Pilot 1 Report
Study details
Measures – Before solutions presented
Issue importance and urgency (2 questions)
- In your opinion, how [important/urgent] is it to solve [issue]
Moral Conviction (3 questions)
Thinking about [issue], to what extent are your views…
based on fundamental questions of right and wrong?
connected to your core moral beliefs and convictions?
Based on moral principles
Nonmoral solution preference (3 questions)
People should try to solve [issue]
It would be wrong to allow [issue] to remain unsolved
Society should focus on reducing the damage caused by [issue]
Moral solution preference (3 questions)
People have a moral responsibility to solve [issue]
Allowing [issue] to remain unsolved is morally wrong
Society should focus on reducing the harm caused by [issue]
Solutions
| Social Problem | Pragmatic Solution | Idealistic Solution |
| Climate change | Carbon Tariffs |
Ban cars |
| Gun violence | Red flag laws |
Ban all assault-style weapons |
| Discriminatory policing | Improve policies and training |
Abolish police |
| Illegal immigration | Prosecute individuals who employ illegal immigrants |
Mass deportations |
| Election fraud | Increase accountability and punishment for those engaging in fraud |
Remove all electronic devices from the voting process (i.e., hand-counted ballots) |
| The culture war | Ban access to gender affirming care for minors |
Focus on religion |
Measures – after solutions presented
Solution effectiveness
- How effective do you think [Solution] would be at solving [issue]? A score of 0 means that this solution would do nothing to solve [issue] and a score of 100 means this solution would completely solve [issue].
Solution likelihood
- How likely is it that [Solution] will be adopted to address [issue] in the next 10 years? A score of 0 means that you think it’s impossible that this solution is adopted and a score of 100 means you think it is certain that this solution will be adopted in the next 10 years
Solution influence
How likely would you be to…
suggest this solution to friends or family members who had never heard of it before?
sign a petition in support of this solution?
attend a march or rally in support of this solution?
donate to an organization working on implementing this solution?
Final measures
Pragmatic preferences
It is better to pursue solutions that have a high chance of success, even if they only make incremental progress.
I prefer solutions to social problems that are achievable, even if they are small.
When thinking about social problems, I am mindful of barriers that limit what can realistically be achieved.
Idealist preferences
It is better to support solutions that will make the largest social change, regardless of how likely they are to succeed.
I support solutions that have the greatest chance of making sure a social problem is solved once and for all.
When considering how to solve social problems, I prefer solutions that lead to an ideal outcome, rather than incremental progress.
Descriptive stats
Moral conviction distributions across issues
Moral and nonmoral solution preferences
| Category | Moral solution prefs | Nonmoral solution prefs | Moral conviction |
|---|---|---|---|
| Climate change | 81.82178 | 87.58416 | 72.81188 |
| Gun violence | 91.33663 | 93.27393 | 87.92739 |
| Discriminatory policing | 86.51155 | 86.64026 | 88.01650 |
| Illegal immigration | 81.19780 | 86.64103 | 79.28571 |
| Election fraud | 82.21245 | 83.51282 | 86.81685 |
| The culture war | 60.99267 | 62.90476 | 69.22711 |
Solution perceptions table
| Solution | Mean Likelihood | Mean Effectiveness | Effectiveness - Likelihood | Share with friends/family | Sign petition | Attend march/rally | Donate to org |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| climate_p | 52.515464 | 53.52577 | 1.0103093 | 53.43299 | 54.71134 | 31.89691 | 40.19588 |
| climate_i | 6.061856 | 39.44330 | 33.3814433 | 11.59794 | 13.60825 | 10.46392 | 11.43299 |
| guns_p | 57.113402 | 57.53608 | 0.4226804 | 64.70103 | 69.97938 | 42.87629 | 46.96907 |
| guns_i | 43.422680 | 66.96907 | 23.5463918 | 68.17526 | 74.76289 | 49.85567 | 56.15464 |
| police_p | 67.432990 | 62.95876 | -4.4742268 | 61.96907 | 64.11340 | 37.64948 | 43.92784 |
| police_i | 13.154639 | 35.87629 | 22.7216495 | 21.64948 | 23.64948 | 21.84536 | 20.01031 |
| immigration_p | 42.538461 | 55.84615 | 13.3076923 | 49.27473 | 47.51648 | 21.52747 | 26.49451 |
| immigration_i | 53.450550 | 71.60440 | 18.1538462 | 62.01099 | 59.28571 | 29.84615 | 40.83516 |
| elections_p | 45.824176 | 64.14286 | 18.3186813 | 57.75824 | 55.60440 | 23.84615 | 34.04396 |
| elections_i | 42.164835 | 52.32967 | 10.1648352 | 45.78022 | 44.83516 | 20.81319 | 27.91209 |
| culture_war_p | 52.945055 | 56.98901 | 4.0439560 | 55.37363 | 55.64835 | 24.27473 | 32.91209 |
| culture_war_i | 25.714286 | 41.48352 | 15.7692308 | 47.92308 | 40.56044 | 27.30769 | 28.75824 |
For most issues, people tend to view idealistic solutions as more effective than they are likely. They also tend to view idealistic solutions as less effective for some issues.
Hypotheses to test
Idealistic solutions will be supported more by people who have higher moral conviction about solving a problem
Pragmatic solutions will be supported more by people who have lower moral conviction about solving a problem
Idealistic solutions will be perceived as more likely to solve a problem, but less likely to be implemented and vice versa for pragmatic solutions
Does issue importance/urgency moderate relationship between moral conviction and solution support?
Check for correlation between pragmatic and idealistic scale from Ashwini
See if this predicts support for more idealistic/pragmatic solutions
Potential mediator
Hypothesis 1 & 2
Does higher moral conviction predict increased support for idealistic solutions?
Effect of moral conviction on willingness to share
======================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_1 climateA_influence_1 gunsA_influence_1 gunsB_influence_1 policeA_influence_1 policeB_influence_1 immA_influence_1 immB_influence_1 electA_influence_1 electB_influence_1 wokeA_influence_1 wokeB_influence_1
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.176 0.033
(0.112) (0.078)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.187 0.702***
(0.168) (0.174)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.456** 0.121
(0.190) (0.181)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.349** 0.526***
(0.159) (0.169)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.733*** 0.184
(0.205) (0.254)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.503*** 0.266*
(0.128) (0.147)
Constant 40.593*** 9.151 48.233*** 6.403 21.692 10.980 21.569 20.310 -5.880 29.776 20.547** 29.532***
(8.744) (6.115) (15.103) (15.633) (17.024) (16.282) (13.115) (13.948) (18.092) (22.394) (9.544) (10.956)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.025 0.002 0.013 0.146 0.057 0.005 0.051 0.098 0.125 0.006 0.148 0.035
Adjusted R2 0.015 -0.009 0.002 0.137 0.047 -0.006 0.041 0.088 0.116 -0.005 0.138 0.025
Residual Std. Error 30.133 (df = 95) 21.074 (df = 95) 29.066 (df = 95) 30.085 (df = 95) 29.521 (df = 95) 28.234 (df = 95) 33.951 (df = 89) 36.107 (df = 89) 29.841 (df = 89) 36.937 (df = 89) 33.903 (df = 89) 38.922 (df = 89)
F Statistic 2.457 (df = 1; 95) 0.182 (df = 1; 95) 1.236 (df = 1; 95) 16.234*** (df = 1; 95) 5.776** (df = 1; 95) 0.443 (df = 1; 95) 4.817** (df = 1; 89) 9.649*** (df = 1; 89) 12.753*** (df = 1; 89) 0.526 (df = 1; 89) 15.461*** (df = 1; 89) 3.271* (df = 1; 89)
======================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Effect of moral conviction on willingness to sign petition
====================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_2 climateA_influence_2 gunsA_influence_2 gunsB_influence_2 policeA_influence_2 policeB_influence_2 immA_influence_2 immB_influence_2 electA_influence_2 electB_influence_2 wokeA_influence_2 wokeB_influence_2
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.216* 0.094
(0.118) (0.099)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.156 0.682***
(0.179) (0.176)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.473** 0.103
(0.214) (0.205)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.293* 0.416**
(0.174) (0.183)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.482** 0.495*
(0.242) (0.257)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.487*** 0.334**
(0.136) (0.147)
Constant 38.917*** 6.707 56.252*** 14.807 22.270 14.528 24.257* 26.279* 13.786 1.853 21.904** 17.439
(9.175) (7.754) (16.034) (15.747) (19.199) (18.428) (14.318) (15.105) (21.339) (22.671) (10.131) (10.939)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.034 0.009 0.008 0.137 0.049 0.003 0.031 0.055 0.043 0.040 0.126 0.055
Adjusted R2 0.024 -0.001 -0.002 0.128 0.039 -0.008 0.020 0.044 0.032 0.029 0.117 0.044
Residual Std. Error 31.619 (df = 95) 26.721 (df = 95) 30.858 (df = 95) 30.305 (df = 95) 33.292 (df = 95) 31.955 (df = 95) 37.064 (df = 89) 39.103 (df = 89) 35.195 (df = 89) 37.392 (df = 89) 35.989 (df = 89) 38.861 (df = 89)
F Statistic 3.376* (df = 1; 95) 0.903 (df = 1; 95) 0.762 (df = 1; 95) 15.072*** (df = 1; 95) 4.902** (df = 1; 95) 0.253 (df = 1; 95) 2.849* (df = 1; 89) 5.154** (df = 1; 89) 3.959** (df = 1; 89) 3.705* (df = 1; 89) 12.881*** (df = 1; 89) 5.187** (df = 1; 89)
====================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Effect of moral conviction on willingness to attend march/rally
=======================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_3 climateA_influence_3 gunsA_influence_3 gunsB_influence_3 policeA_influence_3 policeB_influence_3 immA_influence_3 immB_influence_3 electA_influence_3 electB_influence_3 wokeA_influence_3 wokeB_influence_3
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.092 0.036
(0.113) (0.079)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.121 0.508**
(0.181) (0.202)
police_mor_conv_comp -0.185 -0.250
(0.205) (0.190)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.116 0.189
(0.144) (0.168)
elections_mor_conv_comp -0.176 -0.387*
(0.193) (0.207)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.197* 0.108
(0.115) (0.135)
Constant 25.194*** 7.859 32.243** 5.147 53.966*** 43.951** 12.301 14.825 39.086** 54.382*** 10.662 19.851*
(8.807) (6.145) (16.234) (18.115) (18.446) (17.015) (11.861) (13.824) (17.010) (18.204) (8.583) (10.092)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.007 0.002 0.005 0.062 0.008 0.018 0.007 0.014 0.009 0.038 0.032 0.007
Adjusted R2 -0.004 -0.008 -0.006 0.053 -0.002 0.008 -0.004 0.003 -0.002 0.027 0.021 -0.004
Residual Std. Error 30.349 (df = 95) 21.175 (df = 95) 31.242 (df = 95) 34.862 (df = 95) 31.987 (df = 95) 29.505 (df = 95) 30.705 (df = 89) 35.786 (df = 89) 28.055 (df = 89) 30.025 (df = 89) 30.489 (df = 89) 35.850 (df = 89)
F Statistic 0.660 (df = 1; 95) 0.205 (df = 1; 95) 0.446 (df = 1; 95) 6.333** (df = 1; 95) 0.807 (df = 1; 95) 1.742 (df = 1; 95) 0.653 (df = 1; 89) 1.275 (df = 1; 89) 0.827 (df = 1; 89) 3.505* (df = 1; 89) 2.921* (df = 1; 89) 0.634 (df = 1; 89)
=======================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Effect of moral conviction on willingness to donate
=======================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_4 climateA_influence_4 gunsA_influence_4 gunsB_influence_4 policeA_influence_4 policeB_influence_4 immA_influence_4 immB_influence_4 electA_influence_4 electB_influence_4 wokeA_influence_4 wokeB_influence_4
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.198* -0.007
(0.118) (0.082)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.258 0.489**
(0.183) (0.201)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.241 -0.262
(0.218) (0.182)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.192 0.220
(0.150) (0.186)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.045 -0.224
(0.224) (0.234)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.281** 0.146
(0.128) (0.135)
Constant 25.698*** 11.909* 24.293 13.146 22.621 43.143*** 11.280 23.390 30.127 47.326** 13.463 18.663*
(9.217) (6.429) (16.413) (18.058) (19.538) (16.335) (12.347) (15.342) (19.767) (20.618) (9.546) (10.099)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.029 0.0001 0.020 0.058 0.013 0.021 0.018 0.015 0.0005 0.010 0.051 0.013
Adjusted R2 0.019 -0.010 0.010 0.049 0.002 0.011 0.007 0.004 -0.011 -0.001 0.041 0.002
Residual Std. Error 31.762 (df = 95) 22.153 (df = 95) 31.587 (df = 95) 34.753 (df = 95) 33.880 (df = 95) 28.326 (df = 95) 31.962 (df = 89) 39.717 (df = 89) 32.604 (df = 89) 34.007 (df = 89) 33.910 (df = 89) 35.875 (df = 89)
F Statistic 2.819* (df = 1; 95) 0.006 (df = 1; 95) 1.985 (df = 1; 95) 5.898** (df = 1; 95) 1.227 (df = 1; 95) 2.070 (df = 1; 95) 1.639 (df = 1; 89) 1.396 (df = 1; 89) 0.040 (df = 1; 89) 0.914 (df = 1; 89) 4.820** (df = 1; 89) 1.160 (df = 1; 89)
=======================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Hypothesis 3
I chose bad issues for this and only find the expected pattern for gun violence and illegal immigration
Hypothesis 4
Does issue importance/urgency moderate relationship between moral conviction and solution support?
Moderation test on willingness to share
====================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_1 climateA_influence_1 gunsA_influence_1 gunsB_influence_1 policeA_influence_1 policeB_influence_1 immA_influence_1 immB_influence_1 electA_influence_1 electB_influence_1 wokeA_influence_1 wokeB_influence_1
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.371 0.181
(0.555) (0.410)
clim_imp_urg 0.875*** 0.151
(0.275) (0.203)
clim_imp_urg -0.005 -0.002
(0.006) (0.004)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.568 -0.560
(1.565) (1.549)
guns_imp_urg 0.386 0.340
(1.186) (1.174)
guns_imp_urg -0.004 0.010
(0.016) (0.016)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.889 0.011
(0.555) (0.533)
police_imp_urg 0.727 0.181
(0.617) (0.593)
police_imp_urg -0.008 -0.0002
(0.007) (0.007)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.324 0.029
(0.766) (0.753)
imm_imp_urg 0.508 0.978
(0.712) (0.700)
imm_imp_urg -0.002 0.0004
(0.009) (0.009)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.147 -1.930**
(0.654) (0.791)
elect_imp_urg 0.401 -1.013
(0.661) (0.800)
elect_imp_urg 0.002 0.021**
(0.008) (0.010)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.037 -0.004
(0.229) (0.270)
woke_imp_urg -0.051 -0.550
(0.332) (0.392)
woke_imp_urg 0.005 0.007
(0.004) (0.005)
Constant -19.104 -1.953 14.638 1.818 -20.685 6.700 -8.149 -29.409 1.083 142.334** 30.391** 48.792***
(21.879) (16.171) (109.078) (107.956) (41.407) (39.789) (55.208) (54.234) (47.582) (57.585) (14.262) (16.834)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.132 0.008 0.014 0.220 0.071 0.010 0.077 0.251 0.198 0.128 0.215 0.060
Adjusted R2 0.104 -0.024 -0.018 0.195 0.041 -0.022 0.045 0.225 0.170 0.098 0.188 0.028
Residual Std. Error 28.733 (df = 93) 21.236 (df = 93) 29.356 (df = 93) 29.054 (df = 93) 29.616 (df = 93) 28.459 (df = 93) 33.872 (df = 87) 33.274 (df = 87) 28.907 (df = 87) 34.984 (df = 87) 32.923 (df = 87) 38.859 (df = 87)
F Statistic 4.729*** (df = 3; 93) 0.246 (df = 3; 93) 0.447 (df = 3; 93) 8.756*** (df = 3; 93) 2.375* (df = 3; 93) 0.312 (df = 3; 93) 2.418* (df = 3; 87) 9.720*** (df = 3; 87) 7.144*** (df = 3; 87) 4.266*** (df = 3; 87) 7.926*** (df = 3; 87) 1.856 (df = 3; 87)
====================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Moderation test on willingness to sign petition
==================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_2 climateA_influence_2 gunsA_influence_2 gunsB_influence_2 policeA_influence_2 policeB_influence_2 immA_influence_2 immB_influence_2 electA_influence_2 electB_influence_2 wokeA_influence_2 wokeB_influence_2
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.144 0.172
(0.597) (0.522)
clim_imp_urg 0.659** 0.069
(0.295) (0.258)
clim_imp_urg -0.002 -0.001
(0.006) (0.005)
guns_mor_conv_comp 1.675 0.384
(1.641) (1.499)
guns_imp_urg 1.669 1.528
(1.243) (1.136)
guns_imp_urg -0.018 -0.002
(0.017) (0.016)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.976 -0.037
(0.625) (0.603)
police_imp_urg 0.862 0.211
(0.696) (0.671)
police_imp_urg -0.009 -0.0002
(0.008) (0.008)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.764 0.291
(0.831) (0.842)
imm_imp_urg 1.067 1.150
(0.772) (0.783)
imm_imp_urg -0.008 -0.003
(0.010) (0.010)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.989 -0.645
(0.793) (0.823)
elect_imp_urg 1.102 -0.055
(0.802) (0.833)
elect_imp_urg -0.010 0.008
(0.010) (0.010)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.093 0.034
(0.243) (0.270)
woke_imp_urg 0.244 -0.110
(0.352) (0.392)
woke_imp_urg 0.002 0.004
(0.004) (0.005)
Constant -4.519 1.562 -87.103 -90.024 -27.654 9.920 -46.952 -39.867 -43.730 45.071 22.735 25.788
(23.530) (20.557) (114.329) (104.458) (46.659) (45.016) (59.852) (60.657) (57.691) (59.920) (15.138) (16.840)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.097 0.010 0.034 0.273 0.065 0.009 0.070 0.163 0.072 0.111 0.195 0.076
Adjusted R2 0.068 -0.022 0.003 0.249 0.034 -0.023 0.038 0.134 0.040 0.080 0.167 0.044
Residual Std. Error 30.901 (df = 93) 26.996 (df = 93) 30.769 (df = 93) 28.113 (df = 93) 33.373 (df = 93) 32.198 (df = 93) 36.721 (df = 87) 37.215 (df = 87) 35.049 (df = 87) 36.403 (df = 87) 34.945 (df = 87) 38.874 (df = 87)
F Statistic 3.334** (df = 3; 93) 0.319 (df = 3; 93) 1.105 (df = 3; 93) 11.637*** (df = 3; 93) 2.139 (df = 3; 93) 0.273 (df = 3; 93) 2.191* (df = 3; 87) 5.649*** (df = 3; 87) 2.246* (df = 3; 87) 3.604** (df = 3; 87) 7.018*** (df = 3; 87) 2.375* (df = 3; 87)
==================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Moderation test on willingness to attend march/rally
====================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_3 climateA_influence_3 gunsA_influence_3 gunsB_influence_3 policeA_influence_3 policeB_influence_3 immA_influence_3 immB_influence_3 electA_influence_3 electB_influence_3 wokeA_influence_3 wokeB_influence_3
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.725 0.279
(0.581) (0.412)
clim_imp_urg 0.541* 0.150
(0.288) (0.204)
clim_imp_urg -0.008 -0.003
(0.006) (0.004)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.880 0.215
(1.682) (1.868)
guns_imp_urg 0.491 0.338
(1.274) (1.415)
guns_imp_urg -0.008 0.002
(0.018) (0.020)
police_mor_conv_comp -0.743 -1.370**
(0.601) (0.545)
police_imp_urg -0.162 -0.828
(0.669) (0.606)
police_imp_urg 0.005 0.013*
(0.008) (0.007)
immigration_mor_conv_comp -0.206 -0.621
(0.702) (0.812)
imm_imp_urg -0.295 -0.461
(0.652) (0.755)
imm_imp_urg 0.004 0.009
(0.008) (0.010)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.128 -1.411**
(0.631) (0.676)
elect_imp_urg 0.830 -0.739
(0.638) (0.684)
elect_imp_urg -0.007 0.012
(0.008) (0.008)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.155 -0.099
(0.214) (0.250)
woke_imp_urg 0.116 -0.409
(0.310) (0.362)
woke_imp_urg -0.0004 0.005
(0.004) (0.004)
Constant -15.225 -3.840 -14.809 -14.461 76.731* 110.330*** 35.211 55.753 -1.425 117.720** 8.414 34.268**
(22.913) (16.241) (117.190) (130.137) (44.851) (40.637) (50.552) (58.526) (45.936) (49.206) (13.330) (15.574)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.044 0.009 0.007 0.074 0.024 0.067 0.010 0.030 0.042 0.068 0.036 0.024
Adjusted R2 0.013 -0.023 -0.025 0.044 -0.008 0.037 -0.024 -0.004 0.009 0.036 0.003 -0.010
Residual Std. Error 30.090 (df = 93) 21.328 (df = 93) 31.539 (df = 93) 35.024 (df = 93) 32.080 (df = 93) 29.066 (df = 93) 31.015 (df = 87) 35.908 (df = 87) 27.908 (df = 87) 29.894 (df = 87) 30.771 (df = 87) 35.950 (df = 87)
F Statistic 1.437 (df = 3; 93) 0.281 (df = 3; 93) 0.218 (df = 3; 93) 2.467* (df = 3; 93) 0.750 (df = 3; 93) 2.228* (df = 3; 93) 0.289 (df = 3; 87) 0.887 (df = 3; 87) 1.261 (df = 3; 87) 2.106 (df = 3; 87) 1.080 (df = 3; 87) 0.712 (df = 3; 87)
====================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Moderation test on willingness to donate
========================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climateB_influence_4 climateA_influence_4 gunsA_influence_4 gunsB_influence_4 policeA_influence_4 policeB_influence_4 immA_influence_4 immB_influence_4 electA_influence_4 electB_influence_4 wokeA_influence_4 wokeB_influence_4
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.590 0.161
(0.608) (0.431)
clim_imp_urg 0.590* 0.199
(0.301) (0.213)
clim_imp_urg -0.006 -0.002
(0.006) (0.004)
guns_mor_conv_comp -0.157 -1.395
(1.686) (1.828)
guns_imp_urg 0.334 -0.375
(1.277) (1.385)
guns_imp_urg 0.003 0.017
(0.018) (0.019)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.186 -1.088**
(0.634) (0.529)
police_imp_urg 0.653 -0.700
(0.706) (0.588)
police_imp_urg -0.003 0.010
(0.008) (0.007)
immigration_mor_conv_comp -0.086 -0.223
(0.731) (0.890)
imm_imp_urg -0.235 0.367
(0.679) (0.827)
imm_imp_urg 0.003 0.002
(0.009) (0.011)
elections_mor_conv_comp -0.348 -1.137
(0.723) (0.745)
elect_imp_urg 0.528 0.171
(0.732) (0.754)
elect_imp_urg -0.001 0.005
(0.009) (0.009)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.029 -0.066
(0.235) (0.250)
woke_imp_urg 0.065 -0.451
(0.341) (0.362)
woke_imp_urg 0.002 0.006
(0.004) (0.004)
Constant -16.310 -2.491 6.879 69.527 -2.648 95.783** 29.903 9.016 25.576 74.290 16.357 34.285**
(23.948) (16.970) (117.459) (127.377) (47.351) (39.442) (52.644) (64.114) (52.657) (54.245) (14.646) (15.563)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.068 0.009 0.040 0.103 0.034 0.050 0.020 0.056 0.059 0.091 0.078 0.032
Adjusted R2 0.038 -0.023 0.009 0.074 0.003 0.019 -0.014 0.023 0.027 0.060 0.046 -0.001
Residual Std. Error 31.449 (df = 93) 22.286 (df = 93) 31.612 (df = 93) 34.281 (df = 93) 33.868 (df = 93) 28.211 (df = 93) 32.299 (df = 87) 39.336 (df = 87) 31.991 (df = 87) 32.955 (df = 87) 33.808 (df = 87) 35.925 (df = 87)
F Statistic 2.258* (df = 3; 93) 0.292 (df = 3; 93) 1.278 (df = 3; 93) 3.565** (df = 3; 93) 1.099 (df = 3; 93) 1.619 (df = 3; 93) 0.586 (df = 3; 87) 1.718 (df = 3; 87) 1.828 (df = 3; 87) 2.915** (df = 3; 87) 2.462* (df = 3; 87) 0.969 (df = 3; 87)
========================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Moderation test on all influence items
=========================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
climP_influence_comp climI_influence_comp gunsP_influence_comp gunsI_influence_comp policeP_influence_comp policeI_influence_comp immP_influence_comp immI_influence_comp electP_influence_comp electI_influence_comp wokeP_influence_comp wokeI_influence_comp
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (12)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp 0.198 0.457
(0.425) (0.498)
clim_imp_urg 0.142 0.666***
(0.210) (0.246)
clim_mor_conv_comp:clim_imp_urg -0.002 -0.005
(0.004) (0.005)
guns_mor_conv_comp 0.742 -0.339
(1.302) (1.368)
guns_imp_urg 0.720 0.457
(0.986) (1.037)
guns_mor_conv_comp:guns_imp_urg -0.007 0.007
(0.014) (0.014)
police_mor_conv_comp 0.327 -0.621
(0.491) (0.520)
police_imp_urg 0.520 -0.284
(0.547) (0.579)
police_mor_conv_comp:police_imp_urg -0.004 0.006
(0.006) (0.007)
immigration_mor_conv_comp 0.199 -0.131
(0.649) (0.692)
imm_imp_urg 0.261 0.509
(0.603) (0.643)
immigration_mor_conv_comp:imm_imp_urg -0.001 0.002
(0.008) (0.008)
elections_mor_conv_comp 0.229 -1.281**
(0.550) (0.644)
elect_imp_urg 0.715 -0.409
(0.556) (0.651)
elections_mor_conv_comp:elect_imp_urg -0.004 0.012
(0.007) (0.008)
woke_mor_conv_comp 0.079 -0.034
(0.190) (0.230)
woke_imp_urg 0.094 -0.380
(0.275) (0.333)
woke_mor_conv_comp:woke_imp_urg 0.002 0.005
(0.003) (0.004)
Constant -1.680 -13.789 -20.099 -8.285 6.436 55.683 2.503 -1.127 -4.624 94.854** 19.474 35.783**
(16.751) (19.611) (90.696) (95.334) (36.662) (38.840) (46.762) (49.851) (40.046) (46.856) (11.828) (14.296)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 97 97 97 97 97 97 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.007 0.105 0.027 0.213 0.037 0.017 0.046 0.144 0.095 0.096 0.172 0.053
Adjusted R2 -0.025 0.076 -0.004 0.187 0.006 -0.014 0.013 0.114 0.063 0.065 0.143 0.021
Residual Std. Error 21.998 (df = 93) 25.754 (df = 93) 24.409 (df = 93) 25.657 (df = 93) 26.222 (df = 93) 27.781 (df = 93) 28.690 (df = 87) 30.586 (df = 87) 24.329 (df = 87) 28.466 (df = 87) 27.305 (df = 87) 33.001 (df = 87)
F Statistic 0.233 (df = 3; 93) 3.643** (df = 3; 93) 0.869 (df = 3; 93) 8.383*** (df = 3; 93) 1.199 (df = 3; 93) 0.547 (df = 3; 93) 1.388 (df = 3; 87) 4.865*** (df = 3; 87) 3.032** (df = 3; 87) 3.090** (df = 3; 87) 6.008*** (df = 3; 87) 1.637 (df = 3; 87)
=========================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.1; **p<0.05; ***p<0.01
Looking at the pragmatic and idealistic scales from Ashwini/Robb
Number of categories should be increased in order to count frequencies.
[1] "pragmatic pref alpha: 0.801756250509646"
Number of categories should be increased in order to count frequencies.
[1] "Idealist prefs alpha: 0.842727197171398"
[1] "Correlation between pragmatic and idealistic prefs: -0.15679082443418"
===================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
immA_influence_1 immB_influence_1 gunsA_influence_1 gunsB_influence_1
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
prag_prefs_comp 0.045 0.186 0.358* 0.522**
(0.240) (0.261) (0.158) (0.172)
idealist_prefs_comp 0.512** 0.425* 0.087 0.367*
(0.160) (0.179) (0.145) (0.157)
Constant 45.972* 20.113* 48.354* 37.802*** 38.398** 60.064*** 29.810* 48.551***
(17.984) (9.758) (19.561) (10.896) (11.942) (8.293) (13.027) (8.991)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 91 91 91 91 97 97 97 97
R2 0.0004 0.103 0.006 0.060 0.051 0.004 0.088 0.054
Adjusted R2 -0.011 0.093 -0.005 0.049 0.041 -0.007 0.079 0.044
Residual Std. Error 34.851 (df = 89) 33.014 (df = 89) 37.906 (df = 89) 36.862 (df = 89) 28.492 (df = 95) 29.199 (df = 95) 31.082 (df = 95) 31.657 (df = 95)
F Statistic 0.035 (df = 1; 89) 10.216** (df = 1; 89) 0.508 (df = 1; 89) 5.647* (df = 1; 89) 5.154* (df = 1; 95) 0.359 (df = 1; 95) 9.214** (df = 1; 95) 5.463* (df = 1; 95)
===================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.05; **p<0.01; ***p<0.001
================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Dependent variable:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
clim_mor_conv_comp guns_mor_conv_comp police_mor_conv_comp immigration_mor_conv_comp elections_mor_conv_comp woke_mor_conv_comp
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
prag_prefs_comp 0.233 0.376*** 0.305*** 0.041 0.135 0.147
(0.147) (0.087) (0.083) (0.156) (0.105) (0.193)
idealist_prefs_comp 0.073 0.018 -0.023 0.267* 0.126 0.218
(0.133) (0.085) (0.079) (0.106) (0.074) (0.134)
Constant 55.779*** 68.873*** 60.352*** 86.967*** 65.700*** 89.249*** 76.247*** 64.097*** 76.906*** 79.630*** 58.481*** 56.792***
(11.130) (7.698) (6.584) (4.909) (6.229) (4.543) (11.660) (6.456) (7.880) (4.482) (14.448) (8.182)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observations 101 101 101 101 101 101 91 91 91 91 91 91
R2 0.025 0.003 0.158 0.0004 0.121 0.001 0.001 0.066 0.018 0.032 0.006 0.029
Adjusted R2 0.015 -0.007 0.150 -0.010 0.112 -0.009 -0.010 0.056 0.007 0.021 -0.005 0.018
Residual Std. Error 27.017 (df = 99) 27.313 (df = 99) 15.983 (df = 99) 17.418 (df = 99) 15.121 (df = 99) 16.121 (df = 99) 22.595 (df = 89) 21.841 (df = 89) 15.270 (df = 89) 15.162 (df = 89) 27.998 (df = 89) 27.680 (df = 89)
F Statistic 2.487 (df = 1; 99) 0.299 (df = 1; 99) 18.626*** (df = 1; 99) 0.044 (df = 1; 99) 13.631*** (df = 1; 99) 0.084 (df = 1; 99) 0.071 (df = 1; 89) 6.332* (df = 1; 89) 1.650 (df = 1; 89) 2.942 (df = 1; 89) 0.577 (df = 1; 89) 2.643 (df = 1; 89)
================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================================
Note: *p<0.05; **p<0.01; ***p<0.001
Compositing all pragmatic/ideal solutions
Moral and nonmoral solution composites
Note: moral and nonmoral questions are issue specific but not solution specific
Multi-level model approach
Are there differences in support for pragmatic vs idealistic policies among pragmatists? Looks like no. Idealists support idealist and pragmatist policies roughly equally so no multilevel model for them.
[1] "Multilevel model with random intercepts"
Estimate Std. Error df t value
(Intercept) 44.54280290 7.33808614 300.4224 6.0700845
prag_prefs_comp -0.04074489 0.09723773 301.7403 -0.4190235
is_prag -10.75908683 6.98160547 940.1308 -1.5410620
prag_prefs_comp:is_prag 0.12949599 0.09269068 940.1308 1.3970767
Pr(>|t|)
(Intercept) 3.849413e-09
prag_prefs_comp 6.754971e-01
is_prag 1.236382e-01
prag_prefs_comp:is_prag 1.627202e-01
[1] "Multilevel model with random slopes"
Estimate Std. Error df t value Pr(>|t|)
(Intercept) 44.62851309 7.67468863 195.7761 5.815026 2.433410e-08
prag_prefs_comp -0.04174608 0.10168406 196.6445 -0.410547 6.818517e-01
is_prag -10.93836875 7.02532355 816.4674 -1.556991 1.198600e-01
prag_prefs_comp:is_prag 0.13159020 0.09326586 818.1776 1.410915 1.586498e-01