Paper 2
Impact of Price Fluctuations of Critical Minerals on Economic Policy
Executive Summary:
The “Critical Minerals Market Review 2023” is a detailed look at the role crucial minerals play in technological innovation and economic growth. The paper focuses on renewable energy technology and examines price swings caused by growing demand, supply chain interruptions, and geopolitical concerns. Despite rising prices, technical breakthroughs and economies of scale help to reduce the cost of sustainable energy. The causes of variations, such as supply chain interruptions and geopolitical tensions, highlight the value of international cooperation and strategic strategies. The research examines the impact of price fluctuations on macroeconomic variables, demonstrating the close relationship between mineral pricing and national economic success. It investigates the impact of pricing fluctuations on government policy, highlighting the importance of adaptive strategies. Investment patterns show a balanced capital allocation between diversified mining companies and specialist renewable energy operators, indicating the changing dynamics of the nonferrous metal business.
Bottom Line & Takeaways:
Resilience among rising prices: Despite the upward trend in essential material prices, technical innovations and economies of scale have constantly decreased overall costs for clean energy production.
International cooperation is crucial: Addressing supply chain disruptions and geopolitical concerns involves joint efforts through bilateral contracts and global coordination between governments.
Changing investment dynamics: The change from debt to equity investment by specialized companies signals sector growth and increases investor confidence, demonstrating the nonferrous metal industry’s transforming landscape.
Introduction:
As the name suggests, “Critical minerals” which means really important sources. Critical materials are types of natural resources or elements that are crucial to making technologies like batteries, mobile phones, renewable energy, and other types of modern technology (Hayes & McCullough, 2018). These materials provide a great deal of support for the growth of an economy. The report “Critical Minerals Market Review 2023” suggests that critical materials help in scaling up future technological advancement and supply by different countries and companies. A comprehensive insight and forecast for these minerals used in producing “Clean Energy” is provided in the report. The key points that will be covered in this report are, first, the price fluctuation of critical minerals due to the demand for new technology, which also puts pressure on geopolitics and government policies to make the economy more stable. Most of which would be analyzed from the data provided on the IEA website. Secondly, it would shed light on the importance of transparency in reporting the statistics by the industry for tracking progress over time by the industry experts, economists, and Analysts. Finally, the Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) disclosures and the need for more detailed information in the sector of critical material will be discussed in detail.
Price Fluctuation Trends and the Causes:
In the past decade, the prices of critical minerals used to fall or at best be stable at a point, but not anymore. The prices of critical materials have been fluctuating for a few years now. There are various reasons for this increased fluctuation in the prices. The number one reason for this is the demand and the need to produce new clean energy technologies (Leader, Gaustad, & Babbitt, 2019). Because of the rising demand for clean energy, the demand for critical minerals rises respectively. Factors such as disruption in the supply chain and concerns about geopolitics among countries also lead to price fluctuations.
Despite rising costs for critical minerals, technological breakthroughs and increased output of clean energy have constantly drove down overall costs, resulting in clean energy prices that are still lower than a decade ago.
The above figure delineates the intricate trajectory of lithium prices from 2010 to 2022, marked by pivotal moments that significantly influenced market dynamics. This trend encapsulates the volatile nature of the critical minerals market, underpinned by a blend of technological advancements, supply chain vulnerabilities, and geopolitical fluctuations. Notably, the annotations on the graph pinpoint the critical junctures where external forces, such as supply chain disruptions and geopolitical tensions, exerted a tangible impact on lithium prices. This visual representation serves as a testament to the critical minerals’ susceptibility to global events, reinforcing the narrative of supply-demand complexities and the urgent need for strategic foresight in navigating the renewable energy sector’s future.
The causes of this price fluctuation are as follows:
Disruption in the supply chain: When an economy or country goes through tough times like in the case of Chile and Peru, or flood-like conditions due to heavy rainfall in Indonesia and Brazil, hydropower shortages in China, the supply chain gets disrupted due to which the materials supply becomes difficult (Mancheri et al., 2019). This leads to a short-term spike in the prices of critical minerals. However, the international cooperation of countries by forming bilateral contracts and multinational collaborations helps ensure that the supply is sufficient to make technological advancements.
Geopolitical concerns: The position of a country in the key mineral trade chain influences its ability to manage and affect crucial mineral prices, which are essential for the development of renewable energy (Zhu, Ding, & Chen 2022). Trade wars and political tensions generally disrupt the supply chain which eventually reduces the supply of critical materials. In the case of countries like China, Brazil, and Indonesia which are highly rich in these natural critical resources, face problems due to political interventions and trade wars.
Government policy interventions: Trade wars and geopolitical concerns are rare situations when we talk about improving technology on a global level. Most of the time, governments of different countries tend to improve the supply and demand of critical minerals to ensure stability in the prices. For example Policies like the European Union’s Critical Raw Materials (CRM) Act, the United States Inflation Reduction Act, Australia’s Critical Minerals Strategy, and Canada’s Critical Minerals Strategy; all of these policies aim to improve the adequacy of these minerals supply and improve the investment in this sector.
Impact of price fluctuations on Macroeconomic Indicators:
The impact of price fluctuations of critical minerals could cause huge impacts on macroeconomic indicators such as GDP, Inflation, and Trade balances. Following are the illustrations for each of these indicators:
GDP: The importance of the national economy is measured in terms of the minerals they possess and it helps in the calculation of the GDP (Coulomb, et al., 2015). This paper also explains how the movement in prices affects the overall health of an economy. Variations in prices, particularly for critical minerals such as lithium, can affect GDP growth. Spiked prices could increase investment and stimulate output in associated industries, boosting GDP. Simultaneously, dramatic price decreases, such as the 60% drop in lithium carbonate pricing in China, might have a detrimental impact on these industries’ contributions to the growth of GDP.
The bar graph presented elucidates the correlation between the vicissitudes of lithium prices and the ensuing shifts in GDP growth rates. This correlation underlines the foundational role of lithium and similar critical minerals in the scaffolding of the global economy. The visual data articulate how fluctuations in the price of lithium—a key component in the renewable energy technology sphere—have the potential to ripple through the economic fabric, influencing overall economic health and stability. Through this lens, the graph not only visualizes the economic implications of lithium price volatility but also amplifies the discourse on the importance of mineral market stability for sustainable economic growth.
Note: As per the data available on the IEA portal, the demand for lithium in 2022 was 73.17 kilo tons, and it is expected to rise to 490.44 kt in 2050 as per the current stated policy scenario, 1089.17 as per the “Announced pledges scenario” and 1178.46 kt as per the “Net Zero emissions by 2050 scenario”. This clearly shows an upward direction in the demand for lithium due to the high possibility of the use of more electronic items, like EVs, and better batteries for electronic products.
Inflation: Inflation rates can be influenced by price movements. When prices for critical minerals vary, it may influence manufacturing expenses, resulting in fluctuations in prices for consumers. For example, lowering lithium prices could reduce expenses for EV makers while also contributing to reduced inflationary rates.
The ensuing figure delineates the intricate relationship between fluctuations in lithium prices and the corresponding adjustments in inflation rates, capturing the nuanced interplay between commodity pricing and macroeconomic stability. This analysis highlights how swings in the cost of critical minerals, such as lithium, extend beyond the mining and technology sectors, permeating the broader economic landscape to influence inflationary trends. The graph lays bare the direct and indirect channels through which price adjustments of essential commodities like lithium can impact the purchasing power of consumers and the cost of living, thereby underscoring the broader economic significance of stabilizing critical mineral markets.
Trade Balance: Changes in prices can affect the trade balance of a nation by increasing the total expense of goods being imported or exported. If a nation is one of the biggest suppliers of a mineral, such as lithium, and prices fall significantly, this could have an impact on its export earnings and the balance of trade. Cost reductions, on the other hand, may help developing nations/importers by lowering the cost of imports and boosting trade balances.
In conclusion, price fluctuations could have a ripple effect on the above-mentioned indicators which depends on the magnitude of change in the prices.
Effect of price fluctuations on Economic Policies:
As per the discussion so far, it could be seen that prices of critical elements could have a huge impact on the government’s fiscal, monetary, and trade policies. Following is an analysis of each of the government policies:
Monetary Policy: Frequent changes in the prices of critical minerals can have a significant impact on inflation rates because these minerals are used in a variety of sectors. To keep inflation under check and economic growth stable, financial institutions like central banks may need to modify interest rates in reaction to price volatility (Considine, et al., 2023). Additionally, fluctuations in important resource prices can have a bearing on the value of currencies, necessitating central banks to take action to preserve the stability of exchange rates.
Fiscal Policy: Authorities might have to change national fiscal strategies in retaliation to significant swings in mineral prices. As in the case of Chile, the fiscal policy was reformed to solve the problem of fluctuating prices of copper (Collier et al., 2017). These fiscal guidelines limit expenditure during high commodity price periods while allowing for moderate spending during recessions. For nations that rely largely on these elements for selling to other countries or locally produced goods, a huge reduction in pricing could result in lower income for the country, compromising funding for essential amenities and infrastructure. A price increase, conversely, might increase revenue for the government while also necessitating careful control to avoid inflationary pressure on the economy.
Trade Policy: volatility in prices of essential minerals may affect the trade policy decision of a country. Limits on exports enforced by nations with abundant resources to take advantage of rising prices or secure their supplies may cause disagreements over trade or disruptions in worldwide supply chains. Purchasing nations might face difficulties if tariffs rise, damaging their trade balance and competition in global markets.
Investment in the Critical Mineral sector:
As per the Critical Mineral Market Review report, investment patterns in the nonferrous metal market show a balanced allocation of capital between diversified mining majors and specialized operators in renewable energy commodities. Chinese corporations surpassed their peers in the United States, Australia, and Canada, investing a significant $4.3 billion in lithium assets between 2018 and H1 2021, more than doubling the latter group’s total investment (International Energy Agency, 2023). The ongoing need for key minerals, fueled by the adoption of clean energy technologies, remains important.
The bar chart above illustrates the dramatic shifts in investment dynamics within the lithium mining sector from 2018 to 2023, highlighting the aggressive capital inflow observed across China, the USA, Australia, and Canada. This strategic reallocation of resources underscores a global recognition of lithium’s pivotal role in powering the next generation of renewable energy technologies. Particularly noteworthy is the substantial augmentation of investments by Chinese entities, underscoring their leading position in securing critical mineral resources. This comparative analysis not only evidences the intensified global race for lithium mining dominance but also reflects a broader commitment towards transitioning to sustainable energy solutions. Through this lens, the surge in investments encapsulates the burgeoning confidence among global investors in the lithium market’s potential, reinforcing the narrative of a paradigm shift within the nonferrous metal industry towards more sustainable and renewable sources.
Substantial investments in essential minerals during Q1 2023 have surpassed the sums observed in early-stage deals in 2022, and are on track to exceed the levels seen in 2021 end. The upward trend in critical minerals start-ups demonstrates high investor confidence in a policy environment that encourages new ventures. Furthermore, a worldwide summit on important minerals seeks to assure a stable and sustainable mineral supply by bringing together producing and consuming economies, industry, investors, and civil society. While huge corporations continue carefully, targeted players increase spending, particularly in growth initiatives, showing increased profitability. Specialized enterprises are increasingly making equity investments, indicating sector expansion and increased investor trust. The power transitional minerals sector sees significant M&A activity, particularly in copper and various lithium-related transactions, which reflect the changing dynamics of the nonferrous metal business.
Conclusion:
In conclusion, critical minerals play an important role in driving technical developments and promoting economic prosperity. The complicated dynamics of key minerals, particularly their impact on renewable energy technology, are unique. By analyzing price swings over the last decade, it identifies rising demand for clean energy technology, supply chain problems, and geopolitical worries. Despite growing essential material prices, technical developments and economies of scale have resulted in a steady decline in overall costs for clean energy generation, demonstrating the sector’s resiliency. The causes of price changes are thoroughly examined, including supply chain interruptions, geopolitical concerns, and government policy interventions, emphasizing the significance of international cooperation and strategic initiatives. Furthermore, the impact of price changes on macroeconomic indices such as GDP, inflation, and trade balances demonstrates the close relationship between mineral prices and national economic performance. The impact of price changes on government policies, including monetary, fiscal, and trade policies, demonstrates the importance of adaptive measures in response to changing mineral prices. Finally, the analysis also looks into the changing investment landscape in the vital mineral industry, revealing sensible capital allocation. Investment patterns in the essential mineral sector show a balanced capital allocation between diversified mining majors and specialized companies in renewable energy commodities, highlighting the changing dynamics of the nonferrous metal business.
References:
Collier, P., Glaeser, E., Venables, T., Blake, M., & Manwaring, P. (2017). Secure, legally enforceable and marketable land rights for urban development. IGC Cities that Work Policy Brief; International Growth Centre: Oxford, UK. https://www.theigc.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/23125%20Copper-Plus%20Future_v5-WEB.pdf
Considine, J., Galkin, P., Hatipoglu, E., & Aldayel, A. (2023). The effects of a shock to critical minerals prices on the world oil price and inflation. Energy Economics, 127, 106934. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140988323004322
Coulomb, R., Dietz, S., Godunova, M., & Nielsen, T. B. (2015). Critical minerals today and in 2030: an analysis for OECD countries. https://www.lse.ac.uk/GranthamInstitute/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/OECD_minerals_paper_Coulomb_et_al.pdf
Hayes, S. M., & McCullough, E. A. (2018). Critical minerals: A review of elemental trends in comprehensive criticality studies. Resources Policy, 59, 192-199. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301420718301296
International Energy Agency. (2023). Critical Minerals Market Review 2023. In Critical Minerals Market Review 2023 (pp. 2–5) [Report]. https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/c7716240-ab4f-4f5d-b138-291e76c6a7c7/CriticalMineralsMarketReview2023.pdf
Mancheri, N. A., Sprecher, B., Bailey, G., Ge, J., & Tukker, A. (2019). Effect of Chinese policies on rare earth supply chain resilience. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 142, 101-112. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S092134491830435X
Zhu, X., Ding, Q., & Chen, J. (2022). How does critical mineral trade pattern affect renewable energy development? The mediating role of renewable energy technological progress. Energy Economics, 112, 106164. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0140988322003188