Foie Gras descriptive stats

“Have you ever ordered foie gras at a restaurant?” % each option


Don't know/remember                  No                 Yes 
           2.623856           82.133610           15.242534 
                                              var            category
1 have_you_ever_ordered_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant Don't know/remember
2 have_you_ever_ordered_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant                  No
3 have_you_ever_ordered_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant                 Yes
  proportion    lb    ub
1       2.67  2.13  3.20
2      80.92 79.61 82.22
3      16.42 15.18 17.65

“Have you ever purchased foie gras from a store?” % each option


Don't know/remember                  No                 Yes 
           1.380977           92.853444            5.765579 
                                             var            category proportion
1 have_you_ever_purchased_foie_gras_from_a_store Don't know/remember       1.75
2 have_you_ever_purchased_foie_gras_from_a_store                  No      92.06
3 have_you_ever_purchased_foie_gras_from_a_store                 Yes       6.18
     lb    ub
1  1.29  2.22
2 91.15 92.98
3  5.38  6.99

“How often do you order foie gras at a restaurant or purchase at a store?” % each option


          About once a month Once or twice a year or less 
                   2.6449644                   83.5198372 
       Several times a month         Several times a year 
                   1.6276704                   12.0040692 
              Weekly or more 
                   0.2034588 
                                                                      var
1 how_often_do_you_order_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant_or_purchase_at_a_store
2 how_often_do_you_order_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant_or_purchase_at_a_store
3 how_often_do_you_order_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant_or_purchase_at_a_store
4 how_often_do_you_order_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant_or_purchase_at_a_store
5 how_often_do_you_order_foie_gras_at_a_restaurant_or_purchase_at_a_store
                      category proportion    lb    ub
1           About once a month       2.55  1.35  3.74
2 Once or twice a year or less      82.59 79.57 85.62
3        Several times a month       1.86  0.76  2.95
4         Several times a year      12.95 10.24 15.65
5               Weekly or more       0.06 -0.02  0.14

“How do you think foie gras is typically produced? (select one)” % each option


                                                                                           Before slaughter, ducks or geese are injected with a medication which causes their liver to swell to an abnormally large size, resulting in the taste of the liver. 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2.191781 
                          Ducks and geese are kept confined, unable to move their whole life, with supplementation of corn and fat. Limited exercise and increased fat consumption results in a larger and less lean animal, enhancing the taste of the liver. 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     34.162276 
                                                          Ducks and geese are left to wander and forage for their food, with supplementation of corn and fat. This enhanced exercise and diet results in a healthier animal, enhancing the taste of the liver. 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     11.211802 
Ducks or geese are force fed a diet of corn and fat. This involves having a tube with a funnel inserted down their esophagus to deliver food which causes their liver to swell to an abnormally large size, resulting in the taste of the liver for foie gras. 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     52.434141 
                                                          var
1 how_do_you_think_foie_gras_is_typically_produced_select_one
2 how_do_you_think_foie_gras_is_typically_produced_select_one
3 how_do_you_think_foie_gras_is_typically_produced_select_one
4 how_do_you_think_foie_gras_is_typically_produced_select_one
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        category
1                                                                                            Before slaughter, ducks or geese are injected with a medication which causes their liver to swell to an abnormally large size, resulting in the taste of the liver.
2                           Ducks and geese are kept confined, unable to move their whole life, with supplementation of corn and fat. Limited exercise and increased fat consumption results in a larger and less lean animal, enhancing the taste of the liver.
3                                                           Ducks and geese are left to wander and forage for their food, with supplementation of corn and fat. This enhanced exercise and diet results in a healthier animal, enhancing the taste of the liver.
4 Ducks or geese are force fed a diet of corn and fat. This involves having a tube with a funnel inserted down their esophagus to deliver food which causes their liver to swell to an abnormally large size, resulting in the taste of the liver for foie gras.
  proportion    lb    ub
1       2.02  1.52  2.53
2      33.77 32.05 35.50
3      12.68 11.44 13.92
4      51.53 49.70 53.35

%somewhat and strongly agree:


        0         1 
94.044537  5.955463 
                                                                                                                  var
1 agree_bans_on_foie_gras_productions_and_sales_would_have_significant_negative_economic_impacts_in_the_united_states
2 agree_bans_on_foie_gras_productions_and_sales_would_have_significant_negative_economic_impacts_in_the_united_states
  category proportion    lb    ub
1        0      93.39 92.55 94.24
2        1       6.61  5.76  7.45

        0         1 
90.523045  9.476955 
                                                    var category proportion
1 agree_foie_gras_is_typically_produced_in_a_humane_way        0      88.96
2 agree_foie_gras_is_typically_produced_in_a_humane_way        1      11.04
     lb    ub
1 87.89 90.03
2  9.97 12.11

       0        1 
37.35543 62.64457 
                                                                     var
1 agree_being_able_to_purchase_foie_gras_is_a_symbol_of_class_and_wealth
2 agree_being_able_to_purchase_foie_gras_is_a_symbol_of_class_and_wealth
  category proportion    lb    ub
1        0      38.13 36.52 39.73
2        1      61.87 60.27 63.48

       0        1 
78.87105 21.12895 
                                                            var category
1 agree_at_least_some_of_my_friends_and_or_family_eat_foie_gras        0
2 agree_at_least_some_of_my_friends_and_or_family_eat_foie_gras        1
  proportion    lb    ub
1      78.07 76.70 79.44
2      21.93 20.56 23.30

        0         1 
97.238046  2.761954 
                                 var category proportion    lb    ub
1 agree_most_americans_eat_foie_gras        0      96.84 96.25 97.44
2 agree_most_americans_eat_foie_gras        1       3.16  2.56  3.75

       0        1 
90.24685  9.75315 
                                       var category proportion    lb    ub
1 agree_foie_gras_is_a_healthy_food_option        0       89.2 88.16 90.25
2 agree_foie_gras_is_a_healthy_food_option        1       10.8  9.75 11.84

Demographics

#Gender
prop.table(table(df$gender_raw[!(df$gender_raw %in% c("Prefer not to say","Prefer to self-describe"))]))*100

                   Female                      Male Non-binary / third gender 
                57.453092                 40.392634                  2.154274 
weighted_mean(df[!(df$gender_raw %in% c("Prefer not to say","Prefer to self-describe")),], "gender_raw")
         var                  category proportion    lb    ub
1 gender_raw                    Female      52.99 51.33 54.64
2 gender_raw                      Male      45.76 44.10 47.42
3 gender_raw Non-binary / third gender       1.25  0.96  1.54
#income
prop.table(table(df$income))*100

           $100,000–$149,999            $150,000–$199,999 
                   18.125324                     8.406698 
            $200,000 or more              $25,000–$49,999 
                    6.266183                    18.815812 
             $50,000–$74,999              $75,000–$99,999 
                   18.815812                    16.002071 
                    <$25,000 Prefer not to say or missing 
                   10.460901                     3.107198 
weighted_mean(df, "income")
     var                     category proportion    lb    ub
1 income            $100,000–$149,999      19.17 17.88 20.47
2 income            $150,000–$199,999       9.86  8.86 10.86
3 income             $200,000 or more      11.10  9.94 12.26
4 income              $25,000–$49,999      16.33 15.15 17.51
5 income              $50,000–$74,999      17.61 16.38 18.85
6 income              $75,000–$99,999      14.85 13.69 16.00
7 income                     <$25,000      10.14  9.15 11.13
8 income Prefer not to say or missing       0.93  0.79  1.07
#Do you live in any of the following cities?    
prop.table(table(df$do_you_live_in_any_of_the_following_cities))*100

   Denver, CO  Portland, OR Washington DC 
     41.55844      40.58442      17.85714 
weighted_mean(df, "do_you_live_in_any_of_the_following_cities")
                                         var      category proportion    lb
1 do_you_live_in_any_of_the_following_cities    Denver, CO      41.42 36.39
2 do_you_live_in_any_of_the_following_cities  Portland, OR      39.09 34.12
3 do_you_live_in_any_of_the_following_cities Washington DC      19.49 15.36
     ub
1 46.45
2 44.05
3 23.63
### In politics today, do you consider yourself a Republican, Democrat, an Independent or something else/no party?
prop.table(table(df$political_affiliation))*100

   Democrat Independent  Republican 
   44.43294    35.40480    20.16226 
weighted_mean(df, "political_affiliation")
                    var    category proportion    lb    ub
1 political_affiliation    Democrat      35.26 33.75 36.77
2 political_affiliation Independent      39.42 37.79 41.05
3 political_affiliation  Republican      25.32 23.83 26.82
### Are you of Spanish, Hispanic, or Latino origin? 
prop.table(table(df$hispanic))*100

    Hispanic or Latino Not Hispanic or Latino 
               7.80252               92.19748 
weighted_mean(df, "hispanic")
       var               category proportion    lb    ub
1 hispanic     Hispanic or Latino      13.19 11.93 14.45
2 hispanic Not Hispanic or Latino      86.81 85.55 88.07
### Choose one or more races that you consider yourself to be:  
prop.table(table(df$race))*100

            Asian             Black       Multiracial Native/Indigenous 
       5.45485931       11.15138961        4.95425514        0.37976869 
Other/no response  Pacific Islander             White 
       2.90005179        0.06904885       75.09062662 
weighted_mean(df, "race")
   var          category proportion    lb    ub
1 race             Asian       8.06  7.09  9.04
2 race             Black      12.75 11.65 13.86
3 race       Multiracial       9.10  8.00 10.19
4 race Native/Indigenous       0.58  0.30  0.86
5 race Other/no response       4.49  3.70  5.28
6 race  Pacific Islander       0.18  0.00  0.37
7 race             White      64.84 63.20 66.49
### What is the highest level of education you have completed?  
prop.table(table(df$education))*100

                 Bachelor’s degree    Graduate or professional degree 
                        37.4072156                         20.5420335 
High school graduate or equivalent      Less than high school diploma 
                        11.7210426                          0.5351286 
                 Prefer not to say Some college or associate’s degree 
                         0.2244088                         29.5701709 
weighted_mean(df, "education")
        var                           category proportion    lb    ub
1 education                  Bachelor’s degree      30.30 28.85 31.75
2 education    Graduate or professional degree      17.67 16.47 18.87
3 education High school graduate or equivalent      19.04 17.62 20.46
4 education      Less than high school diploma       1.37  0.87  1.87
5 education                  Prefer not to say       0.07  0.03  0.10
6 education Some college or associate’s degree      31.55 30.01 33.09
### What was your total household income before taxes during the past 12 months?    
prop.table(table(df$income))*100

           $100,000–$149,999            $150,000–$199,999 
                   18.125324                     8.406698 
            $200,000 or more              $25,000–$49,999 
                    6.266183                    18.815812 
             $50,000–$74,999              $75,000–$99,999 
                   18.815812                    16.002071 
                    <$25,000 Prefer not to say or missing 
                   10.460901                     3.107198 
weighted_mean(df, "income")
     var                     category proportion    lb    ub
1 income            $100,000–$149,999      19.17 17.88 20.47
2 income            $150,000–$199,999       9.86  8.86 10.86
3 income             $200,000 or more      11.10  9.94 12.26
4 income              $25,000–$49,999      16.33 15.15 17.51
5 income              $50,000–$74,999      17.61 16.38 18.85
6 income              $75,000–$99,999      14.85 13.69 16.00
7 income                     <$25,000      10.14  9.15 11.13
8 income Prefer not to say or missing       0.93  0.79  1.07

Do you own or have you owned a pet in the past?


       No       Yes 
 7.975142 92.024858 
                                             var category proportion    lb
1 do_you_own_or_have_you_owned_a_pet_in_the_past       No       8.66  7.71
2 do_you_own_or_have_you_owned_a_pet_in_the_past      Yes      91.34 90.40
     ub
1  9.60
2 92.29

I am vegan or vegetarian


        No   Not sure        Yes 
92.5427240  0.5351286  6.9221474 
                       var category proportion    lb    ub
1 i_am_vegan_or_vegetarian       No      93.40 92.60 94.21
2 i_am_vegan_or_vegetarian Not sure       0.48  0.25  0.70
3 i_am_vegan_or_vegetarian      Yes       6.12  5.34  6.89

I hunt or fish


       No  Not sure       Yes 
78.508545  0.327982 21.163473 
             var category proportion    lb    ub
1 i_hunt_or_fish       No      76.54 75.12 77.97
2 i_hunt_or_fish Not sure       0.37  0.15  0.59
3 i_hunt_or_fish      Yes      23.09 21.67 24.50

I am or have been a farmer or rancher


        No   Not sure        Yes 
93.8373900  0.3797687  5.7828414 
                                    var category proportion    lb    ub
1 i_am_or_have_been_a_farmer_or_rancher       No      94.11 93.35 94.87
2 i_am_or_have_been_a_farmer_or_rancher Not sure       0.34  0.14  0.53
3 i_am_or_have_been_a_farmer_or_rancher      Yes       5.56  4.82  6.29

I have friends who are vegan or vegetarian


       No  Not sure       Yes 
25.012947  2.848265 72.138788 
                                         var category proportion    lb    ub
1 i_have_friends_who_are_vegan_or_vegetarian       No      27.50 26.00 29.00
2 i_have_friends_who_are_vegan_or_vegetarian Not sure       3.42  2.75  4.08
3 i_have_friends_who_are_vegan_or_vegetarian      Yes      69.09 67.53 70.64

More Descriptive Statistics

Moderately/Strongly Support for the following variables by message condition weighted and by state weighted for demographics

-need to stratify by state -also stratify by state and control vs most effective.

Support ban on sale of foie gras at the state level


       0        1 
18.64319 81.35681 
                 var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_ban_sale_state        0      19.84 18.52 21.17
2 bin_ban_sale_state        1      80.16 78.83 81.48
library(knitr)
library(rlang)
Warning: package 'rlang' was built under R version 4.4.3

Attaching package: 'rlang'
The following objects are masked from 'package:purrr':

    %@%, flatten, flatten_chr, flatten_dbl, flatten_int, flatten_lgl,
    flatten_raw, invoke, splice
df$state<-df$what_state_do_you_live_in

  outcome_var = "bin_ban_forcefeeding_state"
  y_label = "Percent supportive (weighted)"
  title_state = "Support for state ban on forcefeeding by state"
  title_message = "Support for state ban on forcefeeding by message"
  state_col = "state"
message_col = "tr_message"
keep_category = "1"
title_state_unweighted = NULL
rotate_x = 45

run_support_tables_and_plots <- function(df,
                                        outcome_var,
                                        y_label = "Percent (weighted)",
                                        title_state = NULL,
                                        title_message = NULL,
                                        title_state_unweighted = NULL,
                                        rotate_x = 25,
                                        state_col = "state",
                                        message_col = "tr_message",
                                        keep_category = "1") {
  
  stopifnot(is.character(outcome_var), length(outcome_var) == 1)
  stopifnot(is.character(state_col), length(state_col) == 1)
  stopifnot(is.character(message_col), length(message_col) == 1)

  # Default titles if not provided
  if (is.null(title_state)) {
    title_state <- paste0(outcome_var, " by ", state_col, " (weighted)")
  }
  if (is.null(title_message)) {
    title_message <- paste0(outcome_var, " by ", message_col, " (weighted)")
  }
  if (is.null(title_state_unweighted)) {
    title_state_unweighted <- paste0(outcome_var, " by ", state_col, " (unweighted)")
  }

  # --- 1) Unweighted by state (percent) ---
  unweighted_state <- df %>%
    group_by(.data[[state_col]]) %>%
    summarise(
      prop = mean(.data[[outcome_var]], na.rm = TRUE) * 100,
      n = sum(!is.na(.data[[outcome_var]])),
      .groups = "drop"
    ) %>%
    arrange(desc(prop))

  # --- 2) Weighted by state ---
  state_res <- df %>%
    group_by(.data[[state_col]]) %>%
    do(weighted_mean(., outcome_var)) %>%
    filter(category == keep_category) %>%
    select(
      state = .data[[state_col]],
      var, proportion, lb, ub
    ) %>%
    as.data.frame()

  # Plot: weighted by state
  p_state <- ggplot(state_res, aes(x = reorder(state, -proportion), y = proportion)) +
    geom_bar(stat = "identity") +
    geom_errorbar(aes(ymin = lb, ymax = ub), width = 0.2) +
    labs(x = "State", y = y_label, title = title_state) +
    theme_minimal() +
    theme(axis.text.x = element_text(angle = rotate_x, hjust = 1))

  # --- 3) Weighted by message ---
  message_res <- df %>%
    group_by(.data[[message_col]]) %>%
    do(weighted_mean(., outcome_var)) %>%
    filter(category == keep_category) %>%
    select(
      tr_message = .data[[message_col]],
      var, proportion, lb, ub
    ) %>%
    as.data.frame() 

  # Plot: weighted by message
  p_message <- ggplot(message_res, aes(x = reorder(tr_message, -proportion), y = proportion)) +
    geom_bar(stat = "identity") +
    geom_errorbar(aes(ymin = lb, ymax = ub), width = 0.2) +
    labs(x = "Message", y = y_label, title = title_message) +
    theme_minimal() +
    theme(axis.text.x = element_text(angle = rotate_x, hjust = 1))

  # --- 4) Weighted by message x state (table only) ---
  message_state_res <- df %>%
    group_by(.data[[message_col]], .data[[state_col]]) %>%
      filter(n()>5, length(unique(.data[[outcome_var]]))>1) %>%
    do(weighted_mean(., outcome_var)) %>%
    filter(category == keep_category) %>%
    select(
      tr_message = .data[[message_col]],
      state = .data[[state_col]],
      var, proportion, lb, ub
    ) %>%
    as.data.frame()

  # Print all outputs (tables + plots)
  print(unweighted_state)
  print(state_res)
  print(p_state)
  print(message_res)
  print(p_message)
  print(message_state_res)

  # Return them invisibly for programmatic use
  invisible(list(
    unweighted_state = unweighted_state,
    state_res = kable(state_res),
    plot_state = p_state,
    message_res = kable(message_res),
    plot_message = p_message,
    message_state_res = kable(message_state_res)
  ))
}


run_support_tables_and_plots(
  df = df,
  outcome_var = "bin_ban_sale_state",
  y_label = "Percent supportive (weighted)",
  title_state = "Support for state ban on sale of foie gras by state",
  title_message = "Support for state ban on sale of foie gras by message"
)
Warning: Use of .data in tidyselect expressions was deprecated in tidyselect 1.2.0.
ℹ Please use `all_of(var)` (or `any_of(var)`) instead of `.data[[var]]`
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 No response           84.4   128
 2 Pennsylvania          84.1   804
 3 Ohio                  82.6   657
 4 North Carolina        82.4   648
 5 Maryland              81.5   373
 6 Oregon                81.2   388
 7 Massachuttes          81.0   379
 8 Washington            81.0   420
 9 Colorado              80.8   400
10 Florida               79.5  1138
11 District of Columbia  78.6    56
12 New Jersey            78.1   402
                  state                var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_ban_sale_state      76.78 71.21 82.36
2  District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_state      72.84 56.45 89.22
3               Florida bin_ban_sale_state      79.29 76.37 82.21
4              Maryland bin_ban_sale_state      81.16 76.16 86.15
5          Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_state      80.75 75.81 85.69
6            New Jersey bin_ban_sale_state      80.48 75.85 85.11
7           No response bin_ban_sale_state      84.74 77.18 92.30
8        North Carolina bin_ban_sale_state      78.63 74.29 82.97
9                  Ohio bin_ban_sale_state      83.29 79.75 86.82
10               Oregon bin_ban_sale_state      79.05 73.71 84.39
11         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_state      81.46 77.80 85.11
12           Washington bin_ban_sale_state      80.10 75.16 85.04

             tr_message                var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_ban_sale_state      72.91 69.59 76.22
2  message1_welfareonly bin_ban_sale_state      84.50 81.87 87.13
3     message2_fairness bin_ban_sale_state      80.81 77.84 83.78
4    message3_economics bin_ban_sale_state      79.85 76.82 82.87
5 message4_publichealth bin_ban_sale_state      82.88 80.16 85.60

              tr_message                state                var proportion
1                control             Colorado bin_ban_sale_state      60.55
2                control District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_state      57.84
3                control              Florida bin_ban_sale_state      72.40
4                control             Maryland bin_ban_sale_state      69.26
5                control         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_state      71.74
6                control           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_state      84.25
7                control          No response bin_ban_sale_state      84.77
8                control       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_state      58.20
9                control                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_state      79.41
10               control               Oregon bin_ban_sale_state      81.91
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_state      81.04
12               control           Washington bin_ban_sale_state      74.58
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_ban_sale_state      77.98
14  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_state      78.55
15  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_ban_sale_state      83.28
16  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_ban_sale_state      95.68
17  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_state      80.76
18  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_state      89.77
19  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_ban_sale_state      87.88
20  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_state      87.62
21  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_state      87.18
22  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_ban_sale_state      75.64
23  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_state      82.88
24  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_ban_sale_state      85.68
25     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_ban_sale_state      76.36
26     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_state      84.97
27     message2_fairness              Florida bin_ban_sale_state      76.99
28     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_ban_sale_state      80.53
29     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_state      94.18
30     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_state      72.08
31     message2_fairness          No response bin_ban_sale_state      83.75
32     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_state      79.69
33     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_state      85.96
34     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_ban_sale_state      89.47
35     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_state      80.65
36     message2_fairness           Washington bin_ban_sale_state      81.62
37    message3_economics             Colorado bin_ban_sale_state      84.72
38    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_state      90.84
39    message3_economics              Florida bin_ban_sale_state      80.23
40    message3_economics             Maryland bin_ban_sale_state      85.17
41    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_state      80.79
42    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_state      76.47
43    message3_economics          No response bin_ban_sale_state      81.02
44    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_state      86.71
45    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_state      84.42
46    message3_economics               Oregon bin_ban_sale_state      72.14
47    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_state      70.30
48    message3_economics           Washington bin_ban_sale_state      74.68
49 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_ban_sale_state      84.96
50 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_state      63.03
51 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_ban_sale_state      83.41
52 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_ban_sale_state      78.14
53 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_state      77.90
54 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_state      80.51
55 message4_publichealth          No response bin_ban_sale_state      88.59
56 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_state      87.73
57 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_state      78.78
58 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_ban_sale_state      78.12
59 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_state      91.09
60 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_ban_sale_state      82.20
      lb     ub
1  45.54  75.57
2  17.21  98.47
3  65.23  79.57
4  55.87  82.65
5  58.94  84.54
6  74.73  93.78
7  64.76 104.78
8  47.55  68.84
9  71.11  87.71
10 71.51  92.32
11 73.00  89.07
12 63.53  85.63
13 67.36  88.61
14 42.04 115.06
15 77.32  89.24
16 92.05  99.31
17 69.29  92.23
18 82.68  96.86
19 73.98 101.79
20 80.73  94.52
21 81.29  93.07
22 61.87  89.41
23 74.59  91.17
24 76.30  95.07
25 62.91  89.81
26 60.68 109.26
27 70.20  83.78
28 68.89  92.17
29 89.52  98.84
30 58.49  85.68
31 69.49  98.01
32 70.03  89.35
33 79.12  92.80
34 81.96  96.97
35 72.51  88.79
36 70.98  92.26
37 74.21  95.23
38 72.60 109.07
39 73.63  86.82
40 74.44  95.90
41 69.75  91.82
42 65.47  87.47
43 63.10  98.93
44 78.78  94.63
45 76.28  92.56
46 58.55  85.72
47 60.71  79.90
48 61.41  87.94
49 75.08  94.85
50 25.81 100.25
51 77.46  89.36
52 67.60  88.67
53 66.51  89.29
54 71.73  89.29
55 73.42 103.75
56 79.80  95.67
57 68.64  88.92
58 67.30  88.94
59 85.04  97.15
60 70.85  93.55

Support ban on sale of foie gras at the city level


       0        1 
18.50509 81.49491 
                var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_ban_sale_city        0      19.78 18.46 21.11
2 bin_ban_sale_city        1      80.22 78.89 81.54
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 No response           85.2   128
 2 Pennsylvania          84.1   804
 3 Maryland              82.6   373
 4 Ohio                  82.5   657
 5 North Carolina        82.4   648
 6 Massachuttes          81.3   379
 7 Oregon                81.2   388
 8 Washington            80.7   420
 9 District of Columbia  80.4    56
10 Colorado              80.2   400
11 Florida               79.7  1138
12 New Jersey            78.9   402
                  state               var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_ban_sale_city      75.90 70.21 81.59
2  District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_city      73.36 56.97 89.74
3               Florida bin_ban_sale_city      79.50 76.60 82.39
4              Maryland bin_ban_sale_city      81.80 76.84 86.76
5          Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_city      80.02 74.95 85.09
6            New Jersey bin_ban_sale_city      81.10 76.52 85.69
7           No response bin_ban_sale_city      84.98 77.43 92.52
8        North Carolina bin_ban_sale_city      78.52 74.16 82.88
9                  Ohio bin_ban_sale_city      83.07 79.51 86.63
10               Oregon bin_ban_sale_city      78.91 73.56 84.27
11         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_city      82.00 78.42 85.58
12           Washington bin_ban_sale_city      79.87 74.91 84.83

             tr_message               var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_ban_sale_city      72.98 69.67 76.30
2  message1_welfareonly bin_ban_sale_city      84.64 82.03 87.25
3     message2_fairness bin_ban_sale_city      80.69 77.70 83.67
4    message3_economics bin_ban_sale_city      79.78 76.76 82.80
5 message4_publichealth bin_ban_sale_city      83.16 80.44 85.88

              tr_message                state               var proportion
1                control             Colorado bin_ban_sale_city      55.82
2                control District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_city      57.84
3                control              Florida bin_ban_sale_city      73.41
4                control             Maryland bin_ban_sale_city      71.10
5                control         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_city      73.44
6                control           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_city      85.24
7                control          No response bin_ban_sale_city      84.77
8                control       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_city      58.69
9                control                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_city      78.21
10               control               Oregon bin_ban_sale_city      80.93
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_city      81.04
12               control           Washington bin_ban_sale_city      74.58
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_ban_sale_city      78.32
14  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_city      78.55
15  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_ban_sale_city      84.59
16  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_ban_sale_city      96.12
17  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_city      80.76
18  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_city      87.18
19  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_ban_sale_city      87.88
20  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_city      87.40
21  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_city      87.18
22  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_ban_sale_city      76.01
23  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_city      82.88
24  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_ban_sale_city      85.30
25     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_ban_sale_city      76.36
26     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_city      84.97
27     message2_fairness              Florida bin_ban_sale_city      75.60
28     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_ban_sale_city      80.53
29     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_city      93.52
30     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_city      75.44
31     message2_fairness          No response bin_ban_sale_city      83.75
32     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_city      78.77
33     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_city      86.62
34     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_ban_sale_city      89.47
35     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_city      81.63
36     message2_fairness           Washington bin_ban_sale_city      79.81
37    message3_economics             Colorado bin_ban_sale_city      84.72
38    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_city      90.84
39    message3_economics              Florida bin_ban_sale_city      80.52
40    message3_economics             Maryland bin_ban_sale_city      82.93
41    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_city      77.90
42    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_city      76.18
43    message3_economics          No response bin_ban_sale_city      81.82
44    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_city      86.21
45    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_city      83.99
46    message3_economics               Oregon bin_ban_sale_city      72.14
47    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_city      72.40
48    message3_economics           Washington bin_ban_sale_city      75.85
49 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_ban_sale_city      84.96
50 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_city      65.57
51 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_ban_sale_city      83.13
52 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_ban_sale_city      81.17
53 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_city      76.50
54 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_city      82.12
55 message4_publichealth          No response bin_ban_sale_city      88.59
56 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_city      88.35
57 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_city      78.78
58 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_ban_sale_city      78.12
59 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_city      90.87
60 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_ban_sale_city      82.20
      lb     ub
1  40.75  70.88
2  17.21  98.47
3  66.41  80.41
4  57.89  84.32
5  60.77  86.10
6  75.89  94.59
7  64.76 104.78
8  48.03  69.34
9  69.72  86.71
10 70.28  91.57
11 73.00  89.07
12 63.53  85.63
13 67.70  88.94
14 42.04 115.06
15 78.93  90.25
16 92.63  99.62
17 69.29  92.23
18 79.27  95.10
19 73.98 101.79
20 80.49  94.31
21 81.29  93.07
22 62.28  89.74
23 74.59  91.17
24 75.82  94.78
25 62.91  89.81
26 60.68 109.26
27 68.67  82.53
28 68.89  92.17
29 88.44  98.60
30 62.15  88.72
31 69.49  98.01
32 68.77  88.77
33 79.89  93.35
34 81.96  96.97
35 73.69  89.58
36 68.92  90.70
37 74.21  95.23
38 72.60 109.07
39 73.94  87.10
40 71.78  94.07
41 65.90  89.90
42 65.17  87.20
43 63.97  99.68
44 78.27  94.16
45 75.80  92.18
46 58.55  85.72
47 63.25  81.56
48 62.68  89.03
49 75.08  94.85
50 28.71 102.42
51 77.13  89.13
52 71.09  91.25
53 64.84  88.17
54 73.53  90.72
55 73.42 103.75
56 80.55  96.15
57 68.64  88.92
58 67.30  88.94
59 84.80  96.94
60 70.85  93.55

Support ban on force-feeding for foie gras at the state level


       0        1 
10.90972 89.09028 
                         var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_ban_forcefeeding_state        0      12.53 11.40 13.65
2 bin_ban_forcefeeding_state        1      87.47 86.35 88.60
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 North Carolina        91.2   648
 2 Pennsylvania          91.0   804
 3 Massachuttes          90.0   379
 4 Ohio                  90.0   657
 5 No response           89.8   128
 6 Washington            89.8   420
 7 District of Columbia  89.3    56
 8 Maryland              89.3   373
 9 Colorado              89.2   400
10 Oregon                89.2   388
11 New Jersey            86.3   402
12 Florida               86.2  1138
                  state                        var proportion    lb     ub
1              Colorado bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      86.66 82.25  91.07
2  District of Columbia bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      88.46 76.81 100.10
3               Florida bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      85.40 82.84  87.96
4              Maryland bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      87.75 83.36  92.15
5          Massachuttes bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      88.01 83.73  92.29
6            New Jersey bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      86.87 82.85  90.90
7           No response bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      89.30 82.51  96.08
8        North Carolina bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      88.62 85.28  91.96
9                  Ohio bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      89.23 86.07  92.40
10               Oregon bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      87.13 82.63  91.62
11         Pennsylvania bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      89.03 85.99  92.07
12           Washington bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      87.16 82.73  91.59

             tr_message                        var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      84.16 81.39 86.93
2  message1_welfareonly bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      90.98 88.86 93.10
3     message2_fairness bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      87.33 84.81 89.86
4    message3_economics bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      86.34 83.62 89.06
5 message4_publichealth bin_ban_forcefeeding_state      88.59 86.26 90.92

              tr_message                state                        var
1                control             Colorado bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
2                control District of Columbia bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
3                control              Florida bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
4                control             Maryland bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
5                control         Massachuttes bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
6                control           New Jersey bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
7                control          No response bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
8                control       North Carolina bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
9                control                 Ohio bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
10               control               Oregon bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
12               control           Washington bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
14  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
15  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
16  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
17  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
18  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
19  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
20  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
21  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
22  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
23  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
24     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
25     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
26     message2_fairness              Florida bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
27     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
28     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
29     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
30     message2_fairness          No response bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
31     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
32     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
33     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
34     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
35     message2_fairness           Washington bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
36    message3_economics             Colorado bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
37    message3_economics              Florida bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
38    message3_economics             Maryland bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
39    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
40    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
41    message3_economics          No response bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
42    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
43    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
44    message3_economics               Oregon bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
45    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
46    message3_economics           Washington bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
47 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
48 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
49 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
50 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
51 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
52 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
53 message4_publichealth          No response bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
54 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
55 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
56 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
57 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
58 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_ban_forcefeeding_state
   proportion    lb     ub
1       83.04 71.00  95.09
2       78.82 43.99 113.65
3       80.60 74.35  86.85
4       85.01 73.50  96.51
5       81.40 68.91  93.90
6       91.84 85.16  98.52
7       78.52 55.34 101.70
8       79.84 71.14  88.55
9       89.54 83.06  96.01
10      89.82 81.51  98.12
11      85.64 77.28  93.99
12      84.31 75.43  93.18
13      85.87 77.01  94.72
14      92.39 87.87  96.92
15      97.52 94.51 100.52
16      86.34 75.97  96.72
17      94.32 88.57 100.07
18      96.14 88.43 103.86
19      91.81 85.80  97.82
20      92.31 86.61  98.00
21      80.22 67.28  93.16
22      90.41 84.71  96.11
23      91.93 84.76  99.10
24      78.66 65.39  91.92
25      88.88 66.32 111.44
26      83.36 77.35  89.36
27      83.17 71.94  94.40
28      96.58 92.35 100.81
29      81.90 70.11  93.69
30      88.92 76.06 101.78
31      93.64 88.92  98.36
32      92.32 87.01  97.62
33      92.14 85.22  99.06
34      84.93 77.20  92.66
35      92.95 86.78  99.12
36      90.20 82.43  97.97
37      83.69 77.41  89.96
38      87.28 76.93  97.62
39      96.00 91.36 100.63
40      82.67 72.96  92.38
41      86.11 69.72 102.50
42      88.20 79.76  96.64
43      87.89 80.18  95.61
44      88.30 78.44  98.17
45      86.78 79.59  93.97
46      76.16 61.15  91.17
47      94.82 89.59 100.05
48      80.33 54.71 105.94
49      86.84 81.57  92.10
50      87.48 79.15  95.80
51      80.85 69.95  91.74
52      85.28 76.71  93.84
53      97.04 91.11 102.96
54      92.41 85.55  99.27
55      82.84 72.77  92.91
56      86.00 76.40  95.60
57      97.75 95.84  99.66
58      88.50 78.50  98.50

Support ban on sale of force-fed foie gras at the state level


       0        1 
13.10202 86.89798 
                          var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state        0      14.91 13.70 16.12
2 bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state        1      85.09 83.88 86.30
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 No response           90.6   128
 2 Pennsylvania          89.1   804
 3 North Carolina        89.0   648
 4 Massachuttes          87.9   379
 5 Colorado              87.8   400
 6 Washington            87.4   420
 7 Ohio                  87.1   657
 8 Oregon                86.9   388
 9 Maryland              86.1   373
10 Florida               85.0  1138
11 New Jersey            82.3   402
12 District of Columbia  82.1    56
                  state                         var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      84.69 79.87 89.51
2  District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      75.02 59.01 91.04
3               Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      84.03 81.37 86.70
4              Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      85.56 81.05 90.07
5          Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      86.85 82.57 91.12
6            New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      81.95 77.28 86.62
7           No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      90.43 83.96 96.91
8        North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      85.26 81.43 89.10
9                  Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      85.91 82.40 89.43
10               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      84.66 79.89 89.43
11         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      87.39 84.29 90.50
12           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      84.81 80.17 89.45

             tr_message                         var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      83.00 80.12 85.87
2  message1_welfareonly bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      88.20 85.78 90.63
3     message2_fairness bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      84.08 81.28 86.88
4    message3_economics bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      84.33 81.55 87.12
5 message4_publichealth bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state      85.82 83.27 88.37

              tr_message                state                         var
1                control             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
2                control District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
3                control              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
4                control             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
5                control         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
6                control           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
7                control          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
8                control       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
9                control                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
10               control               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
12               control           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
14  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
15  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
16  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
17  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
18  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
19  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
20  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
21  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
22  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
23     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
24     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
25     message2_fairness              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
26     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
27     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
28     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
29     message2_fairness          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
30     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
31     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
32     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
33     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
34     message2_fairness           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
35    message3_economics             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
36    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
37    message3_economics              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
38    message3_economics             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
39    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
40    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
41    message3_economics          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
42    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
43    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
44    message3_economics               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
45    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
46    message3_economics           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
47 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
48 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
49 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
50 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
51 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
52 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
53 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
54 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
55 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
56 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
57 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_state
   proportion    lb     ub
1       80.33 67.12  93.55
2       59.65 18.84 100.46
3       81.34 75.23  87.45
4       80.71 68.50  92.92
5       82.92 71.67  94.17
6       84.89 74.89  94.90
7       82.16 61.25 103.08
8       74.62 64.82  84.42
9       84.00 75.60  92.40
10      91.49 84.69  98.30
11      92.17 86.58  97.76
12      86.51 78.12  94.91
13      89.49 81.90  97.08
14      88.54 83.07  94.01
15      96.57 93.21  99.93
16      85.19 76.34  94.03
17      85.61 75.63  95.59
18      88.73 80.97  96.48
19      87.71 80.81  94.61
20      76.79 63.05  90.53
21      89.62 83.81  95.43
22      87.07 77.60  96.53
23      77.62 64.28  90.96
24      84.97 60.68 109.26
25      80.68 74.23  87.12
26      83.27 73.18  93.36
27      99.50 98.49 100.50
28      75.29 61.94  88.64
29      85.55 71.29  99.81
30      86.93 78.90  94.96
31      89.22 82.86  95.57
32      83.27 71.11  95.43
33      82.12 74.05  90.20
34      89.86 82.62  97.10
35      85.61 75.17  96.06
36      78.41 49.68 107.14
37      83.20 76.99  89.41
38      86.21 75.75  96.67
39      87.94 78.36  97.51
40      78.39 67.54  89.24
41      86.11 69.72 102.50
42      88.69 81.22  96.15
43      85.55 77.42  93.68
44      88.35 79.68  97.02
45      83.59 76.04  91.13
46      77.75 63.63  91.87
47      88.48 79.26  97.71
48      65.57 28.71 102.42
49      86.30 80.81  91.78
50      83.14 73.59  92.69
51      80.85 69.95  91.74
52      84.92 76.72  93.11
53      91.22 84.66  97.78
54      82.58 73.19  91.96
55      82.81 72.65  92.97
56      90.01 83.54  96.47
57      81.74 70.40  93.09

Support ban on sale of force-fed foie gras at the city level


       0        1 
13.13654 86.86346 
                         var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city        0      14.78 13.58 15.97
2 bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city        1      85.22 84.03 86.42
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 No response           90.6   128
 2 North Carolina        89.0   648
 3 Pennsylvania          88.4   804
 4 Massachuttes          87.9   379
 5 Colorado              87.5   400
 6 Washington            87.1   420
 7 Ohio                  86.5   657
 8 Oregon                86.3   388
 9 Maryland              86.3   373
10 Florida               85.7  1138
11 New Jersey            82.8   402
12 District of Columbia  82.1    56
                  state                        var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.09 79.21 88.97
2  District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      75.02 59.01 91.04
3               Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.99 82.41 87.58
4              Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      86.37 82.04 90.70
5          Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      86.38 81.97 90.80
6            New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      82.80 78.23 87.36
7           No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      90.43 83.96 96.91
8        North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.31 81.50 89.12
9                  Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.38 81.84 88.93
10               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.24 79.45 89.03
11         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      86.56 83.35 89.77
12           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.48 81.02 89.93

             tr_message                        var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      83.03 80.18 85.89
2  message1_welfareonly bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      88.33 85.96 90.69
3     message2_fairness bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.52 81.76 87.28
4    message3_economics bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.33 81.54 87.11
5 message4_publichealth bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.89 83.35 88.44

              tr_message                state                        var
1                control             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
2                control District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
3                control              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
4                control             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
5                control         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
6                control           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
7                control          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
8                control       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
9                control                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
10               control               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
12               control           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
14  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
15  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
16  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
17  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
18  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
19  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
20  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
21  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
22  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
23     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
24     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
25     message2_fairness              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
26     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
27     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
28     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
29     message2_fairness          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
30     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
31     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
32     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
33     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
34     message2_fairness           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
35    message3_economics             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
36    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
37    message3_economics              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
38    message3_economics             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
39    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
40    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
41    message3_economics          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
42    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
43    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
44    message3_economics               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
45    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
46    message3_economics           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
47 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
48 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
49 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
50 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
51 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
52 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
53 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
54 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
55 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
56 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
57 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
   proportion    lb     ub
1       79.45 66.14  92.76
2       59.65 18.84 100.46
3       81.92 75.86  87.98
4       83.32 72.30  94.34
5       84.15 73.07  95.24
6       84.89 74.89  94.90
7       82.16 61.25 103.08
8       74.43 64.63  84.23
9       84.01 75.61  92.41
10      90.42 83.32  97.53
11      91.45 85.76  97.13
12      84.97 76.30  93.65
13      87.75 79.60  95.91
14      90.56 85.69  95.43
15      96.57 93.21  99.93
16      85.19 76.34  94.03
17      85.83 75.93  95.73
18      88.72 81.26  96.19
19      86.82 79.76  93.89
20      75.85 62.10  89.61
21      87.05 80.22  93.88
22      90.33 82.76  97.90
23      77.62 64.28  90.96
24      84.97 60.68 109.26
25      82.24 75.95  88.53
26      83.27 73.18  93.36
27      98.34 95.86 100.83
28      78.64 66.12  91.17
29      85.55 71.29  99.81
30      87.17 79.14  95.19
31      88.56 82.09  95.03
32      83.27 71.11  95.43
33      81.95 73.87  90.03
34      89.86 82.62  97.10
35      85.61 75.17  96.06
36      78.41 49.68 107.14
37      84.13 78.08  90.18
38      87.45 77.17  97.73
39      85.62 74.74  96.49
40      79.49 68.77  90.21
41      86.11 69.72 102.50
42      88.69 81.22  96.15
43      84.53 76.30  92.76
44      88.35 79.68  97.02
45      82.22 74.37  90.06
46      77.75 63.63  91.87
47      88.48 79.26  97.71
48      65.57 28.71 102.42
49      85.98 80.47  91.50
50      83.14 73.59  92.69
51      80.85 69.95  91.74
52      84.92 76.72  93.11
53      91.54 85.00  98.07
54      82.58 73.19  91.96
55      82.81 72.65  92.97
56      90.49 84.08  96.90
57      82.62 71.44  93.81

Believe bans on foie gras production and sales would have negative economic impacts


        0         1 
94.044537  5.955463 
                                 var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_bans_negative_economic_impacts        0      93.39 92.55 94.24
2 bin_bans_negative_economic_impacts        1       6.61  5.76  7.45
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 No response           90.6   128
 2 North Carolina        89.0   648
 3 Pennsylvania          88.4   804
 4 Massachuttes          87.9   379
 5 Colorado              87.5   400
 6 Washington            87.1   420
 7 Ohio                  86.5   657
 8 Oregon                86.3   388
 9 Maryland              86.3   373
10 Florida               85.7  1138
11 New Jersey            82.8   402
12 District of Columbia  82.1    56
                  state                        var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.09 79.21 88.97
2  District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      75.02 59.01 91.04
3               Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.99 82.41 87.58
4              Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      86.37 82.04 90.70
5          Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      86.38 81.97 90.80
6            New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      82.80 78.23 87.36
7           No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      90.43 83.96 96.91
8        North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.31 81.50 89.12
9                  Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.38 81.84 88.93
10               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.24 79.45 89.03
11         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      86.56 83.35 89.77
12           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.48 81.02 89.93

             tr_message                        var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      83.03 80.18 85.89
2  message1_welfareonly bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      88.33 85.96 90.69
3     message2_fairness bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.52 81.76 87.28
4    message3_economics bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      84.33 81.54 87.11
5 message4_publichealth bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city      85.89 83.35 88.44

              tr_message                state                        var
1                control             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
2                control District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
3                control              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
4                control             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
5                control         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
6                control           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
7                control          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
8                control       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
9                control                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
10               control               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
12               control           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
14  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
15  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
16  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
17  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
18  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
19  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
20  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
21  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
22  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
23     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
24     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
25     message2_fairness              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
26     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
27     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
28     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
29     message2_fairness          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
30     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
31     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
32     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
33     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
34     message2_fairness           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
35    message3_economics             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
36    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
37    message3_economics              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
38    message3_economics             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
39    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
40    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
41    message3_economics          No response bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
42    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
43    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
44    message3_economics               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
45    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
46    message3_economics           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
47 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
48 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
49 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
50 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
51 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
52 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
53 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
54 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
55 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
56 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
57 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_ban_sale_forcefed_city
   proportion    lb     ub
1       79.45 66.14  92.76
2       59.65 18.84 100.46
3       81.92 75.86  87.98
4       83.32 72.30  94.34
5       84.15 73.07  95.24
6       84.89 74.89  94.90
7       82.16 61.25 103.08
8       74.43 64.63  84.23
9       84.01 75.61  92.41
10      90.42 83.32  97.53
11      91.45 85.76  97.13
12      84.97 76.30  93.65
13      87.75 79.60  95.91
14      90.56 85.69  95.43
15      96.57 93.21  99.93
16      85.19 76.34  94.03
17      85.83 75.93  95.73
18      88.72 81.26  96.19
19      86.82 79.76  93.89
20      75.85 62.10  89.61
21      87.05 80.22  93.88
22      90.33 82.76  97.90
23      77.62 64.28  90.96
24      84.97 60.68 109.26
25      82.24 75.95  88.53
26      83.27 73.18  93.36
27      98.34 95.86 100.83
28      78.64 66.12  91.17
29      85.55 71.29  99.81
30      87.17 79.14  95.19
31      88.56 82.09  95.03
32      83.27 71.11  95.43
33      81.95 73.87  90.03
34      89.86 82.62  97.10
35      85.61 75.17  96.06
36      78.41 49.68 107.14
37      84.13 78.08  90.18
38      87.45 77.17  97.73
39      85.62 74.74  96.49
40      79.49 68.77  90.21
41      86.11 69.72 102.50
42      88.69 81.22  96.15
43      84.53 76.30  92.76
44      88.35 79.68  97.02
45      82.22 74.37  90.06
46      77.75 63.63  91.87
47      88.48 79.26  97.71
48      65.57 28.71 102.42
49      85.98 80.47  91.50
50      83.14 73.59  92.69
51      80.85 69.95  91.74
52      84.92 76.72  93.11
53      91.54 85.00  98.07
54      82.58 73.19  91.96
55      82.81 72.65  92.97
56      90.49 84.08  96.90
57      82.62 71.44  93.81

Believe bans on sale of force-fed foie gras represent government overreach


      0       1 
84.7402 15.2598 
                          var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_overreach_sale_forcefed        0      83.26 82.01 84.51
2 bin_overreach_sale_forcefed        1      16.74 15.49 17.99
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 Colorado              18.2   400
 2 New Jersey            16.7   402
 3 North Carolina        16.7   648
 4 Ohio                  16.1   657
 5 Florida               16.1  1138
 6 Massachuttes          15.3   379
 7 Washington            13.8   420
 8 Pennsylvania          13.4   804
 9 Oregon                13.4   388
10 Maryland              13.1   373
11 No response           12.5   128
12 District of Columbia  10.7    56
                  state                         var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      22.16 16.65 27.67
2  District of Columbia bin_overreach_sale_forcefed       9.28  0.10 18.46
3               Florida bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      16.53 13.81 19.25
4              Maryland bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      12.84  8.76 16.93
5          Massachuttes bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      16.51 11.63 21.40
6            New Jersey bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      15.89 11.55 20.24
7           No response bin_overreach_sale_forcefed       9.68  4.29 15.07
8        North Carolina bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      17.90 14.03 21.77
9                  Ohio bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      20.63 16.44 24.83
10               Oregon bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      15.25 10.57 19.92
11         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      15.39 12.04 18.75
12           Washington bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      16.91 11.90 21.92

             tr_message                         var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      17.26 14.39 20.12
2  message1_welfareonly bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      16.77 13.95 19.58
3     message2_fairness bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      17.80 14.96 20.63
4    message3_economics bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      17.10 14.24 19.96
5 message4_publichealth bin_overreach_sale_forcefed      14.78 12.17 17.40

              tr_message                state                         var
1                control             Colorado bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
2                control              Florida bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
3                control             Maryland bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
4                control         Massachuttes bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
5                control           New Jersey bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
6                control          No response bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
7                control       North Carolina bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
8                control                 Ohio bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
9                control               Oregon bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
10               control         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
11               control           Washington bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
12  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
13  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
14  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
15  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
16  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
17  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
18  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
19  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
20  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
21  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
22  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
23  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
24     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
25     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
26     message2_fairness              Florida bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
27     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
28     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
29     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
30     message2_fairness          No response bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
31     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
32     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
33     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
34     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
35     message2_fairness           Washington bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
36    message3_economics             Colorado bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
37    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
38    message3_economics              Florida bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
39    message3_economics             Maryland bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
40    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
41    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
42    message3_economics          No response bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
43    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
44    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
45    message3_economics               Oregon bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
46    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
47    message3_economics           Washington bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
48 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
49 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
50 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
51 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
52 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
53 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
54 message4_publichealth          No response bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
55 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
56 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
57 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
58 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
59 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_overreach_sale_forcefed
   proportion     lb    ub
1       32.26  17.16 47.36
2       19.47  13.15 25.79
3       19.94   8.73 31.15
4       17.18   5.56 28.80
5       10.52   2.03 19.01
6       12.16  -7.65 31.96
7       19.11  11.03 27.18
8       17.05   8.53 25.56
9        6.21  -0.03 12.44
10      19.42  10.25 28.60
11       7.84   2.01 13.68
12      21.43  11.12 31.75
13      21.45 -15.06 57.96
14      16.41   9.99 22.82
15       4.64   0.35  8.92
16      19.72   7.97 31.47
17      14.14   4.19 24.10
18       3.86  -3.86 11.57
19      20.83  11.64 30.03
20      18.08   9.62 26.54
21      28.06  14.49 41.64
22      11.93   5.19 18.66
23      15.99   5.98 26.00
24      28.87  14.73 43.01
25      18.94  -7.22 45.09
26      17.43  11.39 23.46
27      17.83   6.30 29.36
28      12.50   3.21 21.78
29      16.17   6.56 25.78
30      15.00   0.32 29.68
31      15.19   8.00 22.39
32      22.02  12.33 31.71
33      17.64   5.68 29.61
34      15.67   8.68 22.66
35      18.83   6.58 31.08
36      11.26   2.53 20.00
37      12.43 -11.44 36.30
38      16.32  10.18 22.47
39       8.18   1.98 14.38
40      17.21   5.44 28.97
41      19.69   9.32 30.05
42       9.48   0.48 18.48
43      18.83   8.97 28.70
44      19.75  10.65 28.85
45      14.39   4.16 24.62
46      21.17  12.81 29.54
47      24.67  10.50 38.85
48      16.89   6.20 27.58
49       2.54  -2.94  8.01
50      13.04   7.60 18.48
51      12.20   3.99 20.42
52      15.59   5.79 25.40
53      17.27   8.05 26.49
54       7.83  -1.82 17.48
55      14.25   6.06 22.44
56      28.09  16.64 39.54
57      10.85   3.14 18.55
58       9.61   3.90 15.32
59      18.22   6.29 30.14

Believe bans on production of force-fed foie gras represent government overreach


       0        1 
86.20749 13.79251 
                                var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_overreach_production_forcefed        0      84.49 83.26 85.71
2 bin_overreach_production_forcefed        1      15.51 14.29 16.74
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 New Jersey           16.2    402
 2 North Carolina       15.6    648
 3 Colorado             15      400
 4 Florida              14.8   1138
 5 Ohio                 14.0    657
 6 Maryland             13.1    373
 7 Oregon               12.9    388
 8 Pennsylvania         12.4    804
 9 Washington           12.4    420
10 Massachuttes         12.1    379
11 District of Columbia  8.93    56
12 No response           8.59   128
                  state                               var proportion    lb
1              Colorado bin_overreach_production_forcefed      17.65 12.71
2  District of Columbia bin_overreach_production_forcefed       5.58 -0.48
3               Florida bin_overreach_production_forcefed      16.24 13.51
4              Maryland bin_overreach_production_forcefed      13.71  9.33
5          Massachuttes bin_overreach_production_forcefed      14.19  9.46
6            New Jersey bin_overreach_production_forcefed      16.02 11.51
7           No response bin_overreach_production_forcefed       7.77  2.70
8        North Carolina bin_overreach_production_forcefed      18.02 14.08
9                  Ohio bin_overreach_production_forcefed      17.70 13.73
10               Oregon bin_overreach_production_forcefed      14.86 10.21
11         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_production_forcefed      13.41 10.26
12           Washington bin_overreach_production_forcefed      14.65 10.00
      ub
1  22.60
2  11.64
3  18.97
4  18.08
5  18.92
6  20.52
7  12.84
8  21.97
9  21.68
10 19.51
11 16.56
12 19.30

             tr_message                               var proportion    lb
1               control bin_overreach_production_forcefed      16.98 14.08
2  message1_welfareonly bin_overreach_production_forcefed      15.80 13.03
3     message2_fairness bin_overreach_production_forcefed      15.29 12.67
4    message3_economics bin_overreach_production_forcefed      16.24 13.43
5 message4_publichealth bin_overreach_production_forcefed      13.16 10.65
     ub
1 19.89
2 18.57
3 17.91
4 19.06
5 15.67

              tr_message                state                               var
1                control             Colorado bin_overreach_production_forcefed
2                control              Florida bin_overreach_production_forcefed
3                control             Maryland bin_overreach_production_forcefed
4                control         Massachuttes bin_overreach_production_forcefed
5                control           New Jersey bin_overreach_production_forcefed
6                control          No response bin_overreach_production_forcefed
7                control       North Carolina bin_overreach_production_forcefed
8                control                 Ohio bin_overreach_production_forcefed
9                control               Oregon bin_overreach_production_forcefed
10               control         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_production_forcefed
11               control           Washington bin_overreach_production_forcefed
12  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_overreach_production_forcefed
13  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_overreach_production_forcefed
14  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_overreach_production_forcefed
15  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_overreach_production_forcefed
16  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_overreach_production_forcefed
17  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_overreach_production_forcefed
18  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_overreach_production_forcefed
19  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_overreach_production_forcefed
20  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_overreach_production_forcefed
21  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_production_forcefed
22  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_overreach_production_forcefed
23     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_overreach_production_forcefed
24     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_overreach_production_forcefed
25     message2_fairness              Florida bin_overreach_production_forcefed
26     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_overreach_production_forcefed
27     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_overreach_production_forcefed
28     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_overreach_production_forcefed
29     message2_fairness          No response bin_overreach_production_forcefed
30     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_overreach_production_forcefed
31     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_overreach_production_forcefed
32     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_overreach_production_forcefed
33     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_production_forcefed
34     message2_fairness           Washington bin_overreach_production_forcefed
35    message3_economics             Colorado bin_overreach_production_forcefed
36    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_overreach_production_forcefed
37    message3_economics              Florida bin_overreach_production_forcefed
38    message3_economics             Maryland bin_overreach_production_forcefed
39    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_overreach_production_forcefed
40    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_overreach_production_forcefed
41    message3_economics          No response bin_overreach_production_forcefed
42    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_overreach_production_forcefed
43    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_overreach_production_forcefed
44    message3_economics               Oregon bin_overreach_production_forcefed
45    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_production_forcefed
46    message3_economics           Washington bin_overreach_production_forcefed
47 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_overreach_production_forcefed
48 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_overreach_production_forcefed
49 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_overreach_production_forcefed
50 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_overreach_production_forcefed
51 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_overreach_production_forcefed
52 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_overreach_production_forcefed
53 message4_publichealth          No response bin_overreach_production_forcefed
54 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_overreach_production_forcefed
55 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_overreach_production_forcefed
56 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_overreach_production_forcefed
57 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_overreach_production_forcefed
58 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_overreach_production_forcefed
   proportion     lb    ub
1       20.29   7.02 33.57
2       21.14  14.41 27.86
3       26.30  13.06 39.54
4       16.79   4.88 28.70
5       15.90   4.96 26.83
6       10.62  -9.11 30.35
7       20.12  11.70 28.55
8       13.96   6.12 21.80
9        6.43   0.21 12.66
10      16.49   7.64 25.34
11       6.49   1.02 11.96
12      21.02  10.57 31.47
13      15.68   9.34 22.02
14       4.47   0.50  8.43
15      15.74   4.93 26.54
16      16.14   4.65 27.63
17       3.86  -3.86 11.57
18      23.12  13.43 32.81
19      15.60   7.47 23.72
20      27.03  13.43 40.63
21       8.03   2.79 13.27
22      16.94   7.24 26.63
23      19.74   7.89 31.59
24      18.94  -7.22 45.09
25      16.43  10.46 22.40
26      18.73   7.13 30.34
27      10.97   1.81 20.14
28      11.77   3.36 20.19
29      15.00   0.32 29.68
30      14.49   7.72 21.26
31      18.35   9.59 27.12
32      13.76   2.44 25.07
33      14.32   7.75 20.88
34      10.62   1.54 19.69
35       8.92   1.96 15.89
36      12.43 -11.44 36.30
37      16.67  10.43 22.91
38       8.88   2.37 15.38
39      14.70   3.13 26.27
40      17.16   7.84 26.48
41       6.53  -1.01 14.07
42      16.95   7.37 26.53
43      19.87  10.66 29.09
44      15.36   4.91 25.81
45      18.88  10.61 27.16
46      24.67  10.50 38.85
47      16.94   6.32 27.56
48       2.54  -2.94  8.01
49      11.28   6.30 16.26
50       8.51   1.79 15.22
51      12.68   3.60 21.77
52      17.75   8.00 27.50
53       3.65  -3.59 10.90
54      13.56   4.81 22.32
55      21.85  10.99 32.72
56      11.90   4.11 19.68
57      10.02   4.40 15.64
58      14.75   3.50 25.99

Believe force-feeding causes unnecessary suffering for ducks and geese


        0         1 
 5.800104 94.199896 
                     var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_forcefed_suffering        0       6.76  5.91  7.61
2 bin_forcefed_suffering        1      93.24 92.39 94.09
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 Massachuttes          96.0   379
 2 Pennsylvania          95.4   804
 3 No response           95.3   128
 4 Maryland              94.9   373
 5 North Carolina        94.8   648
 6 Ohio                  94.4   657
 7 Washington            94.3   420
 8 Colorado              94.2   400
 9 Oregon                94.1   388
10 New Jersey            93.0   402
11 Florida               92.5  1138
12 District of Columbia  91.1    56
                  state                    var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_forcefed_suffering      93.48 90.32 96.63
2  District of Columbia bin_forcefed_suffering      84.80 70.42 99.18
3               Florida bin_forcefed_suffering      92.05 90.08 94.01
4              Maryland bin_forcefed_suffering      94.03 90.84 97.22
5          Massachuttes bin_forcefed_suffering      94.56 91.37 97.75
6            New Jersey bin_forcefed_suffering      92.15 88.92 95.38
7           No response bin_forcefed_suffering      95.71 92.17 99.25
8        North Carolina bin_forcefed_suffering      93.75 91.25 96.25
9                  Ohio bin_forcefed_suffering      94.14 91.85 96.43
10               Oregon bin_forcefed_suffering      91.52 87.61 95.42
11         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_suffering      94.77 92.71 96.82
12           Washington bin_forcefed_suffering      93.19 89.94 96.44

             tr_message                    var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_forcefed_suffering      92.63 90.69 94.57
2  message1_welfareonly bin_forcefed_suffering      93.52 91.60 95.45
3     message2_fairness bin_forcefed_suffering      93.45 91.50 95.40
4    message3_economics bin_forcefed_suffering      92.99 91.03 94.94
5 message4_publichealth bin_forcefed_suffering      93.64 91.92 95.35

              tr_message                state                    var proportion
1                control             Colorado bin_forcefed_suffering      92.98
2                control District of Columbia bin_forcefed_suffering      60.67
3                control              Florida bin_forcefed_suffering      91.06
4                control             Maryland bin_forcefed_suffering      89.98
5                control         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_suffering      92.59
6                control           New Jersey bin_forcefed_suffering      98.08
7                control       North Carolina bin_forcefed_suffering      90.48
8                control                 Ohio bin_forcefed_suffering      95.55
9                control               Oregon bin_forcefed_suffering      93.50
10               control         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_suffering      94.92
11               control           Washington bin_forcefed_suffering      93.96
12  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_forcefed_suffering      89.40
13  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_forcefed_suffering      91.88
14  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_forcefed_suffering      97.90
15  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_suffering      94.02
16  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_forcefed_suffering      94.34
17  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_forcefed_suffering      96.14
18  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_forcefed_suffering      95.39
19  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_forcefed_suffering      96.79
20  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_forcefed_suffering      91.70
21  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_suffering      92.95
22  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_forcefed_suffering      91.95
23     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_forcefed_suffering      92.43
24     message2_fairness              Florida bin_forcefed_suffering      91.69
25     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_forcefed_suffering      91.07
26     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_suffering      98.80
27     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_forcefed_suffering      88.93
28     message2_fairness          No response bin_forcefed_suffering      94.28
29     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_forcefed_suffering      97.91
30     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_forcefed_suffering      93.23
31     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_forcefed_suffering      91.46
32     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_suffering      95.20
33     message2_fairness           Washington bin_forcefed_suffering      92.46
34    message3_economics             Colorado bin_forcefed_suffering      97.65
35    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_forcefed_suffering      90.84
36    message3_economics              Florida bin_forcefed_suffering      93.06
37    message3_economics             Maryland bin_forcefed_suffering      94.36
38    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_suffering      97.71
39    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_forcefed_suffering      87.32
40    message3_economics          No response bin_forcefed_suffering      94.99
41    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_forcefed_suffering      94.60
42    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_forcefed_suffering      90.82
43    message3_economics               Oregon bin_forcefed_suffering      95.99
44    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_suffering      91.10
45    message3_economics           Washington bin_forcefed_suffering      90.71
46 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_forcefed_suffering      96.00
47 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_forcefed_suffering      89.79
48 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_forcefed_suffering      92.49
49 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_forcefed_suffering      97.44
50 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_suffering      90.46
51 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_forcefed_suffering      92.93
52 message4_publichealth          No response bin_forcefed_suffering      94.44
53 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_forcefed_suffering      90.28
54 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_forcefed_suffering      94.15
55 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_forcefed_suffering      84.85
56 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_suffering      99.16
57 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_forcefed_suffering      97.03
      lb     ub
1  86.17  99.80
2  20.14 101.20
3  86.87  95.25
4  80.42  99.54
5  83.13 102.04
6  95.40 100.77
7  84.13  96.82
8  92.24  98.87
9  85.99 101.01
10 90.14  99.69
11 88.93  98.99
12 81.35  97.45
13 86.89  96.87
14 94.95 100.85
15 85.32 102.71
16 88.30 100.39
17 88.43 103.86
18 91.60  99.18
19 93.99  99.60
20 81.83 101.58
21 87.70  98.20
22 83.44 100.46
23 82.81 102.04
24 86.88  96.51
25 82.62  99.52
26 96.43 101.16
27 78.97  98.89
28 86.24 102.31
29 95.12 100.71
30 87.11  99.36
31 83.14  99.79
32 90.58  99.82
33 86.16  98.77
34 93.83 101.48
35 72.60 109.07
36 88.91  97.21
37 86.99 101.73
38 94.48 100.94
39 78.07  96.56
40 87.83 102.16
41 89.45  99.75
42 84.20  97.43
43 88.33 103.66
44 85.38  96.82
45 81.19 100.23
46 91.29 100.71
47 69.36 110.23
48 88.74  96.24
49 94.24 100.64
50 82.50  98.41
51 87.85  98.00
52 83.63 105.25
53 81.54  99.02
54 88.19 100.10
55 75.03  94.68
56 97.85 100.47
57 91.98 102.09

Believe force-feeding has damaging public health impacts


       0        1 
48.76575 51.23425 
                         var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_forcefed_public_health        0      49.37 47.72 51.02
2 bin_forcefed_public_health        1      50.63 48.98 52.28
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 Maryland              55.0   373
 2 No response           54.7   128
 3 North Carolina        54.2   648
 4 Ohio                  52.8   657
 5 Pennsylvania          52.6   804
 6 New Jersey            52.0   402
 7 Florida               51.0  1138
 8 Colorado              48.2   400
 9 District of Columbia  48.2    56
10 Massachuttes          47.8   379
11 Washington            47.6   420
12 Oregon                46.9   388
                  state                        var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_forcefed_public_health      44.08 37.79 50.37
2  District of Columbia bin_forcefed_public_health      49.38 31.91 66.86
3               Florida bin_forcefed_public_health      49.66 46.02 53.30
4              Maryland bin_forcefed_public_health      52.55 46.22 58.88
5          Massachuttes bin_forcefed_public_health      45.90 39.55 52.24
6            New Jersey bin_forcefed_public_health      52.97 46.87 59.08
7           No response bin_forcefed_public_health      53.78 42.80 64.75
8        North Carolina bin_forcefed_public_health      54.31 49.35 59.28
9                  Ohio bin_forcefed_public_health      52.40 47.47 57.33
10               Oregon bin_forcefed_public_health      45.12 38.76 51.48
11         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_public_health      54.54 50.08 59.01
12           Washington bin_forcefed_public_health      47.71 41.43 53.99

             tr_message                        var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_forcefed_public_health      44.64 40.97 48.30
2  message1_welfareonly bin_forcefed_public_health      45.29 41.63 48.95
3     message2_fairness bin_forcefed_public_health      45.22 41.53 48.91
4    message3_economics bin_forcefed_public_health      40.78 37.15 44.41
5 message4_publichealth bin_forcefed_public_health      77.76 74.72 80.80

              tr_message                state                        var
1                control             Colorado bin_forcefed_public_health
2                control District of Columbia bin_forcefed_public_health
3                control              Florida bin_forcefed_public_health
4                control             Maryland bin_forcefed_public_health
5                control         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_public_health
6                control           New Jersey bin_forcefed_public_health
7                control          No response bin_forcefed_public_health
8                control       North Carolina bin_forcefed_public_health
9                control                 Ohio bin_forcefed_public_health
10               control               Oregon bin_forcefed_public_health
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_public_health
12               control           Washington bin_forcefed_public_health
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_forcefed_public_health
14  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_forcefed_public_health
15  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_forcefed_public_health
16  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_forcefed_public_health
17  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_public_health
18  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_forcefed_public_health
19  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_forcefed_public_health
20  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_forcefed_public_health
21  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_forcefed_public_health
22  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_forcefed_public_health
23  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_public_health
24  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_forcefed_public_health
25     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_forcefed_public_health
26     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_forcefed_public_health
27     message2_fairness              Florida bin_forcefed_public_health
28     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_forcefed_public_health
29     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_public_health
30     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_forcefed_public_health
31     message2_fairness          No response bin_forcefed_public_health
32     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_forcefed_public_health
33     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_forcefed_public_health
34     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_forcefed_public_health
35     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_public_health
36     message2_fairness           Washington bin_forcefed_public_health
37    message3_economics             Colorado bin_forcefed_public_health
38    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_forcefed_public_health
39    message3_economics              Florida bin_forcefed_public_health
40    message3_economics             Maryland bin_forcefed_public_health
41    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_public_health
42    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_forcefed_public_health
43    message3_economics          No response bin_forcefed_public_health
44    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_forcefed_public_health
45    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_forcefed_public_health
46    message3_economics               Oregon bin_forcefed_public_health
47    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_public_health
48    message3_economics           Washington bin_forcefed_public_health
49 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_forcefed_public_health
50 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_forcefed_public_health
51 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_forcefed_public_health
52 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_forcefed_public_health
53 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_forcefed_public_health
54 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_forcefed_public_health
55 message4_publichealth          No response bin_forcefed_public_health
56 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_forcefed_public_health
57 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_forcefed_public_health
58 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_forcefed_public_health
59 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_forcefed_public_health
60 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_forcefed_public_health
   proportion     lb     ub
1       44.93  29.92  59.93
2       20.98 -13.59  55.54
3       49.04  40.88  57.19
4       40.97  27.36  54.58
5       27.91  14.80  41.02
6       46.83  32.41  61.26
7       51.73  25.68  77.78
8       50.98  40.50  61.47
9       43.49  33.02  53.96
10      41.39  27.39  55.39
11      47.36  36.81  57.90
12      35.97  23.24  48.69
13      43.08  31.05  55.11
14      20.31  -2.26  42.89
15      42.08  34.07  50.10
16      54.63  39.12  70.14
17      47.96  32.99  62.94
18      53.39  38.63  68.15
19      45.69  17.91  73.47
20      47.68  36.72  58.63
21      46.25  35.47  57.02
22      36.01  22.28  49.73
23      46.21  36.22  56.20
24      44.65  30.92  58.37
25      43.89  28.44  59.34
26      74.02  43.76 104.29
27      43.19  35.29  51.10
28      41.60  27.21  55.98
29      42.33  28.62  56.05
30      39.12  25.29  52.94
31      56.17  33.68  78.66
32      47.92  36.90  58.94
33      47.47  36.12  58.82
34      38.45  22.88  54.02
35      48.90  39.32  58.48
36      47.48  33.49  61.48
37      22.03  10.88  33.18
38      76.93  51.85 102.01
39      38.40  30.42  46.38
40      42.85  29.21  56.48
41      33.44  20.05  46.83
42      38.25  25.22  51.27
43      40.27  17.57  62.97
44      50.80  39.65  61.95
45      47.14  36.18  58.10
46      40.67  26.50  54.84
47      45.06  35.13  54.99
48      34.43  20.33  48.54
49      63.98  50.07  77.88
50      69.96  34.28 105.64
51      76.10  69.26  82.93
52      82.27  71.04  93.50
53      73.45  61.08  85.82
54      79.29  70.77  87.80
55      80.34  62.22  98.46
56      81.81  72.64  90.99
57      84.70  75.62  93.78
58      67.69  54.78  80.60
59      84.96  78.38  91.54
60      76.38  63.44  89.32

Believe force-feeding for foie gras can still be humane


        0         1 
92.473675  7.526325 
                      var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_forcefeeding_humane        0      91.72 90.79 92.64
2 bin_forcefeeding_humane        1       8.28  7.36  9.21
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 North Carolina        9.72   648
 2 New Jersey            8.71   402
 3 Florida               8.35  1138
 4 Maryland              8.04   373
 5 No response           7.81   128
 6 Ohio                  7.61   657
 7 Colorado              7.25   400
 8 District of Columbia  7.14    56
 9 Washington            7.14   420
10 Pennsylvania          5.97   804
11 Massachuttes          5.80   379
12 Oregon                5.15   388
                  state                     var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_forcefeeding_humane       9.11  5.26 12.95
2  District of Columbia bin_forcefeeding_humane      10.87 -1.21 22.96
3               Florida bin_forcefeeding_humane       8.37  6.39 10.34
4              Maryland bin_forcefeeding_humane       9.20  5.40 12.99
5          Massachuttes bin_forcefeeding_humane       5.88  2.80  8.97
6            New Jersey bin_forcefeeding_humane       9.45  5.83 13.08
7           No response bin_forcefeeding_humane       6.67  2.35 10.99
8        North Carolina bin_forcefeeding_humane      10.41  7.38 13.44
9                  Ohio bin_forcefeeding_humane       9.16  6.15 12.18
10               Oregon bin_forcefeeding_humane       5.94  2.86  9.02
11         Pennsylvania bin_forcefeeding_humane       6.12  3.97  8.28
12           Washington bin_forcefeeding_humane       8.63  4.98 12.27

             tr_message                     var proportion   lb    ub
1               control bin_forcefeeding_humane      10.17 7.96 12.38
2  message1_welfareonly bin_forcefeeding_humane       8.15 6.00 10.30
3     message2_fairness bin_forcefeeding_humane       7.17 5.27  9.08
4    message3_economics bin_forcefeeding_humane       8.62 6.54 10.69
5 message4_publichealth bin_forcefeeding_humane       7.21 5.30  9.12

              tr_message                state                     var
1                control             Colorado bin_forcefeeding_humane
2                control District of Columbia bin_forcefeeding_humane
3                control              Florida bin_forcefeeding_humane
4                control             Maryland bin_forcefeeding_humane
5                control         Massachuttes bin_forcefeeding_humane
6                control           New Jersey bin_forcefeeding_humane
7                control          No response bin_forcefeeding_humane
8                control       North Carolina bin_forcefeeding_humane
9                control                 Ohio bin_forcefeeding_humane
10               control               Oregon bin_forcefeeding_humane
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_forcefeeding_humane
12               control           Washington bin_forcefeeding_humane
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_forcefeeding_humane
14  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_forcefeeding_humane
15  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_forcefeeding_humane
16  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_forcefeeding_humane
17  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_forcefeeding_humane
18  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_forcefeeding_humane
19  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_forcefeeding_humane
20  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_forcefeeding_humane
21  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_forcefeeding_humane
22  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_forcefeeding_humane
23  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_forcefeeding_humane
24  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_forcefeeding_humane
25     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_forcefeeding_humane
26     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_forcefeeding_humane
27     message2_fairness              Florida bin_forcefeeding_humane
28     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_forcefeeding_humane
29     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_forcefeeding_humane
30     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_forcefeeding_humane
31     message2_fairness          No response bin_forcefeeding_humane
32     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_forcefeeding_humane
33     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_forcefeeding_humane
34     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_forcefeeding_humane
35     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_forcefeeding_humane
36     message2_fairness           Washington bin_forcefeeding_humane
37    message3_economics             Colorado bin_forcefeeding_humane
38    message3_economics              Florida bin_forcefeeding_humane
39    message3_economics             Maryland bin_forcefeeding_humane
40    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_forcefeeding_humane
41    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_forcefeeding_humane
42    message3_economics          No response bin_forcefeeding_humane
43    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_forcefeeding_humane
44    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_forcefeeding_humane
45    message3_economics               Oregon bin_forcefeeding_humane
46    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_forcefeeding_humane
47    message3_economics           Washington bin_forcefeeding_humane
48 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_forcefeeding_humane
49 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_forcefeeding_humane
50 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_forcefeeding_humane
51 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_forcefeeding_humane
52 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_forcefeeding_humane
53 message4_publichealth          No response bin_forcefeeding_humane
54 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_forcefeeding_humane
55 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_forcefeeding_humane
56 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_forcefeeding_humane
57 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_forcefeeding_humane
58 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_forcefeeding_humane
   proportion     lb    ub
1       10.34   0.89 19.79
2       19.96 -13.25 53.18
3       10.18   5.65 14.70
4       16.62   5.38 27.85
5        3.10  -0.70  6.90
6        7.65   1.18 14.12
7        1.54  -1.61  4.68
8       18.89  10.74 27.03
9       10.27   3.41 17.14
10       7.21   0.63 13.78
11       5.67   0.83 10.50
12       5.12   0.29  9.94
13       8.86   1.26 16.45
14      21.45 -15.06 57.96
15       8.76   4.01 13.51
16       6.54  -0.80 13.88
17       6.03  -2.68 14.75
18       6.07  -1.79 13.93
19       3.99  -3.98 11.97
20       9.62   2.15 17.08
21       8.76   2.58 14.94
22       8.25  -0.57 17.08
23       6.52   1.85 11.18
24       9.29   0.38 18.21
25      10.29   0.08 20.50
26      11.12 -11.44 33.68
27       5.28   2.03  8.54
28      11.77   1.28 22.26
29       0.50  -0.50  1.51
30      10.23   1.86 18.60
31      11.08  -1.78 23.94
32       6.47   1.99 10.95
33       4.77  -0.15  9.69
34       8.46  -1.77 18.68
35       5.48   1.01  9.96
36      14.40   4.73 24.08
37      13.70   2.61 24.78
38      11.15   5.83 16.47
39       6.25   0.27 12.24
40       4.74   0.46  9.03
41       9.92   1.97 17.87
42       5.01  -2.16 12.17
43       7.66   2.51 12.81
44       9.61   2.85 16.38
45       1.98  -0.80  4.76
46       8.78   3.20 14.36
47       9.02  -0.51 18.54
48       3.14  -0.45  6.73
49       6.27   2.54  9.99
50       4.38   0.08  8.68
51      13.24   3.58 22.90
52      12.12   3.55 20.69
53      11.21  -1.61 24.03
54       6.40   0.87 11.93
55      12.98   4.02 21.94
56       4.33  -0.32  8.99
57       4.61  -0.12  9.34
58       5.24  -0.69 11.16

Believe the foie gras industry is unethical and promoted by wealthy elites


       0        1 
18.74676 81.25324 
                           var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_industry_unethical_elite        0      21.46 20.07 22.85
2 bin_industry_unethical_elite        1      78.54 77.15 79.93
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 Ohio                  84.6   657
 2 Pennsylvania          83.5   804
 3 Washington            83.3   420
 4 Maryland              83.1   373
 5 Colorado              81.5   400
 6 North Carolina        81.5   648
 7 Oregon                80.4   388
 8 Massachuttes          79.9   379
 9 New Jersey            79.1   402
10 Florida               78.9  1138
11 No response           77.3   128
12 District of Columbia  64.3    56
                  state                          var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_industry_unethical_elite      76.10 70.41 81.80
2  District of Columbia bin_industry_unethical_elite      60.13 42.80 77.46
3               Florida bin_industry_unethical_elite      76.39 73.24 79.54
4              Maryland bin_industry_unethical_elite      81.81 76.86 86.76
5          Massachuttes bin_industry_unethical_elite      76.63 71.09 82.17
6            New Jersey bin_industry_unethical_elite      76.59 71.35 81.83
7           No response bin_industry_unethical_elite      78.66 70.44 86.89
8        North Carolina bin_industry_unethical_elite      77.94 73.58 82.30
9                  Ohio bin_industry_unethical_elite      83.75 80.09 87.41
10               Oregon bin_industry_unethical_elite      74.74 68.80 80.68
11         Pennsylvania bin_industry_unethical_elite      81.99 78.45 85.54
12           Washington bin_industry_unethical_elite      81.03 76.01 86.06

             tr_message                          var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_industry_unethical_elite      74.62 71.34 77.90
2  message1_welfareonly bin_industry_unethical_elite      80.64 77.68 83.60
3     message2_fairness bin_industry_unethical_elite      82.86 79.95 85.78
4    message3_economics bin_industry_unethical_elite      76.62 73.34 79.90
5 message4_publichealth bin_industry_unethical_elite      78.16 75.10 81.21

              tr_message                state                          var
1                control             Colorado bin_industry_unethical_elite
2                control District of Columbia bin_industry_unethical_elite
3                control              Florida bin_industry_unethical_elite
4                control             Maryland bin_industry_unethical_elite
5                control         Massachuttes bin_industry_unethical_elite
6                control           New Jersey bin_industry_unethical_elite
7                control          No response bin_industry_unethical_elite
8                control       North Carolina bin_industry_unethical_elite
9                control                 Ohio bin_industry_unethical_elite
10               control               Oregon bin_industry_unethical_elite
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_industry_unethical_elite
12               control           Washington bin_industry_unethical_elite
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_industry_unethical_elite
14  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_industry_unethical_elite
15  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_industry_unethical_elite
16  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_industry_unethical_elite
17  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_industry_unethical_elite
18  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_industry_unethical_elite
19  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_industry_unethical_elite
20  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_industry_unethical_elite
21  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_industry_unethical_elite
22  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_industry_unethical_elite
23  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_industry_unethical_elite
24  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_industry_unethical_elite
25     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_industry_unethical_elite
26     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_industry_unethical_elite
27     message2_fairness              Florida bin_industry_unethical_elite
28     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_industry_unethical_elite
29     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_industry_unethical_elite
30     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_industry_unethical_elite
31     message2_fairness          No response bin_industry_unethical_elite
32     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_industry_unethical_elite
33     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_industry_unethical_elite
34     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_industry_unethical_elite
35     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_industry_unethical_elite
36     message2_fairness           Washington bin_industry_unethical_elite
37    message3_economics             Colorado bin_industry_unethical_elite
38    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_industry_unethical_elite
39    message3_economics              Florida bin_industry_unethical_elite
40    message3_economics             Maryland bin_industry_unethical_elite
41    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_industry_unethical_elite
42    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_industry_unethical_elite
43    message3_economics          No response bin_industry_unethical_elite
44    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_industry_unethical_elite
45    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_industry_unethical_elite
46    message3_economics               Oregon bin_industry_unethical_elite
47    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_industry_unethical_elite
48    message3_economics           Washington bin_industry_unethical_elite
49 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_industry_unethical_elite
50 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_industry_unethical_elite
51 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_industry_unethical_elite
52 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_industry_unethical_elite
53 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_industry_unethical_elite
54 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_industry_unethical_elite
55 message4_publichealth          No response bin_industry_unethical_elite
56 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_industry_unethical_elite
57 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_industry_unethical_elite
58 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_industry_unethical_elite
59 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_industry_unethical_elite
60 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_industry_unethical_elite
   proportion    lb     ub
1       71.48 57.71  85.24
2       27.53 -7.75  62.81
3       73.99 66.88  81.11
4       77.25 64.36  90.15
5       67.12 53.37  80.86
6       79.55 67.78  91.31
7       64.97 39.47  90.47
8       67.57 57.30  77.85
9       86.31 80.32  92.29
10      71.58 58.30  84.86
11      80.83 72.21  89.45
12      76.21 64.85  87.57
13      77.17 66.08  88.26
14      56.68 20.72  92.63
15      80.30 73.86  86.74
16      93.63 88.55  98.71
17      77.86 65.55  90.16
18      70.06 55.98  84.15
19      84.09 63.40 104.78
20      76.39 66.84  85.94
21      83.82 75.92  91.72
22      73.63 59.29  87.97
23      85.58 78.65  92.51
24      87.36 78.23  96.50
25      79.16 65.79  92.53
26      75.22 44.03 106.41
27      76.75 69.48  84.03
28      82.40 71.14  93.66
29      92.73 87.16  98.29
30      78.57 66.43  90.71
31      71.49 51.87  91.12
32      93.24 87.67  98.81
33      83.06 73.81  92.31
34      80.02 67.01  93.02
35      86.61 80.17  93.06
36      83.73 73.10  94.35
37      83.04 71.68  94.39
38      81.08 50.86 111.29
39      76.83 69.64  84.02
40      83.12 73.07  93.18
41      67.55 53.34  81.77
42      67.40 54.62  80.18
43      90.52 81.52  99.52
44      80.99 71.32  90.66
45      80.09 70.74  89.44
46      78.08 65.35  90.80
47      67.51 57.57  77.45
48      78.33 64.88  91.78
49      70.81 57.18  84.43
50      77.79 51.22 104.36
51      73.97 66.78  81.16
52      75.09 63.47  86.72
53      79.68 68.63  90.72
54      86.02 78.88  93.16
55      74.02 54.51  93.53
56      72.95 61.71  84.19
57      85.71 77.89  93.54
58      71.53 58.69  84.37
59      86.66 79.51  93.82
60      77.72 65.62  89.82

Believe most Americans are not supportive of the foie gras industry


       0        1 
38.16675 61.83325 
                                var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_most_americans_not_supportive        0      37.64 36.05 39.23
2 bin_most_americans_not_supportive        1      62.36 60.77 63.95
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 Ohio                  65.3   657
 2 Pennsylvania          64.9   804
 3 Oregon                64.2   388
 4 Washington            63.1   420
 5 North Carolina        62.0   648
 6 Florida               61.7  1138
 7 No response           60.2   128
 8 Massachuttes          59.9   379
 9 Colorado              59.8   400
10 New Jersey            59.2   402
11 Maryland              56.6   373
12 District of Columbia  37.5    56
                  state                               var proportion    lb
1              Colorado bin_most_americans_not_supportive      60.39 54.25
2  District of Columbia bin_most_americans_not_supportive      39.45 22.22
3               Florida bin_most_americans_not_supportive      60.39 56.82
4              Maryland bin_most_americans_not_supportive      58.89 52.73
5          Massachuttes bin_most_americans_not_supportive      55.53 49.13
6            New Jersey bin_most_americans_not_supportive      61.47 55.57
7           No response bin_most_americans_not_supportive      57.30 46.30
8        North Carolina bin_most_americans_not_supportive      63.30 58.52
9                  Ohio bin_most_americans_not_supportive      66.83 62.22
10               Oregon bin_most_americans_not_supportive      63.84 57.69
11         Pennsylvania bin_most_americans_not_supportive      67.04 62.87
12           Washington bin_most_americans_not_supportive      67.56 61.80
      ub
1  66.52
2  56.68
3  63.96
4  65.06
5  61.94
6  67.38
7  68.30
8  68.09
9  71.43
10 69.98
11 71.21
12 73.32

             tr_message                               var proportion    lb
1               control bin_most_americans_not_supportive      58.62 55.01
2  message1_welfareonly bin_most_americans_not_supportive      58.68 55.07
3     message2_fairness bin_most_americans_not_supportive      78.08 75.07
4    message3_economics bin_most_americans_not_supportive      60.79 57.19
5 message4_publichealth bin_most_americans_not_supportive      56.25 52.59
     ub
1 62.23
2 62.30
3 81.09
4 64.39
5 59.90

              tr_message                state                               var
1                control             Colorado bin_most_americans_not_supportive
2                control District of Columbia bin_most_americans_not_supportive
3                control              Florida bin_most_americans_not_supportive
4                control             Maryland bin_most_americans_not_supportive
5                control         Massachuttes bin_most_americans_not_supportive
6                control           New Jersey bin_most_americans_not_supportive
7                control          No response bin_most_americans_not_supportive
8                control       North Carolina bin_most_americans_not_supportive
9                control                 Ohio bin_most_americans_not_supportive
10               control               Oregon bin_most_americans_not_supportive
11               control         Pennsylvania bin_most_americans_not_supportive
12               control           Washington bin_most_americans_not_supportive
13  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_most_americans_not_supportive
14  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_most_americans_not_supportive
15  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_most_americans_not_supportive
16  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_most_americans_not_supportive
17  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_most_americans_not_supportive
18  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_most_americans_not_supportive
19  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_most_americans_not_supportive
20  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_most_americans_not_supportive
21  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_most_americans_not_supportive
22  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_most_americans_not_supportive
23  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_most_americans_not_supportive
24  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_most_americans_not_supportive
25     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_most_americans_not_supportive
26     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_most_americans_not_supportive
27     message2_fairness              Florida bin_most_americans_not_supportive
28     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_most_americans_not_supportive
29     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_most_americans_not_supportive
30     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_most_americans_not_supportive
31     message2_fairness          No response bin_most_americans_not_supportive
32     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_most_americans_not_supportive
33     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_most_americans_not_supportive
34     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_most_americans_not_supportive
35     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_most_americans_not_supportive
36     message2_fairness           Washington bin_most_americans_not_supportive
37    message3_economics             Colorado bin_most_americans_not_supportive
38    message3_economics District of Columbia bin_most_americans_not_supportive
39    message3_economics              Florida bin_most_americans_not_supportive
40    message3_economics             Maryland bin_most_americans_not_supportive
41    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_most_americans_not_supportive
42    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_most_americans_not_supportive
43    message3_economics          No response bin_most_americans_not_supportive
44    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_most_americans_not_supportive
45    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_most_americans_not_supportive
46    message3_economics               Oregon bin_most_americans_not_supportive
47    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_most_americans_not_supportive
48    message3_economics           Washington bin_most_americans_not_supportive
49 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_most_americans_not_supportive
50 message4_publichealth District of Columbia bin_most_americans_not_supportive
51 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_most_americans_not_supportive
52 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_most_americans_not_supportive
53 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_most_americans_not_supportive
54 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_most_americans_not_supportive
55 message4_publichealth          No response bin_most_americans_not_supportive
56 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_most_americans_not_supportive
57 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_most_americans_not_supportive
58 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_most_americans_not_supportive
59 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_most_americans_not_supportive
60 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_most_americans_not_supportive
   proportion    lb     ub
1       58.68 44.14  73.22
2       47.88  7.61  88.14
3       56.40 48.34  64.46
4       57.30 43.20  71.40
5       46.34 31.89  60.78
6       55.32 40.92  69.72
7       48.15 22.06  74.24
8       61.14 51.09  71.19
9       66.82 57.22  76.42
10      52.79 38.34  67.23
11      64.29 54.47  74.11
12      62.01 49.37  74.66
13      54.53 42.40  66.66
14      26.03 -0.76  52.81
15      55.69 47.59  63.79
16      43.86 28.61  59.12
17      59.05 44.21  73.88
18      77.59 66.75  88.43
19      38.97 14.81  63.12
20      55.60 44.70  66.50
21      62.35 51.75  72.95
22      58.86 44.74  72.98
23      60.34 50.58  70.09
24      69.63 57.20  82.07
25      76.68 64.91  88.44
26      81.06 54.91 107.22
27      76.62 69.89  83.35
28      69.89 57.18  82.60
29      81.87 70.66  93.08
30      66.62 52.55  80.68
31      58.52 35.61  81.42
32      76.87 67.26  86.48
33      80.22 71.56  88.88
34      88.91 81.20  96.63
35      83.92 77.17  90.67
36      83.62 73.46  93.77
37      60.54 45.88  75.20
38      48.84 11.15  86.53
39      60.58 52.51  68.64
40      72.05 60.47  83.62
41      53.99 39.51  68.46
42      62.67 49.80  75.54
43      66.57 45.61  87.53
44      56.74 45.62  67.86
45      58.29 47.49  69.09
46      67.44 54.57  80.31
47      59.99 50.19  69.78
48      57.74 43.14  72.35
49      55.21 41.20  69.23
50       2.54 -2.94   8.01
51      53.12 44.92  61.32
52      49.23 35.93  62.52
53      41.41 28.60  54.22
54      50.24 38.07  62.40
55      65.26 41.50  89.01
56      68.02 56.86  79.18
57      66.94 55.80  78.08
58      56.49 43.02  69.96
59      62.72 52.81  72.63
60      63.75 50.22  77.27

Believe it is important to preserve consumer choice and stop foie gras bans


       0        1 
86.00035 13.99965 
                            var category proportion    lb    ub
1 bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans        0      84.35 83.12 85.58
2 bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans        1      15.65 14.42 16.88
# A tibble: 12 × 3
   state                 prop     n
   <chr>                <dbl> <int>
 1 New Jersey           16.9    402
 2 Maryland             15.8    373
 3 Florida              15.5   1138
 4 North Carolina       14.8    648
 5 Colorado             14.2    400
 6 Oregon               14.2    388
 7 Washington           13.6    420
 8 Pennsylvania         12.9    804
 9 Ohio                 12.2    657
10 Massachuttes         11.3    379
11 No response          10.2    128
12 District of Columbia  5.36    56
                  state                           var proportion    lb    ub
1              Colorado bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      18.08 12.89 23.27
2  District of Columbia bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans       9.49 -1.48 20.45
3               Florida bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      16.22 13.52 18.92
4              Maryland bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      16.51 11.80 21.23
5          Massachuttes bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      10.32  6.61 14.04
6            New Jersey bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      15.82 11.49 20.16
7           No response bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      10.16  3.66 16.66
8        North Carolina bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      19.43 15.23 23.64
9                  Ohio bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      14.93 11.24 18.61
10               Oregon bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      16.50 11.49 21.52
11         Pennsylvania bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      13.38 10.28 16.48
12           Washington bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      16.29 11.46 21.12

             tr_message                           var proportion    lb    ub
1               control bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      18.54 15.52 21.55
2  message1_welfareonly bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      16.26 13.43 19.08
3     message2_fairness bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      15.47 12.78 18.17
4    message3_economics bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      13.89 11.34 16.45
5 message4_publichealth bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans      14.00 11.41 16.59

              tr_message                state                           var
1                control             Colorado bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
2                control              Florida bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
3                control             Maryland bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
4                control         Massachuttes bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
5                control           New Jersey bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
6                control          No response bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
7                control       North Carolina bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
8                control                 Ohio bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
9                control               Oregon bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
10               control         Pennsylvania bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
11               control           Washington bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
12  message1_welfareonly             Colorado bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
13  message1_welfareonly District of Columbia bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
14  message1_welfareonly              Florida bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
15  message1_welfareonly             Maryland bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
16  message1_welfareonly         Massachuttes bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
17  message1_welfareonly           New Jersey bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
18  message1_welfareonly          No response bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
19  message1_welfareonly       North Carolina bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
20  message1_welfareonly                 Ohio bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
21  message1_welfareonly               Oregon bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
22  message1_welfareonly         Pennsylvania bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
23  message1_welfareonly           Washington bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
24     message2_fairness             Colorado bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
25     message2_fairness District of Columbia bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
26     message2_fairness              Florida bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
27     message2_fairness             Maryland bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
28     message2_fairness         Massachuttes bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
29     message2_fairness           New Jersey bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
30     message2_fairness          No response bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
31     message2_fairness       North Carolina bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
32     message2_fairness                 Ohio bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
33     message2_fairness               Oregon bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
34     message2_fairness         Pennsylvania bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
35     message2_fairness           Washington bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
36    message3_economics             Colorado bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
37    message3_economics              Florida bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
38    message3_economics             Maryland bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
39    message3_economics         Massachuttes bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
40    message3_economics           New Jersey bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
41    message3_economics          No response bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
42    message3_economics       North Carolina bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
43    message3_economics                 Ohio bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
44    message3_economics               Oregon bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
45    message3_economics         Pennsylvania bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
46    message3_economics           Washington bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
47 message4_publichealth             Colorado bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
48 message4_publichealth              Florida bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
49 message4_publichealth             Maryland bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
50 message4_publichealth         Massachuttes bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
51 message4_publichealth           New Jersey bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
52 message4_publichealth          No response bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
53 message4_publichealth       North Carolina bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
54 message4_publichealth                 Ohio bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
55 message4_publichealth               Oregon bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
56 message4_publichealth         Pennsylvania bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
57 message4_publichealth           Washington bin_preserve_choice_stop_bans
   proportion     lb    ub
1       33.81  18.40 49.21
2       21.87  14.99 28.75
3       26.60  13.81 39.39
4       11.28   2.96 19.60
5       16.04   5.26 26.82
6       12.16  -7.65 31.96
7       25.24  15.57 34.91
8       15.59   7.14 24.04
9       11.23   3.43 19.02
10      11.48   4.07 18.89
11       9.80   3.11 16.49
12      15.04   5.88 24.21
13      21.45 -15.06 57.96
14      17.28  10.92 23.63
15      15.66   4.38 26.94
16      11.36   1.80 20.91
17      12.00   3.05 20.95
18       1.40  -1.47  4.27
19      24.26  14.52 34.01
20       7.09   2.85 11.33
21      24.26  10.33 38.19
22      15.72   7.80 23.65
23      20.44   9.00 31.88
24      13.56   4.48 22.63
25      43.62  -2.02 89.27
26      17.61  11.59 23.64
27      17.55   6.01 29.09
28       8.77   1.47 16.06
29      22.44  10.05 34.82
30      10.26  -1.53 22.05
31      15.67   6.74 24.59
32      16.76   7.99 25.54
33      16.80   5.02 28.58
34      13.51   7.36 19.65
35       6.18   0.98 11.39
36      10.23   2.28 18.18
37      11.56   6.66 16.46
38       4.14   0.68  7.60
39       4.41   0.44  8.37
40      14.13   5.43 22.83
41      15.13  -1.57 31.83
42      17.70   8.44 26.96
43      16.45   8.28 24.62
44      18.85   6.03 31.67
45      17.31  10.15 24.47
46      26.19  11.84 40.53
47      16.67   5.83 27.51
48      12.94   7.16 18.73
49      18.31   8.26 28.35
50      15.39   5.32 25.47
51      15.53   7.20 23.85
52       8.60  -1.32 18.52
53      10.47   3.37 17.57
54      19.91   9.19 30.62
55      11.67   4.48 18.86
56       9.31   3.33 15.29
57      18.48   6.91 30.04