NB Project: Cell Death

Author

AB

Published

June 27, 2024

Code
library(readxl)
library(car)
library(multcomp)
library(ggplot2)
library(writexl)
Code
# Load the data
NB_data <- read_excel("Fold Change Calculations for Final Data_tidy.xlsx", sheet = 4)
data3 <- NB_data

# Display the first few rows of the imported data
head(data3)
# A tibble: 6 × 4
  Sample Gene  Treatment cell_death
   <dbl> <chr> <chr>          <dbl>
1      1 C57   Control          4.4
2      2 C57   LPS             12.9
3      3 C57   ATP              8.4
4      4 C57   LPS+ATP         28.5
5      5 C57   NIG              1.2
6      6 C57   LPS+NIG         48.6
Code
# Convert relevant columns to factors (Assuming 'Treatment' and 'Gene' are columns)
data3$Treatment <- factor(data3$Treatment, levels = c(
  "Control", "ATP", "LPS", "LPS+ATP", "LPS+NIG", "NIG"))
data3$Gene <- as.factor(data3$Gene)
head(data3)
# A tibble: 6 × 4
  Sample Gene  Treatment cell_death
   <dbl> <fct> <fct>          <dbl>
1      1 C57   Control          4.4
2      2 C57   LPS             12.9
3      3 C57   ATP              8.4
4      4 C57   LPS+ATP         28.5
5      5 C57   NIG              1.2
6      6 C57   LPS+NIG         48.6
Code
# Perform a two-way ANOVA (Assuming 'cell_death' is the dependent variable)
anova_result <- aov(cell_death ~ Treatment * Gene, data = data3)

# Display the summary of ANOVA results
summary(anova_result)
               Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value   Pr(>F)    
Treatment       5  34902    6980  427.83  < 2e-16 ***
Gene            3   2644     881   54.01 5.40e-16 ***
Treatment:Gene 15   3382     225   13.82 3.58e-13 ***
Residuals      52    848      16                     
---
Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
8 observations deleted due to missingness
Code
# Perform Tukey's HSD post-hoc test for multiple comparisons
tukey_result <- TukeyHSD(anova_result)
print(tukey_result)
  Tukey multiple comparisons of means
    95% family-wise confidence level

Fit: aov(formula = cell_death ~ Treatment * Gene, data = data3)

$Treatment
                         diff        lwr        upr     p adj
ATP-Control      9.044048e+00   4.342699  13.745396 0.0000085
LPS-Control      1.694048e+00  -3.007301   6.395396 0.8924712
LPS+ATP-Control  3.784725e+01  33.244299  42.450206 0.0000000
LPS+NIG-Control  5.636905e+01  51.667699  61.070396 0.0000000
NIG-Control      1.693407e+00  -2.909547   6.296360 0.8837820
LPS-ATP         -7.350000e+00 -12.228820  -2.471180 0.0006076
LPS+ATP-ATP      2.880321e+01  24.019129  33.587282 0.0000000
LPS+NIG-ATP      4.732500e+01  42.446180  52.203820 0.0000000
NIG-ATP         -7.350641e+00 -12.134718  -2.566564 0.0004531
LPS+ATP-LPS      3.615321e+01  31.369129  40.937282 0.0000000
LPS+NIG-LPS      5.467500e+01  49.796180  59.553820 0.0000000
NIG-LPS         -6.410256e-04  -4.784718   4.783436 1.0000000
LPS+NIG-LPS+ATP  1.852179e+01  13.737718  23.305871 0.0000000
NIG-LPS+ATP     -3.615385e+01 -40.841265 -31.466428 0.0000000
NIG-LPS+NIG     -5.467564e+01 -59.459718 -49.891564 0.0000000

$Gene
                  diff         lwr         upr     p adj
APOE4-APOE3   3.626186   0.1826258   7.0697464 0.0354192
C57-APOE3   -12.300000 -15.8735514  -8.7264486 0.0000000
NULL-APOE3   -3.377358  -6.9035760   0.1488591 0.0650924
C57-APOE4   -15.926186 -19.3697464 -12.4826258 0.0000000
NULL-APOE4   -7.003545 -10.3979588  -3.6091303 0.0000075
NULL-C57      8.922642   5.3964240  12.4488591 0.0000001

$`Treatment:Gene`
                                     diff         lwr         upr     p adj
ATP:APOE3-Control:APOE3       8.800000000  -3.8566619  21.4566619 0.5521507
LPS:APOE3-Control:APOE3      -1.800000000 -14.4566619  10.8566619 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:APOE3-Control:APOE3  31.533333333  18.8766714  44.1899953 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE3-Control:APOE3  49.300000000  36.6433381  61.9566619 0.0000000
NIG:APOE3-Control:APOE3      -0.766666667 -13.4233286  11.8899953 1.0000000
Control:APOE4-Control:APOE3  -5.933333333 -17.7725565   5.9058898 0.9522620
ATP:APOE4-Control:APOE3       7.566666667  -5.0899953  20.2233286 0.8019927
LPS:APOE4-Control:APOE3      -7.000000000 -19.6566619   5.6566619 0.8874077
LPS+ATP:APOE4-Control:APOE3  51.866666667  40.0274435  63.7058898 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-Control:APOE3  64.433333333  51.7766714  77.0899953 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-Control:APOE3      -2.908333333 -14.7475565   8.9308898 0.9999984
Control:C57-Control:APOE3    -9.833333333 -22.4899953   2.8233286 0.3428141
ATP:C57-Control:APOE3        -5.600000000 -18.2566619   7.0566619 0.9871084
LPS:C57-Control:APOE3        -6.733333333 -19.3899953   5.9233286 0.9181652
LPS+ATP:C57-Control:APOE3    14.766666667   2.1100047  27.4233286 0.0078401
LPS+NIG:C57-Control:APOE3    27.000000000  14.3433381  39.6566619 0.0000000
NIG:C57-Control:APOE3        -6.333333333 -18.9899953   6.3233286 0.9529505
Control:NULL-Control:APOE3   -7.758333333 -19.5975565   4.0808898 0.6606363
ATP:NULL-Control:APOE3        1.333333333 -11.3233286  13.9899953 1.0000000
LPS:NULL-Control:APOE3       -1.766666667 -14.4233286  10.8899953 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-Control:APOE3   22.466666667   9.8100047  35.1233286 0.0000025
LPS+NIG:NULL-Control:APOE3   60.666666667  48.0100047  73.3233286 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-Control:APOE3       -7.766666667 -20.4233286   4.8899953 0.7660162
LPS:APOE3-ATP:APOE3         -10.600000000 -23.2566619   2.0566619 0.2204672
LPS+ATP:APOE3-ATP:APOE3      22.733333333  10.0766714  35.3899953 0.0000019
LPS+NIG:APOE3-ATP:APOE3      40.500000000  27.8433381  53.1566619 0.0000000
NIG:APOE3-ATP:APOE3          -9.566666667 -22.2233286   3.0899953 0.3930005
Control:APOE4-ATP:APOE3     -14.733333333 -26.5725565  -2.8941102 0.0030525
ATP:APOE4-ATP:APOE3          -1.233333333 -13.8899953  11.4233286 1.0000000
LPS:APOE4-ATP:APOE3         -15.800000000 -28.4566619  -3.1433381 0.0029082
LPS+ATP:APOE4-ATP:APOE3      43.066666667  31.2274435  54.9058898 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-ATP:APOE3      55.633333333  42.9766714  68.2899953 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-ATP:APOE3         -11.708333333 -23.5475565   0.1308898 0.0559583
Control:C57-ATP:APOE3       -18.633333333 -31.2899953  -5.9766714 0.0001597
ATP:C57-ATP:APOE3           -14.400000000 -27.0566619  -1.7433381 0.0110174
LPS:C57-ATP:APOE3           -15.533333333 -28.1899953  -2.8766714 0.0037725
LPS+ATP:C57-ATP:APOE3         5.966666667  -6.6899953  18.6233286 0.9741134
LPS+NIG:C57-ATP:APOE3        18.200000000   5.5433381  30.8566619 0.0002522
NIG:C57-ATP:APOE3           -15.133333333 -27.7899953  -2.4766714 0.0055434
Control:NULL-ATP:APOE3      -16.558333333 -28.3975565  -4.7191102 0.0004244
ATP:NULL-ATP:APOE3           -7.466666667 -20.1233286   5.1899953 0.8189295
LPS:NULL-ATP:APOE3          -10.566666667 -23.2233286   2.0899953 0.2250596
LPS+ATP:NULL-ATP:APOE3       13.666666667   1.0100047  26.3233286 0.0212971
LPS+NIG:NULL-ATP:APOE3       51.866666667  39.2100047  64.5233286 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-ATP:APOE3          -16.566666667 -29.2233286  -3.9100047 0.0013567
LPS+ATP:APOE3-LPS:APOE3      33.333333333  20.6766714  45.9899953 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE3-LPS:APOE3      51.100000000  38.4433381  63.7566619 0.0000000
NIG:APOE3-LPS:APOE3           1.033333333 -11.6233286  13.6899953 1.0000000
Control:APOE4-LPS:APOE3      -4.133333333 -15.9725565   7.7058898 0.9994343
ATP:APOE4-LPS:APOE3           9.366666667  -3.2899953  22.0233286 0.4327662
LPS:APOE4-LPS:APOE3          -5.200000000 -17.8566619   7.4566619 0.9947187
LPS+ATP:APOE4-LPS:APOE3      53.666666667  41.8274435  65.5058898 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-LPS:APOE3      66.233333333  53.5766714  78.8899953 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-LPS:APOE3          -1.108333333 -12.9475565  10.7308898 1.0000000
Control:C57-LPS:APOE3        -8.033333333 -20.6899953   4.6233286 0.7143047
ATP:C57-LPS:APOE3            -3.800000000 -16.4566619   8.8566619 0.9999470
LPS:C57-LPS:APOE3            -4.933333333 -17.5899953   7.7233286 0.9973315
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS:APOE3        16.566666667   3.9100047  29.2233286 0.0013567
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS:APOE3        28.800000000  16.1433381  41.4566619 0.0000000
NIG:C57-LPS:APOE3            -4.533333333 -17.1899953   8.1233286 0.9991772
Control:NULL-LPS:APOE3       -5.958333333 -17.7975565   5.8808898 0.9503210
ATP:NULL-LPS:APOE3            3.133333333  -9.5233286  15.7899953 0.9999982
LPS:NULL-LPS:APOE3            0.033333333 -12.6233286  12.6899953 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS:APOE3       24.266666667  11.6100047  36.9233286 0.0000003
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS:APOE3       62.466666667  49.8100047  75.1233286 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS:APOE3           -5.966666667 -18.6233286   6.6899953 0.9741134
LPS+NIG:APOE3-LPS+ATP:APOE3  17.766666667   5.1100047  30.4233286 0.0003967
NIG:APOE3-LPS+ATP:APOE3     -32.300000000 -44.9566619 -19.6433381 0.0000000
Control:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE3 -37.466666667 -49.3058898 -25.6274435 0.0000000
ATP:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE3     -23.966666667 -36.6233286 -11.3100047 0.0000005
LPS:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE3     -38.533333333 -51.1899953 -25.8766714 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE3  20.333333333   8.4941102  32.1725565 0.0000056
LPS+NIG:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE3  32.900000000  20.2433381  45.5566619 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE3     -34.441666667 -46.2808898 -22.6024435 0.0000000
Control:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE3   -41.366666667 -54.0233286 -28.7100047 0.0000000
ATP:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE3       -37.133333333 -49.7899953 -24.4766714 0.0000000
LPS:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE3       -38.266666667 -50.9233286 -25.6100047 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE3   -16.766666667 -29.4233286  -4.1100047 0.0011084
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE3    -4.533333333 -17.1899953   8.1233286 0.9991772
NIG:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE3       -37.866666667 -50.5233286 -25.2100047 0.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE3  -39.291666667 -51.1308898 -27.4524435 0.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE3      -30.200000000 -42.8566619 -17.5433381 0.0000000
LPS:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE3      -33.300000000 -45.9566619 -20.6433381 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE3   -9.066666667 -21.7233286   3.5899953 0.4950679
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE3   29.133333333  16.4766714  41.7899953 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE3      -39.300000000 -51.9566619 -26.6433381 0.0000000
NIG:APOE3-LPS+NIG:APOE3     -50.066666667 -62.7233286 -37.4100047 0.0000000
Control:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE3 -55.233333333 -67.0725565 -43.3941102 0.0000000
ATP:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE3     -41.733333333 -54.3899953 -29.0766714 0.0000000
LPS:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE3     -56.300000000 -68.9566619 -43.6433381 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE3   2.566666667  -9.2725565  14.4058898 0.9999999
LPS+NIG:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE3  15.133333333   2.4766714  27.7899953 0.0055434
NIG:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE3     -52.208333333 -64.0475565 -40.3691102 0.0000000
Control:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE3   -59.133333333 -71.7899953 -46.4766714 0.0000000
ATP:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE3       -54.900000000 -67.5566619 -42.2433381 0.0000000
LPS:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE3       -56.033333333 -68.6899953 -43.3766714 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE3   -34.533333333 -47.1899953 -21.8766714 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE3   -22.300000000 -34.9566619  -9.6433381 0.0000030
NIG:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE3       -55.633333333 -68.2899953 -42.9766714 0.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE3  -57.058333333 -68.8975565 -45.2191102 0.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE3      -47.966666667 -60.6233286 -35.3100047 0.0000000
LPS:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE3      -51.066666667 -63.7233286 -38.4100047 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE3  -26.833333333 -39.4899953 -14.1766714 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE3   11.366666667  -1.2899953  24.0233286 0.1328085
NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE3      -57.066666667 -69.7233286 -44.4100047 0.0000000
Control:APOE4-NIG:APOE3      -5.166666667 -17.0058898   6.6725565 0.9890103
ATP:APOE4-NIG:APOE3           8.333333333  -4.3233286  20.9899953 0.6523457
LPS:APOE4-NIG:APOE3          -6.233333333 -18.8899953   6.4233286 0.9596597
LPS+ATP:APOE4-NIG:APOE3      52.633333333  40.7941102  64.4725565 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-NIG:APOE3      65.200000000  52.5433381  77.8566619 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-NIG:APOE3          -2.141666667 -13.9808898   9.6975565 1.0000000
Control:C57-NIG:APOE3        -9.066666667 -21.7233286   3.5899953 0.4950679
ATP:C57-NIG:APOE3            -4.833333333 -17.4899953   7.8233286 0.9979753
LPS:C57-NIG:APOE3            -5.966666667 -18.6233286   6.6899953 0.9741134
LPS+ATP:C57-NIG:APOE3        15.533333333   2.8766714  28.1899953 0.0037725
LPS+NIG:C57-NIG:APOE3        27.766666667  15.1100047  40.4233286 0.0000000
NIG:C57-NIG:APOE3            -5.566666667 -18.2233286   7.0899953 0.9879659
Control:NULL-NIG:APOE3       -6.991666667 -18.8308898   4.8475565 0.8176453
ATP:NULL-NIG:APOE3            2.100000000 -10.5566619  14.7566619 1.0000000
LPS:NULL-NIG:APOE3           -1.000000000 -13.6566619  11.6566619 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-NIG:APOE3       23.233333333  10.5766714  35.8899953 0.0000011
LPS+NIG:NULL-NIG:APOE3       61.433333333  48.7766714  74.0899953 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-NIG:APOE3           -7.000000000 -19.6566619   5.6566619 0.8874077
ATP:APOE4-Control:APOE4      13.500000000   1.6607769  25.3392231 0.0106969
LPS:APOE4-Control:APOE4      -1.066666667 -12.9058898  10.7725565 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:APOE4-Control:APOE4  57.800000000  46.8390092  68.7609908 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-Control:APOE4  70.366666667  58.5274435  82.2058898 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-Control:APOE4       3.025000000  -7.9359908  13.9859908 0.9999873
Control:C57-Control:APOE4    -3.900000000 -15.7392231   7.9392231 0.9997655
ATP:C57-Control:APOE4         0.333333333 -11.5058898  12.1725565 1.0000000
LPS:C57-Control:APOE4        -0.800000000 -12.6392231  11.0392231 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-Control:APOE4    20.700000000   8.8607769  32.5392231 0.0000036
LPS+NIG:C57-Control:APOE4    32.933333333  21.0941102  44.7725565 0.0000000
NIG:C57-Control:APOE4        -0.400000000 -12.2392231  11.4392231 1.0000000
Control:NULL-Control:APOE4   -1.825000000 -12.7859908   9.1359908 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-Control:APOE4        7.266666667  -4.5725565  19.1058898 0.7656942
LPS:NULL-Control:APOE4        4.166666667  -7.6725565  16.0058898 0.9993632
LPS+ATP:NULL-Control:APOE4   28.400000000  16.5607769  40.2392231 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-Control:APOE4   66.600000000  54.7607769  78.4392231 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-Control:APOE4       -1.833333333 -13.6725565  10.0058898 1.0000000
LPS:APOE4-ATP:APOE4         -14.566666667 -27.2233286  -1.9100047 0.0094466
LPS+ATP:APOE4-ATP:APOE4      44.300000000  32.4607769  56.1392231 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-ATP:APOE4      56.866666667  44.2100047  69.5233286 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-ATP:APOE4         -10.475000000 -22.3142231   1.3642231 0.1492186
Control:C57-ATP:APOE4       -17.400000000 -30.0566619  -4.7433381 0.0005799
ATP:C57-ATP:APOE4           -13.166666667 -25.8233286  -0.5100047 0.0327738
LPS:C57-ATP:APOE4           -14.300000000 -26.9566619  -1.6433381 0.0120744
LPS+ATP:C57-ATP:APOE4         7.200000000  -5.4566619  19.8566619 0.8602843
LPS+NIG:C57-ATP:APOE4        19.433333333   6.7766714  32.0899953 0.0000681
NIG:C57-ATP:APOE4           -13.900000000 -26.5566619  -1.2433381 0.0173249
Control:NULL-ATP:APOE4      -15.325000000 -27.1642231  -3.4857769 0.0016314
ATP:NULL-ATP:APOE4           -6.233333333 -18.8899953   6.4233286 0.9596597
LPS:NULL-ATP:APOE4           -9.333333333 -21.9899953   3.3233286 0.4395469
LPS+ATP:NULL-ATP:APOE4       14.900000000   2.2433381  27.5566619 0.0069165
LPS+NIG:NULL-ATP:APOE4       53.100000000  40.4433381  65.7566619 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-ATP:APOE4          -15.333333333 -27.9899953  -2.6766714 0.0045769
LPS+ATP:APOE4-LPS:APOE4      58.866666667  47.0274435  70.7058898 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-LPS:APOE4      71.433333333  58.7766714  84.0899953 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-LPS:APOE4           4.091666667  -7.7475565  15.9308898 0.9995134
Control:C57-LPS:APOE4        -2.833333333 -15.4899953   9.8233286 0.9999997
ATP:C57-LPS:APOE4             1.400000000 -11.2566619  14.0566619 1.0000000
LPS:C57-LPS:APOE4             0.266666667 -12.3899953  12.9233286 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS:APOE4        21.766666667   9.1100047  34.4233286 0.0000054
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS:APOE4        34.000000000  21.3433381  46.6566619 0.0000000
NIG:C57-LPS:APOE4             0.666666667 -11.9899953  13.3233286 1.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS:APOE4       -0.758333333 -12.5975565  11.0808898 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS:APOE4            8.333333333  -4.3233286  20.9899953 0.6523457
LPS:NULL-LPS:APOE4            5.233333333  -7.4233286  17.8899953 0.9942780
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS:APOE4       29.466666667  16.8100047  42.1233286 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS:APOE4       67.666666667  55.0100047  80.3233286 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS:APOE4           -0.766666667 -13.4233286  11.8899953 1.0000000
LPS+NIG:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE4  12.566666667   0.7274435  24.4058898 0.0260716
NIG:APOE4-LPS+ATP:APOE4     -54.775000000 -65.7359908 -43.8140092 0.0000000
Control:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE4   -61.700000000 -73.5392231 -49.8607769 0.0000000
ATP:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE4       -57.466666667 -69.3058898 -45.6274435 0.0000000
LPS:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE4       -58.600000000 -70.4392231 -46.7607769 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE4   -37.100000000 -48.9392231 -25.2607769 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE4   -24.866666667 -36.7058898 -13.0274435 0.0000000
NIG:C57-LPS+ATP:APOE4       -58.200000000 -70.0392231 -46.3607769 0.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE4  -59.625000000 -70.5859908 -48.6640092 0.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE4      -50.533333333 -62.3725565 -38.6941102 0.0000000
LPS:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE4      -53.633333333 -65.4725565 -41.7941102 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE4  -29.400000000 -41.2392231 -17.5607769 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE4    8.800000000  -3.0392231  20.6392231 0.4244968
NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:APOE4      -59.633333333 -71.4725565 -47.7941102 0.0000000
NIG:APOE4-LPS+NIG:APOE4     -67.341666667 -79.1808898 -55.5024435 0.0000000
Control:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE4   -74.266666667 -86.9233286 -61.6100047 0.0000000
ATP:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE4       -70.033333333 -82.6899953 -57.3766714 0.0000000
LPS:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE4       -71.166666667 -83.8233286 -58.5100047 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE4   -49.666666667 -62.3233286 -37.0100047 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE4   -37.433333333 -50.0899953 -24.7766714 0.0000000
NIG:C57-LPS+NIG:APOE4       -70.766666667 -83.4233286 -58.1100047 0.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE4  -72.191666667 -84.0308898 -60.3524435 0.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE4      -63.100000000 -75.7566619 -50.4433381 0.0000000
LPS:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE4      -66.200000000 -78.8566619 -53.5433381 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE4  -41.966666667 -54.6233286 -29.3100047 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE4   -3.766666667 -16.4233286   8.8899953 0.9999542
NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:APOE4      -72.200000000 -84.8566619 -59.5433381 0.0000000
Control:C57-NIG:APOE4        -6.925000000 -18.7642231   4.9142231 0.8292973
ATP:C57-NIG:APOE4            -2.691666667 -14.5308898   9.1475565 0.9999996
LPS:C57-NIG:APOE4            -3.825000000 -15.6642231   8.0142231 0.9998268
LPS+ATP:C57-NIG:APOE4        17.675000000   5.8357769  29.5142231 0.0001209
LPS+NIG:C57-NIG:APOE4        29.908333333  18.0691102  41.7475565 0.0000000
NIG:C57-NIG:APOE4            -3.425000000 -15.2642231   8.4142231 0.9999715
Control:NULL-NIG:APOE4       -4.850000000 -15.8109908   6.1109908 0.9871006
ATP:NULL-NIG:APOE4            4.241666667  -7.5975565  16.0808898 0.9991740
LPS:NULL-NIG:APOE4            1.141666667 -10.6975565  12.9808898 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-NIG:APOE4       25.375000000  13.5357769  37.2142231 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-NIG:APOE4       63.575000000  51.7357769  75.4142231 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-NIG:APOE4           -4.858333333 -16.6975565   6.9808898 0.9947978
ATP:C57-Control:C57           4.233333333  -8.4233286  16.8899953 0.9997034
LPS:C57-Control:C57           3.100000000  -9.5566619  15.7566619 0.9999985
LPS+ATP:C57-Control:C57      24.600000000  11.9433381  37.2566619 0.0000002
LPS+NIG:C57-Control:C57      36.833333333  24.1766714  49.4899953 0.0000000
NIG:C57-Control:C57           3.500000000  -9.1566619  16.1566619 0.9999868
Control:NULL-Control:C57      2.075000000  -9.7642231  13.9142231 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-Control:C57         11.166666667  -1.4899953  23.8233286 0.1524665
LPS:NULL-Control:C57          8.066666667  -4.5899953  20.7233286 0.7075894
LPS+ATP:NULL-Control:C57     32.300000000  19.6433381  44.9566619 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-Control:C57     70.500000000  57.8433381  83.1566619 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-Control:C57          2.066666667 -10.5899953  14.7233286 1.0000000
LPS:C57-ATP:C57              -1.133333333 -13.7899953  11.5233286 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-ATP:C57          20.366666667   7.7100047  33.0233286 0.0000249
LPS+NIG:C57-ATP:C57          32.600000000  19.9433381  45.2566619 0.0000000
NIG:C57-ATP:C57              -0.733333333 -13.3899953  11.9233286 1.0000000
Control:NULL-ATP:C57         -2.158333333 -13.9975565   9.6808898 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-ATP:C57              6.933333333  -5.7233286  19.5899953 0.8956791
LPS:NULL-ATP:C57              3.833333333  -8.8233286  16.4899953 0.9999388
LPS+ATP:NULL-ATP:C57         28.066666667  15.4100047  40.7233286 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-ATP:C57         66.266666667  53.6100047  78.9233286 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-ATP:C57             -2.166666667 -14.8233286  10.4899953 1.0000000
LPS+ATP:C57-LPS:C57          21.500000000   8.8433381  34.1566619 0.0000072
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS:C57          33.733333333  21.0766714  46.3899953 0.0000000
NIG:C57-LPS:C57               0.400000000 -12.2566619  13.0566619 1.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS:C57         -1.025000000 -12.8642231  10.8142231 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS:C57              8.066666667  -4.5899953  20.7233286 0.7075894
LPS:NULL-LPS:C57              4.966666667  -7.6899953  17.6233286 0.9970817
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS:C57         29.200000000  16.5433381  41.8566619 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS:C57         67.400000000  54.7433381  80.0566619 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS:C57             -1.033333333 -13.6899953  11.6233286 1.0000000
LPS+NIG:C57-LPS+ATP:C57      12.233333333  -0.4233286  24.8899953 0.0699641
NIG:C57-LPS+ATP:C57         -21.100000000 -33.7566619  -8.4433381 0.0000112
Control:NULL-LPS+ATP:C57    -22.525000000 -34.3642231 -10.6857769 0.0000004
ATP:NULL-LPS+ATP:C57        -13.433333333 -26.0899953  -0.7766714 0.0260941
LPS:NULL-LPS+ATP:C57        -16.533333333 -29.1899953  -3.8766714 0.0014030
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS+ATP:C57      7.700000000  -4.9566619  20.3566619 0.7783031
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:C57     45.900000000  33.2433381  58.5566619 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:C57        -22.533333333 -35.1899953  -9.8766714 0.0000023
NIG:C57-LPS+NIG:C57         -33.333333333 -45.9899953 -20.6766714 0.0000000
Control:NULL-LPS+NIG:C57    -34.758333333 -46.5975565 -22.9191102 0.0000000
ATP:NULL-LPS+NIG:C57        -25.666666667 -38.3233286 -13.0100047 0.0000001
LPS:NULL-LPS+NIG:C57        -28.766666667 -41.4233286 -16.1100047 0.0000000
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS+NIG:C57     -4.533333333 -17.1899953   8.1233286 0.9991772
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:C57     33.666666667  21.0100047  46.3233286 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:C57        -34.766666667 -47.4233286 -22.1100047 0.0000000
Control:NULL-NIG:C57         -1.425000000 -13.2642231  10.4142231 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-NIG:C57              7.666666667  -4.9899953  20.3233286 0.7843389
LPS:NULL-NIG:C57              4.566666667  -8.0899953  17.2233286 0.9990854
LPS+ATP:NULL-NIG:C57         28.800000000  16.1433381  41.4566619 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-NIG:C57         67.000000000  54.3433381  79.6566619 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-NIG:C57             -1.433333333 -14.0899953  11.2233286 1.0000000
ATP:NULL-Control:NULL         9.091666667  -2.7475565  20.9308898 0.3638261
LPS:NULL-Control:NULL         5.991666667  -5.8475565  17.8308898 0.9476465
LPS+ATP:NULL-Control:NULL    30.225000000  18.3857769  42.0642231 0.0000000
LPS+NIG:NULL-Control:NULL    68.425000000  56.5857769  80.2642231 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-Control:NULL        -0.008333333 -11.8475565  11.8308898 1.0000000
LPS:NULL-ATP:NULL            -3.100000000 -15.7566619   9.5566619 0.9999985
LPS+ATP:NULL-ATP:NULL        21.133333333   8.4766714  33.7899953 0.0000108
LPS+NIG:NULL-ATP:NULL        59.333333333  46.6766714  71.9899953 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-ATP:NULL            -9.100000000 -21.7566619   3.5566619 0.4880210
LPS+ATP:NULL-LPS:NULL        24.233333333  11.5766714  36.8899953 0.0000004
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS:NULL        62.433333333  49.7766714  75.0899953 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS:NULL            -6.000000000 -18.6566619   6.6566619 0.9725615
LPS+NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:NULL    38.200000000  25.5433381  50.8566619 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS+ATP:NULL       -30.233333333 -42.8899953 -17.5766714 0.0000000
NIG:NULL-LPS+NIG:NULL       -68.433333333 -81.0899953 -55.7766714 0.0000000