Lab 6: Coffee as a Colloidal Fluid and the Effect of Filtration
Duration: 2 hours
Equipment and Materials
Equipment
- Coffee grinder
- Brush
- Timer
- Digital balance
- Aeropress
- Aeropress filter paper
- Aeropress metal filter
- French press
- Microscope
- Graduated cylinder
- TDS meter or digital refractometer
- Beaker
- Electric kettle or Hot plate + Thermocouple
Materials
- Roasted coffee beans (≥ 180 g per group)
- Water (≥ 2 L per group)
Background
We have learned in previous labs that the extraction time is a critical parameter that affects the final taste of the coffee. In most methods of brewing coffee, the extraction time is controlled by how quickly the hot water moves past the coffee grounds. To look deeper into the fluid velocity, we will need fluid mechanics (yay!).
For this lab, we will focus on how liquids move through porous media, in this case coffee grounds. Recall Darcy’s Law, which states that the velocity of the liquid (in cm/s) is proportional to the pressure difference across the porous medium:
\[ v \approx \frac{\kappa}{\mu}{\nabla}P = \frac{\kappa}{\mu}\frac{(P_{entrance}- P_{exit})}{L} \] where \(\mu\) is viscosity, \(\kappa\) is permeability, and \(\nabla P\) is thepressure gradient. When you use the Mr. Coffee or a pour-over, the pressure difference is provided by the gravity acting on the weight of the water. Other devices provide more control over the pressure gradient, like in an espresso machine. A key goal today is to gaina qualitative appreciation for Darcy’s Law and how quickly liquid flows through the porous grounds and affects the taste of the resulting cup. The lower the applied pressure, the longer the effective extraction time will be, with a corresponding impact on the mass transfer and sensory qualities of the brew.
Previously we also looked at the TDS of a brew. Some of the mass extracted from the grounds are dissolved organic molecules, but there are also dissolved gasses, primarily carbon dioxide and VOCs. The concentration of \(CO_2\) is especially high is especially high in freshly roasted beans, since it hasn’t had as sufficient time to off-gas. When you pour hot water over grounds and you see bubbles rising to the top of the slurry that is a good sign that you’re using freshly roasted coffee!
Additionally, some amount of non-dissolved solids makes it past the filter and into the brew. Ideally during grinding you would make coffee particles all of the same size, but this never happens. Particles smaller than the average pore size in the filter are carried into the brew and get consumed. These small particles are referred to as colloidal particles. Colloids are typically in the range of 1 to 10,000 nanometers and undergo Brownian motion. This is the same sort of random jiggling motion that individual molecules perform, but some colloids are large enough that you can see the Brownian motion with a standard optical microscope. In coffee, the colloids strongly affect the body and mouthfeel by altering the viscosity. The more colloids, the higher the “mouthfeel”.
Finally, there are emulsified oils in the brew. The term “emulsion” simply means a colloidal suspension made of liquid droplets rather than solid, like a vinaigrette. Roasting coffee releases a variety of oils, which you can often see on the surface of dark roasted beans. As with the solid colloids, the emulsified oil droplets also affect the mouthfeel by altering the viscosity. The oil tends to be more potent though since many of the bitter tasting molecules tend to be more oil soluble than water soluble. Typically a little bit of oil is to be desired.
Both the colloids and the emulsified oil are strongly affected by the type of filtration. The filter pore size controls the size of the colloids that make it inot the brew. Less obvious is the composition of the filter matters tremendously. Paper filters are made of cellulosic fibers, which is hydrophobic and oleophilic. In contrast, metal filters are more oleophobic.
Today, you will perform four brews with the Aeropress to quantify the effects of varying grind size/permeability, pressure gradient, and filtration.
Part 1: Brewing
1a: Fluid Mechanics with the Aeropress
Grind beans.
Grind about 140 grams of beans to a medium-fine grind size, the texture of fine sea salt of table salt (xxx seconds in the grinder) Use another 20 grams of beans to grind coarsely, with each piece being roughly 1/4 cm (xxx seconds in the grinder).Perform four brews to assess the effects of varying pressure. Put about 15 grams of medium-fine coffee grounds in the Aeropress, set a timer, and add an appropriate amount of hot water based on your chosen ideal brew ratio. Give a quick stir, and wait 4 minutes to provide some extraction time. For the first trial, apply a very gentle continuous pressure. When the Aeropress is pushed all the way down, it should release a soft hissing noise to let you know it is about done. Note the dispensing time, i.e. how long it takes you to push the plunger all the way to the bottom. Pour some of the brew into a small beaker or vial.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
For subsequent trials, use the same paper filter, water temperature (94 C), and initial extraction time (4 minutes). For the second trial, repeat the first trial but using a strong continuous pressure. The dispensing time should decrease.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
For the third trial, double the mass of coffee (L is doubled). Apply the same gentle pressure as your first trial.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
For the fourth trial, use the coarse grounds, and use the same gentle pressure as your first trial.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
1b: Colloids and Filtration
- Perform four brews to assess the effects of varying filtration.
Perform a brew with the Aeropress with the medium-fine grounds, paper filter, same water temperature (94 C),initial extraction time (4 minutes), but with a medium pressure (between the gentle and strong). Note down the same measurements as before, and save some in a beaker or vial.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
Redo the previous trial, but with a metal filter.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
Next, set up the french press, and try to use identical conditions you used with the Aeropress (same brew ratio, same grind size). At the four minute mark use the press to filter out the grinds and dispense the coffee.
Mass of grounds: ____________________ g Mass of water: ____________________ g
Finally, use the same brew ratio to idk finish later
Measure the TDS of each brew.
Take and note down the TDS measurement for each sample from the brews.Perform microscopy. Prepare a microscope slide by pipetting out a bit of coffee from your french press brew, and take a look at it in the microscope. Can you identify the coffee colloids? Do you see any oil droplets? (The colloids will be irregular, oil droplets will be spherical.) Approximately how large are they? Do you see any evidence of Brownian motion? If possible, take pictures!
Repeat the microscopy to look at another one of your brews and observe the differences.
Part 2: Analysis
You should create a report that includes the following:
- A labeled column chart that shows the TDS value for each of the brews
- A labeled column chart that shows the PE for each of the 7 brews
- A scatterplot of TDS vs dispensing time for the Aeropress brews
In your discussion, you should answer:
- How significantly did the applied pressure affect the rate at which fluid moved through the grounds by gravity? How did this affect the TDS and PE?
- Which variable had the most pronounced effect on TDS? Why do you think this is the case?
- How did the increased amount of grounds affect the rate at which fluid moved through the grounds in the Aeropress? How did grind size affect the rate, TDS, and PE?
- Discuss your observations about the effect of filtration on the TDS and PE, and the samples under the microscope.