Financial Economics – Week 1, Session 2

Classifying Projects and Incremental Cash Flows

Gül Ertan Özgüzer

Session Objectives

By the end of this session, you will be able to:

  • Classify a project by economic life, by risk and by dependence on other projects
  • Split a project’s cash flows into operating and investment cash flows
  • Apply the incremental principle: include opportunity costs and working capital, exclude sunk costs
  • Build a year-by-year cash-flow timeline in the workbook

Warm-up

Three of you share the investment announcement you brought.

The class guesses: what kind of project is it?

1 Classifying Projects

Three lenses on every project

Lens Question it answers Why it matters
Economic life How long do the benefits last? Sets how much the time value of money matters
Risk How uncertain are the cash flows? Sets the discount rate
Dependence How does it interact with other projects? Sets which cash flows to model together

By economic life (6.2.1)

Short-term investment

Benefits arrive within one year.

Mostly current assets: cash, marketable securities, receivables, inventory.

Long-term investment

Benefits arrive beyond one year; the outlay is a capital expenditure.

The time value of money matters most.

Economic life ends through wear, obsolescence or competition: near its end, revenues fall and expenses rise.

By risk

Type What it is Typical risk
Replacement Replace or maintain existing assets; cost-cutting projects Low: known cash flows
Expansion Broaden existing product lines or markets Low to moderate
New products and markets New product or new market High: little experience
Mandated Required by law or agencies Not chosen for return

Mandated projects are common in utilities, transport and chemicals: specific equipment, or rules on waste disposal.

By dependence on other projects

Type Definition Book example
Independent Cash flows unrelated to any other project Values simply add up
Mutually exclusive Accepting one rules out the other Bids from rival equipment makers: install only one
Contingent Depends on accepting another project Pippy T-shirts only if Pippy cards catch on
Complementary One investment lifts another’s cash flows New mouse software boosts mouse sales

2 Incremental Cash Flows

Only the difference the project makes counts

Incremental cash flows = cash flows with the project − cash flows without it, over the same period.

\[ \Delta V_{firm} = PV(\Delta \text{operating cash flows}) + PV(\text{investment cash flows}) \]

  • Operating cash flows (OCF): revenues and operating expenses the project changes. Usually positive.
  • Investment cash flows: buying the assets, later disposing of them. Usually negative.

Operating cash flow

\[ OCF_t = (\Delta Revenue_t - \Delta Costs_t - D_t)(1 - T) + D_t \]

Depreciation \(D\) is not a cash outflow, but it lowers taxes: deduct it to compute tax at rate \(T\), then add it back.

Four rules students break

Rule Why Example
Sunk costs: out Already spent; does not change with the decision A market study paid last year
Opportunity costs: in Value given up by using an asset in the project Rent forgone on the space used
Working capital: twice Outlay at the start, recovered at the end Extra inventory
Side effects: in Changes to the firm’s other cash flows Lost sales of existing products

3 Activity 2.1: The Toy Manufacturer

Place each project on the board

Classify each project by risk class and dependence type (textbook Question 1):

  1. Opening a retail outlet
  2. Introducing a new line of dolls
  3. Introducing a new action figure in an existing line
  4. Adding another packaging line to production
  5. Adding pollution control equipment to avoid environmental fines

4 Activity 2.2: Sunrise Coffee

Build the cash-flow timeline

Sunrise Coffee is considering a roasting machine. In the workbook tab “Lab 2 Cash flows”, build years 0–4.

Item Value Item Value
Machine + installation $120,000 + $10,000 Rent forgone per year $4,000
Working capital (back in year 4) $15,000 Market study already paid $8,000
Extra revenue per year $70,000 Depreciation Straight-line, 4 years
Extra operating costs per year $25,000 Salvage in year 4 · tax rate $20,000 · 25%

Check: operating cash flow, years 1–4

Step Amount
Extra revenue 70,000
− Operating costs -25,000
− Rent forgone -4,000
− Depreciation (130,000 ÷ 4) -32,500
= EBIT 8,500
− Tax at 25% -2,125
+ Depreciation added back 32,500
= Operating cash flow 38,875

Check: the cash-flow timeline

Year OCF Capex Working capital After-tax salvage Net cash flow
0 0 -130,000 -15,000 0 -145,000
1 38,875 0 0 0 38,875
2 38,875 0 0 0 38,875
3 38,875 0 0 0 38,875
4 38,875 0 15,000 15,000 68,875

Keep these net cash flows: Session 3 turns them into an NPV.

Your Turn

Use your timeline in the workbook:

  1. The $8,000 market study is not in the timeline. Why?
  2. Set the rent forgone to 0. How much does OCF rise, and why is it less than $4,000?
  3. Change the tax rate to 20%. Which rows of the timeline change?

Wrap-up

Exit check

  1. Two warehouse sites are compared for the same distribution need. What is the dependence type?
  2. True or false: the $8,000 market study belongs in year 0.
  3. Why is working capital entered twice?

Glossary of Key Terms

Term Meaning
Incremental cash flow Cash flow with the project minus cash flow without it
Operating cash flow (OCF) (Revenue − costs − depreciation)(1 − T) + depreciation
Sunk cost Already spent; ignored in the decision
Opportunity cost Value given up by using an asset in the project; included
Working capital Outflow at the start, recovered at the end
Independent / mutually exclusive / contingent / complementary The four ways projects depend on each other

Summary: What We Learned Today

  • Projects are classified by economic life, risk and dependence; each changes the analysis.
  • Only incremental cash flows count: with the project minus without it.
  • Sunk costs out; opportunity costs, working capital and side effects in.
  • Sunrise Coffee: −145,000 in year 0, 38,875 a year, 68,875 in year 4.

Homework: finish the Your Turn questions