Default

Author

Antonio Leal & Irving Cauich

Introducción a la base de datos

En este reporte utilizaremos el conjunto de datos Default, disponible en el paquete ISLR de R. Los datos contienen información de 10,000 clientes de tarjetas de crédito, incluyendo si han incumplido sus pagos, si son estudiantes, el saldo de sus tarjetas y sus ingresos anuales. Nuestro objetivo es analizar cómo las variables student (condición de estudiante), balance (saldo de la tarjeta de crédito) e income (ingreso anual) permiten clasificar y predecir el incumplimiento de pago ((Y) = default) mediante un modelo de árbol de decisión.

library(mosaic)
library(ISLR)
library(rpart)
library(rpart.plot)
library(caret)

data("Default")

Paso 1. Análisis exploratorio de datos

summary(Default)
 default    student       balance           income     
 No :9667   No :7056   Min.   :   0.0   Min.   :  772  
 Yes: 333   Yes:2944   1st Qu.: 481.7   1st Qu.:21340  
                       Median : 823.6   Median :34553  
                       Mean   : 835.4   Mean   :33517  
                       3rd Qu.:1166.3   3rd Qu.:43808  
                       Max.   :2654.3   Max.   :73554  

Seleccionamos las variables que pueden aportar información para clasificar a los clientes según el incumplimiento de sus pagos.

datos_Default <- Default[,c("default","student","balance","income")]

#Pasamos a factores las variables dicotomicas
datos_Default$student <- as.factor(datos_Default$student)
datos_Default$default <- as.factor(datos_Default$default )
str(datos_Default)
'data.frame':   10000 obs. of  4 variables:
 $ default: Factor w/ 2 levels "No","Yes": 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ...
 $ student: Factor w/ 2 levels "No","Yes": 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 ...
 $ balance: num  730 817 1074 529 786 ...
 $ income : num  44362 12106 31767 35704 38463 ...

Vereficamos si hay datos faltantes en la base de datos.

sum(is.na(datos_Default))
[1] 0

Por lo que, no hay datos faltantes en la base de datos.

Paso 2. Dividir los datos en conjunto de entrenamiento y prueba.

Código
set.seed(2025)
folds <- createFolds(datos_Default$default, k = 5)
entrenamiento <- datos_Default[-folds[[5]],]
pruebadatos_Default  <- datos_Default[folds[[5]],]

pruebadatos_Default
      default student     balance    income
2          No     Yes  817.180407 12106.135
8          No     Yes  808.667504 17600.451
10         No      No    0.000000 29275.268
16         No      No  286.232560 45042.413
17         No      No    0.000000 50265.312
19         No      No  485.936864 61566.106
24         No      No  641.984389 30466.103
25         No      No  773.211725 34353.314
26         No      No  855.008523 25211.332
30         No     Yes 1119.569353 16556.070
33         No     Yes  584.904895 22429.935
36         No     Yes 1499.724657 13190.653
40         No      No  653.118400 39489.595
48         No      No 1228.308350 37408.504
50         No      No  857.485118 31688.346
54         No     Yes  904.040259 16882.301
56         No     Yes 1294.497347 10464.321
60         No      No  492.079768 33379.095
67         No      No 1044.552343 54696.766
76         No     Yes  752.459946 16211.276
80         No      No  196.456913 41346.786
81         No     Yes  948.747918 14297.619
83         No      No  461.638182 46221.211
86         No      No  510.237593 60397.719
88         No     Yes  162.454451 13241.752
89         No      No  932.533156 50537.466
90         No     Yes  893.330468 11905.682
94         No      No  368.223426 57596.826
101        No      No 1422.018488 38224.032
105        No      No 1463.232892 65457.854
112        No      No  596.964119 58088.360
117        No      No  271.551438 32850.120
119        No      No  867.030828 33540.980
123        No      No  449.735086 49643.426
126        No      No    0.000000 31825.765
134        No      No  409.982325 44641.090
144        No      No  441.738285 36012.236
145        No      No 1188.642180 39526.561
156        No      No  352.644414 39404.744
159        No      No 1149.145627 45194.795
165        No      No  647.483529 33226.278
169        No     Yes  335.834119 21759.870
174       Yes     Yes 2205.799521 14271.492
180        No      No  410.497705 53471.214
181        No      No   73.076542 30681.738
189        No     Yes 1290.620169 18408.049
198        No      No  171.559116 23505.993
200        No      No  640.662752 46464.566
209        No      No  746.229775 35159.850
214        No      No  474.727319 32064.335
217        No      No  220.028570 37880.030
223        No     Yes 1099.630422 17064.043
225        No      No  444.264906 35924.339
229        No      No 1412.238721 40785.060
260        No      No  554.107812 30357.026
265        No      No  990.567026 41690.253
266        No      No  590.399786 42769.204
272        No      No  592.253896 30731.202
281        No      No  673.399899 50256.290
284        No      No  527.194087 32431.118
288        No      No 1496.056465 24935.919
300        No      No 1033.468469 59203.968
301        No      No    0.000000 34925.365
306        No     Yes  847.818706 15978.634
308        No     Yes  402.488887 15904.056
313        No      No  386.016049 44694.031
317        No     Yes 1328.183804 24688.474
320        No      No  989.686420 27856.577
323        No     Yes 1428.832047 23204.681
329        No      No 1042.804920 25867.148
335        No      No  455.521513 40907.398
344        No      No  749.608004 41423.941
357        No      No  692.143223 47038.090
364        No      No  165.538152 33436.456
368        No     Yes  434.560259 14812.645
380        No      No  673.016117 29735.962
385        No      No  905.038165 40711.799
388        No     Yes  883.702646 19750.094
400        No      No 1217.321712 25173.620
412        No      No  758.702328 36625.990
414        No     Yes 1890.167411 18402.465
417        No      No 1075.863772 44128.628
424        No      No  267.303728 23117.929
426        No      No  624.731884 38325.174
443        No      No 1322.297091 51792.402
444        No      No  878.026458 27438.585
449        No      No  747.561036 39898.769
450        No      No 1787.285144 37499.094
454        No      No 1101.149707 18153.844
458        No      No 1126.223023 32842.652
462        No     Yes 1383.566333 15764.346
465        No      No  605.220968 21792.322
474        No     Yes  379.082167 18280.367
479        No      No  705.573328 54589.240
484        No      No  777.023737 35115.019
490        No      No  722.788039 53714.186
501        No     Yes  965.587370 16440.100
511        No      No 1088.637520 60650.036
527        No      No 1446.101012 22996.432
533        No      No    0.000000 36283.080
536        No      No  779.657300 40804.476
551        No      No  596.885432 54091.625
565        No     Yes 1478.618545 18026.471
567        No     Yes 1273.550720 23126.636
572        No      No  790.590582 48219.594
574        No      No 1273.244830 49136.474
590        No      No 1063.774937 34914.275
593        No      No  908.931459 68758.878
596        No     Yes 1110.681744 19327.575
598        No      No  972.031864 18510.946
600        No     Yes 1178.248909 29362.605
601        No     Yes  329.558511 19371.812
602        No     Yes  792.529238 14546.302
604        No      No  591.760776 41670.257
609        No     Yes 1268.240691 11914.578
613        No      No 1097.600039 52286.432
627        No     Yes  316.459048 18813.940
628        No      No  622.929507 48874.556
629        No      No  107.277527 42287.303
634        No     Yes  928.060078 21121.845
638        No      No  687.306397 24563.758
642       Yes      No 1531.716459 43930.400
645        No      No  468.132522 25231.346
651        No      No  133.743344 30457.016
670        No      No 1335.028018 21150.856
702        No     Yes 1247.907029 19816.720
705        No      No 1080.291656 43367.900
711        No      No  482.982195 35845.193
714       Yes     Yes 1551.023469 19027.509
715        No      No  981.596275 37747.913
719        No     Yes  544.139769 20056.829
720        No      No 1137.175454 27588.933
724        No      No  679.391842 46603.546
727        No      No 1036.676833 44923.803
735        No     Yes 2004.727568 27136.538
737        No     Yes  662.273556 15092.051
743        No     Yes 1233.343605 13402.073
744        No      No 1221.385959 36961.315
752        No      No   24.871823 29316.970
755        No     Yes 1521.172396 18149.886
762       Yes     Yes 1871.938387 18077.487
763        No      No  793.761718 35157.740
774        No     Yes  555.920680 23909.706
783        No      No   75.177663 52765.978
788        No      No 1180.447542 43914.420
800        No      No   10.188819 33776.825
802        No     Yes  498.505979 16967.620
804       Yes      No 1902.612991 53394.076
807        No      No  418.539870 55002.733
818        No      No  877.793934 30239.721
820        No      No   94.932476 27212.951
825        No      No  787.551772 46185.552
827        No      No 1049.747643 30159.210
828        No      No    0.000000 35738.988
830        No      No  795.541224 51303.140
833        No      No  800.705593 36314.436
838        No      No    0.000000 46353.802
841        No      No 1000.898434 43059.049
848        No      No  388.548350 18007.833
849        No     Yes  842.572226 17279.522
850        No      No  556.115631 44197.908
854        No      No  872.226172 48101.612
855        No      No  415.765429 24740.754
861        No     Yes  163.939823 21083.005
865        No      No 1173.161493 36439.679
867        No      No 1228.907919 46411.820
874        No      No  775.556139 34586.253
876        No      No  801.855034 39156.627
883        No      No  927.165918 33781.815
884        No      No   75.795259 55189.686
887        No     Yes  808.014719 14485.468
895        No      No   57.219838 18982.556
897        No     Yes  383.639664 17445.182
899        No      No  396.985985 55454.631
900        No      No    0.000000 44807.378
921       Yes     Yes 1889.332110 22652.110
923        No      No  343.194499 29555.905
931        No     Yes  631.159770 23245.071
934        No      No 2113.019023 34747.756
942        No     Yes  942.042215 22181.395
944        No      No  285.290876 17606.636
959        No      No  866.045923 44827.266
961        No      No 1554.845545 43901.805
974        No      No  207.895207 52249.312
977        No      No  862.876514 36461.901
979        No      No 1253.181640 71238.551
981        No     Yes 1027.861070 14322.088
992        No      No    0.000000 42284.682
996        No     Yes  731.951715 18117.428
1004       No      No  633.766672 34290.605
1009       No     Yes 1559.627869 22047.782
1012       No      No 1443.648390 45089.390
1013       No      No  791.638233 30303.607
1014       No      No  922.666469 33445.490
1021       No     Yes  773.381163 18978.188
1025       No     Yes 1139.396214 17139.848
1026       No      No 1032.203270 41673.734
1036       No      No  926.985327 48753.313
1037       No      No 1175.420433 37462.643
1045       No     Yes  975.642874 25920.322
1050       No      No 1304.383209 49371.957
1052       No     Yes 1005.593829 15851.483
1058       No      No  547.863342 45966.351
1062       No     Yes   63.036323 12308.018
1071       No      No  253.516796 53125.483
1074       No     Yes  827.041305 18892.821
1076       No     Yes  271.249705 25157.731
1084       No      No 1029.819308 50635.891
1090       No     Yes  985.092699 18499.962
1094       No      No  555.288489 40046.422
1115       No      No  565.505384 39109.310
1122       No     Yes  833.120774 23630.274
1138       No     Yes 1435.181264 11346.842
1141       No     Yes  321.795067 19229.226
1143      Yes     Yes 1402.267516 12104.316
1152       No      No  608.428994 56483.057
1166       No     Yes  876.918625 13372.513
1168       No      No 1129.975937 32795.046
1169       No      No 1077.020824 56862.067
1170       No      No 1411.074241 26040.005
1176       No      No 1387.973385 30716.643
1180       No     Yes 1484.805423 22965.177
1182       No      No  810.412075 28056.784
1187       No     Yes  700.331159 18702.956
1197       No      No  375.700949 37925.975
1199       No      No  318.912568 49305.553
1200       No     Yes  955.120218 25314.853
1203       No      No  278.805260 54559.117
1207       No     Yes  311.530549 18534.431
1221       No      No 1277.795913 56605.599
1222       No     Yes 1200.624471 18973.908
1223       No     Yes 1418.586072 11556.695
1224       No     Yes  480.339704 14592.840
1225       No      No  370.530019 31139.722
1227       No      No  501.921446 41366.678
1236       No      No  549.275970 15706.215
1241       No     Yes  502.797735 13376.053
1247       No     Yes  192.411155 24050.372
1257       No      No 1316.542384 20353.499
1259       No      No 1453.083637 36828.327
1260       No     Yes  323.957087 12327.244
1261       No      No 1152.550664 27346.031
1263       No      No  709.658699 37992.213
1266       No      No    0.000000 17059.368
1267       No     Yes  630.704463 16501.809
1270       No     Yes 1053.161735 25222.979
1272       No     Yes 1762.352183 17032.342
1276       No      No  446.142725 42611.584
1283       No      No    0.000000 49232.707
1292       No      No  198.730918 33512.930
1304       No     Yes  815.077408 18445.660
1305       No     Yes 1026.128247 16430.641
1306       No      No  630.725559 30466.379
1315       No      No  920.647422 37936.089
1321       No      No  429.074698 48109.808
1323       No     Yes  309.524148 12135.038
1326       No      No  872.856966 31471.545
1327       No      No 1105.556173 38886.036
1329       No     Yes 1164.630730 17929.653
1335       No      No  821.493602 34739.395
1339       No     Yes  600.430860 18538.302
1353       No      No  613.742934 56951.360
1354       No      No  362.103498 39658.950
1359       No      No    0.000000 13573.562
1366       No      No  621.736251 51595.752
1368       No      No  636.240520 17355.758
1372       No     Yes  799.743341 16147.577
1389       No      No 1100.238779 34281.255
1397       No     Yes 1334.701119 24621.963
1400       No      No  401.503540 25010.800
1408       No      No  840.105158 33976.708
1413       No      No 1184.212015 34990.581
1422       No     Yes  791.530359 18342.737
1426       No      No 1241.954243 41952.116
1431       No      No  187.310193 31140.747
1435       No      No  355.359646 65798.920
1436       No      No 1138.396686 24098.349
1443       No     Yes  887.290640 14958.551
1444       No      No  938.436914 34184.943
1445       No      No 1076.665439 43972.694
1458       No      No  948.965133 45456.929
1465       No      No 1366.026022 51551.108
1473       No      No  632.803980 51149.425
1485      Yes      No 1790.674983 44607.429
1488      Yes      No 1567.610704 38785.358
1492       No      No  315.012298 44690.498
1494       No      No  851.796275 57950.772
1498       No      No 1243.708322 37926.105
1509       No     Yes  146.151145 15160.489
1514       No     Yes  238.318107 17194.154
1516       No     Yes  740.737951 13065.566
1517       No     Yes  933.711693 11810.555
1521       No      No  835.273500 51471.143
1541       No     Yes  503.216623 21371.246
1542       No      No  215.025329 40399.410
1547       No      No 1143.431379 35773.402
1554       No      No 1536.232276 30635.572
1604       No     Yes 1247.067238 15522.584
1605       No      No  439.068967 47899.170
1608       No      No 1113.276529 51457.539
1609       No      No 1341.077777 40199.841
1611       No      No 1384.264924 27737.609
1613       No      No  745.813205 42762.475
1620       No      No 1085.425572 39274.834
1623       No      No  794.587568 52507.480
1626      Yes      No 1861.060871 55671.724
1627       No      No  900.838759 33130.709
1633       No     Yes 1213.840554 17374.064
1636       No      No  248.041482 36257.161
1643       No     Yes  750.862035 16932.328
1645       No      No  818.060883 35902.472
1648      Yes      No 1456.546056 51508.574
1651       No      No  734.317203 33240.039
1653       No      No 1231.506211 35068.791
1662       No     Yes  685.522535 12361.863
1663       No      No 1262.757445 68579.105
1665       No      No 1181.000359 35123.740
1666       No     Yes  527.653898 17819.965
1670       No      No 1033.121155 66304.774
1672       No     Yes 1319.706449 23373.931
1684       No      No  299.779595 28917.538
1687       No     Yes 1357.849734 11402.541
1693       No      No  640.063894 52413.859
1697       No      No    0.000000 39893.272
1702       No      No 1079.396005 38864.145
1708       No     Yes  403.347053 19690.346
1718       No      No  756.216700 36513.921
1729       No     Yes 1737.607593  7153.540
1731       No      No  994.674438 33002.339
1734       No      No  331.922819 47779.927
1735       No      No  967.135255 23278.666
1736       No      No  132.158429 26878.472
1737       No      No  813.740993 30975.214
1738       No     Yes    0.000000 15986.242
1739       No      No  529.264959 38814.607
1746       No      No 1047.227421 40974.728
1747       No      No 1452.603293 28989.044
1752       No      No  922.696676 34622.619
1762       No      No  946.810051 41237.769
1767       No     Yes 1238.016616 26854.366
1774       No      No  778.830166 44257.331
1779       No      No  465.085535 43480.568
1782       No      No  789.000706 35798.473
1784       No     Yes 1123.595047 16082.906
1793       No     Yes 1345.230627 18518.716
1799       No      No  230.868925 32798.783
1802       No     Yes  970.515947 16584.828
1807       No      No  725.120500 47549.201
1811       No     Yes 1024.024885 18545.900
1814       No      No  321.108807 36275.143
1816       No     Yes 1299.187324 19878.747
1821       No     Yes  904.008927 13996.502
1824       No     Yes  774.413837 12289.864
1834       No      No 1425.801629 34015.850
1841       No     Yes 1176.550060 18662.599
1845      Yes      No 1170.198974 46692.105
1853       No      No  598.513777 42584.121
1855       No      No  911.052233 38629.518
1856       No      No  538.160023 44654.093
1859       No     Yes  516.865449 20179.346
1862       No      No  285.400001 39398.565
1863      Yes      No 1554.816319 26430.489
1864       No      No 1057.015212 54652.710
1865       No     Yes  673.812427 17672.288
1867       No     Yes 1400.344589 14768.696
1870       No      No  639.665261 49977.295
1871       No      No  765.772445 35122.027
1872       No      No  220.368958 24019.311
1874       No     Yes  780.722399 23819.789
1877      Yes      No 1891.109614 34448.694
1885       No      No 1646.613919 39347.457
1896       No      No 1389.386452 39707.990
1898       No      No  196.482990 41972.985
1906       No     Yes 1263.874831 18520.064
1914       No      No  894.275096 36513.539
1917       No     Yes 1204.549630 19058.985
1918       No      No 1666.415624 18916.375
1920       No      No  595.065973 29842.886
1924       No      No 1004.255095 36895.866
1937       No      No  814.553874 39148.558
1939       No     Yes  300.795504 19673.674
1941       No      No    0.000000 54901.822
1956       No      No  181.919779 37725.247
1959       No      No  226.855705 33014.893
1961       No      No  691.928829 23957.715
1970       No      No  408.489247 35984.562
1972       No     Yes  850.159887 26764.292
1975       No      No 1378.169887 48152.988
1981       No      No  702.084751 47811.758
1985       No      No  672.380048 40236.873
1994       No      No  730.179675 42685.185
1995       No      No  152.119513 41847.232
2004       No      No 1391.033809 51881.819
2005       No      No 1338.884597 32500.585
2012       No      No 1010.070759 39456.908
2016       No      No  147.488575 44482.269
2018       No      No  939.420717 55360.033
2026       No      No    0.000000 42009.042
2031       No      No  770.954518 42673.993
2033       No      No   58.443898 44838.695
2038       No     Yes 1300.707924 13675.520
2045       No      No  709.738287 46363.344
2050      Yes      No 1135.047349 48982.226
2063       No      No  656.522701 34229.374
2064       No     Yes 1790.544092 21938.209
2065      Yes     Yes 1925.982795 17763.350
2074       No     Yes    0.000000 19281.715
2076       No      No    0.000000 51480.387
2077       No     Yes    0.000000 13407.759
2084       No     Yes  598.081831 12385.824
2087       No      No    0.000000 46581.362
2093       No     Yes 1805.293071 10405.427
2095       No      No  849.129011 26970.736
2106       No     Yes  446.634847 18309.791
2107       No      No 1277.793381 35620.156
2113       No      No  573.584803 54427.921
2115       No      No  455.348417 41378.997
2124       No      No  948.777979 24094.786
2125       No      No  626.516142 49207.001
2128       No      No  847.635895 33199.375
2129       No      No  241.940740 47843.080
2130       No      No  616.538678 31925.183
2147       No      No    0.000000 22535.506
2150       No      No  721.093434 41411.144
2154       No      No 1194.597579 38222.506
2168       No      No  556.444838 39707.109
2169       No     Yes  306.610770 11511.884
2174      Yes     Yes 1724.963232 22170.687
2183       No     Yes  330.936108 21272.307
2186       No      No  916.073000 42201.821
2187       No      No 1263.676788 25695.481
2188       No      No    0.000000 42118.197
2194       No      No 1153.021310 20586.278
2195       No      No 1470.342593 26136.744
2205       No     Yes 1889.678319 14756.900
2214       No     Yes 1291.915263 17910.065
2216       No      No   30.824450 35960.606
2220       No     Yes  651.550005 17743.066
2222       No     Yes 1181.513221 11784.802
2225       No     Yes 1333.097471 29363.972
2227       No      No  494.653229 40377.668
2239       No      No  137.724617 44747.328
2245       No      No  424.285797 35675.741
2246       No      No 1477.669207 42011.808
2248       No      No  903.549305 46971.562
2255       No     Yes  287.607413 24440.225
2258       No     Yes 1137.028318 25117.763
2260       No      No 1193.676973 34360.910
2266       No     Yes  873.678652 17655.710
2268       No      No  309.823995 28139.626
2269       No      No  286.852327 18402.165
2270       No      No  509.852254 49345.426
2280       No      No  380.333108 30890.074
2285       No     Yes  803.961105 13172.871
2290       No      No 1351.962465 43630.037
2292       No      No  442.590925 38947.354
2294       No      No 1063.797087 41157.357
2296       No      No 1258.576399 33571.145
2298       No      No   38.407785 38702.102
2300       No      No    0.000000 47437.512
2305       No      No  744.766200 35067.644
2315       No      No  414.857562 38030.825
2320       No     Yes  461.782765 17609.831
2325       No      No    0.000000 37409.003
2326       No      No  610.597752 22635.066
2333       No      No 1037.008599 36622.792
2336       No      No  589.542017 28237.821
2337       No      No  754.127490 41341.803
2338       No      No  911.926442 41249.282
2339       No      No  311.918279 39694.484
2348       No      No  421.146500 61655.348
2356       No     Yes 1234.942716 26919.116
2363       No     Yes 1730.291081 19446.676
2367       No     Yes 1764.532309 18148.524
2369       No      No  943.132390 30178.734
2379       No      No 1141.442176 27914.402
2390       No      No  834.711895 28553.472
2394       No     Yes  850.677279 21251.640
2399       No      No 1046.416673 47598.307
2404       No      No  377.713996 46729.333
2405       No      No  994.990170 39315.956
2407       No      No  736.590612 37031.485
2410       No      No 1161.239934 52064.471
2413       No      No 1155.399548 34539.564
2422       No      No 1169.834113 39386.370
2426       No      No  608.948580 26463.375
2431       No      No  561.433746 37884.961
2435       No      No 1349.571750 50645.291
2436       No     Yes 1150.431680 11666.990
2440       No     Yes  852.313952 15956.649
2441       No      No 1378.940514 43998.141
2442       No     Yes 1005.521508 22128.080
2447       No      No  759.345815 32066.707
2461      Yes     Yes 2110.556858 19345.105
2469       No     Yes 1032.670815 13901.119
2475       No     Yes 1080.071527 11239.531
2476       No      No  589.217895 47722.170
2483       No      No  681.417623 26426.229
2488       No      No  754.477578 31592.200
2492       No      No  410.099265 37328.455
2493       No      No   59.132499 34162.235
2494       No     Yes 1939.712360 13836.986
2503       No      No 1306.796916 48799.512
2505       No     Yes 1052.875142 13486.147
2507       No     Yes 2052.133463 13130.654
2514       No     Yes  992.440019 14207.268
2521       No      No 1475.207229 42243.177
2524       No      No 1304.700879 45162.651
2526       No      No 1261.268219 39984.530
2527       No     Yes   30.583672 16246.573
2528       No     Yes  437.035236 16261.208
2533       No     Yes 1322.492812 22930.445
2552       No     Yes 1427.124037 12553.887
2554       No     Yes 1128.141493 10159.242
2556       No     Yes  805.398005 17902.579
2564       No      No  309.862823 56100.054
2566       No     Yes  775.589233 17030.579
2568       No      No 1037.155516 38490.385
2576       No      No  652.817454 41161.857
2584       No      No  412.687613 33923.458
2591       No     Yes  792.975486 17346.171
2593       No      No 1060.016921 39757.438
2600       No     Yes  943.501721 14123.704
2604       No      No  961.999353 37073.192
2611       No      No  179.700071 37727.535
2627       No      No   90.933447 42451.736
2628       No      No 1230.424256 51716.740
2629       No      No  201.558399 27924.847
2630       No     Yes 1562.846155 10353.904
2634       No      No  947.423970 38505.784
2643       No      No  266.647086 16515.308
2644       No     Yes 1339.363614 19496.165
2647       No      No  948.494278 40739.860
2648       No     Yes 1312.933780 20208.545
2652       No     Yes  859.336964 13993.655
2657       No     Yes  631.600848 17845.074
2658       No      No 1236.617914 40668.725
2661       No      No 1054.222110 50900.243
2662       No      No  959.600287 29850.212
2672       No     Yes  961.575564  9681.494
2673       No     Yes  516.121960 17538.462
2678       No     Yes 1015.204535 22208.329
2680       No     Yes 1082.284133 19451.816
2695      Yes      No 1804.036475 31318.296
2696       No      No 1266.113867 29698.516
2712       No      No  708.813976 38295.234
2713       No      No  257.396383 49477.786
2726       No      No  650.418341 47122.072
2727       No     Yes 1382.438231 15680.610
2729       No      No 1424.351218 37845.999
2740       No      No 1755.388910 35031.532
2748       No      No  763.855625 52938.035
2756       No      No  733.199915 34524.919
2759       No      No  943.165719 40369.698
2773       No      No  561.968473 37637.005
2774       No      No  595.486701 34470.418
2780       No      No 1011.431543 36364.754
2782       No     Yes 1154.432105 15221.172
2786       No     Yes  968.671101 22212.741
2788       No     Yes  636.897823 18620.239
2792       No      No  706.974278 46165.155
2803       No     Yes    0.000000 20067.810
2808       No     Yes 1211.040146 16898.129
2818       No      No 1402.690527 39656.632
2824       No      No  365.235880 21358.000
2827       No      No 1006.719786 47784.318
2829       No      No  777.530809 45673.674
2833       No      No    0.000000 30208.046
2834       No      No 1820.325490 31309.998
2836       No      No  837.752621 31017.901
2843       No      No  578.460742 20306.936
2852       No     Yes 1448.060458 21028.287
2864       No      No  888.081432 54072.657
2866       No     Yes 1016.450616 15099.530
2867       No      No 1036.460728 42914.982
2868       No     Yes 1060.220034 22795.943
2875       No      No  868.006030 50549.533
2878       No     Yes  826.453637 21342.703
2879       No     Yes  703.990009 20752.175
2884       No      No 1053.014778 54009.632
2891       No      No  474.355264 58068.622
2893       No      No  292.384144 33961.100
2895       No      No   76.064088 50054.762
2896       No     Yes 1270.092810 16809.006
2899       No      No  279.963388 30262.117
2904       No     Yes  728.549399 22891.929
2905       No      No    0.000000 48365.578
2910       No      No 1526.268669 44845.136
2912       No      No 1004.641773 56533.313
2919       No      No    0.000000 33146.495
2938       No      No 1504.596940 30773.743
2939       No      No 1276.489300 35122.854
2940       No      No  874.915043 25023.323
2944       No      No 1055.410868 33945.143
2953       No      No  584.356741 34128.767
2963       No     Yes 1275.538565 16445.625
2973       No      No  285.910169 43263.631
2979       No      No 1080.185777 38398.866
2980       No      No  906.478544 47101.991
2982       No      No 1215.867359 42762.122
2983       No      No  217.361521 45083.111
2986       No      No 1615.225001 55219.520
2987       No     Yes 1119.001789 22811.394
2990       No     Yes  831.818536 16164.485
2995       No      No 1010.809065 42163.454
2999       No     Yes 1824.368004 20074.281
3003       No      No  576.635577 41699.210
3006       No      No  778.693493 48551.971
3009       No     Yes  153.400096 17840.385
3012       No      No  645.372565 30102.036
3013       No      No    0.000000 49010.273
3015       No     Yes  569.498791 19755.521
3016       No      No 1287.765895 38507.119
3017       No      No 1177.815070 32294.546
3022       No      No  942.737482 38908.881
3024       No      No    0.000000 55158.151
3035       No      No  982.450945 42907.026
3041      Yes     Yes 1500.894533 15802.233
3045       No      No  376.878917 50671.323
3049       No      No  421.172382 42721.478
3051       No      No    0.000000 41663.340
3068       No      No  640.918439 37306.694
3079       No     Yes  979.877155 13522.422
3080       No     Yes  778.249905 23805.911
3087       No      No  638.229501 53812.798
3090       No      No  507.526535 58027.771
3101       No     Yes 1417.225499 16053.974
3105       No     Yes 1624.795642 10623.597
3106       No      No  645.949271 46406.338
3108       No      No 1168.284538 46904.604
3111       No      No  525.890338 45530.509
3114       No      No  913.913966 53809.330
3124      Yes     Yes 2169.196187 18195.267
3128       No      No  448.039968 29537.310
3129       No      No 1188.072875 40704.707
3133       No      No    0.000000 47628.412
3134       No      No 1423.284258 48914.197
3139       No      No  533.989148 64930.240
3140       No     Yes 1626.634079 17721.630
3147       No      No 1265.954833 27233.563
3148       No      No 1303.626132 40010.465
3154       No      No  745.733893 60180.561
3161       No      No 1253.699614 37645.800
3166       No      No  505.697873 31971.313
3168       No      No  981.492213 30385.069
3176       No     Yes 1795.716870 12547.829
3178       No     Yes  990.354260 18998.091
3180       No      No  272.873129 44249.679
3182      Yes      No 1751.347088 38381.586
3187       No      No  403.034377 48874.151
3196       No      No  493.533675 49735.568
3206       No      No  491.520311 37128.774
3208       No      No 1036.503746 37151.411
3209       No      No 1130.893933 35235.366
3213       No      No    0.000000 40341.339
3224       No     Yes 1092.342550 20465.154
3234       No     Yes  484.894317 15883.664
3242       No      No 1289.602237 35164.890
3243       No      No 1054.278499 50795.207
3248       No      No  412.071615 48347.297
3254       No      No 1738.110835 38821.626
3261       No      No  975.571998 28804.000
3263       No      No  713.436813 48176.428
3265       No     Yes  687.064419 14059.458
3267       No      No 1061.284237 32839.345
3268       No      No 1425.495582 37189.025
3273       No     Yes 1152.096644 15852.423
3283       No      No  995.274152 24782.877
3285       No      No 1358.573433 20700.706
3286      Yes      No 1166.798527 30367.611
3293       No      No  618.801159 25927.572
3294       No      No 1310.952365 28978.464
3296       No      No  786.264219 45304.793
3298      Yes     Yes 2124.489239 12651.074
3302       No      No 1611.333882 47894.277
3307      Yes      No 1302.734742 43680.065
3311       No      No  623.574809 57483.504
3315      Yes     Yes 2008.032985 18601.403
3321       No      No 1110.743705 43991.920
3325       No      No 1066.792794 49629.903
3331       No     Yes 1335.131324 17044.365
3337       No      No  439.201792 42132.014
3340       No      No  206.820878 49221.149
3350       No      No  551.254052 48007.992
3351       No     Yes 1521.496682 16830.565
3353       No      No  770.081935 38010.261
3363       No      No  435.402804 35168.727
3366       No     Yes  856.624728 19056.868
3367       No     Yes  934.252048 20747.212
3368       No      No  783.122960 36514.690
3372       No      No  668.942260 42028.924
3374       No      No  766.008842 45155.097
3376       No      No  265.435891 34040.548
3385       No     Yes 1340.529200 19318.840
3387       No      No  317.903574 42209.487
3404       No      No  924.692705 38676.970
3406       No      No  696.510067 28610.195
3408       No      No  464.762682 17862.227
3416       No      No 1203.736179 40969.082
3418       No     Yes  884.918847 27208.771
3421       No     Yes  670.493493 16513.044
3422       No      No  874.847286 36709.108
3423       No      No    0.000000 40021.355
3424       No      No  827.350474 43833.424
3427       No     Yes  914.515479  7525.584
3431       No      No 1120.267458 45153.040
3435       No      No  560.968074 43254.715
3484       No      No  784.383692 44927.496
3490       No     Yes 1334.666264 18064.778
3509       No     Yes 1328.671531 13389.434
3511       No     Yes 1093.639058 14790.769
3517       No      No  563.491173 47142.450
3519       No      No 1610.719681 30098.824
3521       No      No  586.169070 31466.851
3524       No      No 1650.896019 43478.128
3526       No      No 1955.557356 45507.912
3535       No      No  753.960829 21507.995
3538       No     Yes   16.414884 24291.349
3539       No      No  763.900776 64967.640
3552       No      No  610.568639 36145.017
3556       No      No 1074.143357 35054.584
3559       No      No   46.183288 42533.715
3562       No      No  503.513809 62115.105
3567       No      No 1372.935822 35467.758
3576       No      No  835.533443 23160.579
3577       No      No  698.673829 29580.069
3589       No     Yes  925.904861 20952.586
3593       No      No 1071.899150 54791.806
3610       No      No  917.783980 44466.885
3612       No      No  379.063068 14792.512
3613      Yes     Yes 2004.394001 18860.847
3616       No      No  843.429659 39512.069
3621       No      No  908.184443 37319.623
3623       No     Yes 1326.848392 20790.254
3625       No     Yes 1084.381324 20881.457
3633       No     Yes  969.784159 21412.601
3635       No      No 1015.045427 31026.413
3664       No     Yes 1402.310570 21566.557
3669       No      No 1255.920125 43929.143
3671       No      No  691.893199 35562.609
3673       No      No  437.546069 31537.127
3676       No     Yes 1348.995320 25805.810
3691       No      No  450.309012 46172.725
3698       No     Yes  961.797821 13389.069
3701       No      No    0.000000 34563.046
3703       No     Yes 2370.463612 24251.959
3706       No      No 1474.061544 47040.809
3710       No     Yes  747.821683 19330.308
3713       No      No  701.918157 53151.761
3716       No      No  889.901200 20805.614
3717       No     Yes  579.721305 18555.753
3723       No     Yes  452.302356 19922.640
3724       No      No  431.904928 30115.153
3731       No      No    0.000000 55069.812
3736       No     Yes 1507.892451 14632.258
3738       No      No 1159.936580 46789.881
3747       No      No  202.321208 37188.569
3750       No      No 1106.697012 51879.718
3754       No      No  460.873865 49243.445
3765       No      No    0.000000 26275.257
3771       No      No  891.607304 43925.964
3780       No      No  549.191343 43688.680
3786       No      No  965.926572 29219.071
3787       No      No 1768.139978 30762.105
3790       No     Yes  745.230621 12877.510
3791       No      No  161.759487 43676.057
3801       No      No  116.218876 50109.023
3804       No      No  239.384479 25485.173
3808       No      No  232.207550 11151.048
3822       No     Yes 1399.950257 11010.212
3835       No      No  654.277589 37706.595
3839       No      No  988.393947 49804.284
3842       No      No  618.051385 16944.344
3845       No      No  517.459621 39543.587
3856      Yes     Yes 2321.882221 21331.315
3862       No      No    0.000000 44225.616
3866       No      No    0.000000 45104.094
3867       No      No 1028.174611 51228.302
3878       No      No  474.666106 42058.777
3881       No     Yes  552.204087 22554.579
3883       No      No  407.289756 45376.236
3904       No     Yes  973.903110 21590.035
3920       No      No 1290.191542 36898.929
3927       No      No  872.071358 36004.645
3928       No      No    0.000000 28659.488
3930       No     Yes  361.610467 21685.692
3937       No      No  760.720824 40854.469
3938       No      No  883.016251 37961.156
3943       No      No  829.281651 58070.113
3953       No      No  131.576673 51106.995
3954       No     Yes 1096.184606 15535.549
3956       No      No 1236.218720 37884.566
3957       No      No  637.014541 27828.138
3960       No     Yes  113.276476 21068.164
3971       No      No  964.524656 40814.653
3972       No      No 1139.370702 42759.383
3976       No     Yes 1288.551958 24918.415
3980       No      No 1352.703443 35743.004
3981       No     Yes  886.348540 17534.467
3987       No      No 1055.414789 29967.173
3992       No      No  431.536055 46941.059
3993       No      No  851.103567 53433.574
4005       No      No 1097.039083 40021.353
4013       No      No 1023.198467 40866.019
4017       No      No 1008.357462 39610.625
4020       No     Yes 1215.383610 15994.041
4028       No      No 1121.496586 39395.899
4036       No      No  903.925864 27395.796
4038       No      No  539.887947 33856.454
4040       No      No  739.859748 30853.293
4041       No     Yes  408.562974 18471.774
4047       No      No    0.000000 53273.342
4059       No     Yes  710.779997 17625.968
4070       No     Yes 1409.989102 21569.891
4077       No     Yes 1497.364809 10576.341
4080      Yes     Yes 2047.417007 13678.508
4083       No     Yes    0.000000 20565.778
4085       No      No  971.960011 33543.335
4086       No      No  887.594632 59416.160
4087       No      No 1312.847706 64402.609
4089       No      No 1170.743464 49832.951
4098       No     Yes 1418.388650 12788.719
4100       No     Yes 1493.106066 14295.665
4104       No      No  686.869876 32359.337
4106       No      No  814.286312 36613.707
4107       No      No 1569.518216 43024.971
4115       No      No  673.926657 39508.624
4129       No      No 1288.252682 42226.462
4134       No      No 1184.210495 38409.536
4140       No      No    0.000000 47895.805
4141       No      No  606.581005 32497.449
4151       No      No 1512.256314 35652.768
4155       No      No  848.997263 44379.753
4163       No      No  948.689702 39671.534
4167       No     Yes 1770.796815 18837.420
4171       No      No 1041.071523 41485.624
4172       No      No  293.655375 38893.605
4184       No      No  202.070433 28814.175
4185       No      No  625.399025 52074.968
4191       No     Yes   15.153793 13430.416
4196       No      No  891.394822 43535.940
4200       No      No  817.085888 55892.726
4201       No     Yes  908.848634 20332.391
4207       No      No   66.772722 43189.665
4209       No      No 1309.405746 34469.980
4214       No     Yes  453.643970  9770.006
4215       No     Yes 1799.149349 20215.624
4218       No     Yes  341.485593 21278.826
4228       No      No  776.964679 36704.052
4231       No      No    0.000000 30143.964
4237       No     Yes  564.738467 15411.192
4243       No      No  684.186024 45400.017
4254       No      No  462.138387 44546.237
4257       No      No 1432.298465 31250.583
4261       No     Yes  320.012202 14704.478
4265       No      No 1258.878806 40858.868
4267       No      No 1464.028962 43700.143
4273       No      No 1203.205839 43809.260
4285       No      No  748.704836 48036.079
4295       No     Yes  918.590687 14936.708
4316       No      No   89.410102 24086.601
4321       No      No 1177.920843 30169.296
4323       No      No 1114.536871 35044.730
4327       No     Yes  729.189718 18329.721
4338       No      No 1082.119828 43256.401
4350       No      No  557.261712 45040.944
4354       No      No  763.177239 42481.499
4360       No     Yes  724.904735 16643.127
4362       No      No 1441.743359 45037.168
4367       No      No 1257.958107 38532.192
4369       No      No  605.124432 29769.978
4370       No      No  601.081665 45607.347
4401       No      No  537.040333 21364.310
4405       No      No  463.932561 37842.048
4409      Yes      No 1350.603261 21541.299
4415       No     Yes   62.237128 20267.500
4416       No      No 1133.112585 23110.654
4417       No      No  748.487596 36453.645
4425       No     Yes  478.961864 19911.510
4426       No      No  145.476590 41196.420
4429       No      No  536.214278 47956.525
4433       No      No  825.287866 46147.956
4441       No      No  775.022945 39137.077
4442       No      No    0.000000 46542.985
4443       No     Yes  819.727713 10175.310
4450       No     Yes  457.235747  5296.711
4453       No     Yes 1130.544640 20862.904
4454       No      No  486.576050 27687.341
4467       No      No  883.867885 42866.384
4469       No      No  657.687618 26454.586
4473       No      No  358.848341 44486.906
4474       No      No  421.759625 35522.666
4481       No     Yes 1236.678437 16298.568
4497       No      No  815.566907 31752.077
4500       No      No  623.092054 42035.453
4507       No      No 1004.116828 52822.404
4510      Yes      No 1854.604154 38406.356
4513       No     Yes 1127.993934 15186.869
4516       No     Yes 1068.860742 20804.379
4522       No      No 1358.132472 49903.597
4525       No      No 1146.614029 40870.901
4535       No      No  739.901843 47349.532
4541       No      No  906.081360 45720.013
4546       No     Yes  250.173010 17439.629
4552       No     Yes  851.729730 14726.376
4555       No      No  819.018615 49111.392
4558       No     Yes 1200.376613 10817.562
4571       No      No  309.838215 54945.582
4572       No      No 1477.528611 36709.668
4573       No      No   79.538950 34417.376
4575       No      No  812.588032 43980.140
4579       No      No  856.282960 40394.050
4592       No     Yes 1238.589510 10514.829
4607       No      No  635.741696 21297.120
4608       No      No  484.515769 39775.250
4616       No     Yes  251.971745 11757.963
4631       No     Yes  602.307676 11019.587
4638       No      No  367.668096 50025.945
4642       No     Yes  532.382135 17704.814
4643       No     Yes 1346.679507 16104.895
4644       No      No  334.466420 40156.244
4645       No      No    0.000000 36179.827
4646       No     Yes  774.498460 10333.801
4654       No     Yes 1457.858845 17365.567
4670       No     Yes  604.592700 14896.592
4682      Yes      No 1488.469925 36457.223
4687       No     Yes  801.049716 14679.833
4691       No      No  786.987434 33289.851
4693       No      No  173.959461 53965.051
4700       No      No  366.701552 60456.118
4702       No      No    0.000000 33272.152
4708       No      No    0.000000 47447.797
4716       No      No 1023.147921 43698.817
4724       No     Yes 1391.335002 18309.421
4726       No      No  548.645308 38094.426
4729       No      No  863.138441 58119.717
4753       No      No 1529.687857 40977.414
4755       No     Yes  756.995609 26674.391
4771       No     Yes 1055.017327 24188.050
4784       No      No 1208.395128 32430.183
4790       No      No  815.244183 26231.465
4795       No      No  847.432632 37303.574
4800       No     Yes  673.473689 20926.499
4805       No      No 1010.516286 36298.995
4806       No     Yes  613.156883 17665.478
4812       No      No 1210.176036 29460.192
4818       No     Yes 1436.676385 14418.166
4822       No      No  929.925922 34535.455
4827       No      No  890.565508 14327.991
4828       No      No  678.466829 40803.575
4829       No      No 1462.223173 29574.235
4832       No     Yes 2216.329753 24737.082
4858       No      No  854.913442 39190.296
4864       No      No  698.440564 21903.038
4869       No      No  615.477641 45792.900
4871       No      No  956.922613 50834.408
4888       No      No  963.092669 33110.304
4890       No      No   68.305932 52323.902
4896       No      No  655.832042 37267.583
4898       No      No  881.256511 41728.846
4900       No      No 1158.379804 61054.764
4902       No     Yes  465.583629 15625.634
4913       No      No  908.926548 40757.094
4917       No      No 1124.249135 27521.152
4921       No      No    0.000000 16601.635
4924       No      No  699.053866 41722.806
4926       No      No 1380.749804 52664.877
4933       No     Yes 1306.046537 20776.389
4936       No      No  758.134285 33220.575
4944       No     Yes  690.421049 19273.732
4948       No      No    0.000000 47669.704
4953      Yes      No 1028.767207 40346.833
4960       No     Yes 1520.442101 18462.431
4963       No      No  681.693576 33327.113
4964       No      No  376.034544 50748.272
4975       No      No    0.000000 35377.141
4977       No      No 1248.375749 37469.865
4985       No      No  260.162175 33551.715
4990       No      No    0.000000 38686.675
4993       No      No 1316.057411 45308.564
4999       No      No  960.912668 29304.458
5003       No      No  610.500867 28664.043
5005       No      No  326.873676 48756.028
5006       No     Yes  325.282820 15644.242
5009       No      No  929.085468 35571.777
5011       No      No    0.000000 26598.643
5013       No      No  986.358895 41688.064
5025       No     Yes 1340.966389 18725.954
5026       No      No 1252.894039 35587.724
5031       No      No  568.352004 38963.959
5037       No      No  863.954855 17159.163
5039      Yes      No 1586.502199 48925.933
5044       No      No    0.000000 33322.482
5051       No      No  131.747076 36947.779
5058       No      No  758.021078 55278.592
5067       No      No 1795.883711 25878.519
5070       No      No  731.477128 18843.271
5073       No      No  218.114854 38766.108
5082       No      No  896.027136 30452.037
5083       No      No  803.764578 48013.610
5094       No     Yes  711.582823 17780.760
5104       No      No  775.309789 38721.246
5110       No      No 1012.768454 36406.241
5112       No      No  452.372651 59429.123
5120       No     Yes  267.327829 19698.714
5122       No      No  129.596449 52169.232
5123       No      No  327.240437 40061.625
5124       No      No  678.071106 63791.824
5128       No     Yes 1300.720433  9266.530
5130       No      No 1308.529172 57190.875
5133       No     Yes  819.834292 16412.997
5143       No      No  613.231402 34664.571
5152       No      No  692.155234 37592.261
5155       No      No 1394.125443 42921.017
5167       No      No 1489.357027 37758.413
5168       No      No 1527.359325 33923.529
5169       No     Yes 1427.049384 18268.527
5172       No      No  866.299669 65931.951
5174       No      No  836.192865 43275.145
5187       No      No  993.647093 26768.957
5200       No      No  957.238960 57698.408
5206       No     Yes  491.704321  8352.209
5217       No      No  290.145959 32862.555
5229       No      No 1046.562865 26555.489
5231       No      No  642.234628 35800.084
5232       No      No  391.989952 35012.870
5233       No      No 1483.689011 58310.512
5236       No      No    0.000000 41693.386
5239       No      No  634.477776 56726.120
5242       No     Yes 2018.358536 15472.850
5246       No      No 1589.990919 42268.280
5247       No      No    0.000000 57898.415
5254       No      No  761.750634 13889.133
5258       No     Yes 1101.160092 14307.001
5259       No      No    0.000000 46615.698
5261       No      No  582.317222 29239.846
5266       No      No  460.879416 40046.029
5272       No      No 1057.275000 42731.876
5276       No      No  656.023725 36349.437
5290       No     Yes 1639.426608 14682.777
5294       No      No  967.441574 51674.419
5296       No      No 1547.880790 50638.340
5299       No      No 1454.981589 43821.221
5310       No     Yes 1887.881716 21901.182
5313       No      No  576.796120 39209.833
5320       No     Yes 1474.779605 17382.467
5327       No     Yes  806.669236 17359.675
5328       No      No  528.089316 46389.341
5334       No     Yes 1220.524914 12195.362
5351       No      No  182.325444 39703.269
5353       No      No  405.273981 52571.184
5365       No      No  728.186898 52515.068
5370       No     Yes 1370.248937 13358.274
5373       No     Yes  786.106024 20954.452
5379       No     Yes 1381.644434 11059.568
5381       No      No 1357.909718 43377.112
5383       No      No  798.859637 48336.129
5397      Yes      No 1969.942924 29415.753
5400       No      No 1177.249598 35419.610
5412       No      No 1025.527625 22741.391
5416       No     Yes  963.899258 16561.256
5422       No     Yes  731.314859 11510.151
5429       No      No 1320.711115 29105.442
5430       No     Yes 1203.029399 15952.452
5435       No     Yes 1277.894900 20649.930
5443       No      No   10.194457 32641.933
5444       No      No  933.554734 33633.149
5448       No      No  797.742647 53398.929
5449       No      No    0.000000 50243.931
5451       No      No    0.000000 44980.293
5458       No     Yes  699.173401 17572.831
5464       No      No  997.379504 34824.848
5468       No     Yes  776.606473  4755.252
5472       No      No    0.000000 48672.956
5479       No      No 1334.105928 43704.431
5481       No      No 1282.076946 52753.077
5482       No      No  932.828730 48165.180
5486       No      No  874.478742 33485.521
5495       No      No 1043.390338 45309.949
5507      Yes     Yes 1102.434982 17391.780
5509       No     Yes  974.014385 20108.104
5520       No      No  697.666383 35402.268
5531       No     Yes  862.902254 16157.867
5534       No      No  481.862028 32928.239
5537       No      No  514.849025 37656.848
5538       No      No 2087.678741 44997.364
5552       No      No  493.959990 34621.758
5553       No      No   88.254057 43927.316
5559       No      No 1149.689188 39974.563
5560       No     Yes  463.300005 16416.613
5566       No      No  578.290657 48044.384
5569       No      No 1115.738777 48125.647
5574       No     Yes  865.205866 22081.582
5576       No      No  950.341275 64396.165
5582       No      No 1096.246733 42685.107
5586       No     Yes 1217.309875 10520.043
5612       No      No    0.000000 29721.342
5614       No      No  680.164459 25391.633
5615       No      No 1231.351894 29867.876
5617       No      No  830.046094 51847.123
5625       No     Yes  925.896917 12384.204
5635       No      No  796.991208 25159.555
5638       No      No 1217.210527 33865.051
5643       No      No  413.888272 53142.024
5648       No      No  853.246222 41581.195
5649       No      No 1911.668517 52802.089
5655       No     Yes 1415.681994 21856.321
5656       No     Yes 1524.486833 15845.871
5657       No     Yes 1171.441401 19213.386
5659       No      No 1236.158124 19682.711
5675      Yes      No 2075.327892 43817.499
5687       No      No  691.892090 32512.195
5688       No     Yes 1097.969621 16275.684
5691       No      No 1230.903161 44303.198
5697       No      No  858.179965 30892.736
5701       No      No  456.003327 29898.005
5703       No      No  586.968885 50317.653
5705       No      No  419.729052 37444.536
5713       No     Yes  319.262676 24881.386
5716       No      No  984.439163 25294.868
5717       No      No  947.795904 45284.206
5721       No     Yes  645.338827 20122.202
5723       No     Yes  912.832537 19467.979
5725       No     Yes 1376.340022 17101.428
5727       No     Yes  903.458650 17254.961
5734       No      No  507.246294 46106.233
5740       No      No 1943.932300 24193.609
5741       No      No  415.288752 35790.131
5742       No     Yes 1169.420444 19879.248
5760       No      No  539.805316 35924.610
5763       No      No    0.000000 29675.040
5766       No      No  854.140623 52239.800
5767       No      No  468.549457 53273.919
5769       No      No  897.285609 66547.915
5771       No      No  194.575967 44543.781
5774       No      No  630.028951 43547.542
5778       No      No 1384.850571 40131.494
5780       No      No  229.214974 68145.134
5788       No      No  250.835245 58139.022
5791       No     Yes 1506.911513 23375.646
5794       No     Yes  789.283588 20370.174
5795       No      No   41.359176 47351.834
5807       No     Yes  892.383861 17841.523
5810       No     Yes 1058.867384 16059.833
5811       No      No  857.699665 43162.674
5812       No      No 1429.767205 37255.911
5814       No      No  572.186730 35926.376
5815       No      No 1438.758473 24061.648
5818       No      No 1091.418551 43091.157
5820       No      No  607.431270 34541.302
5821      Yes      No 1258.764794 26331.372
5822       No      No 1026.702707 33915.049
5823       No     Yes  590.566233  9143.396
5829       No      No  923.685583 38403.011
5843       No      No 1294.903234 52338.221
5846       No      No    0.000000 24461.854
5848       No     Yes  571.577122 15325.079
5860       No      No  637.902181 48425.723
5863       No      No 1517.918958 49400.171
5864       No      No  190.641105 31463.420
5867       No      No 1637.839922 34107.081
5869       No      No  255.117031 55980.074
5877       No      No  409.404020 48746.434
5880       No      No  324.885414 36555.400
5889       No      No  340.999798 48058.383
5891      Yes     Yes 2145.607674 23516.191
5892       No      No  654.416010 47244.704
5898       No     Yes  946.367150 12532.658
5902       No      No 1265.535986 35133.217
5905       No      No  817.927710 59431.839
5907       No      No  836.343137 34559.158
5916       No     Yes  470.912347 24074.365
5919       No     Yes 1151.899517 15097.512
5925       No     Yes  375.306305 19342.158
5931       No     Yes  795.139554 24606.154
5936       No      No 1059.872271 38698.673
5943       No      No  192.627463 38042.018
5950       No     Yes  957.630204 15018.914
5951       No      No  274.424221 31292.627
5953       No      No  319.807607 45202.635
5957       No     Yes  867.441645 16396.682
5958       No     Yes  271.730926 14215.093
5961       No      No  730.633559 42300.147
5962       No      No    0.000000 56610.236
5965       No     Yes 1181.586009 22142.052
5966       No      No    0.000000 45235.291
5967       No      No  272.219928 47757.824
5969       No      No  812.889626 48563.800
5972       No      No  334.019495 40916.033
5974       No      No 1569.870324 55938.766
5976       No      No 1376.113241 63073.445
5982      Yes     Yes 2125.792202 19539.149
5988       No     Yes 1300.889693 14156.646
5992       No      No  661.528186 58519.860
5993       No      No  630.714845 53546.571
5999       No      No  199.454790 57455.210
6002       No     Yes  604.758740 19369.349
6003       No      No  384.331069 34232.069
6004       No      No 1399.573561 23577.765
6007       No     Yes  145.002121 19927.092
6010       No     Yes 1002.419250 17797.344
6011       No     Yes 1004.844323 20249.207
6015       No      No  796.836730 29397.884
6023       No     Yes 1004.273646 17069.524
6028       No      No 1075.118346 47566.784
6039       No      No    0.000000 34701.196
6041       No      No 1384.392454 35499.527
6042       No      No  713.067544 44413.751
6043       No      No  590.676533 26673.848
6045       No      No  208.007706 42399.530
6047       No      No  773.172691 49308.165
6052       No     Yes 1297.265043 16864.435
6058       No      No  676.098860 38571.414
6060       No      No 1068.146350 27859.864
6065       No      No  123.286068 47467.959
6068       No     Yes  781.680396 21342.479
6070       No      No  509.156011 47444.151
6078      Yes      No 2187.224846 42205.123
6080       No      No 1339.603177 46442.354
6081       No     Yes  793.347451 11495.393
6083       No      No  867.629483 43091.936
6085       No      No  312.415489 47118.999
6090       No      No 1066.296558 42247.779
6099       No      No  460.430191 56002.223
6104       No     Yes  787.618249 11928.555
6112       No      No  591.066666 43869.316
6120       No     Yes 1856.605596 17845.337
6121       No      No  607.837992 33737.175
6125       No      No  777.016248 52797.939
6130       No      No  768.154884 39701.935
6133       No      No  442.827580 42004.197
6135       No     Yes  904.056316 23188.715
6137       No      No 1001.331745 47640.737
6138      Yes      No 1631.615617 38906.956
6139       No      No  790.740518 45900.297
6143       No      No  738.192929 54491.143
6146       No      No  638.540333 20607.459
6148       No      No 1056.443662 31268.737
6155       No      No  268.954350 55892.727
6159       No      No  866.729785 36452.722
6166       No     Yes  176.533835 15175.586
6169       No      No   20.964504 62862.752
6175       No     Yes  671.175869 17564.955
6176       No      No  275.624647 35761.317
6180       No     Yes 1231.212923 20000.063
6184       No      No 1316.421810 45806.902
6187       No      No 1281.520648 37665.294
6191       No      No  351.945107 48726.048
6195       No      No  360.089179 44448.916
6196       No      No  105.441004 35291.463
6202       No     Yes 1001.785683 24771.727
6206       No      No  824.241433 53320.283
6215       No     Yes 1208.144482 17721.294
6234       No     Yes  503.156388 18728.297
6239       No      No  494.660496 47035.755
6261       No     Yes 1395.961882 23717.851
6266       No      No 1567.763856 39201.242
6267       No      No  753.686888 42230.648
6268       No      No   72.371953 28717.941
6270       No     Yes  980.164350 13713.502
6282       No      No  688.022470 29019.818
6283       No      No  599.428359 36654.648
6294       No      No 1715.282689 60137.634
6295       No      No  450.335580 20080.102
6296       No      No  740.580773 20717.544
6309       No      No    0.000000 36338.848
6312       No      No  766.430430 39078.797
6314       No      No 1142.935154 34401.667
6317       No     Yes  938.605975 24392.104
6318       No      No  321.039743 37026.587
6319       No      No  943.387641 39415.596
6338       No      No  504.604495 31870.018
6340       No      No  473.027458 43016.861
6346       No      No 1153.331896 37936.087
6349       No     Yes 1106.453525 14840.938
6354       No     Yes 1035.916689 10607.906
6356       No      No  772.809220 39944.607
6357       No      No 1014.973979 41993.641
6361       No      No  499.550744 45954.671
6377       No      No  563.121261 30226.483
6381       No     Yes 1393.916368 16658.483
6384       No      No  147.049334 52074.511
6385       No      No  734.472781 46805.553
6388       No      No 1271.115698 40578.316
6390       No      No 1004.187665 37132.657
6394       No      No 1471.608629 61385.600
6396       No      No  843.352661 51736.910
6397       No      No  250.468333 42309.083
6408       No      No  670.008248 35919.797
6409       No      No 1036.053835 44869.460
6418       No     Yes 1120.320878 29045.407
6422      Yes      No 1805.559588 40119.788
6424       No      No 1056.993239 45489.897
6425       No     Yes  904.994671 19108.742
6432       No      No  638.476386 53034.552
6434       No      No  815.682132 53817.280
6435       No      No 1276.982650 40611.349
6437       No      No  818.284347 48490.812
6447       No      No  844.403803 36854.636
6449       No      No  679.707581 29534.821
6452       No      No 1379.678044 31766.294
6463       No      No  297.838222 34549.463
6466       No      No    0.000000 36201.539
6472       No      No 1579.359465 50216.572
6479       No      No 1569.556299 36306.019
6499       No     Yes  453.929799 12665.307
6520       No      No 1333.182128 19396.032
6527       No     Yes  635.394658 18344.075
6528       No      No  100.021825 48377.641
6529       No      No  264.968054 36842.823
6533       No      No  715.656722 23266.136
6535       No      No 1335.230281 43660.392
6537       No     Yes 1232.590353 22108.580
6544      Yes      No 1605.214586 26149.148
6547       No      No 1008.290635 30801.090
6552       No     Yes  734.733165 10816.950
6555       No      No  294.024346 49988.147
6568       No      No  599.380380 58909.344
6571       No      No  626.514786 55155.078
6572       No      No    0.000000 54298.860
6575       No      No  580.164721 31879.139
6579       No      No  776.395874 49705.816
6580       No      No  519.308692 42861.933
6584       No      No  660.533672 31480.041
6585       No      No  213.010074 38950.600
6586       No      No  506.824142 50493.095
6597      Yes     Yes 1893.023004 16853.330
6598       No     Yes 1636.519725 17533.342
6624       No      No  376.350444 32168.442
6627       No     Yes 1457.575381 19668.158
6646       No      No  247.199057 37377.358
6648       No     Yes  617.089796 22801.664
6651       No      No  826.981750 35426.181
6661       No     Yes  310.020277 16382.153
6678       No     Yes  953.858482 18121.113
6684       No      No 1193.762792 34909.309
6686       No      No  426.087027 15498.869
6689       No      No  520.947287 41039.282
6690       No      No 1034.892431 34539.846
6720       No     Yes  402.503366 12255.871
6721       No      No  191.215001 41921.683
6723       No     Yes 1273.186248 20429.621
6724       No      No 1037.600637 40415.823
6727       No     Yes  212.708644 13155.672
6735       No      No  519.461494 44498.016
6738       No      No    0.000000 44902.929
6745       No     Yes  303.345868 15220.599
6755       No      No    0.000000 49626.416
6757       No      No 1399.126163 26505.020
6772       No      No    0.000000 56493.486
6776       No      No    0.000000 30172.811
6790       No      No  542.470159 39037.801
6793       No     Yes 1200.875976 13833.982
6794       No      No    0.000000 56895.962
6800       No      No  902.713664 23847.392
6803       No     Yes 1503.578445 18776.534
6805       No      No    0.000000 41655.682
6811       No     Yes 1749.549609 20078.362
6815       No      No  375.720573 35564.410
6816       No      No  772.822998 25556.757
6824       No      No 1061.310874 33942.620
6825       No      No  272.750469 42646.705
6828       No      No 1167.035059 34467.543
6830       No     Yes  565.988728 18645.937
6836       No      No  218.337960 44179.947
6841       No      No  341.386840 29326.339
6844       No      No  875.295335 46041.756
6845       No      No  366.090803 47096.378
6849       No     Yes 1050.431291 19246.333
6851      Yes      No 1456.963930 49054.194
6859       No     Yes 1189.313959 19545.727
6869       No      No 1991.135514 30809.675
6875       No      No  216.846533 37160.941
6888       No      No  666.394795 34912.337
6896       No      No  719.938044 31031.219
6904       No      No 1010.421141 46217.810
6907       No     Yes  919.475485  6100.733
6908       No      No 1004.653816 42729.182
6911       No      No  160.524879 29675.835
6915       No      No 1574.651282 30559.514
6917       No      No    4.814909 28714.135
6918       No      No 1220.312282 36190.994
6920       No      No   81.874489 35818.228
6927       No      No  740.386786 46877.961
6935       No      No  546.986650 37513.700
6949       No     Yes  684.891035 17582.986
6952       No      No  287.966887 37409.978
6959       No      No  335.340083 41942.753
6967       No      No  698.572453 44949.269
6978       No      No  578.495565 46030.881
6983       No      No  842.985665 42682.142
6984       No     Yes 1258.528735 10920.965
6993       No      No  496.001763 32818.157
6999       No     Yes 1787.201938 17553.607
7002       No     Yes  265.503923 23775.436
7006       No     Yes  996.232073 10707.943
7007       No     Yes 1033.056283 15453.034
7009       No      No  358.647642 56331.779
7016       No      No 1119.613426 32213.229
7020       No     Yes 1326.558083 25853.143
7022       No     Yes 1145.279018 12906.204
7026       No     Yes 1947.072679 13157.957
7028       No      No 1165.851838 48855.509
7032       No     Yes  743.415446 19610.180
7044       No      No 1334.950731 51086.445
7046       No      No  419.444570 47155.692
7049       No     Yes  531.358420 11420.569
7055       No      No 1285.371279 39925.203
7058       No      No  577.531956 22111.867
7060       No      No  767.139212 49171.978
7062       No      No  683.942141 35232.835
7067       No      No  365.242330 27027.408
7077       No     Yes  359.936375 26500.209
7079       No     Yes  811.046695 21263.099
7103       No     Yes  821.257288 17347.439
7110       No      No  803.946256 42286.288
7111       No     Yes 1456.005961 15069.883
7112       No      No  954.330590 27180.546
7113       No      No 1224.930711 44002.655
7115       No      No  461.026219 15755.647
7120       No      No  178.047347 35401.709
7125       No     Yes 1279.316806 17837.035
7135       No      No   41.651438 47522.024
7140       No      No  766.096021 41435.592
7142       No      No  594.916783 43152.533
7145       No      No   32.993599 31644.771
7147       No      No 1329.096762 60321.613
7159       No      No  205.006264 36554.627
7164       No      No 1666.224230 34918.433
7168       No      No   78.746441 41335.262
7174       No      No  182.890963 21286.850
7193       No     Yes  666.424384 19177.679
7194       No     Yes 1017.667120 13553.091
7198       No     Yes  171.598895 24809.115
7200      Yes      No 1833.646548 43539.784
7201       No     Yes  633.170444 23694.325
7203       No      No  331.407086 20588.172
7211       No      No  893.114550 43511.652
7213       No      No  413.752193 44803.360
7222       No      No 1197.818051 37487.651
7223       No      No  483.454879 44281.347
7229       No     Yes 1134.559731 20964.213
7235       No     Yes    0.000000 29106.584
7248       No      No  302.399909 32048.742
7251       No     Yes 1298.516266 18755.768
7254       No     Yes  813.185316 24823.799
7266       No      No 1079.372744 66134.718
7267       No      No  508.153060 52772.261
7269       No      No  553.649019 47021.492
7273       No      No 1529.152652 43826.291
7276       No     Yes 1567.211982 15877.786
7277       No      No  429.352533 17208.714
7284       No      No  964.046253 46501.911
7289       No     Yes 1182.000082 18102.834
7290       No      No  351.288801 30345.699
7296       No      No 1498.565036 39948.978
7298       No     Yes  717.339190 18382.187
7303       No      No 1021.220100 47650.003
7312       No     Yes 1252.344171 17621.530
7314       No      No  319.030066 27401.117
7315       No     Yes  850.839296 19413.204
7316       No      No 1072.822621 54527.979
7322       No     Yes 1302.086748 21949.277
7323       No     Yes  329.785854 16476.987
7329       No      No  824.987977 42408.896
7330       No      No 1292.160161 39387.688
7340       No      No  707.443670 42656.649
7357       No      No  330.324289 55734.046
7358       No      No 1080.155564 35471.987
7364       No      No 1185.736827 24265.436
7365       No     Yes 1770.525570 17447.127
7369       No      No    0.000000 56982.506
7375       No      No  125.937700 44260.482
7378       No      No    0.000000 30131.976
7379       No     Yes  210.897923 19075.207
7381       No      No 1125.302093 33408.660
7392       No      No 1038.322871 45057.642
7395       No      No  947.597792 34869.127
7401       No      No 1001.320238 41063.197
7406       No      No 1171.411590 52278.244
7418       No     Yes  864.947986  8624.221
7422       No     Yes  823.471373 12331.916
7429      Yes      No 1392.599753 37620.241
7434       No      No 1493.033897 30848.619
7436       No      No    0.000000 19572.300
7444       No      No 1115.154313 38623.548
7463       No      No  772.405633 39023.492
7473       No     Yes 1669.763112 23741.511
7474       No      No  266.759321 25864.939
7479       No      No  766.512524 43426.831
7482       No     Yes 1034.902391 15945.140
7490      Yes     Yes 2117.120614 12143.475
7491       No      No 1002.144124 44445.527
7499       No      No  759.090406 41891.858
7508       No      No 1005.129339 43501.696
7533       No     Yes  950.776787 17711.742
7545       No      No 1255.425942 17917.795
7547       No      No  431.159894 51727.540
7553      Yes      No 1099.057701 42590.894
7554       No      No  763.773764 60938.664
7555       No      No  506.776514 40625.487
7557       No      No  789.639900 44073.247
7559       No      No 1352.290930 33077.089
7560       No     Yes    0.000000 20217.091
7563       No      No 1144.481793 45548.380
7566       No     Yes 1170.224624  8747.473
7569       No     Yes 1294.285702 17444.604
7579       No      No  960.068060 23482.836
7583       No      No 1073.025819 39553.831
7585       No      No 1160.133222 32978.660
7588       No     Yes  909.101994  7283.763
7593       No      No  150.663618 42800.697
7595       No     Yes  771.295014 15594.012
7596       No      No 1363.481664 35359.754
7601       No      No  455.376336 36590.550
7615       No      No 1490.137485 35882.759
7620       No      No  543.794274 51964.751
7631       No      No  982.514587 62140.925
7632       No     Yes  306.041314 13190.832
7633       No     Yes  806.699911 19269.682
7637       No      No  464.939183 58247.122
7642       No      No  387.755272 34086.387
7645       No     Yes 1251.994891 18922.034
7656       No     Yes  270.599297 15728.911
7660       No      No 1027.054579 44268.959
7668       No      No  232.763666 58488.790
7677       No      No  915.462439 33887.764
7678       No      No   65.332984 31992.242
7687       No      No  394.501840 29642.910
7696       No      No    0.000000 34213.492
7701       No      No  864.460773 44429.067
7703       No      No  151.260770 57657.282
7705       No      No   28.789776 55369.201
7710       No      No 2058.784781 55021.552
7718       No      No 1067.273201 50647.872
7721       No     Yes  652.755692 23492.323
7722       No      No  827.634737 36439.661
7736       No      No    0.000000 38968.416
7738       No      No 1562.669858 52422.780
7739       No     Yes  655.611221 19039.168
7755       No      No  437.555257 37212.269
7759       No      No 1385.303477 35045.439
7761       No      No  599.009725 53004.585
7767       No      No  969.538310 33293.795
7769       No      No  838.653017 25272.486
7770       No      No 1072.033770 47029.260
7776       No     Yes 1881.256521 14992.387
7779       No      No  773.171566 37877.605
7785      Yes      No 2040.590171 50930.911
7788       No      No  805.314488 36864.689
7793       No      No  391.189784 42212.030
7799      Yes      No 2038.891851 58606.486
7803       No     Yes  396.582633 18244.166
7811       No     Yes 1412.089967 17049.660
7820       No     Yes  408.218352 21432.726
7834       No     Yes 1538.973751 15757.934
7841       No     Yes 1604.613738 15467.219
7844       No      No  778.819743 31986.571
7846       No      No  221.479986 37782.997
7851       No     Yes  179.503978 19020.296
7853       No     Yes 1776.728974 21280.877
7861       No     Yes 1675.658764 20773.133
7865       No      No 1025.327348 44194.514
7866       No      No  612.657277 38635.364
7869       No     Yes  180.095142 27351.429
7890       No      No  218.014101 29211.398
7891       No      No 1434.138048 38038.604
7892       No      No  506.267392 48843.002
7893       No      No 1322.367854 34622.686
7903       No      No    0.000000 54053.904
7906       No      No  662.302632 44664.006
7912       No      No  398.427320 37094.568
7929       No      No  794.584067 37520.253
7930       No     Yes  883.157341 18213.076
7931       No      No 1168.167308 17198.984
7932       No      No  257.447025 38275.953
7937       No      No  323.305124 51306.269
7944       No      No  533.429586 24857.907
7946       No      No 1271.328544 43878.813
7955       No     Yes  682.954299 15728.048
7970       No     Yes 1055.597773 16810.560
7974       No      No  610.854306 39175.081
7976       No      No 1092.998159 37351.340
7982       No     Yes 1413.274427 19064.622
7984       No      No    0.000000 26941.798
7993       No      No   81.918092 40936.906
8003       No      No 1269.420335 39010.148
8004       No     Yes  397.542488 22710.866
8010       No     Yes  826.727456 18776.301
8011       No      No 1102.111459 48079.125
8013       No     Yes  991.232829  8926.799
8015       No      No  146.365857 44666.932
8019       No      No 1702.236683 36530.474
8022       No      No  331.164339 25922.417
8037       No      No 1042.791935 26141.006
8038       No      No  989.217093 42813.375
8039       No      No  586.602608 27798.168
8041       No     Yes  978.538567 16514.325
8051       No      No  722.768007 20962.106
8052       No     Yes  887.880819 20563.147
8056       No     Yes 1451.303542 14185.138
8063       No      No  637.082386 49097.901
8070       No      No 1430.576870 44104.959
8088       No      No  558.320540 38014.760
8092       No      No 1149.936856 39231.650
8094       No      No  866.772500 30400.561
8100       No      No  196.912926 35737.604
8101       No      No  488.566319 25407.216
8102       No      No  449.274316 13124.563
8108       No      No  369.430953 63536.775
8111       No     Yes 1051.247162 23200.971
8115       No     Yes 1102.631262 10671.924
8118       No     Yes 1131.085568 21829.082
8120       No     Yes  517.300566 17068.339
8126       No     Yes 1928.592120 17570.195
8130       No      No  871.677412 28182.116
8135       No      No 1237.534378 30967.589
8137       No     Yes 1030.052112  9760.400
8139       No      No  425.779791 42131.536
8142       No     Yes  227.317232 24282.229
8149       No      No 1175.191473 50921.256
8159       No     Yes 1014.769662 12239.884
8171       No      No 1529.131259 36572.026
8174       No     Yes 1312.907203 15495.027
8179       No      No  897.312691 31465.965
8180       No      No 1043.552358 38393.612
8181       No      No 1165.323966 33433.829
8182       No      No 1299.473210 55165.473
8183       No      No  675.776529 21758.023
8195      Yes      No 1562.837918 49303.009
8197       No      No  602.361702 53800.547
8198       No      No 1599.314695 28825.475
8201       No      No   87.948652 47924.698
8206       No      No  181.179345 37380.144
8208       No      No   69.177024 24556.022
8209       No      No  940.894484 54839.124
8211       No      No  214.846235 39629.200
8218       No      No  381.704099 25011.103
8219       No     Yes  866.496761 24262.694
8220       No     Yes 1243.344102 23634.749
8225       No      No  971.278833 26853.301
8229       No      No 1057.350872 39651.124
8232       No     Yes  406.339769 30088.443
8234       No      No  356.244118 21319.086
8244      Yes      No 1804.190505 23096.084
8245       No      No    0.000000 34227.947
8247       No      No  586.470977 52203.859
8249       No      No 1491.640587 61096.492
8259       No      No 1047.673370 34413.196
8269       No      No  981.799330 49644.919
8275       No     Yes  759.397131 18693.188
8279       No      No  253.521882 37506.207
8282       No     Yes 1823.867060 19447.967
8284       No      No  728.673461 36557.235
8285       No      No 1471.198738 56477.131
8292       No      No  751.101931 50290.144
8298       No     Yes 1464.636242 14763.563
8301       No     Yes 1162.590922 15419.111
8304       No      No 1403.839834 43225.042
8305       No      No  460.139804 52708.560
8306       No      No 1218.219887 36290.162
8313       No     Yes 1803.766349 23201.827
8320       No      No 1140.820152 36495.055
8325       No     Yes  806.481973 22127.082
8326       No      No  890.266646 38376.091
8335       No      No   45.476282 27599.072
8351       No      No  353.649992 30726.286
8359       No     Yes  485.653178 16099.918
8361       No     Yes    0.000000 17695.840
8363       No      No  309.179163 31232.071
8365      Yes     Yes 1013.216886 19651.262
8382       No     Yes  647.670288 13618.348
8383       No      No  720.164919 43654.230
8387       No      No 1294.523570 28001.049
8391       No      No 1467.573384 26697.786
8405       No      No  170.070917 27005.577
8407       No      No  611.337290 38389.283
8409       No     Yes  357.595665 18141.003
8410       No      No  813.173887 49274.383
8415       No      No 1352.995532 34089.033
8416       No     Yes 1040.880212 19427.814
8418       No      No 1294.761706 37712.387
8422       No      No  515.619800 39638.640
8433       No     Yes 1203.982260 21524.318
8435       No      No    0.000000 48025.617
8436       No      No 1204.954348 47167.938
8441       No      No  738.221430 25184.467
8442       No     Yes  451.912461 22316.261
8444       No      No 1082.074394 30627.462
8445       No     Yes 1001.348886 19314.922
8451       No      No    0.000000 44561.325
8454       No     Yes  100.850759 17315.130
8455       No      No 1856.530876 33498.835
8456       No      No  620.457309 41059.097
8468       No      No  821.250480 68721.974
8470       No      No  216.961692 31742.994
8483       No      No  784.171575 47322.689
8484       No      No  952.311152 21990.091
8486       No      No  316.124008 37322.932
8489       No      No 1208.304376 38461.047
8495       No      No  603.020400 51229.788
8500       No      No 1168.488567 40615.567
8506       No      No  329.518977 38150.635
8508       No     Yes 1817.280072 20751.432
8515       No      No  896.981468 35755.748
8517       No      No    0.000000 51122.516
8528       No     Yes 1657.113859 10852.293
8533       No      No 1420.507480 37437.738
8535       No     Yes  212.821369 24515.975
8554       No     Yes 1739.837812 21593.013
8562       No     Yes 1282.474952 25304.586
8565       No     Yes 1010.848591 16428.755
8570       No      No  253.630102 50236.505
8573       No      No  736.495522 49119.348
8581       No      No  499.149149 56343.610
8588       No      No  962.223838 43974.057
8593       No      No  423.407947 40844.342
8594       No      No    0.000000 29775.159
8600       No      No   25.800377 44091.688
8612       No      No  718.595254 39157.790
8613       No      No  379.100361 31350.929
8616       No      No  343.493830 67930.344
8617       No      No  375.799319 21297.585
8619       No     Yes 1231.558825 15727.670
8624       No      No 1407.092142 43677.976
8627       No      No  650.046110 46137.933
8635       No      No  326.670018 50562.490
8640       No      No 1356.729836 37664.037
8643       No     Yes  412.388636  9892.128
8656       No     Yes  989.884597 23416.500
8662       No     Yes  598.218194 19794.576
8670       No     Yes  948.151303 18107.357
8675       No      No  102.721441 13719.357
8681       No      No  906.231097 46715.235
8695       No      No  838.578905 43501.258
8699       No      No 1651.322553 34024.664
8703       No     Yes  770.826667 18896.729
8707       No      No 1058.284332 39314.513
8709       No     Yes 1379.770017 15509.409
8713       No      No 1079.965765 43215.806
8727       No      No  294.018790 59128.503
8738      Yes      No 1926.599082 59224.453
8742       No      No  282.889218 42132.074
8751       No     Yes  983.268503 24554.272
8754       No     Yes  317.268000 17801.537
8761       No     Yes 1367.786515 12449.279
8764       No      No  462.004290 33157.362
8767       No      No  846.131295 29812.088
8770       No     Yes 1395.668987 21374.592
8779       No      No  528.569205 42249.357
8781       No     Yes  132.104559 20065.722
8783       No      No  497.725785 26591.113
8795       No      No  130.346822 53852.755
8796       No      No 1400.163187 52343.477
8797       No      No    0.000000 51740.422
8798       No     Yes  552.334240 21262.566
8806       No      No  509.317799 18221.147
8808       No      No  307.730563 48123.551
8810       No      No  851.564660 33211.176
8813       No     Yes 1557.525571 17132.312
8815       No      No 1136.455031 47721.274
8828       No      No  221.334856 31764.203
8829       No      No  149.223219 36550.333
8830       No      No  474.628375 28182.976
8836      Yes      No 1315.558765 35456.696
8841       No      No  250.988820 33568.532
8844       No      No 1363.310379 35387.699
8846       No     Yes 2014.497648 15728.938
8848       No     Yes  237.163586 25219.983
8856       No      No  254.728058 53696.832
8860       No     Yes  514.334987 27443.975
8864       No     Yes  810.308012 16248.456
8871       No      No  792.974068 28674.671
8873       No      No  528.676845 39925.185
8875       No      No 1085.520235 36746.320
8877       No      No 1190.061303 41965.880
8879       No      No 1440.132927 28370.104
8880       No      No  373.178886 30826.075
8885       No     Yes  230.159169 24776.693
8891       No     Yes 1829.909941 21018.960
8892       No     Yes  973.264480 16984.611
8893       No      No  690.640342 26989.394
8902       No      No  696.895693 63952.313
8904       No      No 1585.525089 49011.416
8905       No      No 1322.080983 48906.518
8907       No     Yes 1426.014177 20779.679
8917       No      No  580.379056 55724.271
8922       No      No  970.925552 46051.868
8926       No      No  641.760448 44857.701
8943       No      No  656.434944 26551.601
8947       No      No 1665.036973 48295.525
8952       No      No 1221.083123 29370.585
8965       No      No 1700.294976 53844.579
8967       No      No  762.991491 44162.363
8973       No      No  842.407539 38161.739
8975       No     Yes 1405.876654 27071.322
8976       No      No  419.702000 44989.763
8991       No      No 1235.485768 29992.186
8992       No      No  850.385568 45530.377
8997       No     Yes 1401.193609 17688.856
9001       No      No 1112.064140 27694.721
9003       No      No 1133.414939 36456.949
9006       No      No  783.797563 33151.567
9007       No     Yes  246.081819 20046.772
9012       No      No  951.620226 41689.568
9014       No      No   70.185478 36216.964
9015       No      No 1002.351218 43048.170
9027       No      No 1678.118466 41813.892
9034       No     Yes 1579.216996 15111.914
9052       No      No 1436.647669 38571.328
9056       No      No  979.851049 44869.047
9064       No     Yes 1132.084057 15675.534
9069       No      No  698.078873 38960.267
9071      Yes     Yes 1789.477475 17667.782
9075       No      No  481.777806 34478.953
9082       No      No 1428.725258 51633.433
9092       No      No 1578.463711 51413.840
9095       No      No    0.000000 44712.232
9098       No      No  217.512412 39616.260
9106       No     Yes  740.577851 17700.072
9109       No     Yes  472.024537 13685.470
9113       No      No 1634.996685 36995.751
9114       No      No  155.993061 37599.768
9120       No      No  406.998522 41505.406
9122       No      No 1915.332066 21361.048
9125       No      No  574.469878 46696.186
9126       No     Yes  256.325670 15627.663
9131       No      No  659.783085 42054.915
9132       No     Yes  583.774223 12240.661
9133       No      No 1024.819477 40380.298
9138       No      No  316.563872 30293.963
9146       No      No  667.492041 24613.676
9147       No     Yes  950.477293 17932.125
9155       No     Yes  716.048097 15149.876
9159       No      No  600.820086 49727.490
9160       No      No  965.150484 34783.007
9163       No      No  581.313105 32454.110
9171       No     Yes 1403.163526 28207.932
9172       No      No 1005.525429 34587.244
9181       No     Yes  816.443608 19141.730
9182       No      No  768.378585 43325.970
9188       No      No  499.646324 69342.672
9190       No      No  518.369906 27527.235
9194       No      No   42.149993 31812.892
9195       No      No  989.017792 35129.092
9200       No      No  534.055545 30948.807
9202       No     Yes  732.429942 26433.105
9212       No     Yes 1047.225624 18069.252
9238       No      No 1474.638036 39872.228
9241       No      No  120.843053 36205.878
9249       No      No   43.143500 34316.890
9251       No      No  204.030247 51108.045
9255       No      No 1018.568130 34103.880
9258       No      No    0.000000 56943.909
9259       No     Yes 1006.969158 10364.819
9263       No      No 1278.429972 25590.657
9275       No      No  400.888873 53900.664
9276       No     Yes 1020.589033 13094.946
9282       No      No 1112.455001 40576.190
9295       No      No  938.090134 46370.821
9296      Yes      No 2095.114817 44647.586
9300       No      No 1175.594953 19030.139
9306       No      No 1579.909363 45406.512
9307       No      No  288.178064 36514.676
9308       No     Yes 1626.901421 11702.283
9316       No      No  347.371078 18488.147
9319       No     Yes  985.240890 17263.757
9324       No      No  977.515331 33690.649
9328       No     Yes  596.056247 16084.908
9346       No     Yes  978.236904 15073.788
9352       No      No    0.000000 62160.286
9357       No      No 1634.731555 40868.332
9365       No      No    0.000000 36922.868
9370      Yes      No 1815.174112 23648.414
9383       No     Yes  879.710515 17863.842
9391       No      No  874.617420 37143.645
9392       No      No  650.007041 41427.877
9398       No     Yes 1273.752339 19635.662
9400       No      No 1504.682568 38223.246
9401       No     Yes 1182.679045 17287.748
9402       No      No  853.060423 39553.366
9413       No      No  886.777433 43410.382
9416       No      No 1602.003893 41827.701
9422       No      No  522.644337 35893.288
9425       No      No  562.314178 63794.542
9429       No      No  770.486334 25445.878
9434       No      No 1128.411463 51778.180
9438      Yes      No  961.732662 27600.416
9440       No     Yes 1627.459840 19630.161
9443       No      No  714.512491 48115.505
9475       No      No  815.691295 48646.542
9479       No      No  906.416188 49815.651
9485       No     Yes  830.651798 14420.623
9486      Yes     Yes 1719.255655 15752.008
9491       No      No  527.940359 47963.179
9496       No      No  915.518056 42331.022
9497       No      No  833.957707 34174.645
9498       No      No  381.566520 49114.893
9500       No      No 1156.994528 53450.274
9505       No     Yes  256.367784 18200.880
9511      Yes     Yes 1726.479610 13654.605
9513       No      No  356.613168 44473.396
9523      Yes      No  959.159213 59435.235
9524       No      No  390.530295 57525.266
9527       No      No  216.528262 28859.695
9534       No     Yes 1434.589977 16613.431
9551       No     Yes 1228.993901 18810.384
9553       No      No 1584.565943 45447.187
9554       No      No  751.122224 37304.199
9563       No     Yes 1630.488555 16310.534
9565       No      No  476.301212 25774.488
9567       No     Yes 1671.523208  9981.897
9569       No      No 1280.230190 23647.333
9573       No     Yes 1847.469647 19388.689
9575       No     Yes 1935.504220  9431.294
9576       No      No  808.494794 56204.663
9577       No      No  218.739422 53259.762
9582       No     Yes  475.853205 19993.756
9584       No      No  959.172026 38310.086
9587       No      No 1763.845640 36686.348
9589       No      No  830.234100 36523.481
9595       No     Yes  357.951290 14338.529
9599       No      No  779.477524 34089.797
9614       No      No 1267.485211 40034.567
9619       No      No  870.971726 39653.377
9621       No      No  713.326064 44605.351
9626       No      No 1302.655581 28978.557
9627       No      No 1408.351474 33697.346
9630       No      No    0.000000 40737.867
9632       No     Yes  325.283631 15962.710
9635       No      No 1353.918741 39879.159
9636       No      No 1555.968070 34417.873
9649       No     Yes  641.893646 16400.365
9657       No      No    4.100940 42174.180
9665       No      No  426.764150 38495.798
9667       No      No  968.736620 17352.410
9668       No      No 1188.965168 42286.488
9676       No     Yes 1280.848066 20575.245
9680       No      No    0.000000 36337.352
9682       No      No  548.839276 44909.066
9698       No      No  953.936465 41250.478
9708       No      No  452.367912 29254.871
9711       No      No 1191.610584 49004.836
9714       No      No  182.370460 45507.934
9715       No      No  732.137067 42693.940
9716       No      No 1916.088508 23316.570
9726       No     Yes 1235.966487 21706.630
9733       No      No   92.102195 22726.413
9735       No     Yes  184.925247 11126.266
9736       No      No  209.674451 35688.136
9743       No      No  278.703161 30113.853
9753       No      No  755.460443 33460.926
9755       No      No 1233.618926 49448.171
9761       No      No    0.000000 37538.045
9763       No      No  982.631024 60388.020
9767       No     Yes 1700.572366 20844.719
9770       No      No    0.000000 48112.478
9794       No      No 1534.683210 48592.334
9805       No      No 1508.749012 30587.344
9808       No      No   67.388462 48792.117
9815       No      No  663.663634 43951.253
9816       No      No    0.000000 39043.277
9820       No      No 1664.095652 54087.641
9829       No      No 1135.493293 37962.983
9836       No     Yes 1203.946904 20904.838
9853       No     Yes 1219.975480 15039.554
9856       No      No  761.553725 46836.672
9863       No      No  141.128484 41300.722
9865       No      No 1133.945796 47188.948
9866       No      No    0.000000 43593.954
9867       No      No  599.718846 48085.884
9868       No     Yes  529.273443 20358.834
9872       No     Yes  656.808386 19017.428
9881       No      No  323.034916 33673.810
9882       No      No  980.037169 31977.563
9885       No      No  438.080377 44737.658
9891       No     Yes  512.449778 24192.889
9893       No      No  663.675171 38338.206
9894      Yes      No 2288.408082 52043.569
9901       No      No 1695.387238 26623.768
9916       No      No 1189.241184 29889.602
9924       No      No  751.366628 31574.421
9925       No      No 1074.514538 41545.684
9929       No      No  560.297082 28419.354
9930       No     Yes  364.173415 21487.644
9936       No      No 1486.201068 51021.614
9939       No      No  319.602369 53135.367
9940       No      No  879.035415 52945.819
9946       No      No 1105.467425 32371.401
9947       No     Yes  734.459199 17619.487
9948       No      No  583.307444 37118.831
9950      Yes      No 1750.253150 51578.940
9957       No      No  415.768259 38425.759
9960       No      No    0.000000 53946.234
9970       No      No  991.335394 44445.579
9979      Yes      No 2202.462395 47287.257
9985       No      No  875.241640 52861.744
9987       No     Yes  401.332674 15332.018
9990       No     Yes  999.281112 20013.351
9994       No      No  938.836241 56633.449
10000      No     Yes  200.922183 16862.952

Paso 3. Construimos el modelo ajustado con los datos de entrenamiento.

modelodatos_default <- rpart(default~., data = entrenamiento, method = "class")
modelodatos_default
n= 7999 

node), split, n, loss, yval, (yprob)
      * denotes terminal node

 1) root 7999 266 No (0.96674584 0.03325416)  
   2) balance< 1797.017 7774 136 No (0.98250579 0.01749421) *
   3) balance>=1797.017 225  95 Yes (0.42222222 0.57777778)  
     6) balance< 1971.915 135  58 No (0.57037037 0.42962963)  
      12) income< 30111.74 83  28 No (0.66265060 0.33734940)  
        24) balance< 1874.659 46  11 No (0.76086957 0.23913043) *
        25) balance>=1874.659 37  17 No (0.54054054 0.45945946)  
          50) balance>=1900.522 25   8 No (0.68000000 0.32000000) *
          51) balance< 1900.522 12   3 Yes (0.25000000 0.75000000) *
      13) income>=30111.74 52  22 Yes (0.42307692 0.57692308)  
        26) balance< 1889.562 34  16 No (0.52941176 0.47058824)  
          52) balance>=1859.823 8   1 No (0.87500000 0.12500000) *
          53) balance< 1859.823 26  11 Yes (0.42307692 0.57692308) *
        27) balance>=1889.562 18   4 Yes (0.22222222 0.77777778) *
     7) balance>=1971.915 90  18 Yes (0.20000000 0.80000000) *
rpart.plot(
  modelodatos_default, 
  digits = -4,             # Positivo para mostrar decimales correctos (ej. 3 decimales)
  type = 2,
  extra = 104,            # Muestra la clase predicha, n y las probabilidades de cada clase
  box.palette = "RdYlGn", 
  fallen.leaves = TRUE, 
  branch.lty = 3,        
  main = "Modelo de Árbol de Decisión: Predicción de Descuento"
)

Paso 5. Interpretación de los resultados finales

pred<- predict(modelodatos_default,entrenamiento[,-1],type="class") 
tt<- table(pred,entrenamiento[,1]) 
tt 
     
pred    No  Yes
  No  7697  156
  Yes   36  110
TA <- sum(diag(tt))/sum(tt)  
paste0("Tasa de aciertos con los datos de entrenamiento: ", round(TA,4)*100, "%", sep="")
[1] "Tasa de aciertos con los datos de entrenamiento: 97.6%"

Podemos hablar de una precisión de aproximadamente el 97.6%. Ahora, para analizar la calidad del modelo, veamos que tan buena es la predicción para el conjunto de prueba.

Pred    <- predict(modelodatos_default, pruebadatos_Default[,-1],type="class")
table   <- table(pruebadatos_Default[,1],Pred)
table
     Pred
        No  Yes
  No  1916   18
  Yes   40   27
TAP <- sum(diag(table))/sum(table) 
paste0("Tasa de aciertos con los datos de prueba: ", round(TAP,4)*100, "%", sep="")
[1] "Tasa de aciertos con los datos de prueba: 97.1%"

Encontramos que el modelo logra predecir aproximadamente un 97.1% los datos de prueba.