Indemnity Payments

Vathy M. Kamulete
November 9th, 2015

The Summary (tl;dr)

  • Indemnity payments make investing in NHAMBS safer.
    • Protect against adverse shifts in the yield curve.
    • Option to limit the impact of prepayments.

This is why you pass it on.

  • Indemnity payments are not one-to-one pass-through.
    • What you collect from borrowers.
    • what you pay to investors.
    • The difference: a source of frustration.

The Problem

You issued NHAMBS pools. No one is buying. Why?

They fear that:

  1. Your mortgages will prepay quickly.
  2. They will have to re-invest the proceeds at (lower) interest rates.

The Fix

The (partial) fix? Indemnity payments.

Indemnity payments ensure that:

  1. They are adequately compensated only when the pool prepays.
  2. These payments are tied to the value of the NHAMBS pool in the current interest rate environment.

The Payment to Them (Investors)

How? This simple:

\[ \begin{equation} \begin{aligned} \text{Price Above Par} = &\text{MBS Clean Price} - \text{MBS Par Price} \\ \text{Indemnity Factor} = &\max{[\text{Price Above Par}, 0]} \\ \text{Indemnity Payment} = &\text{Indemnity Factor}*\text{Prepayments} \end{aligned} \end{equation} \]

  • This is what they (investors) expect to receive.
  • This is uniform and mandated by CMHC.

The Payment to You (Issuers)

But typically*

\[ \begin{equation} \begin{aligned} \text{IRD} & = \text{ Locked-in Rate} - \text{ Market Rate} \\ \text{IRD Penalty} & = \text{ No. of Remaining Years}*\text{ IRD } \\ \text{Standard Penalty} & = 3*\text{Monthly WAC Coupon} \\ \text{Indemnity Factor} & = \max{[\text{IRD Penalty}, \text{Standard Penalty}]} \\ \text{Indemnity Payment} & = \text{Indemnity Factor}*\text{Prepayments} \end{aligned} \end{equation} \]

  • This is what you (issuers) expect to collect from mortgagers.
  • This is not uniform across credit unions and financial institutions.

The Headache

The (Official) Guide

For all the gory details, see:

NHA MBS Indemnity Calculation Methodology

The Valuation (Simplified)

The Cash Flows

The Discount Factors

The Valuation (not-so-simple)

The Example

Attributes Values
Issue Date 2012-12-01
Maturity Date 2017-09-01
Number of Mortgage in Pool 1
NHA-MBS Coupon Rate 2.00%
Weighted Average Mortage Coupon (WAC) Rate 3.25%
Weighted Average Remaining Amortization (RAM) 325
Amount Maturing at Maturity Date ( TRM ) $1.00
Amount Maturing 1-Month Before Maturity Date ( TRM-1 ) $0.00
Amount Maturing 2-Month Before Maturity Date ( TRM-2 ) $0.00
Amount Maturing 3-Month Before Maturity Date ( TRM-3 ) $0.00
Amount Maturing 4-Month Before Maturity Date ( TRM-4 ) $0.00
Amount Maturing 5-Month Before Maturity Date ( TRM-5 ) $0.00

The Prepayment Assumptions

CMHC tells you.

For 970/975 pool-type, these are:

  • Annualized Core Liquidation Rate (LQR) is 4.00%
  • Annualzied Partial Prepayment rate (PPR) is 1.00%

The Yield Curves

shifts

The Shift

prices

The Conclusion

For investors, indemnity payments are good

  • They make investing in NHAMBS safe.

For issuers, indemnity payments are good too

  • Investors will buy.

But it also adds an additional layer of complexity for issuers – collecting from borrowers versus paying what's due to investors.

Click here to see difference in payments again

The Contacts

If you have any question…

Blake Dumelie (bdumelie@central1.com)

Linda Jeffery (ljeffery@central1.com)

Vathy M. Kamulete (vkamulete@central1.com)

Thank you.