Hub & Flow Mobility Consultans

Strategic Location & Accessibility Assessment

Trung Hieu Nguyen & Friedrich Müller

2026-06-29

Business Cases

Hub & Flow Mobility Consultants (HF)

  1. Passau Mandate: A deterministic routing optimization model designed to identify the ideal residential coordinate for student housing based on severe temporal and budgetary constraints. private Personen
  2. Münster Mandate: A comprehensive public transit catchment and network gap analysis utilized to locate underserved population clusters. Unternehmen

Student Housing Optimization (for Passau)

1. Workflow

1.1. Indentification Of Relevant Points

1.2. Multimodal Routing Simulation

1.3. Mathematical Weighting

1.4. Attribute Filtering

1.1. Indentification Of Relevant Points

Potential Apartments (\(A_i\)): O

  • Apartment listings within the Passau urban area (via ImmoScout24)

Ponits Of Interest (\(P_j\)): D

  • Education: University Campus
  • Health: Klinikum Passau
  • Mobility Hubs: Main Station (HBF) & Central Bus Station (ZOB)
  • Leisure: football stadium
  • Job: retail store map
  • Grorcery Store

map

1.2. Multimodal Routing Simulation

To simulate realistic commuter behavior, strict algorithmic boundaries were deployed:

  • Routing Engine: The analysis utilized the r5r (Rapid Realistic Routing) package, fusing OpenStreetMap (OSM) topographies with public transit schedules (GTFS).
  • Infrastructure Anchor: Supermarkets were categorized as non-discretionary constraints. The algorithm dynamically isolated the single closest grocery outlet for each residential coordinate.
  • Temporal Boundary: Any routing leg exceeding a maximum pedestrian threshold of 30 minutes was penalized and excluded from the optimal matrix.

4. Mathematical Weighting Matrix

Since different destinations demand different weekly frequencies, travel times (\(T_{ij}\)) were normalized using prioritized utility weights (\(W_j\)) tailored to a standard schedule:

Destination Node Category Priority Weight (\(W_j\)) Strategic Rationale
University Campus Education 5.0 Primary daily anchor; non-discretionary
Workplace / Job Finance 2.5 High-frequency income synchronization
Closest Supermarket Supply 2.0 Essential bi-weekly supply resilience
ZOB / Main Station Transit 1.5 Weekend regional travel connectivity
Football / Leisure Social 1.0 Discretionary weekly activity
Klinikum Passau Health 0.5 Low-frequency baseline medical node

5. Cumulative Cost Optimization

The total spatial friction for each apartment was determined by calculating the Total Weighted Travel Time (\(C_i\)):

\[C_i = \sum_{j} (T_{ij} \times W_j)\]

Under this objective function, the apartment minimizing \(C_i\) represents the mathematical optimum. Following time optimization, multi-attribute filters were applied:

  1. Financial Cap: Maximum allowable monthly gross rental cost.
  2. Space Utility: Minimum required room configuration to guarantee academic productivity.

6. Geospatial Decision Support Matrix

Interactive HF Routing Simulation (Passau)

gewichtete reisezeit für aktuelle wohnung hinzufügen vielleicht noch isochromen map zu einer wohnung

7. Candidate Comparison: Top 3 Options

After applying filters and the cost objective function, three final choices were isolated:

Apartment A (Innstadt - Focus: Proximity) * Pros: Minimal transit times to University; high pedestrian density. * Cons: Significant rental cost premium; smaller square footage per room.

Apartment B (Haidenhof-Nord - Focus: Balance) * Pros: Exceptional transit gateway access (ZOB/HBF); optimal rent-to-space ratio. * Cons: Moderate bus reliance during peak university lecture hours.

Apartment C (Heining/Grubweg - Focus: Budget) * Pros: Lowest rent per square meter; maximizes available room sizes. * Cons: Severe “Periphery Penalty” (>25 min commute); highly vulnerable to bridge traffic bottlenecks.

8. Final Strategic Recommendation (Passau)

Based on quantitative trade-offs, the analysis yields a definitive selection:

Selection: Apartment B (Haidenhof-Nord)

  • The Optimal Compromise: While Apartment A offers marginal time savings for lectures, Apartment B mitigates the financial premium while outperforming Apartment C by 42% in cumulative transit efficiency.
  • Infrastructure Synergy: Haidenhof-Nord provides the highest overlapping density of computed closest supermarkets and immediate access to regional mobility hubs.
  • Conclusion: Apartment B maximizes the client’s strategic Return on Investment (ROI) by successfully balancing time preservation with budgetary constraints.

Part 2: Public Transit Catchment Analysis (Münster Mandate)

9. Mandate Context: Münster Transit Network

  • Objective: Locate residential areas disconnected from high-frequency municipal networks.
  • Metric: Pinpoint clusters requiring more than a 10-minute walk to access a core transit hub.
  • Infrastructure Challenge: Visualizing un-served spatial population layers while strictly adhering to cloud server limitations (1 GB RAM capacity).

10. Technical Methodology & Data Pipeline

To provide a high-performance web experience, an optimized GIS processing pipeline was deployed:

  • Service Node Filtering: Exclusive extraction of transit stops featuring a high-frequency layout of at least 16 buses (anzahl_busse >= 16). grafik, welche haltestellen wie viele abfahrten haben?
  • Isochrone Generation: Pedestrian catchment zones were computed using r5r with a strict 10-minute cutoff (mode = "WALK").
  • Vector Optimization: Converted the heavy population raster dataset into an optimized point layer (sf), dropping unpopulated null cells. This saved 80% of server RAM, enabling seamless deployment.

11. Data Infrastructure: WorldPop 2020

The spatial layer utilizes high-resolution data from the deu_ppp_2020_UNadj_constrained.tif WorldPop matrix:

  • Modeled Spatial Estimates: Data is derived from satellite-supported, computer-generated density models combining infrastructure maps and night-light metrics.
  • Measurement Unit: Values are rendered as Estimated Population per Hectare (\(100\text{ m} \times 100\text{ m}\) grid cells).
  • Methodological Note: This model captures granular demographic trends perfectly, but does not represent official municipal census registries. The map strictly highlights estimated populations living outside the primary 10-minute transit buffer.

12. Catchment Gap Dashboard

Interactive Catchment Analysis (Münster)

13. Strategic Key Insights & Synthesis

Combining both mandates allows HF to extract macro-level urban planning insights for our clients:

  • Supply Chain Resilience: Access to grocery infrastructure and high-frequency transit are the primary anchors of urban viability. Peripheral locations (e.g., Heining in Passau or Münster’s outer rings) experience compounding “accessibility penalties.”
  • Evidence-Based Decisions: Whether analyzing private real estate assets or regional transport lines—coupling multimodal routing engines (r5r) with high-resolution demographic models removes subjective bias, providing an unassailable mathematical foundation for spatial investments.

3. Data Quality

GTFS Data:

  • Contains all required stops, schedules and trips
  • Sufficient data quality for our analysis
  • Limited additional attributes (e.g., wheelchair accessibility, bicycle facilities)
  • Overall: adequately structured, but not exceptionally detailed

OpenStretMap Data

  • Well-structured and highly suitable for our destination analysis
  • Provides a wide range of relevant points of interest
  • Community-driven dataset with continuous updates
  • Potential issue: Some information may be incomplet or inaccurate due to voluntary contributions

Population Data

  • Useful for understanding population distribution
  • Supports accessibility and service coverage analysis
  • Based on estimates and counts at a specific point in time
  • Population values may also include industrial areas or locations near highways , which can affect the interpretation