Presented at 2024 BMC Together for Hope Conference on March 16, 2024.

Note: This is an R Markdown document. Markdown is a simple formatting syntax for authoring HTML, PDF, and MS Word documents. For more details on using R Markdown see http://rmarkdown.rstudio.com.

Note: Dataset is labeled ‘od’ (‘opioid disposal’).


0.1 Summary statistics

0.1.1 Number of respondents

  • 111 respondents out of 169 total enrollees
## 
##        Received packet Did not receive packet                   <NA> 
##                    106                      5                     58

0.1.2 Age of respondents

## # A tibble: 5 × 2
##   age_range_labeled     n
##   <fct>             <int>
## 1 17 or under           2
## 2 18 to 25             14
## 3 26 to 40             19
## 4 41 to 55             27
## 5 56 or over           49

0.1.3 Gender of respondents

  • Male: 53
  • Female: 58
  • Prefer not to say: 0
  • Prefer to self-describe: 0
## # A tibble: 2 × 2
##   gender_labeled     n
##   <fct>          <int>
## 1 Female            58
## 2 Male              53

0.1.4 Type and severity of surgery (by SORT criteria)

  • Breast: 3
  • Ear, nose, or throat: 8
  • Gynecologic: 9
  • Hand: 11
  • Hernia repair: 12
  • Orthopedic: spine: 7
  • Orthopedic: other: 20
  • Urologic: 3
  • Severity:
    . Intermediate: 35
    . Major: 26
    . Complex: 12
## # A tibble: 9 × 2
##   surg_cat                 n
##   <chr>                <int>
## 1 Breast                   3
## 2 Ear, nose, or throat     8
## 3 Gynecologic              9
## 4 Hand                    11
## 5 Hernia repair           12
## 6 Orthopedic: other       20
## 7 Orthopedic: spine        7
## 8 Urologic                 3
## 9 <NA>                    38
## # A tibble: 4 × 2
##   surg_severity     n
##   <chr>         <int>
## 1 Complex          12
## 2 Intermediate     35
## 3 Major            26
## 4 <NA>             38

0.1.5 Opioid prescribed

  • Oxycodone: 56
  • Percocet: 2
  • Hydrocodone: 4
  • Vicodin: 0
  • Hydromorphone: 4
  • Morphine: 0
  • Tramadol: 5
  • Other: 0
## # A tibble: 6 × 2
##   opioid_prescribed     n
##   <chr>             <int>
## 1 Hydrocodone           4
## 2 Hydromorphone         4
## 3 Other                 5
## 4 Oxycodone            56
## 5 Percocet              2
## 6 <NA>                 40

0.1.6 Opioid pill quantity by prescription

  • Oxycodone avg #: 21.0
  • Percocet avg #: 20
  • Hydrocodone avg #: 11.2
  • Hydromorphone avg #: 18
  • Tramadol avg #: 7
## # A tibble: 6 × 2
##   opioid_prescribed  mean
##   <chr>             <dbl>
## 1 Hydrocodone        11.2
## 2 Hydromorphone      18  
## 3 Other               7  
## 4 Oxycodone          21.0
## 5 Percocet           20  
## 6 <NA>              NaN

0.1.7 Mean dose by prescription

  • Oxycodone avg #: 5
  • Percocet avg #: 5
  • Hydrocodone avg #: 5
  • Hydromorphone avg #: 4
  • Tramadol avg #: 50
## # A tibble: 6 × 2
##   opioid_prescribed  mean
##   <chr>             <dbl>
## 1 Hydrocodone           5
## 2 Hydromorphone         4
## 3 Other                50
## 4 Oxycodone             5
## 5 Percocet              5
## 6 <NA>                 30

0.1.8 Opioid quantity x dose (mean, SD)

  • Oxycodone: 105, 92.4
  • Percocet: 100, 0
  • Hydrocodone: 56.2, 12.5
  • Vicodin: 0
  • Hydromorphone: 40, 23.1
  • Morphine: 0
  • Tramadol: 350, 361
  • Other: 0
## # A tibble: 6 × 3
##   opioid_prescribed  mean    sd
##   <chr>             <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 Hydrocodone        56.2  12.5
## 2 Hydromorphone      40    23.1
## 3 Other             350   361. 
## 4 Oxycodone         105.   92.4
## 5 Percocet          100     0  
## 6 <NA>              NaN    NA

0.1.9 Morphine milligram equivalent (MME) x number pills prescribed (mean, SD):

  • Oxycodone: 158, 139
  • Percocet: 150, 0
  • Hydrocodone: 56.2, 12.5
  • Vicodin: 0
  • Hydromorphone: 160, 92.4
  • Morphine: 0
  • Tramadol: NA
  • Other: 0
## # A tibble: 6 × 3
##   opioid_prescribed  mean    sd
##   <chr>             <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 Hydrocodone        56.2  12.5
## 2 Hydromorphone     160    92.4
## 3 Other             NaN    NA  
## 4 Oxycodone         158.  139. 
## 5 Percocet          150     0  
## 6 <NA>              NaN    NA

0.1.10 Responded and received disposal packet: 106

  • Did not receive disposal packet: 5 (2 did not fill script; 1 didn’t see it; 1 doesn’t remember receiving one; 1 lost in transit)
## # A tibble: 2 × 2
##   ddisposal_received_labeled     n
##   <chr>                      <int>
## 1 Did not receive packet         5
## 2 Received packet              106
## 
##                         did not fill script, felt no p/o pain 
##                                                             1 
##           did not fill script, not a huge fan of taking pills 
##                                                             1 
##                                                 didn't see it 
##                                                             1 
##                               does not remember receiving one 
##                                                             1 
## the packet must be with the man that drove her to the surgery 
##                                                             1

0.2 Summary statistics: Disposal packet use

## # A tibble: 2 × 2
##   ddisposal_used_labeled     n
##   <chr>                  <int>
## 1 Did not use packet        86
## 2 Used packet               20

0.2.1 Of those that received but didn’t use the disposal packet, why not?

  • Completed prescription: 10 (1 also endorsed waiting to dispose of multiple)
  • Did not fill script: 17 (1 also endorsed waiting to dispose of multiple)
  • Have not gotten around to it: 35 (1 also reported filling prescription but not taking and losing pouch, 1 also endorsed taking irregularly, 1 also endorsed waiting to dispose of multiple medications, 1 also endorsed taking irregularly and waiting to dispose of multiple medications, 1 also endorsed keeping in case of pain, 1 also endorsed keeping in case of pain and taking irregularly)
  • Holding onto prescription in case of pain: 18
  • Waiting to dispose of many medications at once: 11
  • Taking prescription irregularly: 12
  • Other: 9 total, but 4 that are unique reasons (1 developed allergy to codeine; 1 misplaced packet, 2 still finishing prescription as prescribed)
## # A tibble: 20 × 8
## # Groups:   fin_pres, no_fill, procras, in_case, waiting_mult, irreg_pres [17]
##    fin_pres no_fill procras in_case waiting_mult irreg_pres other     n
##       <dbl>   <dbl>   <dbl>   <dbl>        <dbl>      <dbl> <dbl> <int>
##  1        0       0       0       0            0          0     1     4
##  2        0       0       0       0            0          1     0     3
##  3        0       0       0       0            1          0     0     3
##  4        0       0       0       0            1          1     0     1
##  5        0       0       0       1            0          0     0     8
##  6        0       0       0       1            0          0     1     1
##  7        0       0       0       1            0          1     0     3
##  8        0       0       0       1            1          0     1     1
##  9        0       0       1       0            0          0     0    23
## 10        0       0       1       0            0          0     1     1
## 11        0       0       1       0            0          1     0     2
## 12        0       0       1       0            1          0     0     3
## 13        0       0       1       0            1          1     0     1
## 14        0       0       1       1            0          0     0     3
## 15        0       0       1       1            0          1     0     2
## 16        0       1       0       0            0          0     0    14
## 17        0       1       0       0            0          0     1     2
## 18        0       1       0       0            1          0     0     1
## 19        1       0       0       0            0          0     0     9
## 20        1       0       0       0            1          0     0     1
## # A tibble: 9 × 1
##   ddisposal_used_ifnowhy_spec                                                   
##   <chr>                                                                         
## 1 "did fill script but did not take the medications. do not know where the pouc…
## 2 "plans on giving it to a friend if they are prescribed opioids."              
## 3 "still taking medications, just went in on Thursday"                          
## 4 "wait to use it, until he sees the doc to make sure he doesn't get more to di…
## 5 "used their old back pain meds. would have gotten rid of them anyways, though…
## 6 "developed allergy to codeine, going in to see doctor"                        
## 7 "misplaced the packet"                                                        
## 8 "have another surgery soon, keeping earlier prescriptions just in case"       
## 9 "still taking regularly"

0.2.1.1 Summary

  • 20 people used packet
  • Of the 86 that didn’t use it:
    . 10 finished prescription
    . 17 did not fill or pick up prescription
    . 12 were taking prescription irregularly
  • Therefore, there were 47 people that could have used packet but didn’t:
    . 23 had not gotten around to it
    . 8 were keeping prescription in case of additional pain
    . 3 were waiting to dispose of many medications at once
    . 4 other reason
    . 1 was keeping prescription in case of additional pain and other reason
    . 1 was keeping prescription in case of additional pain, waiting to dispose of multiple medications, and other reason
    . 1 had not gotten around to it and other reason
    . 3 had not gotten around to it and were waiting to dispose of multiple medications
    . 3 had not gotten around to it and were keeping prescription in case of additional pain

0.3 Summary statistics: Used disposal packet

0.3.1 Of those that received and used the disposal packet, what types of drugs were disposed?

  • Only opioids: 16
  • Opioids + prescription other than opioids: 3
  • Opioids + prescription other than opioids + uncertain/not sure: 1
## # A tibble: 3 × 5
## # Groups:   ddrug_type___1, ddrug_type___2, ddrug_type___3 [2]
##   ddrug_type___1 ddrug_type___2 ddrug_type___3 ddrug_type___4     n
##            <dbl>          <dbl>          <dbl>          <dbl> <int>
## 1              1              0              0              0    16
## 2              1              1              0              0     3
## 3              1              1              0              1     1

0.3.2 Of those that received and used the disposal packet, how many pills were in their initial prescription?

## # A tibble: 5 × 2
##   script_num_labeled     n
##   <chr>              <int>
## 1 16 to 30               6
## 2 30 or more             1
## 3 8 to 15                8
## 4 Less than 7            3
## 5 <NA>                   2

0.3.3 Of those that received and used the disposal packet, how many pills were disposed?

## # A tibble: 5 × 2
##   script_disp_num_labeled     n
##   <chr>                   <int>
## 1 16 to 30                    6
## 2 31 or more                  1
## 3 8 to 15                     8
## 4 Less than 7                 3
## 5 <NA>                        2

0.3.4 Of those that received and used the disposal packet, how important was getting instructions and disposal packet to decision to dispose of medications?

## # A tibble: 4 × 2
##   ddisposal_important_labeled     n
##   <chr>                       <int>
## 1 Important                      12
## 2 Not important                   3
## 3 Somewhat important              4
## 4 Undecided/unsure                1

0.3.5 Of those that received and used the disposal packet, how have unused medications been handled in past?

## # A tibble: 6 × 2
##   ddisposal_past_labeled                  n
##   <chr>                               <int>
## 1 Drug disposal bin                       3
## 2 Drug take back event                    1
## 3 Left in medicine chest or household     5
## 4 Other                                   2
## 5 Toilet                                  3
## 6 Trash                                   6
## 
## Disposed of in sink              unsure 
##                   1                   1

0.3.6 Of those that received and used the disposal packet, how many would use again for future prescriptions?

## # A tibble: 2 × 2
##   ddisposal_future_labeled     n
##   <chr>                    <int>
## 1 Would not use again          1
## 2 Would use again             19

0.4 Summary statistics: Didn’t use disposal packet

0.4.1 Of those that received but didn’t use the disposal packet, how many are taking prescription regularly?

## # A tibble: 3 × 2
##   ddisposal_meds_reg_labeled     n
##   <chr>                      <int>
## 1 Not taking regularly          79
## 2 Taking regularly               4
## 3 <NA>                           3

0.4.2 Of those that received but didn’t use the disposal packet, how many plan to use it in the future?

  • Plan to use: 53 (50 if exclude finish prescription/didn’t fill)
  • Don’t plan to use: 27 (7 if exclude finish prescription/didn’t fill)
  • No response: 6 (2 if exclude finish prescription/didn’t fill)
## # A tibble: 3 × 2
##   ddisposal_use_future_labeled     n
##   <chr>                        <int>
## 1 Don't plan to use               27
## 2 Plan to use                     53
## 3 <NA>                             6
## # A tibble: 3 × 2
##   ddisposal_use_future_labeled_with_exclusions     n
##   <chr>                                        <int>
## 1 Don't plan to use                                7
## 2 Plan to use                                     50
## 3 <NA>                                             2

0.5 Pairwise analysis

0.5.1 Is there a difference in packet use by age group?

  • No difference in packet use by age by chi-squared test.
##                       age_range_labeled
## ddisposal_used_labeled 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                    No            2        9       16       21         38
##                    Yes           0        4        2        5          9
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  od$age_range_labeled and od$ddisposal_used_labeled
## X-squared = 2.3801, df = 4, p-value = 0.6662

0.5.2 Are women more likely to use packet than men?

  • Women (~23%) were more likely to use disposal packet than men (~14%) by chi-squared test.
##                       gender_labeled
## ddisposal_used_labeled Female Male Prefer not to say Prefer to self-describe
##                    No      43   43                 0                       0
##                    Yes     13    7                 0                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.numeric(od$gender) and od$ddisposal_used
## McNemar's chi-squared = 16.071, df = 1, p-value = 6.1e-05

0.5.3 Are people prescribed certain medication more likely to use packet than others?

  • No association between packet use and medication prescribed by chi-squared test.
##                       opioid_prescribed
## ddisposal_used_labeled Hydrocodone Hydromorphone Other Oxycodone Percocet
##                    No            4             3     2        43        2
##                    Yes           0             1     2         9        0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  od$ddisposal_used_labeled and od$opioid_prescribed
## X-squared = 4.2073, df = 4, p-value = 0.3787

0.5.4 Are people prescribed a greater quantity of pills more likey to use the packet than others?

  • No association between packet use and quantity of pills prescribed by ANOVA test.
## # A tibble: 3 × 3
##   ddisposal_used_labeled  mean    sd
##   <fct>                  <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 No                     20.7   18.8
## 2 Yes                    18.6   10.6
## 3 <NA>                    8.25   3.5
##               Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)
## od$pill_quant  1  0.018  0.0178   0.121  0.729
## Residuals     62  9.092  0.1466               
## 105 observations deleted due to missingness

0.5.5 Are people that received a certain type of surgery more likey to use the packet than others?

  • No association between packet use and type of surgery received by chi-squared test.
##                       surg_cat
## ddisposal_used_labeled Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                    No       1                    6           7    9
##                    Yes      1                    2           2    1
##                       surg_cat
## ddisposal_used_labeled Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                    No              8                15                 7
##                    Yes             1                 5                 0
##                       surg_cat
## ddisposal_used_labeled Urologic
##                    No         3
##                    Yes        0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  od$ddisposal_used_labeled and od$surg_cat
## X-squared = 5.4216, df = 7, p-value = 0.6087

0.5.6 Are people in certain age or gender group more likely to be prescribed certain medication?

  • No association between medication prescribed and age/gender by chi-squared test.
## , , gender_labeled = Female
## 
##                  age_range_labeled
## opioid_prescribed 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##     Hydrocodone             0        1        1        0          0
##     Hydromorphone           0        0        0        1          3
##     Other                   0        0        0        0          2
##     Oxycodone               0        3        5        7         13
##     Percocet                0        0        1        0          0
## 
## , , gender_labeled = Male
## 
##                  age_range_labeled
## opioid_prescribed 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##     Hydrocodone             0        0        0        1          1
##     Hydromorphone           0        0        0        0          0
##     Other                   0        1        0        0          2
##     Oxycodone               1        5        3        8         11
##     Percocet                0        0        1        0          0
## 
## , , gender_labeled = Prefer not to say
## 
##                  age_range_labeled
## opioid_prescribed 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##     Hydrocodone             0        0        0        0          0
##     Hydromorphone           0        0        0        0          0
##     Other                   0        0        0        0          0
##     Oxycodone               0        0        0        0          0
##     Percocet                0        0        0        0          0
## 
## , , gender_labeled = Prefer to self-describe
## 
##                  age_range_labeled
## opioid_prescribed 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##     Hydrocodone             0        0        0        0          0
##     Hydromorphone           0        0        0        0          0
##     Other                   0        0        0        0          0
##     Oxycodone               0        0        0        0          0
##     Percocet                0        0        0        0          0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$opioid_prescribed) and as.factor(od$gender_labeled)
## X-squared = 4.0805, df = 4, p-value = 0.3952
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$opioid_prescribed) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 17.813, df = 16, p-value = 0.3349

0.5.7 Are people in certain groups more likely to dispose of more medication?

  • No association with age by chi-squared test.
##                        age_range_labeled
## script_disp_num_labeled 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##             Less than 7           0        2        1        1          1
##             8 to 15               0        0        1        2          5
##             16 to 30              0        2        0        1          1
##             31 or more            0        0        0        0          1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$script_disp_num_labeled) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 7.5938, df = 9, p-value = 0.5755
  • No association with gender by chi-squared test.
##                        as.factor(gender_labeled)
## script_disp_num_labeled Female Male Prefer not to say Prefer to self-describe
##             Less than 7      4    1                 0                       0
##             8 to 15          7    1                 0                       0
##             16 to 30         1    3                 0                       0
##             31 or more       0    1                 0                       0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$script_disp_num_labeled) and as.factor(od$gender_labeled)
## X-squared = 7.0875, df = 3, p-value = 0.06916
  • No association with medication prescribed by chi-squared test.
##                        as.factor(opioid_prescribed)
## script_disp_num_labeled Hydrocodone Hydromorphone Other Oxycodone Percocet
##             Less than 7           0             0     0         3        0
##             8 to 15               0             1     1         2        0
##             16 to 30              0             0     1         3        0
##             31 or more            0             0     0         0        0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$script_disp_num_labeled) and as.factor(od$opioid_prescribed)
## X-squared = 3.0938, df = 4, p-value = 0.5423
  • Individuals who were prescribed more pills were more likely to dispose a greater number of pills by ANOVA test.
## # A tibble: 5 × 3
##   script_disp_num_labeled   mean    sd
##   <fct>                    <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 Less than 7               9.33  9.29
## 2 8 to 15                  18     8.12
## 3 16 to 30                 28.3  10.4 
## 4 31 or more              NaN    NA   
## 5 <NA>                     19.8  18.2
##               Df Sum Sq Mean Sq F value Pr(>F)  
## od$pill_quant  1  2.874  2.8739   7.355 0.0266 *
## Residuals      8  3.126  0.3908                 
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 159 observations deleted due to missingness
  • No association with past disposal behavior by chi-squared test.
##                        as.factor(ddisposal_past_labeled)
## script_disp_num_labeled Left them in medicine chest or household
##             Less than 7                                        2
##             8 to 15                                            3
##             16 to 30                                           0
##             31 or more                                         0
##                        as.factor(ddisposal_past_labeled)
## script_disp_num_labeled Disposed of in trash Disposed of in toilet
##             Less than 7                    1                     0
##             8 to 15                        3                     1
##             16 to 30                       2                     0
##             31 or more                     0                     1
##                        as.factor(ddisposal_past_labeled)
## script_disp_num_labeled Disposed of in drug disposal bin
##             Less than 7                                0
##             8 to 15                                    1
##             16 to 30                                   2
##             31 or more                                 0
##                        as.factor(ddisposal_past_labeled)
## script_disp_num_labeled Participated in drug take back event Other
##             Less than 7                                    1     1
##             8 to 15                                        0     0
##             16 to 30                                       0     0
##             31 or more                                     0     0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$script_disp_num_labeled) and as.factor(od$ddisposal_past_labeled)
## X-squared = 19.98, df = 15, p-value = 0.1727

0.5.8 Of those who didn’t use packet, is there an association between reasons for not using packet and age?

  • No association between age and any reason for not using packet.
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           5       20       24       34         76
##                          1           0        0        2        5          3
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 5.6957, df = 4, p-value = 0.2231
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           5       16       25       36         70
##                          1           0        4        1        3          9
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 4.2498, df = 4, p-value = 0.3733
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           3       17       19       30         65
##                          1           2        3        7        9         14
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 2.704, df = 4, p-value = 0.6085
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           5       18       22       35         71
##                          1           0        2        4        4          8
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 1.2463, df = 4, p-value = 0.8704
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           5       19       24       35         75
##                          1           0        1        2        4          4
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 1.6541, df = 4, p-value = 0.799
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           5       19       22       37         74
##                          1           0        1        4        2          5
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 3.5221, df = 4, p-value = 0.4745
##                           as.factor(age_range_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          0           5       20       24       37         74
##                          1           0        0        2        2          5
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 1.856, df = 4, p-value = 0.7622

0.5.9 Of those who didn’t use packet, is there an association between reasons for not using packet and gender?

  • Women were more likely than men to report not getting around to it, holding in case of more pain, waiting to dispose of many medications at once, taking prescription irregularly, and other reasons.
  • Men were more likely than women to have not filled their script, completed their prescription
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     88   71                 0
##                          1      3    7                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 62.486, df = 1, p-value = 2.683e-15
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     86   66                 0
##                          1      5   12                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 52.408, df = 1, p-value = 4.508e-13
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     68   66                 0
##                          1     23   12                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 20.775, df = 1, p-value = 5.165e-06
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     80   71                 0
##                          1     11    7                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 43.902, df = 1, p-value = 3.452e-11
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     84   74                 0
##                          1      7    4                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 55.42, df = 1, p-value = 9.735e-14
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     82   75                 0
##                          1      9    3                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 51.857, df = 1, p-value = 5.969e-13
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7 Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          0     85   75                 0
##                          1      6    3                 0
##                           as.factor(gender_labeled)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7 Prefer to self-describe
##                          0                       0
##                          1                       0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 58.778, df = 1, p-value = 1.765e-14

0.5.10 Of those who didn’t use packet, is there an association between reasons for not using packet and surgery received?

  • No association between surgery and any reason for not using packet.
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      3                    8           9    9
##                          1      0                    0           0    2
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0             9                20                 6
##                          1             3                 0                 1
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 Urologic
##                          0        2
##                          1        1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 10.596, df = 7, p-value = 0.1573
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      3                    7           8    9
##                          1      0                    1           1    2
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0            11                19                 5
##                          1             1                 1                 2
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 Urologic
##                          0        2
##                          1        1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 4.8873, df = 7, p-value = 0.6737
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      2                    3           6    8
##                          1      1                    5           3    3
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0            10                13                 3
##                          1             2                 7                 4
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3 Urologic
##                          0        3
##                          1        0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___3) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 7.9221, df = 7, p-value = 0.3395
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      3                    7           7    9
##                          1      0                    1           2    2
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0            10                17                 7
##                          1             2                 3                 0
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4 Urologic
##                          0        2
##                          1        1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___4) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 3.0647, df = 7, p-value = 0.879
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      3                    8           8   11
##                          1      0                    0           1    0
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0            11                18                 6
##                          1             1                 2                 1
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5 Urologic
##                          0        2
##                          1        1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___5) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 5.004, df = 7, p-value = 0.6595
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      3                    8           7   10
##                          1      0                    0           2    1
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0            12                14                 7
##                          1             0                 6                 0
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6 Urologic
##                          0        3
##                          1        0
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___6) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 11.34, df = 7, p-value = 0.1244
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7 Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          0      3                    8           8   11
##                          1      0                    0           1    0
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7 Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          0            12                19                 7
##                          1             0                 1                 0
##                           as.factor(surg_cat)
## ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7 Urologic
##                          0        2
##                          1        1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___7) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 9.4185, df = 7, p-value = 0.224

0.5.11 Of those who didn’t use packet, is there an association between plan to use in the future and age/gender?

  • No association with age group, surgery, or pill quantity prescribed.
  • Women were more likely to endorse plan to use pouch in the future (78%) than men (54%).
  • This difference remains if you exclude those that completed prescription or didn’t fill it (but 88% of women vs 87% of men)
##                             age_range_labeled
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled 17 or under 18 to 25 26 to 40 41 to 55 56 or over
##                          Yes           2        4       11       12         24
##                          No            0        4        4        8         11
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_use_future_labeled) and as.factor(od$age_range_labeled)
## X-squared = 2.734, df = 4, p-value = 0.6033
##                             surg_cat
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          Yes      1                    5           6    5
##                          No       0                    1           1    4
##                             surg_cat
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          Yes             3                11                 4
##                          No              2                 3                 3
##                             surg_cat
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Urologic
##                          Yes        1
##                          No         1
## 
##  Pearson's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od$ddisposal_use_future_labeled) and as.factor(od$surg_cat)
## X-squared = 4.3548, df = 7, p-value = 0.7381
## # A tibble: 3 × 3
##   ddisposal_use_future_labeled  mean    sd
##   <fct>                        <dbl> <dbl>
## 1 Yes                           23.2  20.3
## 2 No                            18.2  16.5
## 3 <NA>                          14.8  10.7
##                             surg_cat
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Breast Ear, nose, or throat Gynecologic Hand
##                          Yes      1                    5           6    5
##                          No       0                    1           1    4
##                             surg_cat
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Hernia repair Orthopedic: other Orthopedic: spine
##                          Yes             3                11                 4
##                          No              2                 3                 3
##                             surg_cat
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Urologic
##                          Yes        1
##                          No         1
## 
##  Welch Two Sample t-test
## 
## data:  as.numeric(od$pill_quant) by as.factor(od$ddisposal_use_future_labeled)
## t = 0.89613, df = 33.126, p-value = 0.3767
## alternative hypothesis: true difference in means between group Yes and group No is not equal to 0
## 95 percent confidence interval:
##  -6.288508 16.191538
## sample estimates:
## mean in group Yes  mean in group No 
##          23.15152          18.20000
##                             gender_labeled
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          Yes     32   21                 0
##                          No       9   18                 0
##                             gender_labeled
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Prefer to self-describe
##                          Yes                       0
##                          No                        0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$ddisposal_use_future_labeled) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled), ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 4.8, df = 1, p-value = 0.02846
##                             gender_labeled
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Female Male Prefer not to say
##                          Yes     30   20                 0
##                          No       4    3                 0
##                             gender_labeled
## ddisposal_use_future_labeled Prefer to self-describe
##                          Yes                       0
##                          No                        0
## 
##  McNemar's Chi-squared test
## 
## data:  as.factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled) & od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 == 0 & od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 == 0, ]$ddisposal_use_future_labeled) and factor(od[!is.na(od$gender_labeled) & od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___1 == 0 & od$ddisposal_used_ifnowhy___2 == 0, ]$gender_labeled, levels = c("Female", "Male"))
## McNemar's chi-squared = 10.667, df = 1, p-value = 0.001091

0.6 Logistic regression analysis: probability of packet use

0.6.1 Model of packet use with age, gender, and pill quantity

0.6.1.1 Model

  • Those aged 26-40 or 56+ were less likely to use packet than those 18-25. Women were more likely to use the packet than men.
## 
## Call:
## glm(formula = ddisposal_used_labeled ~ relevel(age_range_labeled, 
##     ref = "18 to 25") + relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male") + 
##     as.numeric(pill_quant), family = "binomial", data = od_disposal_model_oxy)
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                                           Estimate Std. Error
## (Intercept)                                                0.79350    1.39170
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under  -15.89403 2399.54491
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40      -4.22309    2.02189
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55      -2.85908    1.64607
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over    -4.07224    1.79646
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                3.21961    1.44281
## as.numeric(pill_quant)                                    -0.08142    0.04345
##                                                         z value Pr(>|z|)  
## (Intercept)                                               0.570   0.5686  
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under  -0.007   0.9947  
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40     -2.089   0.0367 *
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55     -1.737   0.0824 .
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over   -2.267   0.0234 *
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female               2.231   0.0256 *
## as.numeric(pill_quant)                                   -1.874   0.0609 .
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)
## 
##     Null deviance: 47.532  on 50  degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 33.871  on 44  degrees of freedom
##   (103 observations deleted due to missingness)
## AIC: 47.871
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 15

0.6.1.2 Plot of predicted probabilities and odds ratios

0.6.2 Model of packet use with age, gender, milligram morphine equivalent x pill quantity (ie, total opioid prescribed), and surgery

0.6.2.1 Model

  • No significant effects, indicating that type of surgery received and age or gender are likely collinear.
## 
## Call:
## glm(formula = ddisposal_used_labeled ~ relevel(age_range_labeled, 
##     ref = "18 to 25") + relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male") + 
##     MME_total + relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair"), 
##     family = "binomial", data = od)
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                                                           Estimate
## (Intercept)                                                             -1.289e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                 -1.470e-01
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                    -2.908e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                     4.221e-01
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                  -3.783e+00
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                              4.711e-01
## MME_total                                                               -6.943e-03
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                2.495e+01
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat  1.880e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic           3.553e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                 -1.719e+01
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other     2.816e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine    -1.702e+01
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic             -1.731e+01
##                                                                         Std. Error
## (Intercept)                                                              1.887e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                  1.130e+04
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                     1.857e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                     1.740e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                   1.948e+00
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                              1.281e+00
## MME_total                                                                6.350e-03
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                1.075e+04
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat  2.018e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic           2.282e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                  3.464e+03
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other     1.981e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine     3.686e+03
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic              5.515e+03
##                                                                         z value
## (Intercept)                                                              -0.683
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                   0.000
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                     -1.566
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                      0.243
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                   -1.941
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                               0.368
## MME_total                                                                -1.093
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                 0.002
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat   0.932
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic            1.557
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                  -0.005
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other      1.421
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine     -0.005
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic              -0.003
##                                                                         Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept)                                                               0.4947
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                   1.0000
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                      0.1173
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                      0.8083
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                    0.0522
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                               0.7132
## MME_total                                                                 0.2742
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                 0.9981
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat   0.3515
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic            0.1195
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                   0.9960
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other      0.1552
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine      0.9963
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic               0.9975
##                                                                          
## (Intercept)                                                              
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                  
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                     
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                     
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                  .
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                              
## MME_total                                                                
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat  
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic           
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                  
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other     
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine     
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic              
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)
## 
##     Null deviance: 54.429  on 60  degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 28.621  on 47  degrees of freedom
##   (108 observations deleted due to missingness)
## AIC: 56.621
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 18

0.6.3 Model of packet use with age, gender, milligram morphine equivalent x pill quantity (ie, total opioid prescribed), and severity of surgery

0.6.3.1 Model

  • Effects of age and gender on packet use persist when controlling for severity of surgery received.
## 
## Call:
## glm(formula = ddisposal_used_labeled ~ relevel(age_range_labeled, 
##     ref = "18 to 25") + relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male") + 
##     MME_total + relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate"), 
##     family = "binomial", data = od)
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                                                  Estimate
## (Intercept)                                                    -1.122e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under        -1.582e+01
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40           -2.617e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55           -7.706e-01
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over         -2.838e+00
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                     2.048e+00
## MME_total                                                      -4.164e-03
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Complex -3.478e-01
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Major    9.334e-01
##                                                                Std. Error
## (Intercept)                                                     1.206e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under         2.400e+03
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40            1.535e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55            1.215e+00
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over          1.330e+00
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                     1.005e+00
## MME_total                                                       5.160e-03
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Complex  1.609e+00
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Major    9.981e-01
##                                                                z value Pr(>|z|)
## (Intercept)                                                     -0.931   0.3519
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under         -0.007   0.9947
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40            -1.706   0.0881
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55            -0.634   0.5258
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over          -2.133   0.0329
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                      2.038   0.0416
## MME_total                                                       -0.807   0.4197
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Complex  -0.216   0.8288
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Major     0.935   0.3497
##                                                                 
## (Intercept)                                                     
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under         
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40           .
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55            
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over         *
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                    *
## MME_total                                                       
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Complex  
## relevel(as.factor(surg_severity), ref = "Intermediate")Major    
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## (Dispersion parameter for binomial family taken to be 1)
## 
##     Null deviance: 54.429  on 60  degrees of freedom
## Residual deviance: 41.476  on 52  degrees of freedom
##   (108 observations deleted due to missingness)
## AIC: 59.476
## 
## Number of Fisher Scoring iterations: 15

0.7 Linear regression analysis: prescription quantity

0.7.1 Model of pill quantity prescribed with age, gender, type of surgery, medication, and dose

  • Independent of medication and dose, patients 26-40 are less likely to be prescribed, and orthopedic patients are more likely to be prescribed.
## 
## Call:
## lm(formula = pill_quant ~ relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25") + 
##     relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male") + relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), 
##     ref = "Hernia repair") + opioid_dose + relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), 
##     ref = "Oxycodone"), data = od)
## 
## Residuals:
##     Min      1Q  Median      3Q     Max 
## -17.657  -7.640  -1.062   3.256  71.250 
## 
## Coefficients:
##                                                                         Estimate
## (Intercept)                                                               32.699
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                   -6.239
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                     -20.007
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                     -14.157
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                    -9.956
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                                3.074
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                  3.738
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat    4.573
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic            17.888
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                    6.494
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other      21.795
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine      21.484
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic                7.227
## opioid_dose                                                               -2.991
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydrocodone       -2.902
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydromorphone    -11.796
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Other            120.159
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Percocet          16.152
##                                                                         Std. Error
## (Intercept)                                                                 15.188
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                     18.538
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                         8.879
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                         8.735
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                       8.178
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                                  5.050
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                   12.977
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat     12.333
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic               8.978
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                      7.760
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other         6.556
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine         7.905
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic                 13.961
## opioid_dose                                                                  2.418
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydrocodone         12.787
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydromorphone        8.854
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Other              109.844
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Percocet            16.544
##                                                                         t value
## (Intercept)                                                               2.153
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                  -0.337
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                     -2.253
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                     -1.621
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                   -1.218
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                               0.609
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                 0.288
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat   0.371
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic            1.993
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                   0.837
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other      3.324
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine      2.718
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic               0.518
## opioid_dose                                                              -1.237
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydrocodone      -0.227
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydromorphone    -1.332
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Other             1.094
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Percocet          0.976
##                                                                         Pr(>|t|)
## (Intercept)                                                              0.03617
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                  0.73788
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                     0.02865
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                     0.11136
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                   0.22912
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                              0.54551
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                0.77449
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat  0.71233
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic           0.05179
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                  0.40668
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other     0.00166
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine     0.00901
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic              0.60696
## opioid_dose                                                              0.22192
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydrocodone      0.82139
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydromorphone    0.18881
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Other            0.27924
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Percocet         0.33361
##                                                                           
## (Intercept)                                                             * 
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")17 or under                   
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")26 to 40                    * 
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")41 to 55                      
## relevel(age_range_labeled, ref = "18 to 25")56 or over                    
## relevel(gender_labeled, ref = "Male")Female                               
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Breast                 
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Ear, nose, or throat   
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Gynecologic          . 
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Hand                   
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: other    **
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Orthopedic: spine    **
## relevel(as.factor(surg_cat), ref = "Hernia repair")Urologic               
## opioid_dose                                                               
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydrocodone       
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Hydromorphone     
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Other             
## relevel(as.factor(opioid_prescribed), ref = "Oxycodone")Percocet          
## ---
## Signif. codes:  0 '***' 0.001 '**' 0.01 '*' 0.05 '.' 0.1 ' ' 1
## 
## Residual standard error: 15.56 on 50 degrees of freedom
##   (101 observations deleted due to missingness)
## Multiple R-squared:  0.3961, Adjusted R-squared:  0.1908 
## F-statistic: 1.929 on 17 and 50 DF,  p-value: 0.03704

0.7.2 Plot of effects expressed as odds ratios


0.8 Summary statistic plots

0.8.1 Plots summarizing oxycodone quantity prescribed

0.8.2 Plots summarizing product of morphine milligram equivalent x pill quantity (ie, total opioid prescribed):

0.8.3 Plot summarizing reasons for not using packet

0.8.4 Plot summarizing number of pills disposed

0.8.5 Plot summarizing past disposal behavior


0.9 Plot to summarize evidence for number of patients with unused opioids after surgery and factors influencing disposal (Draper et al. (2022); Bicket et al. (2017))