# Load Package
suppressPackageStartupMessages({
  library(sf)
  library(readxl)
  library(tidyverse)
  library(ggplot2)
  library(spdep)
  library(spatialreg)
  library(MuMIn)
  library(patchwork)
  library(corrplot)   
  library(nortest)    
  library(car)        
  library(lmtest)     
})
## Warning: package 'sf' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'readxl' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'tidyverse' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'tibble' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'tidyr' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'readr' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'purrr' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'dplyr' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'forcats' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'lubridate' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'spdep' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'spData' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'spatialreg' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'MuMIn' was built under R version 4.5.3
## Warning: package 'patchwork' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'corrplot' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'nortest' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'car' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'carData' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'lmtest' was built under R version 4.5.2
## Warning: package 'zoo' was built under R version 4.5.2
base_dir <- "C:\\IPB\\TUGAASS!!!!\\SMT 5\\REGSPAS\\Regspas_11\\Regspas_11"

path_china_shp  <- file.path(base_dir, "data china", "China29", "China29.shp")
path_china_xlsx <- file.path(base_dir, "data china", "Data_China.xlsx")
path_jabar_shp  <- file.path(base_dir, "JABAR", "Jabar2", "Jabar2.shp")
path_jabar_xlsx <- file.path(base_dir, "JABAR", "data_jabar.xlsx")

jalankan_pencarian <- TRUE

# Fungsi bantu: uji LM (lm.LMtests sudah deprecated di spdep terbaru -> lm.RStests)
uji_LM <- function(model, listw, ...) {
  tests <- c("LMerr", "RLMerr", "LMlag", "RLMlag", "SARMA")
  if (exists("lm.RStests", where = asNamespace("spdep"), inherits = FALSE)) {
    spdep::lm.RStests(model, listw, test = tests, ...)
  } else {
    spdep::lm.LMtests(model, listw, test = tests, ...)
  }
}

A. Model Prediksi GRP Data China

Deskripsi Data china_join

Data bersumber dari file Data_China.xlsx yang memuat 29 provinsi di China: koordinat geografis (longitude dan latitude), Gross Regional Product (GRP) sebagai ukuran output ekonomi wilayah, serta tingkat urbanisasi (persen penduduk yang tinggal di kawasan perkotaan). Selain itu terdapat matriks jarak kereta api antar provinsi (km) yang menghubungkan 29 ibu kota provinsi dan dijadikan dasar pembentukan matriks bobot spasial. Analisis bertujuan melihat sejauh mana urbanisasi berpengaruh terhadap GRP dengan mempertimbangkan keterkaitan spasial melalui konektivitas kereta api.

1. Persiapan Data

# Membaca data spasial dalam format shapefile (.shp)
shp_china <- st_read(path_china_shp, quiet = TRUE)

data_china <- read_excel(path_china_xlsx)

china_join <- shp_china %>%
  left_join(data_china, by = c("NAME_1" = "Region"))

head(china_join)
## Simple feature collection with 6 features and 16 fields
## Geometry type: MULTIPOLYGON
## Dimension:     XY
## Bounding box:  xmin: 92.76416 ymin: 20.22264 xmax: 120.8376 ymax: 42.77393
## Geodetic CRS:  WGS 84
##   ID_0 ISO NAME_0 ID_1    NAME_1 HASC_1 CCN_1 CCA_1    TYPE_1    ENGTYPE_1
## 1   49 CHN  China    1     Anhui  CN.AH     0  <NA>     Sh?ng     Province
## 2   49 CHN  China    2   Beijing  CN.BJ     0  <NA> Zhíxiáshì Municipality
## 3   49 CHN  China    3 Chongqing  CN.CQ     0  <NA> Zhíxiáshì Municipality
## 4   49 CHN  China    4    Fujian  CN.FJ     0  <NA>     Sh?ng     Province
## 5   49 CHN  China    5     Gansu  CN.GS     0  <NA>     Sh?ng     Province
## 6   49 CHN  China    6 Guangdong  CN.GD     0  <NA>     Sh?ng     Province
##   NL_NAME_1 VARNAME_1     Long      Lat   GRP Level_of_Urbanization
## 1     ??|??     ?nhu? 117.2262 31.82579 28792                 46.50
## 2     ??|??   B?ij?ng 116.4107 40.18491 87475                 86.20
## 3     ??|?? Chóngqìng 107.8748 30.05865 38914                 56.98
## 4        ??    Fújiàn 117.9815 26.08641 52763                 59.60
## 5     ??|??     G?nsù 100.9339 37.82079 21978                 38.75
## 6     ??|?? Gu?ngd?ng 113.4164 23.34225 54095                 67.40
##                         geometry
## 1 MULTIPOLYGON (((116.4263 34...
## 2 MULTIPOLYGON (((116.6669 40...
## 3 MULTIPOLYGON (((108.5419 32...
## 4 MULTIPOLYGON (((117.689 23....
## 5 MULTIPOLYGON (((97.18472 42...
## 6 MULTIPOLYGON (((110.1182 20...

2. Eksplorasi Data

GRP <- ggplot(data = china_join) +
  geom_sf(aes(fill = GRP), color = "white", linewidth = 0.2) +
  scale_fill_viridis_c(option = "magma", name = "GRP") +
  labs(title = "Gross Regional Product", subtitle = "Data kontinu per provinsi",
       x = "Longitude", y = "Latitude") +
  theme_minimal() +
  theme(legend.position = "bottom",
        plot.title = element_text(face = "bold", size = 14),
        plot.subtitle = element_text(size = 11))

Urbanization <- ggplot(data = china_join) +
  geom_sf(aes(fill = `Level_of_Urbanization`), color = "white", linewidth = 0.2) +
  scale_fill_viridis_c(option = "magma", name = "Level of Urbanization") +
  labs(title = "Level of Urbanization", subtitle = "Data kontinu per provinsi",
       x = "Longitude", y = "Latitude") +
  theme_minimal() +
  theme(legend.position = "bottom",
        plot.title = element_text(face = "bold", size = 14),
        plot.subtitle = element_text(size = 11))

GRP | Urbanization

# Pengecekan struktur data
str(china_join)
## Classes 'sf' and 'data.frame':   29 obs. of  17 variables:
##  $ ID_0                 : chr  "49" "49" "49" "49" ...
##  $ ISO                  : chr  "CHN" "CHN" "CHN" "CHN" ...
##  $ NAME_0               : chr  "China" "China" "China" "China" ...
##  $ ID_1                 : chr  "1" "2" "3" "4" ...
##  $ NAME_1               : chr  "Anhui" "Beijing" "Chongqing" "Fujian" ...
##  $ HASC_1               : chr  "CN.AH" "CN.BJ" "CN.CQ" "CN.FJ" ...
##  $ CCN_1                : chr  "0" "0" "0" "0" ...
##  $ CCA_1                : chr  NA NA NA NA ...
##  $ TYPE_1               : chr  "Sh?ng" "Zhíxiáshì" "Zhíxiáshì" "Sh?ng" ...
##  $ ENGTYPE_1            : chr  "Province" "Municipality" "Municipality" "Province" ...
##  $ NL_NAME_1            : chr  "??|??" "??|??" "??|??" "??" ...
##  $ VARNAME_1            : chr  "?nhu?" "B?ij?ng" "Chóngqìng" "Fújiàn" ...
##  $ Long                 : num  117 116 108 118 101 ...
##  $ Lat                  : num  31.8 40.2 30.1 26.1 37.8 ...
##  $ GRP                  : num  28792 87475 38914 52763 21978 ...
##  $ Level_of_Urbanization: num  46.5 86.2 57 59.6 38.8 ...
##  $ geometry             :sfc_MULTIPOLYGON of length 29; first list element: List of 1
##   ..$ :List of 1
##   .. ..$ : num [1:7291, 1:2] 116 116 116 116 116 ...
##   ..- attr(*, "class")= chr [1:3] "XY" "MULTIPOLYGON" "sfg"
##  - attr(*, "sf_column")= chr "geometry"
##  - attr(*, "agr")= Factor w/ 3 levels "constant","aggregate",..: NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA NA ...
##   ..- attr(*, "names")= chr [1:16] "ID_0" "ISO" "NAME_0" "ID_1" ...
# Pengecekan Missing Value
colSums(is.na(china_join))
##                  ID_0                   ISO                NAME_0 
##                     0                     0                     0 
##                  ID_1                NAME_1                HASC_1 
##                     0                     0                     0 
##                 CCN_1                 CCA_1                TYPE_1 
##                     0                    29                     0 
##             ENGTYPE_1             NL_NAME_1             VARNAME_1 
##                     0                     0                     0 
##                  Long                   Lat                   GRP 
##                     0                     0                     0 
## Level_of_Urbanization              geometry 
##                     0                     0

3. Regresi OLS

china.lm <- lm(GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
summary(china.lm)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## 
## Residuals:
##      Min       1Q   Median       3Q      Max 
## -12050.9  -4410.4   -374.8   2961.6  14948.1 
## 
## Coefficients:
##                       Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)    
## (Intercept)           -31895.5     5197.6  -6.137 1.48e-06 ***
## Level_of_Urbanization   1400.0       92.6  15.118 1.06e-14 ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 6595 on 27 degrees of freedom
## Multiple R-squared:  0.8944, Adjusted R-squared:  0.8904 
## F-statistic: 228.6 on 1 and 27 DF,  p-value: 1.064e-14

[Tambahan] Diagnostik asumsi OLS (normalitas & homoskedastisitas)

err.china <- residuals(china.lm)

# Normalitas sisaan (Anderson-Darling)
ad.test(err.china)
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  err.china
## A = 0.48099, p-value = 0.215
par(mfrow = c(1, 2))
hist(err.china, main = "Histogram Sisaan OLS (China)", col = "dodgerblue", xlab = "Sisaan")
qqnorm(err.china); qqline(err.china, col = "red")

par(mfrow = c(1, 1))

# Kehomogenan ragam (Breusch-Pagan)
lmtest::bptest(china.lm)
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  china.lm
## BP = 3.9868, df = 1, p-value = 0.04586

(Multikolinearitas / VIF tidak dihitung pada bagian China karena hanya terdapat satu peubah penjelas.)

4. Matriks Pembobot Spasial

Matriks bobot berbasis railway distance antar provinsi. Data jarak dikonversi menjadi matriks numerik 29×29, ditransformasi menjadi invers jarak (\(w_{ij}=1/d_{ij}\), diagonal = 0), lalu dinormalisasi (row-standardization) agar jumlah bobot tiap provinsi bernilai satu, dan dikonversi menjadi objek listw.

# Baca jarak kereta dari sheet Railway Distance
rail <- read_excel(path_china_xlsx, sheet = "Railway Distance", skip = 1)
## New names:
## • `` -> `...1`
rail_matrix <- as.matrix(rail[, 3:31])
rownames(rail_matrix) <- colnames(rail_matrix)

# Inverse distance (w_ij = 1/d_ij, diagonal = 0)
W_rail <- 1 / rail_matrix
diag(W_rail) <- 0

# Row-standardize
W_rail_std <- W_rail / rowSums(W_rail)

# Buat listw object
W <- mat2listw(W_rail_std, style = "W")

5. Uji Moran’s I

Uji autokorelasi spasial global pada sisaan model OLS.

col.moran <- lm.morantest(china.lm, W)
col.moran
## 
##  Global Moran I for regression residuals
## 
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## weights: W
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.1234, p-value = 0.1306
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Observed Moran I      Expectation         Variance 
##      0.010629595     -0.033552435      0.001546711

Nilai Moran’s I sisaan tidak signifikan (p-value > 0,05): sisaan menyebar acak dan tidak menunjukkan pola mengelompok secara spasial di sepanjang jaringan kereta api China.

6. Uji Lagrange Multiplier

china.lagrange1 <- uji_LM(china.lm, W)
summary(china.lagrange1)
##  Rao's score (a.k.a Lagrange multiplier) diagnostics for spatial
##  dependence
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## test weights: listw
##  
##          statistic parameter p.value
## RSerr    0.0277967         1  0.8676
## adjRSerr 0.0726855         1  0.7875
## RSlag    0.0035418         1  0.9525
## adjRSlag 0.0484307         1  0.8258
## SARMA    0.0762273         2  0.9626

Baik LM-Lag maupun LM-Error tidak signifikan (p-value > 0,05), sehingga tidak ada bukti ketergantungan spasial pada peubah dependen maupun pada komponen error. Model spasial global (SAR, SEM, SDM) dinilai tidak relevan untuk hubungan urbanisasi dan GRP.

7. SLX Model

Meskipun interaksi spasial global tidak terdeteksi, dicoba model SLX (Spatially-Lagged X) untuk melihat limpahan lokal dari tingkat urbanisasi wilayah tetangga (WX).

china.SLX <- lmSLX(GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join, listw = W, Durbin = TRUE)
summary(china.SLX)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = formula(paste("y ~ ", paste(colnames(x)[-1], collapse = "+"))), 
##     data = as.data.frame(x), weights = weights)
## 
## Coefficients:
##                            Estimate    Std. Error  t value     Pr(>|t|)  
## (Intercept)                -2.335e+04   4.130e+04  -5.654e-01   5.766e-01
## Level_of_Urbanization       1.387e+03   1.139e+02   1.217e+01   3.074e-12
## lag.Level_of_Urbanization  -1.418e+02   6.801e+02  -2.086e-01   8.364e-01

8. LR Test : SLX vs OLS Regression

logLik(china.SLX)
## 'log Lik.' -295.1173 (df=4)
logLik(china.lm)
## 'log Lik.' -295.1415 (df=3)
# nilai LR
LR <- 2 * (as.numeric(logLik(china.SLX)) - as.numeric(logLik(china.lm)))

# derajat bebas
df_lr <- attr(logLik(china.SLX), "df") - attr(logLik(china.lm), "df")

# p-value
pchisq(LR, df = df_lr, lower.tail = FALSE)
## [1] 0.8257453
AICc(china.lm)
## [1] 597.2431
AICc(china.SLX)
## [1] 599.9012

Nilai LR tidak signifikan (p-value > 0,05) dan AICc SLX tidak lebih kecil dari OLS, sehingga penambahan WX tidak memberi kontribusi bermakna. Model OLS adalah model terbaik untuk pengaruh Level_of_Urbanization terhadap GRP.


B. Model Dependensi Spasial (Jawa Barat)

Data Kemiskinan Jawa Barat

1. Data Preprocessing

shp_jabar <- st_read(path_jabar_shp, quiet = TRUE)

data_jabar <- read_excel(path_jabar_xlsx)
data_jabar$KABKOTNO <- as.character(data_jabar$KABKOTNO)

jabar <- shp_jabar %>%
  left_join(data_jabar, by = "KABKOTNO") %>%
  na.omit()

colnames(jabar)
##  [1] "PROVNO.x"   "KABKOTNO"   "KODE2010.x" "PROVINSI.x" "KABKOT.x"  
##  [6] "SUMBER"     "IDSP2010.x" "PROVNO.y"   "KODE2010.y" "PROVINSI.y"
## [11] "KABKOT.y"   "IDSP2010.y" "Long"       "Lat"        "p.miskin15"
## [16] "p.miskin16" "j.miskin15" "j.miskin16" "AHH2015"    "AHH2016"   
## [21] "EYS2015"    "EYS2016"    "MYS2015"    "MYS2016"    "EXP2015"   
## [26] "EXP2016"    "APM.SD15"   "APM.SMP15"  "APM.SMA15"  "APM.PT15"  
## [31] "APK.SD15"   "APK.SMP15"  "APK.SMA15"  "APK.PT15"   "APS.USIA15"
## [36] "APS.USIA2"  "APS.USIA3"  "APS.USIA4"  "geometry"
nrow(jabar)
## [1] 17

2. Exploratory Analysis

plot(jabar[, c(
  "p.miskin15", "AHH2015", "EYS2015", "MYS2015", "EXP2015",
  "APM.SD15", "APM.SMP15", "APM.SMA15", "APM.PT15",
  "APK.SD15", "APK.SMP15", "APK.SMA15", "APK.PT15",
  "APS.USIA15", "APS.USIA2", "APS.USIA3", "APS.USIA4"
)], max.plot = 17)

[Tambahan] Ringkasan statistik, pencilan, dan korelasi

vars_model <- c("p.miskin15", "EYS2015", "APM.SD15", "APK.SD15", "APK.PT15", "APS.USIA15")
jabar_df <- st_drop_geometry(jabar)

# Missing value & ringkasan statistik deskriptif
colSums(is.na(jabar_df[, vars_model]))
## p.miskin15    EYS2015   APM.SD15   APK.SD15   APK.PT15 APS.USIA15 
##          0          0          0          0          0          0
summary(jabar_df[, vars_model])
##    p.miskin15        EYS2015         APM.SD15         APK.SD15    
##  Min.   : 2.397   Min.   :11.39   Min.   : 94.89   Min.   :103.8  
##  1st Qu.: 5.841   1st Qu.:11.74   1st Qu.: 96.56   1st Qu.:106.1  
##  Median : 9.139   Median :12.90   Median : 97.47   Median :110.0  
##  Mean   : 9.352   Mean   :12.57   Mean   : 97.51   Mean   :109.1  
##  3rd Qu.:12.266   3rd Qu.:13.36   3rd Qu.: 98.34   3rd Qu.:111.1  
##  Max.   :16.280   Max.   :13.73   Max.   :100.00   Max.   :117.9  
##     APK.PT15        APS.USIA15    
##  Min.   : 7.943   Min.   : 98.90  
##  1st Qu.:11.335   1st Qu.: 99.36  
##  Median :20.081   Median : 99.75  
##  Mean   :20.998   Mean   : 99.66  
##  3rd Qu.:24.081   3rd Qu.:100.00  
##  Max.   :45.224   Max.   :100.00
# Kabupaten/kota dengan kemiskinan tertinggi dan terendah
jabar_df %>% arrange(desc(p.miskin15)) %>% slice(1) %>% pull(KABKOT.x) %>%
  paste("Kab/kota dengan p.miskin15 tertinggi:", .)
## [1] "Kab/kota dengan p.miskin15 tertinggi: TASIKMALAYA"
jabar_df %>% arrange(p.miskin15) %>% slice(1) %>% pull(KABKOT.x) %>%
  paste("Kab/kota dengan p.miskin15 terendah:", .)
## [1] "Kab/kota dengan p.miskin15 terendah: DEPOK"
# Boxplot (identifikasi pencilan)
par(mfrow = c(2, 3))
for (v in vars_model) boxplot(jabar_df[[v]], main = v, col = "dodgerblue")

par(mfrow = c(1, 1))

# Korelasi antar peubah
corrplot(cor(jabar_df[, vars_model]), method = "number")

3. Matriks Pembobot Spasial

Matriks bobot berbasis ketetanggaan (contiguity). poly2nb secara default memakai metode Queen (wilayah bertetangga bila berbagi sisi maupun titik sudut). Kemudian dikonversi dengan nb2listw (row standardization, style = "W"). zero.policy = TRUE menjaga proses tetap berjalan meskipun ada wilayah tanpa tetangga.

nb_jabar <- suppressWarnings(poly2nb(jabar))

lw_jabar <- nb2listw(nb_jabar, style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)
nb_jabar
## Neighbour list object:
## Number of regions: 17 
## Number of nonzero links: 32 
## Percentage nonzero weights: 11.07266 
## Average number of links: 1.882353 
## 5 regions with no links:
## 18, 19, 21, 25, 26
## 6 disjoint connected subgraphs

[Tambahan] Perbandingan berbagai matriks bobot

Sebagai pembanding, dibentuk matriks bobot lain (Rook, K-Nearest Neighbor, Radial Distance, Inverse Distance, Exponential Distance) dan dibandingkan nilai Moran’s I sisaan OLS serta Moran’s I peubah respon.

ff_jabar <- p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15
ols_tmp  <- lm(ff_jabar, data = jabar)

# Centroid tiap kab/kota (koordinat derajat)
cent <- suppressWarnings(st_coordinates(st_centroid(st_geometry(jabar))))
n_j  <- nrow(jabar)

# Rook
nb_rook <- suppressWarnings(poly2nb(jabar, queen = FALSE))
W_rook  <- nb2listw(nb_rook, style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)

# K-Nearest Neighbor (k = 5)
W_knn <- nb2listw(knn2nb(knearneigh(cent, k = 5, longlat = TRUE)), style = "W")

# Radial distance: jarak maksimum = jarak 1-NN terjauh (km) agar tidak ada wilayah terisolasi
d1   <- unlist(nbdists(knn2nb(knearneigh(cent, k = 1, longlat = TRUE)), cent, longlat = TRUE))
## Warning in knn2nb(knearneigh(cent, k = 1, longlat = TRUE)): neighbour object
## has 4 sub-graphs
dmax <- ceiling(max(d1))
W_rdw <- nb2listw(dnearneigh(cent, 0, dmax, longlat = TRUE), style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)
## Warning in dnearneigh(cent, 0, dmax, longlat = TRUE): neighbour object has 2
## sub-graphs
# Inverse & exponential distance (jarak Euclid pada koordinat centroid)
m.jarak <- as.matrix(dist(cent, method = "euclidean"))
bobot_jarak <- function(f) {
  Wm <- f(m.jarak); diag(Wm) <- 0
  mat2listw(Wm / rowSums(Wm), style = "W")
}
W_idw1 <- bobot_jarak(function(d) 1 / d)
W_idw2 <- bobot_jarak(function(d) 1 / d^2)
W_edw1 <- bobot_jarak(function(d) exp(-1 * d))
W_edw2 <- bobot_jarak(function(d) exp(-2 * d))

daftar_W <- list(W_knn, W_rdw, W_idw1, W_idw2, W_edw1, W_edw2, W_rook, lw_jabar)
names(daftar_W) <- c(
  "K-Nearest Neighbor (k=5)",
  paste0("Radial Distance (dmax=", dmax, " km)"),
  "Inverse Distance (alpha=1)",
  "Inverse Distance (alpha=2)",
  "Exponential Distance (alpha=1)",
  "Exponential Distance (alpha=2)",
  "Rook Contiguity",
  "Queen Contiguity"
)

banding_W <- do.call(rbind, lapply(names(daftar_W), function(nm) {
  w   <- daftar_W[[nm]]
  mr  <- lm.morantest(ols_tmp, w, zero.policy = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
  my  <- moran.test(jabar$p.miskin15, w, zero.policy = TRUE,
                    randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
  data.frame(`Matriks Bobot` = nm,
             `Moran I Sisaan OLS` = unname(mr$estimate[1]),
             `p-value Sisaan` = mr$p.value,
             `Moran I Y` = unname(my$estimate[1]),
             `p-value Y` = my$p.value,
             check.names = FALSE)
}))
banding_W
##                    Matriks Bobot Moran I Sisaan OLS p-value Sisaan  Moran I Y
## 1       K-Nearest Neighbor (k=5)         0.42549754   1.215495e-06 0.20792453
## 2   Radial Distance (dmax=42 km)         0.45098329   4.686983e-03 0.24084190
## 3     Inverse Distance (alpha=1)         0.16402613   5.533279e-06 0.09902255
## 4     Inverse Distance (alpha=2)         0.34663540   8.681991e-05 0.24893241
## 5 Exponential Distance (alpha=1)         0.06173724   1.893857e-05 0.03697797
## 6 Exponential Distance (alpha=2)         0.17856719   6.461964e-06 0.11437225
## 7                Rook Contiguity         0.50119771   5.018003e-03 0.41613663
## 8               Queen Contiguity         0.50119771   5.018003e-03 0.41613663
##      p-value Y
## 1 0.0119352745
## 2 0.0961297052
## 3 0.0028024781
## 4 0.0072649942
## 5 0.0008139345
## 6 0.0017745471
## 7 0.0171952628
## 8 0.0171952628
banding_W[banding_W$`p-value Sisaan` < 0.05, ]
##                    Matriks Bobot Moran I Sisaan OLS p-value Sisaan  Moran I Y
## 1       K-Nearest Neighbor (k=5)         0.42549754   1.215495e-06 0.20792453
## 2   Radial Distance (dmax=42 km)         0.45098329   4.686983e-03 0.24084190
## 3     Inverse Distance (alpha=1)         0.16402613   5.533279e-06 0.09902255
## 4     Inverse Distance (alpha=2)         0.34663540   8.681991e-05 0.24893241
## 5 Exponential Distance (alpha=1)         0.06173724   1.893857e-05 0.03697797
## 6 Exponential Distance (alpha=2)         0.17856719   6.461964e-06 0.11437225
## 7                Rook Contiguity         0.50119771   5.018003e-03 0.41613663
## 8               Queen Contiguity         0.50119771   5.018003e-03 0.41613663
##      p-value Y
## 1 0.0119352745
## 2 0.0961297052
## 3 0.0028024781
## 4 0.0072649942
## 5 0.0008139345
## 6 0.0017745471
## 7 0.0171952628
## 8 0.0171952628

Analisis utama di bawah tetap memakai matriks Queen (lw_jabar) agar konsisten dengan tugas; tabel di atas dapat dipakai untuk melihat sensitivitas terhadap pilihan matriks bobot.

4. Penentuan Variabel (Indeks Moran)

Dicari kombinasi variabel independen (1 sampai maksimum 6 variabel) yang menghasilkan autokorelasi spasial paling kuat pada sisaan OLS. p.miskin15 (persentase penduduk miskin) adalah peubah dependen (Y), seluruh variabel lain adalah kandidat prediktor (X). Hanya kombinasi dengan p-value Moran’s I < 0,05 yang disimpan, lalu diurutkan dari p-value terkecil.

# DAFTAR VARIABEL
variabel_list <- c(
  "p.miskin15", "AHH2015", "EYS2015", "MYS2015", "EXP2015",
  "APM.SD15", "APM.SMP15", "APM.SMA15", "APM.PT15",
  "APK.SD15", "APK.SMP15", "APK.SMA15", "APK.PT15",
  "APS.USIA15", "APS.USIA2", "APS.USIA3", "APS.USIA4"
)

variabel_Y <- "p.miskin15"
variabel_X <- setdiff(variabel_list, variabel_Y)

hasil_model <- data.frame(Formula = character(), Jumlah_X = numeric(),
                          Moran_I = numeric(), P_Value = numeric(),
                          stringsAsFactors = FALSE)

if (jalankan_pencarian) {
  maksimum_X <- 6
  baris <- list()

  for (k in 1:maksimum_X) {
    kombinasi_x <- combn(variabel_X, k, simplify = FALSE)

    for (x_set in kombinasi_x) {
      tryCatch({
        formula_text <- paste(variabel_Y, "~", paste(x_set, collapse = " + "))
        model_ols    <- lm(as.formula(formula_text), data = jabar)
        uji_moran    <- lm.morantest(model_ols, lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
        p_val        <- uji_moran$p.value

        if (p_val < 0.05) {
          baris[[length(baris) + 1]] <- data.frame(
            Formula  = formula_text,
            Jumlah_X = k,
            Moran_I  = as.numeric(uji_moran$estimate["Observed Moran I"]),
            P_Value  = p_val
          )
        }
      }, error = function(e) NULL)
    }
  }
  if (length(baris) > 0) hasil_model <- dplyr::bind_rows(baris)
}

hasil_model <- hasil_model %>% arrange(P_Value)

if (nrow(hasil_model) == 0) {
  cat("Tidak ada model signifikan (atau pencarian dilewati).\n")
} else {
  model_terbaik <- hasil_model %>% slice(1)
  cat("Formula              : ", as.character(model_terbaik$Formula), "\n", sep = "")
  cat("Jumlah Variabel X    : ", model_terbaik$Jumlah_X, "\n", sep = "")
  cat("Moran's I            : ", round(model_terbaik$Moran_I, 5), "\n", sep = "")
  cat("P-Value              : ", format(model_terbaik$P_Value, scientific = FALSE), "\n", sep = "")
}
## Formula              : p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15
## Jumlah Variabel X    : 5
## Moran's I            : 0.5012
## P-Value              : 0.005018003

Hasil pencarian pada data tugas: p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15 (Moran’s I = 0,5012; p-value = 0,005), yaitu sisaan OLS memiliki autokorelasi spasial positif yang kuat, sehingga layak dilanjutkan dengan regresi spasial. Formula ini dipakai pada seluruh langkah berikutnya.

5. OLS Regression

jabar.lm <- lm(p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15, data = jabar)
summary(jabar.lm)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + 
##     APS.USIA15, data = jabar)
## 
## Residuals:
##     Min      1Q  Median      3Q     Max 
## -6.2541 -1.5129  0.7468  1.7253  2.9766 
## 
## Coefficients:
##              Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)  
## (Intercept) -263.5186   236.1804  -1.116   0.2883  
## EYS2015        2.7220     2.1113   1.289   0.2238  
## APM.SD15      -0.5289     0.6939  -0.762   0.4619  
## APK.SD15       0.4526     0.2946   1.536   0.1527  
## APK.PT15      -0.3228     0.1731  -1.865   0.0891 .
## APS.USIA15     2.4849     2.5164   0.987   0.3446  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 3.114 on 11 degrees of freedom
## Multiple R-squared:  0.5749, Adjusted R-squared:  0.3816 
## F-statistic: 2.975 on 5 and 11 DF,  p-value: 0.06127

[Tambahan] Diagnostik model OLS

err.jabar <- residuals(jabar.lm)
print(paste("AIC OLS:", round(AIC(jabar.lm), 3)))
## [1] "AIC OLS: 93.465"
# Normalitas sisaan
ad.test(err.jabar)
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  err.jabar
## A = 0.49311, p-value = 0.1877
par(mfrow = c(1, 2))
hist(err.jabar, main = "Histogram Sisaan OLS (Jabar)", col = "dodgerblue", xlab = "Sisaan")
qqnorm(err.jabar); qqline(err.jabar, col = "red")

par(mfrow = c(1, 1))

# Kehomogenan ragam
lmtest::bptest(jabar.lm)
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  jabar.lm
## BP = 0.88003, df = 5, p-value = 0.9717
# Multikolinearitas
car::vif(jabar.lm)
##    EYS2015   APM.SD15   APK.SD15   APK.PT15 APS.USIA15 
##   5.314614   1.904803   1.909792   5.864388   1.432641

6. Uji Lagrange Multiplier

jabar.lagrange <- uji_LM(jabar.lm, lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(jabar.lagrange)
##  Rao's score (a.k.a Lagrange multiplier) diagnostics for spatial
##  dependence
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 +
## APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15, data = jabar)
## test weights: listw
##  
##          statistic parameter  p.value   
## RSerr      7.23955         1 0.007132 **
## adjRSerr   5.48939         1 0.019132 * 
## RSlag      2.01129         1 0.156133   
## adjRSlag   0.26113         1 0.609346   
## SARMA      7.50067         2 0.023510 * 
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1

Uji RSerr signifikan (p = 0,007) dan adjRSerr tetap signifikan (p = 0,019): ada spatial error yang hadir secara mandiri. RSlag (p = 0,156) dan adjRSlag (p = 0,609) tidak signifikan, sehingga dependensi spasial bersumber dari komponen error, bukan dari lag peubah dependen.

7. Spatial Error Model (SEM)

jabar.err <- errorsarlm(p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15,
                        lw_jabar, data = jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(jabar.err)
## 
## Call:errorsarlm(formula = p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + 
##     APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##      Min       1Q   Median       3Q      Max 
## -1.96720 -0.97706  0.17825  0.76731  1.45103 
## 
## Type: error 
## Regions with no neighbours included:
##  18 19 21 25 26 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##                Estimate  Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -425.458866   84.564213 -5.0312 4.874e-07
## EYS2015        4.311729    1.035451  4.1641 3.126e-05
## APM.SD15      -1.521207    0.226462 -6.7173 1.852e-11
## APK.SD15       0.640932    0.101930  6.2880 3.216e-10
## APK.PT15      -0.358322    0.069408 -5.1626 2.436e-07
## APS.USIA15     4.680477    0.828208  5.6513 1.592e-08
## 
## Lambda: 0.9059, LR test value: 23.088, p-value: 1.5476e-06
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.060606
##     z-value: 14.947, p-value: < 2.22e-16
## Wald statistic: 223.43, p-value: < 2.22e-16
## 
## Log likelihood: -28.18863 for error model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 1.0473, (sigma: 1.0234)
## Number of observations: 17 
## Number of parameters estimated: 8 
## AIC: 72.377, (AIC for lm: 93.465)
# [Tambahan] Normalitas sisaan SEM
ad.test(residuals(jabar.err))
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  residuals(jabar.err)
## A = 0.48895, p-value = 0.1924

8. Model SLX

jabar.SLX <- lmSLX(p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15,
                   lw_jabar, data = jabar, zero.policy = TRUE, Durbin = TRUE)
summary(jabar.SLX)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = formula(paste("y ~ ", paste(colnames(x)[-1], collapse = "+"))), 
##     data = as.data.frame(x), weights = weights)
## 
## Coefficients:
##                 Estimate    Std. Error  t value     Pr(>|t|)  
## (Intercept)     -145.59982   307.35728    -0.47372     0.65245
## EYS2015            2.63817     4.59362     0.57431     0.58663
## APM.SD15           0.26488     0.97666     0.27122     0.79532
## APK.SD15           0.59059     0.23882     2.47293     0.04827
## APK.PT15          -0.20577     0.38277    -0.53759     0.61021
## APS.USIA15         0.36388     3.17195     0.11472     0.91241
## lag.EYS2015       -4.02200     9.31944    -0.43157     0.68113
## lag.APM.SD15       3.42980     1.21392     2.82538     0.03014
## lag.APK.SD15      -0.41090     0.69159    -0.59414     0.57412
## lag.APK.PT15       0.38003     0.82137     0.46268     0.65990
## lag.APS.USIA15    -2.48727     1.03245    -2.40910     0.05264

Lag pada sebagian besar variabel X tidak signifikan, sehingga penambahan dependensi spasial pada X (model SDEM) tidak diperlukan.

9. Model SARMA

jabar.sarma <- sacsarlm(p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15,
                        lw_jabar, data = jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(jabar.sarma)
## 
## Call:sacsarlm(formula = p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + 
##     APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##       Min        1Q    Median        3Q       Max 
## -1.837342 -0.900247 -0.050073  0.685523  1.606525 
## 
## Type: sac 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##                Estimate  Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -442.074286   83.148799 -5.3167 1.057e-07
## EYS2015        4.793132    1.140231  4.2037 2.626e-05
## APM.SD15      -1.707710    0.293038 -5.8276 5.623e-09
## APK.SD15       0.672837    0.103147  6.5231 6.886e-11
## APK.PT15      -0.392055    0.076727 -5.1097 3.226e-07
## APS.USIA15     4.939024    0.838588  5.8897 3.869e-09
## 
## Rho: 0.20377
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.19972
##     z-value: 1.0202, p-value: 0.30761
## Lambda: 0.91256
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.065071
##     z-value: 14.024, p-value: < 2.22e-16
## 
## LR test value: 23.918, p-value: 6.4015e-06
## 
## Log likelihood: -27.77358 for sac model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 0.97176, (sigma: 0.98578)
## Number of observations: 17 
## Number of parameters estimated: 9 
## AIC: 73.547, (AIC for lm: 93.465)
# [Tambahan] Normalitas sisaan SARMA
ad.test(residuals(jabar.sarma))
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  residuals(jabar.sarma)
## A = 0.27269, p-value = 0.6224

Rho (\(\rho\) = 0,204) tidak signifikan (p = 0,308), sedangkan Lambda (\(\lambda\) = 0,913) sangat signifikan: dependensi spasial berada pada komponen error, sehingga SEM lebih tepat dibanding SARMA.

10. LR Test : SEM vs SARMA

anova(jabar.err, jabar.sarma)
##             Model df    AIC  logLik Test L.Ratio p-value
## jabar.err       1  8 72.377 -28.189    1                
## jabar.sarma     2  9 73.547 -27.774    2 0.83008 0.36225

L.Ratio = 0,830 dengan p-value = 0,362 (> 0,05), H0 gagal ditolak: penambahan \(\rho\) pada SARMA tidak meningkatkan fit secara signifikan. AIC SEM (72,377) lebih kecil dari SARMA (73,547), sehingga SEM lebih parsimoni.

11. [Tambahan] Model SAR dan SDM

Untuk melengkapi perbandingan, dibangun juga model SAR (spatial lag) dan SDM (Spatial Durbin Model) sebagaimana pada materi tambahan. Catatan: dengan hanya 17 pengamatan, SDM (5 peubah + 5 lag) memiliki banyak parameter sehingga estimasinya bisa tidak stabil; chunk dibungkus tryCatch agar dokumen tetap dapat di-knit.

jabar.sar <- lagsarlm(p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15,
                      data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(jabar.sar, Nagelkerke = TRUE)
## 
## Call:lagsarlm(formula = p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + 
##     APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##      Min       1Q   Median       3Q      Max 
## -5.35929 -0.59379  0.56548  1.22936  3.30456 
## 
## Type: lag 
## Regions with no neighbours included:
##  18 19 21 25 26 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##               Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -125.57741  210.78513 -0.5958 0.551335
## EYS2015        5.98300    2.26537  2.6411 0.008264
## APM.SD15      -1.25194    0.55826 -2.2426 0.024924
## APK.SD15       0.47950    0.21824  2.1972 0.028008
## APK.PT15      -0.56418    0.18450 -3.0578 0.002229
## APS.USIA15     1.39601    2.18125  0.6400 0.522169
## 
## Rho: 0.32622, LR test value: 2.3723, p-value: 0.1235
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.1807
##     z-value: 1.8053, p-value: 0.071034
## Wald statistic: 3.259, p-value: 0.071034
## 
## Log likelihood: -38.54641 for lag model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 5.2836, (sigma: 2.2986)
## Nagelkerke pseudo-R-squared: 0.63023 
## Number of observations: 17 
## Number of parameters estimated: 8 
## AIC: 93.093, (AIC for lm: 93.465)
## LM test for residual autocorrelation
## test value: 7.2833, p-value: 0.0069599
ad.test(residuals(jabar.sar))
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  residuals(jabar.sar)
## A = 0.76822, p-value = 0.03661
jabar.sdm <- tryCatch(
  lagsarlm(p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15,
           data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE, type = "mixed"),
  error = function(e) { message("SDM gagal diestimasi: ", conditionMessage(e)); NULL }
)

if (!is.null(jabar.sdm)) {
  print(summary(jabar.sdm))
  print(ad.test(residuals(jabar.sdm)))
  print(bptest.Sarlm(jabar.sdm))
  print(moran.test(residuals(jabar.sdm), listw = lw_jabar,
                   alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE))
}
## 
## Call:lagsarlm(formula = p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + 
##     APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, type = "mixed", 
##     zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##       Min        1Q    Median        3Q       Max 
## -1.761337 -0.537131 -0.014668  0.470410  1.646040 
## 
## Type: mixed 
## Regions with no neighbours included:
##  18 19 21 25 26 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##                   Estimate  Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept)    -223.304626  126.817210 -1.7608 0.0782657
## EYS2015           6.334925    1.930583  3.2814 0.0010331
## APM.SD15         -1.411171    0.442053 -3.1923 0.0014114
## APK.SD15          0.595334    0.098329  6.0545 1.408e-09
## APK.PT15         -0.512337    0.160297 -3.1962 0.0013926
## APS.USIA15        2.359615    1.324744  1.7812 0.0748821
## lag.EYS2015      -0.658247    3.837250 -0.1715 0.8637981
## lag.APM.SD15      2.391188    0.500735  4.7754 1.794e-06
## lag.APK.SD15     -1.106008    0.318673 -3.4707 0.0005192
## lag.APK.PT15     -0.035526    0.338363 -0.1050 0.9163814
## lag.APS.USIA15   -1.090206    0.444275 -2.4539 0.0141317
## 
## Rho: 0.7606, LR test value: 8.4198, p-value: 0.0037115
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.12636
##     z-value: 6.0194, p-value: 1.7508e-09
## Wald statistic: 36.233, p-value: 1.7508e-09
## 
## Log likelihood: -25.75121 for mixed model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 0.95434, (sigma: 0.9769)
## Number of observations: 17 
## Number of parameters estimated: 13 
## AIC: 77.502, (AIC for lm: 83.922)
## LM test for residual autocorrelation
## test value: 0.36579, p-value: 0.54531
## 
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  residuals(jabar.sdm)
## A = 0.18583, p-value = 0.8908
## 
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  
## BP = 12.426, df = 10, p-value = 0.2576
## 
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  residuals(jabar.sdm)  
## weights: lw_jabar  
## n reduced by no-neighbour observations  
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 0.62361, p-value = 0.5329
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.05730224       -0.09090909        0.05648605

12. Akaike Information Criterion Corrected (AICc) dan Pemilihan Model

AICc(jabar.lm)
## [1] 105.9096
AICc(jabar.err)
## [1] 90.37725
AICc(jabar.sarma)
## [1] 99.26145
# [Tambahan] Tabel perbandingan seluruh model
model_list <- list(
  "OLS (Regresi Klasik)" = jabar.lm,
  "SLX"   = jabar.SLX,
  "SEM"   = jabar.err,
  "SAR"   = jabar.sar,
  "SARMA" = jabar.sarma
)
if (!is.null(jabar.sdm)) model_list[["SDM"]] <- jabar.sdm

perbandingan <- data.frame(
  Model = names(model_list),
  AIC   = sapply(model_list, function(m) AIC(m)),
  AICc  = sapply(model_list, function(m) as.numeric(AICc(m))),
  row.names = NULL
) %>% arrange(AICc)
perbandingan
##                  Model      AIC      AICc
## 1                  SEM 72.37725  90.37725
## 2                SARMA 73.54717  99.26145
## 3 OLS (Regresi Klasik) 93.46513 105.90957
## 4                  SAR 93.09281 111.09281
## 5                  SLX 83.92225 161.92225
## 6                  SDM 77.50241 198.83575

Model dengan AICc terkecil dipilih sebagai model terbaik. Pada hasil tugas, SEM memiliki AICc terendah (90,38) dibanding OLS (105,91) dan SARMA (99,26).

13. [Tambahan] Efek Langsung, Tidak Langsung, dan Umpan Balik (Spillover)

Model SEM tidak memiliki efek spillover melalui \(\rho\) (dependensi hanya di error), sehingga impacts() hanya relevan untuk model dengan lag (SAR, SARMA, SDM).

# SAR
im_sar <- tryCatch(impacts(jabar.sar, listw = lw_jabar), error = function(e) conditionMessage(e))
im_sar
## Impact measures (lag, exact):
##                      Direct   Indirect      Total
## EYS2015 dy/dx     6.1892234  2.6904888  8.8797122
## APM.SD15 dy/dx   -1.2950917 -0.5629833 -1.8580750
## APK.SD15 dy/dx    0.4960284  0.2156262  0.7116546
## APK.PT15 dy/dx   -0.5836212 -0.2537033 -0.8373244
## APS.USIA15 dy/dx  1.4441262  0.6277694  2.0718956
# SARMA + efek umpan balik (feedback = efek langsung - koefisien)
im_sarma <- tryCatch(impacts(jabar.sarma, listw = lw_jabar), error = function(e) conditionMessage(e))
im_sarma
## Impact measures (sac, exact):
##                      Direct    Indirect      Total
## EYS2015 dy/dx     4.8529413  1.16680904  6.0197503
## APM.SD15 dy/dx   -1.7290184 -0.41571374 -2.1447322
## APK.SD15 dy/dx    0.6812325  0.16379102  0.8450235
## APK.PT15 dy/dx   -0.3969468 -0.09543925 -0.4923860
## APS.USIA15 dy/dx  5.0006532  1.20232392  6.2029771
if (!is.character(im_sarma)) {
  koef   <- jabar.sarma$coefficients[-1]   # tanpa intercept
  direct <- as.numeric(im_sarma$res$direct)
  if (length(direct) == 0) direct <- as.numeric(im_sarma$direct)
  data.frame(Peubah = names(koef),
             Koefisien = as.numeric(koef),
             EfekLangsung = direct,
             UmpanBalik = direct - as.numeric(koef))
}
##       Peubah  Koefisien EfekLangsung   UmpanBalik
## 1    EYS2015  4.7931324    4.8529413  0.059808838
## 2   APM.SD15 -1.7077096   -1.7290184 -0.021308847
## 3   APK.SD15  0.6728368    0.6812325  0.008395676
## 4   APK.PT15 -0.3920547   -0.3969468 -0.004892069
## 5 APS.USIA15  4.9390239    5.0006532  0.061629276
# SDM
if (!is.null(jabar.sdm)) {
  tryCatch(impacts(jabar.sdm, listw = lw_jabar), error = function(e) conditionMessage(e))
}
## Impact measures (mixed, exact):
##                      Direct  Indirect     Total
## EYS2015 dy/dx     8.2361210 15.476108 23.712229
## APM.SD15 dy/dx   -0.8089049  4.902563  4.093659
## APK.SD15 dy/dx    0.2968189 -2.429973 -2.133154
## APK.PT15 dy/dx   -0.7066605 -1.581833 -2.288494
## APS.USIA15 dy/dx  2.6815861  2.620904  5.302490

Kesimpulan

  • China: tidak ada dependensi spasial pada sisaan (Moran’s I, LM tidak signifikan) dan SLX tidak memperbaiki OLS, sehingga OLS adalah model terbaik; urbanisasi berpengaruh positif signifikan terhadap GRP.
  • Jawa Barat: dependensi spasial muncul pada komponen error (LM-error signifikan, \(\lambda\) sangat signifikan, \(\rho\) tidak signifikan), sehingga SEM dipilih (AIC/AICc terkecil, LR test terhadap SARMA tidak signifikan).
sessionInfo()
## R version 4.5.1 (2025-06-13 ucrt)
## Platform: x86_64-w64-mingw32/x64
## Running under: Windows 10 x64 (build 19045)
## 
## Matrix products: default
##   LAPACK version 3.12.1
## 
## locale:
## [1] LC_COLLATE=English_Indonesia.utf8  LC_CTYPE=English_Indonesia.utf8   
## [3] LC_MONETARY=English_Indonesia.utf8 LC_NUMERIC=C                      
## [5] LC_TIME=English_Indonesia.utf8    
## 
## time zone: Asia/Jakarta
## tzcode source: internal
## 
## attached base packages:
## [1] stats     graphics  grDevices utils     datasets  methods   base     
## 
## other attached packages:
##  [1] lmtest_0.9-40    zoo_1.8-15       car_3.1-5        carData_3.0-6   
##  [5] nortest_1.0-4    corrplot_0.95    patchwork_1.3.2  MuMIn_1.48.19   
##  [9] spatialreg_1.4-3 Matrix_1.7-3     spdep_1.4-2      spData_2.3.5    
## [13] lubridate_1.9.5  forcats_1.0.1    stringr_1.5.1    dplyr_1.1.4     
## [17] purrr_1.2.1      readr_2.2.0      tidyr_1.3.2      tibble_3.3.0    
## [21] ggplot2_4.0.2    tidyverse_2.0.0  readxl_1.4.5     sf_1.1-2        
## 
## loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
##  [1] tidyselect_1.2.1      viridisLite_0.4.2     farver_2.1.2         
##  [4] S7_0.2.1              fastmap_1.2.0         TH.data_1.1-5        
##  [7] digest_0.6.37         timechange_0.4.0      lifecycle_1.0.5      
## [10] LearnBayes_2.15.2     survival_3.8-3        magrittr_2.0.3       
## [13] compiler_4.5.1        rlang_1.1.7           sass_0.4.10          
## [16] tools_4.5.1           igraph_2.2.1          yaml_2.3.10          
## [19] data.table_1.18.2.1   knitr_1.50            labeling_0.4.3       
## [22] sp_2.2-3              classInt_0.4-11       RColorBrewer_1.1-3   
## [25] abind_1.4-8           multcomp_1.4-32       KernSmooth_2.23-26   
## [28] withr_3.0.2           grid_4.5.1            stats4_4.5.1         
## [31] e1071_1.7-17          scales_1.4.0          MASS_7.3-65          
## [34] cli_3.6.5             mvtnorm_1.4-2         rmarkdown_2.29       
## [37] generics_0.1.4        rstudioapi_0.18.0     tzdb_0.5.0           
## [40] DBI_1.2.3             cachem_1.1.0          proxy_0.4-29         
## [43] splines_4.5.1         s2_1.1.9              cellranger_1.1.0     
## [46] marginaleffects_1.0.0 vctrs_0.7.1           boot_1.3-31          
## [49] sandwich_3.1-1        jsonlite_2.0.0        hms_1.1.4            
## [52] Formula_1.2-5         jquerylib_0.1.4       units_1.0-0          
## [55] glue_1.8.0            codetools_0.2-20      stringi_1.8.7        
## [58] gtable_0.3.6          deldir_2.0-4          pillar_1.11.1        
## [61] htmltools_0.5.8.1     R6_2.6.1              wk_0.9.5             
## [64] evaluate_1.0.4        lattice_0.22-7        backports_1.5.0      
## [67] bslib_0.9.0           class_7.3-23          Rcpp_1.1.1           
## [70] coda_0.19-4.1         nlme_3.1-168          xfun_0.52            
## [73] pkgconfig_2.0.3