1 Konfigurasi dan Pemindaian Data

1.1 Paket

paket <- c("sf", "sp", "readxl", "openxlsx", "spdep", "spatialreg", "MuMIn",
           "corrplot", "DescTools", "nortest", "car", "lmtest", "RColorBrewer",
           "tidyverse")

baru <- paket[!paket %in% rownames(installed.packages())]
if (length(baru) > 0) install.packages(baru)
invisible(lapply(paket, library, character.only = TRUE))

1.2 Parameter analisis

taraf <- 0.05

join_china_shp <- "NAME_1"
join_china_xls <- "Region"
sheet_rail     <- "Railway Distance"
skip_rail      <- 1
k_china        <- 3

join_jabar     <- "KABKOTNO"
y_jabar        <- "p.miskin15"
variabel_jabar <- c("p.miskin15", "AHH2015", "EYS2015", "MYS2015", "EXP2015",
                    "APM.SD15", "APM.SMP15", "APM.SMA15", "APM.PT15",
                    "APK.SD15", "APK.SMP15", "APK.SMA15", "APK.PT15",
                    "APS.USIA15", "APS.USIA2", "APS.USIA3", "APS.USIA4")
maks_x         <- 6
rumus_manual   <- p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15

k_jawa    <- 5
dmax_jawa <- 105

1.3 Fungsi bantu

aman <- function(expr, default = "(tidak tersedia)") tryCatch(expr, error = function(e) default)

sig <- function(p) ifelse(p < taraf, "signifikan", "tidak signifikan")

p_par <- function(m, nama) {
  est <- m[[nama]]
  se  <- m[[paste0(nama, ".se")]]
  if (is.null(est) || is.null(se)) NA_real_ else 2 * pnorm(-abs(est / se))
}

get_im <- function(Im, nm) {
  if (!is.null(Im[[nm]])) Im[[nm]] else Im$res[[nm]]
}

1.4 Pemindaian data

base_dir <- "C:/Valent/Kuliah/Semester 5/Regresi Spasial/tugas 17 nov/Regspas_11"
path_manual <- list(
   "China29.shp" = "C:\\Valent\\Kuliah\\Semester 5\\Regresi Spasial\\tugas 17 nov\\Regspas_11\\Regspas_11\\data china\\China29\\China29.shp",
   "data-06.csv" = "C:\\Valent\\Kuliah\\Semester 5\\Regresi Spasial\\tugas 17 nov\\Regspas_11\\Regspas_11\\Dataset 06\\data-06.csv"
)

butuh <- tibble::tribble(
  ~bagian,                        ~peran,                                  ~file,
  "China",                        "Peta (shapefile)",                      "China29.shp",
  "China",                        "Atribut + sheet jarak kereta",          "Data_China.xlsx",
  "Jawa Barat",                   "Peta (shapefile)",                      "Jabar2.shp",
  "Jawa Barat",                   "Data kemiskinan dan prediktor",         "data_jabar.xlsx",
  "Pulau Jawa (materi tambahan)", "Peta (shapefile)",                      "jawa.shp",
  "Pulau Jawa (materi tambahan)", "Data Y, X1, X2",                        "data-06.csv"
)

cari_file <- function(nama, dir = base_dir) {
  hit <- list.files(dir, pattern = glob2rx(nama), recursive = TRUE,
                    full.names = TRUE, ignore.case = TRUE)
  hit <- hit[!grepl("__MACOSX", hit, fixed = TRUE)]
  if (length(hit) > 0) hit[1] else NA_character_
}

butuh$path <- vapply(butuh$file, cari_file, character(1))
for (f in names(path_manual)) butuh$path[butuh$file == f] <- path_manual[[f]]
butuh$ada <- !is.na(butuh$path) & file.exists(butuh$path)

P <- function(f) butuh$path[butuh$file == f]

ok_china <- all(butuh$ada[butuh$bagian == "China"])
ok_jabar <- all(butuh$ada[butuh$bagian == "Jawa Barat"])
ok_jawa  <- all(butuh$ada[butuh$bagian == "Pulau Jawa (materi tambahan)"])

butuh[, c("bagian", "peran", "file", "ada", "path")]

Ringkasan isi tiap file (dimensi, nama kolom, dan pengecekan kolom wajib):

intip <- function(x, judul, wajib = character(0)) {
  if (inherits(x, "sf")) x <- sf::st_drop_geometry(x)
  cat("\n==", judul, "==\n")
  cat("Dimensi :", paste(dim(x), collapse = " x "), "\n")
  cat("Kolom   :", paste(names(x), collapse = ", "), "\n")
  hilang <- setdiff(wajib, names(x))
  if (length(hilang) > 0) cat("KOLOM WAJIB TIDAK ADA:", paste(hilang, collapse = ", "), "\n")
  else if (length(wajib) > 0) cat("Semua kolom wajib tersedia.\n")
}

if (ok_china) {
  intip(st_read(P("China29.shp"), quiet = TRUE), "China29.shp", join_china_shp)
  cat("\nSheet pada Data_China.xlsx:", paste(excel_sheets(P("Data_China.xlsx")), collapse = " | "), "\n")
  intip(read_excel(P("Data_China.xlsx")), "Data_China.xlsx (sheet pertama)",
        c(join_china_xls, "GRP", "Level_of_Urbanization"))
}
## 
## == China29.shp ==
## Dimensi : 29 x 12 
## Kolom   : ID_0, ISO, NAME_0, ID_1, NAME_1, HASC_1, CCN_1, CCA_1, TYPE_1, ENGTYPE_1, NL_NAME_1, VARNAME_1 
## Semua kolom wajib tersedia.
## 
## Sheet pada Data_China.xlsx: Data | Railway Distance 
## 
## == Data_China.xlsx (sheet pertama) ==
## Dimensi : 29 x 5 
## Kolom   : Region, Long, Lat, GRP, Level_of_Urbanization 
## Semua kolom wajib tersedia.
if (ok_jabar) {
  intip(st_read(P("Jabar2.shp"), quiet = TRUE), "Jabar2.shp", join_jabar)
  intip(read_excel(P("data_jabar.xlsx")), "data_jabar.xlsx", c(join_jabar, variabel_jabar))
}
## 
## == Jabar2.shp ==
## Dimensi : 26 x 7 
## Kolom   : PROVNO, KABKOTNO, KODE2010, PROVINSI, KABKOT, SUMBER, IDSP2010 
## Semua kolom wajib tersedia.
## 
## == data_jabar.xlsx ==
## Dimensi : 26 x 32 
## Kolom   : PROVNO, KABKOTNO, KODE2010, PROVINSI, KABKOT, IDSP2010, Long, Lat, p.miskin15, p.miskin16, j.miskin15, j.miskin16, AHH2015, AHH2016, EYS2015, EYS2016, MYS2015, MYS2016, EXP2015, EXP2016, APM.SD15, APM.SMP15, APM.SMA15, APM.PT15, APK.SD15, APK.SMP15, APK.SMA15, APK.PT15, APS.USIA15, APS.USIA2, APS.USIA3, APS.USIA4 
## Semua kolom wajib tersedia.
if (ok_jawa) {
  intip(st_read(P("jawa.shp"), quiet = TRUE), "jawa.shp", "ID2013")
  intip(read.csv(P("data-06.csv")), "data-06.csv",
        c("ID_KAB", "KAB", "long", "lat", "y", "x1", "x2"))
}
## 
## == jawa.shp ==
## Dimensi : 119 x 5 
## Kolom   : PROVNO, KABKOTNO, PROVINSI, KABKOT, ID2013 
## Semua kolom wajib tersedia.
## 
## == data-06.csv ==
## Dimensi : 119 x 8 
## Kolom   : ID_KAB, PROPINSI, KAB, long, lat, y, x1, x2 
## Semua kolom wajib tersedia.

2 Model Prediksi GRP Data China

Pada bagian ini GRP (Gross Regional Product) provinsi di China diprediksi dari tingkat urbanisasi. Dua matriks pembobot dibandingkan: jarak kereta api (invers jarak) dan KNN.

2.1 Data dan eksplorasi peta

shp_china  <- st_read(P("China29.shp"), quiet = TRUE)
data_china <- read_excel(P("Data_China.xlsx"))

china_join <- shp_china %>%
  left_join(data_china, by = setNames(join_china_xls, join_china_shp))

cat("Jumlah wilayah:", nrow(china_join),
    "| wilayah tanpa pasangan data GRP:", sum(is.na(china_join$GRP)), "\n")
## Jumlah wilayah: 29 | wilayah tanpa pasangan data GRP: 0
china_join %>% st_drop_geometry() %>% head()
tema_peta <- theme_minimal() +
  theme(legend.position = "bottom",
        plot.title = element_text(face = "bold", size = 14),
        plot.subtitle = element_text(size = 11))

peta_kontinu <- function(dat_sf, var, judul, label) {
  ggplot(dat_sf) +
    geom_sf(aes(fill = .data[[var]]), color = "white", linewidth = 0.2) +
    scale_fill_viridis_c(option = "magma", name = label) +
    labs(title = judul, subtitle = "Data kontinu per provinsi",
         x = "Longitude", y = "Latitude") +
    tema_peta
}

peta_kontinu(china_join, "GRP", "Gross Regional Product di China", "GRP")

peta_kontinu(china_join, "Level_of_Urbanization", "Level of Urbanization di China",
             "Level of Urbanization")

2.2 Regresi OLS

china.lm <- lm(GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
summary(china.lm)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## 
## Residuals:
##    Min     1Q Median     3Q    Max 
## -12051  -4410   -375   2962  14948 
## 
## Coefficients:
##                       Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)    
## (Intercept)           -31895.5     5197.6   -6.14  1.5e-06 ***
## Level_of_Urbanization   1400.0       92.6   15.12  1.1e-14 ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 6600 on 27 degrees of freedom
## Multiple R-squared:  0.894,  Adjusted R-squared:  0.89 
## F-statistic:  229 on 1 and 27 DF,  p-value: 1.06e-14

2.3 Matriks pembobot: jarak kereta api (invers jarak)

Bobot \(w_{ij} = 1/d_{ij}\) dengan diagonal 0, lalu distandarisasi baris.

rail <- read_excel(P("Data_China.xlsx"), sheet = sheet_rail, skip = skip_rail)

n_wil <- nrow(china_join)
rail_matrix <- as.matrix(rail[, 3:(2 + n_wil)])
storage.mode(rail_matrix) <- "numeric"
rownames(rail_matrix) <- colnames(rail_matrix)

urut <- match(china_join[[join_china_shp]], rownames(rail_matrix))
if (!anyNA(urut)) {
  rail_matrix <- rail_matrix[urut, urut]
  cat("Urutan matriks jarak kereta disamakan dengan urutan wilayah pada peta.\n")
} else {
  cat("Nama wilayah pada matriks tidak cocok dengan peta; urutan diasumsikan sudah sama.\n")
}
## Nama wilayah pada matriks tidak cocok dengan peta; urutan diasumsikan sudah sama.
W_rail <- 1 / rail_matrix
diag(W_rail) <- 0
W_rail_std <- W_rail / rowSums(W_rail)

W_listw <- mat2listw(W_rail_std, style = "W")

2.3.1 Uji Moran’s I residual (jarak kereta api)

moran_rail <- lm.morantest(china.lm, W_listw)
moran_rail
## 
##  Global Moran I for regression residuals
## 
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## weights: W_listw
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.123, p-value = 0.131
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Observed Moran I      Expectation         Variance 
##       0.01062960      -0.03355243       0.00154671

2.4 Matriks pembobot: K-Nearest Neighbor

Bobot dibentuk dari centroid tiap provinsi dengan knearneigh, yaitu k-nearest neighbor.

coords   <- st_coordinates(st_centroid(china_join))
knn      <- knearneigh(coords, k = k_china)
nb_knn   <- knn2nb(knn)
lw_china <- nb2listw(nb_knn, style = "W")

2.4.1 Uji Moran’s I residual (KNN)

moran_knn <- lm.morantest(china.lm, lw_china)
moran_knn
## 
##  Global Moran I for regression residuals
## 
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## weights: lw_china
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.115, p-value = 0.133
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Observed Moran I      Expectation         Variance 
##        0.0885591       -0.0490493        0.0152411

2.5 Uji Lagrange Multiplier

china.lagrange <- lm.RStests(china.lm, lw_china, test = "all")
summary(china.lagrange)
##  Rao's score (a.k.a Lagrange multiplier) diagnostics for spatial dependence
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join)
## test weights: lw_china
##  
##          statistic parameter p.value  
## RSerr      0.41512         1  0.5194  
## RSlag      5.19965         1  0.0226 *
## adjRSerr   0.02696         1  0.8696  
## adjRSlag   4.81149         1  0.0283 *
## SARMA      5.22661         2  0.0733 .
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1

2.6 Spatial Lag Model (SAR)

china.lag <- lagsarlm(GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join, listw = lw_china)
summary(china.lag)
## 
## Call:lagsarlm(formula = GRP ~ Level_of_Urbanization, data = china_join,     listw = lw_china)
## 
## Residuals:
##       Min        1Q    Median        3Q       Max 
## -14910.34  -4430.21    220.29   2658.44  11459.87 
## 
## Type: lag 
## Coefficients: (numerical Hessian approximate standard errors) 
##                        Estimate Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept)           -34188.68    4717.67 -7.2469 4.263e-13
## Level_of_Urbanization   1300.79      92.97 13.9914 < 2.2e-16
## 
## Rho: 0.1676, LR test value: 4.7197, p-value: 0.029818
## Approximate (numerical Hessian) standard error: 0.073715
##     z-value: 2.2736, p-value: 0.022992
## Wald statistic: 5.1691, p-value: 0.022992
## 
## Log likelihood: -292.782 for lag model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 34198000, (sigma: 5847.9)
## Number of observations: 29 
## Number of parameters estimated: 4 
## AIC: 593.56, (AIC for lm: 596.28)

2.7 Perbandingan model

AICc(china.lm)
## [1] 597.243
AICc(china.lag)
## [1] 595.23
uji_lr <- anova(china.lag, china.lm)
uji_lr

2.8 Ringkasan bagian China

aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **OLS**: setiap kenaikan 1 poin tingkat urbanisasi dikaitkan dengan perubahan GRP rata-rata sebesar %.1f (R-squared = %.3f).\n",
  coef(china.lm)[2], summary(china.lm)$r.squared)))
  • OLS: setiap kenaikan 1 poin tingkat urbanisasi dikaitkan dengan perubahan GRP rata-rata sebesar 1400.0 (R-squared = 0.894).
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **Moran's I residual OLS, bobot jarak kereta**: I = %.4f, p-value = %.4f (%s pada taraf %.0f%%).\n",
  moran_rail$estimate[1], moran_rail$p.value, sig(moran_rail$p.value), taraf * 100)))
  • Moran’s I residual OLS, bobot jarak kereta: I = 0.0106, p-value = 0.1306 (tidak signifikan pada taraf 5%).
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **Moran's I residual OLS, bobot KNN (k = %d)**: I = %.4f, p-value = %.4f (%s pada taraf %.0f%%).\n",
  k_china, moran_knn$estimate[1], moran_knn$p.value, sig(moran_knn$p.value), taraf * 100)))
  • Moran’s I residual OLS, bobot KNN (k = 3): I = 0.0886, p-value = 0.1325 (tidak signifikan pada taraf 5%).
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **Uji LM**: p-value LM-error = %.4f, LM-lag = %.4f, robust LM-error = %.4f, robust LM-lag = %.4f.\n",
  china.lagrange$RSerr$p.value, china.lagrange$RSlag$p.value,
  china.lagrange$adjRSerr$p.value, china.lagrange$adjRSlag$p.value)))
  • Uji LM: p-value LM-error = 0.5194, LM-lag = 0.0226, robust LM-error = 0.8696, robust LM-lag = 0.0283.
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **SAR**: rho = %.4f (p-value = %.4f, %s); AIC OLS = %.2f vs AIC SAR = %.2f; uji rasio likelihood p-value = %.4f.\n",
  china.lag$rho, p_par(china.lag, "rho"), sig(p_par(china.lag, "rho")),
  AIC(china.lm), AIC(china.lag), uji_lr[["p-value"]][2])))
  • SAR: rho = 0.1676 (p-value = 0.0230, signifikan); AIC OLS = 596.28 vs AIC SAR = 593.56; uji rasio likelihood p-value = 0.0298.

3 Model Dependensi Spasial: Kemiskinan Jawa Barat

Peubah respon adalah persentase penduduk miskin 2015 (p.miskin15). Prediktor dipilih dengan mencari kombinasi peubah yang menghasilkan residual OLS dengan autokorelasi spasial paling signifikan (p-value Moran’s I terkecil), kemudian dimodelkan dengan SEM dan SARMA.

3.1 Data kemiskinan Jawa Barat

shp_jabar  <- st_read(P("Jabar2.shp"), quiet = TRUE)
data_jabar <- read_excel(P("data_jabar.xlsx"))

shp_jabar[[join_jabar]]  <- as.character(shp_jabar[[join_jabar]])
data_jabar[[join_jabar]] <- as.character(data_jabar[[join_jabar]])

jabar_gabung <- shp_jabar %>% left_join(data_jabar, by = join_jabar)
jabar        <- na.omit(jabar_gabung)

cat("Wilayah pada peta:", nrow(shp_jabar), "| setelah digabung dan na.omit():", nrow(jabar), "\n")
## Wilayah pada peta: 26 | setelah digabung dan na.omit(): 17
if (nrow(jabar) < nrow(jabar_gabung) && "KABKOT.x" %in% names(jabar_gabung)) {
  cat("Wilayah yang terbuang karena data kosong:",
      paste(setdiff(jabar_gabung$KABKOT.x, jabar$KABKOT.x), collapse = ", "), "\n")
}
## Wilayah yang terbuang karena data kosong: CIANJUR, GARUT, CIAMIS, KUNINGAN
colnames(jabar)
##  [1] "PROVNO.x"   "KABKOTNO"   "KODE2010.x" "PROVINSI.x" "KABKOT.x"   "SUMBER"     "IDSP2010.x"
##  [8] "PROVNO.y"   "KODE2010.y" "PROVINSI.y" "KABKOT.y"   "IDSP2010.y" "Long"       "Lat"       
## [15] "p.miskin15" "p.miskin16" "j.miskin15" "j.miskin16" "AHH2015"    "AHH2016"    "EYS2015"   
## [22] "EYS2016"    "MYS2015"    "MYS2016"    "EXP2015"    "EXP2016"    "APM.SD15"   "APM.SMP15" 
## [29] "APM.SMA15"  "APM.PT15"   "APK.SD15"   "APK.SMP15"  "APK.SMA15"  "APK.PT15"   "APS.USIA15"
## [36] "APS.USIA2"  "APS.USIA3"  "APS.USIA4"  "geometry"

3.2 Matriks pembobot (ketetanggaan queen)

nb_jabar <- suppressWarnings(poly2nb(jabar))
lw_jabar <- nb2listw(nb_jabar, style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(nb_jabar)
## Neighbour list object:
## Number of regions: 17 
## Number of nonzero links: 32 
## Percentage nonzero weights: 11.0727 
## Average number of links: 1.88235 
## 5 regions with no links:
## 18, 19, 21, 25, 26
## 6 disjoint connected subgraphs
## Link number distribution:
## 
## 0 1 2 3 4 5 
## 5 1 5 4 1 1 
## 1 least connected region:
## 23 with 1 link
## 1 most connected region:
## 13 with 5 links

3.3 Penentuan peubah: kombinasi dengan p-value Moran’s I residual terkecil

Setiap kombinasi 1 sampai maks_x prediktor dimodelkan dengan OLS, lalu residualnya diuji dengan Moran’s I. Hanya model dengan p-value < taraf yang disimpan.

variabel_X <- setdiff(variabel_jabar, y_jabar)
variabel_X <- intersect(variabel_X, names(jabar))

hasil <- list()
for (k in seq_len(min(maks_x, length(variabel_X)))) {
  for (x_set in combn(variabel_X, k, simplify = FALSE)) {
    res <- tryCatch({
      formula_text <- paste(y_jabar, "~", paste(x_set, collapse = " + "))
      model_ols    <- lm(as.formula(formula_text), data = jabar)
      uji          <- lm.morantest(model_ols, lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
      if (uji$p.value < taraf) {
        data.frame(Formula  = formula_text,
                   Jumlah_X = k,
                   Moran_I  = as.numeric(uji$estimate["Observed Moran I"]),
                   P_Value  = uji$p.value,
                   stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
      } else NULL
    }, error = function(e) NULL)
    if (!is.null(res)) hasil[[length(hasil) + 1]] <- res
  }
}

hasil_model <- if (length(hasil) > 0) bind_rows(hasil) %>% arrange(P_Value) else data.frame()
cat("Jumlah model dengan residual berautokorelasi spasial signifikan:", nrow(hasil_model), "\n")
## Jumlah model dengan residual berautokorelasi spasial signifikan: 677
head(hasil_model, 10)
if (nrow(hasil_model) == 0) {
  cat("Tidak ada model signifikan. Dipakai rumus cadangan 'rumus_manual'.\n")
  rumus_jabar <- rumus_manual
} else {
  model_terbaik <- hasil_model %>% slice(1)
  cat("Formula           :", as.character(model_terbaik$Formula), "\n")
  cat("Jumlah variabel X :", model_terbaik$Jumlah_X, "\n")
  cat("Moran's I         :", round(model_terbaik$Moran_I, 5), "\n")
  cat("P-Value           :", format(model_terbaik$P_Value, scientific = FALSE), "\n")
  rumus_jabar <- as.formula(model_terbaik$Formula)
}
## Formula           : p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15 
## Jumlah variabel X : 5 
## Moran's I         : 0.5012 
## P-Value           : 0.005018

3.4 Regresi OLS

jabar.lm <- lm(rumus_jabar, data = jabar)
summary(jabar.lm)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = rumus_jabar, data = jabar)
## 
## Residuals:
##    Min     1Q Median     3Q    Max 
## -6.254 -1.513  0.747  1.725  2.977 
## 
## Coefficients:
##             Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)  
## (Intercept) -263.519    236.180   -1.12    0.288  
## EYS2015        2.722      2.111    1.29    0.224  
## APM.SD15      -0.529      0.694   -0.76    0.462  
## APK.SD15       0.453      0.295    1.54    0.153  
## APK.PT15      -0.323      0.173   -1.86    0.089 .
## APS.USIA15     2.485      2.516    0.99    0.345  
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 3.11 on 11 degrees of freedom
## Multiple R-squared:  0.575,  Adjusted R-squared:  0.382 
## F-statistic: 2.97 on 5 and 11 DF,  p-value: 0.0613

3.5 Uji Lagrange Multiplier

jabar.lagrange <- lm.RStests(jabar.lm, lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE, test = "all")
summary(jabar.lagrange)
##  Rao's score (a.k.a Lagrange multiplier) diagnostics for spatial dependence
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = rumus_jabar, data = jabar)
## test weights: lw_jabar
##  
##          statistic parameter p.value   
## RSerr       7.2395         1 0.00713 **
## RSlag       2.0113         1 0.15613   
## adjRSerr    5.4894         1 0.01913 * 
## adjRSlag    0.2611         1 0.60935   
## SARMA       7.5007         2 0.02351 * 
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1

3.6 Spatial Error Model (SEM)

jabar.err <- errorsarlm(rumus_jabar, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(jabar.err)
## 
## Call:errorsarlm(formula = rumus_jabar, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar,     zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##      Min       1Q   Median       3Q      Max 
## -1.96720 -0.97706  0.17825  0.76731  1.45103 
## 
## Type: error 
## Regions with no neighbours included:
##  18 19 21 25 26 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##                Estimate  Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -425.458866   84.564213 -5.0312 4.874e-07
## EYS2015        4.311729    1.035451  4.1641 3.126e-05
## APM.SD15      -1.521207    0.226462 -6.7173 1.852e-11
## APK.SD15       0.640932    0.101930  6.2880 3.216e-10
## APK.PT15      -0.358322    0.069408 -5.1626 2.436e-07
## APS.USIA15     4.680477    0.828208  5.6513 1.592e-08
## 
## Lambda: 0.9059, LR test value: 23.088, p-value: 1.5476e-06
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.060606
##     z-value: 14.947, p-value: < 2.22e-16
## Wald statistic: 223.43, p-value: < 2.22e-16
## 
## Log likelihood: -28.1886 for error model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 1.0473, (sigma: 1.0234)
## Number of observations: 17 
## Number of parameters estimated: 8 
## AIC: 72.377, (AIC for lm: 93.465)

3.7 SARMA (SAC)

jabar.sarma <- sacsarlm(rumus_jabar, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(jabar.sarma)
## 
## Call:sacsarlm(formula = rumus_jabar, data = jabar, listw = lw_jabar,     zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##       Min        1Q    Median        3Q       Max 
## -1.837342 -0.900247 -0.050073  0.685523  1.606525 
## 
## Type: sac 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##                Estimate  Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -442.074286   83.148799 -5.3167 1.057e-07
## EYS2015        4.793132    1.140231  4.2037 2.626e-05
## APM.SD15      -1.707710    0.293038 -5.8276 5.623e-09
## APK.SD15       0.672837    0.103147  6.5231 6.886e-11
## APK.PT15      -0.392055    0.076727 -5.1097 3.226e-07
## APS.USIA15     4.939024    0.838588  5.8897 3.869e-09
## 
## Rho: 0.20377
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.19972
##     z-value: 1.0202, p-value: 0.30761
## Lambda: 0.91256
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.065071
##     z-value: 14.024, p-value: < 2.22e-16
## 
## LR test value: 23.918, p-value: 6.4015e-06
## 
## Log likelihood: -27.7736 for sac model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 0.97176, (sigma: 0.98578)
## Number of observations: 17 
## Number of parameters estimated: 9 
## AIC: 73.547, (AIC for lm: 93.465)

3.8 Perbandingan model

AICc(jabar.lm)
## [1] 105.91
AICc(jabar.err)
## [1] 90.3773
AICc(jabar.sarma)
## [1] 99.2615
lrtest1 <- anova(jabar.err, jabar.lm)
lrtest1
lrtest2 <- anova(jabar.sarma, jabar.err)
lrtest2

3.9 Ringkasan bagian Jawa Barat

aman(cat(sprintf("- **Formula terpilih**: `%s`.\n", paste(deparse(rumus_jabar), collapse = " "))))
  • Formula terpilih: p.miskin15 ~ EYS2015 + APM.SD15 + APK.SD15 + APK.PT15 + APS.USIA15.
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **Uji LM**: p-value LM-error = %.4f, LM-lag = %.4f, robust LM-error = %.4f, robust LM-lag = %.4f, SARMA = %.4f.\n",
  jabar.lagrange$RSerr$p.value, jabar.lagrange$RSlag$p.value,
  jabar.lagrange$adjRSerr$p.value, jabar.lagrange$adjRSlag$p.value,
  jabar.lagrange$SARMA$p.value)))
  • Uji LM: p-value LM-error = 0.0071, LM-lag = 0.1561, robust LM-error = 0.0191, robust LM-lag = 0.6093, SARMA = 0.0235.
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **SEM**: lambda = %.4f (p-value = %.4g, %s).\n",
  jabar.err$lambda, p_par(jabar.err, "lambda"), sig(p_par(jabar.err, "lambda")))))
  • SEM: lambda = 0.9059 (p-value = 1.619e-50, signifikan).
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **SARMA**: rho = %.4f (p-value = %.4f, %s), lambda = %.4f (p-value = %.4g, %s).\n",
  jabar.sarma$rho, p_par(jabar.sarma, "rho"), sig(p_par(jabar.sarma, "rho")),
  jabar.sarma$lambda, p_par(jabar.sarma, "lambda"), sig(p_par(jabar.sarma, "lambda")))))
  • SARMA: rho = 0.2038 (p-value = 0.3076, tidak signifikan), lambda = 0.9126 (p-value = 1.111e-44, signifikan).
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **AIC**: OLS = %.2f, SEM = %.2f, SARMA = %.2f. Model dengan AIC terkecil: **%s**.\n",
  AIC(jabar.lm), AIC(jabar.err), AIC(jabar.sarma),
  c("OLS", "SEM", "SARMA")[which.min(c(AIC(jabar.lm), AIC(jabar.err), AIC(jabar.sarma)))])))
  • AIC: OLS = 93.47, SEM = 72.38, SARMA = 73.55. Model dengan AIC terkecil: SEM.
aman(cat(sprintf(
  "- **Uji rasio likelihood**: SEM vs OLS p-value = %.4g; SARMA vs SEM p-value = %.4f.\n",
  lrtest1[["p-value"]][2], lrtest2[["p-value"]][2])))
  • Uji rasio likelihood: SEM vs OLS p-value = 1.548e-06; SARMA vs SEM p-value = 0.3622.

4 Model Dependensi Spasial Pulau Jawa (Materi Tambahan)

Studi kasus pada 119 kabupaten/kota di Pulau Jawa dengan satu peubah respon (Y) dan dua peubah penjelas (X1 dan X2). Tahapan: eksplorasi data, OLS dan uji asumsi, pemilihan matriks pembobot, uji efek spasial, model regresi spasial beserta uji asumsinya, dan interpretasi efek langsung/tidak langsung.

4.1 Import data

Data terdiri atas data poligon (peta Pulau Jawa, .shp) dan dataframe (peubah Y, X1, X2).

dat  <- read.csv(P("data-06.csv"))
peta <- st_read(P("jawa.shp"), quiet = TRUE)

if ("ID_KAB" %in% names(dat) && "ID2013" %in% names(peta)) {
  urut <- match(as.character(peta$ID2013), as.character(dat$ID_KAB))
  if (!anyNA(urut)) {
    dat <- dat[urut, ]
    rownames(dat) <- NULL
  } else {
    warning("ID pada data dan peta tidak seluruhnya cocok; urutan baris diasumsikan sama.")
  }
}

head(dat)
dim(dat)
## [1] 119   8

Peta Pulau Jawa:

plot(peta, main = "Peta Pulau Jawa")

plot(peta[4], main = "Peta Pulau Jawa (Kabupaten)")

4.2 Eksplorasi data

4.2.1 Missing value

cat("Jumlah baris dengan missing value:", sum(!complete.cases(dat)), "\n")
## Jumlah baris dengan missing value: 0
dat[!complete.cases(dat), ]

4.2.2 Statistik deskriptif

summary(dat[, setdiff(names(dat), c("ID_KAB", "PROPINSI"))])
##         KAB           long          lat              y              x1              x2      
##  Length   :119   Min.   :106   Min.   :-8.36   Min.   :13.7   Min.   : 80.1   Min.   :25.1  
##  N.unique :100   1st Qu.:108   1st Qu.:-7.65   1st Qu.:22.1   1st Qu.: 87.2   1st Qu.:33.2  
##  N.blank  :  0   Median :110   Median :-7.26   Median :25.4   Median : 92.2   Median :41.2  
##  Min.nchar:  4   Mean   :110   Mean   :-7.20   Mean   :25.5   Mean   : 93.0   Mean   :40.8  
##  Max.nchar: 17   3rd Qu.:112   3rd Qu.:-6.82   3rd Qu.:29.2   3rd Qu.: 99.8   3rd Qu.:49.2  
##                  Max.   :114   Max.   :-5.80   Max.   :36.2   Max.   :105.0   Max.   :55.0
kab_max <- dat %>% arrange(desc(y)) %>% slice(1)
kab_min <- dat %>% arrange(y) %>% slice(1)
cat(sprintf(
  "Y tertinggi di Pulau Jawa adalah **%s** sebesar %.2f, sedangkan Y terendah adalah **%s** sebesar %.2f. Rata-rata Y kab/kota adalah %.2f.\n",
  kab_max$KAB, kab_max$y, kab_min$KAB, kab_min$y, mean(dat$y)))

Y tertinggi di Pulau Jawa adalah JAKARTA SELATAN sebesar 36.22, sedangkan Y terendah adalah KLATEN sebesar 13.72. Rata-rata Y kab/kota adalah 25.53.

4.2.3 Boxplot (identifikasi pencilan)

par(mfrow = c(1, 3))
boxplot(dat$y,  main = "Sebaran Y",  col = "dodgerblue")
boxplot(dat$x1, main = "Sebaran X1", col = "dodgerblue")
boxplot(dat$x2, main = "Sebaran X2", col = "dodgerblue")

par(mfrow = c(1, 1))

4.2.4 Hubungan antar peubah

pairs(dat[, c("y", "x1", "x2")], pch = 19, lower.panel = NULL)

4.2.5 Korelasi antar peubah

corrplot(cor(dat[, c("y", "x1", "x2")]), method = "number")

cor(dat[, c("long", "lat", "y", "x1")])
##            long        lat         y         x1
## long  1.0000000 -0.7454178 -0.130615 -0.0897421
## lat  -0.7454178  1.0000000  0.167967  0.0747909
## y    -0.1306153  0.1679668  1.000000  0.8096326
## x1   -0.0897421  0.0747909  0.809633  1.0000000

Uji korelasi Y dengan X1 (H0: tidak ada korelasi; tolak H0 jika p-value < taraf):

cor.test(dat$y, dat$x1)
## 
##  Pearson's product-moment correlation
## 
## data:  dat$y and dat$x1
## t = 14.92, df = 117, p-value <2e-16
## alternative hypothesis: true correlation is not equal to 0
## 95 percent confidence interval:
##  0.737047 0.863753
## sample estimates:
##      cor 
## 0.809633

Uji korelasi Y dengan X2:

cor.test(dat$y, dat$x2)
## 
##  Pearson's product-moment correlation
## 
## data:  dat$y and dat$x2
## t = 6.582, df = 117, p-value = 1.37e-09
## alternative hypothesis: true correlation is not equal to 0
## 95 percent confidence interval:
##  0.374926 0.639955
## sample estimates:
##     cor 
## 0.51984

4.2.6 Sebaran spasial Y, X1, dan X2

k <- 101
colfunc <- colorRampPalette(c("green", "yellow", "red"))

peta$y  <- dat$y
peta$x1 <- dat$x1
peta$x2 <- dat$x2

peta_tematik <- function(var, judul) {
  ggplot(peta) +
    geom_sf(aes(fill = .data[[var]])) +
    scale_fill_gradientn(colors = colfunc(k)) +
    labs(title = judul, fill = var) +
    theme_minimal()
}

peta_tematik("y",  "Peta Sebaran Spasial Peubah Respon Y")

peta_tematik("x1", "Sebaran Spasial Peubah Penjelas X1")

peta_tematik("x2", "Sebaran Spasial Peubah Penjelas X2")

Gradasi warna yang cenderung mengelompok pada peta mengindikasikan kemungkinan autokorelasi spasial positif; dugaan ini diuji secara formal pada bagian berikut.

4.3 Matriks pembobot spasial

Matriks pembobot dapat didasarkan pada ketetanggaan (rook dan queen contiguity) atau pada jarak (k-nearest neighbor, radial distance weight, inverse distance weight, dan exponential distance weight). Matriks terbaik dipilih dari indeks Moran yang signifikan dan terbesar.

4.3.1 Berdasarkan ketetanggaan

Satu wilayah (Kepulauan Seribu) tidak memiliki tetangga, sehingga opsi zero.policy = TRUE diaktifkan.

Queen contiguity: dua wilayah bertetangga bila berbagi sisi atau titik sudut.

peta     <- st_make_valid(peta)
sp.peta  <- as(peta, "Spatial")
queen    <- poly2nb(sp.peta, queen = TRUE)
queen
## Neighbour list object:
## Number of regions: 119 
## Number of nonzero links: 522 
## Percentage nonzero weights: 3.68618 
## Average number of links: 4.38655 
## 1 region with no links:
## 1
## 3 disjoint connected subgraphs
W.queen <- nb2listw(queen, style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)
qc <- moran.test(dat$y, W.queen, randomisation = TRUE,
                 alternative = "greater", zero.policy = TRUE)
qc
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.queen  
## n reduced by no-neighbour observations  
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.392, p-value = 0.0819
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.08598413       -0.00854701        0.00461125

Pengujian dengan simulasi Monte Carlo:

set.seed(123)
moran.mc(dat$y, listw = W.queen, zero.policy = TRUE, nsim = 99)
## 
##  Monte-Carlo simulation of Moran I
## 
## data:  dat$y 
## weights: W.queen  
## number of simulations + 1: 100 
## 
## statistic = 0.08598, observed rank = 90, p-value = 0.1
## alternative hypothesis: greater

Rook contiguity: dua wilayah bertetangga bila berbagi sisi batas saja.

rook <- poly2nb(sp.peta, queen = FALSE)
rook
## Neighbour list object:
## Number of regions: 119 
## Number of nonzero links: 518 
## Percentage nonzero weights: 3.65793 
## Average number of links: 4.35294 
## 1 region with no links:
## 1
## 3 disjoint connected subgraphs
W.rook <- nb2listw(rook, style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)
rc <- moran.test(dat$y, W.rook, randomisation = TRUE,
                 alternative = "greater", zero.policy = TRUE)
rc
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.rook  
## n reduced by no-neighbour observations  
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.599, p-value = 0.0549
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.10024307       -0.00854701        0.00463095
set.seed(123)
moran.mc(dat$y, listw = W.rook, zero.policy = TRUE, nsim = 99)
## 
##  Monte-Carlo simulation of Moran I
## 
## data:  dat$y 
## weights: W.rook  
## number of simulations + 1: 100 
## 
## statistic = 0.1002, observed rank = 96, p-value = 0.04
## alternative hypothesis: greater

4.3.2 Berdasarkan jarak

Jarak dihitung dari koordinat centroid tiap wilayah.

centroids <- st_centroid(peta)
longlat   <- st_coordinates(centroids)

peta$long <- longlat[, 1]
peta$lat  <- longlat[, 2]
coords    <- peta[c("long", "lat")]
koord     <- as.data.frame(coords)

jarak   <- dist(longlat, method = "euclidean")
m.jarak <- as.matrix(jarak)

K-Nearest Neighbor dengan k_jawa tetangga terdekat:

W.knn   <- knn2nb(knearneigh(longlat, k = k_jawa, longlat = TRUE))
W.knn.s <- nb2listw(W.knn, style = "W")

MI.knn <- moran(dat$y, W.knn.s, n = length(W.knn.s$neighbours), S0 = Szero(W.knn.s))
mt1 <- moran.test(dat$y, W.knn.s, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
mt1
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.knn.s    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 2.18, p-value = 0.0146
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.10762813       -0.00847458        0.00283598

Radial Distance Weight: tetangga adalah wilayah dalam radius dmax_jawa km.

W.rdw   <- dnearneigh(longlat, 0, dmax_jawa, longlat = TRUE)
W.rdw.s <- nb2listw(W.rdw, style = "W", zero.policy = TRUE)

MI.rdw <- moran(dat$y, W.rdw.s, n = length(W.rdw.s$neighbours), S0 = Szero(W.rdw.s))
mt2 <- moran.test(dat$y, W.rdw.s, randomisation = TRUE,
                  alternative = "greater", zero.policy = TRUE)
mt2
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.rdw.s    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 0.8287, p-value = 0.204
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.01484480       -0.00847458        0.00079186

Inverse Distance Weight, \(w_{ij} = 1/d_{ij}^{\alpha}\) dengan \(\alpha = 1\) dan \(\alpha = 2\) (diagonal 0, standarisasi baris):

bobot_jarak <- function(m, fungsi) {
  W <- fungsi(m)
  diag(W) <- 0
  W <- W / rowSums(W, na.rm = TRUE)
  mat2listw(W, style = "W")
}

W.idw.s  <- bobot_jarak(m.jarak, function(d) 1 / d^1)
mt3 <- moran.test(dat$y, W.idw.s, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
mt3
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.idw.s    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 2.369, p-value = 0.00893
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##       0.040533196      -0.008474576       0.000428063
W.idw2.s <- bobot_jarak(m.jarak, function(d) 1 / d^2)
mt4 <- moran.test(dat$y, W.idw2.s, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
mt4
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.idw2.s    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.957, p-value = 0.0251
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.08827338       -0.00847458        0.00244289

Exponential Distance Weight, \(w_{ij} = \exp(-\alpha d_{ij})\) dengan \(\alpha = 1\) dan \(\alpha = 2\):

W.edw.s  <- bobot_jarak(m.jarak, function(d) exp(-1 * d))
mt5 <- moran.test(dat$y, W.edw.s, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
mt5
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.edw.s    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.302, p-value = 0.0964
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.00990606       -0.00847458        0.00019924
W.edw2.s <- bobot_jarak(m.jarak, function(d) exp(-2 * d))
mt6 <- moran.test(dat$y, W.edw2.s, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "greater")
mt6
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: W.edw2.s    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 1.875, p-value = 0.0304
## alternative hypothesis: greater
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##       0.032870135      -0.008474576       0.000486208

4.3.3 Pemilihan matriks bobot terbaik

Dipilih matriks dengan indeks Moran terbesar di antara yang signifikan pada taraf taraf.

daftar_listw <- list(W.knn.s, W.rdw.s, W.idw.s, W.idw2.s, W.edw.s, W.edw2.s, W.rook, W.queen)
daftar_uji   <- list(mt1, mt2, mt3, mt4, mt5, mt6, rc, qc)

Matriks <- data.frame(
  `Matriks Bobot` = c(paste0("K-Nearest Neighbor (k=", k_jawa, ")"),
                      paste0("Radial Distance Weight (dmax=", dmax_jawa, ")"),
                      "Invers Distance Weight (alpha=1)",
                      "Invers Distance Weight (alpha=2)",
                      "Exponential Distance Weight (alpha=1)",
                      "Exponential Distance Weight (alpha=2)",
                      "Rook Contiguity",
                      "Queen Contiguity"),
  `Indeks Moran`  = sapply(daftar_uji, function(m) unname(m$estimate[1])),
  `p-value`       = sapply(daftar_uji, function(m) m$p.value),
  check.names = FALSE
)
Matriks
Matriks[Matriks$`p-value` < taraf, ]
pilih <- which(Matriks$`p-value` < taraf)
if (length(pilih) == 0) {
  cat("Tidak ada matriks yang signifikan; seluruh matriks dipertimbangkan.\n")
  pilih <- seq_len(nrow(Matriks))
}
idx_w <- pilih[which.max(Matriks$`Indeks Moran`[pilih])]
ww    <- daftar_listw[[idx_w]]
cat(sprintf(
  "Matriks bobot terpilih untuk analisis selanjutnya: **%s** (indeks Moran = %.4f, p-value = %.4f).\n",
  Matriks$`Matriks Bobot`[idx_w], Matriks$`Indeks Moran`[idx_w], Matriks$`p-value`[idx_w]))

Matriks bobot terpilih untuk analisis selanjutnya: K-Nearest Neighbor (k=5) (indeks Moran = 0.1076, p-value = 0.0146).

4.4 Model regresi klasik (OLS) dan uji asumsi

ols <- lm(y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat)
summary(ols)
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat)
## 
## Residuals:
##    Min     1Q Median     3Q    Max 
## -4.598 -0.836  0.037  0.922  3.593 
## 
## Coefficients:
##             Estimate Std. Error t value Pr(>|t|)    
## (Intercept) -36.6615     1.7271   -21.2   <2e-16 ***
## x1            0.5422     0.0174    31.1   <2e-16 ***
## x2            0.2880     0.0145    19.9   <2e-16 ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 1.39 on 116 degrees of freedom
## Multiple R-squared:  0.922,  Adjusted R-squared:  0.921 
## F-statistic:  685 on 2 and 116 DF,  p-value: <2e-16
cat("Nilai AIC OLS:", AIC(ols), "\n")
## Nilai AIC OLS: 421.321

4.4.1 Normalitas sisaan

H0: sisaan menyebar normal; tolak H0 jika p-value < taraf.

err.ols <- residuals(ols)
ad_ols  <- ad.test(err.ols)
ad_ols
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  err.ols
## A = 0.4831, p-value = 0.226
hist(err.ols, main = "Histogram sisaan OLS", xlab = "Sisaan")

qqnorm(err.ols, datax = TRUE)
qqline(err.ols, datax = TRUE, col = "red")

4.4.2 Kehomogenan ragam

H0: ragam sisaan homogen.

bp_ols <- lmtest::bptest(ols)
bp_ols
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  ols
## BP = 1.557, df = 2, p-value = 0.459

4.4.3 Multikolinearitas (VIF)

Multikolinearitas terjadi bila VIF > 5.

car::vif(ols)
##      x1      x2 
## 1.00002 1.00002

4.5 Pengujian efek spasial

4.5.1 Indeks Moran pada galat model regresi

H0: tidak ada autokorelasi spasial.

lm.morantest(ols, listw = ww, alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
##  Global Moran I for regression residuals
## 
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat)
## weights: ww
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 7.706, p-value = 1.3e-14
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Observed Moran I      Expectation         Variance 
##       0.40129623      -0.00838559       0.00282624
merr <- moran.test(err.ols, ww, randomisation = TRUE,
                   alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE)
merr
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  err.ols  
## weights: ww    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 7.746, p-value = 9.49e-15
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.40129623       -0.00847458        0.00279855

4.5.2 Indeks Moran pada peubah Y, X1, dan X2

my <- moran.test(dat$y, ww, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE)
my
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$y  
## weights: ww    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 2.18, p-value = 0.0292
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.10762813       -0.00847458        0.00283598
moran.plot(dat$y, ww, labels = dat$KAB, zero.policy = TRUE)

mx1 <- moran.test(dat$x1, ww, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE)
mx1
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$x1  
## weights: ww    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 0.8947, p-value = 0.371
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.03925452       -0.00847458        0.00284600
mx2 <- moran.test(dat$x2, ww, randomisation = TRUE, alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE)
mx2
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  dat$x2  
## weights: ww    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = -1.087, p-value = 0.277
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##       -0.06648335       -0.00847458        0.00284567

Rekap hasil autokorelasi spasial:

df1 <- data.frame(
  Peubah         = c("Y", "X1", "X2", "Sisaan"),
  `Indeks Moran` = c(my$estimate[1], mx1$estimate[1], mx2$estimate[1], merr$estimate[1]),
  `p-value`      = c(my$p.value, mx1$p.value, mx2$p.value, merr$p.value),
  check.names = FALSE
)
rownames(df1) <- NULL
df1
for (i in seq_len(nrow(df1))) {
  cat(sprintf("- **%s**: indeks Moran = %.4f (%s), p-value = %.4g, sehingga autokorelasi spasial **%s** pada taraf %.0f%%.\n",
              df1$Peubah[i], df1$`Indeks Moran`[i],
              ifelse(df1$`Indeks Moran`[i] > 0, "positif", "negatif"),
              df1$`p-value`[i], sig(df1$`p-value`[i]), taraf * 100))
}
  • Y: indeks Moran = 0.1076 (positif), p-value = 0.02924, sehingga autokorelasi spasial signifikan pada taraf 5%.
  • X1: indeks Moran = 0.0393 (positif), p-value = 0.371, sehingga autokorelasi spasial tidak signifikan pada taraf 5%.
  • X2: indeks Moran = -0.0665 (negatif), p-value = 0.2768, sehingga autokorelasi spasial tidak signifikan pada taraf 5%.
  • Sisaan: indeks Moran = 0.4013 (positif), p-value = 9.488e-15, sehingga autokorelasi spasial signifikan pada taraf 5%.

4.5.3 Uji Lagrange Multiplier

Uji LM mengidentifikasi model dependensi spasial yang sesuai (SAR, SEM, atau SARMA).

model_lm <- lm.RStests(ols, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE, test = "all")
summary(model_lm)
##  Rao's score (a.k.a Lagrange multiplier) diagnostics for spatial dependence
## data:  
## model: lm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat)
## test weights: ww
##  
##          statistic parameter  p.value    
## RSerr       54.245         1 1.77e-13 ***
## RSlag       32.057         1 1.50e-08 ***
## adjRSerr    31.939         1 1.59e-08 ***
## adjRSlag     9.751         1  0.00179 ** 
## SARMA       63.996         2 1.27e-14 ***
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1

4.5.4 Efek heterogenitas spasial

H0: ragam sisaan homogen.

lmtest::bptest(ols)
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  ols
## BP = 1.557, df = 2, p-value = 0.459

4.6 Model regresi spasial

Fungsi bantu untuk uji asumsi sisaan model spasial (normalitas, kehomogenan ragam, dan kebebasan sisaan):

uji_asumsi <- function(model, lw) {
  e  <- residuals(model)
  ad <- nortest::ad.test(e)
  bp <- spatialreg::bptest.Sarlm(model)
  mi <- spdep::moran.test(e, lw, alternative = "two.sided", zero.policy = TRUE)
  print(ad); print(bp); print(mi)
  invisible(list(ad = ad, bp = bp, mi = mi))
}

narasi_asumsi <- function(a) {
  cat(sprintf("- **Kenormalan sisaan**: p-value = %.4f, %s.\n", a$ad$p.value,
              ifelse(a$ad$p.value > taraf, "gagal tolak H0 (sisaan menyebar normal)",
                     "tolak H0 (sisaan tidak menyebar normal)")))
  cat(sprintf("- **Kehomogenan ragam**: p-value = %.4f, %s.\n", a$bp$p.value,
              ifelse(a$bp$p.value > taraf, "gagal tolak H0 (ragam sisaan homogen)",
                     "tolak H0 (ragam sisaan tidak homogen)")))
  cat(sprintf("- **Kebebasan sisaan**: p-value = %.4f, %s.\n", a$mi$p.value,
              ifelse(a$mi$p.value > taraf, "gagal tolak H0 (tidak ada autokorelasi spasial pada sisaan)",
                     "tolak H0 (masih ada autokorelasi spasial pada sisaan)")))
}

4.6.1 Model SAR (Spatial Lag)

Model: \(y = \rho W y + X\beta + \epsilon\).

sar <- lagsarlm(y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(sar, Nagelkerke = TRUE)
## 
## Call:lagsarlm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##       Min        1Q    Median        3Q       Max 
## -4.278572 -0.761564  0.016699  0.849727  2.695114 
## 
## Type: lag 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##               Estimate Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -41.792688   1.851270 -22.575 < 2.2e-16
## x1            0.532067   0.015553  34.209 < 2.2e-16
## x2            0.290320   0.012806  22.671 < 2.2e-16
## 
## Rho: 0.23233, LR test value: 25.223, p-value: 5.1057e-07
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.047605
##     z-value: 4.8803, p-value: 1.0593e-06
## Wald statistic: 23.817, p-value: 1.0593e-06
## 
## Log likelihood: -194.049 for lag model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 1.5135, (sigma: 1.2303)
## Nagelkerke pseudo-R-squared: 0.93687 
## Number of observations: 119 
## Number of parameters estimated: 5 
## AIC: 398.1, (AIC for lm: 421.32)
## LM test for residual autocorrelation
## test value: 7.358, p-value: 0.0066764

Uji asumsi model SAR:

a_sar <- uji_asumsi(sar, ww)
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  e
## A = 0.2821, p-value = 0.632
## 
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  
## BP = 2.687, df = 2, p-value = 0.261
## 
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  e  
## weights: lw    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = 2.776, p-value = 0.0055
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##        0.13846672       -0.00847458        0.00280196
narasi_asumsi(a_sar)
  • Kenormalan sisaan: p-value = 0.6317, gagal tolak H0 (sisaan menyebar normal).
  • Kehomogenan ragam: p-value = 0.2609, gagal tolak H0 (ragam sisaan homogen).
  • Kebebasan sisaan: p-value = 0.0055, tolak H0 (masih ada autokorelasi spasial pada sisaan).

4.6.2 Model SEM (Spatial Error)

Model: \(y = X\beta + u,\; u = \lambda W u + \epsilon\).

sem <- errorsarlm(y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(sem)
## 
## Call:errorsarlm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##      Min       1Q   Median       3Q      Max 
## -4.61465 -0.56031  0.16416  0.76534  2.46897 
## 
## Type: error 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##               Estimate Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -34.736068   1.427157 -24.339 < 2.2e-16
## x1            0.523408   0.014286  36.637 < 2.2e-16
## x2            0.283754   0.011367  24.963 < 2.2e-16
## 
## Lambda: 0.57406, LR test value: 33.057, p-value: 8.9503e-09
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.093935
##     z-value: 6.1113, p-value: 9.8842e-10
## Wald statistic: 37.348, p-value: 9.8842e-10
## 
## Log likelihood: -190.132 for error model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 1.3381, (sigma: 1.1568)
## Number of observations: 119 
## Number of parameters estimated: 5 
## AIC: 390.26, (AIC for lm: 421.32)
a_sem <- uji_asumsi(sem, ww)
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  e
## A = 0.7588, p-value = 0.0471
## 
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  
## BP = 0.8988, df = 2, p-value = 0.638
## 
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  e  
## weights: lw    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = -0.5503, p-value = 0.582
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##       -0.03748312       -0.00847458        0.00277867
narasi_asumsi(a_sem)
  • Kenormalan sisaan: p-value = 0.0471, tolak H0 (sisaan tidak menyebar normal).
  • Kehomogenan ragam: p-value = 0.6380, gagal tolak H0 (ragam sisaan homogen).
  • Kebebasan sisaan: p-value = 0.5821, gagal tolak H0 (tidak ada autokorelasi spasial pada sisaan).

4.6.3 Model SARMA / GSM (SAC)

SARMA <- sacsarlm(y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE)
summary(SARMA)
## 
## Call:sacsarlm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##      Min       1Q   Median       3Q      Max 
## -4.53574 -0.59853  0.10686  0.78564  2.55146 
## 
## Type: sac 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##               Estimate Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -37.670168   2.567539 -14.672 < 2.2e-16
## x1            0.530517   0.015036  35.282 < 2.2e-16
## x2            0.286556   0.011748  24.392 < 2.2e-16
## 
## Rho: 0.083991
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.064873
##     z-value: 1.2947, p-value: 0.19543
## Lambda: 0.47951
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.11669
##     z-value: 4.1093, p-value: 3.9689e-05
## 
## LR test value: 34.119, p-value: 3.9012e-08
## 
## Log likelihood: -189.601 for sac model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 1.3555, (sigma: 1.1642)
## Number of observations: 119 
## Number of parameters estimated: 6 
## AIC: 391.2, (AIC for lm: 421.32)
a_sarma <- uji_asumsi(SARMA, ww)
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  e
## A = 0.7044, p-value = 0.0643
## 
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  
## BP = 1.285, df = 2, p-value = 0.526
## 
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  e  
## weights: lw    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = -0.3698, p-value = 0.712
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##       -0.02798367       -0.00847458        0.00278326
narasi_asumsi(a_sarma)
  • Kenormalan sisaan: p-value = 0.0643, gagal tolak H0 (sisaan menyebar normal).
  • Kehomogenan ragam: p-value = 0.5259, gagal tolak H0 (ragam sisaan homogen).
  • Kebebasan sisaan: p-value = 0.7115, gagal tolak H0 (tidak ada autokorelasi spasial pada sisaan).

4.6.4 Model SDM (Spatial Durbin)

sdm <- lagsarlm(y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, zero.policy = TRUE, type = "mixed")
summary(sdm)
## 
## Call:lagsarlm(formula = y ~ x1 + x2, data = dat, listw = ww, type = "mixed", 
##     zero.policy = TRUE)
## 
## Residuals:
##       Min        1Q    Median        3Q       Max 
## -4.460816 -0.587583  0.063713  0.803323  2.489449 
## 
## Type: mixed 
## Coefficients: (asymptotic standard errors) 
##               Estimate Std. Error z value  Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -23.011394   5.406184 -4.2565 2.077e-05
## x1            0.528068   0.014497 36.4268 < 2.2e-16
## x2            0.287681   0.012170 23.6394 < 2.2e-16
## lag.x1       -0.226018   0.064788 -3.4886 0.0004856
## lag.x2       -0.113673   0.045416 -2.5029 0.0123175
## 
## Rho: 0.52166, LR test value: 25.205, p-value: 5.1548e-07
## Asymptotic standard error: 0.10037
##     z-value: 5.1973, p-value: 2.0223e-07
## Wald statistic: 27.012, p-value: 2.0223e-07
## 
## Log likelihood: -188.637 for mixed model
## ML residual variance (sigma squared): 1.3227, (sigma: 1.1501)
## Number of observations: 119 
## Number of parameters estimated: 7 
## AIC: 391.27, (AIC for lm: 414.48)
## LM test for residual autocorrelation
## test value: 5.7604, p-value: 0.016392
a_sdm <- uji_asumsi(sdm, ww)
## 
##  Anderson-Darling normality test
## 
## data:  e
## A = 0.6499, p-value = 0.0878
## 
## 
##  studentized Breusch-Pagan test
## 
## data:  
## BP = 2.774, df = 4, p-value = 0.596
## 
## 
##  Moran I test under randomisation
## 
## data:  e  
## weights: lw    
## 
## Moran I statistic standard deviate = -0.5955, p-value = 0.552
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
## sample estimates:
## Moran I statistic       Expectation          Variance 
##       -0.03989522       -0.00847458        0.00278433
err.sdm <- residuals(sdm)
hist(err.sdm, main = "Histogram sisaan SDM", xlab = "Sisaan")

qqnorm(err.sdm, datax = TRUE)
qqline(err.sdm, datax = TRUE, col = "blue")

narasi_asumsi(a_sdm)
  • Kenormalan sisaan: p-value = 0.0878, gagal tolak H0 (sisaan menyebar normal).
  • Kehomogenan ragam: p-value = 0.5963, gagal tolak H0 (ragam sisaan homogen).
  • Kebebasan sisaan: p-value = 0.5515, gagal tolak H0 (tidak ada autokorelasi spasial pada sisaan).

4.7 Kebaikan model (pemilihan model terbaik)

Model terbaik ditentukan dari nilai AIC terkecil, dengan syarat asumsi sisaan terpenuhi.

daftar_model <- list(OLS = ols, SAR = sar, SEM = sem, SARMA = SARMA, SDM = sdm)

ringkasan <- data.frame(
  Model               = names(daftar_model),
  AIC                 = sapply(daftar_model, AIC),
  p_Rho               = c(NA, p_par(sar, "rho"), NA, p_par(SARMA, "rho"), p_par(sdm, "rho")),
  p_Lambda            = c(NA, NA, p_par(sem, "lambda"), p_par(SARMA, "lambda"), NA),
  p_Normalitas        = c(ad_ols$p.value, a_sar$ad$p.value, a_sem$ad$p.value,
                          a_sarma$ad$p.value, a_sdm$ad$p.value),
  p_Homoskedastisitas = c(bp_ols$p.value, a_sar$bp$p.value, a_sem$bp$p.value,
                          a_sarma$bp$p.value, a_sdm$bp$p.value),
  p_Kebebasan         = c(merr$p.value, a_sar$mi$p.value, a_sem$mi$p.value,
                          a_sarma$mi$p.value, a_sdm$mi$p.value),
  row.names = NULL
)
ringkasan[, -1] <- round(ringkasan[, -1], 4)
ringkasan
ok_asumsi <- ringkasan$Model != "OLS" &
  ringkasan$p_Normalitas > taraf &
  ringkasan$p_Homoskedastisitas > taraf &
  ringkasan$p_Kebebasan > taraf

aic_min <- ringkasan$Model[which.min(ringkasan$AIC)]

model_pilihan <- if (any(ok_asumsi)) {
  ringkasan$Model[ok_asumsi][which.min(ringkasan$AIC[ok_asumsi])]
} else aic_min

cat(sprintf("- Model dengan AIC terkecil: **%s**.\n", aic_min))
  • Model dengan AIC terkecil: SEM.
cat(sprintf("- Model spasial yang memenuhi seluruh asumsi sisaan (normalitas, homoskedastisitas, kebebasan) pada taraf %.0f%%: %s.\n",
            taraf * 100,
            ifelse(any(ok_asumsi), paste(ringkasan$Model[ok_asumsi], collapse = ", "), "tidak ada")))
  • Model spasial yang memenuhi seluruh asumsi sisaan (normalitas, homoskedastisitas, kebebasan) pada taraf 5%: SARMA, SDM.
cat(sprintf("- **Model terpilih: %s** (AIC terkecil di antara model yang memenuhi asumsi).\n", model_pilihan))
  • Model terpilih: SARMA (AIC terkecil di antara model yang memenuhi asumsi).

4.8 Interpretasi dan kesimpulan

Model yang memuat efek spillover (SAR, SARMA, SDM) diinterpretasi lewat efek langsung, efek tidak langsung, dan efek total tiap peubah. Selisih efek langsung dengan koefisien disebut efek umpan balik (feedback).

obj_pilihan <- daftar_model[[model_pilihan]]

if (model_pilihan %in% c("SAR", "SARMA", "SDM")) {
  Im <- impacts(obj_pilihan, listw = ww)
  print(Im)

  diref <- as.numeric(get_im(Im, "direct"))
  tdk   <- as.numeric(get_im(Im, "indirect"))
  total <- as.numeric(get_im(Im, "total"))

  nama_x <- setdiff(names(obj_pilihan$coefficients), c("(Intercept)", "rho", "lambda"))
  nama_x <- nama_x[!grepl("^lag\\.", nama_x)]
  koef   <- obj_pilihan$coefficients[nama_x]

  efek <- data.frame(Koefisien       = as.numeric(koef),
                     EfekLangsung    = diref,
                     EfekTakLangsung = tdk,
                     EfekTotal       = total,
                     UmpanBalik      = diref - as.numeric(koef),
                     row.names = nama_x)
  efek
} else {
  cat("Model terpilih (", model_pilihan, ") tidak memuat efek spillover; gunakan koefisien regresinya.\n")
}
## Impact measures (sac, exact):
##            Direct  Indirect    Total
## x1 dy/dx 0.531115 0.0480461 0.579161
## x2 dy/dx 0.286879 0.0259518 0.312831
if (exists("efek")) {
  for (v in rownames(efek)) {
    cat(sprintf("**Peubah penjelas %s**\n\n", toupper(v)))
    cat(sprintf("- *Pengaruh langsung* = %.3f: jika rata-rata %s di wilayah-i naik satu satuan, rata-rata Y di wilayah tersebut berubah sebesar %.3f, dengan peubah lain tetap.\n",
                efek[v, "EfekLangsung"], toupper(v), efek[v, "EfekLangsung"]))
    cat(sprintf("- *Pengaruh tidak langsung* = %.3f: jika rata-rata %s di wilayah-i naik satu satuan, rata-rata Y di wilayah-j (wilayah lain) berubah sebesar %.3f, dengan peubah lain tetap.\n",
                efek[v, "EfekTakLangsung"], toupper(v), efek[v, "EfekTakLangsung"]))
    cat(sprintf("- *Pengaruh total* = %.3f: jika kenaikan %s terjadi di seluruh wilayah, rata-rata Y di seluruh wilayah berubah sebesar %.3f. Efek umpan baliknya %.4f.\n\n",
                efek[v, "EfekTotal"], toupper(v), efek[v, "EfekTotal"], efek[v, "UmpanBalik"]))
  }
}

Peubah penjelas X1

  • Pengaruh langsung = 0.531: jika rata-rata X1 di wilayah-i naik satu satuan, rata-rata Y di wilayah tersebut berubah sebesar 0.531, dengan peubah lain tetap.
  • Pengaruh tidak langsung = 0.048: jika rata-rata X1 di wilayah-i naik satu satuan, rata-rata Y di wilayah-j (wilayah lain) berubah sebesar 0.048, dengan peubah lain tetap.
  • Pengaruh total = 0.579: jika kenaikan X1 terjadi di seluruh wilayah, rata-rata Y di seluruh wilayah berubah sebesar 0.579. Efek umpan baliknya 0.0006.

Peubah penjelas X2

  • Pengaruh langsung = 0.287: jika rata-rata X2 di wilayah-i naik satu satuan, rata-rata Y di wilayah tersebut berubah sebesar 0.287, dengan peubah lain tetap.
  • Pengaruh tidak langsung = 0.026: jika rata-rata X2 di wilayah-i naik satu satuan, rata-rata Y di wilayah-j (wilayah lain) berubah sebesar 0.026, dengan peubah lain tetap.
  • Pengaruh total = 0.313: jika kenaikan X2 terjadi di seluruh wilayah, rata-rata Y di seluruh wilayah berubah sebesar 0.313. Efek umpan baliknya 0.0003.

4.8.1 Efek marginal untuk model lainnya

for (m in setdiff(c("SAR", "SARMA", "SDM"), model_pilihan)) {
  cat("\n=== Efek (impacts) model", m, "===\n")
  print(impacts(daftar_model[[m]], listw = ww))
}
## 
## === Efek (impacts) model SAR ===
## Impact measures (lag, exact):
##            Direct  Indirect    Total
## x1 dy/dx 0.537088 0.1560035 0.693091
## x2 dy/dx 0.293059 0.0851224 0.378181
## 
## === Efek (impacts) model SDM ===
## Impact measures (mixed, exact):
##            Direct  Indirect    Total
## x1 dy/dx 0.533941 0.0975186 0.631459
## x2 dy/dx 0.292003 0.0717746 0.363778