1 Pendahuluan

Analisis ini mengestimasi model regresi data panel statis (CEM, FEM, REM) dengan variabel:

Variabel Keterangan
Y Pertumbuhan ekonomi
X1 Inflasi
X2 Pengangguran
X3 Keseimbangan eksternal / investasi

Alur analisis: (1) persiapan data, (2) uji cross-section dependence, (3) uji stasioneritas CIPS, (4) estimasi dan pemilihan model, (5) uji asumsi klasik, (6) uji heterogenitas, (7) perbaikan dengan standard error robust.

2 Persiapan Data

file <- "C:/Users/User/Downloads/P_Data_Extract_From_World_Development_Indicators theogivesA2.xlsx"
raw  <- read_excel(file, na = c("..", "", "NA"))

# Cek nama seri yang tersedia (sesuaikan 'peta' di bawah bila perlu)
unique(raw$`Series Name`)
#> [1] "GDP growth (annual %)"                                              
#> [2] "Inflation, consumer prices (annual %)"                              
#> [3] "Unemployment, total (% of total labor force) (modeled ILO estimate)"
#> [4] "Foreign direct investment, net inflows (% of GDP)"                  
#> [5] NA
long <- raw %>%
  filter(!is.na(`Series Name`)) %>%
  pivot_longer(cols = matches("^\\d{4}"),
               names_to = "Year", values_to = "Value") %>%
  mutate(Year  = as.integer(substr(Year, 1, 4)),
         Value = as.numeric(Value))

# >>> SESUAIKAN kata kunci dengan nama seri di data kamu <<<
peta <- c(
  Y  = "GDP growth",
  X1 = "Inflation",
  X2 = "Unemployment",
  X3 = "External balance|Foreign direct investment|Gross capital formation"
)

long$Var <- NA_character_
for (v in names(peta)) {
  long$Var[grepl(peta[v], long$`Series Name`, ignore.case = TRUE)] <- v
}

dat <- long %>%
  filter(!is.na(Var)) %>%
  select(Country = `Country Name`, Year, Var, Value) %>%
  group_by(Country, Year, Var) %>% summarise(Value = first(Value), .groups = "drop") %>%
  pivot_wider(names_from = Var, values_from = Value) %>%
  drop_na(Y, X1, X2, X3)

# Panel seimbang (syarat uji CIPS)
T_max <- max(table(dat$Country))
dat <- dat %>% group_by(Country) %>% filter(n() == T_max) %>% ungroup()

pdat <- pdata.frame(as.data.frame(dat), index = c("Country","Year"))

Panel yang digunakan: 15 negara dan 26 tahun (390 observasi).

2.1 Statistik Deskriptif

kable(summary(dat[, c("Y","X1","X2","X3")]), digits = 3)
Y X1 X2 X3
Min. :-9.518 Min. :-1.710 Min. : 0.249 Min. :-2.757
1st Qu.: 2.621 1st Qu.: 2.392 1st Qu.: 3.300 1st Qu.: 1.425
Median : 4.708 Median : 3.813 Median : 4.635 Median : 2.488
Mean : 4.269 Mean : 5.366 Mean : 7.261 Mean : 2.732
3rd Qu.: 6.315 3rd Qu.: 6.072 3rd Qu.: 9.411 3rd Qu.: 3.721
Max. :14.151 Max. :72.309 Max. :34.007 Max. :11.910

3 Uji Cross-Section Dependence (Variabel)

Dilakukan sebelum uji akar unit. Jika terdapat dependensi antar-negara, uji generasi kedua (CIPS) lebih tepat.

  • H0: tidak ada dependensi antar-unit (cross-section independence)
  • H1: ada dependensi antar-unit
for (v in c("Y","X1","X2","X3")) {
  r <- pcdtest(as.formula(paste(v, "~ 1")), data = pdat, test = "cd")
  cat("- **", v, "**: CD = ", round(unname(r$statistic), 4), "; ",
      kep(r$p.value, "independensi antar-unit"), "\n", sep = "")
}
  • Y: CD = 28.3755; p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (independensi antar-unit ditolak)
  • X1: CD = 12.0895; p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (independensi antar-unit ditolak)
  • X2: CD = 6.9328; p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (independensi antar-unit ditolak)
  • X3: CD = 3.2977; p = 0.001 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (independensi antar-unit ditolak)

4 Uji Stasioneritas CIPS (Pesaran, 2007)

  • H0: seluruh unit memiliki akar unit (tidak stasioner)
  • H1: sebagian unit stasioner

4.1 Level

jalankan_cips <- function(pd, vars, lag = 1) {
  hasil <- list()
  for (v in vars) {
    for (tp in c("drift","trend")) {
      r <- try(cipstest(pd[[v]], lags = lag, type = tp, model = "cmg"), silent = TRUE)
      if (!inherits(r, "try-error")) {
        hasil[[paste(v, tp)]] <- data.frame(
          Variabel = v, Spesifikasi = tp,
          CIPS = round(unname(r$statistic), 4),
          p_value = round(r$p.value, 4),
          Keputusan = ifelse(r$p.value < 0.05, "Stasioner", "Tidak stasioner"))
      }
    }
  }
  bind_rows(hasil)
}

cips_level <- jalankan_cips(pdat, c("Y","X1","X2","X3"))
kable(cips_level, caption = "Hasil uji CIPS pada level")
Hasil uji CIPS pada level
Variabel Spesifikasi CIPS p_value Keputusan
Y drift -2.4882 0.0100 Stasioner
Y trend -2.7588 0.0565 Tidak stasioner
X1 drift -2.5236 0.0100 Stasioner
X1 trend -3.0814 0.0100 Stasioner
X2 drift -1.7738 0.1000 Tidak stasioner
X2 trend -2.5528 0.1000 Tidak stasioner
X3 drift -2.7199 0.0100 Stasioner
X3 trend -2.9194 0.0236 Stasioner

4.2 First Difference

Jalankan interpretasi bagian ini hanya untuk variabel yang tidak stasioner pada level.

diff_dat <- data.frame(
  Country = pdat$Country, Year = pdat$Year,
  dY  = as.numeric(diff(pdat$Y)),  dX1 = as.numeric(diff(pdat$X1)),
  dX2 = as.numeric(diff(pdat$X2)), dX3 = as.numeric(diff(pdat$X3))
) %>% drop_na()
pdat_d <- pdata.frame(diff_dat, index = c("Country","Year"))

cips_diff <- jalankan_cips(pdat_d, c("dY","dX1","dX2","dX3"))
kable(cips_diff, caption = "Hasil uji CIPS pada first difference")
Hasil uji CIPS pada first difference
Variabel Spesifikasi CIPS p_value Keputusan
dY drift -4.2194 0.01 Stasioner
dY trend -4.1396 0.01 Stasioner
dX1 drift -4.6965 0.01 Stasioner
dX1 trend -4.7941 0.01 Stasioner
dX2 drift -3.0987 0.01 Stasioner
dX2 trend -3.2045 0.01 Stasioner
dX3 drift -4.5564 0.01 Stasioner
dX3 trend -4.5497 0.01 Stasioner

Catatan: jika ada variabel I(1), ganti pdat dengan pdat_d dan rumus menjadi dY ~ dX1 + dX2 + dX3 pada bagian estimasi.

5 Estimasi Model Panel Statis

form <- Y ~ X1 + X2 + X3

cem <- plm(form, data = pdat, model = "pooling")                        # Common Effect
fem <- plm(form, data = pdat, model = "within",  effect = "individual") # Fixed Effect
rem <- plm(form, data = pdat, model = "random",  effect = "individual") # Random Effect
stargazer(cem, fem, rem, type = "html",
          column.labels = c("CEM","FEM","REM"),
          title = "Perbandingan model panel statis")
Perbandingan model panel statis
Dependent variable:
Y
CEM FEM REM
(1) (2) (3)
X1 0.013 -0.029 -0.021
(0.022) (0.024) (0.023)
X2 -0.110*** -0.133** -0.117**
(0.025) (0.064) (0.049)
X3 0.171** 0.482*** 0.426***
(0.086) (0.108) (0.103)
Constant 4.533*** 4.070***
(0.365) (0.667)
Observations 390 390 390
R2 0.058 0.064 0.059
Adjusted R2 0.051 0.022 0.052
F Statistic 7.898*** (df = 3; 386) 8.531*** (df = 3; 372) 24.212***
Note: p<0.1; p<0.05; p<0.01

6 Pemilihan Model

chow   <- pFtest(fem, cem)
lm_bp  <- plmtest(cem, type = "bp", effect = "individual")
hausm  <- phtest(fem, rem)

chow; lm_bp; hausm
#> 
#>  F test for individual effects
#> 
#> data:  form
#> F = 10.11, df1 = 14, df2 = 372, p-value < 2.2e-16
#> alternative hypothesis: significant effects
#> 
#>  Lagrange Multiplier Test - (Breusch-Pagan)
#> 
#> data:  form
#> chisq = 245.36, df = 1, p-value < 2.2e-16
#> alternative hypothesis: significant effects
#> 
#>  Hausman Test
#> 
#> data:  form
#> chisq = 3.7879, df = 3, p-value = 0.2853
#> alternative hypothesis: one model is inconsistent
cat("- **Chow (CEM vs FEM):** ", kep(chow$p.value, "CEM"), "\n", sep = "")
  • Chow (CEM vs FEM): p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (CEM ditolak)
cat("- **Breusch-Pagan LM (CEM vs REM):** ", kep(lm_bp$p.value, "CEM"), "\n", sep = "")
  • Breusch-Pagan LM (CEM vs REM): p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (CEM ditolak)
cat("- **Hausman (FEM vs REM):** ", kep(hausm$p.value, "REM konsisten"), "\n", sep = "")
  • Hausman (FEM vs REM): p = 0.2853 ≥ 0,05 → gagal tolak H0 (REM konsisten tidak ditolak)
# Aturan pemilihan otomatis
if (chow$p.value < 0.05) {
  if (hausm$p.value < 0.05) { model_terpilih <- fem; nama_model <- "FEM" }
  else                      { model_terpilih <- rem; nama_model <- "REM" }
} else {
  if (lm_bp$p.value < 0.05) { model_terpilih <- rem; nama_model <- "REM" }
  else                      { model_terpilih <- cem; nama_model <- "CEM" }
}
cat("\n**Model terpilih: ", nama_model, "**\n", sep = "")

Model terpilih: REM

Hasil estimasi model terpilih:

summary(model_terpilih)
#> Oneway (individual) effect Random Effect Model 
#>    (Swamy-Arora's transformation)
#> 
#> Call:
#> plm(formula = form, data = pdat, effect = "individual", model = "random")
#> 
#> Balanced Panel: n = 15, T = 26, N = 390
#> 
#> Effects:
#>                 var std.dev share
#> idiosyncratic 7.480   2.735 0.722
#> individual    2.882   1.698 0.278
#> theta: 0.6987
#> 
#> Residuals:
#>    Min. 1st Qu.  Median 3rd Qu.    Max. 
#> -14.467  -1.106   0.288   1.493   7.861 
#> 
#> Coefficients:
#>              Estimate Std. Error z-value  Pr(>|z|)    
#> (Intercept)  4.070453   0.667296  6.0999 1.061e-09 ***
#> X1          -0.021135   0.023422 -0.9024   0.36687    
#> X2          -0.117302   0.049312 -2.3788   0.01737 *  
#> X3           0.426016   0.103175  4.1291 3.642e-05 ***
#> ---
#> Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
#> 
#> Total Sum of Squares:    3074.1
#> Residual Sum of Squares: 2892.7
#> R-Squared:      0.059022
#> Adj. R-Squared: 0.051709
#> Chisq: 24.2116 on 3 DF, p-value: 2.2563e-05
res <- residuals(model_terpilih)

7 Uji Asumsi Klasik

7.1 Normalitas Residual (Jarque-Bera)

H0: residual berdistribusi normal.

jb <- jarque.bera.test(as.numeric(res)); jb
#> 
#>  Jarque Bera Test
#> 
#> data:  as.numeric(res)
#> X-squared = 483.09, df = 2, p-value < 2.2e-16

p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (normalitas ditolak)

hist(as.numeric(res), breaks = 20, main = "Histogram Residual",
     xlab = "Residual", col = "grey85", border = "white")

7.2 Multikolinearitas (VIF)

Nilai VIF < 10 menunjukkan tidak ada multikolinearitas serius.

vif_val <- vif(lm(form, data = pdat))
kable(data.frame(Variabel = names(vif_val), VIF = round(vif_val, 3)))
Variabel VIF
X1 X1 1.023
X2 X2 1.021
X3 X3 1.010
kable(round(cor(dat[, c("X1","X2","X3")]), 3), caption = "Matriks korelasi antar-regresor")
Matriks korelasi antar-regresor
X1 X2 X3
X1 1.000 0.129 -0.083
X2 0.129 1.000 -0.069
X3 -0.083 -0.069 1.000

7.3 Autokorelasi (Serial Correlation)

H0: tidak ada autokorelasi.

bg <- pbgtest(model_terpilih); bg
#> 
#>  Breusch-Godfrey/Wooldridge test for serial correlation in panel models
#> 
#> data:  form
#> chisq = 135.2, df = 26, p-value < 2.2e-16
#> alternative hypothesis: serial correlation in idiosyncratic errors
wo <- pwartest(fem); wo
#> 
#>  Wooldridge's test for serial correlation in FE panels
#> 
#> data:  fem
#> F = 6.1042, df1 = 1, df2 = 373, p-value = 0.01393
#> alternative hypothesis: serial correlation
  • Breusch-Godfrey: p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (tidak ada autokorelasi ditolak)
  • Wooldridge: p = 0.0139 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (tidak ada autokorelasi ditolak)

7.4 Heteroskedastisitas (Breusch-Pagan)

H0: residual homoskedastis.

bp <- bptest(form, data = pdat, studentize = TRUE); bp
#> 
#>  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
#> 
#> data:  form
#> BP = 0.71426, df = 3, p-value = 0.8698

p = 0.8698 ≥ 0,05 → gagal tolak H0 (homoskedastisitas tidak ditolak)

7.5 Cross-Section Dependence pada Residual

H0: residual independen antar-unit.

cd_res <- pcdtest(model_terpilih, test = "cd"); cd_res
#> 
#>  Pesaran CD test for cross-sectional dependence in panels
#> 
#> data:  Y ~ X1 + X2 + X3
#> z = 28.578, p-value < 2.2e-16
#> alternative hypothesis: cross-sectional dependence
lm_res <- pcdtest(model_terpilih, test = "lm"); lm_res
#> 
#>  Breusch-Pagan LM test for cross-sectional dependence in panels
#> 
#> data:  Y ~ X1 + X2 + X3
#> chisq = 902.13, df = 105, p-value < 2.2e-16
#> alternative hypothesis: cross-sectional dependence
  • Pesaran CD: p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (independensi ditolak)
  • Breusch-Pagan LM: p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (independensi ditolak)

8 Uji Heterogenitas

8.1 Heterogenitas Varians Antar-Unit (Modified Wald)

H0: varians homogen antar-unit (groupwise homoskedasticity).

mod_wald <- function(model) {
  e   <- residuals(model)
  id  <- index(model)[,1]
  e_l <- split(as.numeric(e), id)
  N   <- length(e_l); Tn <- length(e_l[[1]])
  s2i <- sapply(e_l, function(x) mean(x^2))
  vi  <- sapply(e_l, function(x) sum((x^2 - mean(x^2))^2) / (Tn*(Tn-1)))
  s2  <- sum(unlist(e_l)^2) / (N*Tn)
  W   <- sum((s2i - s2)^2 / vi)
  c(Chi2 = W, df = N, p_value = pchisq(W, N, lower.tail = FALSE))
}
mw <- mod_wald(fem)
round(mw, 4)
#>    Chi2      df p_value 
#> 70.6837 15.0000  0.0000

p = 0 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (homogenitas varians ditolak)

8.2 Heterogenitas Slope (Poolability)

H0: koefisien homogen antar-unit (data dapat di-pool).

pt <- pooltest(form, data = pdat, model = "within"); pt
#> 
#>  F statistic
#> 
#> data:  form
#> F = 1.5131, df1 = 42, df2 = 330, p-value = 0.02614
#> alternative hypothesis: unstability

p = 0.0261 < 0,05 → tolak H0 (homogenitas slope ditolak)

8.3 Heterogenitas Individu (Efek Tetap per Negara)

kable(data.frame(Negara = names(fixef(fem)), Intersep = round(as.numeric(fixef(fem)), 4)))
Negara Intersep
Brazil 2.2784
Chile 1.8097
China 7.4916
Colombia 3.4302
India 6.6076
Indonesia 5.0882
Korea, Rep. 3.7246
Malaysia 3.6320
Mexico 1.0096
Philippines 4.6537
Poland 3.2543
South Africa 4.9968
Thailand 2.2254
Turkiye 6.3625
Viet Nam 4.4791

9 Perbaikan: Standard Error Robust

Jika asumsi heteroskedastisitas, autokorelasi, atau dependensi antar-unit dilanggar, inferensi dilakukan dengan standard error robust.

cat("Arellano (robust terhadap heteroskedastis dan autokorelasi)\n")
#> Arellano (robust terhadap heteroskedastis dan autokorelasi)
coeftest(model_terpilih, vcov = vcovHC(model_terpilih, method = "arellano",
                                       type = "HC1", cluster = "group"))
#> 
#> t test of coefficients:
#> 
#>               Estimate Std. Error t value  Pr(>|t|)    
#> (Intercept)  4.0704530  0.7942956  5.1246 4.722e-07 ***
#> X1          -0.0211352  0.0096408 -2.1923  0.028956 *  
#> X2          -0.1173019  0.0384549 -3.0504  0.002443 ** 
#> X3           0.4260155  0.1670250  2.5506  0.011139 *  
#> ---
#> Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
cat("\nDriscoll-Kraay (robust terhadap heteroskedastis, autokorelasi, dan CSD)\n")
#> 
#> Driscoll-Kraay (robust terhadap heteroskedastis, autokorelasi, dan CSD)
coeftest(model_terpilih, vcov = function(x) vcovSCC(x, type = "HC1", maxlag = 2))
#> 
#> t test of coefficients:
#> 
#>              Estimate Std. Error t value  Pr(>|t|)    
#> (Intercept)  4.070453   1.410801  2.8852 0.0041311 ** 
#> X1          -0.021135   0.032984 -0.6408 0.5220473    
#> X2          -0.117302   0.044628 -2.6284 0.0089199 ** 
#> X3           0.426016   0.120868  3.5246 0.0004749 ***
#> ---
#> Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1

10 Kesimpulan

Tuliskan kesimpulan berdasarkan hasil di atas: model terbaik (REM), variabel yang signifikan, serta pelanggaran asumsi dan penanganannya.