This tutorial develops a complete clinical prediction-modeling
workflow using the NHANES R package and diabetes as the
binary outcome.
The workflow covers:
Important:
NHANES::NHANESis a teaching dataset derived from NHANES. This example predicts prevalent diabetes at the time of survey, not future incident diabetes. For a publication-quality NHANES analysis, use the original CDC NHANES files and account for the complex survey design, weights, strata, and PSU variables.
The following chunk installs any missing packages. It only needs internet access the first time a package is installed.
required_packages <- c(
"NHANES",
"tidyverse",
"gtsummary",
"naniar",
"mice",
"car",
"rms",
"pROC",
"glmnet",
"broom"
)
missing_packages <- required_packages[
!required_packages %in% rownames(installed.packages())
]
if (length(missing_packages) > 0) {
install.packages(missing_packages)
}
library(NHANES)
library(tidyverse)
library(gtsummary)
library(naniar)
library(mice)
library(car)
library(rms)
library(pROC)
library(glmnet)
library(broom)
set.seed(2026)
options(stringsAsFactors = FALSE)
We want to predict whether an adult participant has diabetes using demographic, anthropometric, blood-pressure, lipid, and lifestyle information.
The binary outcome is
\[ Y_i = \begin{cases} 1, & \text{Diabetes = Yes} \\ 0, & \text{Diabetes = No} \end{cases} \]
The candidate predictor set is
\[ \text{Age} + \text{BMI} + \text{BPSysAve} + \text{TotChol} + \text{Gender} + \text{Race1} + \text{PhysActive} + \text{Smoke100}. \]
We deliberately do not use DiabetesAge,
because it is downstream of diabetes diagnosis and would create outcome
leakage.
data("NHANES")
cat("Rows:", nrow(NHANES), "\n")
## Rows: 10000
cat("Columns:", ncol(NHANES), "\n")
## Columns: 76
glimpse(NHANES)
## Rows: 10,000
## Columns: 76
## $ ID <int> 51624, 51624, 51624, 51625, 51630, 51638, 51646, 5164…
## $ SurveyYr <fct> 2009_10, 2009_10, 2009_10, 2009_10, 2009_10, 2009_10,…
## $ Gender <fct> male, male, male, male, female, male, male, female, f…
## $ Age <int> 34, 34, 34, 4, 49, 9, 8, 45, 45, 45, 66, 58, 54, 10, …
## $ AgeDecade <fct> 30-39, 30-39, 30-39, 0-9, 40-49, 0-9, 0-9, 40…
## $ AgeMonths <int> 409, 409, 409, 49, 596, 115, 101, 541, 541, 541, 795,…
## $ Race1 <fct> White, White, White, Other, White, White, White, Whit…
## $ Race3 <fct> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ Education <fct> High School, High School, High School, NA, Some Colle…
## $ MaritalStatus <fct> Married, Married, Married, NA, LivePartner, NA, NA, M…
## $ HHIncome <fct> 25000-34999, 25000-34999, 25000-34999, 20000-24999, 3…
## $ HHIncomeMid <int> 30000, 30000, 30000, 22500, 40000, 87500, 60000, 8750…
## $ Poverty <dbl> 1.36, 1.36, 1.36, 1.07, 1.91, 1.84, 2.33, 5.00, 5.00,…
## $ HomeRooms <int> 6, 6, 6, 9, 5, 6, 7, 6, 6, 6, 5, 10, 6, 10, 10, 4, 3,…
## $ HomeOwn <fct> Own, Own, Own, Own, Rent, Rent, Own, Own, Own, Own, O…
## $ Work <fct> NotWorking, NotWorking, NotWorking, NA, NotWorking, N…
## $ Weight <dbl> 87.4, 87.4, 87.4, 17.0, 86.7, 29.8, 35.2, 75.7, 75.7,…
## $ Length <dbl> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ HeadCirc <dbl> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ Height <dbl> 164.7, 164.7, 164.7, 105.4, 168.4, 133.1, 130.6, 166.…
## $ BMI <dbl> 32.22, 32.22, 32.22, 15.30, 30.57, 16.82, 20.64, 27.2…
## $ BMICatUnder20yrs <fct> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ BMI_WHO <fct> 30.0_plus, 30.0_plus, 30.0_plus, 12.0_18.5, 30.0_plus…
## $ Pulse <int> 70, 70, 70, NA, 86, 82, 72, 62, 62, 62, 60, 62, 76, 8…
## $ BPSysAve <int> 113, 113, 113, NA, 112, 86, 107, 118, 118, 118, 111, …
## $ BPDiaAve <int> 85, 85, 85, NA, 75, 47, 37, 64, 64, 64, 63, 74, 85, 6…
## $ BPSys1 <int> 114, 114, 114, NA, 118, 84, 114, 106, 106, 106, 124, …
## $ BPDia1 <int> 88, 88, 88, NA, 82, 50, 46, 62, 62, 62, 64, 76, 86, 6…
## $ BPSys2 <int> 114, 114, 114, NA, 108, 84, 108, 118, 118, 118, 108, …
## $ BPDia2 <int> 88, 88, 88, NA, 74, 50, 36, 68, 68, 68, 62, 72, 88, 6…
## $ BPSys3 <int> 112, 112, 112, NA, 116, 88, 106, 118, 118, 118, 114, …
## $ BPDia3 <int> 82, 82, 82, NA, 76, 44, 38, 60, 60, 60, 64, 76, 82, 7…
## $ Testosterone <dbl> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ DirectChol <dbl> 1.29, 1.29, 1.29, NA, 1.16, 1.34, 1.55, 2.12, 2.12, 2…
## $ TotChol <dbl> 3.49, 3.49, 3.49, NA, 6.70, 4.86, 4.09, 5.82, 5.82, 5…
## $ UrineVol1 <int> 352, 352, 352, NA, 77, 123, 238, 106, 106, 106, 113, …
## $ UrineFlow1 <dbl> NA, NA, NA, NA, 0.094, 1.538, 1.322, 1.116, 1.116, 1.…
## $ UrineVol2 <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ UrineFlow2 <dbl> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ Diabetes <fct> No, No, No, No, No, No, No, No, No, No, No, No, No, N…
## $ DiabetesAge <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ HealthGen <fct> Good, Good, Good, NA, Good, NA, NA, Vgood, Vgood, Vgo…
## $ DaysPhysHlthBad <int> 0, 0, 0, NA, 0, NA, NA, 0, 0, 0, 10, 0, 4, NA, NA, 0,…
## $ DaysMentHlthBad <int> 15, 15, 15, NA, 10, NA, NA, 3, 3, 3, 0, 0, 0, NA, NA,…
## $ LittleInterest <fct> Most, Most, Most, NA, Several, NA, NA, None, None, No…
## $ Depressed <fct> Several, Several, Several, NA, Several, NA, NA, None,…
## $ nPregnancies <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, 2, NA, NA, 1, 1, 1, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ nBabies <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, 2, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA…
## $ Age1stBaby <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, 27, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ SleepHrsNight <int> 4, 4, 4, NA, 8, NA, NA, 8, 8, 8, 7, 5, 4, NA, 5, 7, N…
## $ SleepTrouble <fct> Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Yes, NA, NA, No, No, No, No, No, Y…
## $ PhysActive <fct> No, No, No, NA, No, NA, NA, Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes, …
## $ PhysActiveDays <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 5, 5, 5, 7, 5, 1, NA, 2, …
## $ TVHrsDay <fct> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ CompHrsDay <fct> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
## $ TVHrsDayChild <int> NA, NA, NA, 4, NA, 5, 1, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 4, N…
## $ CompHrsDayChild <int> NA, NA, NA, 1, NA, 0, 6, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 3, N…
## $ Alcohol12PlusYr <fct> Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Yes, NA, NA, Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes, Y…
## $ AlcoholDay <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, 2, NA, NA, 3, 3, 3, 1, 2, 6, NA, NA, …
## $ AlcoholYear <int> 0, 0, 0, NA, 20, NA, NA, 52, 52, 52, 100, 104, 364, N…
## $ SmokeNow <fct> No, No, No, NA, Yes, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, No, NA, NA, …
## $ Smoke100 <fct> Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Yes, NA, NA, No, No, No, Yes, No, …
## $ Smoke100n <fct> Smoker, Smoker, Smoker, NA, Smoker, NA, NA, Non-Smoke…
## $ SmokeAge <int> 18, 18, 18, NA, 38, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 13, NA, NA, N…
## $ Marijuana <fct> Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Yes, NA, NA, Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Ye…
## $ AgeFirstMarij <int> 17, 17, 17, NA, 18, NA, NA, 13, 13, 13, NA, 19, 15, N…
## $ RegularMarij <fct> No, No, No, NA, No, NA, NA, No, No, No, NA, Yes, Yes,…
## $ AgeRegMarij <int> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, 20, 15, N…
## $ HardDrugs <fct> Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Yes, NA, NA, No, No, No, No, Yes, …
## $ SexEver <fct> Yes, Yes, Yes, NA, Yes, NA, NA, Yes, Yes, Yes, Yes, Y…
## $ SexAge <int> 16, 16, 16, NA, 12, NA, NA, 13, 13, 13, 17, 22, 12, N…
## $ SexNumPartnLife <int> 8, 8, 8, NA, 10, NA, NA, 20, 20, 20, 15, 7, 100, NA, …
## $ SexNumPartYear <int> 1, 1, 1, NA, 1, NA, NA, 0, 0, 0, NA, 1, 1, NA, NA, 1,…
## $ SameSex <fct> No, No, No, NA, Yes, NA, NA, Yes, Yes, Yes, No, No, N…
## $ SexOrientation <fct> Heterosexual, Heterosexual, Heterosexual, NA, Heteros…
## $ PregnantNow <fct> NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, NA, N…
Check the variables that will be used:
required_vars <- c(
"ID", "SurveyYr", "Diabetes", "Age", "Gender", "Race1",
"BMI", "BPSysAve", "BPDiaAve", "TotChol", "DirectChol",
"PhysActive", "Smoke100", "Education", "Poverty", "SleepHrsNight"
)
missing_vars <- setdiff(required_vars, names(NHANES))
if (length(missing_vars) > 0) {
stop(
"The following expected NHANES variables are missing: ",
paste(missing_vars, collapse = ", ")
)
}
We restrict the example to adults aged 20 years or older and participants with a defined diabetes outcome.
nhanes0 <- NHANES %>%
select(all_of(required_vars))
nhanes1 <- nhanes0 %>%
filter(
Age >= 20,
Diabetes %in% c("Yes", "No")
) %>%
mutate(
Diabetes_num = if_else(Diabetes == "Yes", 1L, 0L)
)
cat("Adult analytical cohort N =", nrow(nhanes1), "\n")
## Adult analytical cohort N = 7233
Check outcome coding:
table(nhanes1$Diabetes, nhanes1$Diabetes_num, useNA = "ifany")
##
## 0 1
## No 6490 0
## Yes 0 743
prop.table(table(nhanes1$Diabetes))
##
## No Yes
## 0.8972764 0.1027236
duplicate_ids <- nhanes1 %>%
count(ID) %>%
filter(n > 1)
duplicate_ids
A duplicate ID should never be deleted automatically. It may represent a true duplicate, repeated measurement, merge error, or multiple records per participant.
sapply(nhanes1, class)
## ID SurveyYr Diabetes Age Gender
## "integer" "factor" "factor" "integer" "factor"
## Race1 BMI BPSysAve BPDiaAve TotChol
## "factor" "numeric" "integer" "integer" "numeric"
## DirectChol PhysActive Smoke100 Education Poverty
## "numeric" "factor" "factor" "factor" "numeric"
## SleepHrsNight Diabetes_num
## "integer" "integer"
list(
Diabetes = levels(nhanes1$Diabetes),
SurveyYr = levels(nhanes1$SurveyYr),
Gender = levels(nhanes1$Gender),
Race1 = levels(nhanes1$Race1),
PhysActive = levels(nhanes1$PhysActive),
Smoke100 = levels(nhanes1$Smoke100),
Education = levels(nhanes1$Education)
)
## $Diabetes
## [1] "No" "Yes"
##
## $SurveyYr
## [1] "2009_10" "2011_12"
##
## $Gender
## [1] "female" "male"
##
## $Race1
## [1] "Black" "Hispanic" "Mexican" "White" "Other"
##
## $PhysActive
## [1] "No" "Yes"
##
## $Smoke100
## [1] "No" "Yes"
##
## $Education
## [1] "8th Grade" "9 - 11th Grade" "High School" "Some College"
## [5] "College Grad"
range_summary <- nhanes1 %>%
summarise(
across(
c(Age, BMI, BPSysAve, BPDiaAve, TotChol, DirectChol, Poverty, SleepHrsNight),
list(
min = ~ min(.x, na.rm = TRUE),
max = ~ max(.x, na.rm = TRUE)
)
)
)
range_summary
The following rules are screening rules, not automatic deletion rules.
flagged_values <- nhanes1 %>%
filter(
Age < 20 | Age > 100 |
(!is.na(BMI) & BMI <= 0) |
(!is.na(BPSysAve) & BPSysAve <= 0) |
(!is.na(BPDiaAve) & BPDiaAve < 0) |
(!is.na(TotChol) & TotChol <= 0)
)
flagged_values %>%
select(ID, Age, BMI, BPSysAve, BPDiaAve, TotChol) %>%
head(20)
missing_summary <- nhanes1 %>%
summarise(
across(
everything(),
~ mean(is.na(.x)) * 100
)
) %>%
pivot_longer(
cols = everything(),
names_to = "Variable",
values_to = "Missing_Percent"
) %>%
arrange(desc(Missing_Percent))
missing_summary
vis_miss(nhanes1)
gg_miss_var(nhanes1)
model_vars_for_missing <- nhanes1 %>%
select(
Diabetes_num,
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
Gender,
Race1,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
)
md.pattern(model_vars_for_missing)
## Diabetes_num Age Gender Race1 PhysActive Smoke100 BMI BPSysAve TotChol
## 6575 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0
## 342 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1
## 214 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1
## 39 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 2
## 45 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1
## 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 2
## 9 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 2
## 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 3
## 0 0 0 0 0 0 63 264 390 717
nhanes1 %>%
select(
Diabetes,
Age,
Gender,
Race1,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
) %>%
tbl_summary(
by = Diabetes,
statistic = list(
all_continuous() ~ "{mean} ({sd}); median {median} [{p25}, {p75}]",
all_categorical() ~ "{n} ({p}%)"
),
missing = "ifany"
)
| Characteristic | No N = 6,4901 |
Yes N = 7431 |
|---|---|---|
| Age | 46 (17); median 44 [31, 57] | 60 (13); median 61 [52, 70] |
| Gender | ||
| female | 3,337 (51%) | 344 (46%) |
| male | 3,153 (49%) | 399 (54%) |
| Race1 | ||
| Black | 691 (11%) | 130 (17%) |
| Hispanic | 372 (5.7%) | 44 (5.9%) |
| Mexican | 537 (8.3%) | 64 (8.6%) |
| White | 4,408 (68%) | 439 (59%) |
| Other | 482 (7.4%) | 66 (8.9%) |
| BMI | 28 (6); median 27 [24, 32] | 33 (8); median 32 [27, 37] |
| Unknown | 52 | 11 |
| BPSysAve | 120 (17); median 118 [109, 128] | 128 (19); median 127 [115, 140] |
| Unknown | 248 | 16 |
| TotChol | 5.10 (1.04); median 5.02 [4.34, 5.72] | 4.79 (1.16); median 4.68 [3.98, 5.43] |
| Unknown | 331 | 59 |
| PhysActive | 3,525 (54%) | 271 (36%) |
| Smoke100 | 2,836 (44%) | 373 (50%) |
| 1 Mean (SD); median Median [Q1, Q3]; n (%) | ||
For prediction modeling, a variable should not be excluded simply because its univariable P-value is greater than 0.05.
ggplot(nhanes1, aes(x = Age)) +
geom_histogram(bins = 30) +
labs(
title = "Distribution of Age",
x = "Age (years)",
y = "Count"
)
ggplot(nhanes1, aes(x = BMI)) +
geom_histogram(bins = 30) +
labs(
title = "Distribution of BMI",
x = "BMI",
y = "Count"
)
## Warning: Removed 63 rows containing non-finite outside the scale range
## (`stat_bin()`).
ggplot(nhanes1, aes(x = BPSysAve)) +
geom_histogram(bins = 30) +
labs(
title = "Distribution of Average Systolic Blood Pressure",
x = "Average systolic BP",
y = "Count"
)
## Warning: Removed 264 rows containing non-finite outside the scale range
## (`stat_bin()`).
ggplot(nhanes1, aes(x = Diabetes, y = BMI)) +
geom_boxplot() +
labs(
title = "BMI by Diabetes Status",
x = "Diabetes",
y = "BMI"
)
## Warning: Removed 63 rows containing non-finite outside the scale range
## (`stat_boxplot()`).
ggplot(nhanes1, aes(x = Diabetes, y = Age)) +
geom_boxplot() +
labs(
title = "Age by Diabetes Status",
x = "Diabetes",
y = "Age"
)
q1_bmi <- quantile(nhanes1$BMI, 0.25, na.rm = TRUE)
q3_bmi <- quantile(nhanes1$BMI, 0.75, na.rm = TRUE)
iqr_bmi <- q3_bmi - q1_bmi
bmi_lower <- q1_bmi - 1.5 * iqr_bmi
bmi_upper <- q3_bmi + 1.5 * iqr_bmi
bmi_outliers <- nhanes1 %>%
filter(
!is.na(BMI),
BMI < bmi_lower | BMI > bmi_upper
) %>%
select(ID, Age, Gender, BMI, Diabetes)
head(bmi_outliers, 20)
A statistical outlier is not automatically a data error. Clinically plausible extreme values should generally be retained unless there is evidence of measurement or data-entry error.
cor_data <- nhanes1 %>%
select(
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
BPDiaAve,
TotChol,
DirectChol
)
round(
cor(cor_data, use = "pairwise.complete.obs"),
2
)
## Age BMI BPSysAve BPDiaAve TotChol DirectChol
## Age 1.00 0.04 0.41 -0.06 0.13 0.11
## BMI 0.04 1.00 0.13 0.12 0.00 -0.34
## BPSysAve 0.41 0.13 1.00 0.33 0.13 0.00
## BPDiaAve -0.06 0.12 0.33 1.00 0.17 -0.04
## TotChol 0.13 0.00 0.13 0.17 1.00 0.22
## DirectChol 0.11 -0.34 0.00 -0.04 0.22 1.00
model_data <- nhanes1 %>%
select(
ID,
SurveyYr,
Diabetes,
Diabetes_num,
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
Gender,
Race1,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
)
model_cc <- model_data %>%
drop_na(
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
Gender,
Race1,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
)
cat("Original modeling N =", nrow(model_data), "\n")
## Original modeling N = 7233
cat("Complete-case N =", nrow(model_cc), "\n")
## Complete-case N = 6575
cat(
"Complete-case retention =",
round(100 * nrow(model_cc) / nrow(model_data), 1),
"%\n"
)
## Complete-case retention = 90.9 %
model_data <- model_data %>%
mutate(
CompleteCase = if_else(
complete.cases(
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
Gender,
Race1,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
),
"Complete",
"Missing"
)
)
model_data %>%
group_by(CompleteCase) %>%
summarise(
N = n(),
Mean_Age = mean(Age, na.rm = TRUE),
Mean_BMI = mean(BMI, na.rm = TRUE),
Diabetes_Rate = mean(Diabetes_num, na.rm = TRUE),
.groups = "drop"
)
The outcome is included in the imputation model because it can help predict missing predictor values. The outcome itself is not imputed here.
mi_data <- model_data %>%
select(
Diabetes_num,
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
Gender,
Race1,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
)
ini <- mice(
mi_data,
maxit = 0,
printFlag = FALSE
)
method <- ini$method
predictor_matrix <- ini$predictorMatrix
method
## Diabetes_num Age BMI BPSysAve TotChol Gender
## "" "" "pmm" "pmm" "pmm" ""
## Race1 PhysActive Smoke100
## "" "" ""
Prevent imputation of the observed outcome:
method["Diabetes_num"] <- ""
predictor_matrix[, "Diabetes_num"] <- 1
predictor_matrix["Diabetes_num", ] <- 0
method
## Diabetes_num Age BMI BPSysAve TotChol Gender
## "" "" "pmm" "pmm" "pmm" ""
## Race1 PhysActive Smoke100
## "" "" ""
set.seed(2026)
imp <- mice(
mi_data,
m = 20,
maxit = 20,
method = method,
predictorMatrix = predictor_matrix,
seed = 2026,
printFlag = FALSE
)
imp
## Class: mids
## Number of multiple imputations: 20
## Imputation methods:
## Diabetes_num Age BMI BPSysAve TotChol Gender
## "" "" "pmm" "pmm" "pmm" ""
## Race1 PhysActive Smoke100
## "" "" ""
## PredictorMatrix:
## Diabetes_num Age BMI BPSysAve TotChol Gender Race1 PhysActive
## Diabetes_num 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
## Age 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1
## BMI 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1
## BPSysAve 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1
## TotChol 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1
## Gender 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1
## Smoke100
## Diabetes_num 0
## Age 1
## BMI 1
## BPSysAve 1
## TotChol 1
## Gender 1
plot(imp)
densityplot(imp, ~ BMI)
fit_mi <- with(
imp,
glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
family = binomial()
)
)
pooled_fit <- pool(fit_mi)
Pooled odds ratios:
summary(
pooled_fit,
conf.int = TRUE,
exponentiate = TRUE
)
Important statistical distinction: The pooled coefficients are useful for regression inference. A fully rigorous prediction-validation workflow with missing data should repeat imputation inside each resampling iteration. The remainder of this tutorial uses one completed dataset for transparent teaching of model diagnostics and validation. That simplification should not be mistaken for the strictest publication-level MI + bootstrap procedure.
model_complete <- complete(imp, action = 1)
summary(model_complete)
## Diabetes_num Age BMI BPSysAve
## Min. :0.0000 Min. :20.00 Min. :15.02 Min. : 78.0
## 1st Qu.:0.0000 1st Qu.:33.00 1st Qu.:24.10 1st Qu.:109.0
## Median :0.0000 Median :46.00 Median :27.75 Median :119.0
## Mean :0.1027 Mean :47.17 Mean :28.76 Mean :120.9
## 3rd Qu.:0.0000 3rd Qu.:60.00 3rd Qu.:32.20 3rd Qu.:130.0
## Max. :1.0000 Max. :80.00 Max. :81.25 Max. :226.0
## TotChol Gender Race1 PhysActive Smoke100
## Min. : 1.530 female:3681 Black : 821 No :3437 No :4024
## 1st Qu.: 4.290 male :3552 Hispanic: 416 Yes:3796 Yes:3209
## Median : 4.990 Mexican : 601
## Mean : 5.069 White :4847
## 3rd Qu.: 5.690 Other : 548
## Max. :13.650
fit_full <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete,
family = binomial()
)
summary(fit_full)
##
## Call:
## glm(formula = Diabetes_num ~ Age + BMI + BPSysAve + TotChol +
## Gender + Race1 + PhysActive + Smoke100, family = binomial(),
## data = model_complete)
##
## Coefficients:
## Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -7.112020 0.445556 -15.962 < 2e-16 ***
## Age 0.060354 0.003116 19.369 < 2e-16 ***
## BMI 0.094418 0.006056 15.591 < 2e-16 ***
## BPSysAve 0.004711 0.002364 1.993 0.04625 *
## TotChol -0.287436 0.043076 -6.673 2.51e-11 ***
## Gendermale 0.323390 0.088541 3.652 0.00026 ***
## Race1Hispanic -0.114461 0.205495 -0.557 0.57753
## Race1Mexican -0.025664 0.181059 -0.142 0.88728
## Race1White -0.747630 0.123100 -6.073 1.25e-09 ***
## Race1Other 0.222607 0.183607 1.212 0.22535
## PhysActiveYes -0.170460 0.089499 -1.905 0.05683 .
## Smoke100Yes 0.163988 0.087292 1.879 0.06030 .
## ---
## Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
##
## (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)
##
## Null deviance: 4788.6 on 7232 degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 3837.1 on 7221 degrees of freedom
## AIC: 3861.1
##
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 6
Odds ratios and confidence intervals:
broom::tidy(
fit_full,
exponentiate = TRUE,
conf.int = TRUE
)
For a prediction model, statistical significance is not the main criterion for retaining a prespecified predictor.
vif_result <- car::vif(fit_full)
vif_result
## GVIF Df GVIF^(1/(2*Df))
## Age 1.351138 1 1.162385
## BMI 1.122581 1 1.059519
## BPSysAve 1.156118 1 1.075229
## TotChol 1.045168 1 1.022335
## Gender 1.086153 1 1.042187
## Race1 1.160336 4 1.018763
## PhysActive 1.065883 1 1.032416
## Smoke100 1.060550 1 1.029830
If vif() returns generalized VIF values for multi-level
factors, the commonly reviewed quantity is
\[ GVIF^{1/(2df)}. \]
rms environmentdd <- datadist(model_complete)
options(datadist = "dd")
lrm()fit_linear <- lrm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete,
x = TRUE,
y = TRUE
)
fit_linear
## Logistic Regression Model
##
## lrm(formula = Diabetes_num ~ Age + BMI + BPSysAve + TotChol +
## Gender + Race1 + PhysActive + Smoke100, data = model_complete,
## x = TRUE, y = TRUE)
##
## Model Likelihood Discrimination Rank Discrim.
## Ratio Test Indexes Indexes
## Obs 7233 LR chi2 951.51 R2 0.255 C 0.820
## 0 6490 d.f. 11 R2(11,7233)0.122 Dxy 0.639
## 1 743 Pr(> chi2) <0.0001 R2(11,2000)0.375 gamma 0.639
## max |deriv| 5e-05 Brier 0.078 tau-a 0.118
##
## Coef S.E. Wald Z Pr(>|Z|)
## Intercept -7.1120 0.4456 -15.96 <0.0001
## Age 0.0604 0.0031 19.37 <0.0001
## BMI 0.0944 0.0061 15.59 <0.0001
## BPSysAve 0.0047 0.0024 1.99 0.0463
## TotChol -0.2874 0.0431 -6.67 <0.0001
## Gender=male 0.3234 0.0885 3.65 0.0003
## Race1=Hispanic -0.1145 0.2055 -0.56 0.5775
## Race1=Mexican -0.0257 0.1811 -0.14 0.8873
## Race1=White -0.7476 0.1231 -6.07 <0.0001
## Race1=Other 0.2226 0.1836 1.21 0.2254
## PhysActive=Yes -0.1705 0.0895 -1.90 0.0568
## Smoke100=Yes 0.1640 0.0873 1.88 0.0603
fit_spline <- lrm(
Diabetes_num ~
rcs(Age, 4) +
rcs(BMI, 4) +
rcs(BPSysAve, 4) +
rcs(TotChol, 4) +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete,
x = TRUE,
y = TRUE
)
fit_spline
## Logistic Regression Model
##
## lrm(formula = Diabetes_num ~ rcs(Age, 4) + rcs(BMI, 4) + rcs(BPSysAve,
## 4) + rcs(TotChol, 4) + Gender + Race1 + PhysActive + Smoke100,
## data = model_complete, x = TRUE, y = TRUE)
##
## Model Likelihood Discrimination Rank Discrim.
## Ratio Test Indexes Indexes
## Obs 7233 LR chi2 1071.54 R2 0.284 C 0.833
## 0 6490 d.f. 19 R2(19,7233)0.135 Dxy 0.666
## 1 743 Pr(> chi2) <0.0001 R2(19,2000)0.409 gamma 0.666
## max |deriv| 0.0002 Brier 0.076 tau-a 0.123
##
## Coef S.E. Wald Z Pr(>|Z|)
## Intercept -3.6721 1.9681 -1.87 0.0621
## Age 0.0956 0.0263 3.64 0.0003
## Age' 0.0529 0.0769 0.69 0.4915
## Age'' -0.3438 0.1992 -1.73 0.0844
## BMI 0.0588 0.0466 1.26 0.2072
## BMI' 0.1883 0.1846 1.02 0.3077
## BMI'' -0.5119 0.4603 -1.11 0.2661
## BPSysAve -0.0251 0.0131 -1.92 0.0544
## BPSysAve' 0.1395 0.0521 2.68 0.0074
## BPSysAve'' -0.3822 0.1423 -2.69 0.0072
## TotChol -0.5670 0.1454 -3.90 <0.0001
## TotChol' -0.2385 0.5390 -0.44 0.6582
## TotChol'' 2.4817 1.7286 1.44 0.1511
## Gender=male 0.2257 0.0908 2.48 0.0130
## Race1=Hispanic -0.0573 0.2106 -0.27 0.7856
## Race1=Mexican 0.0191 0.1875 0.10 0.9189
## Race1=White -0.7037 0.1246 -5.65 <0.0001
## Race1=Other 0.2709 0.1871 1.45 0.1477
## PhysActive=Yes -0.1714 0.0903 -1.90 0.0576
## Smoke100=Yes 0.1400 0.0884 1.58 0.1133
anova(fit_spline)
## Wald Statistics Response: Diabetes_num
##
## Factor Chi-Square d.f. P
## Age 318.48 3 <.0001
## Nonlinear 70.41 2 <.0001
## BMI 212.90 3 <.0001
## Nonlinear 2.02 2 0.3645
## BPSysAve 13.93 3 0.0030
## Nonlinear 7.22 2 0.0270
## TotChol 96.56 3 <.0001
## Nonlinear 37.37 2 <.0001
## Gender 6.17 1 0.0130
## Race1 70.57 4 <.0001
## PhysActive 3.61 1 0.0576
## Smoke100 2.51 1 0.1133
## TOTAL NONLINEAR 117.10 8 <.0001
## TOTAL 709.38 19 <.0001
The Nonlinear rows test whether a purely linear
representation is inadequate for the corresponding continuous
predictor.
plot(
Predict(
fit_spline,
Age,
fun = plogis
),
xlab = "Age",
ylab = "Predicted probability"
)
plot(
Predict(
fit_spline,
BMI,
fun = plogis
),
xlab = "BMI",
ylab = "Predicted probability"
)
AIC(fit_linear, fit_spline)
## [1] 3861.117
A lower AIC indicates a better tradeoff between likelihood fit and model complexity, but AIC should not be the only model-selection criterion.
Suppose there is a clinically plausible question about whether the BMI association differs with age.
fit_interaction <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age * BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete,
family = binomial()
)
Likelihood-ratio comparison:
anova(
fit_full,
fit_interaction,
test = "LRT"
)
Interactions should ideally be prespecified or clinically motivated rather than discovered by indiscriminately testing every possible pair.
fit_step <- step(
fit_full,
direction = "backward",
trace = FALSE
)
formula(fit_step)
## Diabetes_num ~ Age + BMI + BPSysAve + TotChol + Gender + Race1 +
## PhysActive + Smoke100
summary(fit_step)
##
## Call:
## glm(formula = Diabetes_num ~ Age + BMI + BPSysAve + TotChol +
## Gender + Race1 + PhysActive + Smoke100, family = binomial(),
## data = model_complete)
##
## Coefficients:
## Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -7.112020 0.445556 -15.962 < 2e-16 ***
## Age 0.060354 0.003116 19.369 < 2e-16 ***
## BMI 0.094418 0.006056 15.591 < 2e-16 ***
## BPSysAve 0.004711 0.002364 1.993 0.04625 *
## TotChol -0.287436 0.043076 -6.673 2.51e-11 ***
## Gendermale 0.323390 0.088541 3.652 0.00026 ***
## Race1Hispanic -0.114461 0.205495 -0.557 0.57753
## Race1Mexican -0.025664 0.181059 -0.142 0.88728
## Race1White -0.747630 0.123100 -6.073 1.25e-09 ***
## Race1Other 0.222607 0.183607 1.212 0.22535
## PhysActiveYes -0.170460 0.089499 -1.905 0.05683 .
## Smoke100Yes 0.163988 0.087292 1.879 0.06030 .
## ---
## Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
##
## (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)
##
## Null deviance: 4788.6 on 7232 degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 3837.1 on 7221 degrees of freedom
## AIC: 3861.1
##
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 6
Stepwise selection is shown because it is common in practice, but it is generally not preferred for modern clinical prediction modeling because it can produce unstable variable selection, biased coefficients, and optimistic performance.
x <- model.matrix(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete
)[, -1, drop = FALSE]
y <- model_complete$Diabetes_num
set.seed(2026)
cv_lasso <- cv.glmnet(
x = x,
y = y,
family = "binomial",
alpha = 1,
nfolds = 10,
type.measure = "deviance"
)
cv_lasso$lambda.min
## [1] 0.001002943
cv_lasso$lambda.1se
## [1] 0.0112663
plot(cv_lasso)
coef(cv_lasso, s = "lambda.min")
## 12 x 1 sparse Matrix of class "dgCMatrix"
## lambda.min
## (Intercept) -6.996878647
## Age 0.059204398
## BMI 0.092136300
## BPSysAve 0.004389612
## TotChol -0.277855073
## Gendermale 0.294309734
## Race1Hispanic -0.036331184
## Race1Mexican .
## Race1White -0.697458821
## Race1Other 0.201671224
## PhysActiveYes -0.151480083
## Smoke100Yes 0.143180777
coef(cv_lasso, s = "lambda.1se")
## 12 x 1 sparse Matrix of class "dgCMatrix"
## lambda.1se
## (Intercept) -5.896861884
## Age 0.049006896
## BMI 0.072574863
## BPSysAve 0.001079893
## TotChol -0.180075353
## Gendermale 0.034040666
## Race1Hispanic .
## Race1Mexican .
## Race1White -0.399892727
## Race1Other .
## PhysActiveYes .
## Smoke100Yes .
LASSO performs shrinkage and may set some coefficients exactly to zero.
For the remaining primary demonstration, we use the spline model.
model_complete$pred_prob <- as.numeric(
predict(
fit_spline,
type = "fitted"
)
)
roc_obj <- roc(
response = model_complete$Diabetes_num,
predictor = model_complete$pred_prob,
quiet = TRUE
)
roc_obj
##
## Call:
## roc.default(response = model_complete$Diabetes_num, predictor = model_complete$pred_prob, quiet = TRUE)
##
## Data: model_complete$pred_prob in 6490 controls (model_complete$Diabetes_num 0) < 743 cases (model_complete$Diabetes_num 1).
## Area under the curve: 0.8328
auc(roc_obj)
## Area under the curve: 0.8328
ci.auc(roc_obj)
## 95% CI: 0.8184-0.8472 (DeLong)
plot(
roc_obj,
print.auc = TRUE,
main = "ROC Curve: Apparent Performance"
)
The AUC measures discrimination: how well the model ranks participants with diabetes above participants without diabetes.
Bootstrap validation estimates model optimism by repeatedly rebuilding the model in bootstrap samples and testing performance in the original data.
set.seed(2026)
val_boot <- validate(
fit_spline,
method = "boot",
B = 500
)
val_boot
## index.orig training test optimism index.corrected Lower Upper
## Dxy 0.6657 0.6710 0.6617 0.0093 0.6563 0.6263 0.6858
## R2 0.2844 0.2902 0.2800 0.0102 0.2742 0.2440 0.3029
## Intercept 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0469 0.0469 -0.0469 -0.2319 0.1421
## Slope 1.0000 1.0000 0.9730 0.0270 0.9730 0.8780 1.0676
## Emax 0.0000 0.0000 0.0228 -0.0228 0.0228 -0.0072 0.0719
## D 0.1480 0.1516 0.1456 0.0061 0.1419 0.1227 0.1601
## U -0.0003 -0.0003 0.0001 -0.0004 0.0001 -0.0005 0.0016
## Q 0.1483 0.1519 0.1455 0.0065 0.1418 0.1215 0.1600
## B 0.0756 0.0754 0.0760 -0.0006 0.0762 0.0719 0.0807
## g 1.8068 1.8416 1.7897 0.0519 1.7549 1.6042 1.9018
## gp 0.1225 0.1239 0.1216 0.0023 0.1203 0.1108 0.1296
## n
## Dxy 500
## R2 500
## Intercept 500
## Slope 500
## Emax 500
## D 500
## U 500
## Q 500
## B 500
## g 500
## gp 500
The most useful columns are typically:
index.orig: apparent performance in the original
datatraining: average performance in bootstrap samplestest: performance when bootstrap-fitted models are
applied back to the original dataoptimism: estimated over-optimismindex.corrected: optimism-corrected performanceFor a final analysis, increasing B to 1000 or more is
common when computationally feasible.
set.seed(2026)
cal_boot <- calibrate(
fit_spline,
method = "boot",
B = 500
)
cal_boot
## predy calibrated.orig calibrated.corrected index.orig
## [1,] 0.0008740645 0.003503405 0.004389022 0.0026293404
## [2,] 0.0179701314 0.017495185 0.018255665 -0.0004749465
## [3,] 0.0350661982 0.032251078 0.033482756 -0.0028151199
## [4,] 0.0521622651 0.048175553 0.049763262 -0.0039867124
## [5,] 0.0692583319 0.064897931 0.066295135 -0.0043604013
## [6,] 0.0863543988 0.082184954 0.083726698 -0.0041694451
## [7,] 0.1034504656 0.104859703 0.106572743 0.0014092371
## [8,] 0.1205465325 0.127396234 0.128842993 0.0068497011
## [9,] 0.1376425994 0.144538212 0.145571183 0.0068956127
## [10,] 0.1547386662 0.162371847 0.162968787 0.0076331811
## [11,] 0.1718347331 0.182284625 0.182325150 0.0104498917
## [12,] 0.1889307999 0.200513594 0.199763619 0.0115827944
## [13,] 0.2060268668 0.215106080 0.213528258 0.0090792130
## [14,] 0.2231229337 0.229356138 0.227062738 0.0062332045
## [15,] 0.2402190005 0.244710764 0.241820400 0.0044917632
## [16,] 0.2573150674 0.259927244 0.256472316 0.0026121769
## [17,] 0.2744111342 0.274667473 0.270632194 0.0002563392
## [18,] 0.2915072011 0.289100262 0.284462728 -0.0024069389
## [19,] 0.3086032680 0.303822359 0.298570545 -0.0047809092
## [20,] 0.3256993348 0.318808065 0.312932143 -0.0068912702
## [21,] 0.3427954017 0.333831082 0.327326785 -0.0089643199
## [22,] 0.3598914685 0.349200941 0.342089215 -0.0106905274
## [23,] 0.3769875354 0.365180778 0.357500029 -0.0118067569
## [24,] 0.3940836022 0.381932592 0.373719289 -0.0121510100
## [25,] 0.4111796691 0.399121818 0.390393768 -0.0120578510
## [26,] 0.4282757360 0.416429080 0.407184202 -0.0118466558
## [27,] 0.4453718028 0.433731524 0.423953442 -0.0116402788
## [28,] 0.4624678697 0.450987442 0.440655712 -0.0114804279
## [29,] 0.4795639365 0.468186677 0.457284027 -0.0113772592
## [30,] 0.4966600034 0.485359787 0.473876984 -0.0113002160
## [31,] 0.5137560703 0.502553922 0.490493507 -0.0112021481
## [32,] 0.5308521371 0.519785139 0.507158992 -0.0110669986
## [33,] 0.5479482040 0.537051469 0.523874150 -0.0108967351
## [34,] 0.5650442708 0.554347536 0.540632497 -0.0106967353
## [35,] 0.5821403377 0.571665030 0.557423424 -0.0104753073
## [36,] 0.5992364045 0.589002215 0.574242812 -0.0102341897
## [37,] 0.6163324714 0.606363344 0.591092690 -0.0099691279
## [38,] 0.6334285383 0.623757401 0.607980773 -0.0096711372
## [39,] 0.6505246051 0.641194534 0.624915951 -0.0093300710
## [40,] 0.6676206720 0.658678355 0.641900906 -0.0089423175
## [41,] 0.6847167388 0.676206823 0.658932202 -0.0085099158
## [42,] 0.7018128057 0.693788090 0.676018492 -0.0080247159
## [43,] 0.7189088726 0.711419143 0.693155550 -0.0074897292
## [44,] 0.7360049394 0.729093823 0.710335347 -0.0069111166
## [45,] 0.7531010063 0.746809825 0.727429616 -0.0062911814
## [46,] 0.7701970731 0.764560824 0.744675831 -0.0056362488
## [47,] 0.7872931400 0.782354219 0.761926344 -0.0049389211
## [48,] 0.8043892069 0.800208786 0.779178736 -0.0041804204
## [49,] 0.8214852737 0.818083266 0.796551706 -0.0034020073
## [50,] 0.8385813406 0.835957746 0.813565873 -0.0026235943
## training test optimism index.corrected Lower
## [1,] 0.0026853398 0.0035709566 -8.856168e-04 0.0035149572 NA
## [2,] -0.0004664004 0.0002940796 -7.604800e-04 0.0002855335 -0.004156668
## [3,] -0.0028072088 -0.0015755312 -1.231678e-03 -0.0015834422 -0.008012369
## [4,] -0.0041038711 -0.0025161616 -1.587710e-03 -0.0023990028 -0.012153892
## [5,] -0.0038223561 -0.0024251514 -1.397205e-03 -0.0029631966 -0.014963211
## [6,] -0.0028562934 -0.0013145487 -1.541745e-03 -0.0026277004 -0.016109663
## [7,] 0.0009748609 0.0026879017 -1.713041e-03 0.0031222778 -0.011944247
## [8,] 0.0042697897 0.0057165494 -1.446760e-03 0.0082964608 -0.008051966
## [9,] 0.0058705209 0.0069034921 -1.032971e-03 0.0079285839 -0.009638672
## [10,] 0.0071243964 0.0077213357 -5.969393e-04 0.0082301204 -0.009837520
## [11,] 0.0085085699 0.0085490953 -4.052538e-05 0.0104904171 -0.008147028
## [12,] 0.0091916227 0.0084416471 7.499756e-04 0.0108328188 -0.009076676
## [13,] 0.0085028587 0.0069250369 1.577822e-03 0.0075013911 -0.012884590
## [14,] 0.0069801225 0.0046867226 2.293400e-03 0.0039398046 -0.017042771
## [15,] 0.0052219696 0.0023316056 2.890364e-03 0.0016013992 -0.021124085
## [16,] 0.0032959926 -0.0001589358 3.454928e-03 -0.0008427515 -0.025027794
## [17,] 0.0010876792 -0.0029476005 4.035280e-03 -0.0037789405 -0.029352329
## [18,] -0.0012814332 -0.0059189674 4.637534e-03 -0.0070444731 -0.034096437
## [19,] -0.0035252927 -0.0087771060 5.251813e-03 -0.0100327225 -0.038926153
## [20,] -0.0054706815 -0.0113466031 5.875922e-03 -0.0127671917 -0.043068976
## [21,] -0.0071110099 -0.0136153068 6.504297e-03 -0.0154686169 -0.047177229
## [22,] -0.0084398849 -0.0155516111 7.111726e-03 -0.0178022536 -0.051382974
## [23,] -0.0093992164 -0.0170799662 7.680750e-03 -0.0194875068 -0.055124509
## [24,] -0.0099676491 -0.0181809521 8.213303e-03 -0.0203643130 -0.058224796
## [25,] -0.0101875436 -0.0189155933 8.728050e-03 -0.0207859007 -0.060047278
## [26,] -0.0101744189 -0.0194192974 9.244878e-03 -0.0210915343 -0.061759675
## [27,] -0.0100675588 -0.0198456409 9.778082e-03 -0.0214183609 -0.063952575
## [28,] -0.0099585910 -0.0202903211 1.033173e-02 -0.0218121580 -0.066118565
## [29,] -0.0098762804 -0.0207789312 1.090265e-02 -0.0222799100 -0.068657443
## [30,] -0.0098047423 -0.0212875452 1.148280e-02 -0.0227830190 -0.071279835
## [31,] -0.0097174984 -0.0217779133 1.206041e-02 -0.0232625631 -0.073494003
## [32,] -0.0096048458 -0.0222309920 1.262615e-02 -0.0236931448 -0.076105162
## [33,] -0.0094691211 -0.0226464405 1.317732e-02 -0.0240740545 -0.078937714
## [34,] -0.0093146276 -0.0230296665 1.371504e-02 -0.0244117741 -0.081691777
## [35,] -0.0091437444 -0.0233853508 1.424161e-02 -0.0247169137 -0.084713775
## [36,] -0.0089565557 -0.0237159590 1.475940e-02 -0.0249935930 -0.087304054
## [37,] -0.0087502762 -0.0240209292 1.527065e-02 -0.0252397809 -0.090165224
## [38,] -0.0085208697 -0.0242974973 1.577663e-02 -0.0254477648 -0.092789722
## [39,] -0.0082635681 -0.0245421514 1.627858e-02 -0.0256086543 -0.095548761
## [40,] -0.0079740395 -0.0247514883 1.677745e-02 -0.0257197662 -0.098454911
## [41,] -0.0076472863 -0.0249219075 1.727462e-02 -0.0257845370 -0.101526595
## [42,] -0.0072823266 -0.0250519242 1.776960e-02 -0.0257943134 -0.104305237
## [43,] -0.0068761872 -0.0251397805 1.826359e-02 -0.0257533224 -0.107240929
## [44,] -0.0064274853 -0.0251859613 1.875848e-02 -0.0256695926 -0.110526259
## [45,] -0.0058751741 -0.0252553829 1.938021e-02 -0.0256713902 NA
## [46,] -0.0053319534 -0.0252169464 1.988499e-02 -0.0255212418 NA
## [47,] -0.0047632406 -0.0251911153 2.042787e-02 -0.0253667958 NA
## [48,] -0.0042054104 -0.0252354605 2.103005e-02 -0.0252104706 NA
## [49,] -0.0036552396 -0.0251868004 2.153156e-02 -0.0249335681 NA
## [50,] -0.0030717871 -0.0254636608 2.239187e-02 -0.0250154679 NA
## Upper n
## [1,] NA 312
## [2,] 0.005087578 500
## [3,] 0.006106309 500
## [4,] 0.008109391 500
## [5,] 0.009117669 500
## [6,] 0.011537493 500
## [7,] 0.018410024 500
## [8,] 0.024888536 500
## [9,] 0.026059330 500
## [10,] 0.028080623 500
## [11,] 0.031439066 500
## [12,] 0.032053113 500
## [13,] 0.029898070 500
## [14,] 0.027769281 500
## [15,] 0.025934529 500
## [16,] 0.024736779 500
## [17,] 0.023399123 500
## [18,] 0.021991199 500
## [19,] 0.020721715 500
## [20,] 0.020283906 500
## [21,] 0.019944784 500
## [22,] 0.019427573 500
## [23,] 0.019400622 500
## [24,] 0.020058472 500
## [25,] 0.022033922 500
## [26,] 0.024056934 500
## [27,] 0.025548586 500
## [28,] 0.027293459 500
## [29,] 0.028904629 500
## [30,] 0.030694038 500
## [31,] 0.033153496 500
## [32,] 0.035255094 500
## [33,] 0.037182465 500
## [34,] 0.039301275 500
## [35,] 0.041210235 500
## [36,] 0.043723834 500
## [37,] 0.046029474 500
## [38,] 0.048711201 500
## [39,] 0.051334215 500
## [40,] 0.053886442 500
## [41,] 0.056344331 500
## [42,] 0.059220330 500
## [43,] 0.061999723 500
## [44,] 0.064477397 500
## [45,] NA 499
## [46,] NA 499
## [47,] NA 498
## [48,] NA 496
## [49,] NA 494
## [50,] NA 491
## attr(,"class")
## [1] "calibrate.default"
## attr(,"call")
## calibrate.default(fit = fit_spline, method = "boot", B = 500)
## attr(,"kint")
## [1] 1
## attr(,"model")
## [1] "lr"
## attr(,"lev.name")
## [1] "1"
## attr(,"yvar.name")
## [1] "Diabetes_num"
## attr(,"n")
## [1] 7233
## attr(,"freq")
## 0 1
## 6490 743
## attr(,"non.slopes")
## [1] 1
## attr(,"B")
## [1] 500
## attr(,"method")
## [1] "boot"
## attr(,"predicted")
## [1] 0.0441182752 0.0441182752 0.0441182752 0.0491437658 0.0163394264
## [6] 0.0163394264 0.0163394264 0.0762464798 0.0881837421 0.0581427919
## [11] 0.1689632888 0.0528147513 0.0116382075 0.1096401680 0.0300342754
## [16] 0.0300342754 0.0443655164 0.3361993836 0.3361993836 0.0623880305
## [21] 0.0081312791 0.0580411428 0.0580411428 0.3273302720 0.0012946986
## [26] 0.3199213677 0.3199213677 0.1236380069 0.1412074130 0.1412074130
## [31] 0.0102144959 0.0165710671 0.1209914410 0.0094000406 0.0032348333
## [36] 0.0237414481 0.0237414481 0.0420925039 0.2261539777 0.2518390392
## [41] 0.2651252431 0.2651252431 0.2651252431 0.0116258166 0.0220537528
## [46] 0.0145663561 0.0069237961 0.0069237961 0.0069237961 0.0761434102
## [51] 0.0761434102 0.0453561636 0.0052290416 0.0052290416 0.0052290416
## [56] 0.0373427632 0.0303619507 0.0303619507 0.0303619507 0.0078656283
## [61] 0.0078656283 0.0078656283 0.0078656283 0.1204532372 0.1204532372
## [66] 0.1508447593 0.0062859215 0.2394853107 0.1019890488 0.0086563122
## [71] 0.1985521496 0.2223965473 0.4416158136 0.0127289993 0.0127289993
## [76] 0.0127289993 0.0458980514 0.0458980514 0.0458980514 0.2605037986
## [81] 0.0750070371 0.0750070371 0.0959437110 0.0359848106 0.2106029499
## [86] 0.0873609396 0.0873609396 0.0873609396 0.0873609396 0.2670399649
## [91] 0.2686794156 0.0114282961 0.3886882493 0.1141716313 0.2439924856
## [96] 0.6221556793 0.0437853010 0.0049180182 0.0049180182 0.0049180182
## [101] 0.2344008275 0.2344008275 0.1632264865 0.0170007883 0.0282941688
## [106] 0.0282941688 0.0147171268 0.1719664210 0.1371654296 0.1982187580
## [111] 0.0296923912 0.0296923912 0.0284087362 0.0284087362 0.1655477583
## [116] 0.2053318454 0.2053318454 0.0278375236 0.0101857976 0.0101857976
## [121] 0.0101857976 0.0101857976 0.0237403313 0.0146445340 0.0291908172
## [126] 0.0291908172 0.1156685051 0.0038524490 0.0339374137 0.0518878557
## [131] 0.0518878557 0.1397548201 0.1265352532 0.2044654201 0.2044654201
## [136] 0.0751491152 0.0751491152 0.0029735577 0.1032428542 0.1032428542
## [141] 0.0121127883 0.0129081936 0.0129081936 0.0954297811 0.0954297811
## [146] 0.0212567719 0.0212567719 0.0620639882 0.0620639882 0.0299055419
## [151] 0.0299055419 0.0140338087 0.0227707393 0.2254748209 0.2254748209
## [156] 0.1259682622 0.2097270692 0.0906997309 0.0041974405 0.0646391739
## [161] 0.7749016379 0.0243117718 0.2295473072 0.1066526496 0.1066526496
## [166] 0.0257042564 0.0028875202 0.0028875202 0.1743795202 0.1743795202
## [171] 0.0070065504 0.0070065504 0.0570139703 0.1133573488 0.1652417600
## [176] 0.1652417600 0.5193044954 0.1634717559 0.1634717559 0.2819429124
## [181] 0.0266697361 0.2443684773 0.2443684773 0.0098713676 0.0098713676
## [186] 0.0098713676 0.0634623261 0.0634623261 0.0097201466 0.0097201466
## [191] 0.2715175163 0.0117339429 0.7071651212 0.7071651212 0.7071651212
## [196] 0.2052151753 0.0080541384 0.0421866071 0.0421866071 0.1407308366
## [201] 0.0493745569 0.1033923710 0.3597848480 0.0929046912 0.0929046912
## [206] 0.0220382423 0.4595480165 0.1721930855 0.0277959237 0.0277959237
## [211] 0.0566816960 0.0430700988 0.4364552602 0.1859282545 0.1465401788
## [216] 0.1465401788 0.0650532549 0.0016481463 0.0121474767 0.0121474767
## [221] 0.0521703868 0.2661203524 0.2661203524 0.2661203524 0.0481820060
## [226] 0.0481820060 0.0481820060 0.0314527216 0.0314527216 0.0070094538
## [231] 0.1671590400 0.0920924188 0.3478348335 0.3478348335 0.3478348335
## [236] 0.3478348335 0.0215175653 0.1492224323 0.1492224323 0.0896636146
## [241] 0.0495453779 0.0495453779 0.2559938483 0.4479687817 0.0922976087
## [246] 0.0140976563 0.0140976563 0.0896374717 0.0896374717 0.0039061477
## [251] 0.0037265720 0.0893127070 0.0046092219 0.0046092219 0.0313013473
## [256] 0.0051224409 0.0481577684 0.0611623169 0.0611623169 0.0225749486
## [261] 0.0939783540 0.0035731769 0.0432750634 0.0432750634 0.0432750634
## [266] 0.0127430103 0.0718663791 0.0025881583 0.9381325781 0.9381325781
## [271] 0.0092286366 0.0473694595 0.0895678254 0.0354532635 0.3480558763
## [276] 0.1152382320 0.1207865561 0.0066042225 0.6273953995 0.0498626546
## [281] 0.0498626546 0.0024566434 0.1261584307 0.0706779905 0.0173745582
## [286] 0.1410215751 0.0072543494 0.0209611454 0.0676974581 0.0676974581
## [291] 0.1386838660 0.3487463504 0.0476430661 0.0366490162 0.0642404078
## [296] 0.1048342911 0.1629570325 0.1629570325 0.1629570325 0.0116647892
## [301] 0.5270196377 0.0051687162 0.0342335884 0.0342335884 0.0291315234
## [306] 0.1250632330 0.2751315309 0.2751315309 0.3197403531 0.0281001181
## [311] 0.0281001181 0.0281001181 0.2611734080 0.0098017587 0.0098017587
## [316] 0.1569575487 0.1569575487 0.1569575487 0.0059874103 0.2420489051
## [321] 0.2420489051 0.3136818026 0.1676587184 0.1676587184 0.0480356794
## [326] 0.0480356794 0.0480356794 0.0037312728 0.0037312728 0.0044666087
## [331] 0.0802899607 0.1365926050 0.1365926050 0.1365926050 0.0471858984
## [336] 0.0471858984 0.0118434498 0.0979179937 0.0979179937 0.0979179937
## [341] 0.0979179937 0.1610710990 0.0386160898 0.0392160144 0.0402809874
## [346] 0.0402809874 0.0127208322 0.0127208322 0.1577621756 0.1577621756
## [351] 0.0241417987 0.2066977717 0.0663537438 0.0663537438 0.1655690142
## [356] 0.0132581187 0.0683342427 0.0683342427 0.0683342427 0.0083897086
## [361] 0.0183490948 0.0163557219 0.0055337197 0.0093299443 0.0222225007
## [366] 0.0222225007 0.4373367550 0.1270477795 0.1270477795 0.0663901508
## [371] 0.0104112931 0.0104112931 0.0065028553 0.0065028553 0.0776947468
## [376] 0.0776947468 0.1572474851 0.1320563423 0.0090505665 0.2534132943
## [381] 0.4100147141 0.0678225519 0.0678225519 0.0045936744 0.0045936744
## [386] 0.0404666691 0.0404666691 0.5009589388 0.4342723398 0.0229773166
## [391] 0.0346799990 0.0346799990 0.0346799990 0.0346799990 0.2643931283
## [396] 0.0866144780 0.0511725932 0.1275853856 0.2334846976 0.5327765747
## [401] 0.0064224187 0.0762473389 0.4449007627 0.0292800809 0.2620832301
## [406] 0.0688413506 0.0044944077 0.1227460970 0.0206990629 0.3011519713
## [411] 0.0122503564 0.0122503564 0.2386779630 0.0151335040 0.2880107010
## [416] 0.2880107010 0.3186079812 0.1933239694 0.1933239694 0.2375378416
## [421] 0.4110146445 0.1028402931 0.0154302319 0.0292069922 0.0164171528
## [426] 0.0164171528 0.0221129370 0.0111514764 0.1489719456 0.0600022557
## [431] 0.0408448496 0.0408448496 0.0738054443 0.0435596225 0.0284664238
## [436] 0.1975808132 0.1975808132 0.1975808132 0.2201323691 0.2201323691
## [441] 0.2201323691 0.0297304091 0.0297304091 0.0121869476 0.1920687924
## [446] 0.0116421618 0.0028669260 0.1901509040 0.1273364421 0.1273364421
## [451] 0.0175474855 0.0048291293 0.0077719238 0.0254169146 0.0789038230
## [456] 0.0789038230 0.0789038230 0.1803873182 0.1803873182 0.1911349199
## [461] 0.0038287407 0.0038287407 0.1396386054 0.1396386054 0.5564522380
## [466] 0.1715518343 0.1715518343 0.1093205910 0.1322632563 0.0834424475
## [471] 0.0066964601 0.0478941716 0.0930201892 0.1218570446 0.1218570446
## [476] 0.3472309546 0.0081595695 0.1188958899 0.3161153865 0.0204277652
## [481] 0.0204277652 0.0261143824 0.0261143824 0.3633273411 0.1155027174
## [486] 0.1155027174 0.0060995195 0.3864233527 0.0282290599 0.0282290599
## [491] 0.0320006064 0.0142624706 0.0142624706 0.0142624706 0.0015962161
## [496] 0.0141130967 0.0751589023 0.0751589023 0.0751589023 0.1545424508
## [501] 0.0627197950 0.0627197950 0.0094720202 0.0094720202 0.0094720202
## [506] 0.0094720202 0.1414279290 0.0234344845 0.0273925253 0.0398019105
## [511] 0.0030032756 0.0117379210 0.0117379210 0.2839615905 0.0607433174
## [516] 0.0510520447 0.0510520447 0.0249943515 0.0249943515 0.0211322789
## [521] 0.0712727693 0.1126850390 0.0228371908 0.0228371908 0.1250587688
## [526] 0.1250587688 0.1142668203 0.0752973367 0.1144609829 0.0054326366
## [531] 0.1833636369 0.0115744294 0.5014830582 0.0801059776 0.0801059776
## [536] 0.0060538961 0.0780514494 0.3765510117 0.1903865346 0.0437358156
## [541] 0.0437358156 0.0437358156 0.0437358156 0.2973334892 0.3436662210
## [546] 0.1414708360 0.0024633090 0.0024633090 0.0504551657 0.0050777564
## [551] 0.4752854238 0.0914184877 0.0040371740 0.0040371740 0.0549792289
## [556] 0.0098358096 0.0253466178 0.0053632134 0.0053632134 0.0612565183
## [561] 0.0012780064 0.0012780064 0.0046790806 0.1793171362 0.1766479348
## [566] 0.5203874620 0.2597046953 0.0121005148 0.0817106075 0.0172000767
## [571] 0.0753565609 0.1001108082 0.0051163359 0.4209632085 0.3947422421
## [576] 0.4487515273 0.4536685390 0.2172612839 0.1058365966 0.0207429884
## [581] 0.0207429884 0.3951355624 0.0054288840 0.2592289966 0.2592289966
## [586] 0.0611569501 0.1442072180 0.0415866978 0.0415866978 0.0097775803
## [591] 0.1388132596 0.0517104020 0.0517104020 0.5544809784 0.5544809784
## [596] 0.2559922388 0.0116491615 0.0043799970 0.0101052742 0.0112517983
## [601] 0.0649396793 0.2831124623 0.0111600045 0.3066993059 0.3066993059
## [606] 0.3066993059 0.3066993059 0.3266949476 0.0390063213 0.0076650947
## [611] 0.0076650947 0.0076650947 0.0352438332 0.3518866430 0.0132736976
## [616] 0.0132736976 0.0199506224 0.0199506224 0.0022415530 0.3931492935
## [621] 0.3931492935 0.3931492935 0.0290295383 0.0290295383 0.0173443593
## [626] 0.0090556653 0.0095295441 0.0117052325 0.0117052325 0.0117052325
## [631] 0.0117052325 0.0117052325 0.1866184292 0.0101232526 0.0140461114
## [636] 0.0639761649 0.1345038923 0.2348888243 0.0023768230 0.0023768230
## [641] 0.0392579925 0.0120850584 0.0300456538 0.0300456538 0.0015295384
## [646] 0.0050328385 0.1113122391 0.0151682175 0.0151682175 0.0518010623
## [651] 0.0518010623 0.0518010623 0.0861938195 0.0994368506 0.0833702059
## [656] 0.0833702059 0.1641955327 0.0146191448 0.0146191448 0.0146191448
## [661] 0.1211077289 0.2502260937 0.0559203292 0.2446864764 0.0143278683
## [666] 0.0143278683 0.0066654168 0.0066654168 0.0974380678 0.0166946369
## [671] 0.0042645212 0.0511800402 0.0119424038 0.0119424038 0.1465013220
## [676] 0.1465013220 0.0119474836 0.0316907372 0.1186148913 0.1186148913
## [681] 0.1186148913 0.1186148913 0.0364659958 0.0068930675 0.3453046620
## [686] 0.0078619845 0.0078619845 0.0027089843 0.0561924359 0.0561924359
## [691] 0.0034972788 0.0440368616 0.0440368616 0.0440368616 0.0440368616
## [696] 0.3131830745 0.0047029511 0.0146056029 0.1266812925 0.1266812925
## [701] 0.0474936226 0.0474936226 0.0474936226 0.1339764737 0.0692651931
## [706] 0.0692651931 0.0595064284 0.0995591129 0.0995591129 0.0950512066
## [711] 0.0158728189 0.0158728189 0.4366577159 0.0050885850 0.0794846350
## [716] 0.1608433490 0.0169383355 0.1789930395 0.0119402930 0.0841916625
## [721] 0.0841916625 0.0408605945 0.0408605945 0.0408605945 0.0185480587
## [726] 0.0817376264 0.0049435531 0.0322591613 0.0598234350 0.1760570364
## [731] 0.1760570364 0.0837909210 0.3066506023 0.0113895113 0.0288613395
## [736] 0.0039501383 0.0559662710 0.1947190447 0.1947190447 0.0066407911
## [741] 0.0677615012 0.0677615012 0.0677615012 0.0677615012 0.0677615012
## [746] 0.0758484786 0.0758484786 0.0758484786 0.0719785489 0.0719785489
## [751] 0.0345780732 0.0102037507 0.0128311023 0.0236624927 0.0127635088
## [756] 0.0127635088 0.0127635088 0.0127635088 0.0034373201 0.7422457440
## [761] 0.1035096408 0.0236495458 0.5504995310 0.0106552200 0.0117464412
## [766] 0.0237524480 0.0966140447 0.0966140447 0.0125106767 0.0125106767
## [771] 0.0063009065 0.0133943151 0.0145891122 0.4876487212 0.1800625573
## [776] 0.0958419277 0.0491869252 0.1963497671 0.4028502585 0.3307194742
## [781] 0.1499046659 0.0169029452 0.0169029452 0.0723708418 0.0963556300
## [786] 0.0963556300 0.0205154534 0.0205154534 0.0131245989 0.3137736891
## [791] 0.0152562962 0.0152562962 0.0472483386 0.0179504844 0.0179504844
## [796] 0.0835105112 0.9323288478 0.1796770488 0.0577749396 0.0460132639
## [801] 0.1043490150 0.1043490150 0.0502688247 0.0502688247 0.1970730479
## [806] 0.0416368132 0.0416368132 0.0039136586 0.0078487668 0.0078487668
## [811] 0.0165666323 0.0165666323 0.0590780094 0.2655120140 0.0063620673
## [816] 0.0063620673 0.0921895588 0.0039158220 0.0059109339 0.0039158220
## [821] 0.0703375135 0.0951732772 0.0178438529 0.0132604980 0.0032009392
## [826] 0.0050252345 0.0096408550 0.1187338496 0.0290140502 0.0069533811
## [831] 0.0204050042 0.1738272735 0.1738272735 0.1738272735 0.0086463642
## [836] 0.0086463642 0.0408913685 0.0134089517 0.0134089517 0.1817155572
## [841] 0.2236155659 0.0158925348 0.0317643218 0.0317643218 0.0144676678
## [846] 0.0218040950 0.0218040950 0.0218040950 0.0532053565 0.0532053565
## [851] 0.1449352205 0.0507439128 0.0016612547 0.0016612547 0.0016612547
## [856] 0.5648825884 0.0035803879 0.4690367407 0.0942797866 0.0016786526
## [861] 0.0016786526 0.0659725920 0.0659725920 0.0447070884 0.0447070884
## [866] 0.0408349345 0.1977480140 0.0868883874 0.0313897193 0.0108171707
## [871] 0.0153417383 0.1584683276 0.0172159719 0.0554241723 0.0135791322
## [876] 0.0182537161 0.0191574029 0.0313403310 0.0689293730 0.0054907610
## [881] 0.3360347985 0.0113101192 0.0326618218 0.0326618218 0.0835441723
## [886] 0.2584173085 0.0920425119 0.1963509040 0.3997499030 0.3997499030
## [891] 0.1209131086 0.0275860329 0.0101798710 0.0453169140 0.0120582635
## [896] 0.0028910504 0.0028910504 0.0155993036 0.0129636079 0.0966663994
## [901] 0.0966663994 0.0966663994 0.2391356755 0.0976364443 0.3626238952
## [906] 0.1353397009 0.2846813368 0.2846813368 0.0203188862 0.5162120065
## [911] 0.0093059873 0.0093059873 0.0148378873 0.1072517125 0.1072517125
## [916] 0.0530142650 0.0451365363 0.0152880394 0.0317301462 0.1154721745
## [921] 0.1154721745 0.1154721745 0.1154721745 0.1154721745 0.0676567949
## [926] 0.0676567949 0.0676567949 0.0676567949 0.0692414523 0.0692414523
## [931] 0.0096696013 0.0962693291 0.1207396624 0.0444210382 0.0850734624
## [936] 0.0850734624 0.0620672225 0.0620672225 0.3205811300 0.3205811300
## [941] 0.3205811300 0.0034619932 0.0259252046 0.0244679522 0.0259252046
## [946] 0.0957793133 0.1088050900 0.2365200061 0.2365200061 0.0827477732
## [951] 0.0027868360 0.0822074872 0.1228562010 0.3416681082 0.0623870193
## [956] 0.0623870193 0.0784703366 0.0862447238 0.0098902430 0.0029406399
## [961] 0.0541253073 0.0541253073 0.0541253073 0.0245132671 0.1010330609
## [966] 0.0052466925 0.3843609592 0.3843609592 0.0139651388 0.0030122843
## [971] 0.4003126568 0.0160983148 0.0160983148 0.0160983148 0.1610224548
## [976] 0.0028871391 0.0270065720 0.0270065720 0.0270065720 0.0270065720
## [981] 0.0975285166 0.0844522829 0.0015354832 0.0015354832 0.0015354832
## [986] 0.4699849864 0.0651689168 0.0837920777 0.3216691695 0.0089233712
## [991] 0.0300425668 0.0300425668 0.0300425668 0.0788470480 0.0180812630
## [996] 0.2843099632 0.0236827817 0.0236827817 0.0236827817 0.0386329416
## [1001] 0.7638946518 0.1787503484 0.1787503484 0.1787503484 0.0502966957
## [1006] 0.0047520179 0.0047520179 0.0047520179 0.0066948394 0.4265655860
## [1011] 0.0259008338 0.2789670914 0.0259328943 0.0365223100 0.0476461926
## [1016] 0.0476461926 0.0743733770 0.0743733770 0.0670973218 0.0670973218
## [1021] 0.0043841900 0.0043841900 0.6760432471 0.0078306856 0.1005029751
## [1026] 0.0173530850 0.0322162360 0.4551595049 0.4551595049 0.1289872058
## [1031] 0.1289872058 0.0057744590 0.0057744590 0.0057744590 0.0057886684
## [1036] 0.0897219504 0.0897219504 0.4295348994 0.4295348994 0.0044916761
## [1041] 0.0152166961 0.0783488417 0.0783488417 0.1071529646 0.1789458675
## [1046] 0.4003894822 0.0560399417 0.0041175213 0.0760484605 0.0760484605
## [1051] 0.1865578405 0.1445339986 0.0173475522 0.0064385451 0.0064385451
## [1056] 0.0064385451 0.0117514053 0.1512648650 0.0272756201 0.0061096066
## [1061] 0.0040458995 0.0283256234 0.0177755126 0.0177755126 0.0299212556
## [1066] 0.5809697490 0.0043479536 0.0580974899 0.2303470429 0.1564206178
## [1071] 0.0121644533 0.0786338787 0.0044616112 0.0050449129 0.0089787249
## [1076] 0.0310717261 0.0273274194 0.0273274194 0.0335201808 0.1503996863
## [1081] 0.1503996863 0.0124394057 0.0442564716 0.0045632336 0.0045632336
## [1086] 0.0149334255 0.0548603726 0.0548603726 0.0267878900 0.0267878900
## [1091] 0.0258485287 0.0930165930 0.0403414153 0.0016451726 0.1026868829
## [1096] 0.1026868829 0.2715976254 0.0633697049 0.2716745687 0.2460146950
## [1101] 0.0253406939 0.0253406939 0.0533129343 0.5903570393 0.1406536627
## [1106] 0.0351274384 0.0755651700 0.3282981804 0.0215864062 0.0174561833
## [1111] 0.0174561833 0.5355049454 0.0417929733 0.2355399095 0.0178089383
## [1116] 0.0178089383 0.0178089383 0.0178089383 0.4123519906 0.4123519906
## [1121] 0.2129661154 0.2341715125 0.0108085606 0.0981346274 0.1721880046
## [1126] 0.1721880046 0.1680166812 0.0698291378 0.0698291378 0.0638873135
## [1131] 0.0140350863 0.0140350863 0.0024126521 0.0039261437 0.0039261437
## [1136] 0.5358291989 0.2217194695 0.2217194695 0.0199503619 0.2263621630
## [1141] 0.0192799432 0.1068010791 0.1980461296 0.1068010791 0.0214194293
## [1146] 0.1055001381 0.5610228842 0.1033809288 0.3575075582 0.3575075582
## [1151] 0.3575075582 0.0496316073 0.2023769313 0.0236464403 0.0027712095
## [1156] 0.0027712095 0.5358627714 0.1538061826 0.1538061826 0.0022244245
## [1161] 0.0051823865 0.0451270859 0.0496922887 0.0201866845 0.6108383626
## [1166] 0.7051836778 0.0848655835 0.0848655835 0.0848655835 0.0052145910
## [1171] 0.0770473432 0.0770473432 0.0770473432 0.0028957788 0.0223209299
## [1176] 0.5002957746 0.0994271454 0.0152309370 0.0168271660 0.0168271660
## [1181] 0.1144174932 0.1144174932 0.1144174932 0.0054156292 0.0329800861
## [1186] 0.0022570472 0.0022570472 0.1525623097 0.0541293525 0.0023867871
## [1191] 0.0023867871 0.0023867871 0.0023867871 0.1109619157 0.1109619157
## [1196] 0.5581625523 0.0676133409 0.0676133409 0.0676133409 0.1851913739
## [1201] 0.0690145504 0.0125011517 0.0066617165 0.0066617165 0.1085055319
## [1206] 0.1085055319 0.1085055319 0.0035127251 0.2628173811 0.0152621500
## [1211] 0.0152621500 0.0152621500 0.2802496778 0.0337950473 0.0078067241
## [1216] 0.0078067241 0.2728938031 0.0062639077 0.3481821148 0.0123266008
## [1221] 0.0123266008 0.0031496592 0.0061330276 0.0061330276 0.4362836811
## [1226] 0.4362836811 0.0059361748 0.1832090244 0.0059761170 0.0059761170
## [1231] 0.0079164832 0.0014290700 0.0014290700 0.1048233154 0.0409892332
## [1236] 0.0543144567 0.1006474300 0.1006474300 0.0204687155 0.0245313117
## [1241] 0.1027781368 0.1027781368 0.0089267497 0.2559801409 0.0020563814
## [1246] 0.0020563814 0.0145537432 0.4321299724 0.0168059441 0.0168059441
## [1251] 0.0154019284 0.0154019284 0.0154019284 0.0154019284 0.0066482763
## [1256] 0.0249841631 0.0249841631 0.0027305505 0.0027305505 0.0027305505
## [1261] 0.0027305505 0.0762905032 0.0323900676 0.0323900676 0.0453379784
## [1266] 0.5266667942 0.0231508492 0.0231508492 0.0709175997 0.0709175997
## [1271] 0.0044369375 0.1384091036 0.0118858452 0.0118858452 0.1610924192
## [1276] 0.3232013125 0.0101163890 0.0101163890 0.0058932395 0.0058932395
## [1281] 0.0163379506 0.0163379506 0.0163379506 0.2886965228 0.2886965228
## [1286] 0.2886965228 0.0441402458 0.0351895136 0.4377327818 0.0367282424
## [1291] 0.7420397593 0.0544577561 0.2014923112 0.1373516806 0.1942728543
## [1296] 0.1064844254 0.4869048725 0.0508806113 0.0508806113 0.0823463181
## [1301] 0.3880439428 0.0660251124 0.0660251124 0.0966028428 0.0966028428
## [1306] 0.1195506947 0.1195506947 0.1704724610 0.1704724610 0.1704724610
## [1311] 0.0147798820 0.0274612677 0.0274612677 0.0274612677 0.1264828265
## [1316] 0.1264828265 0.1264828265 0.0366823742 0.0665247288 0.0665247288
## [1321] 0.0206184487 0.3537385437 0.0764911876 0.0283355051 0.0283355051
## [1326] 0.0283355051 0.0031804053 0.0128974981 0.0461469288 0.0461469288
## [1331] 0.0174709287 0.0174709287 0.2114403498 0.0294251196 0.0294251196
## [1336] 0.4899530414 0.4899530414 0.3789364527 0.0040883421 0.0262650215
## [1341] 0.0226889378 0.3655523012 0.0847844996 0.0343847468 0.2274009734
## [1346] 0.0094760831 0.0043119001 0.0152191464 0.0152191464 0.0191007866
## [1351] 0.0028309793 0.0028309793 0.3584736396 0.0495831787 0.1436513716
## [1356] 0.1996832076 0.2048948993 0.0109158465 0.0082399284 0.0079678021
## [1361] 0.1597144110 0.0364275701 0.4723986927 0.0889505095 0.0889505095
## [1366] 0.0209456633 0.0237087567 0.0735234690 0.0885085112 0.0131067182
## [1371] 0.0031419242 0.0431743112 0.0070188687 0.0070188687 0.0070188687
## [1376] 0.0070188687 0.0609550368 0.0069106741 0.0142740180 0.0332439181
## [1381] 0.0118739276 0.0239748255 0.0239748255 0.7302332219 0.0065344328
## [1386] 0.0065344328 0.0065344328 0.0476379590 0.0476379590 0.0476379590
## [1391] 0.0055467856 0.0055467856 0.0055467856 0.1021003521 0.0092166066
## [1396] 0.0137409335 0.0135930200 0.0129100103 0.0200516140 0.0417948723
## [1401] 0.0417948723 0.0756135120 0.0337483851 0.0337483851 0.0093615773
## [1406] 0.1472779675 0.1314546689 0.0434905040 0.0101087602 0.1986757021
## [1411] 0.1986757021 0.1478728065 0.0150268477 0.0071558623 0.0071558623
## [1416] 0.0071558623 0.0160885424 0.0032703871 0.0032703871 0.1720359580
## [1421] 0.1369781451 0.1369781451 0.3713210227 0.1699793692 0.5514449507
## [1426] 0.6815010141 0.2101949704 0.1798891229 0.0087807137 0.0087807137
## [1431] 0.0087807137 0.0087807137 0.1853479722 0.0758610716 0.1739832564
## [1436] 0.1739832564 0.1739832564 0.2417431435 0.0248645322 0.0248645322
## [1441] 0.1263571052 0.0277307655 0.0079590206 0.0079590206 0.0079590206
## [1446] 0.0600392895 0.0058491636 0.0058491636 0.0058491636 0.5041687510
## [1451] 0.1803398586 0.0105476472 0.0105476472 0.0105476472 0.1835987409
## [1456] 0.0373544251 0.0063501577 0.0063501577 0.0063501577 0.0063501577
## [1461] 0.0063501577 0.0033328285 0.0113381988 0.0113381988 0.2840665506
## [1466] 0.2840665506 0.0651768475 0.1589488268 0.0204130912 0.0204130912
## [1471] 0.0204130912 0.0594396818 0.0046752512 0.0955462450 0.0128645596
## [1476] 0.0188505854 0.2093131745 0.2093131745 0.0200868810 0.1104147766
## [1481] 0.1104147766 0.1104147766 0.0027658895 0.4207149977 0.0024683609
## [1486] 0.2124404462 0.0048391291 0.1336035464 0.1867318007 0.1867318007
## [1491] 0.0018537505 0.0018537505 0.0018537505 0.0647584140 0.0647584140
## [1496] 0.1193600913 0.1896575919 0.0605416936 0.1539494840 0.0158453992
## [1501] 0.0158453992 0.1029540692 0.1351257310 0.1351257310 0.0181747053
## [1506] 0.3422237316 0.2115467856 0.0373392368 0.0373392368 0.0136966346
## [1511] 0.1268652413 0.0317187163 0.1515546401 0.1176066886 0.1176066886
## [1516] 0.1206765129 0.0270754118 0.0270754118 0.0270754118 0.0024564053
## [1521] 0.0024564053 0.0024564053 0.0024564053 0.0887265041 0.1445204721
## [1526] 0.0035731027 0.0035731027 0.0959710524 0.0058393815 0.0513739095
## [1531] 0.0513739095 0.0215101520 0.0296762920 0.0296762920 0.1555892508
## [1536] 0.0044639112 0.0044639112 0.0044639112 0.0044639112 0.1160393081
## [1541] 0.1160393081 0.1319969938 0.0086856028 0.0188814011 0.0188814011
## [1546] 0.0210054996 0.0210054996 0.1723436633 0.0038774046 0.0038774046
## [1551] 0.0038774046 0.0038774046 0.1073281149 0.0050849814 0.0050849814
## [1556] 0.2730552878 0.4708462492 0.3081739605 0.0307832168 0.0307832168
## [1561] 0.2870317577 0.0294645140 0.0083660356 0.0106856969 0.0384181484
## [1566] 0.0384181484 0.0258472751 0.0364519428 0.0238603686 0.1151570805
## [1571] 0.6894067804 0.0429816281 0.0021367764 0.0021367764 0.0021367764
## [1576] 0.0739802298 0.0074758549 0.0074758549 0.0593764504 0.0173732645
## [1581] 0.0414030673 0.5171914126 0.4524870908 0.2051472954 0.1150411892
## [1586] 0.0135498706 0.0835123429 0.0089945692 0.3673421811 0.0072235975
## [1591] 0.0649465482 0.0258729701 0.3499296115 0.3499296115 0.0186698875
## [1596] 0.2251722344 0.0253457648 0.0858581379 0.0600290794 0.0562139645
## [1601] 0.0571332189 0.0567071251 0.0125201307 0.0272347363 0.0155230551
## [1606] 0.0775860346 0.2847420990 0.0899037314 0.0051865472 0.0983304875
## [1611] 0.0466972955 0.2115942320 0.2018100277 0.0197956200 0.3094756576
## [1616] 0.3094756576 0.3094756576 0.4527053618 0.0128111296 0.0117164871
## [1621] 0.0076815624 0.0076815624 0.1457524813 0.1488903997 0.4420701091
## [1626] 0.0485767213 0.0485767213 0.0277625998 0.0277625998 0.0685524698
## [1631] 0.0685524698 0.2008764393 0.2008764393 0.2008764393 0.0159196012
## [1636] 0.0971778804 0.0438342789 0.0438342789 0.0176524044 0.2741306599
## [1641] 0.0191086257 0.0191086257 0.0191086257 0.0031892105 0.0322255773
## [1646] 0.0485690761 0.0485690761 0.0485690761 0.0485690761 0.1409438470
## [1651] 0.0034177361 0.0444101901 0.0334647954 0.0612413698 0.0612413698
## [1656] 0.0224408975 0.0104657212 0.0104657212 0.0236624704 0.0642911367
## [1661] 0.0286156682 0.0286156682 0.0091701666 0.0091701666 0.0182489872
## [1666] 0.0592766275 0.0057269177 0.0057269177 0.0057269177 0.0025570074
## [1671] 0.0011717641 0.3064124379 0.0175718067 0.3344907692 0.3344907692
## [1676] 0.3804710693 0.0419100655 0.0697055952 0.0497294038 0.3220835521
## [1681] 0.3728468354 0.1520269895 0.1520269895 0.0265551769 0.1019168022
## [1686] 0.0591276271 0.0591276271 0.0786605894 0.0211882573 0.0068950976
## [1691] 0.0271984408 0.0665529285 0.0987303307 0.0987303307 0.0987303307
## [1696] 0.0305548432 0.0402132047 0.0402132047 0.0402132047 0.2424753333
## [1701] 0.2424753333 0.0029860391 0.0029860391 0.0029860391 0.0026154181
## [1706] 0.0026154181 0.5027154868 0.0843539438 0.0024560603 0.3129683519
## [1711] 0.0056840563 0.5322187661 0.0887014714 0.1221591670 0.1192331277
## [1716] 0.1221591670 0.0083792817 0.1374703889 0.0246300468 0.0246300468
## [1721] 0.0082738003 0.0492631486 0.0492631486 0.5509623882 0.3055366125
## [1726] 0.3055366125 0.0189008928 0.0615452282 0.3897189772 0.0182055204
## [1731] 0.0327556269 0.1413888014 0.3825418525 0.1586068064 0.0438319492
## [1736] 0.0438319492 0.0438319492 0.0247573074 0.0179932376 0.0179932376
## [1741] 0.3446910446 0.0121016596 0.0807348688 0.1102697602 0.0055997621
## [1746] 0.0316272765 0.0316272765 0.0316272765 0.0061491959 0.0455902273
## [1751] 0.1494265818 0.0370576364 0.0265381268 0.0951733376 0.0951733376
## [1756] 0.0951733376 0.0416486579 0.0416486579 0.0042216463 0.0973768951
## [1761] 0.2876349907 0.2876349907 0.3770980050 0.0008685074 0.0008740645
## [1766] 0.0022144916 0.0107269029 0.0107269029 0.0107269029 0.3734062876
## [1771] 0.0333485171 0.0565405363 0.0173248597 0.0173248597 0.0411444998
## [1776] 0.0079898540 0.6157231109 0.0592856193 0.0592856193 0.1443750149
## [1781] 0.2685813900 0.2685813900 0.1111615346 0.1079687274 0.3439338342
## [1786] 0.3712337216 0.1900912450 0.0101266589 0.0101266589 0.0124905880
## [1791] 0.0251176272 0.0110283534 0.0877380592 0.3270242958 0.1711671141
## [1796] 0.0431965597 0.2072528511 0.0625291973 0.1139824616 0.0146511928
## [1801] 0.0426239189 0.0426239189 0.0197518875 0.0197518875 0.0197518875
## [1806] 0.0080644836 0.0051079489 0.0133807666 0.0133807666 0.0033412170
## [1811] 0.3425131057 0.1277246481 0.1175862924 0.1175862924 0.1175862924
## [1816] 0.0509976068 0.0613132060 0.0613132060 0.2593442835 0.2593442835
## [1821] 0.2593442835 0.0762821302 0.0369887338 0.0454125101 0.1639020516
## [1826] 0.1444026016 0.0065942038 0.0938363208 0.0938363208 0.2159859481
## [1831] 0.0035452915 0.0035452915 0.4293018743 0.2381727680 0.0419552777
## [1836] 0.3571439500 0.1763947821 0.0026066975 0.1310483716 0.0314308900
## [1841] 0.0190713860 0.1000397210 0.2875431884 0.0038548542 0.4757448859
## [1846] 0.4757448859 0.1597936068 0.1597936068 0.1597936068 0.1607515830
## [1851] 0.0086802500 0.0173796992 0.0905338586 0.0905338586 0.0148662596
## [1856] 0.0831493342 0.4812560907 0.0842090786 0.0482189217 0.0213311648
## [1861] 0.0225434196 0.0116861103 0.0305388274 0.0238763047 0.5044588822
## [1866] 0.5290208419 0.0947696617 0.0947696617 0.1363888488 0.0183908562
## [1871] 0.0070191577 0.0071071067 0.0071071067 0.2013960823 0.0124317160
## [1876] 0.1245325367 0.2008012633 0.2008012633 0.2008012633 0.2008012633
## [1881] 0.1586952885 0.0044209686 0.1601699180 0.0154426212 0.0154426212
## [1886] 0.1564481593 0.1346553158 0.0143638838 0.0176396219 0.1799641903
## [1891] 0.0175054399 0.0018787886 0.1145944405 0.1145944405 0.1145944405
## [1896] 0.1899407766 0.0365440227 0.0365440227 0.0058355582 0.0195088801
## [1901] 0.0195088801 0.1616040932 0.1616040932 0.0203710753 0.0049211153
## [1906] 0.0566270194 0.1497911677 0.0127611917 0.0127611917 0.0127611917
## [1911] 0.0127611917 0.4857948756 0.0170960113 0.0170960113 0.0024476276
## [1916] 0.2396299219 0.2396299219 0.2396299219 0.2396299219 0.2396299219
## [1921] 0.0187098825 0.0163033450 0.0475560554 0.0475560554 0.0335959569
## [1926] 0.3091281940 0.0058711492 0.0667493958 0.1208971058 0.3627057317
## [1931] 0.1653085009 0.0067356503 0.0067356503 0.0067356503 0.1234972079
## [1936] 0.1234972079 0.0589222909 0.0589222909 0.0051741071 0.0028880391
## [1941] 0.0028880391 0.0028880391 0.0132149263 0.0624819975 0.0111241549
## [1946] 0.0111241549 0.0111241549 0.0202900572 0.1715727289 0.1330236153
## [1951] 0.1330236153 0.0134009763 0.0134009763 0.0935873005 0.5591278638
## [1956] 0.4237987921 0.4237987921 0.4237987921 0.4237987921 0.0041207130
## [1961] 0.0041207130 0.1510902921 0.0755481075 0.0061007762 0.0218335356
## [1966] 0.3916315381 0.0769890930 0.6565501583 0.1888967813 0.0199188312
## [1971] 0.0199188312 0.1049262853 0.0135831297 0.1309419873 0.0046095856
## [1976] 0.0046095856 0.0046095856 0.0046095856 0.0046095856 0.0714740167
## [1981] 0.0714740167 0.0117843774 0.0117843774 0.0038633656 0.0502086046
## [1986] 0.0322851728 0.0322851728 0.0625545869 0.0272612804 0.0272612804
## [1991] 0.0272612804 0.0310742431 0.0854976192 0.0772636452 0.0772636452
## [1996] 0.0772636452 0.0105860867 0.0606536986 0.3014877649 0.0174043849
## [2001] 0.0137354665 0.0255771036 0.0255771036 0.0255771036 0.0921514456
## [2006] 0.1138484850 0.0021191348 0.0021191348 0.1798548143 0.1214407834
## [2011] 0.1214407834 0.0012934202 0.0513789088 0.0806306867 0.1322421274
## [2016] 0.0936279224 0.0095512009 0.0095512009 0.1988178649 0.1098923165
## [2021] 0.0197927217 0.0062450908 0.0063385821 0.0063385821 0.0063385821
## [2026] 0.0063385821 0.1832560963 0.0209531450 0.0110682345 0.0960208386
## [2031] 0.0260368917 0.0260368917 0.0260368917 0.0136824178 0.0136824178
## [2036] 0.0136824178 0.2297696134 0.2297696134 0.2297696134 0.2632176438
## [2041] 0.0520389649 0.1904285626 0.0710203045 0.0710203045 0.0250484080
## [2046] 0.0994914126 0.2132733543 0.0265774327 0.0265774327 0.4080365203
## [2051] 0.0842042071 0.0652709965 0.1437341782 0.1437341782 0.1437341782
## [2056] 0.0086002753 0.0086002753 0.0086002753 0.0086002753 0.0414735844
## [2061] 0.0023788998 0.0061147351 0.0310546025 0.0310546025 0.0310546025
## [2066] 0.0033421061 0.0033421061 0.0033421061 0.3925720648 0.0154959517
## [2071] 0.0154959517 0.0942969958 0.0942969958 0.0130346265 0.0058859661
## [2076] 0.0058859661 0.0151396521 0.3268257542 0.2367653445 0.0239465794
## [2081] 0.0239465794 0.0025799521 0.0233473889 0.0233473889 0.0762951726
## [2086] 0.1534959247 0.1534959247 0.0557763157 0.0573649703 0.0573649703
## [2091] 0.0041109586 0.0822392545 0.1150780423 0.1431008751 0.1007523767
## [2096] 0.0829271056 0.0407680341 0.0061520362 0.0204085901 0.3253899505
## [2101] 0.0177025813 0.0177025813 0.1021650102 0.0258570783 0.0258570783
## [2106] 0.1794899302 0.1794899302 0.0385916630 0.0693730510 0.0693730510
## [2111] 0.2694610246 0.0139254058 0.0139254058 0.0139254058 0.0169043302
## [2116] 0.1475495943 0.0134758013 0.0046206073 0.0859986977 0.0859986977
## [2121] 0.3700587547 0.3700587547 0.3700587547 0.3700587547 0.3700587547
## [2126] 0.0548145021 0.4271034411 0.2462181207 0.2462181207 0.0845638425
## [2131] 0.0845638425 0.0845638425 0.0290640582 0.0290640582 0.0290640582
## [2136] 0.0290640582 0.0106745191 0.0050561379 0.1165954095 0.1165954095
## [2141] 0.0060884088 0.0059115903 0.0229479785 0.0229479785 0.0575327920
## [2146] 0.0575327920 0.0079643359 0.0188215475 0.0256462796 0.1443584929
## [2151] 0.0443847115 0.0443847115 0.1932624883 0.1932624883 0.0121077405
## [2156] 0.1981465737 0.0323229472 0.0323229472 0.0323229472 0.0136094041
## [2161] 0.0136094041 0.4225007524 0.2077509216 0.2077509216 0.0053562041
## [2166] 0.0053562041 0.3581361574 0.0028554195 0.0093708663 0.0093708663
## [2171] 0.0093708663 0.0985216866 0.1028059665 0.1095416632 0.3896479079
## [2176] 0.0553556108 0.0620410425 0.0264681521 0.0264681521 0.0034199640
## [2181] 0.0034199640 0.0289168497 0.1424117642 0.0051829381 0.1307644231
## [2186] 0.0545358154 0.0545358154 0.0545358154 0.0283277646 0.0034046932
## [2191] 0.0446211377 0.0624433280 0.1116849549 0.0361421747 0.0361421747
## [2196] 0.0361421747 0.0096253236 0.1157156852 0.0058445589 0.0058445589
## [2201] 0.3793957112 0.3793957112 0.0042669932 0.0042669932 0.0078200717
## [2206] 0.0193134821 0.0213363325 0.0066629196 0.0058116944 0.0981000354
## [2211] 0.0981000354 0.0824924631 0.0824924631 0.0801475950 0.0801475950
## [2216] 0.0801475950 0.1068418252 0.0292929426 0.0414678416 0.0414678416
## [2221] 0.0468222360 0.0468222360 0.0027917446 0.0066291236 0.0111779782
## [2226] 0.2088082393 0.0206321199 0.0795226270 0.0168889924 0.0792782076
## [2231] 0.0466197190 0.0923138790 0.0923138790 0.0923138790 0.0923138790
## [2236] 0.6116986957 0.0178867754 0.0358092160 0.1209217620 0.1209217620
## [2241] 0.0167958061 0.0167958061 0.0169700259 0.0490851213 0.0490851213
## [2246] 0.0032729565 0.0032729565 0.0832578382 0.0384158526 0.2105591386
## [2251] 0.2004828837 0.0240099722 0.0994750987 0.0457511634 0.0479073149
## [2256] 0.0479073149 0.0479073149 0.0479073149 0.1520373544 0.0016934730
## [2261] 0.0016803404 0.0016803404 0.0038042399 0.0041692051 0.0082207833
## [2266] 0.0370008366 0.0153371380 0.0146205579 0.0186503073 0.0186503073
## [2271] 0.1117003598 0.1761346286 0.1556571329 0.3520523019 0.3520523019
## [2276] 0.1401417049 0.1401417049 0.0060546527 0.1993439606 0.0946944465
## [2281] 0.2963358981 0.0435904561 0.0435904561 0.2473319873 0.0497102947
## [2286] 0.0497102947 0.0497102947 0.1315916925 0.0436906379 0.0436906379
## [2291] 0.5234761931 0.0391605794 0.0391605794 0.0862870212 0.0862870212
## [2296] 0.0299702484 0.0299702484 0.0299702484 0.0212220052 0.0213822798
## [2301] 0.0190406036 0.0190406036 0.0190406036 0.0125147015 0.0338219560
## [2306] 0.2993042469 0.0023359949 0.0023359949 0.0881711532 0.0684060217
## [2311] 0.1032873452 0.0711844867 0.3581770472 0.0689272106 0.0689272106
## [2316] 0.0036342610 0.2755252628 0.1114239606 0.1114239606 0.0683406843
## [2321] 0.0255747227 0.0076427050 0.2542225420 0.0731335735 0.0116750341
## [2326] 0.0167244665 0.0368276019 0.0180021168 0.0180021168 0.3767581548
## [2331] 0.0659794094 0.0068752345 0.0410523993 0.0064012823 0.0194286125
## [2336] 0.0194286125 0.0194286125 0.0194286125 0.0159204687 0.0043213259
## [2341] 0.1782647781 0.1782647781 0.1066292912 0.1066292912 0.0653890255
## [2346] 0.1739725452 0.1038242934 0.1150852813 0.1150852813 0.0100579294
## [2351] 0.0100579294 0.0064802085 0.0254201013 0.0407964584 0.0407964584
## [2356] 0.0237431609 0.3118388335 0.3118388335 0.1195876238 0.0784254007
## [2361] 0.0988067338 0.0988067338 0.0215055431 0.2961326568 0.4179894153
## [2366] 0.0183665664 0.1818689458 0.0416863839 0.0416863839 0.0416863839
## [2371] 0.0416863839 0.1150579721 0.0914266819 0.2850516572 0.1038071475
## [2376] 0.1552986496 0.0130489115 0.0482916255 0.0184165311 0.0184165311
## [2381] 0.0909881834 0.1801003435 0.0088241706 0.0923117214 0.6441833385
## [2386] 0.0767338883 0.0136841232 0.0227813767 0.0692502597 0.0161359584
## [2391] 0.0603398723 0.1521101021 0.0984023779 0.0265554417 0.0648557613
## [2396] 0.0789182070 0.0049794301 0.0049794301 0.0127875213 0.1033436000
## [2401] 0.0369229434 0.0369229434 0.0369229434 0.1679891663 0.0396235001
## [2406] 0.0396235001 0.0396235001 0.0396235001 0.0943813928 0.0621723408
## [2411] 0.4099117411 0.5835881214 0.0218863616 0.0208282698 0.5028091510
## [2416] 0.3330225193 0.0650073737 0.3116815467 0.0317820789 0.1239856388
## [2421] 0.2854564412 0.1193934968 0.1526870008 0.1526870008 0.6127225571
## [2426] 0.6130982696 0.1352418875 0.1887997973 0.1728459971 0.1728459971
## [2431] 0.0988246853 0.1189394488 0.1189394488 0.1189394488 0.0952634415
## [2436] 0.0092908033 0.2780992740 0.1048344998 0.1048344998 0.0843323149
## [2441] 0.0974395055 0.1027594281 0.0042025819 0.0221524205 0.0311882693
## [2446] 0.0251371955 0.0340104730 0.1283601106 0.1283601106 0.2217907207
## [2451] 0.0936388252 0.1449895548 0.0482090383 0.0355111074 0.0975178105
## [2456] 0.1586878187 0.0703683317 0.0312109480 0.1656942441 0.2818919031
## [2461] 0.0037184242 0.0374658233 0.2657774360 0.1766572137 0.1962291070
## [2466] 0.0241364635 0.0241364635 0.4761745309 0.0079685213 0.0079685213
## [2471] 0.2391033050 0.2391033050 0.2391033050 0.0370842928 0.0370842928
## [2476] 0.1006684262 0.1006684262 0.0245748777 0.0027863438 0.2312643347
## [2481] 0.6862081532 0.0032229082 0.0032229082 0.0330002290 0.0133337310
## [2486] 0.0133337310 0.0375387177 0.1613656717 0.1203989538 0.1203989538
## [2491] 0.0084879621 0.0064171833 0.3949631040 0.5806994526 0.0452548095
## [2496] 0.2013168108 0.0976761071 0.0976761071 0.0538388287 0.1609398579
## [2501] 0.1609398579 0.1690196826 0.1690196826 0.1690196826 0.1285910754
## [2506] 0.0031304587 0.2478305340 0.1735468455 0.0591217523 0.0279043801
## [2511] 0.0190985915 0.0771216891 0.0110859774 0.0167892108 0.0761978843
## [2516] 0.2724187332 0.0807654767 0.1452936055 0.0366853839 0.1897801938
## [2521] 0.2134323450 0.2134323450 0.2134323450 0.0623573288 0.0623573288
## [2526] 0.1998198184 0.0232200700 0.1766231196 0.0068169811 0.1153126458
## [2531] 0.2358658171 0.0499995280 0.0499995280 0.0499995280 0.0499995280
## [2536] 0.0760821926 0.0760821926 0.2505008004 0.3060485296 0.3060485296
## [2541] 0.0104528868 0.0766291567 0.0134525940 0.1305888450 0.1305888450
## [2546] 0.1305888450 0.0298260407 0.3334280850 0.3334280850 0.0344479222
## [2551] 0.0119816112 0.0106346511 0.0045359695 0.1096314118 0.0548951505
## [2556] 0.0545228281 0.0619139379 0.0619139379 0.0761502902 0.0761502902
## [2561] 0.0608753876 0.1172004500 0.0059499569 0.0059499569 0.0660343888
## [2566] 0.0660343888 0.2000962170 0.0879584500 0.3293418877 0.3809454143
## [2571] 0.0820296621 0.0820296621 0.3444113927 0.0097411776 0.0168528006
## [2576] 0.0570414375 0.0092281943 0.0092281943 0.0092281943 0.0723671343
## [2581] 0.1140144846 0.0239857854 0.0239857854 0.0239857854 0.2451655142
## [2586] 0.2451655142 0.0986266910 0.2361263667 0.2361263667 0.1048882646
## [2591] 0.0130826664 0.0200228976 0.0066203127 0.0066203127 0.0333623180
## [2596] 0.0044438095 0.0044438095 0.0044438095 0.0044438095 0.0044438095
## [2601] 0.0189882128 0.0189882128 0.0189882128 0.0019489954 0.2489535382
## [2606] 0.0327522181 0.0327522181 0.1229779358 0.0813682192 0.0154236580
## [2611] 0.0039281356 0.0154236580 0.0351936016 0.0314752864 0.0576641384
## [2616] 0.0576641384 0.0663020224 0.0663020224 0.1051530401 0.1051530401
## [2621] 0.0604979021 0.0604979021 0.1507986837 0.1215081580 0.1335720416
## [2626] 0.1276769124 0.1276769124 0.0034923126 0.0034923126 0.0419953570
## [2631] 0.3588767326 0.0084569633 0.3111688201 0.1130795457 0.1181613201
## [2636] 0.1181613201 0.1181613201 0.0147923554 0.0147923554 0.0779552844
## [2641] 0.2900782233 0.2900782233 0.0623525748 0.0623525748 0.0305287179
## [2646] 0.2923033790 0.0043461009 0.0583825491 0.0990420723 0.0115908134
## [2651] 0.0089713487 0.3121993923 0.0159412332 0.0159412332 0.1160193277
## [2656] 0.1021052906 0.1021052906 0.3258254985 0.3258254985 0.3258254985
## [2661] 0.3258254985 0.0077262741 0.0077262741 0.1611030313 0.3152805656
## [2666] 0.0090613145 0.2960307607 0.0070237356 0.0070237356 0.0082661588
## [2671] 0.0082661588 0.0323744511 0.0050295705 0.0050295705 0.0095242537
## [2676] 0.1111646840 0.1111646840 0.1111646840 0.0165589005 0.0165589005
## [2681] 0.0040337381 0.1451669936 0.0107820656 0.1429869600 0.0043827455
## [2686] 0.0046243316 0.1503340628 0.3771424081 0.1958583579 0.0047841445
## [2691] 0.0047841445 0.0081061928 0.0081061928 0.0081061928 0.1865207341
## [2696] 0.4613724546 0.1491181495 0.1946436052 0.0668503394 0.0767547807
## [2701] 0.3170244495 0.0370319067 0.0305890954 0.0305890954 0.0305890954
## [2706] 0.0305890954 0.0131952231 0.0679314430 0.0047115356 0.0811897559
## [2711] 0.0131631178 0.0131631178 0.0131631178 0.2013452895 0.0293985756
## [2716] 0.0293985756 0.0293985756 0.1927306261 0.2551569974 0.4303068911
## [2721] 0.0188339346 0.1247444701 0.2001170647 0.0574422949 0.0988906416
## [2726] 0.0021684257 0.0434134094 0.0434134094 0.0418126804 0.0406123838
## [2731] 0.0321370649 0.0087765319 0.0087765319 0.0087765319 0.0741515929
## [2736] 0.0741515929 0.0741515929 0.0741515929 0.1695498571 0.1695498571
## [2741] 0.1695498571 0.1695498571 0.0109932724 0.0109932724 0.1677231480
## [2746] 0.0108974885 0.0058327972 0.2586166304 0.0207952056 0.0207952056
## [2751] 0.0163795974 0.0142789881 0.0113036242 0.0046339982 0.6336086949
## [2756] 0.6336086949 0.0552855275 0.0719250334 0.0719250334 0.0719250334
## [2761] 0.1214135890 0.0027195864 0.0167756048 0.1075973315 0.1075973315
## [2766] 0.1075973315 0.1075973315 0.5489868769 0.0104439392 0.0031128318
## [2771] 0.0050807875 0.0599171487 0.0599171487 0.0556415565 0.0059638799
## [2776] 0.0040922316 0.0379170140 0.0304935506 0.0304935506 0.2652066031
## [2781] 0.0134708871 0.3859930894 0.4151714041 0.0940847450 0.0014082045
## [2786] 0.0014082045 0.0193511673 0.0192048503 0.0630307548 0.0630307548
## [2791] 0.0630307548 0.0062519152 0.0062519152 0.1101394896 0.0076274690
## [2796] 0.3867663401 0.2971726189 0.2971726189 0.2971726189 0.0030307056
## [2801] 0.0030307056 0.0638650762 0.0638650762 0.0638650762 0.4632091311
## [2806] 0.4632091311 0.0344735429 0.0344735429 0.0344735429 0.0612571206
## [2811] 0.3456281985 0.3456281985 0.0033708989 0.0012809130 0.1616301845
## [2816] 0.1616301845 0.1616301845 0.2822109533 0.0999262427 0.0999262427
## [2821] 0.1261224788 0.1261224788 0.1261224788 0.1261224788 0.1261224788
## [2826] 0.0842199336 0.0842199336 0.0140134136 0.0140134136 0.0140134136
## [2831] 0.0140134136 0.3279551638 0.2191967502 0.0409411750 0.0161109479
## [2836] 0.0161109479 0.0176182194 0.0203529269 0.0062384555 0.4489780975
## [2841] 0.3555166699 0.3293467718 0.0112666209 0.1823693075 0.0769476832
## [2846] 0.0218845115 0.0809098543 0.0809098543 0.3584682758 0.3584682758
## [2851] 0.3586252681 0.3586252681 0.0085978651 0.0085978651 0.0165565176
## [2856] 0.0165565176 0.0165565176 0.0197666844 0.0197666844 0.0376149148
## [2861] 0.0376149148 0.1804504713 0.1804504713 0.1018928961 0.1499672774
## [2866] 0.0458836919 0.0111010853 0.0111010853 0.0050017510 0.0084820103
## [2871] 0.0277325877 0.0277325877 0.0737646172 0.0737646172 0.1515436708
## [2876] 0.2507223253 0.2507223253 0.0264656281 0.0088279246 0.0095951683
## [2881] 0.0393469446 0.0393469446 0.0393469446 0.0133522466 0.1397145712
## [2886] 0.1397145712 0.0344686881 0.1610149956 0.1061387077 0.0909930244
## [2891] 0.0282908611 0.0282908611 0.0282908611 0.0282908611 0.0449836956
## [2896] 0.0449836956 0.0106918077 0.2982494305 0.0802591276 0.0802591276
## [2901] 0.0038805840 0.0978552736 0.1408107403 0.0019723610 0.0019723610
## [2906] 0.0019723610 0.0529766024 0.0059307983 0.2240487122 0.0662008923
## [2911] 0.0305403390 0.0726290957 0.0815778441 0.0800662120 0.0598322611
## [2916] 0.0598322611 0.0598322611 0.0598322611 0.0424722139 0.2031825721
## [2921] 0.0471376097 0.1807431533 0.1807431533 0.0012486076 0.0155406228
## [2926] 0.0173810637 0.1290745104 0.0883907270 0.0722314540 0.0456984726
## [2931] 0.0456984726 0.0055565812 0.0984151993 0.0984151993 0.3249393936
## [2936] 0.3249393936 0.3249393936 0.1070247777 0.0066486660 0.0280552975
## [2941] 0.0246121903 0.0246121903 0.0246121903 0.0052526833 0.1531546969
## [2946] 0.2150327543 0.3593807512 0.2985526378 0.0581234831 0.0581234831
## [2951] 0.1058725345 0.1058725345 0.4938452305 0.4938452305 0.0336011025
## [2956] 0.0336011025 0.2011417979 0.2011417979 0.0023369563 0.0210218606
## [2961] 0.0210218606 0.0210218606 0.3833294317 0.0862540540 0.0862540540
## [2966] 0.0220151546 0.0220151546 0.0623198864 0.0623198864 0.0623198864
## [2971] 0.0623198864 0.0604863655 0.0604863655 0.0103702131 0.1926111287
## [2976] 0.1926111287 0.0326127621 0.4429817550 0.0507832728 0.0507832728
## [2981] 0.0473008736 0.0473008736 0.0771861024 0.4163428350 0.0483217464
## [2986] 0.0107374165 0.4269430497 0.0035721139 0.0813719720 0.0813719720
## [2991] 0.5040342559 0.0088414977 0.0116783005 0.0662981116 0.3003573720
## [2996] 0.0636821522 0.0636821522 0.0636821522 0.1087507717 0.1087507717
## [3001] 0.1817943978 0.2024722237 0.0034947826 0.0042912709 0.1483026576
## [3006] 0.2329310998 0.0160611371 0.0160611371 0.0290662045 0.0290662045
## [3011] 0.1445346606 0.2795806995 0.0750930278 0.3151782558 0.3151782558
## [3016] 0.0341848084 0.0341848084 0.0049023727 0.0049023727 0.0049023727
## [3021] 0.0137301549 0.0137301549 0.0137301549 0.0137301549 0.0240167711
## [3026] 0.1666304300 0.0677912010 0.0677912010 0.2539872470 0.3928952869
## [3031] 0.3928952869 0.0026596954 0.1511061605 0.1511061605 0.1511061605
## [3036] 0.0364519427 0.0364519427 0.0364519427 0.1682156273 0.1682156273
## [3041] 0.1682156273 0.0381480418 0.0381480418 0.0381480418 0.0178274185
## [3046] 0.0293679420 0.0177540823 0.0342021410 0.0342021410 0.0342021410
## [3051] 0.0075781880 0.0888034349 0.5380378996 0.0125236082 0.0261779771
## [3056] 0.0261779771 0.0261779771 0.0421554752 0.0421554752 0.4852644097
## [3061] 0.4852644097 0.4852644097 0.0402009320 0.0047449323 0.3756474519
## [3066] 0.2132105715 0.0535226472 0.0349908269 0.0221133478 0.3592219474
## [3071] 0.0286508902 0.0039395040 0.0629862233 0.0077057718 0.0137739596
## [3076] 0.0216506718 0.0103410148 0.0065149197 0.0717246199 0.0163188696
## [3081] 0.0163188696 0.0163188696 0.0280988178 0.0280988178 0.2060514136
## [3086] 0.0036546768 0.1535874838 0.3283934177 0.3283934177 0.0302047783
## [3091] 0.1533181553 0.0452585913 0.0022981455 0.0117849364 0.1154821829
## [3096] 0.1154821829 0.0060890550 0.1061843132 0.0733562578 0.0058646925
## [3101] 0.0058646925 0.0844327536 0.0238988380 0.4870437707 0.0210848557
## [3106] 0.0078392847 0.3765159058 0.3765159058 0.0251341224 0.1012354509
## [3111] 0.0066751973 0.0066751973 0.0066751973 0.0066751973 0.0066751973
## [3116] 0.0066751973 0.0345185276 0.0317248064 0.0081873887 0.1991783517
## [3121] 0.0041635402 0.0057969523 0.0057969523 0.0362922433 0.0362922433
## [3126] 0.0362922433 0.0090990887 0.0090990887 0.5319585499 0.1140758070
## [3131] 0.0042708934 0.0042708934 0.1117818131 0.0142150824 0.0142150824
## [3136] 0.0034088850 0.0745662597 0.3756685310 0.1112150296 0.1112150296
## [3141] 0.0234242719 0.0511789579 0.1131401296 0.1131401296 0.1131401296
## [3146] 0.0677957587 0.0542583673 0.0065816200 0.0118290618 0.0641510921
## [3151] 0.0232860660 0.0232860660 0.0232860660 0.0385686098 0.0037439132
## [3156] 0.0024818893 0.0024818893 0.1826274548 0.0029188691 0.0029188691
## [3161] 0.0339276771 0.0045778415 0.6822757295 0.6822757295 0.0040665433
## [3166] 0.0040665433 0.3617409664 0.1011607636 0.1174120261 0.1174120261
## [3171] 0.0117370054 0.0117370054 0.0096236398 0.0096236398 0.0105574369
## [3176] 0.0196968516 0.0196968516 0.0196968516 0.0754612345 0.0030508250
## [3181] 0.0030508250 0.0030508250 0.0359362125 0.6621364288 0.1135253540
## [3186] 0.0445160875 0.0445160875 0.1780951066 0.0143006447 0.0161930855
## [3191] 0.0161930855 0.2402886932 0.2402886932 0.0137721333 0.0137721333
## [3196] 0.0137721333 0.0137721333 0.0742834096 0.0623326826 0.0623326826
## [3201] 0.0193734168 0.0193734168 0.0308194015 0.0852946123 0.3070173945
## [3206] 0.0115201856 0.2696457996 0.2696457996 0.2696457996 0.0312235779
## [3211] 0.0312235779 0.0468220905 0.0081289792 0.0055075721 0.0055075721
## [3216] 0.0055075721 0.1087709939 0.0790459144 0.0790459144 0.1121760904
## [3221] 0.1786961511 0.4086496635 0.0031241497 0.0031241497 0.0206583281
## [3226] 0.0345406281 0.0865841100 0.1100406076 0.1100406076 0.1100406076
## [3231] 0.5249132739 0.3734847353 0.0211240230 0.0042300198 0.3418187764
## [3236] 0.3418187764 0.1226489385 0.2407447299 0.0016795303 0.0723665686
## [3241] 0.1484122407 0.1484122407 0.1484122407 0.0838168349 0.0699162333
## [3246] 0.0356072841 0.0356072841 0.3762885608 0.0575921951 0.1672858478
## [3251] 0.2398552510 0.0171541930 0.2214964645 0.2214964645 0.2656181291
## [3256] 0.0050075738 0.0930927053 0.0930927053 0.0455439261 0.0067071088
## [3261] 0.2903080921 0.0557964395 0.0121556191 0.0121556191 0.0121556191
## [3266] 0.0242481720 0.0129309966 0.0129309966 0.0129309966 0.1072820614
## [3271] 0.0121037025 0.2111939697 0.2111939697 0.0286616920 0.0286616920
## [3276] 0.1778920229 0.3263349751 0.1523055147 0.1321040014 0.0409388791
## [3281] 0.0409388791 0.0409388791 0.0409388791 0.0466958230 0.0466958230
## [3286] 0.0222844328 0.1793997802 0.0971919871 0.0256965764 0.0256965764
## [3291] 0.0598520123 0.0050714002 0.2714166612 0.0085615253 0.0028295351
## [3296] 0.0138370028 0.2024058696 0.2024058696 0.0377953279 0.0236538494
## [3301] 0.0705978439 0.0306526669 0.0306526669 0.0306526669 0.0520098608
## [3306] 0.0520098608 0.2348379080 0.0132931142 0.2597786076 0.2597786076
## [3311] 0.1688007879 0.2501878816 0.3035451211 0.2260048638 0.3851222196
## [3316] 0.0193961094 0.0062765215 0.0062765215 0.0062765215 0.0062765215
## [3321] 0.0233158546 0.1999758617 0.0078379698 0.1776738631 0.0185566574
## [3326] 0.0185566574 0.0185566574 0.1990478224 0.0277761153 0.1151038012
## [3331] 0.2099086020 0.1017512267 0.0331639994 0.0643947402 0.0643947402
## [3336] 0.2713099484 0.0292364970 0.0292364970 0.0292364970 0.0232326478
## [3341] 0.0017656642 0.0017656642 0.0109495789 0.0109495789 0.0389913068
## [3346] 0.0389913068 0.0389913068 0.0389913068 0.0162595968 0.0510580037
## [3351] 0.0510580037 0.0510580037 0.0160742410 0.0160742410 0.0048550156
## [3356] 0.0554212720 0.2953769426 0.0581663034 0.0581663034 0.0112043146
## [3361] 0.0325088020 0.0325088020 0.0325088020 0.1544960682 0.0104494293
## [3366] 0.0919744442 0.0089292750 0.0552269393 0.0433228670 0.3162701793
## [3371] 0.0896381067 0.0896381067 0.0896381067 0.0896381067 0.0224443840
## [3376] 0.0171643539 0.0171643539 0.3654949056 0.2251425144 0.1814029098
## [3381] 0.0066542543 0.0066542543 0.0066542543 0.0066542543 0.1949551956
## [3386] 0.1949551956 0.0071647767 0.0218611842 0.0145962394 0.0876944112
## [3391] 0.0475422235 0.0475422235 0.0475422235 0.0475422235 0.0475422235
## [3396] 0.0475422235 0.0090881392 0.0186295853 0.0186295853 0.0665436855
## [3401] 0.2839534884 0.2839534884 0.0983994813 0.0983994813 0.0692601019
## [3406] 0.0692601019 0.0245850519 0.2246420538 0.2246420538 0.0688664566
## [3411] 0.5102424968 0.1067316285 0.1067316285 0.0240200918 0.0240200918
## [3416] 0.0122932359 0.1452416828 0.0400845964 0.0400845964 0.0118657662
## [3421] 0.0118657662 0.0601265282 0.0395646860 0.0395646860 0.0183640477
## [3426] 0.0847624218 0.0847624218 0.0115950454 0.0023087324 0.0434214520
## [3431] 0.0066018435 0.0066018435 0.0066018435 0.0561275680 0.0144883323
## [3436] 0.2525319694 0.1309320620 0.0055584884 0.0807642249 0.1511100966
## [3441] 0.0816665474 0.0816665474 0.0069048205 0.0194918727 0.1689036069
## [3446] 0.1689036069 0.3217059077 0.0277469508 0.0560156855 0.0560156855
## [3451] 0.2085505859 0.0442598941 0.0134891039 0.0399971592 0.0214895960
## [3456] 0.0214895960 0.0078713994 0.0166639819 0.0044971772 0.0044971772
## [3461] 0.4315961858 0.0155549852 0.0033033087 0.0033033087 0.0100476533
## [3466] 0.0100476533 0.3836361149 0.0521659040 0.0521659040 0.2398676703
## [3471] 0.0236992254 0.0236992254 0.0236992254 0.0182130230 0.0997046781
## [3476] 0.0024019980 0.0024019980 0.0596069826 0.0596069826 0.0596069826
## [3481] 0.0596069826 0.3273581299 0.3273581299 0.3120061162 0.1591875695
## [3486] 0.0048840862 0.0048840862 0.0267227459 0.0928928552 0.0037062772
## [3491] 0.0267962999 0.0267962999 0.0267962999 0.0147080129 0.0147080129
## [3496] 0.0147080129 0.0147080129 0.0065347530 0.0994249195 0.0046716801
## [3501] 0.0046716801 0.0913094060 0.1237002774 0.1237002774 0.1649006697
## [3506] 0.2098263431 0.0020617342 0.0533978917 0.0533978917 0.0533978917
## [3511] 0.1967461747 0.1967461747 0.1967461747 0.1967461747 0.1967461747
## [3516] 0.2892980444 0.0031167052 0.0031167052 0.0276951494 0.0276951494
## [3521] 0.2465333489 0.0465902214 0.0465902214 0.0157492333 0.0042542926
## [3526] 0.0042542926 0.0386271020 0.0210608647 0.0210608647 0.0210608647
## [3531] 0.0210608647 0.0169240191 0.0046760130 0.0103792008 0.0060010001
## [3536] 0.0060010001 0.0377041626 0.0447642237 0.0447642237 0.0122247527
## [3541] 0.2587972309 0.0481297260 0.0101053954 0.1538782290 0.0286250377
## [3546] 0.0286250377 0.0230450799 0.0230450799 0.0034465002 0.2581024457
## [3551] 0.0599612877 0.0427697755 0.0427697755 0.1103645545 0.1103645545
## [3556] 0.1103645545 0.1103645545 0.5913990244 0.1537789817 0.1286815386
## [3561] 0.0053659738 0.0053659738 0.0098234521 0.0325133274 0.0145867541
## [3566] 0.0049923368 0.0049923368 0.0355742177 0.0603035768 0.0546304348
## [3571] 0.0042495326 0.1214916640 0.0622035470 0.1099184840 0.5122455065
## [3576] 0.0166212090 0.0166212090 0.0166212090 0.0166212090 0.0087498270
## [3581] 0.0067382780 0.0067382780 0.3162502361 0.1529653452 0.1529653452
## [3586] 0.1529653452 0.0622389769 0.0610229918 0.4060373455 0.0577156474
## [3591] 0.0577156474 0.0577156474 0.3723421277 0.0708711756 0.2132844193
## [3596] 0.0279484277 0.0279484277 0.0322911324 0.0095588109 0.0699586148
## [3601] 0.0347105064 0.0355355310 0.0201343262 0.0201343262 0.0042334824
## [3606] 0.0016300637 0.0016300637 0.1533462482 0.1533462482 0.0414782999
## [3611] 0.0458565092 0.3503552362 0.1858207644 0.0121395446 0.0067012003
## [3616] 0.0091934807 0.0091934807 0.0028603448 0.2892734973 0.0744669789
## [3621] 0.0744669789 0.0071850686 0.4757425461 0.3224359486 0.3224359486
## [3626] 0.0273962755 0.0577632701 0.0247383186 0.0247383186 0.6872220423
## [3631] 0.6872220423 0.0771733830 0.0771733830 0.0074858897 0.0074858897
## [3636] 0.3006246921 0.0985244080 0.0052492449 0.0066081641 0.0669385989
## [3641] 0.0669385989 0.1813790288 0.3741099568 0.0757620265 0.0775724240
## [3646] 0.0653698200 0.1265930526 0.2173416459 0.2173416459 0.0063059028
## [3651] 0.1276065207 0.0242764317 0.1179709814 0.1179709814 0.1179709814
## [3656] 0.1179709814 0.0049335274 0.0049335274 0.0049335274 0.0049335274
## [3661] 0.0102918859 0.0132084707 0.1787870585 0.0339367294 0.0050214288
## [3666] 0.0050214288 0.0050214288 0.0050214288 0.0820152864 0.1870723563
## [3671] 0.1870723563 0.1870723563 0.0171817037 0.1393864292 0.0247848901
## [3676] 0.7920111036 0.2473361159 0.2473361159 0.0076251506 0.0076251506
## [3681] 0.2843871038 0.0917916881 0.7396021199 0.0425697190 0.3478346595
## [3686] 0.3478346595 0.0787687478 0.0787687478 0.4112527031 0.4112527031
## [3691] 0.2893622090 0.0646176043 0.0646176043 0.0169615647 0.0169615647
## [3696] 0.0738300950 0.0448524901 0.0448524901 0.2109627196 0.0721990294
## [3701] 0.0721990294 0.0351644361 0.2057592593 0.0398672825 0.0398672825
## [3706] 0.0398672825 0.0398672825 0.0161533934 0.0161533934 0.0161533934
## [3711] 0.0257003240 0.0235920004 0.0791840119 0.0171677063 0.0171677063
## [3716] 0.0172218428 0.0172218428 0.0172218428 0.0079471579 0.0079471579
## [3721] 0.0079471579 0.0165083795 0.2430807045 0.1306806042 0.0062126277
## [3726] 0.5785017954 0.0023739746 0.6218854912 0.6218854912 0.5732115692
## [3731] 0.1280686396 0.6222331065 0.6222331065 0.6222331065 0.6222331065
## [3736] 0.0037941359 0.0037941359 0.0037941359 0.0037941359 0.0132063582
## [3741] 0.1806439833 0.1806439833 0.1806439833 0.1806439833 0.2453001880
## [3746] 0.0904404615 0.0904404615 0.0067879803 0.0043294751 0.0117713254
## [3751] 0.0772233912 0.0332760642 0.4972465228 0.0052775944 0.0128812306
## [3756] 0.0128812306 0.3401515903 0.0196368038 0.0196368038 0.0635986746
## [3761] 0.0635986746 0.0635986746 0.0635986746 0.2688498483 0.2688498483
## [3766] 0.0170662233 0.0651486037 0.0307887710 0.0643297398 0.0643297398
## [3771] 0.0198474478 0.1878206395 0.1490877572 0.0450690814 0.0450690814
## [3776] 0.0089740667 0.0089740667 0.0365134755 0.0365134755 0.2292302854
## [3781] 0.2292302854 0.3091447861 0.3091447861 0.0603229168 0.0551989740
## [3786] 0.0225217736 0.0027872978 0.1442049747 0.1364802996 0.1364802996
## [3791] 0.0460100122 0.4242957131 0.1012060221 0.0973879877 0.0973879877
## [3796] 0.0105854243 0.0105854243 0.0105854243 0.0105854243 0.0207545292
## [3801] 0.0207545292 0.0207545292 0.1134755309 0.0093211060 0.0093211060
## [3806] 0.0093211060 0.0019738196 0.0019738196 0.0019738196 0.0019738196
## [3811] 0.3117524878 0.0021273254 0.3168601609 0.3168601609 0.3168601609
## [3816] 0.0046759993 0.0046759993 0.0046759993 0.0046759993 0.0046759993
## [3821] 0.2003300601 0.0068711820 0.0912726972 0.0912726972 0.0912726972
## [3826] 0.2112515643 0.2112515643 0.0319084011 0.0256735610 0.2492299488
## [3831] 0.1169703339 0.0993570613 0.2211741338 0.2211741338 0.2211741338
## [3836] 0.0048717863 0.0048717863 0.0767111822 0.2134106516 0.2134106516
## [3841] 0.7605558482 0.7605558482 0.7605558482 0.4219033462 0.2539948918
## [3846] 0.0055370488 0.4142160023 0.0033284110 0.0033284110 0.0121515802
## [3851] 0.0121515802 0.0309423438 0.2983550432 0.1550389520 0.1550389520
## [3856] 0.4840473354 0.0547884240 0.2075853488 0.0572590946 0.0804536257
## [3861] 0.0804536257 0.0804536257 0.0804536257 0.0804536257 0.0420488130
## [3866] 0.0420488130 0.1767104911 0.1767104911 0.0141202462 0.0141202462
## [3871] 0.1025603643 0.2255595751 0.1424939228 0.1501890356 0.0091854424
## [3876] 0.3992208235 0.2090854645 0.0094439813 0.0163414605 0.0337576087
## [3881] 0.0124130311 0.0233907995 0.2500204546 0.2500204546 0.2500204546
## [3886] 0.2500204546 0.0551589734 0.0817825026 0.0083667149 0.0083667149
## [3891] 0.0083667149 0.3150383277 0.3150383277 0.3150383277 0.3150383277
## [3896] 0.3150383277 0.1999755777 0.1654600095 0.0235353370 0.1624919723
## [3901] 0.1858996329 0.0356777241 0.0085314741 0.0558982181 0.0063024089
## [3906] 0.5526201306 0.2592934200 0.0039606362 0.1499464035 0.1499464035
## [3911] 0.1499464035 0.1499464035 0.0731494350 0.0731494350 0.1004638997
## [3916] 0.0483940272 0.1465918906 0.0637644330 0.0637644330 0.0637644330
## [3921] 0.0683813610 0.0683813610 0.0683813610 0.1437220732 0.0110247644
## [3926] 0.0110247644 0.0110247644 0.0147436434 0.0411303684 0.0382062427
## [3931] 0.0382062427 0.0107762082 0.0107762082 0.0148277541 0.0080185056
## [3936] 0.0080185056 0.0080185056 0.2998440320 0.2998440320 0.2998440320
## [3941] 0.2998440320 0.2998440320 0.2998440320 0.2998440320 0.2152828464
## [3946] 0.1744036393 0.4534166226 0.0968169014 0.0281436671 0.2304937183
## [3951] 0.0049945363 0.0049945363 0.0800135178 0.2742617773 0.2240287095
## [3956] 0.0039067149 0.0039067149 0.0039067149 0.0080467148 0.2979195809
## [3961] 0.3891475124 0.0486964371 0.0486964371 0.0486964371 0.2126604456
## [3966] 0.1336380934 0.1336380934 0.1336380934 0.2429033997 0.1920960285
## [3971] 0.3951730221 0.2050202803 0.0605565251 0.0605565251 0.0605565251
## [3976] 0.0107663011 0.0107663011 0.0066800444 0.0289147129 0.0461802439
## [3981] 0.0204420009 0.0204420009 0.1889194561 0.0075007598 0.0097788386
## [3986] 0.1910118380 0.0182611685 0.0182611685 0.0049130376 0.0705272702
## [3991] 0.0705272702 0.0705272702 0.1882896315 0.1047029741 0.1047029741
## [3996] 0.0731742032 0.0731742032 0.0731742032 0.0731742032 0.2479236876
## [4001] 0.0829231405 0.0829231405 0.0729004023 0.0729004023 0.0366248965
## [4006] 0.0328576423 0.0269807469 0.0241917189 0.0152795391 0.0152795391
## [4011] 0.3927358093 0.0117041202 0.3150047125 0.0090340763 0.0104769060
## [4016] 0.1496496533 0.0287785082 0.0192553519 0.0192553519 0.0192553519
## [4021] 0.0192553519 0.0192553519 0.1300669893 0.0340724778 0.0340724778
## [4026] 0.1851985107 0.1838801315 0.4363555347 0.4415993223 0.0950279041
## [4031] 0.0950279041 0.0495399016 0.0950279041 0.0950279041 0.0495399016
## [4036] 0.0048041871 0.1826661353 0.6529689876 0.1073467082 0.0033678306
## [4041] 0.0198083754 0.0113735852 0.4103530598 0.0768870832 0.0768870832
## [4046] 0.0924270815 0.0513083156 0.0513083156 0.1528213585 0.1528213585
## [4051] 0.8972893160 0.0366950030 0.0171469414 0.1842374529 0.1842374529
## [4056] 0.0183043121 0.0183043121 0.1061053135 0.1061053135 0.0167345952
## [4061] 0.0246930188 0.0246930188 0.2438669821 0.1159405805 0.0639843298
## [4066] 0.1617485393 0.1617485393 0.0312962214 0.1639535918 0.1161156126
## [4071] 0.7168679627 0.7168679627 0.0027186994 0.0027186994 0.0344357918
## [4076] 0.0344357918 0.2991614031 0.2991614031 0.1296599661 0.3553075397
## [4081] 0.2017444172 0.0804074043 0.1587139912 0.1587139912 0.1587139912
## [4086] 0.1587139912 0.1587139912 0.1587139912 0.1587139912 0.0025285717
## [4091] 0.0025285717 0.0025285717 0.0150313173 0.0139013512 0.2025592151
## [4096] 0.1611466243 0.1611466243 0.0269934612 0.0134082097 0.0830070842
## [4101] 0.0830070842 0.0830070842 0.0830070842 0.0830070842 0.0830070842
## [4106] 0.3509948644 0.0428750199 0.2071675393 0.0131596920 0.3279489029
## [4111] 0.0215891370 0.1026795550 0.0039736258 0.1858843383 0.2563971789
## [4116] 0.0268903935 0.1028284018 0.1127440211 0.1127440211 0.1127440211
## [4121] 0.1127440211 0.1127440211 0.1127440211 0.4539680035 0.1014472374
## [4126] 0.0918057738 0.3006191467 0.3006191467 0.0169449764 0.0169449764
## [4131] 0.0169449764 0.2512862711 0.1342830249 0.1342830249 0.1342830249
## [4136] 0.0037136846 0.0037136846 0.0649376762 0.1424694561 0.2134285195
## [4141] 0.0679546196 0.0019326627 0.0022604357 0.0013198974 0.0019326627
## [4146] 0.0019326627 0.0058194101 0.0586721743 0.0586721743 0.0188490990
## [4151] 0.2727129160 0.2727129160 0.0244812911 0.0891739611 0.0891739611
## [4156] 0.0891739611 0.0891739611 0.0891739611 0.0095174285 0.0095174285
## [4161] 0.0095174285 0.0095174285 0.2367099938 0.0163044116 0.0163044116
## [4166] 0.0643245820 0.0803188543 0.2666613082 0.0364312874 0.0364312874
## [4171] 0.1561828096 0.1561828096 0.1561828096 0.0740975775 0.4414410018
## [4176] 0.0029303212 0.0018458402 0.0250127759 0.0250127759 0.0250127759
## [4181] 0.4379569565 0.0451512767 0.0032573837 0.1691834386 0.1691834386
## [4186] 0.1691834386 0.0375323951 0.0437829501 0.1829722706 0.0735232914
## [4191] 0.0735232914 0.1765101084 0.1765101084 0.1765101084 0.1765101084
## [4196] 0.1323085237 0.0525628412 0.0525628412 0.0074417436 0.0715949997
## [4201] 0.0318910902 0.0318910902 0.0244709424 0.0667389786 0.0667389786
## [4206] 0.0092218698 0.1765637618 0.3334594788 0.0301287901 0.2999292831
## [4211] 0.4448815520 0.0144998356 0.0045097048 0.0045097048 0.0075515718
## [4216] 0.0075515718 0.0569699778 0.0569699778 0.0569699778 0.1474775177
## [4221] 0.0039130913 0.0039130913 0.3760886923 0.1706645933 0.1591881015
## [4226] 0.1591881015 0.1591881015 0.0100488323 0.2614802681 0.0058405044
## [4231] 0.0058405044 0.0180167717 0.3116315702 0.2225025072 0.1866570476
## [4236] 0.1866570476 0.0224278090 0.0721604524 0.0053353357 0.1150947773
## [4241] 0.1150947773 0.0712073668 0.0712073668 0.0124057428 0.1658658719
## [4246] 0.1658658719 0.1658658719 0.0873760918 0.0606946913 0.0606946913
## [4251] 0.0606946913 0.2190151398 0.0381616141 0.0389368815 0.0389368815
## [4256] 0.1444259997 0.1444259997 0.1444259997 0.1444259997 0.0029862887
## [4261] 0.0025398869 0.0025398869 0.0247048126 0.0912762198 0.1108917600
## [4266] 0.0665820378 0.0442261984 0.0442261984 0.0442261984 0.0442261984
## [4271] 0.0442261984 0.0442261984 0.0684843205 0.0029737374 0.0079103379
## [4276] 0.0079103379 0.0608741657 0.0608741657 0.1277390105 0.0195660159
## [4281] 0.0075744337 0.0075744337 0.0075744337 0.0075744337 0.0035042318
## [4286] 0.0035042318 0.1160375520 0.1160375520 0.1160375520 0.1160375520
## [4291] 0.1160375520 0.0150012421 0.4388000229 0.0236535628 0.0327204746
## [4296] 0.0921545064 0.0921545064 0.0921545064 0.1303012952 0.0541287799
## [4301] 0.0541287799 0.2613606114 0.0999403482 0.0999403482 0.0999403482
## [4306] 0.0283017259 0.0283017259 0.0283017259 0.0425530571 0.1420559242
## [4311] 0.1420559242 0.1420559242 0.0646900803 0.0384221847 0.0384221847
## [4316] 0.0384221847 0.0819512776 0.0819512776 0.1052504809 0.0029908468
## [4321] 0.0029908468 0.0572114911 0.0011927954 0.0011927954 0.3844176057
## [4326] 0.3132185315 0.2327202409 0.2327202409 0.0129995117 0.0174072384
## [4331] 0.1844059901 0.1651991954 0.1651991954 0.0532438329 0.0532438329
## [4336] 0.0532438329 0.0532438329 0.0604691606 0.0324257486 0.0340761289
## [4341] 0.0136108487 0.0136108487 0.0136108487 0.0136108487 0.0136108487
## [4346] 0.0126827189 0.0106005468 0.0873712924 0.0873712924 0.0356721944
## [4351] 0.0053749355 0.1132048448 0.0873531822 0.1010900996 0.1189330623
## [4356] 0.1095987350 0.0107708821 0.3204371518 0.0070075037 0.0536925399
## [4361] 0.0766034952 0.0766034952 0.1064365459 0.0386862414 0.0386862414
## [4366] 0.0040849728 0.0040849728 0.3142977511 0.0088094169 0.0088094169
## [4371] 0.3795937285 0.0618930316 0.0182129888 0.0182129888 0.0182129888
## [4376] 0.0663273389 0.0576251970 0.0576251970 0.0094347242 0.0094347242
## [4381] 0.0382808688 0.0424266597 0.0424266597 0.0424266597 0.0231272863
## [4386] 0.0093861681 0.1772306793 0.1772306793 0.1772306793 0.0436662866
## [4391] 0.0139398133 0.1270419689 0.1270419689 0.1083548612 0.0362984191
## [4396] 0.5278967375 0.0088870677 0.0798545858 0.0383231924 0.4198102175
## [4401] 0.4198102175 0.0248727989 0.0248727989 0.0029339331 0.0472149677
## [4406] 0.0472149677 0.0472149677 0.0472149677 0.0074990629 0.0311933884
## [4411] 0.0208931618 0.0120912875 0.1537120442 0.1999545775 0.2453881413
## [4416] 0.2453881413 0.0564057924 0.0269649590 0.1202578391 0.0082953406
## [4421] 0.0082953406 0.0937098416 0.0031579529 0.0031579529 0.0100331603
## [4426] 0.0100331603 0.0100331603 0.0100331603 0.0100331603 0.0813966510
## [4431] 0.0813966510 0.0813966510 0.0813966510 0.0813966510 0.2376309400
## [4436] 0.0164687655 0.1015612050 0.1015612050 0.1143947548 0.1143947548
## [4441] 0.0105838009 0.1466821640 0.1466821640 0.0063510565 0.2638428310
## [4446] 0.0017553107 0.1196248986 0.1196248986 0.1449130660 0.1515630864
## [4451] 0.1515630864 0.2097077144 0.0565685855 0.3483052503 0.1117381060
## [4456] 0.2352964689 0.2352964689 0.0158200788 0.2103970375 0.0385155660
## [4461] 0.0385155660 0.2292058535 0.0350821274 0.0350821274 0.0350821274
## [4466] 0.0350821274 0.0062983668 0.0062983668 0.0854870292 0.0020677273
## [4471] 0.0282937338 0.0282937338 0.0057996465 0.3843763529 0.3016304270
## [4476] 0.0132794082 0.0039666517 0.0039666517 0.3841764721 0.0316248005
## [4481] 0.0808367043 0.0155032213 0.5010075499 0.0849706800 0.1399565563
## [4486] 0.0012941101 0.0012675471 0.0776021566 0.0191432813 0.0191432813
## [4491] 0.0940775919 0.0940775919 0.0940775919 0.1991977961 0.0155736338
## [4496] 0.1359820106 0.1359820106 0.1359820106 0.0292720904 0.0292720904
## [4501] 0.0094872812 0.0094872812 0.0094872812 0.0018526106 0.0584026073
## [4506] 0.0584026073 0.0584026073 0.0584026073 0.4435835665 0.0684946199
## [4511] 0.0684946199 0.0451309363 0.0337377483 0.0153110981 0.0062358883
## [4516] 0.0131938381 0.0713954016 0.0082467552 0.0081348323 0.0724905674
## [4521] 0.0062979107 0.1263300409 0.0293163943 0.0044409691 0.0044409691
## [4526] 0.0044409691 0.0044409691 0.3932398710 0.3932398710 0.1924453268
## [4531] 0.0032273322 0.0032273322 0.1890454748 0.1510781368 0.2948398170
## [4536] 0.1945398955 0.0083331715 0.0083331715 0.0173430645 0.0010511971
## [4541] 0.1078134981 0.1078134981 0.1078134981 0.1078134981 0.2352338672
## [4546] 0.2352338672 0.2352338672 0.2352338672 0.2352338672 0.2352338672
## [4551] 0.2041700764 0.2041700764 0.2210541381 0.2029937035 0.1084641994
## [4556] 0.5412128562 0.5412128562 0.5412128562 0.1436643187 0.0183519899
## [4561] 0.0183519899 0.0183519899 0.0183519899 0.4621966879 0.4621966879
## [4566] 0.0507642677 0.1241920780 0.0352268142 0.0352268142 0.1221171695
## [4571] 0.1221171695 0.0223326559 0.1043864089 0.1043864089 0.1043864089
## [4576] 0.0336103839 0.1289420958 0.1289420958 0.1737390861 0.0021898759
## [4581] 0.0771773896 0.0771773896 0.0771773896 0.4449981696 0.4449981696
## [4586] 0.0124686927 0.0349173652 0.0359522266 0.6301282737 0.6335672372
## [4591] 0.0071269871 0.0071269871 0.0348713200 0.0348713200 0.0348713200
## [4596] 0.0348713200 0.0121007517 0.0121007517 0.0610143755 0.0777020094
## [4601] 0.0362715583 0.0362715583 0.0362715583 0.0362715583 0.0362715583
## [4606] 0.0362715583 0.1215990430 0.0339343653 0.0339343653 0.0339343653
## [4611] 0.0339343653 0.0339343653 0.1858044542 0.0094499507 0.0098596251
## [4616] 0.0244488503 0.0244488503 0.2858830699 0.2858830699 0.0082444360
## [4621] 0.0196669065 0.0196669065 0.0037334042 0.0318365152 0.1139813079
## [4626] 0.1139813079 0.1139813079 0.0124394034 0.0124394034 0.0146824651
## [4631] 0.0146824651 0.0146824651 0.0410126726 0.0943870454 0.0943870454
## [4636] 0.0943870454 0.0214454607 0.0139641700 0.0241623105 0.0241623105
## [4641] 0.1499648332 0.1499648332 0.0066097853 0.2237727326 0.2237727326
## [4646] 0.0433390280 0.0433390280 0.1398630188 0.0371118161 0.2653190389
## [4651] 0.2653190389 0.2653190389 0.1218134810 0.0224302113 0.0224302113
## [4656] 0.0309148141 0.0309148141 0.0143472731 0.2516794955 0.4160322429
## [4661] 0.1644962211 0.0342118130 0.0342118130 0.0342118130 0.0342118130
## [4666] 0.0342118130 0.0146479006 0.0055391105 0.0795386102 0.0980514323
## [4671] 0.0980514323 0.0980514323 0.0980514323 0.0980514323 0.3601826079
## [4676] 0.0021152355 0.0021152355 0.0021152355 0.0021152355 0.1179490665
## [4681] 0.1482145651 0.1482145651 0.0243782722 0.0075599601 0.0103427255
## [4686] 0.0103427255 0.2326103355 0.2326103355 0.2326103355 0.0119255618
## [4691] 0.0119255618 0.0807045235 0.0281123120 0.3996616735 0.0022059728
## [4696] 0.2617268966 0.2617268966 0.2617268966 0.2617268966 0.0293827034
## [4701] 0.1378594347 0.0090608878 0.1065893833 0.0740386378 0.0074498998
## [4706] 0.1791401033 0.1772769782 0.2505415208 0.0178435101 0.0994916659
## [4711] 0.0994916659 0.0120982868 0.0120982868 0.0951622116 0.0062457878
## [4716] 0.0062457878 0.0062457878 0.0205296042 0.0205296042 0.0205296042
## [4721] 0.0205296042 0.1022406544 0.0179160222 0.0179160222 0.0179160222
## [4726] 0.0179160222 0.0063191384 0.2922479110 0.0058886400 0.0109424730
## [4731] 0.0109424730 0.0109424730 0.0109424730 0.0109424730 0.0223116926
## [4736] 0.1578857728 0.0812797360 0.0812797360 0.0525673237 0.1709068748
## [4741] 0.1317525726 0.0295040411 0.0295040411 0.0031999863 0.2210422824
## [4746] 0.2210422824 0.0318126264 0.0318126264 0.0318126264 0.3226399009
## [4751] 0.0064028040 0.0064028040 0.0114593548 0.0114593548 0.0114593548
## [4756] 0.2807445569 0.2807445569 0.0028708150 0.0028708150 0.0028708150
## [4761] 0.0028708150 0.1571179044 0.0134478345 0.0591330738 0.0591330738
## [4766] 0.0464510922 0.1463446413 0.1463446413 0.0248745554 0.0139442936
## [4771] 0.0031552336 0.2170942822 0.0138928984 0.0129056676 0.0129056676
## [4776] 0.1893123035 0.0041000565 0.0041000565 0.4186324371 0.2931974531
## [4781] 0.2931974531 0.0010971887 0.1257703764 0.2069180947 0.2069180947
## [4786] 0.0059949277 0.0049388677 0.0198092497 0.0198092497 0.0066065529
## [4791] 0.2722009896 0.2722009896 0.4319039633 0.0840609064 0.0099129655
## [4796] 0.0044410194 0.1332630874 0.2311063276 0.2311063276 0.2735433974
## [4801] 0.1390545178 0.1390545178 0.0928593877 0.0928593877 0.0928593877
## [4806] 0.0016987917 0.0016987917 0.0016987917 0.2788215561 0.0018562599
## [4811] 0.0018562599 0.0098185951 0.0609309272 0.0609309272 0.0330729761
## [4816] 0.0330729761 0.0330729761 0.0330729761 0.0947005617 0.0456525866
## [4821] 0.0456525866 0.1091323697 0.0067215635 0.0208157492 0.0180598997
## [4826] 0.0492987330 0.0492987330 0.0492987330 0.0492987330 0.2151380217
## [4831] 0.0585295328 0.1971867519 0.2066030304 0.0738768049 0.0046820174
## [4836] 0.0046820174 0.0046820174 0.0083925017 0.0011276952 0.0477035176
## [4841] 0.1290699394 0.0422279242 0.5308892831 0.2328686688 0.0252645910
## [4846] 0.4052943831 0.0159428626 0.1712725470 0.1561185948 0.0238945966
## [4851] 0.0238945966 0.0238945966 0.0238945966 0.0238945966 0.4501302773
## [4856] 0.3970814320 0.2313492348 0.0198353931 0.0151396950 0.0058816213
## [4861] 0.2015614746 0.0514867425 0.0251594298 0.0838965851 0.0082851112
## [4866] 0.0648580322 0.2194222977 0.0229726998 0.0313545240 0.0593529885
## [4871] 0.0313545240 0.0015879595 0.0056900776 0.0064117547 0.0678420849
## [4876] 0.0678420849 0.0399670408 0.0060057846 0.0060057846 0.0060057846
## [4881] 0.0060057846 0.0295655145 0.0295655145 0.2728278937 0.5684461030
## [4886] 0.3882865017 0.0565241848 0.1192197113 0.0334728239 0.0073213721
## [4891] 0.0038499470 0.0038499470 0.0038499470 0.0038499470 0.0038499470
## [4896] 0.0033387471 0.0417770892 0.0417770892 0.4885614086 0.3080640625
## [4901] 0.0554360984 0.0699133325 0.1667488899 0.0225296045 0.0126076284
## [4906] 0.0126076284 0.0126076284 0.0222643052 0.0222643052 0.0222643052
## [4911] 0.0222643052 0.0233211841 0.0233211841 0.0233211841 0.0899933388
## [4916] 0.0147935635 0.1063163724 0.2819975709 0.0085752447 0.0048719208
## [4921] 0.0571283914 0.0571283914 0.0077427873 0.0400207924 0.0400207924
## [4926] 0.0400207924 0.0400207924 0.0400207924 0.0525881119 0.0525881119
## [4931] 0.0525881119 0.0525881119 0.0525881119 0.0059098716 0.5249364342
## [4936] 0.0718139891 0.0718139891 0.0165163525 0.0047803345 0.3569390364
## [4941] 0.0623777826 0.1999533632 0.1999533632 0.1999533632 0.0278686805
## [4946] 0.0098100070 0.0076957899 0.0076957899 0.1432240427 0.1432240427
## [4951] 0.0343528631 0.3064758920 0.3064758920 0.0303747408 0.0068964473
## [4956] 0.2986787568 0.0017667263 0.0287342032 0.1146418993 0.0039219363
## [4961] 0.0039219363 0.0203639049 0.0203639049 0.0286066173 0.0163931155
## [4966] 0.0133807746 0.1815937520 0.1815937520 0.1815937520 0.1877317178
## [4971] 0.1877317178 0.1877317178 0.2666895287 0.0134838657 0.0134838657
## [4976] 0.0134838657 0.1541352408 0.0603786890 0.3394656297 0.1479167361
## [4981] 0.1479167361 0.1807005271 0.1807005271 0.0450773321 0.0450773321
## [4986] 0.0706324490 0.1071828084 0.1422892437 0.1422892437 0.1422892437
## [4991] 0.1422892437 0.0120909472 0.0120909472 0.0209420284 0.0704857162
## [4996] 0.0704857162 0.0704857162 0.0704857162 0.1344021953 0.1344021953
## [5001] 0.0874817815 0.0045861963 0.0247804819 0.1003699603 0.1003699603
## [5006] 0.1003699603 0.1569374443 0.1569374443 0.1569374443 0.2632540257
## [5011] 0.2632540257 0.0115091549 0.1234493228 0.0097268704 0.0110703705
## [5016] 0.0042093040 0.0042093040 0.0846311157 0.2078349416 0.2078349416
## [5021] 0.2078349416 0.2078349416 0.2078349416 0.0509032637 0.0256306167
## [5026] 0.0256306167 0.0029212175 0.2703408713 0.0268103488 0.0070017234
## [5031] 0.0070017234 0.2414150072 0.0308372241 0.0193888471 0.0193888471
## [5036] 0.0193888471 0.0193888471 0.0174476022 0.0174185119 0.0174185119
## [5041] 0.0174185119 0.0481289089 0.0481289089 0.0481289089 0.0481289089
## [5046] 0.0043053433 0.1413366139 0.0955835301 0.0955835301 0.0955835301
## [5051] 0.0955835301 0.1094122296 0.1094122296 0.1094122296 0.1078189076
## [5056] 0.1348967322 0.0130760671 0.2373661775 0.1420236051 0.4085542563
## [5061] 0.6020993856 0.0064717092 0.1082027431 0.2112321345 0.0104831353
## [5066] 0.0020638942 0.0089480428 0.0089480428 0.1615432145 0.2317643506
## [5071] 0.0793511505 0.0793511505 0.0793511505 0.0793511505 0.0793511505
## [5076] 0.0793511505 0.0541816035 0.0245045231 0.0245045231 0.0266794208
## [5081] 0.0026412884 0.0026412884 0.0026412884 0.0026412884 0.0661772890
## [5086] 0.0296142280 0.2402823107 0.0696583789 0.2075221143 0.0201679281
## [5091] 0.0125240134 0.1651680160 0.0068261249 0.0068261249 0.0270170975
## [5096] 0.0036712018 0.0483276785 0.1210422067 0.0048466567 0.0728888328
## [5101] 0.2954853271 0.1762693311 0.0297416195 0.0297416195 0.0297416195
## [5106] 0.0120036039 0.0120036039 0.0120036039 0.1027352592 0.1361421051
## [5111] 0.0205473362 0.1538913671 0.2590321353 0.0673233709 0.0673233709
## [5116] 0.0781122671 0.0781122671 0.0034830469 0.0034830469 0.0034830469
## [5121] 0.0082069658 0.0082069658 0.2318819723 0.0963425009 0.0226470056
## [5126] 0.0442706531 0.0442706531 0.0442706531 0.0442706531 0.0028198999
## [5131] 0.0209702992 0.0146865093 0.1017125266 0.1017125266 0.0115879326
## [5136] 0.0115879326 0.0955864879 0.0955864879 0.0324396074 0.0363549922
## [5141] 0.1048837999 0.0864256299 0.0864256299 0.0864256299 0.0603337836
## [5146] 0.0603337836 0.0067496870 0.2506579096 0.1155834089 0.1155834089
## [5151] 0.0266973818 0.0266973818 0.2167619818 0.0263437962 0.0263437962
## [5156] 0.0068857118 0.0068857118 0.0109608865 0.0109608865 0.0109608865
## [5161] 0.0406151460 0.0218783659 0.0218783659 0.0218783659 0.0270406553
## [5166] 0.1623517539 0.1623517539 0.1623517539 0.1623517539 0.0060614760
## [5171] 0.3554995622 0.3554995622 0.0523647388 0.0103430964 0.0962923346
## [5176] 0.0962923346 0.0962923346 0.1132489816 0.1561060055 0.0368647417
## [5181] 0.2350241244 0.2350241244 0.2812435201 0.0051543836 0.0154691272
## [5186] 0.1147012816 0.2276255403 0.0891473784 0.2462032297 0.2891734843
## [5191] 0.3319608135 0.3319608135 0.0080802190 0.1100324836 0.0364551218
## [5196] 0.0364551218 0.0364551218 0.0364551218 0.0364551218 0.0364551218
## [5201] 0.1115666528 0.0014462073 0.0723473501 0.2060727852 0.2060727852
## [5206] 0.2060727852 0.2060727852 0.2416687921 0.0223115686 0.0660228915
## [5211] 0.0681227986 0.0102271742 0.0069913861 0.5475586533 0.5475586533
## [5216] 0.5475586533 0.0610547315 0.0610547315 0.0610547315 0.0354896975
## [5221] 0.1687570463 0.0705045197 0.0040556009 0.3065497438 0.0032931812
## [5226] 0.0014470140 0.4993407764 0.0102807729 0.0018412661 0.1719094085
## [5231] 0.0395105129 0.0395105129 0.0395105129 0.1042994163 0.1042994163
## [5236] 0.1042994163 0.1042994163 0.2896374424 0.0907563842 0.0907563842
## [5241] 0.0907563842 0.0907563842 0.0907563842 0.1856779020 0.1432389749
## [5246] 0.1432389749 0.2166437982 0.2166437982 0.2166437982 0.0585113733
## [5251] 0.0585113733 0.0027810779 0.0027810779 0.0027810779 0.0027810779
## [5256] 0.0592917618 0.0592917618 0.1649365795 0.1649365795 0.1019574926
## [5261] 0.1019574926 0.1019574926 0.1019574926 0.0154973003 0.0105666483
## [5266] 0.0105666483 0.0105666483 0.0105666483 0.0105666483 0.0115921338
## [5271] 0.0526261455 0.0481305440 0.0122508684 0.0122508684 0.0369158349
## [5276] 0.0369158349 0.3643175746 0.0140167555 0.0140167555 0.2914226542
## [5281] 0.0670159030 0.0138370734 0.0138370734 0.0138370734 0.0138370734
## [5286] 0.0997962518 0.0994232035 0.0994232035 0.0374154316 0.0374154316
## [5291] 0.2951527254 0.0896640568 0.0896640568 0.0809339448 0.0244156981
## [5296] 0.0244156981 0.1864336130 0.0023846102 0.1378665854 0.1378665854
## [5301] 0.1378665854 0.2830254982 0.2421236643 0.0030953466 0.0030953466
## [5306] 0.0030953466 0.0030953466 0.0225466590 0.3002547344 0.0361557241
## [5311] 0.0361557241 0.0361557241 0.0747249987 0.0033804634 0.0143363930
## [5316] 0.0143363930 0.2911918707 0.0740122736 0.3454879021 0.0663412600
## [5321] 0.0411215447 0.0685438616 0.0739167324 0.0739167324 0.0739167324
## [5326] 0.3754951256 0.4700935117 0.3024072547 0.3662605238 0.2016832302
## [5331] 0.0133899773 0.0198891149 0.1745573444 0.0122298992 0.0132243078
## [5336] 0.0046010279 0.1705079771 0.1904500646 0.1904500646 0.0164984685
## [5341] 0.0186041753 0.2785552867 0.2785552867 0.2785552867 0.0389320509
## [5346] 0.0071953815 0.0071953815 0.0071953815 0.0071953815 0.0372831115
## [5351] 0.0372831115 0.0038823082 0.0321406022 0.0321406022 0.0321406022
## [5356] 0.3966443057 0.0336715145 0.0052167119 0.5315307452 0.5315307452
## [5361] 0.0047781558 0.3125424686 0.3125424686 0.0542036483 0.3162003746
## [5366] 0.0327161307 0.0164350263 0.0173152273 0.0034893065 0.0034893065
## [5371] 0.0034893065 0.2469235975 0.6591103545 0.6591103545 0.6591103545
## [5376] 0.0284588132 0.0069540675 0.1158369383 0.1158369383 0.1158369383
## [5381] 0.0279842804 0.0012740160 0.0998793473 0.0998793473 0.0137087110
## [5386] 0.0334918635 0.1906392520 0.1906392520 0.1833310821 0.1833310821
## [5391] 0.0569395321 0.0569395321 0.1408896733 0.1408896733 0.0957150185
## [5396] 0.0347799346 0.0442867503 0.0028158226 0.0028158226 0.0031753631
## [5401] 0.0031753631 0.3812845173 0.3812845173 0.3812845173 0.3812845173
## [5406] 0.3812845173 0.1855744209 0.0719820562 0.0018725590 0.0018725590
## [5411] 0.0018725590 0.0018725590 0.0565019335 0.5385385099 0.5385385099
## [5416] 0.5385385099 0.1754137223 0.0613169040 0.0613169040 0.0164528280
## [5421] 0.0164528280 0.0096030149 0.0978049628 0.1305346886 0.1305346886
## [5426] 0.0352830953 0.0352830953 0.0352830953 0.2796181981 0.2544955209
## [5431] 0.7593649923 0.0060286670 0.0060286670 0.0060286670 0.1873629381
## [5436] 0.1873629381 0.1037541923 0.1037541923 0.2275437396 0.0077291563
## [5441] 0.0312489935 0.0312489935 0.0135240259 0.0135240259 0.0090337418
## [5446] 0.0157036582 0.0157036582 0.0157036582 0.0127878045 0.1138333955
## [5451] 0.0209895345 0.0209895345 0.1361462757 0.1361462757 0.0252807708
## [5456] 0.3539969019 0.0196582175 0.0196582175 0.0174255280 0.0174255280
## [5461] 0.0174255280 0.0174255280 0.0174255280 0.0362533022 0.0362533022
## [5466] 0.0630215789 0.0179918357 0.0073814732 0.0141206260 0.0141206260
## [5471] 0.0063018479 0.0063018479 0.0542488954 0.0542488954 0.0542488954
## [5476] 0.0112506380 0.0084107946 0.0026423494 0.0738256881 0.1143565177
## [5481] 0.0242504311 0.0242504311 0.0057686095 0.0853045987 0.0853045987
## [5486] 0.0225155892 0.1378780664 0.1347611552 0.0048046252 0.0048046252
## [5491] 0.0114979063 0.0130802555 0.2191388276 0.0051335473 0.0061906677
## [5496] 0.0061906677 0.0273638548 0.2470551647 0.2979227760 0.2260012898
## [5501] 0.2260012898 0.0128779744 0.4424731999 0.0609278501 0.0931341958
## [5506] 0.0618299865 0.0618299865 0.0448076257 0.4160042226 0.4160042226
## [5511] 0.0146112257 0.0074051981 0.0501841414 0.0501841414 0.0213334436
## [5516] 0.3614159900 0.0064877259 0.2572427067 0.0289577173 0.0289577173
## [5521] 0.0289577173 0.0289577173 0.0289577173 0.0289577173 0.0773488549
## [5526] 0.0557004203 0.3437740592 0.1848392846 0.0396275142 0.0396275142
## [5531] 0.0935891914 0.1323574631 0.4220899010 0.2154282077 0.5646300142
## [5536] 0.0127692228 0.0127692228 0.2659474254 0.2659474254 0.2021827586
## [5541] 0.1573138060 0.3103188956 0.6743198371 0.0082057316 0.0080640326
## [5546] 0.0080640326 0.5061254893 0.0585741911 0.2383586286 0.0484365952
## [5551] 0.0484365952 0.0666840077 0.0666840077 0.0666840077 0.1070530545
## [5556] 0.1070530545 0.1070530545 0.0166998427 0.0166998427 0.0926599147
## [5561] 0.3604969862 0.3604969862 0.1741236565 0.1280757350 0.0050790296
## [5566] 0.0050790296 0.3258643476 0.0487783884 0.0356588094 0.0811998691
## [5571] 0.1184319835 0.0163486255 0.0263810887 0.0578109003 0.0578109003
## [5576] 0.0578109003 0.0530011817 0.1702314412 0.1702314412 0.1702314412
## [5581] 0.1702314412 0.1702314412 0.2713666225 0.2713666225 0.0675890259
## [5586] 0.1206474564 0.1206474564 0.0592280476 0.0592280476 0.0262687487
## [5591] 0.0262687487 0.0262687487 0.1367728904 0.0210315953 0.0210315953
## [5596] 0.0210315953 0.2378403486 0.2375118074 0.2429454598 0.0191631054
## [5601] 0.2743806907 0.2743806907 0.4544148866 0.1029334369 0.1029334369
## [5606] 0.1029334369 0.1029334369 0.1029334369 0.0686839763 0.0686839763
## [5611] 0.0686839763 0.2314610924 0.1887077046 0.1812206264 0.0941441851
## [5616] 0.0714468155 0.4086310843 0.4086310843 0.4086310843 0.0096772059
## [5621] 0.0096772059 0.2114244963 0.1341244395 0.1341244395 0.0391082612
## [5626] 0.0103400168 0.0103400168 0.0067209553 0.0197085241 0.0197085241
## [5631] 0.0197085241 0.2159576306 0.0037386912 0.0037386912 0.3322720678
## [5636] 0.3255842995 0.2275539430 0.1461446926 0.0368369013 0.1320220321
## [5641] 0.0815231798 0.0412041117 0.0216127472 0.0096702584 0.0096702584
## [5646] 0.1272854984 0.1272854984 0.1272854984 0.2172670924 0.2172670924
## [5651] 0.2172670924 0.2740779317 0.0171163931 0.0043238759 0.0043238759
## [5656] 0.0043238759 0.0247748850 0.0770710938 0.3235054215 0.3235054215
## [5661] 0.4331549397 0.4331549397 0.0702401553 0.0156589253 0.0156589253
## [5666] 0.3862562260 0.3013385240 0.0317730977 0.0135918455 0.0504932712
## [5671] 0.0410069000 0.3205394915 0.3205394915 0.0458626990 0.3401939720
## [5676] 0.2617855435 0.7421049020 0.7421049020 0.0027021797 0.1184458558
## [5681] 0.0054171722 0.0023388185 0.0023388185 0.0023388185 0.3405404784
## [5686] 0.0086713989 0.0282808142 0.0585303212 0.0111232060 0.0172367204
## [5691] 0.1245264400 0.0020504892 0.0020504892 0.0315336070 0.0315336070
## [5696] 0.0315336070 0.0315336070 0.0315336070 0.0463916928 0.0308261635
## [5701] 0.0626355625 0.0626355625 0.0239626579 0.0239626579 0.1217165917
## [5706] 0.1217165917 0.3664388407 0.3664388407 0.1455995430 0.4077945162
## [5711] 0.4077945162 0.2541027845 0.0103149305 0.0103149305 0.0022421099
## [5716] 0.0022421099 0.1363718678 0.0100106658 0.0100106658 0.0100106658
## [5721] 0.0428442854 0.0428442854 0.1697701651 0.1697701651 0.1697701651
## [5726] 0.1697701651 0.0328765716 0.0328765716 0.0328765716 0.2091616815
## [5731] 0.0928155442 0.1004735309 0.0136252821 0.0136252821 0.2109620183
## [5736] 0.0263649050 0.0096981879 0.0130536393 0.0130536393 0.5645075863
## [5741] 0.0290596699 0.4367873454 0.0060017158 0.0298241567 0.0298241567
## [5746] 0.1653543228 0.0991130414 0.0192705969 0.0821727205 0.0821727205
## [5751] 0.2193015875 0.0221336723 0.6064156191 0.0793025524 0.0049547189
## [5756] 0.0917424567 0.0777466609 0.0398613272 0.1142194341 0.1142194341
## [5761] 0.0612438370 0.0612438370 0.0612438370 0.0206419611 0.0206419611
## [5766] 0.0206419611 0.0273574909 0.0273574909 0.0273574909 0.0015146294
## [5771] 0.0015146294 0.0034101549 0.0040459737 0.0040459737 0.5034040472
## [5776] 0.5034040472 0.4256662839 0.0108208010 0.0198172576 0.4042173828
## [5781] 0.1719288212 0.1719288212 0.2396040769 0.0103712064 0.0103712064
## [5786] 0.0112680495 0.0040749208 0.0085472672 0.1487932530 0.1487932530
## [5791] 0.1487932530 0.1487932530 0.1487932530 0.1487932530 0.0072426111
## [5796] 0.0037054563 0.0037054563 0.2612219566 0.0977160100 0.0856509316
## [5801] 0.0977160100 0.0856509316 0.0132868650 0.0167239832 0.0013840608
## [5806] 0.0013840608 0.0800739183 0.0800739183 0.0800739183 0.0763784931
## [5811] 0.0159105706 0.0110083648 0.1525970075 0.0090418936 0.0722643233
## [5816] 0.1142617184 0.1407682160 0.0581594755 0.1023456563 0.0399971086
## [5821] 0.1721248629 0.1721248629 0.0616193875 0.1577924576 0.1037984588
## [5826] 0.0201296053 0.0201296053 0.2503820653 0.2503820653 0.1438228669
## [5831] 0.6941475682 0.1785512673 0.1785512673 0.0333968801 0.0026078265
## [5836] 0.0026078265 0.0320871494 0.0320871494 0.0320871494 0.1785838189
## [5841] 0.0088033672 0.0691079531 0.0691079531 0.3535364915 0.3535364915
## [5846] 0.0397027974 0.0955485348 0.2118028129 0.0304527236 0.0304527236
## [5851] 0.0013388890 0.1858039663 0.0556296216 0.0202670010 0.1296602623
## [5856] 0.1296602623 0.0816743546 0.0816743546 0.0816743546 0.0816743546
## [5861] 0.5724898631 0.0666756774 0.0666756774 0.0840491529 0.0840491529
## [5866] 0.0840491529 0.0150011346 0.0150011346 0.0150011346 0.0150011346
## [5871] 0.0051338624 0.0098083418 0.1345395502 0.1345395502 0.1345395502
## [5876] 0.0275591071 0.4161318820 0.1788722055 0.1788722055 0.1788722055
## [5881] 0.2455547952 0.2396323660 0.2396323660 0.2396323660 0.2396323660
## [5886] 0.2396323660 0.0286288629 0.3582702892 0.0056870553 0.2963796760
## [5891] 0.0888451528 0.0261415388 0.0407153281 0.0037567325 0.0034995358
## [5896] 0.2279153562 0.2279153562 0.2279153562 0.0097573998 0.0405078500
## [5901] 0.1787518712 0.1053753358 0.0691218285 0.4229871084 0.0369996522
## [5906] 0.2938093620 0.2129781056 0.2305032996 0.0385814062 0.0815415095
## [5911] 0.1247204807 0.0122230604 0.0122230604 0.0122230604 0.0092912016
## [5916] 0.0050899389 0.0050899389 0.0050899389 0.0050899389 0.0452088771
## [5921] 0.0452088771 0.0279238237 0.0279238237 0.0279238237 0.0279238237
## [5926] 0.0279238237 0.2734811391 0.2734811391 0.2734811391 0.0122512964
## [5931] 0.0103604374 0.0734805047 0.1464474283 0.0499319763 0.0499319763
## [5936] 0.0326268636 0.0326268636 0.0326268636 0.0068243794 0.0068243794
## [5941] 0.0022482557 0.0022482557 0.0245688074 0.0245688074 0.0245688074
## [5946] 0.3775999761 0.4423630245 0.4423630245 0.0202307002 0.0074568294
## [5951] 0.0074568294 0.0074568294 0.2513959767 0.0630157776 0.0630157776
## [5956] 0.0630157776 0.0630157776 0.0630157776 0.0630157776 0.0638865746
## [5961] 0.0638865746 0.0638865746 0.1984997150 0.1984997150 0.1984997150
## [5966] 0.0700106268 0.0373689624 0.0970788246 0.0366488915 0.0108720190
## [5971] 0.0108720190 0.0108720190 0.5344759568 0.5344759568 0.0506742994
## [5976] 0.0012184100 0.2704544428 0.1878505311 0.1878505311 0.1878505311
## [5981] 0.1878505311 0.1312741507 0.2688384745 0.0330591541 0.0191426483
## [5986] 0.0292761284 0.0972878038 0.0192000114 0.0192000114 0.0445695023
## [5991] 0.1816003609 0.1816003609 0.0716401745 0.3689712924 0.3689712924
## [5996] 0.0184297686 0.1270941296 0.2033839345 0.2298964882 0.1782521690
## [6001] 0.1209187006 0.1209187006 0.1209187006 0.1209187006 0.1209187006
## [6006] 0.2984907871 0.0079626729 0.0782800449 0.0782800449 0.0071573662
## [6011] 0.0071573662 0.2743738685 0.0692544632 0.0692544632 0.0086324969
## [6016] 0.0086324969 0.1150058887 0.1150058887 0.0327017476 0.1201985144
## [6021] 0.1201985144 0.1201985144 0.0031645177 0.0031645177 0.0045288318
## [6026] 0.0045288318 0.2626161786 0.0727516977 0.0727516977 0.1242841528
## [6031] 0.1242841528 0.1823248256 0.1308920679 0.1308920679 0.1308920679
## [6036] 0.1308920679 0.1308920679 0.0049384929 0.1630909563 0.0597640977
## [6041] 0.0070149286 0.0070149286 0.0070149286 0.0070149286 0.0044185594
## [6046] 0.4756964022 0.4756964022 0.4756964022 0.4756964022 0.4756964022
## [6051] 0.1031366941 0.0395992169 0.0752262818 0.0752262818 0.0752262818
## [6056] 0.4827775423 0.0027444738 0.0027444738 0.0027444738 0.0027444738
## [6061] 0.3370415575 0.0657182492 0.0504319502 0.2403400526 0.1872325185
## [6066] 0.0129997718 0.0129997718 0.0129997718 0.0129997718 0.0129997718
## [6071] 0.0619789371 0.0619789371 0.0619789371 0.0619789371 0.0619789371
## [6076] 0.0619789371 0.0065353531 0.0042891376 0.0134351538 0.0134351538
## [6081] 0.0050767319 0.0020271408 0.1907780427 0.1907780427 0.1907780427
## [6086] 0.0657856228 0.0715088285 0.5788938440 0.1134487939 0.5936484385
## [6091] 0.1173387130 0.1415441210 0.1415441210 0.0686520231 0.2182789729
## [6096] 0.2182789729 0.2182789729 0.2185753933 0.0119484489 0.0119484489
## [6101] 0.0641544606 0.0168073349 0.0604322507 0.0604322507 0.0604322507
## [6106] 0.0604322507 0.0136760774 0.0136760774 0.0305172819 0.1253684890
## [6111] 0.1253684890 0.1253684890 0.1318649375 0.1318649375 0.1841346934
## [6116] 0.0191703486 0.0748935033 0.0748935033 0.0713503250 0.0252819490
## [6121] 0.0252819490 0.0252819490 0.0065263601 0.0065263601 0.0065263601
## [6126] 0.0065263601 0.2600735293 0.0099644158 0.1696245030 0.0246420102
## [6131] 0.0246420102 0.1117828776 0.1818202518 0.1418277224 0.0429590305
## [6136] 0.2519544154 0.0067751607 0.0166415241 0.0718693775 0.0087631487
## [6141] 0.0087631487 0.0569056495 0.0569056495 0.0569056495 0.0569056495
## [6146] 0.3088472534 0.0075264974 0.0517163324 0.0517163324 0.0517163324
## [6151] 0.0517163324 0.0517163324 0.0822531350 0.1020214621 0.0590801554
## [6156] 0.1371410993 0.1371410993 0.1371410993 0.0277871907 0.1199997519
## [6161] 0.1199997519 0.4854047783 0.0495463568 0.0488830973 0.0488830973
## [6166] 0.0829569811 0.3427290332 0.0142320187 0.1990209090 0.1990209090
## [6171] 0.6208565803 0.0033947901 0.0033947901 0.0226235816 0.0216737111
## [6176] 0.0216737111 0.2982717205 0.0008283317 0.0008283317 0.0008283317
## [6181] 0.1150306313 0.0060602463 0.0867841661 0.0113653832 0.1676721886
## [6186] 0.1676721886 0.1695564748 0.0359785987 0.0398579557 0.0398579557
## [6191] 0.0893381377 0.0893381377 0.0174301955 0.1712084785 0.1726055596
## [6196] 0.1726055596 0.0703973349 0.4014270779 0.1156271741 0.1156271741
## [6201] 0.1156271741 0.1156271741 0.0096184178 0.0044359726 0.1181031656
## [6206] 0.4902546943 0.1421011582 0.1833465485 0.0129505327 0.0057872824
## [6211] 0.0057872824 0.3163000057 0.0537493449 0.0032586364 0.1388616123
## [6216] 0.1186886251 0.0259099539 0.0259099539 0.0259099539 0.0259099539
## [6221] 0.0580497248 0.0580497248 0.1804209249 0.0076586967 0.0068868438
## [6226] 0.1081739155 0.1081739155 0.1081739155 0.1081739155 0.2398541514
## [6231] 0.2398541514 0.0021378654 0.0289432181 0.1061029598 0.0656544260
## [6236] 0.1579651529 0.2180641143 0.4797082483 0.0293338606 0.0293338606
## [6241] 0.0735692588 0.0656330825 0.0044634140 0.5050630205 0.7452360857
## [6246] 0.0038364359 0.0043043291 0.0043043291 0.2566485177 0.2566485177
## [6251] 0.2566485177 0.2566485177 0.0185235969 0.1650722467 0.1650722467
## [6256] 0.1650722467 0.1650722467 0.0257523518 0.0019624318 0.0019624318
## [6261] 0.0250977016 0.4119602671 0.0095984401 0.1743677272 0.0249153765
## [6266] 0.0249153765 0.0912434936 0.1156201343 0.1156201343 0.2340360838
## [6271] 0.2340360838 0.0720708642 0.1097248142 0.2867671519 0.0066561142
## [6276] 0.1704899400 0.3878939951 0.2297911574 0.1068532257 0.1068532257
## [6281] 0.1068532257 0.1068532257 0.0343534594 0.1889223389 0.1749066114
## [6286] 0.0824543636 0.0824543636 0.0827984186 0.0132415380 0.0133837316
## [6291] 0.0133837316 0.2786739449 0.2786739449 0.2603427539 0.2603427539
## [6296] 0.1939409908 0.1939409908 0.0957855612 0.1552125391 0.0570208292
## [6301] 0.0341360812 0.0570208292 0.0376550507 0.0376550507 0.0376550507
## [6306] 0.0376550507 0.2848596139 0.0397054289 0.1463303284 0.1463303284
## [6311] 0.1909914317 0.0059125680 0.0059125680 0.0073886506 0.0073886506
## [6316] 0.0544406360 0.0544406360 0.0544406360 0.0544406360 0.0467969122
## [6321] 0.1661305510 0.0294265675 0.1652491181 0.0028611686 0.0028611686
## [6326] 0.0028611686 0.1449082335 0.0032758446 0.3961499435 0.3961499435
## [6331] 0.3961499435 0.3961499435 0.0039114015 0.1150162481 0.0837435580
## [6336] 0.0837435580 0.0837435580 0.0837435580 0.0837435580 0.0043835598
## [6341] 0.0188025977 0.0063228856 0.0070903926 0.0070903926 0.2328624837
## [6346] 0.2328624837 0.0199729572 0.0199729572 0.0199729572 0.0199729572
## [6351] 0.2424971335 0.0093812502 0.0067576041 0.3100068737 0.0494662695
## [6356] 0.0220513409 0.1286246707 0.0057177931 0.0100068939 0.0100068939
## [6361] 0.0020364800 0.1000720813 0.1000720813 0.1000720813 0.0546648085
## [6366] 0.0045616737 0.0045616737 0.2965446802 0.2965446802 0.2965446802
## [6371] 0.2965446802 0.2965446802 0.2965446802 0.2965446802 0.0792231344
## [6376] 0.0792231344 0.1125631631 0.1125631631 0.1125631631 0.1125631631
## [6381] 0.1125631631 0.0128127789 0.0128127789 0.0026191028 0.0022685238
## [6386] 0.0028672813 0.0022685238 0.0022685238 0.0022685238 0.3403046701
## [6391] 0.0776183551 0.0138264726 0.0138264726 0.0916188545 0.0354513523
## [6396] 0.0204269759 0.5614555724 0.0829112128 0.0829112128 0.0829112128
## [6401] 0.8385813406 0.1089119849 0.1089119849 0.6314219116 0.0374758910
## [6406] 0.0374758910 0.0374758910 0.0340373946 0.1489650038 0.0869900036
## [6411] 0.2130510768 0.2130510768 0.0061183702 0.2909984295 0.0115717089
## [6416] 0.0115717089 0.0115717089 0.0115717089 0.0211175848 0.0211175848
## [6421] 0.0080292216 0.0080292216 0.0080292216 0.4744236010 0.4744236010
## [6426] 0.0057435258 0.1330320580 0.0098328952 0.0543111276 0.0543111276
## [6431] 0.0543111276 0.0803918899 0.0061896108 0.0061896108 0.0061896108
## [6436] 0.0061896108 0.0944239897 0.0192042355 0.0442119351 0.0338976655
## [6441] 0.0338976655 0.0338976655 0.0928164500 0.0928164500 0.7084380490
## [6446] 0.7084380490 0.1251794795 0.0581084893 0.0019074001 0.0019074001
## [6451] 0.0889510056 0.2567076649 0.5614730313 0.2372154331 0.1277196342
## [6456] 0.0155293033 0.0155293033 0.0155293033 0.0155293033 0.0155293033
## [6461] 0.0115329260 0.1092979431 0.1092979431 0.1092979431 0.0560462019
## [6466] 0.0104420437 0.0860413552 0.0860413552 0.3639278489 0.5780041544
## [6471] 0.7162746774 0.6996912799 0.6996912799 0.6996912799 0.0085332732
## [6476] 0.0085332732 0.0085332732 0.1820858368 0.0118934545 0.2352228493
## [6481] 0.0174168845 0.2074515074 0.0093303115 0.0320802872 0.0320802872
## [6486] 0.0065601274 0.0104430097 0.0104430097 0.0082405119 0.0371016140
## [6491] 0.0371016140 0.0371016140 0.0371016140 0.0371016140 0.0331250295
## [6496] 0.0023787506 0.0023787506 0.0053123293 0.0130642880 0.0130642880
## [6501] 0.0051022458 0.0051022458 0.5559451516 0.0644173905 0.0644173905
## [6506] 0.0644173905 0.0720313240 0.4275611287 0.0040221664 0.0069649239
## [6511] 0.0584518266 0.0584518266 0.0584518266 0.1102751350 0.0192350655
## [6516] 0.0671987364 0.1025227352 0.0918663574 0.2380322636 0.0055751300
## [6521] 0.6878040731 0.0845973730 0.0184732088 0.0184732088 0.0184732088
## [6526] 0.0068270339 0.0089478698 0.1967877792 0.0333157765 0.0333157765
## [6531] 0.0333157765 0.0333157765 0.3418870781 0.0087524842 0.0087524842
## [6536] 0.0087524842 0.0360802068 0.0360802068 0.4050593384 0.0884887616
## [6541] 0.0884887616 0.0074133292 0.0074133292 0.0587844316 0.0494441346
## [6546] 0.1479922706 0.0260093549 0.0260093549 0.0260093549 0.1299198046
## [6551] 0.0465244947 0.0531842588 0.0191438488 0.0191438488 0.0191438488
## [6556] 0.4871542540 0.1987634151 0.1003789221 0.0619717753 0.0519247019
## [6561] 0.0519247019 0.0519247019 0.0065659936 0.0065659936 0.0065659936
## [6566] 0.0553494228 0.0610772982 0.0610772982 0.1039193600 0.1039193600
## [6571] 0.1039193600 0.1039193600 0.1039193600 0.0182447644 0.1236429825
## [6576] 0.1236429825 0.1236429825 0.0738090609 0.0738090609 0.0836755146
## [6581] 0.0390675322 0.0761535197 0.0761535197 0.0761535197 0.0055404938
## [6586] 0.0055404938 0.0055404938 0.0034422081 0.0035151899 0.0035151899
## [6591] 0.0016961614 0.0016961614 0.1179074522 0.0379694070 0.0379694070
## [6596] 0.0739597944 0.2050302717 0.0311606161 0.0437852300 0.0437852300
## [6601] 0.0437852300 0.0085735649 0.0085735649 0.4531253258 0.0327545387
## [6606] 0.1258198003 0.0275619271 0.0275619271 0.0201142034 0.0201142034
## [6611] 0.0201142034 0.0021025703 0.0838187427 0.0103048666 0.0375323119
## [6616] 0.0628794140 0.0628794140 0.0628794140 0.0067887673 0.0265718697
## [6621] 0.0265718697 0.0265718697 0.0265718697 0.1114708523 0.1114708523
## [6626] 0.0117516729 0.0166770017 0.0296227181 0.1395387935 0.2293366080
## [6631] 0.2293366080 0.0065846009 0.0065846009 0.0812024434 0.0812024434
## [6636] 0.0019539674 0.0231740031 0.1334461294 0.2501870031 0.0719908891
## [6641] 0.0825572365 0.0189071674 0.0101196051 0.0101196051 0.0101196051
## [6646] 0.1314325092 0.1314325092 0.1333696441 0.0112929909 0.0070749953
## [6651] 0.1094791800 0.0359726922 0.0359726922 0.0043501238 0.0043501238
## [6656] 0.0930473064 0.0025337946 0.0018395699 0.0025337946 0.0049657838
## [6661] 0.4641233157 0.2194339151 0.0406313449 0.0406313449 0.0406313449
## [6666] 0.4599464640 0.0310886065 0.0310886065 0.0070251397 0.0070251397
## [6671] 0.0070251397 0.0070251397 0.0070251397 0.0031647258 0.0343575240
## [6676] 0.0343575240 0.0343575240 0.0404734320 0.0404734320 0.0404734320
## [6681] 0.0404734320 0.0146173173 0.0113477637 0.0087893867 0.2040910718
## [6686] 0.0767318014 0.0563450774 0.0766587571 0.0105167090 0.0166455804
## [6691] 0.0227586968 0.0227586968 0.0227586968 0.2179894364 0.2566186678
## [6696] 0.0542676337 0.0542676337 0.0542676337 0.2314024778 0.1467307400
## [6701] 0.0779870749 0.0873538068 0.0193074749 0.0089068288 0.0126125165
## [6706] 0.0161139182 0.0141698209 0.0155280197 0.0206432879 0.0380257311
## [6711] 0.0380257311 0.1372022336 0.1372022336 0.3581677261 0.1521820292
## [6716] 0.0765966630 0.0765966630 0.0765966630 0.0765966630 0.0172356320
## [6721] 0.0054390727 0.1166285907 0.0931413863 0.0931413863 0.0931413863
## [6726] 0.0931413863 0.3010238455 0.2105251587 0.2105251587 0.0739327297
## [6731] 0.1064601695 0.0095467936 0.1932283492 0.2593181009 0.2593181009
## [6736] 0.1047204907 0.0241460564 0.0241460564 0.0231540498 0.0207776987
## [6741] 0.1070677266 0.1070677266 0.1070677266 0.0686990614 0.0686990614
## [6746] 0.0686990614 0.0686990614 0.0686990614 0.0686990614 0.0176636515
## [6751] 0.0176636515 0.0176636515 0.1229812322 0.4371840214 0.0439290636
## [6756] 0.2505866845 0.1118210852 0.0102289464 0.3705225681 0.0752788742
## [6761] 0.1618852840 0.0401851518 0.0249831529 0.0055353852 0.0613650376
## [6766] 0.0613650376 0.0613650376 0.0613650376 0.0613650376 0.0359705208
## [6771] 0.0934926909 0.0934926909 0.0160868495 0.0160868495 0.0120886199
## [6776] 0.2679955003 0.2679955003 0.1566026755 0.0091022316 0.0132100899
## [6781] 0.0080712645 0.0248789623 0.1268271358 0.1268271358 0.1268271358
## [6786] 0.0123050988 0.0046204682 0.0046204682 0.0046204682 0.0203232618
## [6791] 0.1073262292 0.1709020718 0.0085268075 0.2874609963 0.2874609963
## [6796] 0.2077796332 0.2077796332 0.2077796332 0.2374869700 0.2374869700
## [6801] 0.2374869700 0.2486681586 0.2374869700 0.0845861978 0.0845861978
## [6806] 0.1263708982 0.1990601249 0.1263708982 0.0243756285 0.0243756285
## [6811] 0.0243756285 0.0160226435 0.2032657599 0.0045170650 0.0179629989
## [6816] 0.0149548186 0.0149548186 0.1832471162 0.1832471162 0.0396216525
## [6821] 0.0396216525 0.0396216525 0.0396216525 0.0111764787 0.0111764787
## [6826] 0.0111764787 0.0111764787 0.0145162393 0.0122664448 0.0080253201
## [6831] 0.0080253201 0.0080253201 0.0019527928 0.0071551338 0.0071551338
## [6836] 0.0655252027 0.0655252027 0.2224560761 0.0368021095 0.0368021095
## [6841] 0.0368021095 0.0368021095 0.0110540891 0.0335707326 0.0335707326
## [6846] 0.0335707326 0.0445562520 0.0021581996 0.0021581996 0.3125027979
## [6851] 0.0055313884 0.0055313884 0.5572244799 0.5572244799 0.0689691371
## [6856] 0.0689691371 0.0689691371 0.1013094169 0.1013094169 0.1013094169
## [6861] 0.1783964066 0.0296396781 0.0473945219 0.0378222063 0.0378222063
## [6866] 0.0823053501 0.0823053501 0.0134792792 0.0413262837 0.0483540440
## [6871] 0.0802090038 0.0802090038 0.0802090038 0.1572651051 0.0596385873
## [6876] 0.0596385873 0.3016637882 0.0098630084 0.2564921005 0.0028490065
## [6881] 0.0028490065 0.0028490065 0.0028490065 0.0088434815 0.0088434815
## [6886] 0.0088434815 0.0088434815 0.0812990955 0.0096614468 0.0096614468
## [6891] 0.1901787513 0.1901787513 0.0012899560 0.0241447647 0.0241447647
## [6896] 0.0241447647 0.0742612378 0.1375038674 0.0533329721 0.0533329721
## [6901] 0.0032344989 0.0032344989 0.2125628661 0.0054418462 0.0482572270
## [6906] 0.0083659277 0.0083659277 0.1324943247 0.1324943247 0.1324943247
## [6911] 0.1017161564 0.1017993060 0.1017993060 0.1017993060 0.1017993060
## [6916] 0.0790566390 0.0790566390 0.0017697371 0.0017697371 0.2988275317
## [6921] 0.0548253446 0.0548253446 0.0548253446 0.0548253446 0.0090025637
## [6926] 0.0281500385 0.0234041060 0.0399769489 0.1265542882 0.1265542882
## [6931] 0.2538988129 0.0067921395 0.0067921395 0.0067921395 0.2739322087
## [6936] 0.0121200563 0.1672734456 0.0317928144 0.0499135402 0.0499135402
## [6941] 0.0499135402 0.0499135402 0.0499135402 0.0652342158 0.0652342158
## [6946] 0.0652342158 0.0944935701 0.1433532804 0.0012721875 0.0012721875
## [6951] 0.2011865123 0.0230854479 0.1429514955 0.0625109529 0.3673190358
## [6956] 0.0593484041 0.0593484041 0.0593484041 0.0068375524 0.1729470550
## [6961] 0.0717602031 0.0440616546 0.0103263937 0.0103263937 0.0199947507
## [6966] 0.0199947507 0.0938247222 0.0043611111 0.0789309069 0.0789309069
## [6971] 0.0450661428 0.0450661428 0.1845371284 0.0211530123 0.0211530123
## [6976] 0.0211530123 0.0345649059 0.0345649059 0.0363599158 0.1110786931
## [6981] 0.0065842973 0.0065842973 0.0052304883 0.0146421128 0.0533565589
## [6986] 0.0533565589 0.0154311944 0.0061491596 0.0061491596 0.0061491596
## [6991] 0.0570070087 0.0570070087 0.0570070087 0.0171271813 0.0239812003
## [6996] 0.0239812003 0.0726732968 0.0726732968 0.0726732968 0.0726732968
## [7001] 0.0726732968 0.0412669936 0.0917559530 0.0917559530 0.0917559530
## [7006] 0.0469555857 0.0079224209 0.0079224209 0.0079224209 0.0040603720
## [7011] 0.0225690321 0.0038639240 0.0634697814 0.0634697814 0.0634697814
## [7016] 0.0393329529 0.0393329529 0.0393329529 0.0393329529 0.0015354207
## [7021] 0.0015354207 0.0119241888 0.0119241888 0.0119241888 0.0013816689
## [7026] 0.0013816689 0.0949390841 0.0949390841 0.2076817939 0.2076817939
## [7031] 0.2076817939 0.2076817939 0.2076817939 0.5395823281 0.6183323086
## [7036] 0.1166791246 0.1166791246 0.2918208966 0.2918208966 0.2918208966
## [7041] 0.2918208966 0.1775174277 0.0678630680 0.0662803641 0.0557046230
## [7046] 0.2368984237 0.0786860635 0.0786860635 0.0618965143 0.0618965143
## [7051] 0.0060751009 0.1701172609 0.0139582507 0.0155906768 0.0020586961
## [7056] 0.0143835515 0.0143835515 0.1418300656 0.0997981320 0.0285411298
## [7061] 0.0285411298 0.0098282054 0.0905657957 0.0255171797 0.0179524451
## [7066] 0.0179524451 0.0176504702 0.0129908211 0.2604205507 0.0120326433
## [7071] 0.0384308485 0.0384308485 0.0384308485 0.0249430066 0.0076046684
## [7076] 0.0072686109 0.0071850078 0.0039361063 0.0039361063 0.0445214127
## [7081] 0.0445214127 0.0445214127 0.2547937520 0.0909858382 0.1864006664
## [7086] 0.0159688675 0.0509979167 0.2792484623 0.0290340934 0.0290340934
## [7091] 0.0233387889 0.2869045560 0.0067630360 0.0067630360 0.0067630360
## [7096] 0.0067630360 0.0067630360 0.0185611024 0.5278596012 0.0066151984
## [7101] 0.0013674547 0.0013674547 0.1950349413 0.1217284518 0.0143353876
## [7106] 0.0018283984 0.0173139907 0.0173139907 0.0173139907 0.2021883348
## [7111] 0.2855885035 0.0428422525 0.0428422525 0.0428422525 0.0643126311
## [7116] 0.0643126311 0.0080914213 0.0080914213 0.0024338867 0.1432023366
## [7121] 0.0820750735 0.0123165442 0.2003558492 0.3331419101 0.0057732916
## [7126] 0.0710531223 0.0564428909 0.0564428909 0.0564428909 0.0861889793
## [7131] 0.0861889793 0.0121248923 0.3216501633 0.3216501633 0.1620696726
## [7136] 0.1620696726 0.2100959968 0.2100959968 0.2100959968 0.1047662969
## [7141] 0.3215742941 0.3716589360 0.0132667423 0.1783798417 0.1783798417
## [7146] 0.1783798417 0.2259105218 0.0154680440 0.0154680440 0.1628279074
## [7151] 0.2714546766 0.7369112464 0.0073262745 0.0216407701 0.0165944686
## [7156] 0.2393650939 0.4226958299 0.1247976588 0.0220260706 0.0031230677
## [7161] 0.0133838306 0.0133838306 0.0025976153 0.0097058602 0.0932132054
## [7166] 0.0932132054 0.0105755955 0.0105755955 0.0105755955 0.0387343707
## [7171] 0.0387343707 0.0490438103 0.0273382789 0.0273382789 0.0070748723
## [7176] 0.0070748723 0.2932276043 0.4863374046 0.4863374046 0.0013282882
## [7181] 0.6608084173 0.0281084560 0.4563712844 0.0102376631 0.1506647506
## [7186] 0.1506647506 0.0239922091 0.0239922091 0.2429037449 0.2429037449
## [7191] 0.1087563862 0.1087563862 0.1384533468 0.0320592226 0.0453270288
## [7196] 0.0480501142 0.2579502027 0.2579502027 0.2270860984 0.0118686457
## [7201] 0.2364102025 0.0105204454 0.0105204454 0.1664600188 0.2442540780
## [7206] 0.2442540780 0.0167421512 0.0167421512 0.0111344031 0.0869532203
## [7211] 0.0869532203 0.0869532203 0.0869532203 0.4338771247 0.4338771247
## [7216] 0.4338771247 0.0049341286 0.0384210198 0.0049574236 0.2631225968
## [7221] 0.2112067291 0.3955287280 0.1421335212 0.1421335212 0.1421335212
## [7226] 0.1483770157 0.1483770157 0.0311688121 0.0311688121 0.0311688121
## [7231] 0.0165044699 0.1462450707 0.1462450707
## attr(,"smoother")
## [1] "lowess"
plot(
cal_boot,
xlab = "Predicted Probability",
ylab = "Observed Probability"
)
##
## n=7233 Mean absolute error=0.004 Mean squared error=5e-05
## 0.9 Quantile of absolute error=0.011
A perfectly calibrated model would lie on the 45-degree identity line.
Calibration should preferably be evaluated on validation or resampled predictions. The following calculation on the development data is shown to explain the definitions.
model_complete$lp <- as.numeric(
predict(
fit_spline,
type = "lp"
)
)
cal_intercept_model <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~ 1 + offset(lp),
data = model_complete,
family = binomial()
)
calibration_intercept <- unname(coef(cal_intercept_model)[1])
calibration_intercept
## [1] 3.057055e-10
Ideal value:
\[ \text{Calibration intercept}=0. \]
cal_slope_model <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~ lp,
data = model_complete,
family = binomial()
)
calibration_slope <- unname(coef(cal_slope_model)[2])
calibration_slope
## [1] 1
Ideal value:
\[ \text{Calibration slope}=1. \]
A slope less than 1 often indicates overly extreme predictions and overfitting.
The Brier score is
\[ \text{Brier} = \frac{1}{n}\sum_{i=1}^{n}(\hat p_i-y_i)^2. \]
brier_model <- mean(
(model_complete$pred_prob - model_complete$Diabetes_num)^2
)
prevalence <- mean(model_complete$Diabetes_num)
brier_null <- mean(
(prevalence - model_complete$Diabetes_num)^2
)
brier_model
## [1] 0.07563335
brier_null
## [1] 0.09217148
A smaller Brier score indicates lower overall prediction error.
To avoid dependence on an additional package, this tutorial calculates net benefit directly.
For a threshold probability \(p_t\), net benefit is
\[ NB = \frac{TP}{N} - \frac{FP}{N}\frac{p_t}{1-p_t}. \]
net_benefit_model <- function(y, p, threshold) {
pred_positive <- p >= threshold
tp <- sum(pred_positive & y == 1)
fp <- sum(pred_positive & y == 0)
n <- length(y)
tp / n - fp / n * threshold / (1 - threshold)
}
net_benefit_all <- function(y, threshold) {
prevalence <- mean(y)
prevalence - (1 - prevalence) * threshold / (1 - threshold)
}
thresholds <- seq(0.01, 0.50, by = 0.01)
dca_results <- tibble(
threshold = thresholds,
model = map_dbl(
thresholds,
~ net_benefit_model(
y = model_complete$Diabetes_num,
p = model_complete$pred_prob,
threshold = .x
)
),
treat_all = map_dbl(
thresholds,
~ net_benefit_all(
y = model_complete$Diabetes_num,
threshold = .x
)
),
treat_none = 0
) %>%
pivot_longer(
cols = c(model, treat_all, treat_none),
names_to = "Strategy",
values_to = "Net_Benefit"
)
ggplot(
dca_results,
aes(
x = threshold,
y = Net_Benefit,
linetype = Strategy
)
) +
geom_line(linewidth = 0.9) +
labs(
title = "Decision Curve Analysis",
x = "Threshold Probability",
y = "Net Benefit"
) +
theme_minimal()
DCA is used to determine whether the model provides useful clinical net benefit over a clinically relevant threshold range. It is not simply an automatic cutoff-selection procedure.
Suppose, for illustration, a threshold of 20% is clinically relevant.
cutoff <- 0.20
model_complete <- model_complete %>%
mutate(
pred_class = if_else(pred_prob >= cutoff, 1L, 0L)
)
confusion_matrix <- table(
Predicted = model_complete$pred_class,
Observed = model_complete$Diabetes_num
)
confusion_matrix
## Observed
## Predicted 0 1
## 0 5693 342
## 1 797 401
Calculate sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV:
tp <- sum(
model_complete$pred_class == 1 &
model_complete$Diabetes_num == 1
)
fp <- sum(
model_complete$pred_class == 1 &
model_complete$Diabetes_num == 0
)
tn <- sum(
model_complete$pred_class == 0 &
model_complete$Diabetes_num == 0
)
fn <- sum(
model_complete$pred_class == 0 &
model_complete$Diabetes_num == 1
)
classification_metrics <- tibble(
Metric = c("Sensitivity", "Specificity", "PPV", "NPV"),
Value = c(
tp / (tp + fn),
tn / (tn + fp),
tp / (tp + fp),
tn / (tn + fn)
)
)
classification_metrics
coords(
roc_obj,
x = "best",
best.method = "youden",
ret = c("threshold", "sensitivity", "specificity")
)
A Youden-optimal cutoff maximizes sensitivity + specificity - 1, but it does not directly incorporate clinical consequences, treatment burden, resource use, or the relative cost of false positives and false negatives.
For influence diagnostics, use the ordinary logistic model.
cook <- cooks.distance(fit_full)
cook_threshold <- 4 / nrow(model_complete)
influential_indices <- which(cook > cook_threshold)
cat("Number above 4/n threshold:", length(influential_indices), "\n")
## Number above 4/n threshold: 645
plot(
cook,
type = "h",
ylab = "Cook's Distance",
main = "Influence Diagnostic"
)
abline(h = cook_threshold, lty = 2)
The 4/n rule is only a screening heuristic. Large Cook’s
distance does not justify automatic deletion.
This is a sensitivity analysis, not the primary model.
model_sens <- model_complete[
cook <= cook_threshold,
,
drop = FALSE
]
fit_sens <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_sens,
family = binomial()
)
coef_comparison <- tibble(
Term = names(coef(fit_full)),
Primary = coef(fit_full),
Sensitivity = coef(fit_sens)[names(coef(fit_full))]
)
coef_comparison
Complete-case model:
fit_cc <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_cc,
family = binomial()
)
broom::tidy(
fit_cc,
exponentiate = TRUE,
conf.int = TRUE
)
Compare this with the pooled MI estimates reported earlier.
set.seed(2026)
val_linear <- validate(
fit_linear,
method = "boot",
B = 300
)
set.seed(2026)
val_spline <- validate(
fit_spline,
method = "boot",
B = 300
)
val_linear
## index.orig training test optimism index.corrected Lower Upper
## Dxy 0.6395 0.6424 0.6368 0.0056 0.6338 0.6044 0.6648
## R2 0.2546 0.2579 0.2520 0.0059 0.2487 0.2204 0.2766
## Intercept 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0306 0.0306 -0.0306 -0.2267 0.1722
## Slope 1.0000 1.0000 0.9855 0.0145 0.9855 0.8995 1.0790
## Emax 0.0000 0.0000 0.0211 -0.0211 0.0211 -0.0057 0.0671
## D 0.1314 0.1337 0.1300 0.0037 0.1277 0.1098 0.1451
## U -0.0003 -0.0003 0.0000 -0.0003 0.0000 -0.0005 0.0013
## Q 0.1317 0.1340 0.1299 0.0040 0.1276 0.1089 0.1449
## B 0.0781 0.0783 0.0784 -0.0001 0.0783 0.0739 0.0829
## g 1.4931 1.5056 1.4829 0.0227 1.4704 1.3604 1.5856
## gp 0.1157 0.1168 0.1152 0.0017 0.1140 0.1046 0.1238
## n
## Dxy 300
## R2 300
## Intercept 300
## Slope 300
## Emax 300
## D 300
## U 300
## Q 300
## B 300
## g 300
## gp 300
val_spline
## index.orig training test optimism index.corrected Lower Upper
## Dxy 0.6657 0.6708 0.6617 0.0091 0.6566 0.6274 0.6859
## R2 0.2844 0.2901 0.2800 0.0101 0.2743 0.2443 0.3032
## Intercept 0.0000 0.0000 -0.0476 0.0476 -0.0476 -0.2305 0.1494
## Slope 1.0000 1.0000 0.9738 0.0262 0.9738 0.8776 1.0651
## Emax 0.0000 0.0000 0.0230 -0.0230 0.0230 -0.0073 0.0715
## D 0.1480 0.1518 0.1456 0.0062 0.1418 0.1224 0.1601
## U -0.0003 -0.0003 0.0001 -0.0004 0.0001 -0.0005 0.0016
## Q 0.1483 0.1520 0.1455 0.0066 0.1417 0.1213 0.1602
## B 0.0756 0.0755 0.0760 -0.0005 0.0761 0.0719 0.0808
## g 1.8068 1.8412 1.7909 0.0503 1.7565 1.6079 1.9012
## gp 0.1225 0.1241 0.1217 0.0024 0.1201 0.1105 0.1298
## n
## Dxy 300
## R2 300
## Intercept 300
## Slope 300
## Emax 300
## D 300
## U 300
## Q 300
## B 300
## g 300
## gp 300
If a more complex spline model provides little improvement after optimism correction, the simpler linear model may be preferable.
Subgroup evaluation asks whether the same model performs similarly across clinically important groups. It is different from fitting a new model within each subgroup.
gender_auc <- model_complete %>%
split(.$Gender) %>%
imap_dfr(
function(dat, group_name) {
if (length(unique(dat$Diabetes_num)) < 2) {
return(
tibble(
Gender = group_name,
N = nrow(dat),
AUC = NA_real_
)
)
}
r <- roc(
dat$Diabetes_num,
dat$pred_prob,
quiet = TRUE
)
tibble(
Gender = group_name,
N = nrow(dat),
AUC = as.numeric(auc(r))
)
}
)
gender_auc
race_calibration <- model_complete %>%
group_by(Race1) %>%
summarise(
N = n(),
Observed = mean(Diabetes_num),
Predicted = mean(pred_prob),
Difference = Predicted - Observed,
.groups = "drop"
)
race_calibration
This is only a simple subgroup calibration summary. More complete subgroup validation would also examine calibration slopes and smooth calibration curves where sample size permits.
The NHANES teaching dataset contains two survey cycles.
We use the earlier cycle for development and the later cycle as a
temporal validation sample.
Check the actual coding first:
levels(NHANES$SurveyYr)
## [1] "2009_10" "2011_12"
table(NHANES$SurveyYr, useNA = "ifany")
##
## 2009_10 2011_12
## 5000 5000
For clarity, this section uses complete cases. In a publication-level analysis, the missing-data strategy should be carefully transported to the validation sample as well.
temporal_data <- NHANES %>%
filter(
Age >= 20,
Diabetes %in% c("Yes", "No")
) %>%
mutate(
Diabetes_num = if_else(Diabetes == "Yes", 1L, 0L)
) %>%
select(
SurveyYr,
Diabetes_num,
Age,
BMI,
BPSysAve,
TotChol,
Gender,
Race1,
PhysActive,
Smoke100
) %>%
drop_na()
survey_levels <- levels(droplevels(temporal_data$SurveyYr))
if (length(survey_levels) != 2) {
stop(
"Expected exactly two SurveyYr levels, but found: ",
paste(survey_levels, collapse = ", ")
)
}
survey_levels
## [1] "2009_10" "2011_12"
Use the first factor level as development and the second as validation:
development_level <- survey_levels[1]
validation_level <- survey_levels[2]
development <- temporal_data %>%
filter(SurveyYr == development_level) %>%
droplevels()
validation <- temporal_data %>%
filter(SurveyYr == validation_level) %>%
droplevels()
cat("Development cycle:", development_level, "N =", nrow(development), "\n")
## Development cycle: 2009_10 N = 3309
cat("Validation cycle:", validation_level, "N =", nrow(validation), "\n")
## Validation cycle: 2011_12 N = 3266
fit_dev <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = development,
family = binomial()
)
summary(fit_dev)
##
## Call:
## glm(formula = Diabetes_num ~ Age + BMI + BPSysAve + TotChol +
## Gender + Race1 + PhysActive + Smoke100, family = binomial(),
## data = development)
##
## Coefficients:
## Estimate Std. Error z value Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept) -6.8850902 0.6860389 -10.036 < 2e-16 ***
## Age 0.0664924 0.0047231 14.078 < 2e-16 ***
## BMI 0.0883082 0.0090216 9.789 < 2e-16 ***
## BPSysAve 0.0006185 0.0035770 0.173 0.86272
## TotChol -0.3032185 0.0651632 -4.653 3.27e-06 ***
## Gendermale 0.3103351 0.1300745 2.386 0.01704 *
## Race1Hispanic 0.1373539 0.3315429 0.414 0.67866
## Race1Mexican 0.1655300 0.2704597 0.612 0.54052
## Race1White -0.6308608 0.1940783 -3.251 0.00115 **
## Race1Other 0.4236475 0.2992126 1.416 0.15681
## PhysActiveYes -0.0059153 0.1328445 -0.045 0.96448
## Smoke100Yes 0.3063495 0.1285849 2.382 0.01720 *
## ---
## Signif. codes: 0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
##
## (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)
##
## Null deviance: 2182.4 on 3308 degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 1743.7 on 3297 degrees of freedom
## AIC: 1767.7
##
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 6
The validation model must not be refitted before performance is evaluated.
validation$pred <- predict(
fit_dev,
newdata = validation,
type = "response"
)
validation$lp <- predict(
fit_dev,
newdata = validation,
type = "link"
)
roc_val <- roc(
response = validation$Diabetes_num,
predictor = validation$pred,
quiet = TRUE
)
validation_auc <- as.numeric(auc(roc_val))
validation_auc_ci <- ci.auc(roc_val)
validation_auc
## [1] 0.8026075
validation_auc_ci
## 95% CI: 0.7787-0.8265 (DeLong)
plot(
roc_val,
print.auc = TRUE,
main = "ROC Curve: Temporal Validation"
)
cal_intercept_val_model <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~ 1 + offset(lp),
data = validation,
family = binomial()
)
cal_intercept_val <- unname(
coef(cal_intercept_val_model)[1]
)
cal_intercept_val
## [1] -0.1317141
Ideal:
\[ \alpha = 0. \]
cal_slope_val_model <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~ lp,
data = validation,
family = binomial()
)
cal_slope_val <- unname(
coef(cal_slope_val_model)[2]
)
cal_slope_val
## [1] 0.9214491
Ideal:
\[ \gamma = 1. \]
validation <- validation %>%
mutate(
risk_group = ntile(pred, 10)
)
calibration_table <- validation %>%
group_by(risk_group) %>%
summarise(
N = n(),
Predicted = mean(pred),
Observed = mean(Diabetes_num),
.groups = "drop"
)
calibration_table
ggplot(
calibration_table,
aes(
x = Predicted,
y = Observed
)
) +
geom_point() +
geom_line() +
geom_abline(
intercept = 0,
slope = 1,
linetype = 2
) +
coord_equal() +
labs(
title = "Temporal Validation Calibration",
x = "Mean Predicted Probability",
y = "Observed Proportion"
) +
theme_minimal()
brier_val <- mean(
(validation$pred - validation$Diabetes_num)^2
)
brier_val
## [1] 0.07749806
If discrimination remains acceptable but calibration has shifted, a recalibration model can be considered.
recal_model <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~ lp,
data = validation,
family = binomial()
)
coef(recal_model)
## (Intercept) lp
## -0.2579499 0.9214491
The updated linear predictor is
\[ LP_{new} = \alpha + \gamma LP_{old}, \]
where \(\alpha\) is the calibration intercept and \(\gamma\) is the calibration slope.
Predictions from the recalibrated model:
validation$pred_recalibrated <- predict(
recal_model,
type = "response"
)
head(
validation %>%
select(pred, pred_recalibrated)
)
For an easy-to-deploy risk calculator, use the ordinary logistic model fitted to the completed modeling dataset.
final_fit <- glm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete,
family = binomial()
)
coef(final_fit)
## (Intercept) Age BMI BPSysAve TotChol
## -7.112019578 0.060353831 0.094418073 0.004711273 -0.287435639
## Gendermale Race1Hispanic Race1Mexican Race1White Race1Other
## 0.323389816 -0.114460591 -0.025663962 -0.747630347 0.222607119
## PhysActiveYes Smoke100Yes
## -0.170460081 0.163988180
The linear predictor is
\[ LP = \beta_0 + \sum_{j=1}^{p}\beta_j X_j, \]
and the predicted probability is
\[ P(\text{Diabetes}) = \frac{e^{LP}}{1+e^{LP}}. \]
Factor levels can differ in capitalization across datasets. The following helper selects an available level using case-insensitive matching.
match_factor_level <- function(x, desired) {
lvls <- levels(x)
idx <- match(tolower(desired), tolower(lvls))
if (is.na(idx)) {
stop(
"Requested level '", desired,
"' not found. Available levels: ",
paste(lvls, collapse = ", ")
)
}
lvls[idx]
}
Inspect available levels:
levels(model_complete$Gender)
## [1] "female" "male"
levels(model_complete$Race1)
## [1] "Black" "Hispanic" "Mexican" "White" "Other"
levels(model_complete$PhysActive)
## [1] "No" "Yes"
levels(model_complete$Smoke100)
## [1] "No" "Yes"
Create an illustrative new patient:
new_patient <- tibble(
Age = 60,
BMI = 32,
BPSysAve = 145,
TotChol = 5.2,
Gender = factor(
match_factor_level(model_complete$Gender, "male"),
levels = levels(model_complete$Gender)
),
Race1 = factor(
match_factor_level(model_complete$Race1, "white"),
levels = levels(model_complete$Race1)
),
PhysActive = factor(
match_factor_level(model_complete$PhysActive, "no"),
levels = levels(model_complete$PhysActive)
),
Smoke100 = factor(
match_factor_level(model_complete$Smoke100, "yes"),
levels = levels(model_complete$Smoke100)
)
)
new_patient
new_patient_probability <- predict(
final_fit,
newdata = new_patient,
type = "response"
)
new_patient_probability
## 1
## 0.1763617
Because the NHANES example is cross-sectional, interpret
this as a model-based probability of prevalent diabetes
status, not future 5-year risk.
A nomogram can be created from the ordinary lrm()
model.
nom_fit <- lrm(
Diabetes_num ~
Age +
BMI +
BPSysAve +
TotChol +
Gender +
Race1 +
PhysActive +
Smoke100,
data = model_complete,
x = TRUE,
y = TRUE
)
nom <- nomogram(
nom_fit,
fun = plogis,
fun.at = c(0.05, 0.10, 0.20, 0.30, 0.50),
funlabel = "Probability of Diabetes"
)
plot(nom)
performance_summary <- tibble(
Domain = c(
"Development sample size",
"Development event rate",
"Apparent AUC",
"Apparent Brier score",
"Temporal validation sample size",
"Temporal validation AUC",
"Temporal validation calibration intercept",
"Temporal validation calibration slope",
"Temporal validation Brier score"
),
Value = c(
as.character(nrow(model_complete)),
sprintf("%.3f", mean(model_complete$Diabetes_num)),
sprintf("%.3f", as.numeric(auc(roc_obj))),
sprintf("%.3f", brier_model),
as.character(nrow(validation)),
sprintf("%.3f", validation_auc),
sprintf("%.3f", cal_intercept_val),
sprintf("%.3f", cal_slope_val),
sprintf("%.3f", brier_val)
)
)
performance_summary
A clinical prediction model should not be judged by AUC alone.
A useful summary is
\[ \boxed{ \text{Model Quality} = \text{Discrimination} + \text{Calibration} + \text{Prediction Error} + \text{Clinical Utility} + \text{Validation} } \]
Typical measure:
\[ AUC/C\text{-statistic}. \]
Question:
Can the model rank participants with the outcome above those without the outcome?
Typical measures:
Question:
Are predicted probabilities numerically close to observed risks?
Typical measure:
\[ \text{Brier Score}. \]
Typical method:
\[ \text{Decision Curve Analysis}. \]
Question:
Does using the model provide greater clinical net benefit than reasonable default strategies over relevant threshold probabilities?
Assess with:
The complete process can be summarized as:
Research question
↓
Define target population and outcome
↓
Choose clinically justified candidate predictors
↓
Check IDs and duplicates
↓
Check coding and variable types
↓
Check ranges and clinically impossible values
↓
Assess missingness
↓
Assess outliers
↓
EDA and descriptive statistics
↓
Check correlation and multicollinearity
↓
Assess continuous-variable functional forms
↓
Multiple imputation
↓
Fit prespecified/full model
↓
Consider nonlinear terms and interactions
↓
Consider penalization/shrinkage
↓
Estimate apparent performance
↓
Bootstrap internal validation
↓
Optimism-corrected discrimination
↓
Calibration assessment
↓
Brier score
↓
Decision-curve analysis
↓
Clinically justified threshold assessment
↓
Sensitivity analyses
↓
Subgroup performance
↓
Temporal/external validation
↓
Recalibration if needed
↓
Individual prediction
↓
Nomogram / calculator / deployment
For a real publication, consider the following upgrades beyond this teaching example:
10 events per variable rule.Always save session information so the analysis can be reproduced later.
sessionInfo()
## R version 4.4.3 (2025-02-28)
## Platform: aarch64-apple-darwin20
## Running under: macOS 26.5.2
##
## Matrix products: default
## BLAS: /Library/Frameworks/R.framework/Versions/4.4-arm64/Resources/lib/libRblas.0.dylib
## LAPACK: /Library/Frameworks/R.framework/Versions/4.4-arm64/Resources/lib/libRlapack.dylib; LAPACK version 3.12.0
##
## locale:
## [1] en_US.UTF-8/en_US.UTF-8/en_US.UTF-8/C/en_US.UTF-8/en_US.UTF-8
##
## time zone: America/New_York
## tzcode source: internal
##
## attached base packages:
## [1] stats graphics grDevices utils datasets methods base
##
## other attached packages:
## [1] broom_1.0.10 glmnet_4.1-10 Matrix_1.7-2 pROC_1.19.0.1
## [5] rms_8.1-1 Hmisc_5.2-5 car_3.1-3 carData_3.0-5
## [9] mice_3.19.0 naniar_1.1.0 gtsummary_2.5.0 lubridate_1.9.4
## [13] forcats_1.0.1 stringr_1.5.2 dplyr_1.2.0 purrr_1.1.0
## [17] readr_2.1.5 tidyr_1.3.1 tibble_3.2.1 ggplot2_4.0.2
## [21] tidyverse_2.0.0 NHANES_2.1.0
##
## loaded via a namespace (and not attached):
## [1] Rdpack_2.6.4 gridExtra_2.3 sandwich_3.1-1 rlang_1.1.7
## [5] magrittr_2.0.3 multcomp_1.4-30 polspline_1.1.25 compiler_4.4.3
## [9] vctrs_0.7.2 quantreg_6.1 pkgconfig_2.0.3 shape_1.4.6.1
## [13] fastmap_1.2.0 backports_1.5.0 labeling_0.4.3 rmarkdown_2.30
## [17] markdown_2.0 tzdb_0.5.0 nloptr_2.2.1 visdat_0.6.0
## [21] MatrixModels_0.5-4 xfun_0.53 jomo_2.7-6 cachem_1.1.0
## [25] litedown_0.7 jsonlite_2.0.0 pan_1.9 cluster_2.1.8
## [29] R6_2.6.1 bslib_0.9.0 stringi_1.8.7 RColorBrewer_1.1-3
## [33] boot_1.3-31 rpart_4.1.24 jquerylib_0.1.4 Rcpp_1.1.0
## [37] iterators_1.0.14 knitr_1.50 zoo_1.8-14 base64enc_0.1-3
## [41] splines_4.4.3 nnet_7.3-20 timechange_0.3.0 tidyselect_1.2.1
## [45] rstudioapi_0.17.1 abind_1.4-8 yaml_2.3.10 codetools_0.2-20
## [49] lattice_0.22-6 withr_3.0.2 S7_0.2.0 evaluate_1.0.5
## [53] foreign_0.8-88 survival_3.8-3 xml2_1.4.0 pillar_1.10.1
## [57] checkmate_2.3.4 foreach_1.5.2 reformulas_0.4.1 generics_0.1.4
## [61] hms_1.1.4 commonmark_2.0.0 scales_1.4.0 minqa_1.2.8
## [65] glue_1.8.0 tools_4.4.3 data.table_1.17.8 lme4_1.1-37
## [69] SparseM_1.84-2 fs_1.6.6 mvtnorm_1.3-3 grid_4.4.3
## [73] rbibutils_2.3 cards_0.7.1 colorspace_2.1-1 nlme_3.1-167
## [77] htmlTable_2.4.3 Formula_1.2-5 cli_3.6.5 gt_1.3.0
## [81] gtable_0.3.6 sass_0.4.10 digest_0.6.37 TH.data_1.1-5
## [85] htmlwidgets_1.6.4 farver_2.1.2 htmltools_0.5.8.1 lifecycle_1.0.5
## [89] mitml_0.4-5 MASS_7.3-64