Montessori Preschool and Children’s Executive Function Development

Author

Wenli Xu

Introduction

I have worked as a Montessori Primary teacher for several years, and I have always been interested in how young children develop independence, concentration, and self-regulation.

In Montessori classrooms, we focus on Order, Concentration, Coordination, and Independence (OCCI). Children practice these skills through everyday activities such as pouring water, preparing food, cleaning, and working with classroom materials. I have seen children become more independent and better able to manage their behavior over time.

However, I also want to understand what research data can tell us beyond my own classroom experience.

For this project, I am looking at children’s executive function development from baseline to the end of kindergarten. I will compare children who were offered admission to public Montessori preschool programs with children who were not offered admission.

Research Question: How do changes in executive function differ between children who were offered Montessori preschool admission and those who were not?

My main audience is parents of preschool-aged children, especially those who are considering Montessori education. I hope this analysis can help parents better understand children’s development beyond reading and math skills.

Data Source

For this project, I am using the DERS_CLASS dataset from a study of public Montessori preschool programs in the United States. The study used a lottery-based admission process to compare children who were offered Montessori preschool admission with children who were not offered admission.

The dataset includes 588 children and 157 variables. For my analysis, I will focus on three main variables:

The HTKS assessment measures children’s behavioral self-regulation, including skills related to attention, working memory, and controlling their actions. Children are asked to follow instructions that sometimes require them to do the opposite of what they hear.

I will use HTKS scores to explore how children’s self-regulation skills change over time. My main analysis will include children who have scores at both baseline and kindergarten.

The dataset is available through the Open Science Framework (OSF): https://osf.io/vuc42/

Data Import

# Load the dataset
data <- read.csv("DERS_CLASS_data.csv")

# Check the number of rows and columns
dim(data)
[1] 588 157
# Preview the first six rows
head(data)
  X student_id lottery_id lottery_school_id lottery_ranked_choice
1 1     101017         29                21                     0
2 2     101024         29                21                     0
3 3     101025         29                21                     0
4 4     101026         30                21                     0
5 5     101028         30                21                     0
6 6     101036         30                21                     0
  lottery_priority mont_offer mont_enroll female hispanic  race asian black
1             none          1           1      0       NA white     0     0
2             none          0           0      1        0 white     0     0
3             none          0           0      1        0 white     0     0
4       low-income          0           1      1        0 black     0     1
5       low-income          1           1      1        0 asian     1     0
6       low-income          0           0      1        1 white     0     0
  white racemulti raceother primary_lang_english household_size
1     1         0         0                    1              4
2     1         0         0                    1              3
3     1         0         0                    1              4
4     0         0         0                    1              3
5     0         0         0                    0              3
6     1         0         0                    0              3
  household_size_log caregiver_married caregiver_bachelors income_over_75k
1           1.386294                 1                   1               1
2           1.098612                 1                   1               1
3           1.386294                 1                   1               1
4           1.098612                 1                   1               1
5           1.098612                 0                   1               0
6           1.098612                 1                   0               0
  age_study assessed_in_spanish_bl assessed_in_spanish_pk3
1  3.312329                      0                       0
2  3.238356                     NA                       0
3  3.293151                      0                       0
4  3.547945                      0                       0
5  3.695890                      0                       0
6  3.424658                     NA                      NA
  assessed_in_spanish_pk4 assessed_in_spanish_k wjlw_bl wjap_bl wjpv_bl htks_bl
1                      NA                     0    0.05   -0.25    0.11       1
2                       0                     0      NA      NA      NA      NA
3                      NA                    NA    1.00    1.51    2.07       3
4                       0                     0   -0.78    0.03    1.27       1
5                      NA                     0    0.78   -0.25    0.09       1
6                      NA                    NA      NA      NA      NA      NA
  fdigit_bl bdigit_bl tom_bl sps_bl puzz_bl wjlw_pk3 wjap_pk3 wjpv_pk3 htks_pk3
1         4         0      1      0       0     0.01     1.61     0.72       22
2        NA        NA     NA     NA      NA     0.87     1.12     1.05        0
3         7         0      1      0      NA     1.29     1.42     1.73       37
4         7         0      2      0       0    -1.13     1.00     0.24        0
5         5         0      1      1       0     0.24     1.03    -0.11        1
6        NA        NA     NA     NA      NA       NA       NA       NA       NA
  fdigit_pk3 bdigit_pk3 tom_pk3 sps_pk3 puzz_pk3 wjlw_pk4 wjap_pk4 wjpv_pk4
1          4          0       1       2        1       NA       NA       NA
2          9          0       0       1        0     0.52     1.70     0.22
3          7          2       1       2        0       NA       NA       NA
4          6          0       2       1        0    -1.26     0.47     0.03
5          5          0       1       1        0       NA       NA       NA
6         NA         NA      NA      NA       NA       NA       NA       NA
  htks_pk4 fdigit_pk4 bdigit_pk4 tom_pk4 sps_pk4 puzz_pk4 wjlw_k wjap_k wjpv_k
1       NA         NA         NA      NA      NA       NA   2.18   1.41   0.41
2       43          5          2       2       3        0   0.25   0.81  -0.43
3       NA         NA         NA      NA      NA       NA     NA     NA     NA
4       50          8          0       4       1        0   0.10   0.67   0.06
5       NA         NA         NA      NA      NA       NA   1.19   0.96  -0.69
6       NA         NA         NA      NA      NA       NA     NA     NA     NA
  htks_k fdigit_k bdigit_k tom_k sps_k puzz_k assessed_bl assessed_pk3
1     49        9        0     4     0      0           1            1
2     54        7        3     3     4      0           0            1
3     NA       NA       NA    NA    NA     NA           1            1
4     43       10        3     3     2      0           1            1
5     46        8        3     3     3      1           1            1
6     NA       NA       NA    NA    NA     NA           0            0
  assessed_pk4 assessed_k     schl_type_pk3     schl_type_pk4       schl_type_k
1            0          1        mont_study        mont_study        mont_study
2            1          1 mont_nonstudy_pub mont_nonstudy_pub mont_nonstudy_pub
3            0          0           private           private        public_reg
4            1          1        mont_study        mont_study        mont_study
5            0          1        mont_study        public_reg        public_reg
6            0          0           unknown           unknown           unknown
  schl_curric_pk3 schl_curric_pk4 schl_curric_k   schl_curric_detail_pk3
1            mont            mont          mont               Montessori
2            mont            mont          mont               Montessori
3       play_proj       play_proj  other_unsure Play-Based (Unspecified)
4            mont            mont          mont               Montessori
5            mont    other_unsure  other_unsure               Montessori
6         unknown         unknown       unknown                  Unknown
    schl_curric_detail_pk4 schl_curric_detail_k schl_span_pk3 schl_span_pk4
1               Montessori           Montessori          elem          elem
2               Montessori           Montessori          elem          elem
3 Play-Based (Unspecified)              Unclear     childcare     childcare
4               Montessori           Montessori          elem          elem
5     Responsive Classroom Responsive Classroom          elem          elem
6                  Unknown              Unknown       unknown       unknown
  schl_span_k schl_class_age_mix_pk3 schl_class_age_mix_pk4
1        elem                      3                      3
2        elem                      3                      3
3        elem                      2                      2
4        elem                      3                      3
5        elem                      3                      1
6     unknown                Unknown                Unknown
  schl_class_age_mix_k study_mont_yrs_enrolled schl_changes_total
1                    3                     all                  0
2                    3                   never                  0
3                    1                   never                  1
4                    3                     all                  0
5                    1                     pk3                  1
6              Unknown                   never                  0
  schl_changes_ever treatmentstatus schoolid_fall21 schoolid_wint22
1                 0               1             101             101
2                 0               0             108             108
3                 1               0             102             102
4                 0               0             101             101
5                 1               1             101             101
6                 0               0              99              99
  schoolid_pk3 schoolid_pk4 schoolid_k classroomid_wint22 classroomid_pk4
1          101          101        101            101C007         101C007
2          108          108        108            108C001            <NA>
3          102          102       3017            101C009            <NA>
4          101          101        101            101C008            <NA>
5          101          114        114            101C005            <NA>
6           99           99         99               <NA>            <NA>
  dersobsdate dersduration hispanic_raw white_raw black_raw asian_raw
1  02/28/2022     00:58:21           NA         1         0         0
2  03/02/2022     01:00:00            0         1         0         0
3  03/03/2022     00:56:22            0         1         0         0
4       44621     01:00:00            0         0         1         0
5       44620     01:00:00            0         0         0         1
6        <NA>         <NA>            1         1         0         0
  nativehawaiianorpacificislander_raw alaskanativeoramericanindian_raw
1                                   0                                0
2                                   0                                0
3                                   0                                0
4                                   0                                0
5                                   0                                0
6                                   0                                0
  otherrace_raw otherrace_text_raw           race_ethnicity_all hispanicALL
1             0               <NA>                      'White'          NA
2             0               <NA>                      'White'           0
3             0               <NA>                      'White'           0
4             0               <NA>     'Black/African American'           0
5             0               <NA>                      'Asian'           0
6             0               <NA> 'Hispanic or Latino' 'White'           1
  racemultiNH otherraceNH blackNH whiteNH asianNH
1           0           0       0       0       0
2           0           0       0       1       0
3           0           0       0       1       0
4           0           0       1       0       0
5           0           0       0       0       1
6           0           0       0       0       0
  alaskanativeoramericanindianNH hispanic1 black1 asian1 white1 otherrace1
1                              0        NA      0      0     NA          0
2                              0         0      0      0      1          0
3                              0         0      0      0      1          0
4                              0         0      1      0      0          0
5                              0         0      0      1      0          0
6                              0         1      0      0      0          0
  montessori_pk4 montessori_k montessori_sum_k montessori_sum_pk4 wjlw_ws
1              1            1                3                  2     314
2              1            1                3                  2      NA
3              0            0                1                  1     340
4              1            1                3                  2     293
5              0            0                1                  1     340
6              0            0                1                  1      NA
  wjlw_ws_sp22 wjlw_ws_sp23 wjlw_ws_sp24 wjap_ws wjap_ws_sp22 wjap_ws_sp23
1          320           NA          449     372          423           NA
2          345          359          379      NA          411          444
3          359           NA           NA     411          419           NA
4          293          314          388     382          415          427
5          336           NA          434     377          419           NA
6           NA           NA           NA      NA           NA           NA
  wjap_ws_sp24 wjpv_ws wjpv_ws_sp22 wjpv_ws_sp23 wjpv_ws_sp24 ders_child_sum
1          458     452          467           NA          481             43
2          444      NA          470          470          467             45
3           NA     481          481           NA           NA             NA
4          449     470          464          470          477             49
5          458     456          460           NA          467             37
6           NA      NA           NA           NA           NA             NA
  ders_child_percent ders_adult_sum ders_adult_percent ders_envi_sum
1           71.66667             45           75.00000            28
2           75.00000             49           81.66667            32
3                 NA             NA                 NA            NA
4           81.66667             53           88.33333            41
5           61.66667             30           50.00000            26
6                 NA             NA                 NA            NA
  ders_envi_percent ders_total_mean ders_total_percent AvgNoChildren
1          63.63636        38.66667           70.10101         20.50
2          72.72727        42.00000           76.46465         16.00
3                NA              NA                 NA            NA
4          93.18182        47.66667           87.72727         21.75
5          59.09091        31.00000           56.91919         19.50
6                NA              NA                 NA            NA
  AvgNoAdults EmotionalSupport_DomainScore ClassroomOrganization_DomainScore
1        1.75                       4.5625                          4.166667
2        4.75                       5.4375                          5.083333
3          NA                           NA                                NA
4        2.00                       6.2500                          5.833333
5        2.00                       5.0000                          5.416667
6          NA                           NA                                NA
  InstructionalSupport_DomainScore PCCompositeScore NCCompositeScore
1                         1.916667             4.75                1
2                         2.583333             5.75                1
3                               NA               NA               NA
4                         3.333333             6.25                1
5                         2.333333             5.25                1
6                               NA               NA               NA
  ReversedNCCompositeScores_UsedForDomainScore TSCompositeScore
1                                            7             3.75
2                                            7             5.25
3                                           NA               NA
4                                            7             6.00
5                                            7             4.25
6                                           NA               NA
  RSPCompositeScore BMCompositeScore PCompositeScore ILFCompositeScore
1              2.75             5.00            4.00              3.50
2              3.75             6.50            5.00              3.75
3                NA               NA              NA                NA
4              5.75             6.25            6.25              5.00
5              3.50             5.75            5.75              4.75
6                NA               NA              NA                NA
  CDCompositeScore QFCompositeScore LMCompositeScore montessori_pk3
1             1.75             1.75             2.25              1
2             2.25             3.00             2.50              1
3               NA               NA               NA              0
4             2.75             4.00             3.25              1
5             2.25             2.50             2.25              1
6               NA               NA               NA              0

Missing Data

# Check missing HTKS scores
data.frame(
  total_children = nrow(data),
  missing_baseline = sum(is.na(data$htks_bl)),
  missing_kindergarten = sum(is.na(data$htks_k)),
  complete_cases = sum(
    !is.na(data$htks_bl) & !is.na(data$htks_k)
  )
)
  total_children missing_baseline missing_kindergarten complete_cases
1            588              183                  224            292

Data Cleaning and Preparation

# Keep children with scores at both time points
analysis_data <- data[
  !is.na(data$htks_bl) & !is.na(data$htks_k),
]

# Create group labels
analysis_data$group <- ifelse(
  analysis_data$mont_offer == 1,
  "Montessori Offer",
  "No Montessori Offer"
)

# Calculate change in HTKS scores
analysis_data$htks_change <-
  analysis_data$htks_k - analysis_data$htks_bl

# Check the cleaned dataset
nrow(analysis_data)
[1] 292
table(analysis_data$group)

   Montessori Offer No Montessori Offer 
                133                 159 

Descriptive Statistics

# Calculate average HTKS scores for each group
summary_table <- aggregate(
  cbind(htks_bl, htks_k, htks_change) ~ group,
  data = analysis_data,
  FUN = mean
)

# Round the results to two decimal places
summary_table[, 2:4] <- round(summary_table[, 2:4], 2)

# Display the results
summary_table
                group htks_bl htks_k htks_change
1    Montessori Offer    0.70  43.68       42.98
2 No Montessori Offer    0.99  45.70       44.71
# Prepare data for the line chart
plot_data <- data.frame(
  group = rep(summary_table$group, each = 2),
  time = rep(c("Baseline", "Kindergarten"), 2),
  mean_score = c(
    summary_table$htks_bl[1],
    summary_table$htks_k[1],
    summary_table$htks_bl[2],
    summary_table$htks_k[2]
  )
)

# Draw the line chart
library(ggplot2)

ggplot(
  plot_data,
  aes(x = time, y = mean_score, group = group, color = group)
) +
  geom_line(linewidth = 1.2) +
  geom_point(size = 3) +
  labs(
    title = "Changes in Executive Function Scores",
    subtitle = "Baseline to Kindergarten",
    x = "Time",
    y = "Average HTKS Score",
    color = "Group"
  ) +
  theme_minimal(base_size = 13)

The Results

The line chart shows that both groups had much higher average HTKS scores at the end of kindergarten compared to baseline. The Montessori Offer group increased from 0.70 to 43.68, while the No Montessori Offer group increased from 0.99 to 45.70.

Both groups showed large increases in their average scores. The No Montessori Offer group had a slightly higher average increase, but the difference between the groups was small. At this point, we cannot say whether this difference is statistically significant.

These results are interesting to me because I have seen children develop stronger self-regulation skills over time in my Montessori classroom. However, the data remind me that children’s development can happen in different educational settings.

Individual Differences in HTKS Score Changes

# Create a boxplot of HTKS score changes
ggplot(analysis_data, aes(x = group, y = htks_change, fill = group)) +
  geom_boxplot(alpha = 0.7, width = 0.5) +
  labs(
    title = "Differences in HTKS Score Changes",
    subtitle = "Baseline to Kindergarten",
    x = "Group",
    y = "Change in HTKS Score"
  ) +
  theme_minimal(base_size = 13) +
  theme(legend.position = "none")

Individual Differences

The boxplot shows that children in both groups had different levels of improvement in their HTKS scores. The middle ranges of the two groups are quite similar, and their median scores are also close.

Some children showed much smaller changes than others. This reminds me of my Montessori teaching experience, where children develop at different speeds and may need different levels of support.

Overall, the two groups show similar patterns of improvement. However, we would need further statistical analysis to understand whether the difference between them is meaningful.

Comparing HTKS Score Changes

# Compare average HTKS changes between the two groups
t_test_result <- t.test(
  htks_change ~ group,
  data = analysis_data
)

# Display the results
t_test_result

    Welch Two Sample t-test

data:  htks_change by group
t = -1.093, df = 251.42, p-value = 0.2754
alternative hypothesis: true difference in means between group Montessori Offer and group No Montessori Offer is not equal to 0
95 percent confidence interval:
 -4.835158  1.383699
sample estimates:
   mean in group Montessori Offer mean in group No Montessori Offer 
                         42.98496                          44.71069 

The T-test Results

I used a t-test to compare the average changes in HTKS scores between the two groups. The Montessori Offer group had an average increase of 42.98 points, while the No Montessori Offer group had an average increase of 44.71 points.

The p-value was 0.2754, which is higher than 0.05. This means the difference between the two groups was not statistically significant. The 95% confidence interval for the difference was -4.84 to 1.38 points, which also includes zero.

Based on this analysis, I did not find enough evidence that children offered Montessori admission had different average HTKS score changes from those who were not offered admission. However, this does not mean the two educational experiences are exactly the same.

##Final Findings and Recommendations

My research question was whether children who were offered Montessori preschool admission showed different changes in executive function compared to children who were not offered admission.

Based on my analysis, both groups showed large increases in their average HTKS scores from baseline to kindergarten. The Montessori Offer group increased by 42.98 points on average, while the No Montessori Offer group increased by 44.71 points.

The difference between the two groups was not statistically significant (p = 0.2754). This means I did not find enough evidence that the two groups had different average changes in HTKS scores.

As a Montessori teacher, I found these results interesting. I have seen children develop stronger concentration and self-regulation through everyday classroom activities. However, this analysis reminds me that children can develop these skills in different learning environments.

For parents, I think the main takeaway is to pay attention to children’s development beyond academic skills. Giving children opportunities to practice independence, follow routines, and complete tasks on their own can be valuable. Parents can also ask schools how they support children’s self-regulation and independence, rather than only focusing on reading and math.

I would not use these results alone to decide which preschool approach is better. The analysis only looks at one measure of children’s development, and there are other factors to consider when choosing a school.

##Limitations and Ethical Considerations

There are several limitations to my analysis.

First, the original dataset includes 588 children, but only 292 children had HTKS scores at both baseline and kindergarten. I used these 292 children for my main analysis. Since almost half of the children were excluded because of missing scores, the results may not represent everyone in the original study.

Second, HTKS is only one measure of children’s executive function. It focuses on behavioral self-regulation and does not measure everything children learn or develop during preschool. Skills such as independence, social development, and problem-solving are also important, but they were not directly measured in my analysis.

Third, I compared children who were offered Montessori admission with those who were not offered admission. This does not mean that every child in the Montessori Offer group attended a Montessori school or that every child in the comparison group attended a traditional preschool.

My analysis also uses a simple comparison of score changes. It does not account for all possible differences between children or schools, so I cannot use these results alone to make strong claims about the effects of Montessori education.

Since this research involves young children, protecting their privacy is important. I used a publicly available research dataset and reported results at the group level. I will not share information that could identify individual children.

Finally, I want to be careful not to use the results to label children or judge one type of school based on a single test score.

##References

Lillard, A. S., Loeb, D., Berg, J., Escueta, M., Manship, K., Hauser, A., & Daggett, E. D. (2025). A national randomized controlled trial of the impact of public Montessori preschool at the end of kindergarten. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(43), e2506130122. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2506130122

Research Dataset: Open Science Framework (OSF). https://osf.io/vuc42/

Analysis Tools: R, Quarto, and ggplot2.