Author: Oanh Tran, Steffy Valenny, Ismail Khawaja, Joseph Meyer

Date: March 13, 2024

This analysis’s objective is to measure the extent, trends, and attributes of breaches, as a whole and categorized by industry, to provide cybersecurity stakeholders insights into the threats posed by breaches. Initially, the analysis begins with the discussion of general trends before looking at risk factors specific to six industries. The dataset utilized for this analysis is sourced from the Washington State Attorney General’s (AG) Office through data.wa.gov.

According to Washington State legislation, entities are obligated to inform the AG’s office in the event of a data breach impacting 500 or more residents of Washington state (Washington State Attorney General’s Office, 2024). This dataset provides details regarding the breach, affected individuals, and the compromised organization. For this analysis, a breach is defined as the unauthorized access and extraction of information from an organization’s secure system through one of three means: malicious cyberattacks, theft or IT errors, or unauthorized entry. As part of the analysis, we replaced missing values in the breach lifecycle with the median lifecycle for that year. Each entry in the dataset represents a distinct breach of an organization’s secure system.

Breaches Spiked in 2021, Driven by Malicious Cyberattacks, and Remain Elevated

Starting in 2016, data breaches affecting over 500 Washingtonians (reported breaches) remained under 100 incidents a year until 2021 when they spiked to almost 300 incidents. And the number of breaches remained elevated at over 150 incidents in 2022 and 2023. Alarmingly, while the data for 2024 is only available for January and February, there have already been over 140 incidents. Out of the three types of breaches, malicious cyberattacks make up most attacks. Although comprising a smaller portion of breaches compared to cyberattacks, the incidence of unauthorized access has doubled from 25 incidents in 2021 to 54 in 2023.

The Attorney General’s Office tracks six categories of cyberattacks: malware, phishing, ransomware, skimmers, other, and unclear/ unknown. “Other” represents classified but less common types of cyberattacks. According to a report published by Washington AG’s Office “Cyberattacks remained the chief type of attack, accounting for…61% of all data breaches” (Washington State Attorney General’s Office, 2023). Before 2021, the majority of these were malware or “unknown” cyberattacks while the number of ransomware attacks were negligible. In 2021 when breaches spiked due to cyberattacks, ransomware attacks rose from 7 in 2020 to 150 in 2021. The peak in 2021 cyberattacks (247 total) were also influenced by the series peaks in malware (47), phishing (23), and unknown (23) attacks. Since 2021, ransomware remains the most common cyberattack, though 2023 and early 2024 show a slight rise in “other” attacks.

As reported breaches remain elevated, organizations should consider increasing resources to manage the increasing risk of data breaches. And focusing efforts primarily on preventing the most common breach—malicious cyberattacks—while taking steps to decrease unauthorized access breaches.

The Number of Affected Washingtonians Followed the 2021 Spike in Breaches

Despite a decrease in 2019 and 2020, the number of Washingtonians affected by a data breach peaked in 2021. That year six million Washingtonians were affected by breach incidents (incidents affecting over 500 Washingtonians). The number of affected Washingtonians remained higher than before 2021 at above four million people per year. The increase in breaches informs our second recommendation. Organizations should develop communication plans to quickly inform affected people and government agencies if a breach occurs. The plan should clearly address who is responsible for communication with affected users and how they are going to quickly begin customer outreach (Chapple, 2024).

Good News: Median Breach Lifecycles, in Days, Decreased Below 25 Days After in 2022 and 2023

Median breach lifecycles—a measure of the days to detect and resolve a breach—represented one of the few positive trends. The median breach lifecycle decreased to below 25 days since 2022 from a peak of 227 days in 2017. While not shown, the median time to detect a breach—part of the total breach lifecycle—decreased at a similar rate to the total breach lifecycle. This makes it appear that faster breach detection led to decreasing median breach lifecycle times.

Business

Breaches of businesses peaked in 2021, similar to the cross-industry trend, then gradually decreased through 2023 (while staying above pre-2021 levels). However, the number of affected Washingtonians climbed steeply in 2022 suggesting the large number of breaches in 2021 affected fewer people per breach. While not shown in these charts, retail businesses reported the most breaches each year. Similar to the cross-industry trend mentioned above, malicious cyberattacks represented the majority of breaches and median reach lifecycle times declined from a 2017 peak of 300 days to a 2023 low of 21 days.

Education

Education organizations represented the second smallest industry category in our dataset. Except for a spike in 44 breaches in 2021, education historically has less than 5 breaches per year. Given the small sample size in most years, single breaches can easily skew years. For example, the 2019 Washington Attorney General’s Office Breach Report noted that a Yale University breach took 3,728 days to discover and resolve (Washington State Attorney General’s Office, 2019).  

Finance

The finance industry saw the most breaches in 2023, where breaches started rising significantly in 2021. Starting in 2021, most of the breaches were cyberattacks, but the number unauthorized accesses is growing as a portion of yearly attacks. This high portion of unauthorized data accesses in unique to the finance industry. Excluding a large breach affecting 3.26 million Washingtonians in 2018, the number of affected Washingtonians has stayed between 0.25 million and 0.75 million people affected per year.

Government

Government represented the smallest number of breaches in the dataset registering with no more than 11 breaches in 2021 and none some years. However, the small number of breaches affected a large number of Washingtonians such as breaches in 2016 and 2021 that affected over 1.5M Washingtonians. Excluding 2021, the three types of breaches are relatively evenly distributed each year unlike most industries where cyberattacks make up most breaches.  Breach lifecycle times also remain consistently low, except for the Medicaid data breach in 2016 which represented the longest median lifecycle time in our dataset at 769 days (Washington State Attorney General’s Office, 2016).

Health

In the years 2022 and 2023, data breaches of healthcare facilities peaked at 38 and 39 incidents due to a large increase in cyberattacks. Since 2022, over 1 million Washingtonians have been affected annually compared to less than 0.5 million before 2022. One long lifecycle breach in 2019, the 286 day LabCorp breach, skewed the lifecycle time upwards to create a peak in 2019 median lifecycle days (Washington State Attorney General’s Office, 2019).

Nonprofit

The nonprofit sector typically registers less than 5 breaches per year, except for a spike in 76 cases in 2021, all of which were cyberattacks, that affected almost 3 million Washingtonians.

Conclusion

Our analysis showed that the number of breaches spike in 2021, largely due to cyberattacks, and have remained at elevate levels ever since. Ransomware makes up a large share of the cyberattacks since the 2021 spike. And as breaches have increased, the number of affected Washingtonians have increased to over 4 million people annually while the median breach lifecycle (a measure of time to identify and resolve a breach) has decreased to below 25 days. While different industries all show slightly different frequencies of breaches, 2021 shows up as an elevated year for breaches that started period of more incidents in the majority of industries.

Simply put, breaches caused by cyberattacks are happening more frequently in almost all industries within just the last three year. As attacks increase, we recommend organizations in all sectors increase resources to improve cyber security preparedness to address the increase in cyberattacks. And as the number of Washingtonians affected increases, organizations should develop communication plans to alert affected people if a breach occurs.

Work Cited