Profit Maximisation and Supply

EC2201 · Week 7

From costs to the output decision

Last time, we asked what it costs to make a given quantity. Today, the firm also knows the price it can sell for.

We will use bakeries selling standard trays of rolls to a wholesale market. All figures are illustrative.

A price-taking bakery

Many bakeries sell identical trays of rolls. Buyers can compare offers. One small bakery cannot noticeably move the wholesale price by changing its own output.

If the market price is £10 per tray, the bakery can sell its feasible output at £10. If it asks for more, buyers can go elsewhere.

Free entry and exit matter later, when we look at the long run.

Price taking in a wheat market

Defra publishes separate price series for agricultural commodities, including wheat.

Imagine a farmer with a small share of the market selling a given grade of wheat.

Source: Defra, Commodity prices

Economic profit

A bakery earns £300 in a day. It pays £210 in wages, rent and ingredients. The owner gives up £90 they could earn managing another shop.

Measure Daily amount
Revenue less explicit costs £90
Opportunity cost of the owner’s time £90
Economic profit £0

Zero economic profit means all costs are covered, including the value of the owner’s next best alternative.

Total revenue and marginal revenue

At a market price of £10 per tray, \(TR(q)=10q\).

Trays sold Total revenue Revenue from one more tray
1 £10 £10
2 £20 £10
3 £30 £10

For a price taker, marginal revenue equals price: \(MR=P\).

Selling more need not mean earning more profit

Selling a fifth tray at £10 takes revenue from £40 to £50.

Suppose making that fifth tray costs £13 because the bakery has to pay for overtime.

\[ \Delta\pi=\Delta TR-\Delta TC=10-13=-3. \]

Revenue rises by £10. Profit falls by £3.

Is the next tray worth making?

Each tray sells for £10. The table gives the cost of adding each tray.

Tray Cost of this tray Change in profit
1 £4 ?
2 £6 ?
3 £9 ?
4 £12 ?

Try it: How many trays would you make? Assume these are the only available quantities and the firm pays the same fixed cost even at zero.

The third tray adds £1 to profit

Tray Extra revenue Extra cost Change in profit
1 £10 £4 +£6
2 £10 £6 +£4
3 £10 £9 +£1
4 £10 £12 −£2

Make three trays. The fourth adds to revenue, but its cost is larger than the revenue it brings in.

Why the firm looks for P = MC

For a smooth output choice:

\[ \pi(q)=Pq-TC(q),\qquad \frac{d\pi}{dq}=P-MC(q). \]

Compare the best positive candidate with \(q=0\).

A calculation: how many trays at £20?

In a separate example, a price-taking bakery has

\[ TC(q)=10+4q+q^2,\qquad P=20. \]

The £10 is unavoidable today.

  1. Derive marginal cost and find the best positive output.
  2. Work out revenue, cost and profit at that output.
  3. Compare with shutting for the day.

Calculation answer: eight trays

\[ MC=4+2q,\qquad 20=4+2q\quad\Rightarrow\quad q=8. \]

At eight trays Amount
Revenue: \(20(8)\) £160
Cost: \(10+4(8)+8^2\) £106
Profit £54
Profit if the bakery shuts −£10

MC is rising at eight. Making eight trays beats shutting.

A bakery with a fixed oven

Let \(q\) be trays per day, and all total costs be pounds per day:

\[ TC(q)=64+8q-4q^2+q^3. \]

The bakery can vary how many trays it makes this week, but it cannot cancel the lease.

Worked output choice at £11

Set price equal to marginal cost:

\[ 11=8-8q+3q^2 \quad\Longleftrightarrow\quad (q-3)(3q+1)=0. \]

The feasible positive solution is \(q=3\), where MC is rising.

At three trays: \(TR=11(3)=£33\), \(VC=£15\), and \(TC=£79\).

Profit is −£46. Would you still open today?

Operating at a loss can be the better choice

Today Open and make 3 trays Shut
Revenue £33 £0
Variable cost £15 £0
Oven lease £64 £64
Economic profit −£46 −£64

Opening brings in £18 more than it adds to cost. That covers part of the lease.

Revenue and cost at the chosen output

Total cost and total revenue versus trays per day; at three trays cost exceeds revenue by £46.

At \(q=3\), the two curves have the same slope. Their vertical gap is profit. Here production reduces the loss compared with shutting.

Two cost curves answer two questions

At the best positive output \(q^*\):

\[ \begin{aligned} \text{Profit from producing} &= [P-ATC(q^*)]q^*,\\ \text{Gain versus shutting} &= [P-AVC(q^*)]q^*. \end{aligned} \]

Profit, break-even and loss on the graph

Three panels show positive profit, zero profit and loss at their respective chosen outputs.

The shaded rectangle is \(|P-ATC|\times q\). It shows economic profit or loss at the chosen output.

The shutdown price

\[ AVC(q)=8-4q+q^2=(q-2)^2+4. \]

Its minimum is £4 at two trays.

Same price twice: which crossing matters?

For the original bakery, set price to £3:

\[ 3=8-8q+3q^2 \quad\Rightarrow\quad (q-1)(3q-5)=0. \]

Three pounds is below the shutdown price. The firm makes zero.

Exercise: should this bakery open?

Use the same costs. For each price, decide whether the firm produces, and whether it makes a profit.

Wholesale price Helpful information
£3 Minimum AVC is £4
£4 At \(q=2\), \(MC=AVC=£4\)
£24 At \(q=4\), \(MC=ATC=£24\)

For each answer, give the comparison that settles it.

Exercise answers

Price Best output Economic profit Why
£3 0 −£64 Below minimum AVC
£4 0 or 2 −£64 either way Revenue exactly covers VC at 2
£24 4 £0 Revenue covers all costs at 4

Shutdown can leave a loss. Break-even means economic profit is zero.

A takeaway kitchen decides whether to open tonight

Suppose a takeaway expects £80 in sales from a set of confirmed orders.

Cost If it opens If it shuts
Rent owed either way £100 £100
Ingredients £35 £0
Staff called in only if it opens £25 £0

Discuss: Should it open for these orders? Would your answer change if sales were only £50?

Takeaway answer: compare the two losses

Sales if open Profit if open Profit if shut Better choice
£80 −£80 −£100 Open
£50 −£110 −£100 Shut

For this bundle, £60 of sales makes the takeaway indifferent.

When the lease comes up for renewal, the relevant costs may change.

The firm’s short-run supply curve

Short-run supply follows rising marginal cost above £4; at £4 either zero or two trays are optimal.

Below the shutdown price, output is zero. Above it, this firm follows the rising part of \(MC\) starting at minimum \(AVC\).

A movement along supply or a shift?

Predict the change before you draw it

For each event, ask whether the bakery supplies a different number of trays at the same wholesale price.

  1. A supermarket wants more bread, raising the wholesale price.
  2. A mixer upgrade cuts the labour needed for each extra tray.
  3. The bakery’s unavoidable lease payment increases.

Which shifts the firm’s short-run supply curve?

Market supply adds quantities at the same price

Price per tray Bakery A Bakery B Market supply
£5 0 2 2
£8 3 4 7
£11 5 6 11

Quantities are trays per day. At £8, the two bakeries together supply 7 trays.

In the short run the set of firms is fixed, though an individual firm may shut.

Two suppliers, two starting prices

Suppose a farmers’ market has two suppliers of an identical product. At a price of \(P\) pounds, their short-run supplies are

\[ q_A=\max\{0,P-4\},\qquad q_B=\max\{0,2(P-6)\}. \]

Complete the market supply schedule at £3, £5, £6 and £8.

At which price does supplier B start to contribute positive output?

Two suppliers: worked answer

Price A B Market quantity
£3 0 0 0
£5 1 0 1
£6 2 0 2
£8 4 4 8

Between £4 and £6 only A supplies. Above £6, market supply is \((P-4)+2(P-6)=3P-16\).

Short-run market equilibrium

Market demand and supply cross at £30 and 40 trays per day.

At the intersection, buyers want the same quantity that existing firms want to sell. The market price is £30 and market output is 40 trays per day.

Market equilibrium: solve it and check it

Use the same wholesale market as the previous graph:

\[ Q_D=100-2P,\qquad Q_S=2P-20. \]

Set quantity demanded equal to quantity supplied:

\[ 100-2P=2P-20 \quad\Rightarrow\quad P=30,\quad Q=40. \]

Check: At £35, buyers want 30 trays and sellers offer 50. There is excess supply of 20 trays.

Long run: choosing capacity or exiting

In the long run the bakery can choose its oven and premises, or leave the industry.

Think of \(LRTC(q)\) as the cheapest cost of producing \(q\) when all inputs can adjust.

Long-run supply of one firm

Long-run average and marginal cost meet at the £10 minimum at four trays.

At an interior minimum of \(LRAC\), \(LRMC=LRAC\). In the usual smooth, single-minimum case, the individual firm’s positive supply follows rising \(LRMC\) from that point.

Shut for a day or leave the market?

Suppose a wholesale bakery still makes less than its full cost after covering flour, fuel and wages.

Decision Relevant comparison
Open this week while the lease is unavoidable Can sales cover the costs avoided by shutting this week?
Renew the lease for next year or exit Can sales cover all future economic costs of staying?

It can be sensible to open this week and still decide to exit when the lease ends.

Long-run calculation: is it worth staying?

Use the long-run costs from the graph: \(LRAC=10+(q-4)^2\) and \(LRMC=26-16q+3q^2\).

Wholesale price Best decision Why
£9 Exit Even minimum LRAC is £10
£10 Exit or make 4 trays Both give zero prospective profit
£21 Make 5 trays At 5, LRMC = £21 and LRAC = £11

At £21, the firm earns \((21-11)\times5=£50\) per day in economic profit.

Entry and exit change market supply

If firms expect… Over time… At unchanged demand…
Positive economic profit Firms enter if they can replicate the opportunity Supply shifts right and price tends to fall
Negative economic profit Some firms leave if losses persist Supply shifts left and price tends to rise

Zero economic profit includes a normal return on the firm’s resources.

A demand increase: today and after entry

A demand increase initially raises price. Entry then shifts supply right, returning price to £10.

A constant-cost industry: who makes the extra trays?

Suppose identical bakeries can enter freely. Each has minimum \(LRAC=£10\) at 4 trays per day, and entry leaves input prices unchanged.

Long-run outcome Before demand grows After demand grows
Market price £10 £10
Total trays per day 40 60
Trays per bakery 4 4
Number of bakeries 10 15

The industry’s long-run supply is horizontal at £10 under these assumptions.

Demand falls: how many firms remain?

Initially, ten identical bakeries each make 4 trays per day. The market price is £10, equal to minimum long-run average cost.

Demand drops permanently. At £10 buyers now want 28 trays per day.

Assume unchanged input costs and the usual upward-sloping short-run market supply.

Exit can bring price back to its old level

  1. Short run: the demand curve shifts left. Price falls below £10, and firms cannot cover long-run economic costs at that price.
  2. Long run: some firms leave. Market supply shifts left, and price rises back to £10 under the model’s assumptions.
  3. New equilibrium: \(28/4=7\) bakeries. Three have exited.

The surviving bakeries each make four trays. The market makes fewer trays because it has fewer firms.

When industry growth changes costs

Compare long-run equilibria after entry and exit.

Different firms can have different costs

Suppose the cheapest sites are limited. To supply more in the long run, the industry may need sites with higher costs.

A carbon charge and the cost of one more tray

Suppose a charge on emissions adds £4 per tray for a bakery with a fixed emissions rate per tray.

\[ TC_{\text{with tax}}(q)=TC(q)+4q. \]

At a given positive output, MC, AVC and ATC all rise by £4 per tray. The unavoidable oven lease does not change.

If the bakery can use a cleaner oven, the extra tax cost need not stay at £4 per tray.

Carbon costs in electricity generation

In the UK, Carbon Price Support applies to certain fossil fuels used for electricity generation.

Consider two illustrative plants that need different amounts of gas to produce one extra MWh:

If the charge adds a hypothetical £2 per MWh of gas used, how much does it add to each plant’s marginal cost of electricity?

Source: HMRC, Climate Change Levy rates

A £4 tax creates a wedge

The £4 charge moves market quantity from 40 to 36 trays; buyers pay £32 and sellers receive £28.

Before tax With tax
Price buyers pay £30 £32
Price sellers keep, net of tax £30 £28
Trays traded per day 40 36

Tax wedge: the arithmetic in three steps

  1. Sellers receive \(P_S\). Buyers pay \(P_B=P_S+4\).
  2. Equate the two quantities at their respective prices:

\[ 100-2(P_S+4)=2P_S-20 \quad\Rightarrow\quad P_S=28. \]

  1. Buyers pay \(P_B=32\). Either quantity equation gives \(Q=36\).

Before the charge the price was £30, so the burden per tray is £2 on each side in this example.

What the tax graph can tell us

In this example, the charge raises the buyer price and reduces the number of trays sold, holding demand fixed.

A welfare comparison also needs the benefits of lower emissions and the costs of adapting.

Same output, different emissions

Suppose each plant can make the same electricity with less emissions. For one tonne of emissions avoided:

Plant Cost of avoiding that tonne Emissions charge saved
A £10 £25
B £40 £25

Which plant would choose to cut this tonne? What if both plants were required to cut one tonne?

Final check

  1. A firm has \(P=MC\) at its best positive output, but \(P<AVC\) there. Should it produce today?
  2. If firms can enter freely at unchanged costs, how can industry output rise permanently while price returns to its old level?
  3. In the tax example, why doesn’t the buyer price rise by the full £4?

For each question, give the comparison or assumption that settles it.

Final check: answers

  1. No. The best positive output cannot cover variable cost, so shutting reduces the loss.
  2. More firms enter. At the same price, a larger number of firms sell the same output per firm in the constant-cost example.
  3. The net seller price also falls. Buyers pay £2 more and sellers keep £2 less, which together account for the £4 wedge.

For any output problem, ask: how much if the firm produces, and does producing beat the alternative?