index: All Arizona Census Tracts (2023)
Decomposing the Economic Hardship Index
Economic Hardship Clusters (LISA)
Within-County Variation in Economic Hardship (EH) — All 15 Arizona Counties

High Economic Hardship Clusters (HH) — Hot Spot Tracts Statewide:

244

Low Economic Hardship Clusters (LL) — Cold Spot Tracts Statewide:

254

Economic Hardship Mobility: Maricopa Tracts (2013 → 2023)
Neighborhood Hardship Trajectories (2013–2019)

Tracts Improved (2013→2023)

57.5%

Tracts Worsened (2013→2023)

31.7%

Persistently High Hardship (2013–2023)

17.8%

Emerging Hot Spots (2013–2023)

2.8%

🔴 Areas of Persistent Concern
158 Persistent Hot Spot Tracts (17.8% of Maricopa tracts)

These census tracts had statistically significant high-hardship clustering in both 2013 and 2019. The pattern is not random: a Global Moran’s I of 0.65 confirms that hardship is spatially concentrated, not scattered. Tracts in this category share infrastructure deficits, limited employment access, and concentrated poverty that reinforce one another across neighborhood boundaries.

Implication: Individual-level interventions alone are unlikely to move the needle. Place-based, multi-sector investment is required.

The persistent hardship hot spots appear concentrated around central Phoenix and nearby urban neighborhoods. These areas would benefit from coordinated housing, employment, and community development investments.
🟡 Early Warning Signals
24 Emerging Hot Spot Tracts (2.8% of Maricopa tracts)

These tracts were not significant hardship clusters in 2013 but became statistically significant by 2019, representing the spatial expansion of hardship beyond historically distressed cores. This is an early warning signal that hardship is spreading, not contained.

Displacement paradox: Some “improving” tracts nearby may be gentrifying, pushing lower-income households outward into these emerging clusters. Declining hardship scores do not necessarily mean existing residents are better off.

The trajectory map shows emerging hot spots near existing hardship clusters in the central Phoenix area. Rising housing costs and displacement pressures could contribute to changing neighborhood conditions, so these areas should be monitored more closely.
🟢 Signs of Progress Read With Caution
57.5% of Maricopa tracts showed EHI improvement (2013→2023)

The majority of tracts improved over the decade-long window. However, aggregate improvement masks significant variation: 31.7% of tracts worsened over the same period. The data cannot distinguish genuine economic uplift from population turnover: a tract with a declining hardship index may simply have replaced lower-income residents with higher-income newcomers.

Data limitation: Before drawing conclusions from improving scores, ground-truth verification through community engagement and displacement tracking is essential.

In Maricopa County, particularly around central Phoenix, improvements in economic hardship scores do not necessarily mean that long-term residents are benefiting. Although 57.5% of tracts improved between 2013 and 2023, rising housing costs and changes in neighborhood populations could affect these results. I would recommend reviewing local housing and displacement data to better understand whether these improvements reflect actual economic progress for existing residents.
Recommendation 1

Target: 158 Persistent Hot Spot tracts (17.8% of all Maricopa tracts): spatially concentrated, entrenched hardship confirmed by a Global Moran’s I of 0.65.

I recommend prioritizing the persistent hardship clusters concentrated around central Phoenix and surrounding urban neighborhoods. The expanded index identified 158 persistent hot spot tracts, representing 17.8% of Maricopa County tracts, while a Global Moran’s I of 0.65 indicates strong spatial clustering. I would recommend that the City of Phoenix and Maricopa County Human Services Department coordinate investments in affordable housing, job training, and access to community services in these areas. Using both housing and food assistance indicators can help identify communities experiencing multiple forms of economic hardship.
Recommendation 2

Target: 24 Emerging Hot Spot tracts (2.8% of all Maricopa tracts), new high-hardship clusters not present in 2013, signaling spatial expansion.

The 24 emerging hot spot tracts should also receive attention before economic hardship becomes more concentrated. The trajectory map shows emerging clusters around the central urban area, near existing hardship clusters. I would recommend monitoring changes in rent, household income, and SNAP participation to identify communities experiencing growing financial pressure. The displacement paradox is also important because a neighborhood may appear to improve when lower-income residents move away rather than when their financial circumstances improve. Early housing assistance and tenant protection programs could help prevent further instability.
Recommendation 3

Evidence base: 57.5% of tracts improved (2013→2023) but 31.7% worsened; Moran’s I = 0.65 confirms strong spatial clustering persists.

Although 57.5% of Maricopa County tracts improved between 2013 and 2023, another 31.7% experienced worsening hardship. The mobility diagram also shows that neighborhoods can move between hardship categories over time, so improvements should not be assumed to be permanent. I recommend that Maricopa County work with local housing agencies and community organizations to regularly monitor changes in poverty, employment, renter households, and SNAP participation. Tracking these indicators alongside neighborhood feedback would help policymakers identify emerging problems earlier and determine whether investments are benefiting existing residents.
🔬 Index Sensitivity Reflection

The baseline EHI consists of 3 measures: Poverty + Unemployment + Income (inv.)

Current index: 5-component EHI: Poverty + Unemployment + Income (inv.) + Renter Burden + Food Insecurity (SNAP)

After adding your extra component(s), answer the following (minimum 2 sentences each):

Q1: What changed spatially?
Compare Hot Spot tract counts and cluster map patterns between your expanded index and the 3-component baseline. Did adding Renter Burden + Food Insecurity (SNAP) shift which tracts or corridors are flagged?

After adding renter burden and SNAP participation to the original Economic Hardship Index, I noticed a change in the number of areas identified as high-hardship hot spots. The original three-component index identified 201 hot-spot census tracts across Arizona, while my expanded five-component index identified 244, an increase of 43 tracts. The number of low-hardship cold spots also decreased slightly from 260 to 254. Looking at the maps, the general pattern of hardship remains similar, with significant clusters in northern and eastern Arizona, but the expanded index identifies additional areas experiencing disadvantage. This suggests that including housing and food assistance measures can reveal economic challenges that poverty, unemployment, and income alone may not fully capture.

Q2: What stayed the same?
Which Persistent Hot Spot areas appear robustly across index specifications? What does consistency across different index compositions tell us about the reliability of hardship diagnoses in those tracts?

One thing that stayed relatively consistent was the concentration of persistent hardship hot spots around central Phoenix and nearby urban neighborhoods. Even after adding renter households and SNAP participation, these areas continued to appear as clusters of economic hardship. The baseline dashboard identified 17.0% of Maricopa County tracts as persistently high hardship, compared with 17.8% in my expanded index. This suggests that the overall pattern of concentrated disadvantage is fairly consistent across the two measures. However, the exact number and boundaries of the clusters can still change depending on which indicators are included. Areas that remain identified as hot spots under different index compositions may be stronger candidates for long-term investment.

Q3: Policy implications of index choice
If a policymaker targeted place-based investments using the baseline index versus your expanded index, would resource allocation differ? Name specific tracts or geographic corridors and argue which composition better captures the full burden of economic hardship for policy purposes.

I think the expanded five-component index provides a more complete picture of economic hardship because it includes renter households and SNAP participation along with poverty, unemployment, and income. If policymakers relied only on the original index, they might overlook communities experiencing housing-related pressures or greater reliance on food assistance. For example, the expanded index identifies more high-hardship hot spots across Arizona, which could change how resources are distributed. In Maricopa County, I would continue prioritizing persistent hardship clusters around central Phoenix while also examining neighborhoods newly identified by the expanded index. I would use the five-component index as the primary screening tool, but also review each individual indicator before making funding decisions. This would help ensure that assistance addresses the specific challenges communities face rather than relying on one overall score.