Design Computational Solutions:

Identify a problem and develop (creative) solutions by identifying input, output, and algorithms

AEI construct (public URL):

https://cr4cr.bear-apps.com/constructs/public/u1JW9pXGW4QlVnjYGwnaF1PzwKMXNr

Fall 2021 report (requires login):

https://cr4cr.bear-apps.com/table_of_reports?scheduled_activities=141

Fall 2021 (AFE) report (requires login):

https://cr4cr.bear-apps.com/table_of_reports?scheduled_activities=219

Spring 2022 report (requires login):

https://cr4cr.bear-apps.com/table_of_reports?scheduled_activities=267

BASS page:

https://cr4cr.bear-apps.com/

1 Construct levels

AEI6: Step Beyond/Strategic:


AEI5: Integrated Relational - Complex:


AEI4: Integrated Relational - Simple:


AEI3: Multi-step Solutions:


AEI2: One-step Solutions:


AEI1: Attempting/Partial:


AEI0: Not Evident:


2 Analyses

Unidimensional Rasch calibration of the AEI items (pre and post, 3 common items)

3 Datasets (raw files)

There are n=933 respondents at Pretest and n=295 at Posttest. Raw data file is available here:

4 Calibration

## $Delivery.03d_NU_F
## 
## AEI1 AEI4 
##  363   24 
## 
## $Elevator.04c_OE_F
## 
## AEI0 AEI1 AEI2 AEI3 AEI4 
##   69  117  122   46    3 
## 
## $Park.01b_MC_F
## 
## AEI1 AEI4 
##  306   82 
## 
## $Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F
## 
## AEI0 AEI1 AEI2 AEI3 
##  181   14   99   82 
## 
## $Sorting.03b_MC_F
## 
## AEI1 AEI2 AEI3 
##  184  157   38 
## 
## $Sorting.03c_MC_F
## 
## AEI1 AEI2 AEI3 
##  126   51  202 
## 
## $TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F
## 
## AEI0 AEI1 AEI2 AEI3 
##   74   39  397  262 
## 
## $Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C
## 
## AEI1 AEI3 
##  334  140 
## 
## $SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C
## 
## AEI0 AEI1 AEI3 
##   24  432   92 
## 
## $Travel.01_NU_C
## 
## AEI0 AEI2 
##  336  662 
## 
## $Delivery.01b_MC_S
## 
## AEI0 AEI1 AEI2 
##   15   10   59 
## 
## $Delivery.01c_MC_S
## 
## AEI0 AEI2 
##   46   38 
## 
## $Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S
## 
## AEI0 AEI1 AEI2 AEI3 
##   29    9   21   21
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## TAM 4.1-4 (2022-08-28 16:03:54) 
## R version 4.2.2 (2022-10-31) x86_64, darwin17.0 | nodename=Permans-MacBook-Pro-4.local | login=root 
## 
## Date of Analysis: 2023-02-22 15:53:02 
## Time difference of 0.267741 secs
## Computation time: 0.267741 
## 
## Multidimensional Item Response Model in TAM 
## 
## IRT Model: PCM2
## Call:
## TAM::tam.mml(resp = aei[, c(6:18)], Y = aei[, 5], irtmodel = "PCM2", 
##     verbose = FALSE)
## 
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Number of iterations = 73 
## Numeric integration with 21 integration points
## 
## Deviance = 8259.96 
## Log likelihood = -4129.98 
## Number of persons = 1228 
## Number of persons used = 1103 
## Number of items = 13 
## Number of estimated parameters = 28 
##     Item threshold parameters = 26 
##     Item slope parameters = 0 
##     Regression parameters = 1 
##     Variance/covariance parameters = 1 
## 
## AIC = 8316  | penalty=56    | AIC=-2*LL + 2*p 
## AIC3 = 8344  | penalty=84    | AIC3=-2*LL + 3*p 
## BIC = 8456  | penalty=196.16    | BIC=-2*LL + log(n)*p 
## aBIC = 8367  | penalty=107.13    | aBIC=-2*LL + log((n-2)/24)*p  (adjusted BIC) 
## CAIC = 8484  | penalty=224.16    | CAIC=-2*LL + [log(n)+1]*p  (consistent AIC) 
## AICc = 8317  | penalty=57.51    | AICc=-2*LL + 2*p + 2*p*(p+1)/(n-p-1)  (bias corrected AIC) 
## GHP = 0.78364     | GHP=( -LL + p ) / (#Persons * #Items)  (Gilula-Haberman log penalty) 
## 
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## EAP Reliability
## [1] 0.478
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Covariances and Variances
##       [,1]
## [1,] 0.639
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Correlations and Standard Deviations (in the diagonal)
##      [,1]
## [1,]  0.8
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Regression Coefficients
##       [,1]
## [1,] 0.000
## [2,] 0.542
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Standardized Coefficients
##        parm dim   est  StdYX   StdX   StdY
## 1 Intercept   1 0.000     NA     NA     NA
## 2        Y1   1 0.542 0.2783 0.2317 0.6511
## 
## ** Explained Variance R^2
## [1] 0.0774
## ** SD Theta
## [1] 0.8325
## ** SD Predictors
## Intercept        Y1 
##    0.0000    0.4274 
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Item Parameters -A*Xsi
##                       item   N     M xsi.item AXsi_.Cat1 AXsi_.Cat2 AXsi_.Cat3
## 1        Delivery.03d_NU_F 387 0.062    2.975      2.975         NA         NA
## 2        Elevator.04c_OE_F 357 1.431    1.071     -0.870     -0.835      0.637
## 3            Park.01b_MC_F 388 0.211    1.466      1.466         NA         NA
## 4   Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F 376 1.218    0.411      2.344      0.536      1.234
## 5         Sorting.03b_MC_F 379 0.615    1.007      0.137      2.014         NA
## 6         Sorting.03c_MC_F 379 1.201   -0.293      0.637     -0.585         NA
## 7       TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F 772 2.097   -0.686     -0.059     -2.655     -2.058
## 8     Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C 474 0.295    1.061      1.061         NA         NA
## 9       SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C 548 1.124   -0.601     -3.149     -1.202         NA
## 10          Travel.01_NU_C 998 0.663   -0.646     -0.646         NA         NA
## 11       Delivery.01b_MC_S  84 1.524   -0.486      0.366     -0.973         NA
## 12       Delivery.01c_MC_S  84 0.452    0.679      0.679         NA         NA
## 13 Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S  80 1.425    0.766      1.369      1.181      2.299
##    AXsi_.Cat4 B.Cat1.Dim1 B.Cat2.Dim1 B.Cat3.Dim1 B.Cat4.Dim1
## 1          NA           1           0           0           0
## 2       4.286           1           2           3           4
## 3          NA           1           0           0           0
## 4          NA           1           2           3           0
## 5          NA           1           2           0           0
## 6          NA           1           2           0           0
## 7          NA           1           2           3           0
## 8          NA           1           0           0           0
## 9          NA           1           2           0           0
## 10         NA           1           0           0           0
## 11         NA           1           2           0           0
## 12         NA           1           0           0           0
## 13         NA           1           2           3           0
## 
## Item Parameters Xsi
##                                  xsi se.xsi
## Delivery.03d_NU_F              2.975  0.216
## Elevator.04c_OE_F              1.071  0.065
## Park.01b_MC_F                  1.466  0.131
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F         0.411  0.052
## Sorting.03b_MC_F               1.007  0.086
## Sorting.03c_MC_F              -0.293  0.066
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F            -0.686  0.048
## Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C           1.061  0.107
## SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C            -0.601  0.103
## Travel.01_NU_C                -0.646  0.071
## Delivery.01b_MC_S             -0.486  0.161
## Delivery.01c_MC_S              0.679  0.234
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S        0.766  0.120
## Elevator.04c_OE_F_step1       -1.941  0.143
## Elevator.04c_OE_F_step2       -1.037  0.118
## Elevator.04c_OE_F_step3        0.400  0.169
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F_step1   1.932  0.116
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F_step2  -2.219  0.122
## Sorting.03b_MC_F_step1        -0.870  0.107
## Sorting.03c_MC_F_step1         0.930  0.151
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F_step1       0.627  0.075
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F_step2      -1.910  0.074
## SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C_step1      -2.548  0.108
## Delivery.01b_MC_S_step1        0.852  0.340
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S_step1  0.603  0.238
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S_step2 -0.955  0.262
## 
## Item Parameters in IRT parameterization
##                       item alpha   beta tau.Cat1 tau.Cat2 tau.Cat3 tau.Cat4
## 1        Delivery.03d_NU_F     1  2.975       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 2        Elevator.04c_OE_F     1  1.071   -1.941   -1.037    0.400    2.578
## 3            Park.01b_MC_F     1  1.466       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 4   Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F     1  0.411    1.932   -2.219    0.287       NA
## 5         Sorting.03b_MC_F     1  1.007   -0.870    0.870       NA       NA
## 6         Sorting.03c_MC_F     1 -0.293    0.930   -0.930       NA       NA
## 7       TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F     1 -0.686    0.627   -1.910    1.283       NA
## 8     Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C     1  1.061       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 9       SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C     1 -0.601   -2.548    2.548       NA       NA
## 10          Travel.01_NU_C     1 -0.646       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 11       Delivery.01b_MC_S     1 -0.486    0.852   -0.852       NA       NA
## 12       Delivery.01c_MC_S     1  0.679       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 13 Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S     1  0.766    0.603   -0.955    0.352       NA
## Item parameters
## |**********|
## |----------|
## Regression parameters
## |**|
## ||
## |--|
##    est.Dim1    se.Dim1
## 1 0.0000000 0.00000000
## 2 0.5420039 0.08824013

Please see this link below for the calibration of the same dataset in ConQuest:

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/u3sy2wk3zg66vs5/AAA9oZRXvTKNlxNs0rptzqWJa?dl=0

4.1 Model specification

## [1] "item+item*step"

4.2 Latent regression coefficient (gain from pre to post)

##                   hs
## Main dimension 0.542
## S. errors      0.058

—> ## Reliability

## EAP/PV RELIABILITY: 0.485

4.3 Variance

##           errors
## [1,] 0.64  0.026

4.4 Item parameters

The parameter difficulty parameters may be thought of as a kind of “average” item difficulty for a partial credit item. This may be useful, if one wishes to have one indicative difficulty parameter for a partial credit item as a whole. Otherwise, to describe the difficulty of a partial credit item, one needs to describe the difficulties of individual score categories within the item, such as using the Thurstonian thresholds (Wu et al., 2016).

##    n_item          item    est error
## 1       1 Delivery.03..  2.975 0.216
## 2       2 Elevator.04..  1.072 0.065
## 3       3 Park.01b_MC..  1.467 0.131
## 4       4 Shipping.03..  0.412 0.052
## 5       5 Sorting.03b..  1.007 0.086
## 6       6 Sorting.03c.. -0.293 0.066
## 7       7 TicTac.01ab.. -0.686 0.048
## 8       8 Delivery.03..  1.062 0.107
## 9       9 SignUp.01ab.. -0.601 0.103
## 10     10 Travel.01_N.. -0.646 0.071
## 11     11 Delivery.01.. -0.486 0.161
## 12     12 Delivery.01..  0.679 0.234
## 13     13 Shipping.03..  0.767 0.120
## W.fit: Weighted fit (Infit)
##       [,1]     [,2]                     
##  [1,] "item1"  "Delivery.03d_NU_F"      
##  [2,] "item2"  "Elevator.04c_OE_F"      
##  [3,] "item3"  "Park.01b_MC_F"          
##  [4,] "item4"  "Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F" 
##  [5,] "item5"  "Sorting.03b_MC_F"       
##  [6,] "item6"  "Sorting.03c_MC_F"       
##  [7,] "item7"  "TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F"     
##  [8,] "item8"  "Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C"   
##  [9,] "item9"  "SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C"     
## [10,] "item10" "Travel.01_NU_C"         
## [11,] "item11" "Delivery.01b_MC_S"      
## [12,] "item12" "Delivery.01c_MC_S"      
## [13,] "item13" "Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S"

4.5 Step parameters

Delta is the point at which the probability of being in category k − 1 and category k is equals. This mathematical fact provides an interpretation for the delta (d) parameters (Wu et al., 2016)

##    n_item          item step    est error
## 1       2 Elevator.04..    0     NA    NA
## 2       2 Elevator.04..    1 -1.942 0.143
## 3       2 Elevator.04..    2 -1.037 0.118
## 4       2 Elevator.04..    3  0.400 0.169
## 5       2 Elevator.04..    4  2.579    NA
## 6       4 Shipping.03..    0     NA    NA
## 7       4 Shipping.03..    1  1.932 0.117
## 8       4 Shipping.03..    2 -2.220 0.122
## 9       4 Shipping.03..    3  0.287    NA
## 10      5 Sorting.03b..    0     NA    NA
## 11      5 Sorting.03b..    1 -0.870 0.107
## 12      5 Sorting.03b..    2  0.870    NA
## 13      6 Sorting.03c..    0     NA    NA
## 14      6 Sorting.03c..    1  0.929 0.151
## 15      6 Sorting.03c..    2 -0.929    NA
## 16      7 TicTac.01ab..    0     NA    NA
## 17      7 TicTac.01ab..    1  0.627 0.075
## 18      7 TicTac.01ab..    2 -1.911 0.074
## 19      7 TicTac.01ab..    3  1.284    NA
## 20      9 SignUp.01ab..    0     NA    NA
## 21      9 SignUp.01ab..    1 -2.548 0.108
## 22      9 SignUp.01ab..    2  2.548    NA
## 23     11 Delivery.01..    0     NA    NA
## 24     11 Delivery.01..    1  0.852 0.340
## 25     11 Delivery.01..    2 -0.852    NA
## 26     13 Shipping.03..    0     NA    NA
## 27     13 Shipping.03..    1  0.603 0.238
## 28     13 Shipping.03..    2 -0.955 0.262
## 29     13 Shipping.03..    3  0.352    NA

4.6 Thurstonian thresholds

For partial credit items, to achieve a score of 2, students would generally need to accomplish more tasks than for achieving a score of 1. To reflect this “cumulative achievement”, the Thurstonian thresholds are sometimes used as indicators of “score difficulties”. The Thurstonian threshold for a score category is defined as the ability at which the probability of achieving that score or higher reaches 0.50.

##                           [,1]   [,2]  [,3] [,4]
## Delivery.03d_NU_F        2.976     NA    NA   NA
## Elevator.04c_OE_F       -1.153  0.116 1.566 3.75
## Park.01b_MC_F            1.467     NA    NA   NA
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F   0.013  0.100 0.968   NA
## Sorting.03b_MC_F        -0.005  2.019    NA   NA
## Sorting.03c_MC_F        -0.489 -0.097    NA   NA
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F      -1.517 -1.270 0.653   NA
## Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C     1.062     NA    NA   NA
## SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C      -3.155  1.953    NA   NA
## Travel.01_NU_C          -0.646     NA    NA   NA
## Delivery.01b_MC_S       -0.698 -0.275    NA   NA
## Delivery.01c_MC_S        0.680     NA    NA   NA
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S  0.227  0.549 1.440   NA
##                           AEI1   AEI2  AEI3 AEI4
## Delivery.03d_NU_F        2.976     NA    NA   NA
## Elevator.04c_OE_F       -1.153  0.116 1.566 3.75
## Park.01b_MC_F            1.467     NA    NA   NA
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F   0.013  0.100 0.968   NA
## Sorting.03b_MC_F        -0.005  2.019    NA   NA
## Sorting.03c_MC_F        -0.489 -0.097    NA   NA
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F      -1.517 -1.270 0.653   NA
## Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C     1.062     NA    NA   NA
## SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C      -3.155  1.953    NA   NA
## Travel.01_NU_C          -0.646     NA    NA   NA
## Delivery.01b_MC_S       -0.698 -0.275    NA   NA
## Delivery.01c_MC_S        0.680     NA    NA   NA
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S  0.227  0.549 1.440   NA
##       AEI1               AEI2              AEI3             AEI4     
##  Min.   :-3.15500   Min.   :-1.2700   Min.   :0.6530   Min.   :3.75  
##  1st Qu.:-0.69800   1st Qu.:-0.1415   1st Qu.:0.8892   1st Qu.:3.75  
##  Median :-0.00500   Median : 0.1080   Median :1.2040   Median :3.75  
##  Mean   :-0.09523   Mean   : 0.3869   Mean   :1.1567   Mean   :3.75  
##  3rd Qu.: 0.68000   3rd Qu.: 0.9000   3rd Qu.:1.4715   3rd Qu.:3.75  
##  Max.   : 2.97600   Max.   : 2.0190   Max.   :1.5660   Max.   :3.75  
##                     NA's   :5         NA's   :9        NA's   :12
##                          X   AEI1   AEI2   AEI3  AEI4
## 1        Delivery.03d_NU_F     NA     NA     NA 2.976
## 2        Elevator.04c_OE_F -1.153  0.116  1.566 3.750
## 3            Park.01b_MC_F     NA     NA     NA 1.467
## 4   Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F  0.013  0.100  0.968    NA
## 5         Sorting.03b_MC_F     NA -0.005  2.019    NA
## 6         Sorting.03c_MC_F     NA -0.489 -0.097    NA
## 7       TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F -1.517 -1.270  0.653    NA
## 8     Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C     NA     NA  1.062    NA
## 9       SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C -3.155     NA  1.953    NA
## 10          Travel.01_NU_C     NA -0.646     NA    NA
## 11       Delivery.01b_MC_S -0.698 -0.275     NA    NA
## 12       Delivery.01c_MC_S     NA  0.680     NA    NA
## 13 Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S  0.227  0.549  1.440    NA

6 Item fit graph

7 Wright Map

8 Category Characteristic Curves (CCC)

9 Calibration summary from TAM

## ------------------------------------------------------------
## TAM 4.1-4 (2022-08-28 16:03:54) 
## R version 4.2.2 (2022-10-31) x86_64, darwin17.0 | nodename=Permans-MacBook-Pro-4.local | login=root 
## 
## Date of Analysis: 2023-02-22 15:53:02 
## Time difference of 0.267741 secs
## Computation time: 0.267741 
## 
## Multidimensional Item Response Model in TAM 
## 
## IRT Model: PCM2
## Call:
## TAM::tam.mml(resp = aei[, c(6:18)], Y = aei[, 5], irtmodel = "PCM2", 
##     verbose = FALSE)
## 
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Number of iterations = 73 
## Numeric integration with 21 integration points
## 
## Deviance = 8259.96 
## Log likelihood = -4129.98 
## Number of persons = 1228 
## Number of persons used = 1103 
## Number of items = 13 
## Number of estimated parameters = 28 
##     Item threshold parameters = 26 
##     Item slope parameters = 0 
##     Regression parameters = 1 
##     Variance/covariance parameters = 1 
## 
## AIC = 8316  | penalty=56    | AIC=-2*LL + 2*p 
## AIC3 = 8344  | penalty=84    | AIC3=-2*LL + 3*p 
## BIC = 8456  | penalty=196.16    | BIC=-2*LL + log(n)*p 
## aBIC = 8367  | penalty=107.13    | aBIC=-2*LL + log((n-2)/24)*p  (adjusted BIC) 
## CAIC = 8484  | penalty=224.16    | CAIC=-2*LL + [log(n)+1]*p  (consistent AIC) 
## AICc = 8317  | penalty=57.51    | AICc=-2*LL + 2*p + 2*p*(p+1)/(n-p-1)  (bias corrected AIC) 
## GHP = 0.78364     | GHP=( -LL + p ) / (#Persons * #Items)  (Gilula-Haberman log penalty) 
## 
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## EAP Reliability
## [1] 0.478
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Covariances and Variances
##       [,1]
## [1,] 0.639
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Correlations and Standard Deviations (in the diagonal)
##      [,1]
## [1,]  0.8
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Regression Coefficients
##       [,1]
## [1,] 0.000
## [2,] 0.542
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Standardized Coefficients
##        parm dim   est  StdYX   StdX   StdY
## 1 Intercept   1 0.000     NA     NA     NA
## 2        Y1   1 0.542 0.2783 0.2317 0.6511
## 
## ** Explained Variance R^2
## [1] 0.0774
## ** SD Theta
## [1] 0.8325
## ** SD Predictors
## Intercept        Y1 
##    0.0000    0.4274 
## ------------------------------------------------------------
## Item Parameters -A*Xsi
##                       item   N     M xsi.item AXsi_.Cat1 AXsi_.Cat2 AXsi_.Cat3
## 1        Delivery.03d_NU_F 387 0.062    2.975      2.975         NA         NA
## 2        Elevator.04c_OE_F 357 1.431    1.071     -0.870     -0.835      0.637
## 3            Park.01b_MC_F 388 0.211    1.466      1.466         NA         NA
## 4   Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F 376 1.218    0.411      2.344      0.536      1.234
## 5         Sorting.03b_MC_F 379 0.615    1.007      0.137      2.014         NA
## 6         Sorting.03c_MC_F 379 1.201   -0.293      0.637     -0.585         NA
## 7       TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F 772 2.097   -0.686     -0.059     -2.655     -2.058
## 8     Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C 474 0.295    1.061      1.061         NA         NA
## 9       SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C 548 1.124   -0.601     -3.149     -1.202         NA
## 10          Travel.01_NU_C 998 0.663   -0.646     -0.646         NA         NA
## 11       Delivery.01b_MC_S  84 1.524   -0.486      0.366     -0.973         NA
## 12       Delivery.01c_MC_S  84 0.452    0.679      0.679         NA         NA
## 13 Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S  80 1.425    0.766      1.369      1.181      2.299
##    AXsi_.Cat4 B.Cat1.Dim1 B.Cat2.Dim1 B.Cat3.Dim1 B.Cat4.Dim1
## 1          NA           1           0           0           0
## 2       4.286           1           2           3           4
## 3          NA           1           0           0           0
## 4          NA           1           2           3           0
## 5          NA           1           2           0           0
## 6          NA           1           2           0           0
## 7          NA           1           2           3           0
## 8          NA           1           0           0           0
## 9          NA           1           2           0           0
## 10         NA           1           0           0           0
## 11         NA           1           2           0           0
## 12         NA           1           0           0           0
## 13         NA           1           2           3           0
## 
## Item Parameters Xsi
##                                  xsi se.xsi
## Delivery.03d_NU_F              2.975  0.216
## Elevator.04c_OE_F              1.071  0.065
## Park.01b_MC_F                  1.466  0.131
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F         0.411  0.052
## Sorting.03b_MC_F               1.007  0.086
## Sorting.03c_MC_F              -0.293  0.066
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F            -0.686  0.048
## Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C           1.061  0.107
## SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C            -0.601  0.103
## Travel.01_NU_C                -0.646  0.071
## Delivery.01b_MC_S             -0.486  0.161
## Delivery.01c_MC_S              0.679  0.234
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S        0.766  0.120
## Elevator.04c_OE_F_step1       -1.941  0.143
## Elevator.04c_OE_F_step2       -1.037  0.118
## Elevator.04c_OE_F_step3        0.400  0.169
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F_step1   1.932  0.116
## Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F_step2  -2.219  0.122
## Sorting.03b_MC_F_step1        -0.870  0.107
## Sorting.03c_MC_F_step1         0.930  0.151
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F_step1       0.627  0.075
## TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F_step2      -1.910  0.074
## SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C_step1      -2.548  0.108
## Delivery.01b_MC_S_step1        0.852  0.340
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S_step1  0.603  0.238
## Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S_step2 -0.955  0.262
## 
## Item Parameters in IRT parameterization
##                       item alpha   beta tau.Cat1 tau.Cat2 tau.Cat3 tau.Cat4
## 1        Delivery.03d_NU_F     1  2.975       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 2        Elevator.04c_OE_F     1  1.071   -1.941   -1.037    0.400    2.578
## 3            Park.01b_MC_F     1  1.466       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 4   Shipping.03abc_MCOE2_F     1  0.411    1.932   -2.219    0.287       NA
## 5         Sorting.03b_MC_F     1  1.007   -0.870    0.870       NA       NA
## 6         Sorting.03c_MC_F     1 -0.293    0.930   -0.930       NA       NA
## 7       TicTac.01ab_MCOE_F     1 -0.686    0.627   -1.910    1.283       NA
## 8     Delivery.03ab_MCMC_C     1  1.061       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 9       SignUp.01ab_MCRO_C     1 -0.601   -2.548    2.548       NA       NA
## 10          Travel.01_NU_C     1 -0.646       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 11       Delivery.01b_MC_S     1 -0.486    0.852   -0.852       NA       NA
## 12       Delivery.01c_MC_S     1  0.679       NA       NA       NA       NA
## 13 Shipping.03abc_MCMCOE_S     1  0.766    0.603   -0.955    0.352       NA