Tugas Regresi Spasial

library(sp)
library(sf)
## Linking to GEOS 3.14.1, GDAL 3.12.1, PROJ 9.7.1; sf_use_s2() is TRUE
library(terra)
## terra 1.9.46
library(tmap)
library(viridis)
## Loading required package: viridisLite
library(gstat)
library(dplyr)
## 
## Attaching package: 'dplyr'
## The following objects are masked from 'package:terra':
## 
##     intersect, union
## The following objects are masked from 'package:stats':
## 
##     filter, lag
## The following objects are masked from 'package:base':
## 
##     intersect, setdiff, setequal, union
library(ggplot2)

# Memuat data
data(meuse)
data(meuse.grid)

# Mengubah menjadi objek sf (CRS 28992 = Amersfoort / RD New)
d <- st_as_sf(meuse, coords = c("x", "y"), crs = 28992)
coop <- st_as_sf(meuse.grid, coords = c("x", "y"), crs = 28992)

# Peubah yang diinterpolasi
d$vble <- log(d$zinc)

# Peta sebaran data pengamatan
ggplot() +
  geom_sf(data = coop, color = "grey85", size = 0.2) +
  geom_sf(data = d, aes(color = vble), size = 2) +
  scale_color_viridis(name = "log(zinc)") + theme_bw()

# Grid raster 40 m; extent diperluas 20 m agar titik pusat sel = titik meuse.grid
e <- ext(vect(coop))
grid <- rast(ext(e[1] - 20, e[2] + 20, e[3] - 20, e[4] + 20),
             resolution = 40, crs = "EPSG:28992")

# Fungsi bantu: ubah prediksi pada coop menjadi peta raster
buat_peta <- function(pred, judul) {
  resp <- st_sf(pred = pred, geometry = st_geometry(coop))
  r <- rasterize(vect(resp), grid, field = "pred", fun = "mean")
  tm_shape(r) + tm_raster(alpha = 0.6, palette = "viridis", title = "log(zinc)") +
    tm_layout(main.title = judul, main.title.size = 0.9, legend.outside = FALSE)
}

Metode Deterministik

Closest Observation

# Diagram Voronoi
vor <- st_voronoi(st_union(st_geometry(d))) %>%
  st_collection_extract("POLYGON") %>%
  st_sfc(crs = 28992)
vor <- st_intersection(st_sf(geometry = vor), st_convex_hull(st_union(coop)))

plot(st_geometry(vor), border = "grey50", main = "Diagram Voronoi (Meuse)")
plot(st_geometry(d), add = TRUE, pch = 16, cex = 0.4)

# Prediksi Closest Observation
idx <- st_nearest_feature(coop, d)
pred_closest <- d$vble[idx]

c1 <- buat_peta(pred_closest, "Closest Observation")
## 
## ── tmap v3 code detected ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
## [v3->v4] `tm_tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the scale of the
## map variable `col` namely 'palette' (rename to 'values') to col.scale =
## tm_scale(<HERE>).
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: use `col_alpha` instead of `alpha`.
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the legend of the
## map variable `col` namely 'title' to 'col.legend = tm_legend(<HERE>)'
## [v3->v4] `tm_layout()`: use `tm_title()` instead of `tm_layout(main.title = )`
c1

Inverse Distance Weighting (IDW)

IDW memberi bobot berbanding terbalik dengan jarak (pangkat idp). Di sini digunakan idp = 2 dengan seluruh titik pengamatan.

res <- gstat(formula = vble ~ 1, locations = d, nmax = nrow(d), set = list(idp = 2))
pred_idw <- predict(res, coop)$var1.pred
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
c2 <- buat_peta(pred_idw, "IDW (idp = 2)")
## 
## ── tmap v3 code detected ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
## [v3->v4] `tm_tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the scale of the
## map variable `col` namely 'palette' (rename to 'values') to col.scale =
## tm_scale(<HERE>).
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: use `col_alpha` instead of `alpha`.
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the legend of the
## map variable `col` namely 'title' to 'col.legend = tm_legend(<HERE>)'
## [v3->v4] `tm_layout()`: use `tm_title()` instead of `tm_layout(main.title = )`
c2

Nearest Neighbors (NN)

NN merata-ratakan nilai dari k = 5 titik terdekat dengan bobot sama.

res <- gstat(formula = vble ~ 1, locations = d, nmax = 5, set = list(idp = 0))
pred_nn <- predict(res, coop)$var1.pred
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
c3 <- buat_peta(pred_nn, "Nearest Neighbors (k = 5)")
## 
## ── tmap v3 code detected ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
## [v3->v4] `tm_tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the scale of the
## map variable `col` namely 'palette' (rename to 'values') to col.scale =
## tm_scale(<HERE>).
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: use `col_alpha` instead of `alpha`.
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the legend of the
## map variable `col` namely 'title' to 'col.legend = tm_legend(<HERE>)'
## [v3->v4] `tm_layout()`: use `tm_title()` instead of `tm_layout(main.title = )`
c3

Metode Stokastik: Ordinary Kriging

# Variogram empiris log(zinc)
v <- variogram(vble ~ 1, data = d)
plot(v)

# Fit model Spherical
vinitial <- vgm(psill = 0.5, model = "Sph", range = 900, nugget = 0.1)
fv <- fit.variogram(object = v, model = vinitial)
fv
##   model      psill    range
## 1   Nug 0.05066017   0.0000
## 2   Sph 0.59060556 897.0044
plot(v, fv, cex = 1.5)

# Ordinary Kriging pada grid
k <- gstat(formula = vble ~ 1, data = d, model = fv)
kpred <- predict(k, coop)
## [using ordinary kriging]
pred_krig <- kpred$var1.pred

c5 <- buat_peta(pred_krig, "Ordinary Kriging")
## 
## ── tmap v3 code detected ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
## [v3->v4] `tm_tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the scale of the
## map variable `col` namely 'palette' (rename to 'values') to col.scale =
## tm_scale(<HERE>).
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: use `col_alpha` instead of `alpha`.
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the legend of the
## map variable `col` namely 'title' to 'col.legend = tm_legend(<HERE>)'
## [v3->v4] `tm_layout()`: use `tm_title()` instead of `tm_layout(main.title = )`
c5

# Peta ketidakpastian (varians kriging)
ggplot() + geom_sf(data = kpred, aes(color = var1.var)) +
  geom_sf(data = d, size = 0.8) +
  scale_color_viridis(name = "Varians") + theme_bw()

Pendekatan Ensembel

Ensembel menggabungkan empat metode: Closest Observation, IDW, NN, dan Kriging. Dua skema pembobotan dibandingkan:

  1. Ensembel bobot sama (masing-masing 1/4).
  2. Ensembel bobot invers RMSE, yaitu metode dengan RMSE lebih kecil mendapat bobot lebih besar.
# Fungsi: prediksi keempat metode dasar untuk data 'test' berdasarkan 'train'
pred_semua <- function(train, test) {
  # Closest observation
  p1 <- train$vble[st_nearest_feature(test, train)]

  # IDW
  g2 <- gstat(formula = vble ~ 1, locations = train, nmax = nrow(train), set = list(idp = 2))
  p2 <- predict(g2, test)$var1.pred

  # Nearest neighbors
  g3 <- gstat(formula = vble ~ 1, locations = train, nmax = 5, set = list(idp = 0))
  p3 <- predict(g3, test)$var1.pred

  # Ordinary kriging (variogram di-fit ulang pada data latih)
  vt <- variogram(vble ~ 1, data = train)
  fvt <- fit.variogram(vt, vgm(psill = 0.5, model = "Sph", range = 900, nugget = 0.1))
  g5 <- gstat(formula = vble ~ 1, data = train, model = fvt)
  p5 <- predict(g5, test)$var1.pred

  cbind(Closest = p1, IDW = p2, NN = p3, Kriging = p5)
}

RMSE <- function(observed, predicted) sqrt(mean((observed - predicted)^2))

# Fungsi: bobot invers RMSE dari 5-fold CV internal pada data latih
bobot_ensemble <- function(train, K = 5) {
  f <- sample(rep(1:K, length.out = nrow(train)))
  P <- matrix(NA, nrow(train), 4)
  for (j in 1:K) {
    P[f == j, ] <- pred_semua(train[f != j, ], train[f == j, ])
  }
  colnames(P) <- c("Closest", "IDW", "NN", "Kriging")
  w <- 1 / apply(P, 2, function(p) RMSE(train$vble, p))
  w / sum(w)
}
set.seed(123)

# Prediksi metode dasar pada grid
P_grid <- pred_semua(d, coop)
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
# Bobot invers RMSE dari data pengamatan
w_grid <- bobot_ensemble(d)
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
round(w_grid, 3)
## Closest     IDW      NN Kriging 
##   0.194   0.243   0.255   0.308
# Ensembel bobot invers RMSE
pred_ens <- as.numeric(P_grid %*% w_grid)

c4 <- buat_peta(pred_ens, "Ensembel (bobot invers RMSE)")
## 
## ── tmap v3 code detected ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
## [v3->v4] `tm_tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the scale of the
## map variable `col` namely 'palette' (rename to 'values') to col.scale =
## tm_scale(<HERE>).
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: use `col_alpha` instead of `alpha`.
## [v3->v4] `tm_raster()`: migrate the argument(s) related to the legend of the
## map variable `col` namely 'title' to 'col.legend = tm_legend(<HERE>)'
## [v3->v4] `tm_layout()`: use `tm_title()` instead of `tm_layout(main.title = )`
c4

Perbandingan Peta Prediksi

tmap_arrange(c1, c2, c3, c4, c5, ncol = 2)

Interpretasi Perbandingan Peta

Kelima metode menghasilkan pola umum yang serupa: nilai tinggi di tepi barat laut (dekat sungai), nilai rendah di bagian tengah-timur, dan nilai sedang di selatan. Hal ini menegaskan struktur spasial yang kuat pada data. Zona rendah di tengah tampak paling luas pada Closest Observation dan Kriging, sedangkan pada NN dan IDW lebih menyempit karena efek perataan. Kemiripan visual tidak menjamin akurasi yang sama, sehingga perlu evaluasi dengan cross validation.

Evaluasi Model: Cross Validation

set.seed(123)

n <- nrow(d)
K <- 5
kf <- sample(rep(1:K, length.out = n))

rmse <- matrix(NA, K, 6,
               dimnames = list(paste0("Fold", 1:K),
                               c("Closest", "IDW", "NN", "Kriging",
                                 "Ensembel_Sama", "Ensembel_InvRMSE")))

for (k in 1:K) {
  test  <- d[kf == k, ]
  train <- d[kf != k, ]

  P <- pred_semua(train, test)

  # Ensembel bobot sama
  p_eq <- rowMeans(P)

  # Ensembel bobot invers RMSE (bobot dari CV internal pada data latih)
  w <- bobot_ensemble(train)
  p_w <- as.numeric(P %*% w)

  rmse[k, ] <- c(apply(P, 2, function(p) RMSE(test$vble, p)),
                 RMSE(test$vble, p_eq), RMSE(test$vble, p_w))
}
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [inverse distance weighted interpolation]
## [using ordinary kriging]
# RMSE untuk masing-masing fold
round(as.data.frame(rmse), 4)
##       Closest    IDW     NN Kriging Ensembel_Sama Ensembel_InvRMSE
## Fold1  0.5710 0.5616 0.5261  0.4213        0.4800           0.4768
## Fold2  0.4728 0.4216 0.3685  0.2919        0.3447           0.3401
## Fold3  0.7532 0.5505 0.5292  0.4411        0.5217           0.5138
## Fold4  0.7641 0.5362 0.5305  0.4685        0.5313           0.5259
## Fold5  0.6685 0.5362 0.5223  0.4157        0.4778           0.4718
# Metode terbaik pada setiap fold
terbaik_fold <- colnames(rmse)[apply(rmse, 1, which.min)]
terbaik_fold
## [1] "Kriging" "Kriging" "Kriging" "Kriging" "Kriging"

Kriging menjadi metode terbaik pada kelima fold tanpa terkecuali (RMSE 0,292 sampai 0,469), sedangkan Closest Observation hampir selalu yang terburuk (RMSE 0,473 sampai 0,764). Urutan metode konsisten: Kriging < Ensembel < NN < IDW < Closest pada hampir semua fold. Konsistensi ini membuat kesimpulan cukup meyakinkan walaupun tiap fold hanya berisi sekitar 31 titik. Fold 2 paling mudah diprediksi (semua metode memiliki RMSE terkecil), sedangkan fold 3 dan 4 paling sulit, terlihat dari RMSE Closest Observation yang mencapai 0,75 sampai 0,76.

# Rata-rata RMSE dari 5 fold
hasil <- data.frame(Metode = colnames(rmse),
                    RMSE = colMeans(rmse)) %>%
  arrange(RMSE)
rownames(hasil) <- NULL
hasil
##             Metode      RMSE
## 1          Kriging 0.4077012
## 2 Ensembel_InvRMSE 0.4656763
## 3    Ensembel_Sama 0.4711085
## 4               NN 0.4953159
## 5              IDW 0.5212259
## 6          Closest 0.6459117

Kesimpulan

Berdasarkan 5-fold cross validation pada log(zinc), Ordinary Kriging memberikan galat prediksi terkecil (RMSE rata-rata 0,408) dan menjadi yang terbaik di semua fold. Ensembel (0,466 dengan bobot invers RMSE) berada di urutan kedua, diikuti NN (0,495), IDW (0,521), dan Closest Observation (0,646). Keunggulan Kriging didukung oleh struktur spasial yang kuat pada data (nugget sekitar 8% dari sill, range sekitar 897 m), dan Kriging juga memberikan peta ketidakpastian prediksi. Ensembel tidak melampaui Kriging karena tiga anggota lainnya jauh lebih lemah; ensembel akan lebih bermanfaat bila anggotanya memiliki kinerja yang sebanding. Mengingat jumlah data terbatas (155 titik), hasil dapat sedikit berubah bila set.seed() atau parameter (idp, k pada NN, model variogram) diganti.