library(readxl)
## Warning: package 'readxl' was built under R version 4.6.2
library(MASS)
library(dplyr)
##
## Attaching package: 'dplyr'
## The following object is masked from 'package:MASS':
##
## select
## The following objects are masked from 'package:stats':
##
## filter, lag
## The following objects are masked from 'package:base':
##
## intersect, setdiff, setequal, union
library(tidyr)
library(lme4)
## Loading required package: Matrix
##
## Attaching package: 'Matrix'
## The following objects are masked from 'package:tidyr':
##
## expand, pack, unpack
library(glmmTMB)
## Warning: package 'glmmTMB' was built under R version 4.6.2
library(ggplot2)
# ============================================================
# 0. PENGATURAN
# ============================================================
file_data <- "C:\\Users\\LENOVO\\Documents\\Copy of data pemstat.xlsx"
dir_luaran <- "luaran_simulasi"
nsim <- 500
nu <- 5
k_kontaminasi <- 5
mode_X <- "riil"
pakai_REML <- FALSE
seed_dasar <- 2026
skenario <- data.frame(
nama = "t5_murni",
eps = 0,
stringsAsFactors = FALSE
)
dir.create(dir_luaran, showWarnings = FALSE)
# 1. MEMBACA DAN MEMERIKSA DATA
kolom_perlu <- c("provinsi", "tahun", "ipm", "pdrb", "rls", "rtsl", "ppm")
data <- read_excel(file_data)
if (!all(kolom_perlu %in% names(data))) {
data <- read_excel(file_data, skip = 1)
}
stopifnot(all(kolom_perlu %in% names(data)))
data <- as.data.frame(data[, kolom_perlu])
stopifnot(!anyNA(data))
data$provinsi = as.factor(data$provinsi)
data$tahun = as.factor(data$tahun)
# Penskalaan pdrb
data$pdrb = data$pdrb / 1000
str(data)
## 'data.frame': 136 obs. of 7 variables:
## $ provinsi: Factor w/ 34 levels "ACEH","BALI",..: 1 34 32 26 8 33 4 19 17 18 ...
## $ tahun : Factor w/ 4 levels "2022","2023",..: 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ...
## $ ipm : num 74.1 74.5 75.2 74.5 73.1 ...
## $ pdrb : num 26.1 37.8 32.2 80.8 44.5 ...
## $ rls : num 9.44 9.71 9.18 9.22 8.68 ...
## $ rtsl : num 77.5 82.3 69.3 84.1 79.5 ...
## $ ppm : num 14.64 8.42 5.92 6.78 7.62 ...
head(data)
## provinsi tahun ipm pdrb rls rtsl ppm
## 1 ACEH 2022 74.11 26.062 9.44 77.48 14.64
## 2 SUMATERA UTARA 2022 74.51 37.781 9.71 82.30 8.42
## 3 SUMATERA BARAT 2022 75.16 32.167 9.18 69.27 5.92
## 4 RIAU 2022 74.45 80.774 9.22 84.06 6.78
## 5 JAMBI 2022 73.11 44.515 8.68 79.54 7.62
## 6 SUMATERA SELATAN 2022 72.48 39.724 8.37 78.62 11.90
summary(data)
## provinsi tahun ipm pdrb
## ACEH : 4 2022:34 Min. :62.16 Min. : 13.26
## BALI : 4 2023:34 1st Qu.:72.48 1st Qu.: 29.25
## BANTEN : 4 2024:34 Median :74.17 Median : 39.13
## BENGKULU : 4 2025:34 Mean :74.27 Mean : 49.19
## DI YOGYAKARTA: 4 3rd Qu.:75.70 3rd Qu.: 47.36
## DKI JAKARTA : 4 Max. :85.05 Max. :211.95
## (Other) :112
## rls rtsl ppm
## Min. : 7.020 Min. :40.34 Min. : 3.420
## 1st Qu.: 8.290 1st Qu.:79.61 1st Qu.: 5.965
## Median : 9.015 Median :84.09 Median : 8.105
## Mean : 9.032 Mean :83.85 Mean : 9.557
## 3rd Qu.: 9.580 3rd Qu.:88.27 3rd Qu.:11.805
## Max. :11.590 Max. :98.20 Max. :26.560
##
table(data$provinsi, data$tahun)[1:3, ]
##
## 2022 2023 2024 2025
## ACEH 1 1 1 1
## BALI 1 1 1 1
## BANTEN 1 1 1 1
stopifnot(all(table(data$provinsi, data$tahun) == 1))
n <- nrow(data)
# 2. IDENTIFIKASI OUTLIER DENGAN IQR
variabel <- c("ipm", "pdrb", "rls", "rtsl", "ppm")
prediktor <- c("pdrb", "rls", "rtsl", "ppm")
deteksi_outlier <- function(x) {
Q1 <- quantile(x, 0.25, na.rm = TRUE)
Q3 <- quantile(x, 0.75, na.rm = TRUE)
IQR_x <- IQR(x, na.rm = TRUE)
batas_bawah <- Q1 - 1.5 * IQR_x
batas_atas <- Q3 + 1.5 * IQR_x
outlier <- x < batas_bawah | x > batas_atas
data.frame(
Jumlah_Outlier = sum(outlier, na.rm = TRUE),
Persentase = mean(outlier, na.rm = TRUE) * 100,
Batas_Bawah = unname(batas_bawah),
Batas_Atas = unname(batas_atas)
)
}
hasil_outlier <- bind_rows(lapply(data[variabel], deteksi_outlier),
.id = "Variabel")
hasil_outlier
## Variabel Jumlah_Outlier Persentase Batas_Bawah Batas_Atas
## 1 ipm 13 9.5588235 67.650000 80.53000
## 2 pdrb 22 16.1764706 2.082875 74.53188
## 3 rls 1 0.7352941 6.355000 11.51500
## 4 rtsl 2 1.4705882 66.623750 101.25375
## 5 ppm 4 2.9411765 -2.795000 20.56500
data_long <- data %>%
dplyr::select(dplyr::all_of(variabel)) %>%
tidyr::pivot_longer(cols = dplyr::everything(),
names_to = "Variabel", values_to = "Nilai")
ggplot(data_long, aes(x = Variabel, y = Nilai)) +
geom_boxplot() +
facet_wrap(~Variabel, scales = "free") +
theme_minimal()

# 3. STATISTIK DESKRIPTIF
stat_deskriptif <- data %>%
summarise(across(
all_of(variabel),
list(Mean = mean, SD = sd, Varians = var, Minimum = min, Maksimum = max),
.names = "{.col}__{.fn}"
)) %>%
tidyr::pivot_longer(everything(),
names_to = c("Variabel", ".value"),
names_sep = "__")
stat_deskriptif
## # A tibble: 5 × 6
## Variabel Mean SD Varians Minimum Maksimum
## <chr> <dbl> <dbl> <dbl> <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 ipm 74.3 3.61 13.0 62.2 85.0
## 2 pdrb 49.2 36.5 1334. 13.3 212.
## 3 rls 9.03 0.893 0.797 7.02 11.6
## 4 rtsl 83.9 8.22 67.6 40.3 98.2
## 5 ppm 9.56 4.79 22.9 3.42 26.6
# 4. KORELASI DAN KOVARIANS PREDIKTOR
matriks_korelasi <- cor(data[prediktor], use = "complete.obs")
matriks_kovarians <- cov(data[prediktor], use = "complete.obs")
round(matriks_korelasi, 3)
## pdrb rls rtsl ppm
## pdrb 1.000 0.564 0.270 -0.319
## rls 0.564 1.000 0.436 -0.416
## rtsl 0.270 0.436 1.000 -0.571
## ppm -0.319 -0.416 -0.571 1.000
matriks_kovarians
## pdrb rls rtsl ppm
## pdrb 1334.03495 18.4006867 81.179204 -55.760995
## rls 18.40069 0.7969085 3.198695 -1.776885
## rtsl 81.17920 3.1986948 67.578440 -22.472336
## ppm -55.76099 -1.7768848 -22.472336 22.934853
# 5. LMM (DATA ASLI)
rumus <- ipm ~ pdrb + rls + rtsl + ppm + tahun + (1 | provinsi)
model_lmm_awal <- lmer(rumus, data = data, REML = TRUE)
summary(model_lmm_awal)
## Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerMod']
## Formula: ipm ~ pdrb + rls + rtsl + ppm + tahun + (1 | provinsi)
## Data: data
##
## REML criterion at convergence: 137.1
##
## Scaled residuals:
## Min 1Q Median 3Q Max
## -1.87120 -0.57397 -0.00258 0.59075 2.35958
##
## Random effects:
## Groups Name Variance Std.Dev.
## provinsi (Intercept) 3.10498 1.7621
## Residual 0.02758 0.1661
## Number of obs: 136, groups: provinsi, 34
##
## Fixed effects:
## Estimate Std. Error t value
## (Intercept) 46.150977 1.390214 33.197
## pdrb 0.014970 0.004112 3.641
## rls 2.537191 0.175630 14.446
## rtsl 0.067502 0.012261 5.505
## ppm -0.155906 0.036067 -4.323
## tahun2023 0.246042 0.042709 5.761
## tahun2024 0.437175 0.050381 8.677
## tahun2025 0.492421 0.057651 8.541
##
## Correlation of Fixed Effects:
## (Intr) pdrb rls rtsl ppm th2023 th2024
## pdrb -0.166
## rls -0.687 0.022
## rtsl 0.090 -0.004 -0.759
## ppm -0.852 0.039 0.414 0.166
## tahun2023 0.128 -0.256 0.027 -0.153 -0.105
## tahun2024 -0.102 -0.379 0.199 -0.201 0.238 0.523
## tahun2025 0.071 -0.494 -0.009 -0.070 0.172 0.513 0.683
isSingular(model_lmm_awal)
## [1] FALSE
beta_awal <- fixef(model_lmm_awal)
vc <- as.data.frame(VarCorr(model_lmm_awal))
sigma_u2 <- vc$vcov[vc$grp == "provinsi"] # varians efek acak provinsi
sigma_e2 <- vc$vcov[vc$grp == "Residual"] # varians galat
sigma_e <- sqrt(sigma_e2)
cat("\nsigma_u^2 =", sigma_u2, "| sigma_e^2 =", sigma_e2,
"| ICC =", round(sigma_u2 / (sigma_u2 + sigma_e2), 4), "\n")
##
## sigma_u^2 = 3.10498 | sigma_e^2 = 0.02757544 | ICC = 0.9912
nama_beta <- sub("\\(Intercept\\)", "Intersep", names(beta_awal))
parameter_asli <- c(setNames(as.numeric(beta_awal), nama_beta),
Var_Provinsi = sigma_u2,
Var_Residual = sigma_e2)
parameter_asli
## Intersep pdrb rls rtsl ppm tahun2023
## 46.15097693 0.01497034 2.53719126 0.06750165 -0.15590608 0.24604206
## tahun2024 tahun2025 Var_Provinsi Var_Residual
## 0.43717513 0.49242057 3.10497994 0.02757544
# 6. DATA SIMULASI
# Parameter untuk membangkitkan prediktor (log untuk pdrb)
x_lat <- data.frame(log_pdrb = log(data$pdrb), data[c("rls", "rtsl", "ppm")])
mean_x <- colMeans(x_lat)
sigma_x <- cov(x_lat)
bangkit_x <- function() {
if (mode_X == "riil") return(data[, prediktor])
z <- MASS::mvrnorm(n = n, mu = mean_x, Sigma = sigma_x)
data.frame(
pdrb = exp(z[, "log_pdrb"]),
rls = pmax(z[, "rls"], 0),
rtsl = pmin(pmax(z[, "rtsl"], 0), 100),
ppm = pmax(z[, "ppm"], 0)
)
}
# Galat Student-t (variansi = sigma_e^2)
bangkit_galat <- function(jumlah, eps) {
z <- rt(jumlah, df = nu) * sqrt((nu - 2) / nu) # variansi 1
if (eps > 0) {
pengali <- ifelse(runif(jumlah) < eps, k_kontaminasi, 1)
z <- z * pengali / sqrt(1 - eps + eps * k_kontaminasi^2)
}
sigma_e * z
}
bangkit_data <- function(eps = 0) {
d <- data.frame(provinsi = data$provinsi,
tahun = data$tahun,
bangkit_x())
# Efek acak provinsi
u_b <- rnorm(nlevels(d$provinsi), mean = 0, sd = sqrt(sigma_u2))
names(u_b) <- levels(d$provinsi)
u <- unname(u_b[as.character(d$provinsi)])
# Bagian tetap pada skala asli
X_b <- model.matrix(~ pdrb + rls + rtsl + ppm + tahun, data = d)
X_b <- X_b[, names(beta_awal), drop = FALSE]
mu <- as.numeric(X_b %*% beta_awal)
d$ipm <- mu + u + bangkit_galat(n, eps) # data latih
d$ipm_uji <- mu + u + bangkit_galat(n, eps) # data uji (galat baru, provinsi sama)
d
}
# 7. FUNGSI PENAKSIRAN MODEL
fit_lmm <- function(d) {
tryCatch(
suppressMessages(suppressWarnings(
lmer(rumus, data = d, REML = pakai_REML)
)),
error = function(e) NULL
)
}
# df dikunci pada nu (psi = log(df))
fit_tlmm <- function(d) {
tryCatch(
suppressMessages(suppressWarnings(
glmmTMB(rumus, data = d,
family = t_family(),
REML = pakai_REML,
start = list(psi = log(nu)),
map = list(psi = factor(NA)))
)),
error = function(e) NULL
)
}
# Mengambil hasil satu model -> list(par, mod)
ekstrak <- function(m, tipe, d) {
baris_mod <- data.frame(model = tipe, valid = FALSE, singular = NA,
aic = NA_real_, bic = NA_real_, loglik = NA_real_,
rmse_uji = NA_real_, mae_uji = NA_real_)
if (is.null(m)) return(list(par = NULL, mod = baris_mod))
hasil <- tryCatch({
if (tipe == "LMM") {
konv <- is.null(m@optinfo$conv$lme4$messages)
est <- fixef(m)
se <- sqrt(diag(as.matrix(vcov(m))))
v_u <- as.numeric(VarCorr(m)$provinsi[1])
v_e <- sigma(m)^2
sing <- isSingular(m)
pred <- predict(m, newdata = d)
} else {
konv <- isTRUE(m$fit$convergence == 0) && isTRUE(m$sdr$pdHess)
est <- fixef(m)$cond
se <- sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond))
v_u <- as.numeric(VarCorr(m)$cond$provinsi[1])
# sigma(m) adalah parameter skala; variansi galat = skala^2 * nu/(nu-2)
v_e <- sigma(m)^2 * nu / (nu - 2)
sing <- v_u < 1e-6
pred <- predict(m, newdata = d, type = "response")
}
est <- est[names(beta_awal)]
se <- se[names(beta_awal)]
baris_mod$aic <- AIC(m)
baris_mod$bic <- BIC(m)
baris_mod$loglik <- as.numeric(logLik(m))
baris_mod$rmse_uji <- sqrt(mean((d$ipm_uji - pred)^2))
baris_mod$mae_uji <- mean(abs(d$ipm_uji - pred))
baris_mod$singular <- sing
baris_mod$valid <- konv && is.finite(baris_mod$aic) &&
all(is.finite(est)) && all(is.finite(se)) &&
is.finite(v_u) && is.finite(v_e)
list(
par = data.frame(
model = tipe,
parameter = names(parameter_asli),
est = c(unname(est), v_u, v_e),
se = c(unname(se), NA_real_, NA_real_)
),
mod = baris_mod
)
}, error = function(e) NULL)
if (is.null(hasil)) return(list(par = NULL, mod = baris_mod))
hasil
}
# 8. CONTOH SATU DATASET (PEMERIKSAAN CEPAT)
set.seed(seed_dasar)
data_simulasi <- bangkit_data(eps = 0)
summary(data_simulasi[c("pdrb", "rls", "rtsl", "ppm", "ipm")])
## pdrb rls rtsl ppm
## Min. : 13.26 Min. : 7.020 Min. :40.34 Min. : 3.420
## 1st Qu.: 29.25 1st Qu.: 8.290 1st Qu.:79.61 1st Qu.: 5.965
## Median : 39.13 Median : 9.015 Median :84.09 Median : 8.105
## Mean : 49.19 Mean : 9.032 Mean :83.85 Mean : 9.557
## 3rd Qu.: 47.36 3rd Qu.: 9.580 3rd Qu.:88.27 3rd Qu.:11.805
## Max. :211.95 Max. :11.590 Max. :98.20 Max. :26.560
## ipm
## Min. :65.49
## 1st Qu.:71.93
## Median :74.43
## Mean :74.14
## 3rd Qu.:76.24
## Max. :81.23
model_lmm <- fit_lmm(data_simulasi)
model_tlmm <- fit_tlmm(data_simulasi)
summary(model_lmm)
## Linear mixed model fit by maximum likelihood ['lmerMod']
## Formula: ipm ~ pdrb + rls + rtsl + ppm + tahun + (1 | provinsi)
## Data: d
##
## AIC BIC logLik -2*log(L) df.resid
## 102.7 131.8 -41.4 82.7 126
##
## Scaled residuals:
## Min 1Q Median 3Q Max
## -2.38922 -0.55285 0.05663 0.59209 1.88621
##
## Random effects:
## Groups Name Variance Std.Dev.
## provinsi (Intercept) 3.03135 1.7411
## Residual 0.02225 0.1492
## Number of obs: 136, groups: provinsi, 34
##
## Fixed effects:
## Estimate Std. Error t value
## (Intercept) 44.954615 1.281625 35.076
## pdrb 0.009666 0.003774 2.561
## rls 2.552972 0.161189 15.838
## rtsl 0.073976 0.011166 6.625
## ppm -0.093847 0.033104 -2.835
## tahun2023 0.288345 0.038420 7.505
## tahun2024 0.486912 0.045509 10.699
## tahun2025 0.629994 0.052213 12.066
##
## Correlation of Fixed Effects:
## (Intr) pdrb rls rtsl ppm th2023 th2024
## pdrb -0.171
## rls -0.692 0.036
## rtsl 0.101 -0.019 -0.761
## ppm -0.850 0.037 0.423 0.156
## tahun2023 0.129 -0.260 0.023 -0.149 -0.106
## tahun2024 -0.107 -0.385 0.199 -0.197 0.245 0.523
## tahun2025 0.067 -0.504 -0.012 -0.060 0.176 0.513 0.686
isSingular(model_lmm)
## [1] FALSE
summary(model_tlmm)
## Family: t ( identity )
## Formula: ipm ~ pdrb + rls + rtsl + ppm + tahun + (1 | provinsi)
## Data: d
##
## AIC BIC logLik -2*log(L) df.resid
## 107.1 136.2 -43.5 87.1 126
##
## Random effects:
##
## Conditional model:
## Groups Name Variance Std.Dev.
## provinsi (Intercept) 3.018 1.737
## Number of obs: 136, groups: provinsi, 34
##
## Dispersion estimate for t family (sigma^2): 0.0153
##
## Conditional model:
## Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) 45.026925 1.423091 31.64 < 2e-16 ***
## pdrb 0.009240 0.003732 2.48 0.01330 *
## rls 2.570333 0.169344 15.18 < 2e-16 ***
## rtsl 0.072274 0.011380 6.35 2.14e-10 ***
## ppm -0.100459 0.033708 -2.98 0.00288 **
## tahun2023 0.284612 0.039408 7.22 5.11e-13 ***
## tahun2024 0.498553 0.049024 10.17 < 2e-16 ***
## tahun2025 0.624745 0.060947 10.25 < 2e-16 ***
## ---
## Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
# Pemeriksaan konvergensi t-LMM
model_tlmm$fit$convergence
## [1] 0
model_tlmm$sdr$pdHess
## [1] TRUE
model_tlmm$fit$message
## [1] "relative convergence (4)"
# diagnose()
try(glmmTMB::diagnose(model_tlmm), silent = TRUE)
## Unusually large Z-statistics (|x|>5):
##
## beta beta beta beta beta beta betadisp
## 31.640229 15.178177 6.351235 7.222241 10.169587 10.250554 -24.201677
##
## Large Z-statistics (estimate/std err) suggest a *possible* failure of
## the Wald approximation - often also associated with parameters that are
## at or near the edge of their range (e.g. random-effects standard
## deviations approaching 0). (Alternately, they may simply represent
## very well-estimated parameters; intercepts of non-centered models may
## fall in this category.) While the Wald p-values and standard errors
## listed in summary() may be unreliable, profile confidence intervals
## (see ?confint.glmmTMB) and likelihood ratio test p-values derived by
## comparing models (e.g. ?drop1) are probably still OK. (Note that the
## LRT is conservative when the null value is on the boundary, e.g. a
## variance or zero-inflation value of 0 (Self and Liang 1987; Stram and
## Lee 1994; Goldman and Whelan 2000); in simple cases these p-values are
## approximately twice as large as they should be.)
perbandingan_satu <- data.frame(
Model = c("LMM", "Student-t LMM"),
AIC = c(AIC(model_lmm), AIC(model_tlmm)),
BIC = c(BIC(model_lmm), BIC(model_tlmm)),
LogLik = c(as.numeric(logLik(model_lmm)), as.numeric(logLik(model_tlmm)))
)
perbandingan_satu
## Model AIC BIC LogLik
## 1 LMM 102.7226 131.8492 -41.36131
## 2 Student-t LMM 107.0743 136.2008 -43.53714
# Diagnostik residual
res_lmm <- residuals(model_lmm)
res_tlmm <- residuals(model_tlmm) / sigma(model_tlmm)
par(mfrow = c(1, 2))
qqnorm(res_lmm, main = "QQ Plot Residual LMM"); qqline(res_lmm, col = "red")
# t-LMM dibandingkan dengan kuantil t (bukan normal)
qqplot(qt(ppoints(length(res_tlmm)), df = nu), res_tlmm,
main = "QQ Plot Residual t-LMM (kuantil t)",
xlab = "Kuantil t teoretis", ylab = "Residual terstandar")
abline(0, 1, col = "red")

par(mfrow = c(1, 1))
shapiro.test(res_lmm)
##
## Shapiro-Wilk normality test
##
## data: res_lmm
## W = 0.99257, p-value = 0.6976
shapiro.test(ranef(model_lmm)$provinsi[, 1])
##
## Shapiro-Wilk normality test
##
## data: ranef(model_lmm)$provinsi[, 1]
## W = 0.97464, p-value = 0.6001
plot(fitted(model_lmm), res_lmm, xlab = "Nilai Prediksi", ylab = "Residual",
main = "Residual vs Fitted LMM"); abline(h = 0, col = "red")

VarCorr(model_lmm)
## Groups Name Std.Dev.
## provinsi (Intercept) 1.74108
## Residual 0.14918
# 9. SIMULASI MONTE CARLO
satu_replikasi <- function(i, eps, idx_skenario) {
set.seed(seed_dasar + 100000 * idx_skenario + i)
d <- bangkit_data(eps)
r1 <- ekstrak(fit_lmm(d), "LMM", d)
r2 <- ekstrak(fit_tlmm(d), "t-LMM", d)
list(par = bind_rows(r1$par, r2$par),
mod = bind_rows(r1$mod, r2$mod))
}
tbl_par_list <- list()
tbl_mod_list <- list()
waktu_mulai <- Sys.time()
for (s in seq_len(nrow(skenario))) {
message("\n=== Skenario: ", skenario$nama[s],
" (eps = ", skenario$eps[s], ") ===")
for (i in seq_len(nsim)) {
if (i %% 50 == 0 || i == 1) {
message(" replikasi ", i, " / ", nsim)
}
h <- satu_replikasi(i, skenario$eps[s], s)
tbl_par_list[[length(tbl_par_list) + 1]] <-
mutate(h$par, skenario = skenario$nama[s], rep = i)
tbl_mod_list[[length(tbl_mod_list) + 1]] <-
mutate(h$mod, skenario = skenario$nama[s], rep = i)
}
}
##
## === Skenario: t5_murni (eps = 0) ===
## replikasi 1 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 50 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 100 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 150 / 500
## replikasi 200 / 500
## replikasi 250 / 500
## replikasi 300 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 350 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 400 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 450 / 500
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## Warning in sqrt(diag(vcov(m)$cond)): NaNs produced
## replikasi 500 / 500
cat("\nWaktu simulasi:",
round(difftime(Sys.time(), waktu_mulai, units = "mins"), 2), "menit\n")
##
## Waktu simulasi: 2.83 menit
tbl_par <- bind_rows(tbl_par_list)
tbl_mod <- bind_rows(tbl_mod_list)
saveRDS(list(par = tbl_par, mod = tbl_mod,
parameter_asli = parameter_asli,
pengaturan = list(nsim = nsim, nu = nu,
k_kontaminasi = k_kontaminasi,
mode_X = mode_X, skenario = skenario)),
file.path(dir_luaran, "hasil_simulasi_mentah.rds"))
# 10. RINGKASAN HASIL
# 10.1 Tingkat keberhasilan (semua replikasi)
tabel_keberhasilan <- tbl_mod %>%
group_by(skenario, model) %>%
summarise(
n_replikasi = n(),
pct_valid = 100 * mean(valid),
pct_singular = 100 * mean(singular[valid], na.rm = TRUE),
.groups = "drop"
)
tabel_keberhasilan
## # A tibble: 2 × 5
## skenario model n_replikasi pct_valid pct_singular
## <chr> <chr> <int> <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 t5_murni LMM 500 100 0
## 2 t5_murni t-LMM 500 97.2 0
# Perbandingan
rep_ok <- tbl_mod %>%
group_by(skenario, rep) %>%
summarise(ok = all(valid) && n() == 2, .groups = "drop") %>%
filter(ok)
cat("\nReplikasi dengan kedua model valid:\n")
##
## Replikasi dengan kedua model valid:
print(rep_ok %>% count(skenario))
## # A tibble: 1 × 2
## skenario n
## <chr> <int>
## 1 t5_murni 486
benar <- data.frame(parameter = names(parameter_asli),
benar = as.numeric(parameter_asli))
par_ok <- tbl_par %>%
semi_join(rep_ok, by = c("skenario", "rep")) %>%
left_join(benar, by = "parameter") %>%
mutate(parameter = factor(parameter, levels = names(parameter_asli)))
# 10.2 Evaluasi estimasi parameter
tabel_parameter <- par_ok %>%
group_by(skenario, model, parameter) %>%
summarise(
benar = first(benar),
rata2_est = mean(est),
bias = mean(est - benar),
bias_rel_pct = 100 * bias / benar,
SD = sd(est),
RMSE = sqrt(mean((est - benar)^2)),
cakupan_CI95 = mean(abs(est - benar) <= 1.96 * se), # NA utk komponen variansi
lebar_CI95 = mean(2 * 1.96 * se),
.groups = "drop"
)
print(as.data.frame(tabel_parameter), digits = 4)
## skenario model parameter benar rata2_est bias bias_rel_pct
## 1 t5_murni LMM Intersep 46.15098 46.33321 1.822e-01 0.394862
## 2 t5_murni LMM pdrb 0.01497 0.01511 1.384e-04 0.924372
## 3 t5_murni LMM rls 2.53719 2.52764 -9.549e-03 -0.376351
## 4 t5_murni LMM rtsl 0.06750 0.06720 -3.040e-04 -0.450397
## 5 t5_murni LMM ppm -0.15591 -0.16071 -4.804e-03 3.081106
## 6 t5_murni LMM tahun2023 0.24604 0.24486 -1.180e-03 -0.479640
## 7 t5_murni LMM tahun2024 0.43718 0.43255 -4.630e-03 -1.058960
## 8 t5_murni LMM tahun2025 0.49242 0.48994 -2.485e-03 -0.504615
## 9 t5_murni LMM Var_Provinsi 3.10498 2.96234 -1.426e-01 -4.594062
## 10 t5_murni LMM Var_Residual 0.02758 0.02598 -1.599e-03 -5.798557
## 11 t5_murni t-LMM Intersep 46.15098 46.35442 2.034e-01 0.440829
## 12 t5_murni t-LMM pdrb 0.01497 0.01504 7.088e-05 0.473498
## 13 t5_murni t-LMM rls 2.53719 2.52506 -1.213e-02 -0.478121
## 14 t5_murni t-LMM rtsl 0.06750 0.06726 -2.432e-04 -0.360356
## 15 t5_murni t-LMM ppm -0.15591 -0.16077 -4.868e-03 3.122288
## 16 t5_murni t-LMM tahun2023 0.24604 0.24606 1.784e-05 0.007251
## 17 t5_murni t-LMM tahun2024 0.43718 0.43407 -3.101e-03 -0.709244
## 18 t5_murni t-LMM tahun2025 0.49242 0.49137 -1.048e-03 -0.212854
## 19 t5_murni t-LMM Var_Provinsi 3.10498 2.97183 -1.331e-01 -4.288220
## 20 t5_murni t-LMM Var_Residual 0.02758 0.02591 -1.665e-03 -6.037331
## SD RMSE cakupan_CI95 lebar_CI95
## 1 1.417985 1.428199 0.9321 5.22722
## 2 0.004151 0.004149 0.9342 0.01545
## 3 0.175104 0.175184 0.9444 0.65986
## 4 0.012781 0.012771 0.9321 0.04615
## 5 0.038488 0.038748 0.9177 0.13545
## 6 0.040660 0.040635 0.9588 0.16137
## 7 0.050164 0.050326 0.9444 0.19015
## 8 0.054430 0.054431 0.9527 0.21745
## 9 0.739580 0.752463 NA NA
## 10 0.006084 0.006285 NA NA
## 11 1.390501 1.403889 0.9300 5.02778
## 12 0.004116 0.004113 0.9239 0.01473
## 13 0.170078 0.170336 0.9362 0.63071
## 14 0.012189 0.012178 0.9177 0.04358
## 15 0.037155 0.037435 0.9198 0.12979
## 16 0.037654 0.037616 0.9527 0.15155
## 17 0.046173 0.046230 0.9506 0.17926
## 18 0.052408 0.052365 0.9403 0.20498
## 19 0.736274 0.747470 NA NA
## 20 0.004846 0.005119 NA NA
# 10.3 Efisiensi relatif: MSE(LMM) / MSE(t-LMM); > 1 berarti t-LMM lebih efisien
tabel_efisiensi <- tabel_parameter %>%
dplyr::select(skenario, model, parameter, RMSE) %>%
mutate(MSE = RMSE^2) %>%
dplyr::select(-RMSE) %>%
tidyr::pivot_wider(names_from = model, values_from = MSE) %>%
mutate(efisiensi_relatif = LMM / `t-LMM`)
print(as.data.frame(tabel_efisiensi), digits = 4)
## skenario parameter LMM t-LMM efisiensi_relatif
## 1 t5_murni Intersep 2.040e+00 1.971e+00 1.035
## 2 t5_murni pdrb 1.721e-05 1.691e-05 1.018
## 3 t5_murni rls 3.069e-02 2.901e-02 1.058
## 4 t5_murni rtsl 1.631e-04 1.483e-04 1.100
## 5 t5_murni ppm 1.501e-03 1.401e-03 1.071
## 6 t5_murni tahun2023 1.651e-03 1.415e-03 1.167
## 7 t5_murni tahun2024 2.533e-03 2.137e-03 1.185
## 8 t5_murni tahun2025 2.963e-03 2.742e-03 1.080
## 9 t5_murni Var_Provinsi 5.662e-01 5.587e-01 1.013
## 10 t5_murni Var_Residual 3.950e-05 2.620e-05 1.507
# 10.4 Kriteria model dan kinerja prediksi (pada data uji)
tabel_model <- tbl_mod %>%
semi_join(rep_ok, by = c("skenario", "rep")) %>%
group_by(skenario, model) %>%
summarise(
rata2_AIC = mean(aic),
rata2_BIC = mean(bic),
rata2_logLik = mean(loglik),
RMSE_uji = mean(rmse_uji),
MAE_uji = mean(mae_uji),
.groups = "drop"
)
print(as.data.frame(tabel_model), digits = 5)
## skenario model rata2_AIC rata2_BIC rata2_logLik RMSE_uji MAE_uji
## 1 t5_murni LMM 113.99 143.11 -46.994 0.18773 0.14324
## 2 t5_murni t-LMM 110.64 139.77 -45.320 0.18539 0.14125
# Proporsi replikasi di mana t-LMM memiliki AIC lebih kecil
tabel_aic_menang <- tbl_mod %>%
semi_join(rep_ok, by = c("skenario", "rep")) %>%
dplyr::select(skenario, rep, model, aic) %>%
tidyr::pivot_wider(names_from = model, values_from = aic) %>%
group_by(skenario) %>%
summarise(pct_tLMM_AIC_lebih_kecil = 100 * mean(`t-LMM` < LMM),
rata2_selisih_AIC = mean(LMM - `t-LMM`), .groups = "drop")
tabel_aic_menang
## # A tibble: 1 × 3
## skenario pct_tLMM_AIC_lebih_kecil rata2_selisih_AIC
## <chr> <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 t5_murni 63.2 3.35
# Simpan tabel
write.csv(tabel_keberhasilan, file.path(dir_luaran, "keberhasilan.csv"), row.names = FALSE)
write.csv(tabel_parameter, file.path(dir_luaran, "evaluasi_parameter.csv"), row.names = FALSE)
write.csv(tabel_efisiensi, file.path(dir_luaran, "efisiensi_relatif.csv"), row.names = FALSE)
write.csv(tabel_model, file.path(dir_luaran, "kriteria_dan_prediksi.csv"), row.names = FALSE)
write.csv(tabel_aic_menang, file.path(dir_luaran, "perbandingan_AIC.csv"), row.names = FALSE)
# 11. VISUALISASI
for (nm in skenario$nama) {
p <- ggplot(filter(par_ok, skenario == nm),
aes(x = model, y = est, fill = model)) +
geom_boxplot(alpha = 0.7, outlier.size = 0.8) +
geom_hline(aes(yintercept = benar), linetype = 2, colour = "red") +
facet_wrap(~ parameter, scales = "free_y", ncol = 5) +
labs(title = paste("Sebaran estimasi parameter:", nm),
subtitle = "Garis merah putus-putus = nilai parameter sebenarnya",
x = NULL, y = "Estimasi") +
theme_minimal() +
theme(legend.position = "none")
print(p)
ggsave(file.path(dir_luaran, paste0("sebaran_estimasi_", nm, ".png")),
p, width = 14, height = 6, dpi = 150)
}
