Indexing Housing Finance Tightness and Its Short-Run Impact on Mortgage Lending in Germany

Khushal Khan · Parisa Arfaei

Indexing Housing Finance Tightness and Its Short-Run Impact on Mortgage Lending in Germany

Khushal Khan · Parisa Arfaei
University of Hohenheim logo
Applied Data Science Lab · MLW-BW · University of Hohenheim · Supervisor: Prof. Aderonke Osikominu

Summary

We build a monthly Housing Finance Tightness Index (HFTI) for Germany from Bundesbank MFI statistics and measure how lending responds in the next few months when tightness changes. Inputs are rate level, monthly rate change, and loan volume growth. We cross-check with PCA and estimate a small distributed-lag model for short-run effects.

Data

Source: Deutsche Bundesbank, MFI interest rate statistics (BBIM1), new business to private households, monthly.

Main series: mortgage rate with initial fixation >10y (level), total new housing loan volume.

Units: rates in % p.a. and volumes in million EUR.

Index construction

Inputs (monthly):

Standardisation: for any series \(x_t\), define \(\tilde{x}_t = \dfrac{x_t - \mu_x}{\sigma_x}\).

Index:

\[ \mathrm{HFTI}_t = \frac{1}{3}\,\Big(\tilde{r}_t + \widetilde{\Delta r}_t - \tilde{g}_t\Big). \]

Higher values indicate tighter housing finance conditions.


HFTI over time

HFTI line
Monthly z-score; higher means tighter. Source: Bundesbank (BBIM1).

Short-run response

Outcome: \(y_t = \Delta \log V_t\) (monthly loan-volume growth).

Model (distributed lags):

\[ y_t = \alpha + \beta_{0}\,\mathrm{HFTI}_{t} + \beta_{1}\,\mathrm{HFTI}_{t-1} + \beta_{2}\,\mathrm{HFTI}_{t-2} + \beta_{3}\,\mathrm{HFTI}_{t-3} + \varepsilon_t . \]

Key effects:

Estimation by OLS; we report point estimates with 95% confidence intervals.


Effect of tightness by month

Lag coefficients
OLS coefficients with 95% confidence intervals.

PCA check

We also build a PCA index (PC1) from the same inputs and compare it to HFTI to confirm both tell the same story.

HFTI vs PCA (sanity check)

Overlay HFTI vs PC1
Solid line is HFTI; dashed blue line is PCA PC1.

Takeaways