Methods 1, Week 3

Outline

  • In-class analysis overview

  • Homework review

  • Joining data

  • Summary statistics

  • Simple visualization

  • Assignment 3

In-class Analysis

Explore the level of economic inequality in school districts across New York State.

  • What is the difference between the student poverty rate in each school district and:
    • the poverty rate of the county as a whole?
    • the poverty rate of the state as a whole?
  • What counties have the most economic inequality, as measured by the student poverty rate of school districts?

New York School Districts and Counties

Poverty Rate Guidelines, 2019

source

Analysis plan

  • Create dataframe of student poverty rate by school district in 2019
    • Homework assignment 2b
  • Create dataframe of poverty rate by county in 2019
    • Homework assignment 2c
  • Calculate the statewide student poverty rate
  • Measure the difference in the student poverty rate of each school district and
    1. the county poverty rate
    2. the state poverty rate
  • Use summary statistics to explore and increase understanding
  • Use visualizations to explore and increase understanding

Analysis steps

  • Script 1. Process data
    • Create dataframe of student poverty rate by school district
  • Script 2. Process data
    • Create dataframe of poverty rate by county
  • Script 3. Create analysis dataframe
    • Calculate statewide student poverty rate
    • Join county poverty dataframe to school district data
    • Create new variables
      • difference from county rate = district poverty rate - county poverty rate
      • difference from state rate = district poverty rate - state poverty rate
    • Calculate summary statistics
  • Script 4. Visualize and explore your analysis dataframe

Open Assignment 2b: Process school district poverty rate

Open your script 2019 student poverty script from homework new_york_student_poverty_2019_your_name.R

We’re going to:

  • go through the whole script so you can correct any errors
  • remove the filter and overwrite your homework dataset
    • We want to include all districts, even those with fewer than 100 students
  • convert our id field into a text string

Student poverty rate by school district

# Create dataframe of school district poverty rate

library(tidyverse)
# import raw student poverty dataset
raw_stpov19 <- read_csv("data/raw/ny_student_poverty_2019.csv")

# create new dataframe from raw_stpov19 to process the data
stpov19 <- raw_stpov19 |>
  rename(Estimated_Pop_5_17 = `Estimated Population 5-17`) |> 
  mutate(stud_pov_rate = Estimated_relevant_5_17_in_poverty/Estimated_Pop_5_17,
         year = "2019",
         CONUM = as.character(CONUM)) |> 
  select(Postal, County, CONUM, district_id, Name, Estimated_Total_Pop, Estimated_Pop_5_17,
         Estimated_relevant_5_17_in_poverty, stud_pov_rate, year) |>
  # remove filter for now so that we have all school districts
  # filter(Estimated_Pop_5_17 >= 100) |> 
  rename(district = Name,
         id = district_id,
         tpop = Estimated_Total_Pop,
         stpop = Estimated_Pop_5_17,
         stpov = Estimated_relevant_5_17_in_poverty,
         stpovrate = stud_pov_rate)

# write out school district poverty rate
write_csv(stpov19, "data/processed/school_district_student_pov_rate_2019.csv")

Notice

Notice

  • If there are spaces in a variable name, you need to wrap it in back ticks ` - back ticks - “``” are the symbol underneath the “~” on your keyboard
  • You can redefine the data type of a column for example:
    • as.character()
    • as.numeric()

Open Assignment 2c: Poverty rate by county

Open your script 2019 county poverty script from homework ny_county_poverty_rate_19_you_name.R

We’re going to:

  • go through the whole script so you can correct any errors
  • add a county_pov variable to hold the number of people living in poverty
  • create a simplified the county id number using the substr() function
    • the substring function selects part of a text string

Poverty rate by county

# Processing and exploring the 2019 poverty data from the American Community Survey for New York

library(tidyverse)

# import the county poverty rate dataset
raw_county_pov19 <- read_csv("data/raw/nhgis0042_csv/county_poverty_2019.csv") 

## variable definition from metadata in "data/raw/nhgis0042_csv/county_poverty_2019_codebook.txt"
# ALWVE001:    Total Population
# ALWVE002:    Under .50 (Population living at less than 50% of poverty level)
# ALWVE003:    .50 to .99 (Population living at 50% to 99% of poverty level)

## process the data to create New York poverty rate dataset
county_pov_19 <- raw_county_pov19 |> 
  select(STATE, COUNTY, GEOID, ALWVE001, ALWVE002, ALWVE003) |> 
  filter(STATE == "New York") |> 
  rename(county_pop = ALWVE001) |> 
  mutate(county_pov = ALWVE002 + ALWVE003,
         county_pov_rate = county_pov/county_pop,
         # use the substring function to select the county number from the GEOID
         CONUM = substr(GEOID, 8, 13)) |> 
  select(STATE, COUNTY, CONUM, county_pop, county_pov, county_pov_rate) 

# write out county poverty rate
write_csv(county_pov_19, "data/processed/county_pov_rate_2019.csv")

Notice

Notice

  • Use the substr() function to select text by index
    • substr(column_name, start, stop)

Script 3. Create analysis dataframe


Create a new script named analyze_ny_poverty.R

  • list the analysis steps (with a hash before every line so that it doesn’t run)
# Create analysis dataframe

library(tidyverse)
# Import processed dataframes
# Calculate state-wide student poverty rate
# Join county poverty dataframe to school district data
# Create new variables 
### difference from county rate = district poverty rate - county poverty rate
### difference from state rate = district poverty rate - state poverty rate
# Calculate summary statistics of poverty rate

Script 3. import data

Import your 2 processed datasets

# Create analysis dataframe
library(tidyverse)

# Import processed dataframes
county_pov_19 <- read_csv("data/processed/county_pov_rate_2019.csv")
stpov19 <- read_csv("data/processed/school_district_student_pov_rate_2019.csv")

# Calculate the state-wide poverty rate
# Join county poverty dataframe to school district data
# Create new variables 
### difference from county rate = district poverty rate - county poverty rate
### difference from state rate = district poverty rate - state poverty rate
# Calculate summary statistics of poverty rate
STATE COUNTY CONUM county_pop county_pov county_pov_rate
New York Albany County 36001 291149 34570 0.1187365
New York Allegany County 36003 41742 7047 0.1688228


Postal County CONUM id district tpop stpop stpov stpovrate year
NY Steuben County 36101 3602370 Addison Central School District 6856 1210 283 0.2338843 2019
NY Oneida County 36065 3605040 Adirondack Central School District 8424 1346 189 0.1404160 2019

State-wide poverty rate

# Create analysis dataframe
library(tidyverse)

# Import processed dataframes
county_pov_19 <- read_csv("data/processed/county_pov_rate_2019.csv")
stpov19 <- read_csv("data/processed/school_district_student_pov_rate_2019.csv")

# Calculate the state-wide poverty rate
state_stpovrate = sum(county_pov_19$county_pov)/sum(county_pov_19$county_pop)

# Join county poverty dataframe to school district data
# Create new variables 
### difference from county rate = district poverty rate - county poverty rate
### difference from state rate = district poverty rate - state poverty rate
# Calculate summary statistics of poverty rate

Notice

Notice

  • to calculate the statewide poverty rate:
    • add all of the people living in poverty statewide with the sum() function
    • add all of the people statewide with the sum() function
    • divide to calculate poverty rate: people living in poverty statewide / people statewide
  • the statewide poverty rate is a value, not a dataframe
  • to call a column use dataframe_name$column_name
    • the dollar sign after a dataframe means column

Consider how to connect school districts and counties

  • To connect two dataframes, you need at least one id variable that is in both dataframes - called a key.

County dataframe

STATE COUNTY CONUM county_pop county_pov county_pov_rate
New York Albany County 36001 291149 34570 0.1187365
New York Allegany County 36003 41742 7047 0.1688228


School district dataframe

Postal County CONUM id district tpop stpop stpov stpovrate year
NY Albany County 36001 3602460 Albany City School District 98257 10895 2897 0.2659018 2019
NY Orleans County 36073 3602520 Albion Central School District 14487 1847 354 0.1916622 2019


  • These two datasets do have a common key.

Script 3. left join

Join the county data to the school district poverty data

# Create analysis dataframe
library(tidyverse)

# Import processed dataframes
county_pov_19 <- read_csv("data/processed/county_pov_rate_2019.csv")
stpov19 <- read_csv("data/processed/school_district_student_pov_rate_2019.csv")

# Calculate the state-wide poverty rate
state_stpovrate = sum(county_pov_19$county_pov)/sum(county_pov_19$county_pop)

# Create a copy of the school district  dataframe and join the county poverty dataframe to to it
sd_county_pov <- stpov19 |> 
  left_join(county_pov_19, by = "CONUM")

# Create new variables 
### difference from county rate = district poverty rate - county poverty rate
### difference from state rate = district poverty rate - state poverty rate
# Calculate summary statistics of poverty rate

Notice

Notice

  • The by = argument indicates which variable to connect the two dataframes
  • If the key variable has a different name in the two dataframes
    • use by = c("CONUM"="GEOID")
  • If the key variable has the same name in the two dataframes
    • use by = "CONUM"

Joins explained

When you join two dataframes together, you need to think about which one is your primary table.

In the school district - county example:

  • Each school district has 1 county
  • Each county has many school districts

We want to keep all of the school district rows and add a column with the county poverty rate. So we:

  • create a new dataframe from the school districts
  • use a left_join() to add the county data to the school district data based on county id.
# sd_county_pov <- sd_pov |> 
#   left_join(county_pov, by = "CONUM")

Types of joins

We will discuss this more later! For now, just know that there are other types of joins.

Script 3 - Select your variables

# Create analysis dataframe
library(tidyverse)

# Import processed dataframes
county_pov_19 <- read_csv("data/processed/county_pov_rate_2019.csv")
stpov19 <- read_csv("data/processed/school_district_student_pov_rate_2019.csv")

# Calculate state-wide student poverty rate
state_stpovrate = sum(county_pov_19$county_pov)/sum(county_pov_19$county_pop)

# Join county poverty dataframe to school district data
# Create a copy of the school district  dataframe and join the county poverty dataframe to to it
sd_county_pov <- stpov19 |> 
  left_join(county_pov_19, by = "CONUM") |> 
  select(id, district, COUNTY, CONUM, tpop, stpop, 
         stpovrate, county_pop, county_pov_rate) 

# Create new variables 
### difference from county rate = district poverty rate - county poverty rate
### difference from state rate = district poverty rate - state poverty rate
# Calculate summary statistics of poverty rate

Script 3 - Calculate poverty rate difference

# Create analysis dataframe
library(tidyverse)

# Import processed dataframes
county_pov_19 <- read_csv("data/processed/county_pov_rate_2019.csv")
stpov19 <- read_csv("data/processed/school_district_student_pov_rate_2019.csv")

# Calculate the state-wide poverty rate
state_stpovrate = sum(county_pov_19$county_pov)/sum(county_pov_19$county_pop)

# Join county poverty dataframe to school district data
# Create a copy of the school district  dataframe and join the county poverty dataframe to to it
sd_county_pov <- stpov19 |> 
  left_join(county_pov_19, by = "CONUM") |> 
  select(id, district, COUNTY, CONUM, tpop, stpop, stpov,
         stpovrate, county_pop, county_pov_rate) |> 
  mutate(pov_diff_county = round(stpovrate - county_pov_rate, 3),
         pov_diff_state = round(stpovrate - state_stpovrate, 3))

write_csv(sd_county_pov, "data/processed/ny_sd_county_pov_data.csv")
# Calculate summary statistics of poverty rate

Analysis dataframe created

selected columns from the analysis dataframe:

district COUNTY stpop stpovrate county_pov_rate pov_diff_county pov_diff_state
Addison Central School District Steuben County 1210 0.2338843 0.1369303 0.097 0.093
Adirondack Central School District Oneida County 1346 0.1404160 0.1547234 -0.014 0.000
Afton Central School District Chenango County 583 0.1972556 0.1353454 0.062 0.057
Akron Central School District Erie County 1503 0.0951430 0.1419954 -0.047 -0.046
Albany City School District Albany County 10895 0.2659018 0.1187365 0.147 0.125
Albion Central School District Orleans County 1847 0.1916622 0.1372050 0.054 0.051
Alden Central School District Erie County 1817 0.0731976 0.1419954 -0.069 -0.067
Alexander Central School District Genesee County 834 0.0779376 0.1087335 -0.031 -0.063
Alexandria Central School District Jefferson County 560 0.1267857 0.1401767 -0.013 -0.014
Alfred-Almond Central School District Allegany County 575 0.2034783 0.1688228 0.035 0.063
Allegany-Limestone Central School District Cattaraugus County 1198 0.1385643 0.1650263 -0.026 -0.002
Altmar-Parish-Williamstown Central School District Oswego County 1217 0.1848809 0.1700055 0.015 0.044
Amagansett Union Free School District Suffolk County 155 0.0451613 0.0687418 -0.024 -0.095
Amherst Central School District Erie County 3388 0.1077332 0.1419954 -0.034 -0.033
Amityville Union Free School District Suffolk County 3498 0.1277873 0.0687418 0.059 -0.013
Amsterdam City School District Montgomery County 3933 0.2684973 0.1977416 0.071 0.128
Andes Central School District Delaware County 95 0.1263158 0.1658030 -0.039 -0.014
Andover Central School District Allegany County 370 0.2000000 0.1688228 0.031 0.059
Ardsley Union Free School District Westchester County 1882 0.0180659 0.0883991 -0.070 -0.123
Argyle Central School District Washington County 555 0.1117117 0.1129600 -0.001 -0.029
Arkport Central School District Steuben County 472 0.1588983 0.1369303 0.022 0.018
Arlington Central School District Dutchess County 8788 0.0640646 0.0904110 -0.026 -0.077
Attica Central School District Wyoming County 1451 0.0882150 0.1047348 -0.017 -0.052
AuSable Valley Central School District Clinton County 1143 0.1242345 0.1500062 -0.026 -0.016
Auburn City School District Cayuga County 4273 0.2251346 0.1209675 0.104 0.084
Averill Park Central School District Rensselaer County 3245 0.0533128 0.1170876 -0.064 -0.087
Avoca Central School District Steuben County 577 0.1490468 0.1369303 0.012 0.008
Avon Central School District Livingston County 958 0.0908142 0.1317511 -0.041 -0.050
Babylon Union Free School District Suffolk County 1652 0.0369249 0.0687418 -0.032 -0.104
Bainbridge-Guilford Central School District Chenango County 735 0.1469388 0.1353454 0.012 0.006
Baldwin Union Free School District Nassau County 5603 0.0605033 0.0555672 0.005 -0.080
Baldwinsville Central School District Onondaga County 5765 0.0737207 0.1411194 -0.067 -0.067
Ballston Spa Central School District Saratoga County 4195 0.0803337 0.0584428 0.022 -0.060
Barker Central School District Niagara County 879 0.1433447 0.1345573 0.009 0.003
Batavia City School District Genesee County 2484 0.1646538 0.1087335 0.056 0.024
Bath Central School District Steuben County 1498 0.1955941 0.1369303 0.059 0.055
Bay Shore Union Free School District Suffolk County 5222 0.1014937 0.0687418 0.033 -0.039
Bayport-Blue Point Union Free School District Suffolk County 2280 0.0337719 0.0687418 -0.035 -0.107
Beacon City School District Dutchess County 2991 0.0899365 0.0904110 0.000 -0.051
Beaver River Central School District Lewis County 936 0.1773504 0.1347545 0.043 0.037
Bedford Central School District Westchester County 4933 0.0833164 0.0883991 -0.005 -0.057
Beekmantown Central School District Clinton County 1890 0.1518519 0.1500062 0.002 0.011
Belfast Central School District Allegany County 352 0.3153409 0.1688228 0.147 0.175
Belleville Henderson Central School District Jefferson County 507 0.2544379 0.1401767 0.114 0.114
Bellmore Union Free School District Nassau County 1069 0.0280636 0.0555672 -0.028 -0.113
Bellmore-Merrick Central High School District Nassau County 6125 0.0204082 0.0555672 -0.035 -0.120
Bemus Point Central School District Chautauqua County 714 0.0882353 0.1819851 -0.094 -0.052
Berlin Central School District Rensselaer County 968 0.1291322 0.1170876 0.012 -0.012
Berne-Knox-Westerlo Central School District Albany County 988 0.0829960 0.1187365 -0.036 -0.058
Bethlehem Central School District Albany County 5067 0.0434182 0.1187365 -0.075 -0.097
Bethpage Union Free School District Nassau County 3005 0.0312812 0.0555672 -0.024 -0.109
Binghamton City School District Broome County 5852 0.3696172 0.1741052 0.196 0.229
Binghamton Common School District Broome County 76 0.0789474 0.1741052 -0.095 -0.062
Blind Brook-Rye Union Free School District Westchester County 1435 0.0271777 0.0883991 -0.061 -0.113
Bolivar-Richburg Central School District Allegany County 714 0.2310924 0.1688228 0.062 0.090
Bolton Central School District Warren County 225 0.0533333 0.0947304 -0.041 -0.087
Boquet Valley Central School District at Elizabethtown-Lewis-Westport Essex County 470 0.1553191 0.0987296 0.057 0.015
Bradford Central School District Schuyler County 287 0.2125436 0.1539551 0.059 0.072
Brasher Falls Central School District St. Lawrence County 1043 0.2272291 0.1786742 0.049 0.087
Brentwood Union Free School District Suffolk County 14062 0.1464941 0.0687418 0.078 0.006
Brewster Central School District Putnam County 3178 0.0695406 0.0498089 0.020 -0.071
Briarcliff Manor Union Free School District Westchester County 1555 0.0154341 0.0883991 -0.073 -0.125
Bridgehampton Union Free School District Suffolk County 146 0.0205479 0.0687418 -0.048 -0.120
Brighton Central School District Monroe County 3578 0.0612074 0.1439197 -0.083 -0.079
Broadalbin-Perth Central School District Fulton County 1741 0.1309592 0.1490226 -0.018 -0.010
Brockport Central School District Monroe County 3814 0.1106450 0.1439197 -0.033 -0.030
Brocton Central School District Chautauqua County 636 0.2657233 0.1819851 0.084 0.125
Bronxville Union Free School District Westchester County 1430 0.0503497 0.0883991 -0.038 -0.090
Brookfield Central School District Madison County 230 0.1434783 0.0977792 0.046 0.003
Brookhaven-Comsewogue Union Free School District Suffolk County 3477 0.1219442 0.0687418 0.053 -0.019
Brunswick Central School District (Brittonkill) Rensselaer County 1251 0.0919265 0.1170876 -0.025 -0.049
Brushton-Moira Central School District Franklin County 831 0.2503008 0.1777902 0.073 0.110
Buffalo City School District Erie County 39847 0.3808317 0.1419954 0.239 0.240
Burnt Hills-Ballston Lake Central School District Saratoga County 3312 0.0452899 0.0584428 -0.013 -0.095
Byram Hills Central School District Westchester County 2701 0.0281377 0.0883991 -0.060 -0.113
Byron-Bergen Central School District Genesee County 1046 0.0956023 0.1087335 -0.013 -0.045
Cairo-Durham Central School District Greene County 1140 0.2017544 0.1399206 0.062 0.061
Caledonia-Mumford Central School District Livingston County 857 0.1096849 0.1317511 -0.022 -0.031
Cambridge Central School District Washington County 903 0.1162791 0.1129600 0.003 -0.024
Camden Central School District Oneida County 2328 0.1108247 0.1547234 -0.044 -0.030
Campbell-Savona Central School District Steuben County 930 0.2064516 0.1369303 0.070 0.066
Canajoharie Central School District Montgomery County 1070 0.2299065 0.1977416 0.032 0.089
Canandaigua City School District Ontario County 3797 0.0829602 0.0866414 -0.004 -0.058
Canaseraga Central School District Allegany County 256 0.2148438 0.1688228 0.046 0.074
Canastota Central School District Madison County 1443 0.1275121 0.0977792 0.030 -0.013
Candor Central School District Tioga County 795 0.1018868 0.1015274 0.000 -0.039
Canisteo-Greenwood Central School District Steuben County 880 0.1715909 0.1369303 0.035 0.031
Canton Central School District St. Lawrence County 1343 0.1496649 0.1786742 -0.029 0.009
Carle Place Union Free School District Nassau County 1376 0.0595930 0.0555672 0.004 -0.081
Carmel Central School District Putnam County 4185 0.0508961 0.0498089 0.001 -0.090
Carthage Central School District Jefferson County 3229 0.1387426 0.1401767 -0.001 -0.002
Cassadaga Valley Central School District Chautauqua County 1027 0.1635833 0.1819851 -0.018 0.023
Cato-Meridian Central School District Cayuga County 919 0.1653972 0.1209675 0.044 0.025
Catskill Central School District Greene County 1484 0.1826146 0.1399206 0.043 0.042
Cattaraugus-Little Valley Central School District Cattaraugus County 1117 0.1584602 0.1650263 -0.007 0.018
Cazenovia Central School District Madison County 1580 0.0664557 0.0977792 -0.031 -0.074
Center Moriches Union Free School District Suffolk County 1205 0.0539419 0.0687418 -0.015 -0.087
Central Islip Union Free School District Suffolk County 5792 0.1519337 0.0687418 0.083 0.011
Central Square Central School District Oswego County 4068 0.1519174 0.1700055 -0.018 0.011
Central Valley School District Herkimer County 2233 0.1791312 0.1363726 0.043 0.038
Chappaqua Central School District Westchester County 3930 0.0218830 0.0883991 -0.067 -0.119
Charlotte Valley Central School District Delaware County 391 0.1815857 0.1658030 0.016 0.041
Chateaugay Central School District Franklin County 539 0.1743970 0.1777902 -0.003 0.034
Chatham Central School District Columbia County 1175 0.1046809 0.1157255 -0.011 -0.036
Chautauqua Lake Central School District Chautauqua County 772 0.1645078 0.1819851 -0.017 0.024
Chazy Union Free School District Clinton County 445 0.0966292 0.1500062 -0.053 -0.044
Cheektowaga Central School District Erie County 2552 0.2061129 0.1419954 0.064 0.065
Cheektowaga-Maryvale Union Free School District Erie County 2231 0.1698790 0.1419954 0.028 0.029
Cheektowaga-Sloan Union Free School District Erie County 1459 0.1761480 0.1419954 0.034 0.035
Chenango Forks Central School District Broome County 1560 0.1467949 0.1741052 -0.027 0.006
Chenango Valley Central School District Broome County 1767 0.1528014 0.1741052 -0.021 0.012
Cherry Valley-Springfield Central School District Otsego County 494 0.2044534 0.1486627 0.056 0.064
Chester Union Free School District Orange County 1104 0.0824275 0.1164923 -0.034 -0.058
Chittenango Central School District Madison County 2007 0.0792227 0.0977792 -0.019 -0.061
Churchville-Chili Central School District Monroe County 4261 0.0891809 0.1439197 -0.055 -0.051
Cincinnatus Central School District Cortland County 620 0.2290323 0.1640128 0.065 0.088
Clarence Central School District Erie County 5234 0.0724112 0.1419954 -0.070 -0.068
Clarkstown Central School District Rockland County 9794 0.0480907 0.1387053 -0.091 -0.093
Cleveland Hill Union Free School District Erie County 1568 0.1702806 0.1419954 0.028 0.030
Clifton-Fine Central School District St. Lawrence County 322 0.2173913 0.1786742 0.039 0.077
Clinton Central School District Oneida County 1418 0.1050776 0.1547234 -0.050 -0.036
Clyde-Savannah Central School District Wayne County 866 0.1974596 0.1161587 0.081 0.057
Clymer Central School District Chautauqua County 599 0.1769616 0.1819851 -0.005 0.036
Cobleskill-Richmondville Central School District Schoharie County 1755 0.1566952 0.1210375 0.036 0.016
Cohoes City School District Albany County 1988 0.2047284 0.1187365 0.086 0.064
Cold Spring Harbor Central School District Suffolk County 1925 0.0316883 0.0687418 -0.037 -0.109
Colton-Pierrepont Central School District St. Lawrence County 318 0.1823899 0.1786742 0.004 0.042
Commack Union Free School District Suffolk County 6699 0.0246305 0.0687418 -0.044 -0.116
Connetquot Central School District Suffolk County 5879 0.0437149 0.0687418 -0.025 -0.097
Cooperstown Central School District Otsego County 827 0.1209190 0.1486627 -0.028 -0.020
Copenhagen Central School District Lewis County 457 0.1750547 0.1347545 0.040 0.034
Copiague Union Free School District Suffolk County 4322 0.1439149 0.0687418 0.075 0.003
Corinth Central School District Saratoga County 1196 0.1505017 0.0584428 0.092 0.010
Corning City School District Steuben County 5118 0.1201641 0.1369303 -0.017 -0.020
Cornwall Central School District Orange County 3485 0.0622669 0.1164923 -0.054 -0.078
Cortland City School District Cortland County 2657 0.2021076 0.1640128 0.038 0.061
Coxsackie-Athens Central School District Greene County 1383 0.1062907 0.1399206 -0.034 -0.034
Croton-Harmon Union Free School District Westchester County 1771 0.0282326 0.0883991 -0.060 -0.112
Crown Point Central School District Essex County 222 0.1531532 0.0987296 0.054 0.013
Cuba-Rushford Central School District Allegany County 932 0.2414163 0.1688228 0.073 0.101
Dalton-Nunda Central School District (Keshequa) Livingston County 771 0.1686122 0.1317511 0.037 0.028
Dansville Central School District Livingston County 1483 0.1975725 0.1317511 0.066 0.057
DeRuyter Central School District Madison County 416 0.2139423 0.0977792 0.116 0.073
Deer Park Union Free School District Suffolk County 3808 0.0803571 0.0687418 0.012 -0.060
Delhi Central School District Delaware County 688 0.1438953 0.1658030 -0.022 0.003
Depew Union Free School District Erie County 2098 0.1601525 0.1419954 0.018 0.020
Deposit Central School District Delaware County 575 0.1947826 0.1658030 0.029 0.054
Dobbs Ferry Union Free School District Westchester County 1659 0.0319470 0.0883991 -0.056 -0.109
Dolgeville Central School District Herkimer County 862 0.1867749 0.1363726 0.050 0.046
Dover Union Free School District Dutchess County 1448 0.1422652 0.0904110 0.052 0.002
Downsville Central School District Delaware County 263 0.1558935 0.1658030 -0.010 0.015
Dryden Central School District Tompkins County 1949 0.1385326 0.1889363 -0.050 -0.002
Duanesburg Central School District Schenectady County 866 0.0785219 0.1144935 -0.036 -0.062
Dundee Central School District Yates County 1198 0.3046745 0.1190616 0.186 0.164
Dunkirk City School District Chautauqua County 1885 0.3326260 0.1819851 0.151 0.192
East Aurora Union Free School District Erie County 2134 0.0407685 0.1419954 -0.101 -0.100
East Bloomfield Central School District Ontario County 998 0.0861723 0.0866414 0.000 -0.054
East Greenbush Central School District Rensselaer County 4388 0.0565178 0.1170876 -0.061 -0.084
East Hampton Union Free School District Suffolk County 1079 0.0917516 0.0687418 0.023 -0.049
East Irondequoit Central School District Monroe County 3252 0.1752768 0.1439197 0.031 0.035
East Islip Union Free School District Suffolk County 4246 0.0355629 0.0687418 -0.033 -0.105
East Meadow Union Free School District Nassau County 7534 0.0423414 0.0555672 -0.013 -0.098
East Moriches Union Free School District Suffolk County 899 0.0444939 0.0687418 -0.024 -0.096
East Quogue Union Free School District Suffolk County 737 0.0678426 0.0687418 -0.001 -0.073
East Ramapo Central School District (Spring Valley) Rockland County 28654 0.3423606 0.1387053 0.204 0.202
East Rochester Union Free School District Monroe County 1202 0.1247920 0.1439197 -0.019 -0.016
East Rockaway Union Free School District Nassau County 1386 0.0454545 0.0555672 -0.010 -0.095
East Syracuse-Minoa Central School District Onondaga County 3148 0.1051461 0.1411194 -0.036 -0.036
East Williston Union Free School District Nassau County 1839 0.0315389 0.0555672 -0.024 -0.109
Eastchester Union Free School District Westchester County 3030 0.0247525 0.0883991 -0.064 -0.116
Eastport-South Manor Central School District Suffolk County 3413 0.0542045 0.0687418 -0.015 -0.086
Eden Central School District Erie County 1661 0.0608067 0.1419954 -0.081 -0.080
Edgemont Union Free School District Westchester County 1664 0.0294471 0.0883991 -0.059 -0.111
Edinburg Common School District Saratoga County 145 0.1379310 0.0584428 0.079 -0.003
Edmeston Central School District Otsego County 395 0.2354430 0.1486627 0.087 0.095
Edwards-Knox Central School District St. Lawrence County 562 0.1761566 0.1786742 -0.003 0.036
Elba Central School District Genesee County 446 0.0919283 0.1087335 -0.017 -0.049
Eldred Central School District Sullivan County 729 0.1440329 0.1515181 -0.007 0.003
Ellenville Central School District Ulster County 1591 0.2093023 0.1379147 0.071 0.069
Ellicottville Central School District Cattaraugus County 497 0.1307847 0.1650263 -0.034 -0.010
Elmira City School District Chemung County 6928 0.2479792 0.1387266 0.109 0.107
Elmira Heights Central School District Chemung County 1011 0.1839763 0.1387266 0.045 0.043
Elmont Union Free School District Nassau County 3969 0.0866717 0.0555672 0.031 -0.054
Elmsford Union Free School District Westchester County 1155 0.0874459 0.0883991 -0.001 -0.053
Elwood Union Free School District Suffolk County 2397 0.0471423 0.0687418 -0.022 -0.094
Evans-Brant Central School District (Lake Shore) Erie County 2653 0.1560498 0.1419954 0.014 0.015
Fabius-Pompey Central School District Onondaga County 827 0.0725514 0.1411194 -0.069 -0.068
Fairport Central School District Monroe County 6678 0.0705301 0.1439197 -0.073 -0.070
Falconer Central School District Chautauqua County 1058 0.1776938 0.1819851 -0.004 0.037
Fallsburg Central School District Sullivan County 1586 0.2723834 0.1515181 0.121 0.132
Farmingdale Union Free School District Nassau County 6027 0.0496101 0.0555672 -0.006 -0.091
Fayetteville-Manlius Central School District Onondaga County 4622 0.0350498 0.1411194 -0.106 -0.106
Fillmore Central School District Allegany County 772 0.2823834 0.1688228 0.114 0.142
Fire Island Union Free School District Suffolk County 43 0.0930233 0.0687418 0.024 -0.048
Fishers Island Union Free School District Suffolk County 29 0.0000000 0.0687418 -0.069 -0.141
Floral Park-Bellerose Union Free School District Nassau County 1656 0.0289855 0.0555672 -0.027 -0.112
Florida Union Free School District Orange County 940 0.0787234 0.1164923 -0.038 -0.062
Fonda-Fultonville Central School District Montgomery County 1440 0.1513889 0.1977416 -0.046 0.011
Forestville Central School District Chautauqua County 499 0.1563126 0.1819851 -0.026 0.016
Fort Ann Central School District Washington County 483 0.1490683 0.1129600 0.036 0.008
Fort Edward Union Free School District Washington County 470 0.1638298 0.1129600 0.051 0.023
Fort Plain Central School District Montgomery County 1067 0.2614808 0.1977416 0.064 0.121
Frankfort-Schuyler Central School District Herkimer County 1176 0.1598639 0.1363726 0.023 0.019
Franklin Central School District Delaware County 243 0.1563786 0.1658030 -0.009 0.016
Franklin Square Union Free School District Nassau County 1899 0.0463402 0.0555672 -0.009 -0.094
Franklinville Central School District Cattaraugus County 718 0.2172702 0.1650263 0.052 0.077
Fredonia Central School District Chautauqua County 1412 0.1529745 0.1819851 -0.029 0.012
Freeport Union Free School District Nassau County 6169 0.1288702 0.0555672 0.073 -0.012
Frewsburg Central School District Chautauqua County 746 0.1394102 0.1819851 -0.043 -0.001
Friendship Central School District Allegany County 364 0.2884615 0.1688228 0.120 0.148
Frontier Central School District Erie County 5359 0.0815451 0.1419954 -0.060 -0.059
Fulton City School District Oswego County 3250 0.2393846 0.1700055 0.069 0.099
Galway Central School District Saratoga County 1109 0.0703336 0.0584428 0.012 -0.070
Gananda Central School District Wayne County 1089 0.0523416 0.1161587 -0.064 -0.088
Garden City Union Free School District Nassau County 4298 0.0146580 0.0555672 -0.041 -0.126
Garrison Union Free School District Putnam County 333 0.0390390 0.0498089 -0.011 -0.102
Gates-Chili Central School District Monroe County 4536 0.1291887 0.1439197 -0.015 -0.011
General Brown Central School District Jefferson County 1443 0.2418572 0.1401767 0.102 0.101
Genesee Valley Central School District Allegany County 596 0.2399329 0.1688228 0.071 0.099
Geneseo Central School District Livingston County 918 0.1917211 0.1317511 0.060 0.051
Geneva City School District Ontario County 2297 0.1758816 0.0866414 0.089 0.035
Georgetown-South Otselic Central School District Chenango County 453 0.1633554 0.1353454 0.028 0.023
Germantown Central School District Columbia County 496 0.0947581 0.1157255 -0.021 -0.046
Gilbertsville-Mount Upton Central School District Otsego County 383 0.1644909 0.1486627 0.016 0.024
Gilboa-Conesville Central School District Schoharie County 322 0.1521739 0.1210375 0.031 0.012
Glen Cove City School District Nassau County 3636 0.1039604 0.0555672 0.048 -0.037
Glens Falls City School District Warren County 1885 0.1543767 0.0947304 0.060 0.014
Glens Falls Common School District Warren County 306 0.2614379 0.0947304 0.167 0.121
Gloversville City School District Fulton County 2871 0.3092999 0.1490226 0.160 0.169
Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman) Ontario County 1608 0.1809701 0.0866414 0.094 0.040
Goshen Central School District Orange County 3260 0.0723926 0.1164923 -0.044 -0.068
Gouverneur Central School District St. Lawrence County 1700 0.2529412 0.1786742 0.074 0.112
Gowanda Central School District Cattaraugus County 1421 0.2104152 0.1650263 0.045 0.070
Grand Island Central School District Erie County 3358 0.0592615 0.1419954 -0.083 -0.081
Granville Central School District Washington County 1158 0.1666667 0.1129600 0.054 0.026
Great Neck Union Free School District Nassau County 7117 0.0560629 0.0555672 0.000 -0.085
Greece Central School District Monroe County 12136 0.1428807 0.1439197 -0.001 0.002
Green Island Union Free School District Albany County 304 0.2236842 0.1187365 0.105 0.083
Greenburgh Central School District Westchester County 2467 0.0753952 0.0883991 -0.013 -0.065
Greene Central School District Chenango County 1025 0.1248780 0.1353454 -0.010 -0.016
Greenport Union Free School District Suffolk County 434 0.1612903 0.0687418 0.093 0.021
Greenville Central School District Greene County 1146 0.1143106 0.1399206 -0.026 -0.026
Greenwich Central School District Washington County 978 0.1022495 0.1129600 -0.011 -0.038
Greenwood Lake Union Free School District Orange County 900 0.0644444 0.1164923 -0.052 -0.076
Groton Central School District Tompkins County 946 0.1754757 0.1889363 -0.013 0.035
Guilderland Central School District Albany County 5178 0.0502124 0.1187365 -0.069 -0.090
Hadley-Luzerne Central School District Warren County 848 0.1202830 0.0947304 0.026 -0.020
Haldane Central School District Putnam County 742 0.0619946 0.0498089 0.012 -0.079
Half Hollow Hills Central School District Suffolk County 8793 0.0417377 0.0687418 -0.027 -0.099
Hamburg Central School District Erie County 3982 0.0509794 0.1419954 -0.091 -0.090
Hamilton Central School District Madison County 524 0.0763359 0.0977792 -0.021 -0.064
Hammond Central School District St. Lawrence County 296 0.2128378 0.1786742 0.034 0.072
Hammondsport Central School District Steuben County 479 0.1858038 0.1369303 0.049 0.045
Hampton Bays Union Free School District Suffolk County 1752 0.1033105 0.0687418 0.035 -0.037
Hancock Central School District Delaware County 387 0.1653747 0.1658030 0.000 0.025
Hannibal Central School District Oswego County 1406 0.2268848 0.1700055 0.057 0.086
Harborfields Central School District Suffolk County 3313 0.0383338 0.0687418 -0.030 -0.102
Harpursville Central School District Broome County 843 0.1969158 0.1741052 0.023 0.056
Harrison Central School District Westchester County 4512 0.0511968 0.0883991 -0.037 -0.089
Harrisville Central School District Lewis County 367 0.1280654 0.1347545 -0.007 -0.013
Hartford Central School District Washington County 459 0.1851852 0.1129600 0.072 0.045
Hastings-on-Hudson Union Free School District Westchester County 1677 0.0184854 0.0883991 -0.070 -0.122
Hauppauge Union Free School District Suffolk County 3652 0.0432640 0.0687418 -0.025 -0.097
Haverstraw-Stony Point Central School District (North Rockland) Rockland County 9003 0.1316228 0.1387053 -0.007 -0.009
Hempstead Union Free School District Nassau County 6840 0.1932749 0.0555672 0.138 0.053
Hendrick Hudson Central School District Westchester County 2520 0.0563492 0.0883991 -0.032 -0.084
Herkimer Central School District Herkimer County 1182 0.1996616 0.1363726 0.063 0.059
Hermon-DeKalb Central School District St. Lawrence County 465 0.2021505 0.1786742 0.023 0.061
Herricks Union Free School District Nassau County 4018 0.0340966 0.0555672 -0.021 -0.107
Heuvelton Central School District St. Lawrence County 830 0.3349398 0.1786742 0.156 0.194
Hewlett-Woodmere Union Free School District Nassau County 3690 0.0449864 0.0555672 -0.011 -0.096
Hicksville Union Free School District Nassau County 5693 0.0700861 0.0555672 0.015 -0.071
Highland Central School District Ulster County 1810 0.1298343 0.1379147 -0.008 -0.011
Highland Falls Central School District Orange County 1657 0.0760410 0.1164923 -0.040 -0.065
Hilton Central School District Monroe County 4424 0.0664557 0.1439197 -0.077 -0.074
Hinsdale Central School District Cattaraugus County 452 0.2212389 0.1650263 0.056 0.081
Holland Central School District Erie County 1012 0.0879447 0.1419954 -0.054 -0.053
Holland Patent Central School District Oneida County 1614 0.1078067 0.1547234 -0.047 -0.033
Holley Central School District Orleans County 1054 0.1565465 0.1372050 0.019 0.016
Homer Central School District Cortland County 2064 0.1138566 0.1640128 -0.050 -0.027
Honeoye Central School District Ontario County 761 0.0735874 0.0866414 -0.013 -0.067
Honeoye Falls-Lima Central School District Monroe County 2532 0.1109795 0.1439197 -0.033 -0.030
Hoosic Valley Central School District Rensselaer County 1089 0.0844812 0.1170876 -0.033 -0.056
Hoosick Falls Central School District Rensselaer County 1293 0.2242846 0.1170876 0.107 0.084
Hornell City School District Steuben County 1652 0.2445521 0.1369303 0.108 0.104
Horseheads Central School District Chemung County 4118 0.0881496 0.1387266 -0.051 -0.053
Hudson City School District Columbia County 1720 0.1848837 0.1157255 0.069 0.044
Hudson Falls Central School District Washington County 2073 0.1625663 0.1129600 0.050 0.022
Hunter-Tannersville Central School District Greene County 409 0.3154034 0.1399206 0.175 0.175
Huntington Union Free School District Suffolk County 4792 0.1035058 0.0687418 0.035 -0.037
Hyde Park Central School District Dutchess County 3858 0.1119751 0.0904110 0.022 -0.029
Indian Lake Central School District Hamilton County 114 0.0877193 0.0989060 -0.011 -0.053
Indian River Central School District Jefferson County 3513 0.1833191 0.1401767 0.043 0.043
Inlet Common School District Hamilton County 40 0.1250000 0.0989060 0.026 -0.016
Iroquois Central School District Erie County 2715 0.0541436 0.1419954 -0.088 -0.087
Irvington Union Free School District Westchester County 1823 0.0416895 0.0883991 -0.047 -0.099
Island Park Union Free School District Nassau County 1075 0.0697674 0.0555672 0.014 -0.071
Island Trees Union Free School District Nassau County 2515 0.0429423 0.0555672 -0.013 -0.098
Islip Union Free School District Suffolk County 3078 0.0500325 0.0687418 -0.019 -0.091
Ithaca City School District Tompkins County 5423 0.1108243 0.1889363 -0.078 -0.030
Jamestown City School District Chautauqua County 4766 0.3308854 0.1819851 0.149 0.190
Jamesville-DeWitt Central School District Onondaga County 2926 0.1141490 0.1411194 -0.027 -0.027
Jasper-Troupsburg Central School District Steuben County 772 0.2914508 0.1369303 0.155 0.151
Jefferson Central School District Schoharie County 256 0.1835938 0.1210375 0.063 0.043
Jericho Union Free School District Nassau County 2802 0.0453248 0.0555672 -0.010 -0.095
Johnsburg Central School District Warren County 318 0.1855346 0.0947304 0.091 0.045
Johnson City Central School District Broome County 2515 0.2687873 0.1741052 0.095 0.128
Johnstown City School District Fulton County 1659 0.1711875 0.1490226 0.022 0.031
Jordan-Elbridge Central School District Onondaga County 1428 0.1505602 0.1411194 0.009 0.010
Katonah-Lewisboro Union Free School District Westchester County 3888 0.0241770 0.0883991 -0.064 -0.116
Keene Central School District Essex County 112 0.0535714 0.0987296 -0.045 -0.087
Kendall Central School District Orleans County 750 0.1226667 0.1372050 -0.015 -0.018
Kenmore-Tonawanda Union Free School District Erie County 8885 0.1277434 0.1419954 -0.014 -0.013
Kinderhook Central School District (Ichabod Crane) Columbia County 1827 0.0788177 0.1157255 -0.037 -0.062
Kings Park Central School District Suffolk County 3760 0.0526596 0.0687418 -0.016 -0.088
Kingston City School District Ulster County 6540 0.1587156 0.1379147 0.021 0.018
Kiryas Joel Village Union Free School District Orange County 7366 0.5010861 0.1164923 0.385 0.360
La Fargeville Central School District Jefferson County 585 0.1811966 0.1401767 0.041 0.041
LaFayette Central School District Onondaga County 656 0.1143293 0.1411194 -0.027 -0.026
Lackawanna City School District Erie County 2525 0.3667327 0.1419954 0.225 0.226
Lake George Central School District Warren County 815 0.0773006 0.0947304 -0.017 -0.063
Lake Placid Central School District Essex County 846 0.1182033 0.0987296 0.019 -0.022
Lake Pleasant Central School District Hamilton County 62 0.1935484 0.0989060 0.095 0.053
Lakeland Central School District Westchester County 6225 0.0473896 0.0883991 -0.041 -0.093
Lancaster Central School District Erie County 6333 0.0525817 0.1419954 -0.089 -0.088
Lansing Central School District Tompkins County 1280 0.1007812 0.1889363 -0.088 -0.040
Lansingburgh Central School District Rensselaer County 2575 0.2287379 0.1170876 0.112 0.088
Laurens Central School District Otsego County 313 0.1661342 0.1486627 0.017 0.025
Lawrence Union Free School District Nassau County 6712 0.0750894 0.0555672 0.020 -0.066
Le Roy Central School District Genesee County 1250 0.0856000 0.1087335 -0.023 -0.055
Letchworth Central School District Wyoming County 898 0.1547884 0.1047348 0.050 0.014
Levittown Union Free School District Nassau County 7467 0.0374983 0.0555672 -0.018 -0.103
Lewiston-Porter Central School District Niagara County 2316 0.0777202 0.1345573 -0.057 -0.063
Liberty Central School District Sullivan County 1410 0.2737589 0.1515181 0.122 0.133
Lindenhurst Union Free School District Suffolk County 6182 0.0724685 0.0687418 0.004 -0.068
Lisbon Central School District St. Lawrence County 628 0.1210191 0.1786742 -0.058 -0.020
Little Falls City School District Herkimer County 1091 0.2062328 0.1363726 0.070 0.066
Liverpool Central School District Onondaga County 7227 0.0981043 0.1411194 -0.043 -0.043
Livingston Manor Central School District Sullivan County 515 0.1766990 0.1515181 0.025 0.036
Livonia Central School District Livingston County 1689 0.1042037 0.1317511 -0.028 -0.036
Lockport City School District Niagara County 5120 0.1806641 0.1345573 0.046 0.040
Locust Valley Central School District Nassau County 2718 0.0408389 0.0555672 -0.015 -0.100
Long Beach City School District Nassau County 4305 0.0613240 0.0555672 0.006 -0.079
Long Lake Central School District Hamilton County 42 0.1190476 0.0989060 0.020 -0.022
Longwood Central School District Suffolk County 8579 0.0979135 0.0687418 0.029 -0.043
Lowville Academy and Central School District Lewis County 1460 0.1719178 0.1347545 0.037 0.031
Lyme Central School District Jefferson County 317 0.2050473 0.1401767 0.065 0.064
Lynbrook Union Free School District Nassau County 2849 0.0347490 0.0555672 -0.021 -0.106
Lyncourt Union Free School District Onondaga County 516 0.2189922 0.1411194 0.078 0.078
Lyndonville Central School District Orleans County 634 0.1924290 0.1372050 0.055 0.052
Lyons Central School District Wayne County 896 0.2020089 0.1161587 0.086 0.061
Madison Central School District Madison County 471 0.1507431 0.0977792 0.053 0.010
Madrid-Waddington Central School District St. Lawrence County 694 0.2074928 0.1786742 0.029 0.067
Mahopac Central School District Putnam County 4312 0.0384972 0.0498089 -0.011 -0.102
Maine-Endwell Central School District Broome County 2250 0.1524444 0.1741052 -0.022 0.012
Malone Central School District Franklin County 2403 0.2014149 0.1777902 0.024 0.061
Malverne Union Free School District Nassau County 2294 0.0496949 0.0555672 -0.006 -0.091
Mamaroneck Union Free School District Westchester County 5271 0.0478088 0.0883991 -0.041 -0.093
Manchester-Shortsville Central School District Ontario County 892 0.1042601 0.0866414 0.018 -0.036
Manhasset Union Free School District Nassau County 3306 0.0299456 0.0555672 -0.026 -0.111
Marathon Central School District Cortland County 731 0.2421341 0.1640128 0.078 0.101
Marcellus Central School District Onondaga County 1769 0.0678349 0.1411194 -0.073 -0.073
Margaretville Central School District Delaware County 414 0.1642512 0.1658030 -0.002 0.024
Marion Central School District Wayne County 879 0.1149033 0.1161587 -0.001 -0.026
Marlboro Central School District Ulster County 1959 0.0796325 0.1379147 -0.058 -0.061
Massapequa Union Free School District Nassau County 8357 0.0183080 0.0555672 -0.037 -0.122
Massena Central School District St. Lawrence County 2656 0.2650602 0.1786742 0.086 0.124
Mattituck-Cutchogue Union Free School District Suffolk County 1316 0.0448328 0.0687418 -0.024 -0.096
Mayfield Central School District Fulton County 823 0.1798299 0.1490226 0.031 0.039
McGraw Central School District Cortland County 560 0.1571429 0.1640128 -0.007 0.016
Mechanicville City School District Saratoga County 1401 0.1434690 0.0584428 0.085 0.003
Medina Central School District Orleans County 1610 0.1826087 0.1372050 0.045 0.042
Menands Union Free School District Albany County 380 0.1578947 0.1187365 0.039 0.017
Merrick Union Free School District Nassau County 1653 0.0302480 0.0555672 -0.025 -0.110
Mexico Central School District Oswego County 2039 0.1549779 0.1700055 -0.015 0.014
Middle Country Central School District Suffolk County 9691 0.0730575 0.0687418 0.004 -0.068
Middleburgh Central School District Schoharie County 805 0.1043478 0.1210375 -0.017 -0.036
Middletown City School District Orange County 7164 0.1842546 0.1164923 0.068 0.044
Milford Central School District Otsego County 376 0.0904255 0.1486627 -0.058 -0.050
Millbrook Central School District Dutchess County 1259 0.0643368 0.0904110 -0.026 -0.076
Miller Place Union Free School District Suffolk County 2855 0.0252189 0.0687418 -0.044 -0.115
Mineola Union Free School District Nassau County 3018 0.0453943 0.0555672 -0.010 -0.095
Minerva Central School District Essex County 96 0.0833333 0.0987296 -0.015 -0.057
Minisink Valley Central School District Orange County 4399 0.1129802 0.1164923 -0.004 -0.028
Monroe-Woodbury Central School District Orange County 7568 0.0874736 0.1164923 -0.029 -0.053
Montauk Union Free School District Suffolk County 339 0.0530973 0.0687418 -0.016 -0.088
Monticello Central School District Sullivan County 3441 0.2877071 0.1515181 0.136 0.147
Moravia Central School District Cayuga County 930 0.1903226 0.1209675 0.069 0.050
Moriah Central School District Essex County 595 0.2268908 0.0987296 0.128 0.086
Morris Central School District Otsego County 384 0.1250000 0.1486627 -0.024 -0.016
Morristown Central School District St. Lawrence County 428 0.2663551 0.1786742 0.088 0.126
Morrisville-Eaton Central School District Madison County 741 0.1133603 0.0977792 0.016 -0.027
Mount Markham Central School District Herkimer County 1153 0.1595837 0.1363726 0.023 0.019
Mount Morris Central School District Livingston County 480 0.2562500 0.1317511 0.124 0.116
Mount Pleasant Central School District Westchester County 2474 0.0347615 0.0883991 -0.054 -0.106
Mount Sinai Union Free School District Suffolk County 2296 0.0326655 0.0687418 -0.036 -0.108
Mount Vernon School District Westchester County 10090 0.1540139 0.0883991 0.066 0.013
Nanuet Union Free School District Rockland County 2526 0.0577989 0.1387053 -0.081 -0.083
Naples Central School District Ontario County 794 0.1536524 0.0866414 0.067 0.013
New Hartford Central School District Oneida County 2545 0.0447937 0.1547234 -0.110 -0.096
New Hyde Park-Garden City Park Union Free School District Nassau County 1719 0.0383944 0.0555672 -0.017 -0.102
New Lebanon Central School District Columbia County 513 0.1013645 0.1157255 -0.014 -0.039
New Paltz Central School District Ulster County 2097 0.0739151 0.1379147 -0.064 -0.067
New Rochelle City School District Westchester County 11749 0.1048600 0.0883991 0.016 -0.036
New Suffolk Common School District Suffolk County 24 0.4166667 0.0687418 0.348 0.276
New York City Department Of Education New York County 1193045 0.2171016 0.1583354 0.059 0.076
New York Mills Union Free School District Oneida County 672 0.1026786 0.1547234 -0.052 -0.038
Newark Central School District Wayne County 2098 0.1939943 0.1161587 0.078 0.053
Newark Valley Central School District Tioga County 1152 0.1527778 0.1015274 0.051 0.012
Newburgh City School District Orange County 11728 0.1911664 0.1164923 0.075 0.051
Newcomb Central School District Essex County 47 0.2340426 0.0987296 0.135 0.093
Newfane Central School District Niagara County 1705 0.1002933 0.1345573 -0.034 -0.040
Newfield Central School District Tompkins County 878 0.1628702 0.1889363 -0.026 0.022
Niagara Falls City School District Niagara County 6992 0.3136442 0.1345573 0.179 0.173
Niagara-Wheatfield Central School District Niagara County 4054 0.1031080 0.1345573 -0.031 -0.038
Niskayuna Central School District Schenectady County 4100 0.0453659 0.1144935 -0.069 -0.095
North Babylon Union Free School District Suffolk County 4422 0.0730439 0.0687418 0.004 -0.068
North Bellmore Union Free School District Nassau County 2093 0.0277114 0.0555672 -0.028 -0.113
North Collins Central School District Erie County 672 0.1041667 0.1419954 -0.038 -0.036
North Colonie Central School District Albany County 5593 0.0616842 0.1187365 -0.057 -0.079
North Greenbush Common School District (Williams) Rensselaer County 170 0.0588235 0.1170876 -0.058 -0.082
North Merrick Union Free School District Nassau County 1230 0.0235772 0.0555672 -0.032 -0.117
North Rose-Wolcott Central School District Wayne County 1324 0.1752266 0.1161587 0.059 0.035
North Salem Central School District Westchester County 1352 0.0569527 0.0883991 -0.031 -0.084
North Shore Central School District Nassau County 2995 0.0253756 0.0555672 -0.030 -0.115
North Syracuse Central School District Onondaga County 9497 0.1044540 0.1411194 -0.037 -0.036
North Tonawanda City School District Niagara County 3969 0.1254724 0.1345573 -0.009 -0.015
North Warren Central School District Warren County 514 0.2003891 0.0947304 0.106 0.060
Northeast Central School District Dutchess County 1058 0.1379962 0.0904110 0.048 -0.003
Northeastern Clinton Central School District Clinton County 1356 0.2109145 0.1500062 0.061 0.070
Northern Adirondack Central School District Clinton County 883 0.1291053 0.1500062 -0.021 -0.012
Northport-East Northport Union Free School District Suffolk County 6049 0.0310795 0.0687418 -0.038 -0.110
Northville Central School District Fulton County 383 0.1879896 0.1490226 0.039 0.047
Norwich City School District Chenango County 1923 0.1731669 0.1353454 0.038 0.033
Norwood-Norfolk Central School District St. Lawrence County 1051 0.2036156 0.1786742 0.025 0.063
Nyack Union Free School District Rockland County 3543 0.0821338 0.1387053 -0.057 -0.059
Oakfield-Alabama Central School District Genesee County 894 0.0715884 0.1087335 -0.037 -0.069
Oceanside Union Free School District Nassau County 5850 0.0376068 0.0555672 -0.018 -0.103
Odessa-Montour Central School District Schuyler County 762 0.1902887 0.1539551 0.036 0.050
Ogdensburg City School District St. Lawrence County 1649 0.2674348 0.1786742 0.089 0.127
Olean City School District Cattaraugus County 2273 0.2278927 0.1650263 0.063 0.087
Oneida City School District Madison County 2267 0.1645346 0.0977792 0.067 0.024
Oneonta City School District Otsego County 1595 0.1573668 0.1486627 0.009 0.017
Onondaga Central School District Onondaga County 964 0.1141079 0.1411194 -0.027 -0.027
Onteora Central School District Ulster County 1666 0.2148860 0.1379147 0.077 0.074
Oppenheim-Ephratah-St. Johnsville Central School District Montgomery County 903 0.2380952 0.1977416 0.040 0.097
Orchard Park Central School District Erie County 5663 0.0512096 0.1419954 -0.091 -0.089
Oriskany Central School District Oneida County 740 0.0945946 0.1547234 -0.060 -0.046
Ossining Union Free School District Westchester County 4642 0.0915554 0.0883991 0.003 -0.049
Oswego City School District Oswego County 3862 0.2128431 0.1700055 0.043 0.072
Otego-Unadilla Central School District Otsego County 889 0.1754781 0.1486627 0.027 0.035
Owego-Apalachin Central School District Tioga County 2018 0.1159564 0.1015274 0.014 -0.025
Oxford Academy and Central School District Chenango County 745 0.1838926 0.1353454 0.049 0.043
Oyster Bay-East Norwich Central School District Nassau County 2106 0.0417854 0.0555672 -0.014 -0.099
Oysterponds Union Free School District Suffolk County 159 0.0566038 0.0687418 -0.012 -0.084
Palmyra-Macedon Central School District Wayne County 1891 0.1385510 0.1161587 0.022 -0.002
Panama Central School District Chautauqua County 547 0.1919561 0.1819851 0.010 0.051
Parishville-Hopkinton Central School District St. Lawrence County 501 0.1776447 0.1786742 -0.001 0.037
Patchogue-Medford Union Free School District Suffolk County 7321 0.0904248 0.0687418 0.022 -0.050
Pavilion Central School District Genesee County 714 0.0868347 0.1087335 -0.022 -0.054
Pawling Central School District Dutchess County 1441 0.0687023 0.0904110 -0.022 -0.072
Pearl River Union Free School District Rockland County 3005 0.0778702 0.1387053 -0.061 -0.063
Peekskill City School District Westchester County 3328 0.1496394 0.0883991 0.061 0.009
Pelham Union Free School District Westchester County 2709 0.0402362 0.0883991 -0.048 -0.100
Pembroke Central School District Genesee County 941 0.1317747 0.1087335 0.023 -0.009
Penfield Central School District Monroe County 4775 0.0446073 0.1439197 -0.099 -0.096
Penn Yan Central School District Yates County 2141 0.2162541 0.1190616 0.097 0.076
Perry Central School District Wyoming County 871 0.1239954 0.1047348 0.019 -0.017
Peru Central School District Clinton County 2070 0.1173913 0.1500062 -0.033 -0.023
Phelps-Clifton Springs Central School District Ontario County 1813 0.0959735 0.0866414 0.009 -0.045
Phoenix Central School District Oswego County 1901 0.1546554 0.1700055 -0.015 0.014
Pine Bush Central School District Orange County 5713 0.1330299 0.1164923 0.017 -0.008
Pine Plains Central School District Dutchess County 1097 0.1312671 0.0904110 0.041 -0.009
Pine Valley Central School District (South Dayton) Chautauqua County 881 0.2179342 0.1819851 0.036 0.077
Piseco Common School District Hamilton County 36 0.2222222 0.0989060 0.123 0.082
Pittsford Central School District Monroe County 6053 0.0338675 0.1439197 -0.110 -0.107
Plainedge Union Free School District Nassau County 3230 0.0235294 0.0555672 -0.032 -0.117
Plainview-Old Bethpage Central School District Nassau County 4960 0.0199597 0.0555672 -0.036 -0.121
Plattsburgh City School District Clinton County 1766 0.1806342 0.1500062 0.031 0.040
Pleasantville Union Free School District Westchester County 1608 0.0205224 0.0883991 -0.068 -0.120
Pocantico Hills Central School District Westchester County 457 0.0940919 0.0883991 0.006 -0.047
Poland Central School District Herkimer County 660 0.1409091 0.1363726 0.005 0.000
Port Byron Central School District Cayuga County 993 0.1409869 0.1209675 0.020 0.000
Port Chester-Rye Union Free School District Westchester County 4473 0.1464342 0.0883991 0.058 0.006
Port Jefferson Union Free School District Suffolk County 1135 0.0343612 0.0687418 -0.034 -0.106
Port Jervis City School District Orange County 2950 0.2155932 0.1164923 0.099 0.075
Port Washington Union Free School District Nassau County 5190 0.0581888 0.0555672 0.003 -0.082
Portville Central School District Cattaraugus County 800 0.1675000 0.1650263 0.002 0.027
Potsdam Central School District St. Lawrence County 1440 0.1437500 0.1786742 -0.035 0.003
Poughkeepsie City School District Dutchess County 4004 0.2385115 0.0904110 0.148 0.098
Prattsburgh Central School District Steuben County 424 0.2264151 0.1369303 0.089 0.086
Pulaski Central School District Oswego County 951 0.1861199 0.1700055 0.016 0.045
Putnam Central School District Washington County 90 0.2666667 0.1129600 0.154 0.126
Putnam Valley Central School District Putnam County 1650 0.0733333 0.0498089 0.024 -0.067
Queensbury Union Free School District Warren County 3373 0.0969463 0.0947304 0.002 -0.044
Quogue Union Free School District Suffolk County 133 0.0300752 0.0687418 -0.039 -0.111
Randolph Central School District Cattaraugus County 1338 0.2115097 0.1650263 0.046 0.071
Raquette Lake Union Free School District Hamilton County 1 0.0000000 0.0989060 -0.099 -0.141
Ravena-Coeymans-Selkirk Central School District Albany County 2035 0.0997543 0.1187365 -0.019 -0.041
Red Creek Central School District Wayne County 837 0.2066906 0.1161587 0.091 0.066
Red Hook Central School District Dutchess County 1914 0.0548589 0.0904110 -0.036 -0.086
Remsen Central School District Oneida County 459 0.1154684 0.1547234 -0.039 -0.025
Remsenburg-Speonk Union Free School District Suffolk County 302 0.0198675 0.0687418 -0.049 -0.121
Rensselaer City School District Rensselaer County 1110 0.2045045 0.1170876 0.087 0.064
Rhinebeck Central School District Dutchess County 1122 0.0561497 0.0904110 -0.034 -0.085
Richfield Springs Central School District Otsego County 529 0.1663516 0.1486627 0.018 0.026
Ripley Central School District Chautauqua County 297 0.1548822 0.1819851 -0.027 0.014
Riverhead Central School District Suffolk County 4688 0.1299061 0.0687418 0.061 -0.011
Rochester City School District Monroe County 32648 0.3791963 0.1439197 0.235 0.239
Rockville Centre Union Free School District Nassau County 3948 0.0466059 0.0555672 -0.009 -0.094
Rocky Point Union Free School District Suffolk County 3026 0.0571712 0.0687418 -0.012 -0.083
Rome City School District Oneida County 5527 0.1943188 0.1547234 0.040 0.054
Romulus Central School District Seneca County 713 0.1865358 0.1216951 0.065 0.046
Rondout Valley Central School District Ulster County 2135 0.1302108 0.1379147 -0.008 -0.010
Roosevelt Union Free School District Nassau County 2948 0.1519674 0.0555672 0.096 0.011
Roscoe Central School District Sullivan County 241 0.1327801 0.1515181 -0.019 -0.008
Roslyn Union Free School District Nassau County 3333 0.0396040 0.0555672 -0.016 -0.101
Rotterdam-Mohonasen Central School District Schenectady County 2982 0.1123407 0.1144935 -0.002 -0.028
Roxbury Central School District Delaware County 311 0.1061093 0.1658030 -0.060 -0.035
Royalton-Hartland Central School District Niagara County 1437 0.0932498 0.1345573 -0.041 -0.047
Rush-Henrietta Central School District Monroe County 5751 0.1184142 0.1439197 -0.026 -0.022
Rye City School District Westchester County 3396 0.0267962 0.0883991 -0.062 -0.114
Rye Neck Union Free School District Westchester County 1626 0.0412054 0.0883991 -0.047 -0.099
Sachem Central School District Suffolk County 12814 0.0520524 0.0687418 -0.017 -0.089
Sackets Harbor Central School District Jefferson County 461 0.1431670 0.1401767 0.003 0.003
Sag Harbor Union Free School District Suffolk County 907 0.0683572 0.0687418 0.000 -0.072
Sagaponack Common School District Suffolk County 34 0.0000000 0.0687418 -0.069 -0.141
Salamanca City School District Cattaraugus County 1196 0.2391304 0.1650263 0.074 0.098
Salem Central School District Washington County 550 0.1618182 0.1129600 0.049 0.021
Salmon River Central School District Franklin County 1423 0.3155306 0.1777902 0.138 0.175
Sandy Creek Central School District Oswego County 858 0.1596737 0.1700055 -0.010 0.019
Saranac Central School District Clinton County 1527 0.1394892 0.1500062 -0.011 -0.001
Saranac Lake Central School District Franklin County 1415 0.2148410 0.1777902 0.037 0.074
Saratoga Springs City School District Saratoga County 6884 0.0647879 0.0584428 0.006 -0.076
Saugerties Central School District Ulster County 2794 0.1052255 0.1379147 -0.033 -0.035
Sauquoit Valley Central School District Oneida County 1080 0.0907407 0.1547234 -0.064 -0.050
Sayville Union Free School District Suffolk County 2961 0.0888213 0.0687418 0.020 -0.052
Scarsdale Union Free School District Westchester County 4600 0.0184783 0.0883991 -0.070 -0.122
Schalmont Central School District Schenectady County 2041 0.0783929 0.1144935 -0.036 -0.062
Schenectady City School District Schenectady County 10344 0.3345901 0.1144935 0.220 0.194
Schenevus Central School District Otsego County 308 0.1103896 0.1486627 -0.038 -0.030
Schodack Central School District Rensselaer County 1044 0.0459770 0.1170876 -0.071 -0.095
Schoharie Central School District Schoharie County 835 0.1353293 0.1210375 0.014 -0.005
Schroon Lake Central School District Essex County 195 0.2461538 0.0987296 0.147 0.106
Schuylerville Central School District Saratoga County 1724 0.0690255 0.0584428 0.011 -0.072
Scio Central School District Allegany County 375 0.2666667 0.1688228 0.098 0.126
Scotia-Glenville Central School District Schenectady County 2755 0.1415608 0.1144935 0.027 0.001
Seaford Union Free School District Nassau County 2686 0.0208488 0.0555672 -0.035 -0.120
Seneca Falls Central School District Seneca County 1358 0.1899853 0.1216951 0.068 0.049
Sewanhaka Central High School District Nassau County 9377 0.0505492 0.0555672 -0.005 -0.090
Sharon Springs Central School District Schoharie County 295 0.2847458 0.1210375 0.164 0.144
Shelter Island Union Free School District Suffolk County 269 0.0297398 0.0687418 -0.039 -0.111
Shenendehowa Central School District Saratoga County 10016 0.0409345 0.0584428 -0.018 -0.100
Sherburne-Earlville Central School District Chenango County 1243 0.1496380 0.1353454 0.014 0.009
Sherman Central School District Chautauqua County 556 0.1870504 0.1819851 0.005 0.046
Sherrill City School District Oneida County 2102 0.0899144 0.1547234 -0.065 -0.051
Shoreham-Wading River Central School District Suffolk County 2343 0.0392659 0.0687418 -0.029 -0.101
Sidney Central School District Delaware County 940 0.2106383 0.1658030 0.045 0.070
Silver Creek Central School District Chautauqua County 878 0.1788155 0.1819851 -0.003 0.038
Skaneateles Central School District Onondaga County 1551 0.0515796 0.1411194 -0.090 -0.089
Smithtown Central School District Suffolk County 10071 0.0292920 0.0687418 -0.039 -0.111
Sodus Central School District Wayne County 1066 0.2326454 0.1161587 0.116 0.092
Solvay Union Free School District Onondaga County 1351 0.1857883 0.1411194 0.045 0.045
Somers Central School District Westchester County 3644 0.0216795 0.0883991 -0.067 -0.119
South Colonie Central School District Albany County 5190 0.0936416 0.1187365 -0.025 -0.047
South Country Central School District Suffolk County 4333 0.1225479 0.0687418 0.054 -0.018
South Glens Falls Central School District Saratoga County 3035 0.0797364 0.0584428 0.021 -0.061
South Huntington Union Free School District Suffolk County 5611 0.0912493 0.0687418 0.023 -0.049
South Jefferson Central School District Jefferson County 1834 0.1384951 0.1401767 -0.002 -0.002
South Kortright Central School District Delaware County 336 0.1904762 0.1658030 0.025 0.050
South Lewis Central School District Lewis County 1034 0.1808511 0.1347545 0.046 0.040
South Orangetown Central School District Rockland County 3770 0.0469496 0.1387053 -0.092 -0.094
South Seneca Central School District Seneca County 1013 0.2339585 0.1216951 0.112 0.093
Southampton Union Free School District Suffolk County 1228 0.0814332 0.0687418 0.013 -0.059
Southern Cayuga Central School District Cayuga County 848 0.1403302 0.1209675 0.019 0.000
Southold Union Free School District Suffolk County 825 0.1393939 0.0687418 0.071 -0.001
Southwestern Central School District at Jamestown Chautauqua County 1270 0.1370079 0.1819851 -0.045 -0.004
Spackenkill Union Free School District Dutchess County 1347 0.0623608 0.0904110 -0.028 -0.078
Spencer-Van Etten Central School District Tioga County 982 0.1395112 0.1015274 0.038 -0.001
Spencerport Central School District Monroe County 3955 0.0849558 0.1439197 -0.059 -0.056
Springs Union Free School District Suffolk County 849 0.2673734 0.0687418 0.199 0.127
Springville-Griffith Institute Central School Erie County 2109 0.1014699 0.1419954 -0.041 -0.039
St. Regis Falls Central School District Franklin County 353 0.2407932 0.1777902 0.063 0.100
Stamford Central School District Delaware County 303 0.1518152 0.1658030 -0.014 0.011
Starpoint Central School District Niagara County 2771 0.0476362 0.1345573 -0.087 -0.093
Stillwater Central School District Saratoga County 1134 0.0749559 0.0584428 0.017 -0.066
Stockbridge Valley Central School District Madison County 460 0.1130435 0.0977792 0.015 -0.028
Suffern Central School District Rockland County 5581 0.0946067 0.1387053 -0.044 -0.046
Sullivan West Central School District Sullivan County 1379 0.1798405 0.1515181 0.028 0.039
Susquehanna Valley Central School District Broome County 1728 0.1487269 0.1741052 -0.025 0.008
Sweet Home Central School District Erie County 3641 0.1645152 0.1419954 0.023 0.024
Syosset Central School District Nassau County 6559 0.0246989 0.0555672 -0.031 -0.116
Syracuse City School District Onondaga County 20678 0.3638650 0.1411194 0.223 0.223
Taconic Hills Central School District Columbia County 1481 0.1417961 0.1157255 0.026 0.001
Thousand Islands Central School District Jefferson County 1037 0.1986500 0.1401767 0.058 0.058
Three Village Central School District Suffolk County 6784 0.0275649 0.0687418 -0.041 -0.113
Ticonderoga Central School District Essex County 688 0.1773256 0.0987296 0.079 0.037
Tioga Central School District Tioga County 922 0.1594360 0.1015274 0.058 0.019
Tonawanda City School District Erie County 1976 0.1477733 0.1419954 0.006 0.007
Town of Webb Union Free School District Herkimer County 244 0.0778689 0.1363726 -0.059 -0.063
Tri-Valley Central School District Sullivan County 1050 0.2409524 0.1515181 0.089 0.100
Troy City School District Rensselaer County 4603 0.2615685 0.1170876 0.144 0.121
Trumansburg Central School District Tompkins County 1093 0.1354071 0.1889363 -0.054 -0.005
Tuckahoe Common School District Suffolk County 426 0.0657277 0.0687418 -0.003 -0.075
Tuckahoe Union Free School District Westchester County 1104 0.0489130 0.0883991 -0.039 -0.092
Tully Central School District Onondaga County 1089 0.0752984 0.1411194 -0.066 -0.065
Tupper Lake Central School District Franklin County 839 0.1299166 0.1777902 -0.048 -0.011
Tuxedo Union Free School District Orange County 390 0.0538462 0.1164923 -0.063 -0.087
Unadilla Valley Central School District Chenango County 771 0.1867704 0.1353454 0.051 0.046
Union Free School District of the Tarrytowns Westchester County 2865 0.0991274 0.0883991 0.011 -0.042
Union Springs Central School District Cayuga County 932 0.1137339 0.1209675 -0.007 -0.027
Union-Endicott Central School District Broome County 4265 0.2051583 0.1741052 0.031 0.065
Uniondale Union Free School District Nassau County 6057 0.1269605 0.0555672 0.071 -0.014
Utica City School District Oneida County 10084 0.3207061 0.1547234 0.166 0.180
Valhalla Union Free School District Westchester County 1564 0.0358056 0.0883991 -0.053 -0.105
Valley Central School District (Montgomery) Orange County 5030 0.0825050 0.1164923 -0.034 -0.058
Valley Stream Central High School District Nassau County 4765 0.0612802 0.0555672 0.006 -0.079
Valley Stream Union Free School District 13 Nassau County 2151 0.0595072 0.0555672 0.004 -0.081
Valley Stream Union Free School District 24 Nassau County 1105 0.0778281 0.0555672 0.022 -0.063
Valley Stream Union Free School District 30 Nassau County 1467 0.0865712 0.0555672 0.031 -0.054
Van Hornesville-Owen D. Young Central School District Herkimer County 270 0.2370370 0.1363726 0.101 0.096
Vestal Central School District Broome County 3696 0.1025433 0.1741052 -0.072 -0.038
Victor Central School District Ontario County 4159 0.0512142 0.0866414 -0.035 -0.089
Voorheesville Central School District Albany County 1158 0.0405872 0.1187365 -0.078 -0.100
Wainscott Common School District Suffolk County 90 0.3666667 0.0687418 0.298 0.226
Wallkill Central School District Ulster County 3194 0.1033187 0.1379147 -0.035 -0.037
Walton Central School District Delaware County 828 0.2004831 0.1658030 0.035 0.060
Wantagh Union Free School District Nassau County 3491 0.0163277 0.0555672 -0.039 -0.124
Wappingers Central School District Dutchess County 11216 0.0545649 0.0904110 -0.036 -0.086
Warrensburg Central School District Warren County 755 0.1933775 0.0947304 0.099 0.053
Warsaw Central School District Wyoming County 926 0.1155508 0.1047348 0.011 -0.025
Warwick Valley Central School District Orange County 4489 0.0512364 0.1164923 -0.065 -0.089
Washingtonville Central School District Orange County 4711 0.0995542 0.1164923 -0.017 -0.041
Waterford-Halfmoon Union Free School District Saratoga County 785 0.1044586 0.0584428 0.046 -0.036
Waterloo Central School District Seneca County 1842 0.1568947 0.1216951 0.035 0.016
Watertown City School District Jefferson County 4298 0.2931596 0.1401767 0.153 0.153
Waterville Central School District Oneida County 946 0.1120507 0.1547234 -0.043 -0.029
Watervliet City School District Albany County 1473 0.2226748 0.1187365 0.104 0.082
Watkins Glen Central School District Schuyler County 1056 0.1979167 0.1539551 0.044 0.057
Waverly Central School District Tioga County 1485 0.1771044 0.1015274 0.076 0.036
Wayland-Cohocton Central School District Steuben County 1390 0.1604317 0.1369303 0.024 0.020
Wayne Central School District Wayne County 2305 0.0720174 0.1161587 -0.044 -0.069
Webster Central School District Monroe County 9219 0.0541273 0.1439197 -0.090 -0.087
Weedsport Central School District Cayuga County 799 0.0901126 0.1209675 -0.031 -0.051
Wells Central School District Hamilton County 118 0.0932203 0.0989060 -0.006 -0.047
Wellsville Central School District Allegany County 1285 0.2194553 0.1688228 0.051 0.079
West Babylon Union Free School District Suffolk County 3893 0.0644747 0.0687418 -0.004 -0.076
West Canada Valley Central School District Herkimer County 765 0.1346405 0.1363726 -0.002 -0.006
West Genesee Central School District Onondaga County 4871 0.0640526 0.1411194 -0.077 -0.077
West Hempstead Union Free School District Nassau County 3092 0.0601552 0.0555672 0.005 -0.080
West Irondequoit Central School District Monroe County 3620 0.0831492 0.1439197 -0.061 -0.058
West Islip Union Free School District Suffolk County 4800 0.0325000 0.0687418 -0.036 -0.108
West Seneca Central School District Erie County 7226 0.0943814 0.1419954 -0.048 -0.046
West Valley Central School District Cattaraugus County 340 0.1264706 0.1650263 -0.039 -0.014
Westbury Union Free School District Nassau County 3978 0.1347411 0.0555672 0.079 -0.006
Westfield Central School District Chautauqua County 683 0.1961933 0.1819851 0.014 0.056
Westhampton Beach Union Free School District Suffolk County 782 0.0856777 0.0687418 0.017 -0.055
Westhill Central School District Onondaga County 1851 0.0567261 0.1411194 -0.084 -0.084
Westmoreland Central School District Oneida County 980 0.0632653 0.1547234 -0.091 -0.077
Wheatland-Chili Central School District Monroe County 718 0.1518106 0.1439197 0.008 0.011
Wheelerville Union Free School District Fulton County 174 0.1321839 0.1490226 -0.017 -0.008
White Plains City School District Westchester County 7421 0.1183129 0.0883991 0.030 -0.022
Whitehall Central School District Washington County 680 0.2044118 0.1129600 0.091 0.064
Whitesboro Central School District Oneida County 3584 0.0892857 0.1547234 -0.065 -0.051
Whitesville Central School District Allegany County 205 0.1853659 0.1688228 0.017 0.045
Whitney Point Central School District Broome County 1349 0.1979244 0.1741052 0.024 0.057
William Floyd Union Free School District Suffolk County 8306 0.1435107 0.0687418 0.075 0.003
Williamson Central School District Wayne County 1058 0.0945180 0.1161587 -0.022 -0.046
Williamsville Central School District Erie County 11339 0.0526501 0.1419954 -0.089 -0.088
Willsboro Central School District Essex County 262 0.1564885 0.0987296 0.058 0.016
Wilson Central School District Niagara County 1257 0.1073986 0.1345573 -0.027 -0.033
Windham-Ashland-Jewett Central School District Greene County 360 0.1416667 0.1399206 0.002 0.001
Windsor Central School District Broome County 1772 0.1608352 0.1741052 -0.013 0.020
Worcester Central School District Otsego County 329 0.1428571 0.1486627 -0.006 0.002
Wyandanch Union Free School District Suffolk County 2084 0.2068138 0.0687418 0.138 0.066
Wynantskill Union Free School District Rensselaer County 492 0.0528455 0.1170876 -0.064 -0.088
Wyoming Central School District Wyoming County 264 0.1060606 0.1047348 0.001 -0.035
Yonkers City School District Westchester County 28822 0.1649781 0.0883991 0.077 0.024
York Central School District Livingston County 761 0.1169514 0.1317511 -0.015 -0.024
Yorkshire-Pioneer Central School District Cattaraugus County 2425 0.1513402 0.1650263 -0.014 0.011
Yorktown Central School District Westchester County 4004 0.0374625 0.0883991 -0.051 -0.103

Notice

Notice

  • you can use a defined value in an equation, like state_stpovrate
  • use the round() function to roudn your numbers
    • round(variable, decimal_places)

Research Questions

We have created the dataframes to answer these questions!

  • What is the difference between the student poverty rate in each school district and:

    • the poverty rate of the county as a whole?
    • the poverty rate of the state as a whole?

Still to do

  • What counties have the most economic inequality, as measured by the student poverty rate of school districts?

In-class work time


Work through this analysis on your own up to this point for ~ 30 minutes.

I’ll come around to help!

We’ll come back together and answer these questions together:

  • What district has the highest student poverty rate?
  • What county is that district in?
  • What county has the highest poverty rate?
  • What school district has the lowest student poverty rate in that county?

If you finish, try working through the examples of different types of joins on the next slide

Joins

Create a new script, name it joins_practice.R

  • Work through these joins and look at each dataframe to try to figure out how they work
library(tidyverse)

# the two lines below create test dataframes
customer_purchase = data.frame(CustomerId = c(1:6), Product = c(rep("Toaster", 3), rep("Radio", 3)))
customer_state = data.frame(CustomerId = c(2, 4, 6), State = c(rep("Alabama", 2), rep("Ohio", 1)))

# Inner Join 
# keep only rows where CustomerId matches
inner_join_purchase <- customer_purchase %>% 
  inner_join(customer_state, by = "CustomerId")

# Full Join
# keep all rows from both dataframes
full_join_purchase <- customer_purchase %>% 
  full_join(customer_state, by = "CustomerId")

# Left Join 
#  keep all of the rows in the first dataframe and add the columns from the second
left_join_purchase <- customer_purchase %>% 
  left_join(customer_state, by = "CustomerId")

# Right Join 
#  keep the rows in the first dataframe that have the same value for CustomerId as the second
right_join_purchase <- customer_purchase %>% 
  right_join(customer_state, by = "CustomerId")

Exploratory Analysis

Now that we have our analysis dataset, it’s time to use it to learn more about poverty in New York state. We’ll use descriptive statistics and visualization to interpret the data.

  • Summary statistics for each variable with the summary() function
  • A very simple scatterplot & histogram to understand the shape of our data
  • Calculate our own descriptive statistics with the summarise() function
    • for the state
    • for each county

Calculate some quick summary statistics

summary(sd_county_pov)
       id            district            COUNTY              CONUM      
 Min.   :3600001   Length:681         Length:681         Min.   :36001  
 1st Qu.:3609330   Class :character   Class :character   1st Qu.:36033  
 Median :3616980   Mode  :character   Mode  :character   Median :36065  
 Mean   :3616755                                         Mean   :36066  
 3rd Qu.:3624240                                         3rd Qu.:36103  
 Max.   :3632010                                         Max.   :36123  
      tpop             stpop             stpov            stpovrate      
 Min.   :    104   Min.   :      1   Min.   :     0.0   Min.   :0.00000  
 1st Qu.:   5280   1st Qu.:    782   1st Qu.:    84.0   1st Qu.:0.06954  
 Median :   9629   Median :   1441   Median :   156.0   Median :0.12479  
 Mean   :  28935   Mean   :   4260   Mean   :   713.2   Mean   :0.13102  
 3rd Qu.:  20556   3rd Qu.:   3306   3rd Qu.:   294.0   3rd Qu.:0.18085  
 Max.   :8336817   Max.   :1193045   Max.   :259012.0   Max.   :0.50109  
   county_pop      county_pov_rate   pov_diff_county    pov_diff_state     
 Min.   :   4479   Min.   :0.04981   Min.   :-0.11000   Min.   :-0.141000  
 1st Qu.:  63306   1st Qu.:0.08840   1st Qu.:-0.03300   1st Qu.:-0.071000  
 Median : 153415   Median :0.12097   Median : 0.00000   Median :-0.016000  
 Mean   : 457515   Mean   :0.11926   Mean   : 0.01177   Mean   :-0.009631  
 3rd Qu.: 893029   3rd Qu.:0.14392   3rd Qu.: 0.04800   3rd Qu.: 0.040000  
 Max.   :1584693   Max.   :0.19774   Max.   : 0.38500   Max.   : 0.360000  

Look at a histogram

A histogram is a chart that shows the distribution of your data.

  • The height of each bar indicates how many district’s poverty difference is within that range.


hist(sd_county_pov$pov_diff_county)

( pov_diff_county = stpovrate - county_pov_rate )

Look at a scatterplot

A scatterplot is a chart that is used to look at the relationship between two variables.

  • Each dot is a school district.
  • The pattern of dots helps you to determine whether a relationship exists between two variables.
  • Here, you can say there is a positive relationship between County Poverty Rate and School District Poverty Rate
    • meaning as County Poverty Rate increases, the School District Poverty Rate tends to be higher also
plot(sd_county_pov$county_pov_rate, sd_county_pov$stpovrate, 
     xlab="County Poverty Rate", 
     ylab="School District Poverty Rate")

summarise()


  • We can use the summarise() function to create our own statistics to help answer our questions.
    • we’ll create a new dataframe that is a single row summarizing our dataframe
    • useful arguments within summarize:
      • mean(), median(), min(), max(), sum(), n()
      • n() returns the number of rows

summarise() New York poverty


# calculate student poverty statistics for New York

ny_pov_stats <- sd_county_pov |>
  summarise(districts = n(),
            kids = sum(stpop),
            kids_in_pov = sum(stpov),
            stud_poverty_rate = kids_in_pov/kids,
            mean_sd_stpovrate = mean(stpovrate),
            max_sd_stpovrate = max(stpovrate), 
            min_sd_stpovrate = min(stpovrate),
            poverty_range = max_sd_stpovrate - min_sd_stpovrate)

write_csv(ny_pov_stats, "data/output/ny_state_poverty_stats.csv")


districts kids kids_in_pov stud_poverty_rate mean_sd_stpovrate max_sd_stpovrate min_sd_stpovrate poverty_range
681 2901286 485661 0.1673951 0.1310178 0.5010861 0 0.5010861

group_by() & summarise()

  • We can also calculate the same statistics for each county by using:
    • group_by() and summarise() together
    • group_by() indicates that you want to summarize based on another variable rather than the whole dataset
ny_county_pov_stats <- sd_county_pov |>
  group_by(COUNTY) |> 
  summarise(districts = n(),
            kids = sum(stpop),
            kids_in_pov = sum(stpov),
            stud_poverty_rate = round(kids_in_pov/kids, 3),
            mean_sd_stpovrate = round(mean(stpovrate), 3),
            max_sd_stpovrate = round(max(stpovrate), 3),
            min_sd_stpovrate = round(min(stpovrate), 3),
            poverty_range = max_sd_stpovrate - min_sd_stpovrate) 

write_csv(ny_county_pov_stats, "data/output/ny_county_poverty_stats.csv")

summarize poverty in new york counties

COUNTY districts kids kids_in_pov stud_poverty_rate mean_sd_stpovrate max_sd_stpovrate min_sd_stpovrate poverty_range
Albany County 12 40249 5403 0.134 0.129 0.266 0.041 0.225
Allegany County 12 6796 1633 0.240 0.241 0.315 0.185 0.130
Broome County 12 27673 5916 0.214 0.182 0.370 0.079 0.291
Cattaraugus County 12 13775 2594 0.188 0.183 0.239 0.126 0.113
Cayuga County 7 9694 1728 0.178 0.152 0.225 0.090 0.135
Chautauqua County 18 19226 4335 0.225 0.190 0.333 0.088 0.245
Chemung County 3 12057 2267 0.188 0.173 0.248 0.088 0.160
Chenango County 8 7478 1225 0.164 0.166 0.197 0.125 0.072
Clinton County 8 11080 1647 0.149 0.144 0.211 0.097 0.114
Columbia County 6 7212 894 0.124 0.118 0.185 0.079 0.106
Cortland County 5 6632 1179 0.178 0.189 0.242 0.114 0.128
Delaware County 13 5774 1012 0.175 0.165 0.211 0.106 0.105
Dutchess County 13 41543 3759 0.090 0.098 0.239 0.055 0.184
Erie County 28 134940 24775 0.184 0.124 0.381 0.041 0.340
Essex County 10 3533 578 0.164 0.160 0.246 0.054 0.192
Franklin County 7 7803 1733 0.222 0.218 0.316 0.130 0.186
Fulton County 6 7651 1643 0.215 0.185 0.309 0.131 0.178
Genesee County 8 8609 972 0.113 0.101 0.165 0.072 0.093
Greene County 6 5922 959 0.162 0.177 0.315 0.106 0.209
Hamilton County 7 413 51 0.123 0.120 0.222 0.000 0.222
Herkimer County 10 9636 1673 0.174 0.168 0.237 0.078 0.159
Jefferson County 11 17784 3598 0.202 0.191 0.293 0.127 0.166
Lewis County 5 4254 731 0.172 0.167 0.181 0.128 0.053
Livingston County 8 7917 1168 0.148 0.154 0.256 0.091 0.165
Madison County 10 10139 1190 0.117 0.125 0.214 0.066 0.148
Monroe County 18 113152 19831 0.175 0.113 0.379 0.034 0.345
Montgomery County 5 8413 2014 0.239 0.230 0.268 0.151 0.117
Nassau County 56 216350 12320 0.057 0.054 0.193 0.015 0.178
New York County 1 1193045 259012 0.217 0.217 0.217 0.217 0.000
Niagara County 10 30500 4912 0.161 0.129 0.314 0.048 0.266
Oneida County 15 35425 6159 0.174 0.119 0.321 0.045 0.276
Onondaga County 18 70736 12000 0.170 0.115 0.364 0.035 0.329
Ontario County 9 17119 1754 0.102 0.112 0.181 0.051 0.130
Orange County 17 72854 11745 0.161 0.126 0.501 0.051 0.450
Orleans County 5 5895 1027 0.174 0.169 0.192 0.123 0.069
Oswego County 9 19552 3686 0.189 0.186 0.239 0.152 0.087
Otsego County 12 6822 1067 0.156 0.155 0.235 0.090 0.145
Putnam County 6 14400 780 0.054 0.056 0.073 0.038 0.035
Rensselaer County 12 22228 3147 0.142 0.124 0.262 0.046 0.216
Rockland County 8 65876 12842 0.195 0.110 0.342 0.047 0.295
Saratoga County 12 34936 2350 0.067 0.088 0.151 0.041 0.110
Schenectady County 6 23088 4600 0.199 0.132 0.335 0.045 0.290
Schoharie County 6 4268 652 0.153 0.169 0.285 0.104 0.181
Schuyler County 3 2105 415 0.197 0.200 0.213 0.190 0.023
Seneca County 4 4926 917 0.186 0.192 0.234 0.157 0.077
St. Lawrence County 17 15926 3519 0.221 0.212 0.335 0.121 0.214
Steuben County 12 15402 2732 0.177 0.195 0.291 0.120 0.171
Suffolk County 68 230466 17818 0.077 0.081 0.417 0.000 0.417
Sullivan County 8 10351 2537 0.245 0.214 0.288 0.133 0.155
Tioga County 6 7354 1038 0.141 0.141 0.177 0.102 0.075
Tompkins County 6 11569 1457 0.126 0.137 0.175 0.101 0.074
Ulster County 9 23786 3177 0.134 0.134 0.215 0.074 0.141
Warren County 9 9039 1183 0.131 0.149 0.261 0.053 0.208
Washington County 11 8399 1283 0.153 0.163 0.267 0.102 0.165
Wayne County 11 14309 2098 0.147 0.153 0.233 0.052 0.181
Westchester County 40 157456 13588 0.086 0.058 0.165 0.015 0.150
Wyoming County 5 4410 510 0.116 0.118 0.155 0.088 0.067
Yates County 2 3339 828 0.248 0.260 0.305 0.216 0.089

Research Questions

We have created the dataframes to answer these questions!

  • What is the difference between the student poverty rate in each school district and:
    • the poverty rate of the county as a whole?
    • the poverty rate of the state as a whole?
  • What counties have the most economic inequality, as measured by the student poverty rate of school districts?

In-class work time

Work through the rest of the analysis on your own for ~ 30 minutes.

I’ll come around to help!

We’ll come back together and answer these questions together:

  • What county has the largest range in student poverty rate?
  • What county has the smallest range in student poverty rate?
  • What other questions could you answer?

If you finish, take a look at the homework assignments.

Write out your csvs

Save these processed dataframe and summary stats dataframe to your computer

# write out poverty rate stat
write_csv(ny_pov_stats, "data/output/ny_student_poverty_state_stats_2019.csv")

write_csv(ny_county_pov_stats, "data/output/ny_student_poverty_state_stats_by_county_2019.csv")

To Be Continued…


Next week we’ll use much prettier plots to explore this dataset more.

Assignment 3a

Please read and be prepared to discuss the following readings:

Listen to the CodeSwitch episode Who You Calling Hispanic

Optionally, read Chapter 13 of R for Data Science on joining data if you would like more about relational data and joining data with R.

Assignment 3b


Research Journal

Assignment 3c

Work through the in-class exercise and answer the following questions:

  • What district has the highest student poverty rate?
  • What county is that district in?
  • What county has the highest poverty rate? (you should use the county poverty dataset to answer this question)
  • What school district has the lowest student poverty rate in Montgomery County?
  • What county has the largest range in student poverty rate?
  • What county has the smallest range in student poverty rate?

On Canvas, submit a text document with the answer to these questions and your 3 scripts.