Our group is examining the relationship between an MLB team’s spending on players and the success that results from that spending. We will take both a micro and macro approach to our analysis. Our macro approach will focus on team statistics like wins, as well as team-wide averages for key offensive and pitching statistics. Our micro approach will focus on the individual to determine the extent to which higher-paid players perform better than lower-paid players, if at all. We hope to answer how a team’s spending on players operates as a predictor for both individual and team success. This analysis is important because it can help MLB organizations understand existing trends and inform their spending decisions. Teams that pay attention to this data may learn how to avoid bad spending decisions or secure undervalued players. This is a big advantage.
Lots of discussion currently surrounds this topic in the world of Major League Baseball. There is a proposed salary cap that would change the entire way spending operates in the MLB. It would limit the amount of money that can be spent on certain players while ensuring other lower-paid players receive more. One article from Front Office Sports cites that while younger players produce 71% of value, they only get 31% of the pay. The salary cap would attempt to mitigate this imbalance. The vast majority of players oppose a salary cap because they believe it is a way for their owners to decrease spending at their expense. According to NBC News and Commissioner Rob Manfred, this disagreement will likely lead to a lockout. It is clearly a very relevant time for this analysis, as advancing demands for a salary cap mean team spending and player salary trends could potentially change forever.
We will be combining 6 datasets for this analysis. All datasets are from the year 2024. The first is team payroll. This dataset is from Spotrac, an online sports financials database. Important variables from this data are team payroll and 26-man active roster payroll. Each observation is a different team. The next two datasets, team pitching and batting statistics, are each from Baseball Reference, the most prominent online home for baseball statistics. For offensive production, we will look at major stats like AVG, OPS, and RBIs. Important variables in the pitching dataset are ERA and strikeouts. We will also use WAR. Each observation in these datasets is a different MLB team. The data we will use for individual player salary is from USA TODAY Sports. Important variables are salary and total value. The last two datasets, indiviudal batting and pitching statistics, are also from Baseball Reference. We will also use AVG, OPS, RBIs, ERA, strikeouts, and WAR. Each observation in the last three datasets is an individual player.
References:
Fisher, E. (2026, November 19). MLB says young players produce 71% of value, only get 31% of pay. Front Office Sports. https://frontofficesports.com/article/mlb-says-young-players-produce-71-of-value-only-get-31-of-pay/
The Associated Press. (2026, November 18). Rob Manfred says MLB owners won’t compromise on a salary cap, leaving sport headed to a lockout. NBC News.https://www.nbcnews.com/sports/mlb/rob-manfred-mlb-owners-players-salary-cap-lockout-rcna610111
Spotrac. (2024). 2024 MLB team salary payroll tracker. Spotrac.Com. https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/payroll/_/year/2024
Major League Baseball salaries 2024 - USA today databases. (2024, March 27). USA TODAY Databases. https://databases.usatoday.com/major-league-baseball-salaries-2024/page/48/
Baseball Reference. (2024). 2024 Major League Baseball Standard pitching | baseball-reference.Com. Baseball-Reference.Com. https://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/majors/2024-standard-pitching.shtml
Baseball Reference. (2024). 2024 Major league baseball standard batting | baseball-reference.Com. Baseball-Reference.Com. https://www.baseball-reference.com/leagues/majors/2024-standard-batting.shtml