| Case | Return | Firm value |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Bakery oven | 14% | Rises: accept |
| 2. Utility scrubber | 10% | Unchanged: indifferent |
| 3. Retail store | 7% | Falls: reject |
Why Firms Invest: Capital Budgeting and Owners’ Wealth
A firm earns 12% on a project financed at 10%.
Does the firm’s value rise?
Vote: Yes · No · It depends
A firm’s total assets, tangible and intangible.
Land, buildings, machinery; receivables, securities, patents, copyrights
Additions to the existing capital stock: investment in new assets.
A new plant, a new production line
Assets needed for day-to-day operations that support long-term investments.
Inventory, cash, accounts receivable
Capital budgeting is the process of identifying and selecting investments in long-lived assets: assets expected to produce benefits over more than one year.
Do not change the firm’s course or risk.
e.g., replacing a worn delivery van
Change market position or open new product lines; often large and hard to reverse.
e.g., entering a new product market
A capital project is a set of assets that are contingent on one another and evaluated together.
| Land | + | Facilities | + | Equipment | + | Working capital | = | One project |
|---|
Example: producing a new product requires land, a plant, equipment, and more inventory, cash and receivables.
Management should maximise the market value of the firm, and hence owners’ current wealth.
Firm value today is the present value of all expected future cash flows, discounted at a rate that reflects their risk:
\[ V_0 = \sum_{t=1}^{\infty} \frac{E[CF_t]}{(1+r)^t} \]
In a perfect capital market, investment (operating) and financing decisions can be made separately. A perfect capital market without uncertainty means everybody borrows and lends at market interest rates, and everyone has the same information. Therefore, a project’ value depends on its own cash flows and their risk.
Two cash-flow streams with the same total ($14 million), discounted at 10%:
| Year | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Total | Present value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Early stream ($m) | 5 | 4 | 3 | 2 | 14 | $11,471,211 |
| Late stream ($m) | 0 | 2 | 3 | 9 | 14 | $10,053,958 |
The later stream is worth $1,417,253 less today: the market value rule cares about when cash arrives, not just how much.
| Sales risk | + | Operating risk | = | Business risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| How much output will sell, and at what price | How sensitive operating cash flows are to sales | Priced in the discount rate | ||
| Driven by the economy and the product market | Set by the mix of fixed and variable costs |
The discount rate has one value, two names:
| If the project earns… | Then firm value… | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| More than the cost of capital | Rises | Accept |
| Exactly the cost of capital | Is unchanged | Indifferent |
| Less than the cost of capital | Falls | Reject |
Back to the poll: 12% beats 10% only if 10% is the right rate for the project’s risk. The financing rate is not the hurdle.
Cost of capital = 10% in every case. Work in breakout rooms; post each answer in chat with a one-line reason.
| Case | Return | Firm value |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Bakery oven | 14% | Rises: accept |
| 2. Utility scrubber | 10% | Unchanged: indifferent |
| 3. Retail store | 7% | Falls: reject |
Suppose the cost of capital were 12% instead of 10%.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Capital | A firm’s total assets, tangible and intangible |
| Capital budgeting | Identifying and selecting investments in long-lived assets |
| Working capital | Inventory, cash and receivables that support daily operations |
| Market value rule | Maximise the firm’s market value, and so owners’ wealth |
| Business risk | Sales risk + operating risk |
| RRR / cost of capital | The return required for the risk borne; the project’s hurdle rate |
Homework: read textbook pp. 102–106 and bring one real company announcement of a new investment.
Financial Economics · Chapter 6: Firm Investment Decisions